Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S10 E1 / Transcript
Transcript · S10 E1 · 1:34:31 · 29 Dec 2021

S10 E1: Eric Martindale and George Burke on Portal and DeFi on Bitcoin Layer 3

With George Burke, Eric Martindale. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:29Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 10, Episode 1. So this is the premiere, guys, of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad and my guests today are Eric Martindale, who has been in Bitcoin for longer than a decade, is the co-founder and CEO of Portal, a DeFi company which is trying to build stuff on Bitcoin's second layer. And the second guest is George Burke, who is the co-founder and community builder of Portal and he has also been in Bitcoin for like eight years.

1:20And has built interesting stuff, and I feel like a newbie and a rookie right now, given your credentials. And you guys also organize a Bitcoin meetup that takes place, if I'm not mistaken, in Silicon Valley.

1:34George BurkeThat's right. It's actually the first Bitcoin meetup I think that was ever created. I can't take the credit for having created it. It was put together by Roger Ver, I think back in 2011 or 2012, and also co-organized by Andreas Antonopoulos. So it was passed down to me through a couple of different people and I am currently the meetup organizer, but we will be looking for a new meetup organizer because I am no longer in Silicon Valley.

2:10Vlad CosteaOh, no. And I very much appreciate this, George. So just for the record, those listening, that was George and the other voice is going to be Eric. And I appreciate that you mentioned two trigger warning names that maximalists don't like. So you mentioned Roger Ver and then also Andreas Antonopoulos. This is a good start.

2:31George BurkeYeah. Well, look, they created the meetup. Say what you want about them.

2:37Vlad CosteaAnd now we're going to move on to what you guys actually do, which is DeFi on Bitcoin's layer two. And people are going to be like, "What the hell, man? Why that? Why do we need that? Bitcoin is perfect as it is." So what's up? What's the story behind this?

2:55Eric MartindaleYeah, sure. Absolutely, I can chime in there. So when I first looked at Bitcoin, you know, I obviously saw the benefits of the monetary system. But what I learned over the next couple years of, you know, going down the rabbit hole that people typically talk about is that it had a lot more capabilities than just simply transferring money around. I do think there was probably a lot of early efforts such as storing data in the blockchain. There's nice long blog posts detailing how people used the transaction data to actually store the raw information from files, text messages, etc.

3:39But ultimately, as I learned the layered approach, basically from, you know, Ian Grigg's original financial layers of cryptography to looking at the actual features of Bitcoin Script versus the other things that you can do with it, like the early payment channel support. I realized I got very excited, actually, about those extra features. So payment channels is probably the middle ground, where payment channels you can pay incrementally to a counterparty for example, ounces of gas or ohms of electricity, for example.

4:15And I saw, you know, money is the base layer, but getting into the second layer and the things that you can build on top of it, I think the reason Bitcoin is the game changer is because it has this functionality. By replacing the money supply, we get to move agreements and relationships away from existing custodians, and I think that is really at the core. That's the core impetus, ultimately, for a decentralized system such as Bitcoin.

4:50You know, you go all the way back to the early cypherpunk movements and the attempts to create decentralized monies. Now that we have something that looks like it works, it would make sense to go back and rehash a lot of those old ideas, these pie-in-the-sky things that people want to build without trusting any third party. And I see Bitcoin as a necessary first layer for that.

5:13You can look at Lightning, you can look at, you know, Fabric, you can look at all of the different things that have been built on top of Bitcoin to date and see that, you know, there are other people in the space doing exactly the same thing, which is keeping the money layer focused on the money. We no longer put data in the Bitcoin blockchain. You know, that's a database that's meant to last, be survivable for 10,000 years. So you don't necessarily want to be storing data in there because it's going to be around forever.

5:47So if we can find a way to lift that up and move it out of the layer one and keep each layer focused on what it does best, I think the... I mean, pie in the sky, you know, I think the world will be a vastly better place with far less trusted third parties.

6:06Vlad CosteaYeah, I think this is a very interesting conversation about what Bitcoin maximalism actually means. Because to some people, it means that Bitcoin is perfect as it is, and we should not make any attempt to change it. And anything else that gets developed outside of Bitcoin is a scam by default, and it's going to fail because it cannot be as decentralized. And there's another school of thought which says everything that we see in shitcoins today may be interesting from a point of view. And there's a market for some aspects of it.

6:40And of course, we're not going to build it on Bitcoin. Of course, we're going to build it on some sort of layer. And of course, we're going to take the best of it because we get to watch what other projects are doing and how they experiment with it. And by the time it gets added to a Bitcoin layer, we know that it's going to be a lot more robust and a lot more well thought, as opposed to an experiment with people's money. And we see lots of DeFi hacks, and they even came up with this term, the rug pull, to designate the scams that take place.

7:14Eric MartindaleYeah, I think there is definitely something to be said about affinity scams. Bitcoin is definitely not perfect in its current form. It's certainly the most perfect money that exists, but it is not perfect. And that's the reason why it is not Bitcoin 1.0. You know, we're currently sitting at, I believe, Bitcoin Core 0.22, and obviously there's optimizations that can be made, which we've seen over the past several years with Segregated Witness being activated. And yeah, just like you were saying, Segregated Witness is a great example of something that was actually originally developed on a different chain.

7:56In this case, it was actually a Bitcoin sidechain, the Elements platform, which I also worked on, I was responsible for. But that feature was tested and prototyped and tested again and rewritten. I think it was actually rewritten, redesigned even two or three times. And eventually, once it passes the, I would even say conservative threshold of meeting all of the tests and requirements, it gets proposed as a BIP, a Bitcoin Improvement Proposal, and eventually it did make its way into Bitcoin. Obviously, not without some controversy. We mentioned Roger Ver and I think that plays into the whole SegWit2x thing. But SegWit's a great example.

8:41I think anything that altcoins do or shitcoins do that is novel or interesting, I think it inevitably will be absorbed by Bitcoin. We call these things affinity scams because they create a completely separate monetary system rather than building on top of or extending the existing system.

9:01And I think it is a bit disingenuous to compare even Ethereum, which is probably the number two to Bitcoin, at least in terms of security and decentralization. You know, you can talk about the number of nodes, the cost of running those nodes, and why you only see between 8 and 15 Ethereum full nodes. But at the end of the day, Ethereum by comparison is not only heading in the opposite direction as proof of work, but it's currently at least, you know, one tenth, an order of magnitude less thermodynamically secure than Bitcoin. So I think there is something to the argument that changes from shitcoins will be merged up into Bitcoin eventually. I think the vast majority of them, however, are really not providing anything novel. They're tweaking monetary parameters. They're tweaking inflation.

10:00Maybe they're adding easier smart contracts. But not much of it is novel. And, you know, outside of the massive amount of funding that they've swindled from uninformed investors, I think most of them are probably just going to die on the vine. And all the attention is going to continue to be absorbed by Bitcoin.

10:22Vlad CosteaYes, so Eric, I'm not sure if many of the listeners are aware of this, but you have been, or I'm not sure if you still work for them, but you're the head of open source at Blockstream. And you also mentioned Elements blockchain, which is basically the testbed which also lays at the foundation of the Liquid sidechain. And I wanted to ask you something specific about Bitcoin development and why layers are so necessary at this point, and also why you decided to build Portal on layer two, which is the Lightning Network, as opposed to the Liquid sidechain or some other kind of sidechain.

