S10 E5: Lucas Ontivero on Wasabi Wallet, Wabisabi & Bitcoin Privacy
Search this conversation
0:29Vlad CosteaHello there, and welcome to Season 10, Episode 5 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad, and my guest today is Lucas Ontivero, who is from Argentina. He was the first employee at Wasabi Wallet, who also happens to be a sponsor of this season. And I have met him last week, and by the time I publish this, it will probably have been last month. But I have met him and he was working on something very interesting with WabiSabi.
1:05And he seems to be concerned with making Bitcoin more fungible and improving the CoinJoins so that the outputs are not equal anymore and anyone can contribute with any amount regardless of how much money they have. So mixing would be for everyone. And also he has been involved in Bitcoin for a long time because at the time when he first started working for Wasabi, I suppose he was already interested in Bitcoin for a number of years. I'm not sure if that's going to be the focus of our conversation, but privacy is very important. And I'm very happy to have you, Lucas.
1:52Lucas OntiveroHello, Vlad. I'm happy to be here.
1:56Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm happy to have you. You're one of the happiest people I've ever met in this space. Very optimistic. So tell me... Okay, let me start with this. Last week, you were making a presentation at Wasabi about the CoinJoin implementation and how it's going to divide the mixes in smaller amounts that are uneven and hard to distinguish. And you kind of lost me during the explanation. And I was wondering if you have like a very simple way of explaining what that WabiSabi algorithm is going to do.
2:36Lucas OntiveroOkay, yes. Basically, as you have described, the idea is to allow to have unequal outputs, right? It's different to what now we have in the version one, where all the outputs are 0.1 or so.
2:55So in this way, how to guarantee that you have privacy after you create unequal outputs? It's a very, very delicate topic. And the idea is that, well, if those amounts will be different, we are going to use some kind of standard amounts. Just for example, you know, what we have normally in the fiat currencies: we have, for example, let's say dollars, we have one dollar, five dollars, ten dollars, two dollars, twenty dollars. Well, those amounts are basically standard and highly composable. Basically, you can pay whatever amount just by combining those standard denominations.
3:51This is basically the idea with the new WabiSabi protocol. Of course, the number of standard denominations is really big. There are a very, very big set of denominations that you can use to combine in different ways to pay whatever you want in exact amounts, if you have those coins. And the idea is, okay, given we have not only one standard denomination, but a lot of different denominations, how can we make sure that your denominations will be the same, let's say, that you are going to use, with highly probably that you use the same denominations that other participants, right?
4:52So basically, for example, if I participate with, let's say, one Bitcoin and you participate with 0.8 Bitcoins, how can we generate outputs, right, that an external observer cannot distinguish? I mean, it cannot know if those outputs are yours or are mine. Well, in that case, I can, for example, break my Bitcoin, my one Bitcoin, into 0.5, and you can break your 0.8 in 0.5 and 0.3, for example, right?
5:30In that case, there is one anonymity set. We are changing that metric, but let's talk about anonymity set. There will be three 0.5 outputs: two are mine, one is yours, and one 0.3 output that is yours, right? So in that case, you have some ambiguity, because an observer doesn't know which one of those 0.5 coins is yours.
6:06Right. Of course, it knows. The external observer can know that two of those have to be mine, right? Because it's easy to verify. So what happened? It is possible to select other denominations, right? For example, 0.2. I can split my one Bitcoin in five 0.2 outputs, and you can split your 0.8 in four 0.2 outputs. So in that case, we have something similar to what we have right now in Wasabi 1. All the outputs look the same, so an external observer cannot say, "Okay, this output belongs to Lucas and this output belongs to Vlad."
7:02So, as you can see, there are many possible strategies to split or decompose your participating amount. Right. So the idea is to follow a deterministic strategy that if everybody follows the same strategy, right, we can guarantee that the denominations that we are going to select will be the same, or with high chances to use the same denominations that everybody else. And in that way we can guarantee that an external observer cannot, let's say, undo the transaction, if you want, right? Of course, this is a simplification, right?
7:54The idea is that when you have more and more and more users, let's say 100 users, and all of them try to use or select those denominations that have higher chances to be selected by the rest, right? So in that way, the observer cannot know if the 0.5 is mine, is yours, or is who knows, belong to whom. I mean, taking account of those, let's say, 100 participants.
8:35In the end, that is all the complexity. Technically, it's much harder, but from the point of view of the high level understanding, that is basically what we are working on. Does it make sense?
8:51Vlad CosteaYes, so you're trying to allow anyone regardless of the amount of Bitcoin that they own. Currently, you need 0.1 to CoinJoin with Wasabi. And you're trying to allow anyone with smaller amounts to be able to participate. And those who have larger amounts and participate in the same round, the same CoinJoin, are going to have their coins divided into, or divided by, the minimum amount and they're going to have many more outputs that are equal to that specific amount. Did I understand that correctly?
9:26Lucas OntiveroYes, it's not only for those that have less than the current 0.1. It's for any amount. So we are removing... because... Okay, let me finish this and I would like to go deeper. Now, the amount that you participate with is irrelevant, right? You can participate with 0.001 or with 100 Bitcoins, that doesn't matter really, right? That is something very important. So the thing is how to make sure that if everybody follows the same strategy, or at least a group, a set of people follow the same strategy, all will split the participating amount in standard denominations, right?
10:28And that we can guarantee that those standard denominations will repeat many times, right? So not only that it will repeat many times, also that the amount of possible decompositions that an external observer can extract from that CoinJoin has the highest level of ambiguity, right? If you allow me, I would like to tell you what's the problem with Wasabi Wallet 1. It's not with Wasabi Wallet 1, it's with the ZeroLink protocol.
