Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S5 · E6 · 57:07

nopara73 on Wasabi Wallet, Pay to Endpoint and the Future of Bitcoin Privacy (S5 E6 Full Article)

8 May 2020 · by Vlad Costea · 6 min read
Published at block 629,439
Cover art for S5 E6, Nopara73 on Wasabi Wallet, P2EP, Samourai & Bitcoin Privacy
MP3 (52 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript6,840 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

When I recorded this episode in 2020, I called Wasabi "one of the best wallets ever," and I meant it. Its creator, nopara73, had built most of it while traveling through Asia, and it had become the most popular desktop privacy wallet for Bitcoin. I'd been craving a guest who could explain CoinJoins properly, and how they differ from the tumblers of the early days.

On the day we recorded, nopara73 was in a great mood. He'd been reading cypherpunk literature and Chaumian ecash research, and he had new ideas for mixing. The original show notes list the topics. Here's the conversation in full.

CoinJoin in One Paragraph

He started with the basics. "So CoinJoin is a really simple concept. When you build a Bitcoin transaction, if you don't sign it, then that Bitcoin transaction, while properly built, it is not signed, so it is invalid." That lets many people build one big transaction together, "with many inputs and many, many outputs," and nobody's coins move unless everyone signs.

Pay to endpoint is "a special kind of CoinJoin, where both the receiver and the sender of the transactions participate together."

Where the Names Came From

I loved the history here. The name P2EP "has come out of a CoinJoin meeting where many privacy researchers and Bitcoin Core contributors have participated," including Adam Back and Matthew Haywood from Blockstream. It built on nopara73's blog post "Clusterfuck Wallet," which came from a presentation by Adam Gibson asking "what if the receiver puts some UTXOs into the transaction too."

It even goes back to Satoshi. "There was a feature Satoshi implemented back then which was called Pay to IP." You could give someone an IP address and negotiate the transaction. They generalized IP to endpoint. "And then later Adam Gibson implemented it in JoinMarket and he called it PayJoin, and then the PayJoin name seemed to stick." The Samourai developers said they'd had the idea internally too, which became Stowaway.

He's precise about the difference. "Every PayJoin is a pay-to-endpoint transaction, but not every pay-to-endpoint transaction is a PayJoin." Someone in marketing preferred the P2EP name, "and he's the marketing guy and not me, so he's probably right."

Bigger Ambitions for P2EP

P2EP, in his view, "has much larger potential than PayJoin." It could enable merge avoidance and knapsack mixing. The most exciting idea was letting the sender and receiver agree on whether a payment goes on-chain or over Lightning, without users even knowing which one it was. "So pretty cool things are possible here." His dream: "If I give you a Bitcoin address, then you can either send me the money or some magic establishes a connection between me and you." He didn't want to ruin the user experience of simply sharing an address.

Privacy Isn't Censorship Resistant

nopara73 doesn't oversell. "It's 100% that CoinJoin is identifiable, 100%." You "cannot hide in a crowd without that crowd being identified," and that applies to Monero users too.

Wasabi was never built to resist shutdown. "It wasn't a design goal to build something that's censorship resistant. The design goal was privacy." Even JoinMarket needs a bulletin board, and "if you shut down the IRC, then people don't find each other. So privacy in Bitcoin right now is not censorship resistant."

He described three problems from the history of electronic money: anonymity, private networking and "how do you build money that cannot be shut down? And that's what Bitcoin solved." Altcoins trying to do it all on one chain get a polite "good luck for them," because "that's not how human progress works." His hope is to bring all three together in Bitcoin.

More Bullish Than a Month Ago

"If you ask the same question one month ago, then I would 100% agree with you that Bitcoin privacy is kind of lost." What changed was research. A presentation by Tadge Dryja, "one of the inventors of the Lightning Network," broadened his horizon. "So I became more bullish on how Bitcoin privacy will end up in the future."

For newcomers, his advice was practical: Wasabi on desktop if they speak English, and Green Wallet on mobile. What he cares about most is that a wallet "works and is stable."

The Samourai Criticism

This is the part that got attention. nopara73 explained that Samourai users send their xpub to Samourai's server, so it can see which CoinJoin inputs and outputs belong to the same wallet. Dojo, their full node option, doesn't fix it in small rounds: with five participants and four not using Dojo, "you don't need to be a genius to figure out which input and output pairs you cannot de-anonymize."