11:03We also have RSK, we also have... What else do we have? We have the project for Drivechains, which I'm not sure is finalized. But there are so many ideas out there, and you chose layer 2, Lightning. Why was it Lightning?

11:19Eric MartindaleYeah, so the primary reason that we want to separate things comes from an engineering standpoint. So in Bitcoin development, like I talked about with Segregated Witness, you know, there's extensive amounts of testing. And, you know, once you deploy something to a network like this, it's live. Like, you can't take it back. If you make a mistake in the code or it doesn't provide the features that people are actually looking for, you really don't get a second chance to deploy something like that.

11:49So from one, the engineering perspective is it has to be well tested. And two, it has to be safe and secure. And one of the best ways of doing that is what we call an engineering separation of concerns, where each element of your system is focused exclusively on doing one thing and only that one thing very well. That way you can keep the code modular such that it's less code to look over. It's not a complicated system, which is a criticism lofted at Ethereum extensively. I think that's probably my number one criticism of Ethereum outside of the false marketing.

12:31That, you know, it is literally, it looks like a house of cards, in that it is a lot of complexity built into the layer one. What Lightning and Bitcoin layer two does, Liquid, RSK, Drivechain, like you mentioned, is they let Bitcoin be the base settlement layer. This is the final record of account for the global ledger, where we all agree mutually in a decentralized fashion as to the state of that ledger.

13:02Anything that adds complexity either needs to be tested aggressively before it gets merged in, or it should be following that separation of concern, where it is a separate system that simply relies on the underlying layer, the settlement layer, to provide the actual security. And I think that's the same design that Lightning chose. Lightning is obviously much more technically sophisticated, I would say, than really any of the current market competitors. I'm only aware of two or three comparable layer two attempts in other systems, most notably, I think, Raiden for Ethereum. But I haven't seen any progress on that.

13:45I don't think there's really a payments narrative over there anyways. But again, the reason is just keeping separation of concerns helps protect people's money. And when you're writing code that deals with other people's money, you are responsible for making sure that they don't lose their money.

14:05So you have to be writing secure software. And one of the best ways to do that is to develop separate systems which do one thing very well individually.

14:17Vlad CosteaYes. And I've heard a lot of arguments in favor of Lightning as basically something on which you build, and I know that you call Portal a layer three, something that is going to provide services on top of the Lightning Network. And definitely this layered approach is interesting. And I must ask you, because so far I know of only one other application which calls itself layer three, actually two of them. But I got to ask you about Sphinx. I'm not sure if you got to try it. It's like a chat application, which also works as a wallet.

14:54And enables for content creators like podcasters to broadcast their episodes to an audience which pays per minute or per listen. Is that really a layer three?

15:09Eric MartindaleYeah, so the split between layer one and layer two is very clear. Layer two means off-chain, effectively. It means that you're committing to spend some money and then incrementally sending it to your counterparty as per a prior agreement. So I think that separation is fairly clear. The separation between layers two and three, however, are far less clear. The Lightning Network at large is a separate peer-to-peer network from the Bitcoin network. There is no reason for every counterparty in the Lightning Network to be aware of every single message that is being sent back and forth.

15:51I am aware of Sphinx. I'm actually a big fan of Sphinx. But there's no reason, for example, if let's take the example of like medical data, right? If we're building some sort of medical system dealing with patient data, you don't want to put that, you obviously don't want to put that data in the Bitcoin blockchain. You obviously, you don't want to use the full peer-to-peer network of Lightning to distribute those messages to everyone. You only want the people who need access to that data to be able to see that data.

16:25So when I describe layer three, what I'm describing is an explicit contract that runs on top of the layer two, the Lightning Network, the payment channel network, that is only the counterparties involved. So with regards to Portal, you know, we're doing trading, right? We don't necessarily want to publish the individual orders in the Bitcoin blockchain. We don't want to have to flood fill the Lightning Network and announce a new channel every time I make a trade. All I want is a list of people that I can connect to that have potential orders, and then ask only them for the order, and then fulfill the order on our side.

17:09So really, the layer three for me is primarily the privacy aspect. Lightning, you know, you have routes, you have multi-path payments, you announce your channels to the world so that other people can see, you know, what the available routes are. In this case, we rely on that such that the layer three network is aware of all of the channels, is aware of what's possible. But the individual agreements themselves or the individual applications, in our case Portal, is only contained to the participants in that subset of the network.

17:54Ad voiceoverCommercial break. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.

18:15Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

19:36Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free.

20:42Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

21:30George BurkeEric, you might want to go a little more into how Portal is using layer three, especially when it comes to order composability. Since you brought up the ability to post orders, I think that would make sense to discuss that a little more.

21:49Eric MartindaleYeah. So back to the privacy aspect and kind of extending that to enrapture George's commentary here. So we are indeed constructing ZK proofs around the orders and the order book. And those ZK proofs are, it is, it's certainly like a chat, like a messaging system where you can send information that's encrypted, and then prove certain properties of that information. But really, that layer, that zero-knowledge circuit, that MPC or multi-party computation, is what I describe as the layer three. So the layer two inputs from Lightning, for example, are the inputs into the proof.

22:37You then add the orders to the proof, and you end up with a nice digital signature, which allows you to guarantee or prove certain properties about the underlying data. So the way Portal uses it is explicitly to construct. We use layer two explicitly to construct agreements around ZK circuits and/or known as multi-party computations.

23:05Vlad CosteaRight. And before this interview, I took a look at your white paper, which is available on portaldefi.com, and

23:15George BurkeA podcaster who does his homework.

23:18Vlad CosteaRight. I took a look at it and I noticed that you include the concept of atomic swaps, which were a big deal back when Lightning was being announced. I guess this was before the era of Bitcoin, you know, hardcore Bitcoin maximalism, where everyone is supposed to only hold BTC. And they were saying that you could exchange without any kind of third party in the middle assets between blockchains with atomic swaps. And that was a huge deal. I remember Litecoin was promoting this. Monero, I think, more recently announced that they have developed a way for you to exchange BTC for XMR trustlessly and without any kind of third party in the middle. So given these premises, why does Portal, which is a company, try to do atomic swaps, which theoretically don't need any kind of third party?

24:19Eric MartindaleYeah, that's a good point. And atomic swaps are absolutely very interesting, right? Let me preface this by also saying, like, my motivation for moving down this pathway is very specifically to give people an exit from shitcoins. I think everybody is going to be left holding a bag if they don't have a clear on-ramp to get rid of their shitcoins and acquire Bitcoin. So I kind of go the other way around. I don't want to trade my Bitcoin for shitcoins. I want other people to be able to get rid of their shitcoins in exchange for other people's Bitcoin.

24:53So the reason atomic swaps have not really taken off is because there are a couple gotchas in there. So in the traditional atomic swap construction, you still, you do indeed need some degree of coordination, if not a coordinator, to facilitate the exchange or the setup process between the two traders.

25:20Vlad CosteaThis is the Tier Nolan protocol.

25:22Eric MartindaleYeah, the original Tier Nolan atomic swap, exactly right. You know, it uses the time lock functionality in the same way that Lightning has chosen to use the time lock functionality to basically lock up the funds for a period of time and give the counterparty the opportunity to perform the corresponding counter-trade or counter-transaction on the opposing chain. So, yeah, in general, what Portal is doing is we are not a trusted third party.