11:15Vlad CosteaOf course I allow you.
11:17Lucas OntiveroThe ZeroLink protocol. The ZeroLink protocol is based on signatures, cryptographic signatures. In this case are blinded signatures, but they are signatures, right? And a signature, you can verify if the signature is valid or not, and the result is "yes, it's valid" or "not, it's not valid." That is basically all the information that you can extract from a signature.
11:57It's basically true/false or zero/one. It's one bit of information. So if you verify the signature and the signature is not valid, well, in that case, you send an error and say, "Okay, something is wrong. There is nothing we can do," right? Basically, if the signature is valid, then what to do? Well, in that case, we say, "Okay, you sent me this signature, so you have the right to register an output," right?
12:36But given we only know that the signature is true, there is no way for us to decide, right, what output, I mean, what's the value of the output that you can register, or the script type, anything. So there is no other option than using one and only one standard denomination, that in our case is 0.1. If you want to allow, for example, to participate with 0.5, or I mean, not participate with 0.5, I mean, if you want, for example, to be able to create output of 0.5 or 0.0005, you have to create another pool, right? Another round. But you cannot generate different amount because you don't have that information. Now, in WabiSabi, we don't use signatures.
13:39We use credentials, and these credentials are not only valid or not, but also provide additional information. For example, the amount, right? You can verify that the credential is valid and that the amount that comes with that credential is available, right? So that the one who is sending you this credential have that money in the round, so you can create an output, right, with that amount. That amount is arbitrary and is not enforced by the protocol. You can create an output of whatever you want.
14:31Of course, the client uses these standard amounts because it's convenient, right? But the protocol in itself, it's flexible enough to allow you to do a lot of crazy things, right? Batching transactions, payment in CoinJoins, etc. Right now, we are not doing anything of that. Our first goal is to have CoinJoins with unequal outputs, and that allow us again to remove the minimal denomination, the maximum denomination, right? And that's it. There are still some minimum denomination because there are, you know, dust, also a maximum denomination that I don't remember. I think are 4,000 Bitcoins or something like that, something really, really, really crazy.
15:33But basically, given we change the cryptography, the cryptography primitives or constructions that we are using, is that now all the previous restrictions have gone, and we can finally create CoinJoins with these arbitrary outputs, right? That is basically the big difference. Another thing that is also very important, and it's possible now with WabiSabi, for example, is that before, in ZeroLink, it doesn't matter how you implement ZeroLink, the coordinator knows your inputs, because you register your inputs all together, so they know that input 1, input 2, input 3 are yours.
16:32In WabiSabi, with the credential system, that doesn't happen anymore. The coordinator doesn't know which coins belong to you, right? So the coordinator knows a lot less than before, so you don't have to trust on the coordinator as before. I think that's another huge thing. Basically, also, given we have this power of breaking and selecting arbitrary denominations, some are really big, other are really small, the chances of getting change as result is also much, much lower. It's not impossible. Sometimes, from time to time, you will receive some output that is different to the rest of the outputs, right? So we can call it change, but that is more like an exception, right, when there is no other way, right?
17:54Anyway, removing that is something that can be done with long-term fee credentials, so that you can give that money, that of course has to be just a few sats, right, to the coordinator, for example, so you can use that long-term credential as payment for the fee of future CoinJoins. I mean, there are many, many, many ideas that can be done, but are out of scope for the moment.
19:01Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.
19:02Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp, and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
20:23Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs.
20:52After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels.
21:39Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.
22:18Yeah, and I really like the fact that you're so open about the fact that WabiSabi is not going to solve Bitcoin privacy, you know, entirely. It's just a solution to gain more privacy for transactions. But something which I like and that you described concerns your privacy against the CoinJoin coordinator, because usually we think about, you know, chain analysis or outside observers or the people who sent us the funds or whoever looks at what happens on the public blockchain. But we don't think much about what the coordinator of these CoinJoins actually knows about us, and what kind of information they get, and what kind of information they can retain.
23:04So the fact that with WabiSabi you minimize that kind of data, I think that's very useful.
23:10Lucas OntiveroYep, in our mind, I mean, right now there are a few coordinators, right? One is the official, let's say, WabiSabi coordinator. And there are other guys that are running coordinators. In fact, there are one that modify the coordinator for allowing mixing Litecoins, and in the future we have... well, this is a bit secret, but there will be more coordinators, not all run by zkSNACKs, that is the company behind Wasabi Wallet. But the idea is that this is open source. It's really open source project.
24:04Everything is there. Everything is in GitHub. That means that if someone wants to run a coordinator, well, it's really easy. Just clone the repository and compile it and that's all, right? And there is no way for you, for example, to verify what the coordinator is doing, right? You can verify that what you compile in your machine, what you are running in your machine, right, is correct, and you can see how it works and review the code, but you don't know what code is running in the coordinator. So...
24:54Obviously, you cannot trust on the coordinator, because tomorrow someone can, you know, set up a coordinator and say, "Come and mix for free. Mix for free with our new super coordinator. Faster, whatever, right? Cheaper, or we pay you for mixing with us," whatever, right? And many people can switch to that other coordinator, because that's something that is allowed and is perfectly okay in Wasabi, right? You can configure your Wasabi to run, to work with any coordinator, right? You don't know what, if that coordinator is run by whom.
