Paul Sztorc on the Derangements of Bitcoin (S17 E5 Full Article)
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript40,909 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Paul Sztorc has been in Bitcoin since 2011, and he cares more about being right than about being popular. In July 2025 he published an essay called Derangements of Bitcoin, a long, sourced list of beliefs he thinks the community keeps getting wrong. I invited him to walk me through it.
Paul is the CEO of LayerTwo Labs and the author of the Drivechain proposals, BIP 300 and BIP 301. He's never shy, and some of his targets are people. I've kept this article on the ideas. The original show notes have the full list and categories.
What a Derangement Is
Paul's definition is easy to picture. "They go to the post office and like, you didn't put a stamp on this. And then like, okay, and then they try again without putting the stamp on." Or they show up at 5:01 every day and find it closed. "The derangements are just these mistakes that never get corrected. And it's kind of like this scar tissue that like doesn't like heal."
Some derangements are slogans: "Bitcoin fixes this. It's, you know, infinity divided by 21 billion, etc. Fix the money, fix the world. There is no second best." The gist of his essay "is that nothing can fix this accumulated disaster."
He was careful to add that he's not bearish on his own bags. "I'm certainly a Bitcoiner myself. I'm heavily invested in Bitcoin financially and career-wise and intellectually and reputationally." The essay doesn't mean "anyone who owns Bitcoin today will lose their money or will regret it."
Custodial Lightning
The biggest one for Paul is Lightning. "The Lightning Network is the biggest sacred cow of them all." His sharpest example is custodial Lightning. "It's like a bunch of engineers building an elevator to reach the top of the Burj Khalifa or the Empire State Building. And you get into the elevator and you have to climb the stairs." His point: "The whole point of the Lightning Network is so that it's not custodial."
The same logic applies to letting a company hold bitcoin for you. "There's no reason to have someone else buy Bitcoin for you. You should be buying your own Bitcoin."
The Final Rotation
This one is less known, so Paul explained it carefully. Rotation means "people switching out their... They have fiat and they swap it for Bitcoin in their daily lives." The last people to rotate "have to be real users. They cannot be NGU, number go up, investors. Because the number can't go up by the time they swap out."
His math: "You have this log scale. It goes 10x, 10x. Now we're at 100,000x. So we can only do 10x like two more times." So "the final one has to be 8 billion people using Bitcoin."
And competition matters. "The fact that Bitcoin is the sovereign capital that people can't take away from you, that is enormously beneficial." But if something else offers the same and everyone uses it, "then there is no room for Bitcoin in that world." It would be like "the Myspace, Facebook type thing."
Non-Mined L2s and the Security Budget
Paul thinks layer twos that aren't mined create a future conflict. Every L2 adds L1 fees when you move in and out. But imagine a future where block subsidies are near zero. "What percent go to the L1 miners versus what percent go to a non-mined L2?" A miner might think, "as a miner, I make zero dollars per year," but running a big L2 service could pay far more. So "I think for this reason, non-mined L2s are doomed."
The fix he's spent years on is drivechains, sidechains that miners secure. His team says it has tested at "a rate that would allow 8 billion people to onboard and use." With Lightning, he argued, "there's not enough L1 block space to give channels to everyone."
The SegWit Discount Myth
This one surprised me. People think SegWit transactions are smaller. "And we use fewer bytes because of the magic of SegWit. But that is completely a myth." In reality, "The SegWit transactions do not use fewer bytes in physical space. And in fact, in some cases they use many more."
So why the discount? "The SegWit discount is a political decision to incentivize cleaning up UTXO bloat." Spending an old output includes a signature, so discounting signatures rewards cleaning up. "There's no physics trick making it cheaper."
Bikeshedding Over Soft Forks
Paul is frustrated with how upgrades get discussed. "All the soft fork talk has been bike shedding. So it has all just been about the political reputation of the people talking instead of the cost benefit analysis." He argues the OP_SUCCESS style of soft fork carries very little risk, being "ignorable, opt-in and easily reversible."
He also took a fair point from the other side. Bitcoin is "still adding coins until the year 21, whatever," so it's still moving toward 21 million. Critics who point that out "have a small point."