25:56We are creating a market for this coordination, this effort, which is effectively, it boils down to exchanging public keys such that the two counterparties can connect to each other and construct a transaction which has to, by definition, include the key of the counterparty. So you have to know the counterparty ahead of time. You at least have to know their public key. So that's really the primary value that Portal is adding to the existing atomic swap conversation.

26:34And then obviously we are very excited about the zero-knowledge proof components, which allow us to conceal the amount that's being traded, except for between the two counterparties that individually are trading.

26:49Vlad CosteaThat is actually a criticism. I think I said "quitticism", but it's supposed to be "criticism". I'm supposed to check my pronunciation so I don't sound like a little kid. But that's something that I don't like about Ethereum DeFi right now. I feel like it's some sort of Orwellian nightmare where you can see what everyone is doing. There is no privacy in anything, and you have the same address for all of your transactions across lots of assets. And I've always considered that the feature that's essentially lacking from the whole DeFi ecosystem is some solid privacy.

27:29So I guess the fact that you include zero-knowledge proofs, which is also something that's being used in Zcash, and there's also something that I read about in the book. It's called Introduction to Applied Cryptography by Bruce... what's his last name?

27:47Eric MartindaleSchneier.

27:48Vlad CosteaSchneier, yes. So you're going to use zero-knowledge proofs, which are very scalable, if I'm not mistaken, because they don't store too much data, and also very efficient because they only display the relevant kind of information to the sender, to the receiver, and to the rest of the world. I think this is useful, so take it as a compliment of sorts, even if I haven't seen the final product, but I like the idea of having more privacy to anything.

28:19Eric MartindaleYeah, that is the same criticism that I level. One of the many criticisms that I level at Ethereum as well is just the complete and utter lack of privacy or even privacy awareness among the developer community. I do know there, I mean, to give them some credit where credit is due, there were definitely and, you know, I think there are continuing to be other shitcoins that are focusing on the privacy aspect. You mentioned Zcash, for example. But in the Ethereum community, by and large, you're watching web developers who are not security engineers, who are not really cryptographers for the most part, writing code with very little awareness or understanding of the original ethos behind why Bitcoin exists, which is to be a peer-to-peer digital cash.

29:04The entire history of that is centered around our right to spend our money as we choose, not at the behest or regulation of any authority, but rather to use money as an expression of our free speech.

29:23And so subsequently, you know, obviously censorship is a primary concern, but privacy. Bitcoin came out of the cypherpunk movement, which is explicitly about using cryptography to conceal and/or to make private not only communications but the movement of money. And at the end of the day, money is just information, and so it is exchanged exactly like that. Money exists to extract pricing information from the free market. So when I started Fabric and when I chose to work at Portal, that's exactly what I wanted. I wanted that right to free expression and I didn't want the censorship and I wanted that privacy.

30:05I think it's absolutely abhorrent that so many uninformed users of these other shitcoins are being roped into, like you said, the Orwellian nightmare of putting all of their trading information, all of their transactions into a database which is supposed to last for a long time. I don't have high hopes for Ethereum's blockchain, but I do know that my best estimate would suggest, even given catastrophic, you know, loss of civilization, I do think Bitcoin will persist and survive for something to the extent of... I'm not trying to be hyperbolic here, but I do think it's a 10,000-year database.

30:47So the privacy aspect of putting your information into a database like that is very concerning, and I think a lot of people are going to get, are already being burned, have already been burned, and a lot more people will be burned by it.

31:06George BurkeAt scale, it's a nightmare. And it becomes Orwellian because of all the information that has been amassed over several years of personal data essentially being recorded on the blockchain. But just as a practical personal note, take a look at wanting to use a Web3 protocol, a wallet to connect to, you know, name any web-based DeFi service you want. You connect your MetaMask wallet. What do you have in there? You might have millions across different coins in there, and it's now attached either to an account on their end, or it's attached to an IP address.

31:52All of this is dangerous, right? If you're not using separate wallets, if you're not using some kind of cloaking mechanism to be able to protect your identity, then you're really a sitting duck. What if I used my original Ethereum Genesis wallet to connect to DeFi? Right? Those coins back then, they were only 30 cents. Right, so people who participated in that, they had a lot of coins, but those people also now have hundreds of millions of dollars if they didn't spend them all. So if you ever attached one of those wallets, you might be put on a list.

32:35So, just as a practical matter, I think that anonymity is going to be hugely important moving forward, and Portal, my hope is that Portal will help us get there.

32:49Vlad CosteaYes, so what you just said is music to my ears from two points of view. The first one is that I got so mad in the past couple of years when I saw that privacy is no longer part of the community conversation. And you can even see that during this bull market, privacy coins like Monero and Zcash are underperforming massively. And you have stuff like Dogecoin, which is getting popular, and SHIB and whatever. And everything DeFi seems to be rising in price, you know.

33:24And it's crazy to me. And the second remark that I want to make is that you mentioned prior to starting recording that you went on the POV Crypto podcast and one of the co-hosts, I'm not sure if he's still doing that podcast, he's doing something called Bankless or something nowadays, but David Hoffman is one of these guys who are so cocky about their power user status in the Ethereum ecosystem that he even bought himself a.eth domain where you can see all of his financial transactions.

34:02Eric MartindaleYeah, it's utterly ridiculous. You know, like I said, the core ethos that motivated this entire ecosystem to exist is that privacy aspect. It's not only no one's business how much money I have, it's certainly no one's business how I spend it. So I do appreciate the transparency aspect of individual choices. But Ethereum and all of these other DeFi products, Dogecoin, Shibcoin, you know, whatever else is out there these days, none of them have that privacy focus. So they're roping in each successive wave of adoption. You know, there have been multiple bubbles, there have been multiple hype waves, multiple hype cycles.

34:44Each wave brings in more people. And if those people are not, you know, at least educated or informed about, you know, what the risks and the dangers are, as the state continues to expand its regulatory regime, continues to decrease the limits by which suspicious action reports, suspicious activity reports are reported to the government, now to the travel rule being dropped down to, I think it's like $600 at this point. So if you move More than $600, any institution that you touch by law has to report that to the government. And I don't know about you, but the history of governments is not kind. Every single government in history has eventually collapsed and failed, number one. And number two, they show a very strong tendency of once they get power, they not only hang on to it, but they continue to grow it to the point of it becoming authoritarian.

35:48And I do think at this point we're staring down, certainly since the 2008 financial crisis, and if not, then certainly since the 2001 Patriot Act here in the United States, a massive surveillance network, a massive financial intelligence network, all at the behest of the state in the name of anti-terrorism and anti-money laundering. But the core principles, again, are: it's my money, I can spend it how I want, and it's none of your business. So I think each successive wave, I think we're really causing... I think shitcoins are causing harm is basically what I should say here, because even Bitcoin has sort of fallen back a little bit.

36:30I know there's definitely a strong privacy contingency within the Bitcoin community. But I can't tell you the last time I looked at a friend's Bitcoin wallet or anybody who's using Bitcoin and seeing them making the right decisions: one address per transaction, never reuse addresses, etc. I do think we're doing a, I say we in the royal we, but I think very primarily the shitcoiners are doing a vast disservice to the public by not considering the privacy and anonymity components of it.