25:44Right? So obviously, in our model, the coordinator is an enemy. The client treats the coordinator as an enemy, and it tries to minimize what reveals to the coordinator. So now, the fact that the coordinator cannot link your inputs. In fact, not only because we don't send all the inputs in a same message, but also because we have in mind things like timing analysis. So we randomize the times when we register the inputs, and it's a bit more complex than that even. And it is really, really important, so you can one day switch to another coordinator, and you know that your client is taking care of protecting your privacy against that coordinator.
26:48Vlad CosteaRight. So that's really interesting and useful. And something else about which I want to talk right now is that you're basically not the first guy, but the second guy and the first employee that Adam, nopara73, hired for the Wasabi project. Prior to your involvement, he was working with Matthew Haywood, who right now is at Blockstream. And they were working on a wallet that wasn't named Wasabi, but had similar properties and similar qualities. And what was the project like along the years? Because you have seen it grow as the first employee, you're the person to work on the code and see everything that has changed.
27:31How do you feel about it? And do you think that it's heading towards the right direction to make Bitcoin more fungible?
27:39Lucas OntiveroI think so, yes. I'm sure about that. At the beginning, you know, the first wallet that nopara73 started, it's the HiddenWallet. I think it worked, but nopara was not happy with the result, it seems, so he decided to make something better, and I think Wasabi is really much, much better than that. And after that, you know, we had some really, really modest goals.
28:24Sometimes I don't remember the goals, but at the beginning it was, okay, what if we have one CoinJoin a week? Then one CoinJoin a day. Then our goal was to have 20 participants in a CoinJoin. After that, I don't remember honestly if the next goal was 50 or something like that, because 50 was an important number, because many people said that, well, 50 anonymity set was good enough. But then we had this goal of having the first 100 participants CoinJoin, and well, then one CoinJoin every hour, and it was getting better and better and better and better.
29:22But even though, the idea of having a more flexible CoinJoin algorithm was always in our mind, always. Particularly in my case, the idea of having these huge transactions for specifically making payments in CoinJoin, so that I can pay you, right, in a cheaper and also more private way, was always in my mind. However, it was nopara who started with this research, using some technology that developed by the Signal app team. That is basically this credential system. Well, and with that, a new set of possibilities appear, and I think the future is unknown.
30:36I mean, the kind of things we can do with this is really amazing. For example, something that, this is an idea that we are not going to implement anytime soon, but it is really easy to do, is, for example, imagine I want to pay you. I have to pay you one Bitcoin. So I register my inputs.
31:02Vlad CosteaOh, you have to pay me one Bitcoin. Send it to me.
31:06Lucas OntiveroYeah. Yes, I'm doing that. I'm doing it. I'm describing the mechanism. So I send the inputs, right? I receive one credential for the equivalent to one input, sorry, for one Bitcoin, right? And I can send that credential to you. I don't know, let's imagine it should be automatically, right? Your wallet with my wallet should be able to talk, to communicate, so my wallet can send the credential to your wallet, right? And then your wallet can register the outputs. I mean, use that credential to register the outputs.
31:50Right? It can be in any way, in 0.5, 0.5 or 5 0.2 or whatever, right? So, and when I have to sign, my wallet asks your wallet, "Is everything okay?" If yes, my wallet signs the CoinJoin transaction. And what that means? It means that I pay you, right? But I don't know what your outputs are. So that is completely different than what we have right now, that I pay you and I know the link and I can follow the payment. I can see how you spend the payment that I send you, right?
32:44This unlinkability of the payment is something that increases the fungibility, because I cannot follow the payment, right? And you cannot follow the payment back neither, because you receive a credential, but you don't know which of all those inputs are mine, you know? Something like that is possible. It's possible to implement other protocols. It's possible to use it for creating Lightning Network channels. I mean, because remember, these standard denominations are just an agreement, right, between the clients, but are not enforced by the protocol. You can register the output of any arbitrary amount, whatever you want. So it's really powerful. But again, this is taking a lot of time, so we narrow the scope to CoinJoins. And that is the first goal and the most important, of course.
33:57Vlad CosteaYes, something I like about zk-SNARKs, zkSNACKs, not SNARKs, as a company and the Wasabi project is that the goal is privacy. The goal is Bitcoin privacy, not, you know, to make CoinJoins. So I don't think CoinJoins is the end game. It's just the tool that will get us there. But I like the fact that you're also looking into opening Lightning channels, and I'm pretty sure that you're looking into that statechain way of transferring UTXOs, which I think is also interesting. CoinSwap, I think it's called.
34:33And ultimately, this will only make it harder to track Bitcoins, because now the traditional way of tracking transactions is to look at addresses and try to associate them with a name with an ID, and then see with whom they're making transactions and make assumptions about who they might be. But when you have this kind of mixing technology, which takes outputs that are owned by different people and puts them together in a way that they carry the fingerprints of all of the participants, so that all coins are equally clean and equally tainted, I think that opens up a new possibility.
35:16Plus, if you are able to use that statechain application to swap your UTXO with somebody else's, that can be interesting, even though sometimes I think about it and I think, okay, so how do you know you're not going to end up with a worse UTXO set just because you have done this CoinSwap with an unknown person? I don't know. At least in CoinJoins, everything is uniform and everything is just as clean and just as tainted. In the case of CoinSwaps, you never know what you're going to get. It's a box of chocolates.
35:56Lucas OntiveroYep, yep, I don't know. There are different solutions. CoinSwap is one. It's true that you are switching or exchanging coins with different history, so you don't never know if the... I mean, personally, I don't like it. But it's something personal, it's not something technically, right? It's just the fact that you don't know. But with CoinJoins, I think it is different, because it is true that some people can be participating in the same round with you with coins that, I don't know, let's imagine it have some illicit source, I don't know. But we will have, right?
