The Block Size War
What it proposed
Raise the 1 MB block size limit by hard fork: 8 MB doubling every two years (BIP 101), 2 MB (BIP 102, BIP 109), miner-voted sizes (BIP 100) and growth formulas (BIPs 103–107).
Big blocks · Andresen, Hearn, Garzik, Classic, Unlimited
On-chain payments must stay cheap; raise the limit now. Shipped in Bitcoin XT (BIP 101) and Bitcoin Classic (BIP 109).
VS
Small blocks · SegWit first
Bigger blocks centralise validation; add capacity with SegWit and second layers such as Lightning, without a hard fork.
Why it blew up
Two years of client wars, roundtables and agreements over who decides Bitcoin's rules: developers, miners, businesses or users. BIP 101's 75% trigger was never reached.
Outcome
None of the hard-fork BIPs activated; every one is Closed. Bitcoin Cash split on 1 August 2017 to raise the limit on its own chain.
Timeline
- 4 Oct 2010Satoshi sketches how a larger limit could be phased in at a future block height. [1]
- 11 Jun – 23 Jun 2015BIP 100 (miner-voted size) and BIP 102 (2 MB) by Jeff Garzik are assigned; Gavin Andresen’s fixed-schedule increase becomes BIP 101. [1] [2] [3] [4]
- 21–31 Jul 2015Pieter Wuille’s BIP 103 proposes slow growth; Mike Hearn calls it virtually the same as keeping 1 MB. [1] [2]
- Aug 2015Bitcoin XT ships BIP 101; r/Bitcoin’s moderator bans promotion of XT as an altcoin. [1] [2]
- 7 Dec 2015After Scaling Bitcoin Hong Kong, Gregory Maxwell posts the SegWit-first capacity roadmap. [1]
- 18 Dec 2015Jeff Garzik answers that SegWit alone does not solve the fee problem. [1]
- 28 Jan 2016BIP 109 (2 MB, 75% trigger), shipped by Bitcoin Classic, is assigned. [1]
- Feb 2016Gavin Andresen withdraws BIP 101; the Hong Kong roundtable agreement is signed on 20 February. [1] [2]
- 1 Aug 2017Bitcoin Cash splits off to raise the limit on its own chain. [1]
In their own words
“It can start being in versions way ahead, so by the time it reaches that block number and goes into effect, the older versions that don't have it are already obsolete.”
Bitcointalk · 4 Oct 2010 · source
“Miners are businesses that sell a service to Bitcoin users”
bitcoin-dev · 1 Jun 2015 · source
“Having lots of variables in the profitability equation is a decentralizing force”
bitcoin-dev · 23 Jun 2015 · source
“this BIP is virtually the same as keeping the 1mb cap.”
bitcoin-dev · 31 Jul 2015 · source
“XT is programmed to create a separate currency and network, so it is not Bitcoin.”
r/Bitcoin (moderator post) · Aug 2015 · source
“If 90% of r/Bitcoin users find these policies to be intolerable, then I want these 90% of r/Bitcoin users to leave.”
r/Bitcoin (moderator post) · Aug 2015 · source
“Bitcoin is P2P electronic cash that is valuable over legacy systems because of the monetary autonomy it brings to its users through decentralization.”
bitcoin-dev · 7 Dec 2015 · source
“I also think that a hard fork is better for SegWit, as it reduces the size of fraud proofs considerably, makes the whole design more elegant and less kludgey, and is safer for clients who do not upgrade in a timely fashion.”
bitcoin-dev · 8 Dec 2015 · source
“Segregated Witness does not kick the can, it solves none of the problems #1, #3 - #8 explicitly defined and listed in email #1.”
bitcoin-dev · 18 Dec 2015 · source
In the Bitcoin Takeover Wiki
Block size warBitcoin XTBitcoin ClassicBitcoin UnlimitedHong Kong RoundtableGavin AndresenMike HearnJeff GarzikBitcoin Cash
Heard on Bitcoin Takeover
- S16 E60: Jonathan Bier on Bitcoin Civil Wars & BitMEX Research▶ listen at 2:13:25timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S17 E35: Vinny Lingham on what the block size limit produced▶ listen at 9:05timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S17 E39: Kurt Wuckert Jr. on the DDoS attacks on XT nodes▶ listen at 48:20timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
- S16 E30: Peter Rizun on what Bitcoin Unlimited was trying to show▶ listen at 1:19:19timestamp transcript-derived, pending a listen
Sources: BIP 100, “Dynamic maximum block size by miner vote”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · BIP 101, “Increase maximum block size”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · BIP 102, “Block size increase to 2MB”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · BIP 103, “Block size following technological growth”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · BIP 109, “Two million byte size limit with sigop and sighash limits”, bitcoin/bips (commit a7f9132, 2026-11-17) · Bitcointalk, satoshi, “Re: [PATCH] increase block size limit” (4 Oct 2010) · bitcoin-dev, Jeff Garzik, “Re: Block size: It's economics & user preparation & moral hazard” (18 Dec 2015), b10c mirror · bitcoin-dev, Gavin Andresen, “Re: Draft BIP: fixed-schedule block size increase” (23 Jun 2015), b10c mirror · bitcoin-dev, Mike Hearn, “Re: Fwd: Block Size Increase Requirements” (1 Jun 2015), b10c mirror · bitcoin-dev, Mike Hearn, “Re: Block size following technological growth” (31 Jul 2015), b10c mirror · bitcoin-dev, Gregory Maxwell, “Capacity increases for the Bitcoin system.” (7 Dec 2015), b10c mirror · bitcoin-dev, Jonathan Toomim, “Re: Capacity increases for the Bitcoin system.” (8 Dec 2015), b10c mirror · r/Bitcoin, theymos (moderator), “It's time for a break: About the recent mess & temporary new rules” (Aug 2015) · bitcoin/bips pull request #329, “Withdraw BIP 101 proposal” (Gavin Andresen, Feb 2016) · Bitcoin Cash: The Big Block Breakaway (BTCTKVR: Forks!) · Fork Wars: the block size war timeline (Bitcoin Takeover) · Bitcoin Roundtable, “Bitcoin Roundtable Consensus”, Medium, 20 Feb 2016 (Wayback Machine copy) · Bitcoin Wiki (en.bitcoin.it), “Bitcoin XT”