37:07George BurkeYeah, but Eric, we're still far behind on the anonymity promises that the Bitcoin community itself has wanted to institute with Bitcoin itself. If you were to receive a significant payment, let's call it several thousand dollars, into one transaction in your wallet, or hell, maybe that transaction was several years ago and it was only a hundred bucks, but now it's worth thousands. And you get to a point where you're about to spend that coin. Perhaps you're spending that coin to make a purchase in person to some person that you don't trust.

37:57Maybe you're buying food off of a lunch truck in El Salvador. And God forbid that that person takes a look at the transaction history of the wallet that was used to make the payment of buying that burrito and being able to see, "Hey, this guy has at least three BTC in this wallet. Let's go grab them."

38:26Eric MartindaleYeah, absolutely. And I think this is really where atomic swaps shine, is the ability for you to do a submarine swap where the transaction that you actually receive is not associated at all with the original inputs that the original user was swapping out. So there is definitely a case for Bitcoin-to-Bitcoin swaps, as we see with one of my favorite projects in the space, JoinMarket, which is an implementation of CoinJoin, which is sort of a precursor to kind of where we're heading, where you just roll up all of your transactions into one big transaction. It's kind of like a mixer of sorts. So it makes it much more indistinguishable. But the well-funded intelligence services and blockchain analytics companies are still able to glean lots of useful information from that. So really...

39:25George BurkeAlso, just because you've even used it in the first place makes you stand out like a sore thumb.

39:29Eric MartindaleAbsolutely. I mean, the primary thing right now is making all Bitcoin transactions, whether they be a movement of money or a more complex smart contract or a payment channel, whatever they may be... The current focus for Bitcoin Core developers is to make all of those transactions appear identical, the same. And that basically has been adopted by the Bitcoin network at this point and is due to be activated within the next month. I think it's going to be middle of November or something like that. So I think, yeah, atomic swaps are crucial here. I think that the on-chain privacy aspect is also crucial.

40:11But when we talk about moving things up into layer two, then we can just basically preclude the problem altogether by just not putting that data on chain.

40:23Vlad CosteaYou know, this is music to my ears all the way through. And I have once again two remarks. First of all, I wish you guys were on podcasts more often, for the simple reason that you have people like Dan Held, like Michael Saylor, who will go on and say, "Oh no, Bitcoin privacy is a bad idea. We need auditability" or whatever, as if they understand how zero-knowledge proofs work or how any of the privacy projects actually function, and as if they're aware how Grin works, because I think that's one of the most interesting breakthroughs, because it's very scalable.

41:03And it's very much in the spirit of this small block Bitcoin, which is going to have very minimal amounts of data that can be easily transmitted across the world when every block gets mined. I think that's brilliant. And I'm not saying that we should hard fork to integrate it, but I think that there's going to be a lot of interesting opportunities to make Bitcoin more private. But we're not going to get there unless there is a community demand for it. And I feel like the cypherpunks are losing part of their influence and their voice within the community. And it's more like bankers nowadays.

41:43And I even was disappointed earlier this year, I don't recall during which month the Miami conference was, the one organized by Bitcoin Magazine. It was early June, right? So I watched Nick Szabo on stage, and he mentioned how Bitcoin is going to scale through Visa and through PayPal, and there are like layers that help it do more transactions. And I was so pissed off, like, oh, come on, this guy's supposed to be a cypherpunk.

42:12It'll scale through Visa and Mastercard? So he presented Visa and Mastercard as extra layers that are going to help Bitcoin scale. Well, okay. And, you know, I was pissed off because of this. And what was the second remark that I wanted to make? Let's comment on this and I'm going to remember.

42:34Eric MartindaleYeah, let me talk about that a little bit too. So I think the core cypherpunks, the privacy advocates, are definitely still here and we're still in the fight. The challenge is, up until really the past five years or so, the actual math and the actual cryptography underlying building a scalable, private, zero-knowledge system has been mostly in research land. And in Real World Cryptography, which by the way is a great conference that I recommend, you don't want to be using math and crypto that have not been battle-tested or hardened for extensive periods of time.

43:22And we're talking typically on a five to ten year time horizon, which is right about where we're at. You don't want to use new math, you don't want to use new crypto, especially when you're securing other people's money. So I think part of the holdback, at least from an implementation concern, is just...

43:42There are a lot of options, there are a lot of proposals, but the unfortunate fact is everything, almost every single one of them, are largely untested crypto. For example, Grin, which is an implementation of the Mimblewimble protocol. I was actually very... I like it, I like Mimblewimble more than I like Grin, but the reason I don't like Grin is because they chose to launch a completely separate blockchain from scratch instead of doing what I perceive to be the simple thing, which would be to launch a sidechain where I can move my Bitcoin into the sidechain, use it with this new system, and have some sort of fallback guarantee that if something breaks in that system, that I can still go back to Bitcoin.

44:34And that would be very similar to what Segregated Witness has done. I think actually even the original Elements project, we had Confidential Transactions, which allow you to, what we call, cryptographically blind the amounts in the transactions using one of these ZK proofs. I think it definitely needs more testing, and we got to choose a solution that, you know, is going to be resilient. Crypto systems do have a lifetime, and you know, Bitcoin has accounted for this with its upgrade pathing and the ability to migrate to other hashing schemes, other cryptographic signature schemes, etc.

45:14But we do want to get it right. We don't want to endanger people's money. So now that the math has been out there for a few years, and you know, there have been a lot of people working on it, not specifically around Bitcoin, but certainly in the academic sphere, as well as now production prototypes in a lot of places, we do have options that can potentially be added to Bitcoin itself once they have been validated. So I think that's really part of what we're doing here: we're creating a functional system that uses the best-in-class cryptography that's possible.

45:56And we're going to continue to monitor it, continue to monitor the academic sphere to make sure there's no new attack vectors that have been discovered, any new potential compromises or vulnerabilities. But this stuff is, it's not easy. It's definitely, you know, more heady cryptography, more heady math. But that's exactly what we need: we need widespread community review. The more eyeballs, the better. The same thing as the open source philosophy. But I really do wish that Grin chose to... I don't even care if they issued their own coin, but they should have done it as a sidechain so that I could move my existing Bitcoin into that chain.

46:54Vlad CosteaCommercial break.

47:08Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.

47:09Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp, and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip, and if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

48:30Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins.

49:20To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

50:24Right. And I've just remembered the second remark that I wanted to make, because in the previous season of the podcast, I have had Vlad Zamfir, who is the co-founder of Ethereum, who is also morally responsible for, you know, that rollback of their blockchain during the DAO hack. And I got a lot of backlash for that one, but I feel like he has become a lot more cautious and rational in recent years. And he said something very interesting about privacy and about the way that Ethereum was designed.

51:00He said that he feels like we, and by we he means the entire, what he perceives as a larger crypto community, are morally responsible for the fact that right now governments are looking into CBDCs and they have very low expectations and very low standards for privacy, because they're going to offer none. And the fact that we have so many popular blockchains that offer public DeFi, and nobody takes issue in that because they're making money, or I don't know, they have a feeling like they're part of the future of money, it just makes governments lazy and it makes them copy the features of this, and they're gonna be like, "Yeah, so people don't care about privacy." This is the conclusion to which they're going to get, just because early developers were lazy about it and didn't think too much about what's going to happen in the future.