36:58Now, right now we have hundreds of coins participating, and with WabiSabi, I think we will have even more. Also, right now, the minimum amount for participating is 0.1. It could be a lot, right? But with WabiSabi, that will be removed. So I think the number of people that can participate will be much, much bigger, right? Also, it will be much faster for those with a lot of money to participate, because basically right now we have outputs with higher denominations, not only 0.1, right?
37:49Finally, the idea of having CoinJoins in background, right, that the wallet is taking care of mixing your coins, it's also something that is really good. And I hope we can have rounds more often, so that you don't need to be online, let's say, 40 minutes or one hour. It could be really, really good if we have liquidity enough to guarantee, let's say, a CoinJoin every I don't know, 10 minutes. It could be really good. So, because, you know, you open your wallet for receiving a payment, and that payment is automatically mixed, right? And that's it. It could be really good.
38:52In the end, I think the solutions, I mean, this protocol should be used for other things too. The thing is that eliminating the restrictions allows you to do much more things. You are not tied to any specific amounts or outputs or whatever. So I think that the possibilities are huge. But of course we have to finish it first. If we don't finish it... I mean, this is taking a lot of time, because we want to take care of all the details. That is, and sometimes we continue trying to make it perfect.
39:49Vlad CosteaYeah, and I very much appreciate the process of getting there and the fact that you're taking so much time coding and reviewing. I was part of a coding session, which also involved some reviewing, where basically all of you guys, everyone working on the WabiSabi protocol, you're looking at lines of code and making suggestions about what can be changed, what can be improved, trying to explain how stuff works. And I was feeling a bit, you know, not part of that conversation, because I did not understand what the code was doing, every line individually.
40:27But at the same time, it's good to see that there is this kind of pursuit, this kind of research that goes into making Bitcoin more fungible. Because if we want to have a universal currency of the internet, which doesn't make any kind of discriminations, we must make sure that you cannot discriminate between the coins. And that's going to be very hard, specifically because when they are mined, the bitcoins are not really fungible. They have a very clear history since they became part of the block reward and all the transactions that have happened since then.
41:06You can actually discriminate between a Bitcoin that was used on the Silk Road in 2012 and one that was used recently to get transacted on Coinbase. And I don't think that's very good for, you know, for the mission of the Bitcoin project.
41:28Lucas OntiveroI'm sorry. Do you think that is good or that is not good? Sorry, I didn't get it.
41:34Vlad CosteaOh, I said I don't think that it's good for the mission of the Bitcoin project. I'm sorry if I said otherwise, but that's what I meant. I don't think it's good that we have this situation.
41:46Lucas OntiveroOkay. I think the final goal, basically, is to have this new money that is Bitcoin as fungible as possible. I think in the end we are not going to be... I mean, now, right now, there are a lot of solutions, right? We have JoinMarket, Wasabi, Samourai. I think there are other solutions too, or proposals. I think many of them will appear in the future and will provide also good services.
42:30I think there will be many providers like us, probably using our own technology, right? Our coordinators, because it's really easy. You just need to clone the repository and that's all, right? Of course, you can modify it too, or configure it in a different way. I think in the future there will be many providers. I think there is less room for centralized mixers because they are risky. They have their exit scams. It's really safe to mix with Wasabi, for example, or JoinMarket or Samourai.
43:16So I think that is a trend that will continue. In the end, I think we will have the privacy that we deserve, basically because the need for exchanges and KYC interactions will be lower, or at least that's what I envision, right? If I can, for example, pay you with your car, I want your car. If I want to, if I can pay you with my bitcoins without having to go to a bridge to the legacy system because you want, I don't know, US dollars, for example.
44:06And if you accept my bitcoins and someone else accepts your bitcoins, right? And we don't touch those exchanges or banks or whatever. That, in conjunction with the CoinJoins or privacy enhancement providers, I think Bitcoin will be really fungible.
44:34Vlad CosteaYes, and I very much look forward to that day when we can look at Bitcoin and not make any discrimination. Because in its essence, fungibility means that one unit is equal to any other one. So you shouldn't mind that this one has been in that place and that one has been in another place. In the case of fiat money like US dollars, you can argue that they have different backgrounds, like the dollar bills. They can be printed recently. They can come from Pablo Escobar and have cocaine traces on them.
45:08But in commerce, nobody is going to differentiate between them, just because they have switched hands so many times that it's very hard to incriminate anyone with the fact that they have possessed one of those bills. And money is money. Like, you cannot argue that a criminal is not allowed to buy bread to eat until the legal system does its job. So you cannot restrict some economic freedoms on the basis that you don't want bad actors to actually participate in this, because it's inhumane. And we're supposed to build a system which enables anyone to have the greatest amount of economic freedom.
45:52At least that, to me, is my understanding of what Bitcoin is. And we should not just accept that it is traceable and this pseudonymity is getting thinner by the day.
46:07Lucas OntiveroYes, exactly. And that's basically why, if, well, we develop, for example, the coordinator, the coordinator cannot be trusted, and you can verify the code that you are running in your machine and see that the client doesn't trust on the coordinator, right? And that's why, for example, even if the coordinator, for example, could be logging the IP addresses, you go with Tor. Even if the coordinator tries to fool the client, sending some customized, let's say, information, the client will not trust on that information. That is basically the model, right?