The Libbitcoin Mystery
Another big derangement, in Paul's view, is how little attention Libbitcoin gets. Its maintainer, Eric Voskuil, has shown a full node syncing in less than an hour. Paul's metaphor: everyone takes "a six hour flight from New York to San Francisco," while Eric's "experimental craft" gets "from New York to San Francisco in 15 minutes." He thinks Eric "aggressively parallelized so that a lot of stuff could take place out of order," and that people stay quiet because "the guy next to me is not talking about it."
Paul's own method for speed is competition. For his Thunder sidechain, "I just ran a contest and I said, whoever can improve," with a stopwatch test and a cash prize, "week after week after week." His conclusion: "If you want to do something and you have money and you have time and you have an internet connection, like you can do it."
Addresses Should Be Gone by Now
His favorite usability complaint is addresses. "Why do we even have addresses?" Bech32 needed a fix, so "now we had to do Bech32m." He thinks reusable payment codes should be standard. "With BIP47, all you have to do is post your one code, which is your permanent friend code." No back-and-forth, nothing to intercept.
A Community That Gave Up on Progress
This was the saddest part. "People have given up on progress, unfortunately. It's funny, on one hand there's a totally delusional optimism, but on the other hand there's actually, beneath the surface, I think the whole thing is paralyzed by pessimism."
In 2014, "it was taken for granted, every altcoin feature will be bolted into Bitcoin because it's all open source." The expectation was that "Bitcoin will be this super cool piece of software. Eventually we'll get rid of addresses."
He understands why maximalism made sense. Early altcoins were mostly copies. "So maximalism was like, just ignore all that stuff and focus on Bitcoin." But by 2018, "I had already noticed that there was a lot of complacency."
Try BitWindow
Paul's practical advice is to try his team's software. BitWindow "is a fully cosmetic graphical user interface," so anyone can fork it "and then you can change the colors or just rewrite or just delete, tear things up." His tip: "The real way to actually get involved is to try the software." Their Telegram is where the team hangs out.
What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To
You'll disagree with Paul on something, and that's the point. He has spent years writing down where he thinks Bitcoin went wrong, with sources. Even if you only accept half of it, the SegWit discount and final rotation sections alone will change how you think. And yes, it's a long one.
You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Paul Sztorc's guest page.
Listen to Paul Sztorc on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:02:48– Mistakes that never get corrected
- 00:05:55– Still a Bitcoiner
- 00:39:23– Custodial Lightning
- 00:40:56– Buy your own bitcoin
- 00:54:16– New derangements every year
- 00:56:24– BitWindow
- 01:00:54– Testing for 8 billion people
- 01:06:55– Soft fork bikeshedding
- 01:43:42– Still adding coins
- 02:08:36– A 15-minute flight
- 02:10:20– Optimizing by contest
- 02:17:20– The final rotation
- 02:21:06– Two more 10x
- 02:24:51– Room for Bitcoin
- 02:37:10– L2s and L1 fees
- 02:45:26– Non-mined L2s
- 03:09:15– The SegWit discount
- 03:11:32– Not fewer bytes
- 03:13:15– A political decision
- 03:29:52– Why do we have addresses?
- 03:31:53– BIP47
- 03:52:24– Paralyzed by pessimism
- 03:55:27– Complacency
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
574988457d7d1ba8a2d709c343f9f4bb9778e49adb4262f9b5905f4a9dedd813- Proof
- 2026-01-29_s17_e5_paul_sztorc_on_bitcoin_derangements.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 29 Jan 2026, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2026-01-29_s17_e5_paul_sztorc_on_bitcoin_derangements.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2026-01-29_s17_e5_paul_sztorc_on_bitcoin_derangements.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2026-01-29_s17_e5_paul_sztorc_on_bitcoin_derangements.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2026-01-29_s17_e5_paul_sztorc_on_bitcoin_derangements.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S17 E38: Keagan McClelland on Lightning Metrics, Covenants, Consensus Politics & Verifying Bitcoin
There is a certain genre of Bitcoin Twitter argument that never quite resolves into a conversation. People trade metrics, memes…
S17 E21: Paul Sztorc Hard Forks Bitcoin to Launch Ecash with Drivechains!
In August 2026, Paul Sztorc (developer and LayerTwo Labs CEO) will hard fork Bitcoin to create a BIP300-powered altcoin called…
S17 E5: Paul Sztorc on Bitcoin Derangements
As a 2011 bitcoiner, Paul Sztorc has noticed a series of derangements: from expectations that never came true but stuck around as…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.