51:58Eric MartindaleYeah, I would say maybe it's... I would actually prefer the government get lazy. The reality is quite the opposite, though. The government has a huge incentive to expand their surveillance network. They are in the business of supposedly, you know, upholding society and keeping things safe and sane. But that expands, and eventually, imagine if down the line your government changed some law because they didn't like the amount of money that was flowing to some group of people. Well, they can, theoretically, they can go back retrospectively to look at previous data and then prosecute individuals based on it, depriving people of liberty, of that free speech, of the free market.

52:53I mean, you can't even say that we have a free market, and this is a larger debate, when the government actually sets the rules of the market. And you can only send money in these specific ways. You can only send money to these specific parties. I mean, there is a very real, real-world risk that, you know, people lose their freedoms, people lose their liberties. We already saw this with the Patriot Act, which after 2001, 9/11, politicians, the government got in a frenzy about cracking down on all of these, the terrorist activity. They enhanced their surveillance network, they threw the American Constitution out the window and allowed for unprecedented insight into what were previously supposed to be private transactions, and an expression of free speech.

53:50So I think it's the opposite way. I think the government has a huge incentive to learn more, and they're just staying silent about the privacy issue. And I've actually seen a lot of commentary from agencies about being very opposed to Zcash and these privacy systems that are already implementing it today, because they want more information, they want more power. Even if it's not an explicit statement that they make, I think they are being quite intelligent about staying back and implementing the less private systems because it gives them more data. It gives them more intelligence for them to pursue what they perceive to be their objectives.

54:36George BurkeAnd if you're talking about CBDCs, yeah, that is certainly what we're likely to see, Eric. But you said that you would prefer they be lazy. I'm going to take the opposite approach. I prefer that they be extremely aggressive. I think of this as survival of the fittest. I think of the protocols being strengthened only by threat. So if we have adversaries that are challenging what Bitcoin can become, then it is up to the community to strengthen Bitcoin in the ways that we know we can. But, you know, we're lazy. Only in the face of a threat will we actually get together to solve problems.

55:49Eric MartindaleYeah, I can kind of understand where you're coming from. But let me just go ahead and state it outright for the record. You know, I would actually just prefer the government not exist altogether. So that's where I'm coming from. But yeah, I do agree. I was just about to reply that I think, yeah, you're right. Bitcoin, I think, should be the tip of the spear, though. Like, we shouldn't be a reactionary force against some aggressor. We already have the aggressor. We already know what the threat is. It is the state. It is the government, and Bitcoin is your defense against it. It's the tip of the spear in preventing, removing the government's power.

56:01George BurkeI'm just saying that humans are somewhat inherently lazy, right? We only perceive a threat when it is already too late. Otherwise, we don't prep for it, right? Any kind of person who is a prepper is seen as a fanatic, insane person.

56:22Eric MartindaleWell, not anymore. Not anymore. I mean, you look at this COVID ridiculousness.

56:30George BurkeYeah, I mean, I think you're right, though. People are lazy, right? That's why we see these new waves of adoption. These people are not even aware of what a cypherpunk is, let alone what the implications are of having privacy versus not. And so I think it's a serious issue. And there's... I definitely... You mentioned earlier that we should be on more podcasts. I totally agree. That is coming. We've been in kind of a deep engineering cycle for the past year and a half. We're just about to... We're on the threshold of releasing the first iteration of our product.

57:08So I definitely think, you know, I'll be shouting from the hilltops: protect yourself from the state and the regulatory burden by making yourself more aware of privacy and understanding how to protect it. Because privacy is one of those things that once it's gone, you can't get it back, right? It's the one thing that you can't, other than time, which, yeah, it's one of the few things you can't get back. Because once your privacy is compromised, you are compromised.

57:44Eric MartindaleWell, George, that's actually a good segue into what can we as Portal do to try to protect Bitcoin from the powers that be? What can we do to strengthen its ability to be resilient?

58:01George BurkeHire full-time Bitcoin Core developers.

58:04Eric MartindaleOh, there's more than that then, right? I'm kind of baiting you into our own rhetoric here, right? The many layers of financial infrastructure that we plan to see built on top of Bitcoin, because it not only allows for more dollars to flow through... dollars, excuse me, monetary value to flow through Bitcoin's pipes, but simultaneously creates a bit of an anti-incentive to have politicians want to destroy what we've built with Bitcoin, because the more financial contracts that the world is running on, the more likely that an attack against Bitcoin would cause a real economic downturn or collapse.

58:58George BurkeYeah, well, I mean, I think you're trying to get me to say the phrase "privacy by default", right? We just got to understand that the average person, until they really need it, which is generally when it's too late, they're not going to understand privacy, right? Like, I remember all the way, even up after the Snowden revelations, even after the Panama Papers, even after all of the insane things that we discovered the government was doing with surveillance, the conversation only changed moderately. I would say maybe the number of people who were excited and passionate about, you know, stopping the government from monitoring your every little movement, maybe it doubled, but it's still not enough, right?

59:45We need to make things private and secure by default, so even the lowest common denominator, the average swindled shitcoin investor, is not falling victim to this surveillance, which, again, like I said before, once you lose your privacy, you can't get it back. So that's why we've spent so much time refining and working on what we have. But I definitely, Eric, you and I have talked about this before, but there's lots of other things that we can be doing: guides and workshops and seminars and more podcasts, et cetera. But I do want to recurse back to the importance of getting full-time Bitcoin Core developers on staff whose job is to submit privacy improvements to the Bitcoin code base.

1:00:41Vlad CosteaFirst of all, I would like to thank George for basically doing the segue back into Portal in a way that did not cross my mind. Like, that was really good.

1:00:53George BurkeMy title is CMO, right? The middle... What's the middle M?

1:00:56Vlad CosteaRight.

1:00:57George BurkeExactly, yeah.

1:00:59Vlad CosteaAnd you mentioned something about bringing more Bitcoin developers, but we have seen last week, I think, that Jonas Schnelli, who was a maintainer of the project, announced that he was leaving. And it's interesting. I'm not sure if this is just a way for him to become an anonymous contributor or if there was something that made him leave. I know that ideologically he's more on the left side, so maybe there were some events that happened within the community that made him lose interest, just like it happened with Matt Corallo and others.

1:01:36But it's definitely interesting to see this phenomenon where there is a lot more money than there used to be in development for Bitcoin. There are grants. There's Alex Gladstein of the Human Rights Foundation who's giving away every month money to people who contribute to Bitcoin projects. But at the same time, you see people who have been around for such a long time and have such a good understanding of how Bitcoin works and have been arguably essential to the development of the project so far, and they leave.

1:02:11Eric MartindaleYeah, you mentioned several other cases. You know, I worked with Matt Corallo, even Greg Maxwell stepped back from Bitcoin as well. Listen, like, because the price is going up, right? Number go up technology. It increases the stress and pressure. I mean, not only is the baseline stress and pressure of writing code that deals with other people's money already heavily burdensome, you know, having worked firsthand with many Bitcoin Core developers across the years, it definitely bears a huge toll on individuals. I can't speak of pretty much any core developer that I know of that is not stressed out by what's going on.

1:02:59It doesn't matter whether you're on the left or the right. The core ethos, the importance of protecting ourselves from state overreach. So even if you're on the left, there is still that asset. There's still that idea that you do need that freedom and liberty, I hope. Maybe I'm wrong there, but... No, I think it is such a huge stressor, and I can't speak about Jonas in particular, but I know of death threats that have been sent. I know about, you know, all sorts of very nasty things that have been leveled in the direction of Bitcoin developers because someone doesn't believe in what they're doing or they just outright don't like it. And it is a huge burden.