47:02So given the coordinator cannot be trusted, right, the client doesn't send useful information to the coordinator. So the coordinator, even if it's malicious, right, and it does its best, it cannot collect information from you. So basically, if tomorrow, for example, imagine we are not running the coordinator, someone else is running our Wasabi coordinator, even if that person tries to deanonymize you, right, and tries to log everything, that information is not useful. That's basically the secret. Otherwise, imagine if we, for example, require you to create an account, for example, right?
48:04And you have to access to the API with your API ID, right? So you have no privacy against the coordinator. So the coordinator could log absolutely everything, right? All your activity, right? And know where your money come from, where your money is going to, right? It makes no sense. The idea is exactly the opposite. Don't discriminate, because if we don't know anything, we cannot discriminate you. This is more or less like in the real world. If you interact with me with your avatar and your name in Twitter is "the little mouse", for example, well, I cannot discriminate you, because I don't know if you are a kid, an old man, a woman, an Asian, a black, an Arab, an American.
49:15I know nothing about you, right? So I cannot discriminate you. Basically, that is more or less the idea.
49:22Vlad CosteaYes, and we are trying to build that. And we should be as open as we can to these privacy innovations in Bitcoin, because there are lots of people who say, "No, the base layer is supposed to be transparent, and let's not do anything to it to obfuscate transactions, because this is not Monero," or arguments like that. But if the project, you know... I like to think of Satoshi, the creator of Bitcoin, as a cypherpunk, and he also had a chapter in the white paper which was called Privacy.
49:54And just because his assumptions about privacy were wrong and he was proven to be too optimistic about the pseudonymity of using different addresses doesn't mean that we should not pursue to improve that.
50:08Lucas OntiveroYep. By the way, I think Satoshi was not so wrong. The thing is that now we are interacting with entities that collect information, right? And also that people doesn't take enough care of their privacy, so they reveal and create these links between addresses and identities. So I think Satoshi was not so wrong. I think perhaps in the end he will be right. But, you know, now, for example, I think there are people working on the cross-input signature feature for Bitcoin. Basically, that means that we can have, instead of having one signature per input we can have only one signature for all the inputs, basically, right?
51:11What in the end means, basically, in terms of space, it saves space in the blockchain. What means also that it could be cheaper to create batch transactions than sending normal transactions, right? And that could make transactions like CoinJoins, that are huge transactions with tons of inputs, cheaper than other transactions. So basically we could have an, I don't know if an incentive, but at least if you know that you don't have to pay so much, that right now are really inexpensive, but if you know that mixing your coins is cheaper than just sending, right?
52:09Or that you can pay in a CoinJoin, or you can, for example, open Lightning channels in a cheaper way using a batch transaction or a CoinJoin, for example. I think that could be a very good incentive for moving more privacy on-chain, because we need privacy on-chain too. I mean, in the layer one, or layer zero, I don't know, in the first layer, if you want. So I think it's important too.
52:48Vlad CosteaYou know, not only that Bitcoin privacy matters and it's important to work on it, but, you know, there are so many projects happening, and I like to think that they are all well-intended, even though there was this hype around Taproot that basically it would make chain analysis obsolete and it would make, you know, Bitcoin a lot more private. But this is only applicable to closing Lightning channels and to multisigs and to other types of complex transactions that are going to look exactly the same. And Taproot is more like an upgrade for efficiency, to not make big transactions occupy a lot of block space. I think that's what it does, basically. The fact that it has some small impact on privacy and some small impact on scalability, and also, you know, it might make transactions smaller and make the fees smaller. I mean, those are like byproducts, but the point was to make it efficient.
53:58Lucas OntiveroWell, I think what happened with Taproot is something similar to what happened with WabiSabi, right? You switch the crypto primitives to something more flexible, and then the range of possibilities increases a lot, right? So now it is easier to do a lot of things that before... with Taproot, basically, that's the point. For example, what I mentioned a few minutes ago, if we have cross-input signatures, for example, well, that is basically because we have Schnorr signatures that came with Taproot, with the Taproot fork, right?
54:54Before, I don't know if that was possible. I think, I don't know, but in case it were possible, I think it shouldn't be so easy to implement, even when I'm sure it is not easy to implement. If it's not easy to implement with Schnorr signatures, then with ECDSA could be much, much difficult, right? Also, it's something that is designed to... It's not a solution. It's just like the toolset that allow other people to create solutions and smart contracts on Bitcoin.
55:42So I think there is some kind of marketing sometimes in this, with these things, that says, "No, well, now Taproot will solve everything, it will be more private, it will be..." Well, in the end it's not a lie, right? Because you need Taproot in order to develop these new solutions, but it's not the solution. What is being, let's say, released is just the toolset, or the tools to create those solutions, right? Now people have to develop those solutions, right? I think we, for example, in Wasabi, could use that for many things.
56:35For example, talking with people from Trezor, they say that, well, Taproot is something very good for them, right? Because it allows them to mitigate a lot of... not a lot, sorry, one very specific problem that they have right now, that they have solved, of course, but with Taproot the solution to that problem is simplified by a lot, because, for example, the amount of the output that you are spending, I mean the UTXO that you are spending, right, is part of the hash of the transaction.
57:26For example, there is a commit to that amount. All that kind of things are big improvements. It's just that people have to use those new tools, basically. And yeah, it's like sometimes, let's say, the marketing... it's not marketing, but let's say the marketing is like too optimistic, like that everything will be solved. And well, no, it's not magic. We have to create the solutions, but now at least we have the tools.
58:36Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp, and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured...
59:05Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
59:57Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast, Season 6, Episode 6, with Max Hillebrand.