He was blunt about Samourai's claim that 60% of users ran Dojo, calling it something "which cannot be verified" and inconsistent with how few people run full nodes. He also explained why small denominations are risky. Wasabi's minimum was 0.1 BTC, so an attacker with 10 BTC could block about 100 rounds. Go down to 0.005 BTC and you could stop CoinJoins "for, I don't know, for a month or years." Smaller services get away with it "because no one is denial-of-service attacking, so they get away with cutting corners here." Still, he credited their contributions to P2EP, Cahoots and Stowaway. These were his views as a competitor in 2020, and I'm reporting them as he said them.

Both projects changed a lot later. Samourai's founders were arrested in April 2024, and zkSNACKs, the company behind Wasabi's coordinator, shut it down in June 2024.

Sidechains Won't Save Privacy

I asked whether Liquid's confidential transactions could help. "Not really. I mean, confidential transactions simply means the amounts are not known by other people." Amounts are still visible when you move on and off Liquid, and you'd still need mixing there. Liquid is "not as decentralized as you would like it to be," so he didn't prioritize it. As for a Mimblewimble sidechain, it would need "some federated peg or something like that, like what Blockstream is doing, which is good but not ideal."

A Last Big Project, and a Work of Art

The most personal moment came when he talked about the new mixing technology. "Possibly this new mixing technology will be my last big project." He'd "spent five years without really much weekends, working hard on this project." And he saw it differently from a job: "I certainly look at it as a piece of art rather than some job that has to be done."

The goals were clear. Get rid of the high minimum amount and the unmixed change, and let people "send money in the CoinJoins." Wasabi had just hired cryptographer István Seres and Nothing Much, "who is like Greg Maxwell. He knows everything." That work became WabiSabi, which shipped with Wasabi 2.0 in 2022.

He also admitted to changing his mind on hardware wallets. "I was against implementing hardware wallets, but I had a brain fart and I implemented it anyway." They gave users network privacy and coin control, though CoinJoins with hardware wallets weren't possible yet.

What "Don't Trust, Verify" Really Means

We ended on a meme. Citing Michael Goldstein's BitBlockBoom 2019 talk, he separated argumentation from rhetoric. "Argumentation is the way of figuring out the truth, and rhetoric is something that you tell people who don't want to figure out the truth." Even Bitcoin Core, "the most 'don't trust, verify' thing in the world," relies on libraries and operating systems nobody fully verifies. His sweet spot: "If the product is open source, then that's a pretty good sign."

Bitstein's talk, he said, "made me feel like a lamb between a bunch of wolves on Twitter." I know the feeling.

What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To

You get the origin story of P2EP from someone who was in the room, an honest account of what CoinJoin can and can't do, and a developer who treats his work as art. It's a snapshot of Bitcoin privacy just before WabiSabi.

You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit nopara73's guest page.

Listen to nopara73 on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:02:23– CoinJoin in one paragraph
  2. 00:03:36– Pay to endpoint as a special CoinJoin
  3. 00:05:16– The meeting that named P2EP
  4. 00:07:05– Satoshi's pay to IP
  5. 00:08:58– PayJoin, Cahoots and Stowaway
  6. 00:10:58– Bigger ambitions for P2EP
  7. 00:16:26– CoinJoin is identifiable
  8. 00:18:13– Privacy isn't censorship resistant
  9. 00:22:40– More bullish than a month ago
  10. 00:26:32– Wallets for newcomers
  11. 00:29:58– The Samourai criticism
  12. 00:38:23– A last big project
  13. 00:39:10– Fixing Wasabi's problems
  14. 00:46:04– Changing his mind on hardware wallets
  15. 00:48:28– P2EP versus PayJoin
  16. 00:50:23– What don't trust, verify really means

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
d2522518e268daf62d91fd50ce44bb5417b4a90cb8c08f525765cacac2d1d375
Proof
2020-05-01_s5_e6_nopara73_on_wasabi_wallet__p2ep__samourai__bitcoin_privacy.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 1 May 2020, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2020-05-01_s5_e6_nopara73_on_wasabi_wallet__p2ep__samourai__bitcoin_privacy.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2020-05-01_s5_e6_nopara73_on_wasabi_wallet__p2ep__samourai__bitcoin_privacy.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2020-05-01_s5_e6_nopara73_on_wasabi_wallet__p2ep__samourai__bitcoin_privacy.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2020-05-01_s5_e6_nopara73_on_wasabi_wallet__p2ep__samourai__bitcoin_privacy.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00