1:03:51So anything we can do to support and encourage people to become Bitcoin Core developers, we've got to do it, because I don't know what the turnover rate is going to work out to be over the long run, but I do know that there is a limited timeline at which a limited amount of time and energy that people can spend before they have to step back. So.

1:04:16Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I agree with that, but it seems so hard to find people who are at the same time competent and ideologically driven, because that's a very important component of contributing to Bitcoin. Unless you have this drive to create something that's neutral and state-agnostic and resistant to any kind of state attack, you're going to end up with someone who maybe is very technically competent but doesn't get why any of this exists.

1:04:47George BurkeYou're right. I mean, take a look at the engineers who've been working on DeFi protocols in the past two years or ICOs in the past four years or just early Bitcoin in general. There are so many, let's call them technically competent people who have been in the space for a long time but are not ideologically aligned. And those people have deep pockets but may not be willing to work or work hard. So it certainly is difficult, more and more difficult each day, to find the competent engineers who are still hungry enough to want to work while ideologically aligned, to want to see Bitcoin succeed in a way that is not centralized.

1:05:36Vlad CosteaYeah, to me, that's the ultimate challenge, to find the right people who are willing to take the sacrifice. And I very much admire those who have stuck around for a longer time, like Wladimir van der Laan, for example. I have great respect for him for the simple reason that he hasn't given up yet, and I bet he is under a lot of stress. And he has maintained this perfect OPSEC so far, like no public appearances with at least, you know, photos or video or anything. He's very private. He does his job very well.

1:06:12He said at the beginning of the year that he's going to try to decentralize his job a little more. But now that a maintainer has left, I suppose that's not as feasible anymore. And I don't know, it feels like there is a clock that's ticking and we have to move very fast before people like Michael Saylor are going to onboard the next billion people who are going to get in for all the wrong reasons without understanding what this is about. And I feel like there is this threshold where...

1:06:48Socially, Bitcoin can be taken over. Like, you can have a larger amount of community members who demand for something to exist or a critical mass of people who are against some sort of development and make it redundant and don't support it. Just like that. Like, I see people like Luke Dashjr, I'm not sure how I'm supposed to pronounce his name, but he struggles a lot to get funding just because he doesn't have the most popular of ideas. And it can happen the same with someone who brings privacy. Even if it's the holy grail of transaction privacy, which works as a soft fork and doesn't break consensus.

1:07:26Eric MartindaleYeah, I remember saying and tweeting out, actually, you can go back and look, that I thought we should focus on privacy first, not scaling. So Segregated Witness was a scaling solution. So when the Segregated Witness debate was ongoing, you know, I was saying privacy first, privacy first, privacy first. And I still think that's the case. I mean, the SegWit ship has sailed, the Taproot ship is sailing currently. So Taproot is a good step forward.

1:07:59But the important thing about Bitcoin here is, even if you don't agree with someone like Luke, Luke Dashjr, your method of voting, your method of participation is really, it's threefold. You can, one, mine, right? That's the obvious baseline case. You add to Bitcoin's thermodynamic security. Or two, you run a node, right? You don't have to mine, but if you run a node, you have a say in the system.

1:08:32You get to choose what version of the protocol, what features are running on your software. And that's the greatest thing that I like about Luke Dashjr, is that he literally maintains a separate fork of Bitcoin Core, which implements all of his personal choices. For example, he uses a different number system, right? He uses the tonal number system.

1:09:00Any other features, like, for example, I think one of the other controversial things was Luke's mining pool would not mine any transactions that were participating in gambling. You know, that's a personal decision. That's an amount of revenue. That's an amount of the block subsidy as well as the transaction fees that he's not receiving. But he has the individual right and freedom to do that. And I think that's the most beautiful thing about Bitcoin versus any other crypto system, is that you are the one who chooses what your node runs. So I think that's really ultimately where we should be heading: everybody should run their own node.

1:09:42And the third thing that I wanted to add on there is obviously contributing to the development. So if you want Bitcoin to do something that it doesn't currently, the answer is not to go start a shitcoin. The answer is to go write some code, get it tested and then submit it as a proposal to the Bitcoin community. And I think Luke really set a very, very solid example of how to express those freedoms, technologically as well as ideologically.

1:10:11Vlad CosteaYou mentioned something about running nodes, and by the way, I don't want you to run out of time, so if you're getting late somewhere, I can end this quickly, just let me know.

1:10:21Eric MartindaleYeah, I've still have time. I will have to go in about 15 minutes at most.

1:10:28Vlad CosteaOh, that's good, because I want to ask you about these full node solutions that you buy, like a node in a box, which naturally is something that was developed for the purpose of enabling a greater amount of people to become sovereign and run the code that they want. But usually it ends up just turning into some sort of smartphone OS, where there is a new update that came out, you update with the rest of the network. You don't put too much thought into what you're getting or why you should be upgrading.

1:11:01You just do it. And these are my two problems with this kind of approach. And I may be a hypocrite because I run RaspiBlitz, which is like the open source way of running on a Raspberry Pi. But you definitely have to upgrade with the rest of the network to keep up. And there's also this option that you have as a user when you purchase the device that you can get a pre-synced blockchain, which I think is the worst of ideas. You should sync it by yourself from the Genesis block so you're sure that there's nothing malevolent or malicious in there. But yeah, what's your take on it?

1:11:44Eric MartindaleYeah, that's a great conversation. So basically by buying someone else's hardware that they have produced, they've put some software, hopefully it's open source, on it, onto the node and then they ship it to you. You're reintroducing trust into what is supposed to be a trust-minimized or trustless system. But going down that rabbit hole is a long road. If you really want to trust nothing, verify everything, you're going to have to build your own hardware. You're going to have to verify your hardware. And then you're going to have to build your own software, which includes reading all of the code.

1:12:28And that's just a very high burden. But it is necessary if you want that degree of security. So there is like a spectrum of: on one end you have fully self-sovereign hardware that I built myself. I even manufactured the chip myself such that it wasn't produced in a factory in China, for example. And two, the software component. Yeah, it's definitely a burden.

1:12:58But on the other end of the spectrum, you have the too easy aspect where people just pay, you know, I don't know, some hundred dollars and they get a piece of hardware, they plug it in, they turn it on and then they just forget about it, right? It's just kind of a blind drone in the network. A freedom that you have that you don't express is a freedom that you don't have. So I do think I'm in favor of what's called a mass algorithm society, in which at some point in the future, hopefully, we're not only teaching calculus by the fourth grade, but we're also making sure that everybody is competent at changing the software to do what the user wants.

1:13:43If you don't control the software, the software controls you. So I think this is ultimately up to you, Vlad, me, anybody else that is running a node. We do have a responsibility to set that, to verify our hardware, to verify our software, to sync the blockchain from the Genesis block with the verify flag equals true, which I believe was false for a long time in Bitcoin Core, I should point out. And just really be fully aware of and competent at our own settings, because when push comes to shove, we are the people that are competent at it now.

1:14:20And if we don't speak up, who will? So if a change gets made or something comes down the pipeline that is disagreeable, we should not only disable it on our own hardware, but we should hop on Bitcoin Talk. We should hop on the mailing list. We should tweet about it and say, "Hey, this setting is an insecure setting. It is currently contained in these defaults." And of course, all of this is predicated on open source.