1:00:49And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.
1:01:51Yes, and right now, you know, a lot of people were very excited about the fact that Taproot improves privacy, but right now not many people use Taproot wallets and Taproot addresses. So, you know, the fact that it was activated doesn't make any difference unless we actually use it. It's the same as in the case of SegWit. We need to actually make use of that upgrade, which in our current situation we're not. But it's going to take a while for wallets to get developed. Now, let me ask you a very hard question, very unpopular. It can make you say stuff that people don't like.
1:02:35But it's the kind of question that I like. So let's say that tomorrow there's going to be an emergency hard fork for whatever reason, because there is some fatal flaw in Bitcoin and we need to hard fork. And yeah. Would you be in favor of also adding confidential transactions or some other type of privacy like ring signatures or zero-knowledge proofs to Bitcoin? If, you know, we have always said that to add more privacy, we need to hard fork. And since we need to do an emergency hard fork, we can also add that. So would you be in favor of it?
1:03:11Lucas OntiveroI don't know. I don't know, because, well, you know, some people said, okay, it is not easy to verify that you are not creating money from thin air, because you cannot visually verify it. Right now transactions are not visually verifiable. I mean, they are visually verifiable, but nobody's verifying the transactions by hand, right? So, in that, that is something, an argument that I don't buy much, but it's true that it could be dangerous because it could allow someone to create money from nothing, right? And that can destroy... That can destroy Bitcoin.
1:04:20Because the Bitcoin promise is basically that nobody can create Bitcoin, more Bitcoins, right? That we have this 21 Bitcoin limit. So, I don't know in that regard. Also, you know, the range proofs used to, well, to guarantee that you are not having an overflow and creating money or doing some trick are really big, and I think the trend goes in the different direction. We are all the time looking for new ways to make the transactions smaller. Now, for example, this cross-input signature, it's also in some way a mechanism for scaling, right? Because if it is cheaper to use batch of transactions, right, you have an incentive to do that.
1:05:33And this is exactly the opposite, right? The range proofs are big, are really big, so it goes in the wrong direction. I really don't know. Sometimes I think about these topics, but I have no... I'm not 100% sure. So if I am not 100% sure, I have to say no. I could be against adding that. But anyway, with more information, my opinion can change.
1:06:17Vlad CosteaI think that with Zcash, they did quite a good job with zero-knowledge proofs, even though it's opt-in. There is still some way to verify publicly transactions and I think, you know, the shielded ones which are private are kind of in the minority. So it's probably easy to identify who's doing these transactions anyway, based on social media activity. But still, I think that maybe the research in privacy is not very mature yet. There are some promising protocols and methods to obtain transaction privacy.
1:07:00Lucas OntiveroYes, but you know that... I mean, there will be never another Bitcoin. Bitcoin is the thing, right? We have to take care of it. I think the idea is being as conservative as possible, right? In the end, in the end, it doesn't matter if some developer takes the opportunity to introduce something like that, right? Confidential transactions, because developers can do whatever they want. Now, are we going to install and run that node? I think I couldn't. And others like me by sure exist, so I think the net could split, right? You will have two different Bitcoins. And that's not good at all.
1:08:12Vlad CosteaOh no, and there was always this conversation that, okay, we had the scaling wars and what's coming next is the privacy wars.
1:08:23Lucas OntiveroYep, yep, but I don't know. Honestly, I know you expect something more than "I don't know" from me, but I don't know. That is the truth.
1:08:40Vlad CosteaWe haven't had any wars so far, so it's interesting. But at the same time, it seems like the privacy side is losing ground by the simple fact that the newcomers who are getting popular are anti-privacy and they express views that say no, Bitcoin should stay like this. So we are heading towards this ossification specifically because there are people who don't want any changes to be made. On the other hand, it's encouraging to see that Taproot got merged, even though the idea of adding Schnorr signatures for efficiency has been there since I guess 2010 or 2011.
1:09:19I think Adam Back was the first one to talk about it. Since then, they have been looking for ways to replace ECDSA with Schnorr. I don't think we have made a full transition to Schnorr as far as I can understand. I'm not a coder. But still, it's an important upgrade that we have made and it's encouraging to know that we can pursue future soft forks.
1:09:47Lucas OntiveroYeah, well, about the Schnorr signatures, it was introduced. Now you have to use it, right? It is there. You can use it. But in the end, Bitcoin is what the users agree, right? So I don't think the trend is against privacy. I don't see that. In fact, look at our business, let's say, it's growing. Other providers similar to Wasabi are also growing. So the demand in that area is getting bigger, right? So I think other technologies that, I mean, they are not something magical, but they provide some extra level of privacy like Lightning networks, for example, are being used more and more, right? The capacity of the channels are growing too. So this diversification of the clients, wallets, technologies are also making the thing a bit more not so easy to watch, right? I mean to surveil, because otherwise it was much easier when there was no CoinJoins, when everything was on-chain, it was much, much easier.
1:11:38Vlad CosteaYeah, I agree that it was much easier, but also there was a lot less activity. So I think it took like six or seven years until blockchain analysis really took off. And before that, the people were not really interested. If you read on Bitcoin Talk to see what they were saying about Satoshi's coins, their attitude was more towards the idea of not looking into it because it would affect the fungibility of the currency and they did not really care. They were like, "No, it's none of our business.
1:12:10We are libertarians mostly. Let's just leave that the way it is and move forward with the network." But then they developed all of these blockchain analysis tools, and they became more complex and also the tools to circumvent blockchain analysis became more sophisticated. So I feel like, in this battle, if we can call it a battle, the forces have always been, to some extent, even.
1:12:39Lucas OntiveroYep, I agree with that. But basically, you know, I never... It is hard to imagine how this evolved. This evolved really fast, really, really fast. There are things that sounded like impossible just two or three years ago, and now we are seeing things happen that are surprising me, for example, many things, right? I believe that Bitcoin will continue being adopted and also will continue being used as a peer-to-peer payment system, if you want, right? Because the problem is that right now everybody has to go through the legacy financial system.
1:13:40I think that that will change. That will change by sure. If I can buy something, I mean, now it's possible to buy things with Bitcoin in a way that was not so easy before, right? You can rent your house, buy airplane tickets, you can, in El Salvador, you can see that there is more real activity. There are a lot of things. So if people are not forced to use the legacy system, right, and also are educated and interested in the privacy enhancement technologies, well, I think that the future is...
1:14:31It's good. Of course, there is a lot of people that just want to gamble with the price, and they, okay, they open an account. They don't have their keys. They don't care. They are not, let's say... They don't really understand Bitcoin, but in the end they will understand it, right? Even if you, for example, are a trader, and after you see that Bitcoin price goes up, up, and more people want Bitcoin and more people have Bitcoin.
1:15:07It's impossible you don't get it. You will get it sooner or later. And in that case, right, when someone wants to offer you to pay you with bitcoins, you will say, "Yes, I want bitcoins. I have no problem accepting bitcoins." Right now, that is not the norm. In many... I think in most places, if you want to buy something you have to sell your bitcoins or something like that, right? Sell your bitcoins for fiat money. I think that will not last forever. I think now, you know, people in the street talk about Bitcoin, in any radio, in TV. So how long until people start getting the whole idea? I think it's unstoppable.
1:16:12Vlad CosteaYes, but you know, my biggest concern when it comes to adoption is that maybe it's happening too fast in the sense that we don't really have the user interfaces and something that's entirely non-custodial and allows you to use Bitcoin. I think right now the mobile wallet that I like the most and allows you to have a truly non-custodial onboarding experience is Breez, B-R-E-E-Z.
1:16:43But outside of that one, I can't really think of any solutions that I would entirely recommend to people to just use Bitcoin, because that one is very simple. And in the background, it's running LND. It's running BIP 157 or 158 for Neutrino. So it downloads some block filters. It works kind of like Wasabi in this regard. And part of the reason why I like Wasabi is that it grants you privacy even if you don't CoinJoin, by giving you network level privacy, and allowing you to learn how to manage UTXOs. I think that's very useful, especially to a newbie.
1:17:21And as far as I can understand, version 2.0 is going to have an even better user experience. Yeah, but my biggest concern is that we will end up with the kind of adoption which is custodial. I see that, I know that you like the situation in El Salvador, but I'm not a fan of the fact that they use the Chivo wallet. And most people just didn't think about it. They said, "Okay, the government tells us that this is the wallet that they developed for us.
1:17:55We're going to use it because it works." And I'm not even sure if they can withdraw. I guess they can convert to fiat, but that's a custodial experience over which the government has control. And I'm not even sure, but they might make the users KYC, so that they know who transacts which amounts. So what do you think about the situation in El Salvador where the situation with the Chivo wallet is entirely custodial, and the government might know how much money each of their citizens is using with that wallet?
1:18:34I think the most freedom that they have is to withdraw cash from an ATM. But even for that, they have to register. I don't think this is the ideal kind of adoption that we should be having.
1:18:48Lucas OntiveroNo, it is not. But the point is that people have this contact with the Chivo wallet because the government offers them free $30. Some of those people live with $10 a day or something like that, so it's something good for them. They just want the dollars, right? But what happened with those that now... They didn't know about Bitcoin and now they know about it. And they are young, and they have cell phones. And, you know, they start playing with this, with Lightning, because they can pay, for example, I don't know, McDonald's or any other of those places, and they can receive money.
1:19:50They can receive money from their, I don't know, their uncle or other familiar from the US, for example, right, with less fee. So, wait. Yeah, the idea, I understand the government wants to implement this. I understand they need KYC because basically they need to be sure that those $30 are going to the right person. I understand the government wants to, wanted to have control over the population, right?
1:20:32But on the other hand, they have introduced this system, right, that gives people freedom. Those that, not, it's not magical, right? You have to decide to use Bitcoin. You have to invest time in understanding Bitcoin, right? But now it is allowed to pay with Bitcoin, to receive Bitcoins, right? It's everything, it's easier for them. In fact, it's easier for them than for me, right, because I cannot receive Bitcoins, right, and register that I received my salary in Bitcoins, but they can, right? So it's much easier there. So it is not black and white. There are grays too.
1:21:31So in the end, in the end, I think it was a very good move. In the end, you cannot help someone that don't want to be helped. But there are people that will benefit from this movement, and I think in the end it will be good.
1:21:52Vlad CosteaYeah, you're always the optimist one, but I feel like we need to push for more education and help them understand that this is not the real Bitcoin experience, and you only use Bitcoin when you also use the Bitcoin network. Otherwise, you are trading the token on somebody else's network, which, you know, is not the ideal situation and does not provide you the same advantages and protections of, you know, decentralized money, which is immutable, which grants you irreversible transactions, lets you be sovereign with your own money.
1:22:27When somebody else is hosting the tokens on their network, you're open to confiscation and to all sorts of problems of censorship that happen today in the legacy financial system. And my point is that we should try to educate these people, to help them understand that they should move on from that one. It's okay to start with Chivo wallet, but we should help them aspire to do more and use more.