1:14:49But you're right. I don't like the mindless drone following of just buying hardware on that end of the spectrum. But the other end of the spectrum, the completely trustless end of the spectrum, is impractical in the best case and out of reach currently for the majority of people. So, making things safer and more secure by default, first of all, and two, continuing to run nodes and continuing to understand the parameters of the system, the attack vectors, the configurations, the changes being proposed currently in the pipeline, the changes being worked on and deployed, etc.

1:15:33Because like I said, if we don't speak up now, who will? Especially as, you know, Saylor continues to bring the masses to the Bitcoin revolution.

1:15:44Vlad CosteaYeah, and just for the record, I became paranoid at some point about the Raspberry Pi itself, because it's very likely that the CPU is compromised and there's a backdoor in it. And the only alternative that we have is to build RISC-V boards, but these seem to be very expensive at this point. So I took a look at the computers that are built on that open source architecture and they seem to be more on the $5,000 side. So that's a lot more money than most people are willing to spend on a computer.

1:16:23But I did read about lots of initiatives to make that more affordable. And I do hope that in the coming years, we're going to run our Bitcoin nodes on open source hardware, which I think is very important. And maybe that we're going to learn more about verification and we're going to have better tools for the average user to verify. Because at this point, I feel like we're heading too much towards this plug and play device, which was never really the point. Like, it's nice that we have another node in the network.

1:16:56It's nice that someone is going to learn how to use a node by using this box, which they plug into their power outlet. But that's not the point. And that's, you know, at some point we have to ask ourselves, why are we even here? Is it the number go up component? And I'm not judgmental. Like, if you're only here to make more US dollars, that's fine. You can come whenever you want, you can leave whenever you want, and that's it. But is there really more to this project? And if there is, how are we going to enable the average user to, you know, access that?

1:17:34Eric MartindaleYeah, so the question really, and it sounds like your specific case even, is about the hardware. And in order to really verify it, you not only have to be using the quote-unquote open source hardware, but you really should go to the chip fabricator and watch the chip you're going to use be manufactured. I mean, this is the level of detail and attention that would be necessary. But again, I think it's getting back to secure by default, right? If any one of these chip manufacturers is caught inserting a backdoor, it's a huge deal, number one. So there is some protection there.

1:18:11But I think the hardware, RISC-V, what you mentioned, has a lot of energy and momentum behind it currently. It's been around for a long time. But in the past few years, it has really been taking off. So I think, like I said, if we don't speak up, who will? In this case, we have to speak with our Bitcoin and probably go ahead and buy that hardware because it's probably the best that we can do currently, at least at that price point. And because you're talking tens of millions, if not hundreds of millions of dollars to build your own chip manufacturer at this point.

1:18:50But if we establish there is a demand for these chips, then the producer will respond to that demand by producing more. The technology will continue to advance. It will continue to get cheaper and more commoditized. That's the same thesis that I have for mining hardware as well. As people continue to buy, you have all this old hardware, old supply on the market that maybe it gets turned off, but it ultimately increases not only the energy efficiency of the market, but also the price point at which we and future users will be able to acquire it at.

1:19:27So I'm happy to, if you collected any research about the RISC-V processor, send it my way. I'm a big fan of the RISC instruction set, reduced instruction set compute, R-I-S-C. But yeah, I think ultimately we should be pushing that boundary because we are the lucky early comers even still. Here we are, what, 12, almost 13 years later, I believe, something like that, after Bitcoin's creation. And we need to, we still aren't where we need to be with regards to the safe and secure by default aspect.

1:20:06But people have to care. And I think people are probably not going to really care until it matters to them. And like I said earlier, by that point, it's too late. So we got to vote with our dollars, help bring that price point down, maybe even start companies that do chip fab. I mean, there's lots of things to be done here. But we got to do it ourselves such that the next generation, the person that comes after us, the 10, 20, 50 people that we excitedly tell about the future of Bitcoin, they have better options that we have experience with and they gain a little bit more of that security as a result of the accumulated community knowledge, I should say.

1:20:52Vlad CosteaYou know, Eric, you remind me of a younger, more proactive and pro-Bitcoin version of David Chaum. I feel like you guys have a lot in common. You remind me of him.

1:21:06Eric MartindaleThat is a hell of a compliment. I deeply appreciate that. Thank you.

1:21:09Vlad CosteaYou even have the beard, but I don't want to blow your opsec right now.

1:21:13Eric MartindaleYeah, damn. Well, I have to say, you spend an amount of time in Bitcoin and the beard just appears. It seems like everybody who did cryptography and or Bitcoin eventually ended up with a beard. So I think the beard is a side effect of the cryptography knowledge, not the other way around.

1:21:32Vlad CosteaOkay, so I feel like I should have asked this last question early on, but this has been a bit backwards. So what's the ELI5, explain me like I'm 5 version of Portal?

1:21:46Eric MartindaleYeah, so the 30-second elevator pitch, as we like to say, is Portal is a self-sovereign wallet with an integrated exchange. Now, it's not quite ELI5, explain it like I'm five, but that's a full encapsulation of it. Now I'll break down self-sovereign. I don't, I'm sure your listeners kind of already know, but self-sovereign means you and only you have control over, you know, what goes on, what happens. It's an expression of your agency, your ability to make those decisions for yourself without being compelled by an outside authority. And the wallet part is fairly self-explanatory. We allow you to store multiple digital assets in the wallet.

1:22:32And the exchange component, I think, is fairly clear as well. But without getting into the atomic swaps and the technicals, we basically just allow people to trade digital currencies using the latest technology without having to trust a third party.

1:22:53Vlad CosteaThat sounds nice, but how do you make money?

1:22:58Eric MartindaleWell, we definitely have a number of options to make money. We can do things between charging for software to providing value-add services. For example, we may end up being a facilitator to help people find peering relationships. So currently, for example, the Lightning Network, you have to coordinate and find a node, you have to get the public key, you have to get the IP address, you have to get the port from somewhere else, which means you don't have to trust that source because you can verify what you see once you connect. That's really where we sit. We sit as a service provider inside of a big pool. A rising tide lifts all boats kind of thing, where we'll provide services. I'm confident we'll make back all the money we're putting into it. But there is a whole host of services that can be included inside of this network, paid per use, for example, just like a paid API, if you will.

1:24:10And that's really the core direction that we're going right now. But I will say, as an early stage startup, and unfortunately, unlike the much maligned Silicon Valley strategy, we're kind of going in this from a technological angle. We want to build this because we want to see it exist. We can figure out how to make money on top of it later. That is not the priority. Right now, the priority is making it exist first, such that the ecosystem exists and it's in people's hands. And then it's a translation of the existing economy to the new economy, which is that those services that all exist in the traditional world will exist in the digital world.

1:24:58George BurkeWe just want to create the space for those projects, for those features, for those services to exist. We'd like to see privacy by default be something that can be inherent to actual exchange and cross-chain trading. Because right now there really isn't a way to be anonymous while making a cross-chain trade. You either need a centralized exchange or you need to go to wrap a token onto another chain. And how do you wrap that token? Well, you hand it over to a custodian. So you therefore then have yet another trusted party that can fail. And we're actually looking at something like 200,000 or more Bitcoin has been wrapped onto the Ethereum chain in order to participate in DeFi.

1:25:58That's dangerous. It really is. If there is a compromise at BitGo, who is the custodian for all wrapped Bitcoin, I shudder to think what would occur when we find out that much of the wrapped BTC, or some, any of it really, has been compromised. The underlying Bitcoin is gone. What happens to the WBTC? Is there a bifurcation? That's really scary. And then, you know, WBTC is then wrapped on other chains.

1:26:33This could be a cascading effect. So if we have the ability to do cross-chain atomic swaps using the native protocols, but built using the technology that we are trying to birth into the world, I think we'll have a much safer ability to trade. Plus, you get to eliminate all the gas fees by having to wrap things three or four times. It can get nuts. So, yeah, that said, I think we probably have to wrap it up with this interview.

1:27:11Vlad CosteaOh yeah, I just want to make a final remark that I find it very strange that there's more Bitcoin wrapped on Ethereum than Bitcoin in Lightning or Bitcoin on any other sidechain like Liquid or RSK. That's very strange, but I guess early Ethereum investors have a lot of Bitcoin to spare. But yeah, I appreciate what you guys are doing. And when I first heard from Chris Lockie, I'm not sure how you pronounce his last name, but I met him in Mallorca and he emailed me and was like, "You should interview these guys about their Bitcoin DeFi project."

1:27:45And I was like a bit skeptical, but I like it. So I like anything that goes against the orthodoxy, just for the sake of it.

1:27:51George BurkeWell, I think you're talking to the right guys. We do nothing but go against orthodoxy, apparently. Ask my girlfriend.

1:28:00Vlad CosteaOkay, I'm not gonna, but thank you very much. And one last question: how can people follow you wherever, like the project and you personally?

1:28:13George BurkeSo I'll start with the project. Personally, I have no real brand or presence. Not like Eric, Eric's the rock star. So the company, Portal, can be found at portaldefi.com. Twitter is portal_finance. And this is where, you know, you can engage with us. If you want to engage with Eric personally, Eric, go for it, man.

1:28:41Eric MartindaleYeah, I'm @martindale everywhere. M-A-R-T-I-N-D-A-L-E. I haven't been as active on Twitter lately, too much wrapped up in the code, but twitter.com/martindale. I'm also github.com/martindale if you want to snoop around on my code. Those are probably the best places to go. I also talk about a couple of these things, like if you don't control the software, the software controls you. My website ericmartindale.com, and portaldefi.com for the overall project.

1:29:17Vlad CosteaI very much appreciate the fact that you took the time to do this interview, and I know that you have another meeting right now that's about to start and you have to run to get to it, so I'll let you go. So thank you very much, and I very much look forward to having another conversation, because it seems like we can't really run out of topics.

1:29:37George BurkeI really enjoyed this personally. Thank you for hosting it. You're a great host, you know the topic extremely well, and it takes a really talented podcaster to understand, you know, what the heck is coming out of Eric's mouth here, because really, it's technically hard.

1:29:55Vlad CosteaI try, so don't think of me as someone technical, but I try to read and understand stuff. And I had Peter Todd, for example, almost two years ago, and I felt like a complete idiot. I had no idea what he was saying, so I had to keep up with him somehow. So I had to pick up some books, some readings, read more on cypherpunk culture and history, and just try to keep up.

1:30:19Eric MartindaleThat's exactly right. That's the rabbit hole for you. And I think it is going to result in a net positive benefit for all of humanity and human liberty. So, Vlad, thank you again for the time and for the interview. Looking forward to future conversations. And raise one glass to human liberty for me.

1:30:39Vlad CosteaI will. So talk to you later. Bye.

1:30:58George BurkeBye guys.

1:31:13Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin are volatile.

1:31:14Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp, and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip, and if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.

1:32:35Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free.

1:33:40Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.

1:33:40================================================================================ Production notes: Remote video-call interview in English, with a short music intro and recorded sponsor reads for Vaultoro, Wasabi Wallet and Bitcoin Reserve repeated in three ad breaks, around 17:54, 46:54 and 1:30:58. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (127 chunks) and 57 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; second opinion: /workspace/bitcoin-takeover-best-quotes/s10-transcripts/s10e1.txt (read-only); [unclear] resolve pass: 1 of 1 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021" and "Thank you." hallucinations; Guest A→Eric Martindale, Guest B→George Burke; fixed Yellamance→Elements, Ian Griggs→Ian Grigg, layer-free→layer three, these camps→the scams, well-taught→well thought, tasks→tests, SegWit2x, Drivechain(s), "in the meetup"→"the meetup"; restored dropped speech (Vlad's DeFi hacks line, Bitcoin Core 0.22, Fabric/Lightning, custodians, gas, Lightning Network flood-fill, etc.) from second ASR/re-check; split long paragraphs with interpolated timestamps; Speakers mapped (Guest A=Eric, Guest B=George); "Eric, you might want..." reassigned to George; Tier Nolan interjection split to Vlad; Schneier reply split to Eric. Hallucinations removed ("Bitcoin Layer 3" lines, "This is a very important topic", "they're not going to be able to do that", jingle); ad voiceover labelled; Vaultoro/Chaumian CoinJoins/Hillebrand/portaldefi.com/POV Crypto fixed; dropped gaps restored from second ASR and Scribe; Restored dropped speech (JoinMarket, "appear identical", "preclude the problem", Grin sidechain sentence, "open source philosophy", ad-read gaps incl. Bitcoin Reserve URL) from second ASR/re-check; removed hallucinations ("I'm going to be talking about Bitcoin...", injected "Eric Martindale:" label, "existing Bitcoin into that chain" echo, "doing right now"); fixed "typhoon"→cypherpunk, GRIN→Grin, Segregated Witness, Confidential Transactions, Real World Cryptography, Voltoro→Vaultoro, Chaumian CoinJoins, Max Hillebrand, "doing the DAO hack"→during; Guest A/B→Eric Martindale/George Burke; jingle labelled Ad voiceover, commercial break to Vlad; split long monologues; Restored dropped speech from second opinion/Qwen (larger debate, gap at 55:17, 55:49, 57:44-58:04, 59:45, 01:05:08, 01:07:42-01:08:06); removed "Bitcoin Layer 3.0" hallucinations and fake "Eric Martindale: Hello everyone" turn; fixed speaker attribution (Portal segue question is Eric's per "Well, Eric" contradiction resolved by "Hire full-time Bitcoin Core developers" answer; tip-of-spear split; "Oh yeah, I agree" to Vlad); names: Wladimir van der Laan, Michael Saylor, Luke Dashjr, Matt Corallo, Jonas Schnelli, Alex Gladstein, Portal, Bitcoin Core, SegWit, Taproot; Guest A→Eric Martindale; removed "The Bitcoin Layer 3.0" hallucination at 01:11:14 and stray "Thank you."; split Vlad's "Oh, that's good", "You even have", "That sounds" lines; restored dropped speech from second ASR/re-check (shitcoin context, "the other end of the spectrum", "mass algorithm society", "And of course", "So", "I mean, this is the level of detail...", "energy efficiency of the market", "maybe even start companies that do chip fab", "compelled by an outside authority", "So currently... Lightning Network", "we'll provide services", "We want to build", "existing economy... those services"); David Tom→David Chaum, "You're mine, Mirko"→"You remind me of him"; Eli5→ELI5; RaspiBlitz, RISC-V, Saylor, pre-synced; Assigned continuation to George Burke; removed "Thank yo

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00