1:22:59Lucas OntiveroYes, but we do it. You do it all the time. I try to do it. We all try to do it. We all try to educate more people, right? And red pill them, right? But, you know, money is something that you never had to learn. You were born, and after a while you received a bill or a coin from somewhere, and for you it's natural. People don't learn about or don't study about money.
1:23:33Money is something that it was already there when you were born, right? So you never had to think about these things. People don't know what money is, how money is created, what it represents, why some money is worth more than other, why some people prefer one coin or one kind of money over others, why Venezuela money is worthless. You know, it's something that happens to them. There are people that will not, some people cannot learn about Bitcoin because it's incredibly difficult, because first of all, they have to understand what money is.
1:24:20And that topic alone is too complex, right? In fact, there is people that don't understand where the value comes from. In fact, there are competing theories about value, right? So it's really complex. On top of that, you have to explain this peer-to-peer cash system, right, with consensus mechanism. It's impossible. So, honestly, I'm the optimist, but I don't think someone that cannot read more or less well, right, can understand Bitcoin, because Bitcoin is the last topic of a long chain of things that you need to understand first.
1:25:15So I think that the other way around is possible. You say, "Hey, it's okay to receive Bitcoin. It's okay to send Bitcoin. You can pay your taxes in Bitcoin. You can request Bitcoin, to be paid in Bitcoin," right?
1:25:38And people can learn that. They can see how those that are saving Bitcoins start having a better, a more relaxed, let's say, economical situation, while those that bet for the local currencies, fiat currencies, are going bankrupt, if you want, or having hard times, right? So they can see it. And this happens again and again. Someone said, "Yes, because two years ago I received a payment in Bitcoin and I decided to save it, and now I have twice the amount," or something like that, right? And that is something that they can see, right? You don't need to explain anything. They can see it. So I think that in that way this can work. And also at the level of nation state, I think it could work.
1:26:48If, for example, this new bond that the El Salvador government have launched has a good acceptance from the investors, well, that would be huge, because there are many, many countries that have to pay a lot of interest rates or have to have these tough negotiations with the IMF and all that things, that could look at El Salvador and say, "Hey, look at how these guys are bypassing all the legacy system." It could work. I don't know if it will work, but it could.
1:27:48Vlad CosteaYeah, that's an interesting take. Sorry, I think I was speaking to you during your speech and I was muted, but it doesn't matter. I don't think I've said anything interesting or of value. But my point here is that we should always aspire to use better wallets, and we should always encourage the better technology to become popular. Right now, I think for mobile, the standard for a trustless onboarding is Breez. And I hope that they also add some sort of Tor integration for network-level privacy, even though you can get that optionally with an application like Orbot. But as you said, you should not have to learn about how money works.
1:28:34It should be just an afterthought or some sort of hobby. You want to use it, and if you want to use it, we should make it, you know, we should help the users make the most out of their payment experience. So in this regard, we should always promote the better wallets and tell people to use them. That's my point.
1:28:57Lucas OntiveroYes, and right now there is a very healthy competition on the wallet side, right? For example, if you use Breez, it's because you find something very attractive and convenient on that wallet, and then other wallets, by sure, will take things from Breez. But for example, those that want privacy will use Wasabi, for example, and then other ones say, "Okay, you know what, yes, I want to have this, but I also would like to have something like Wasabi, so let's use the Wasabi service for CoinJoining," right?
1:29:28And so basically this is evolving, this is evolving. There are many, many solutions. It is true that most are centralized, because when you have centralized, I mean, no, centralized, sorry.
1:29:58More are custodial, because being custodial makes your life easier, right? Your interfaces are easier to develop, are less expensive in terms of resources, and a lot of things. But of course, those wallets will be used only for those that don't care about privacy, right? If tomorrow people really, really decide that they want to have privacy, they will abandon those wallets and will use, for example, Wasabi. So there is this competition, right? It's focused mostly in features. Right now, I think the feature that most wallets want to provide is user friendliness, right? I mean, they want to have a great user experience, fast. They want to integrate frictionless on-chain and off-chain payments, that kind of things.
1:31:19Well, it is evolving all the time. And I think sooner they will also integrate some kind of CoinJoin, when CoinJoins are, you know, when they can, for example, have unequal outputs, if the CoinJoins are cheap enough, right? Why not? They can just integrate it in their wallets and so provide more features and better features.
1:31:54Vlad CosteaYeah, and that's also why I like Wasabi. I think for a desktop wallet, it offers the most interesting and most useful tools that are Bitcoin-only. There are people who are interested in, you know, multisig and stuff like that, but this is only optimized for privacy. And I don't think we should expect a wallet that's optimized for privacy to offer extra layers of complexity when it should get this one job done and do it very well. And I very much look forward to Wasabi 2.0. I'm not sure when it's launching, but everything that I hear about it is exciting and seems useful and seems to fix existing issues and improve stuff that we did not even think about. So I like that you're also thinking a bit ahead.
1:32:47Lucas OntiveroWell, yeah, we have now another preview, internal preview, in December. We hope this is the last internal preview, but I mean, it is the second one, right? We had one a month ago. And the idea is to release Wasabi Wallet 2 with basically two main changes: UX, usability, on one hand, and basically WabiSabi on the other one, and make it privacy, private by default.
1:33:30That means that you don't have to worry about handling your coins and mixing them, or selecting which coins you have to use or you want to spend, things like that. Just letting the wallet decide for you and take care of your privacy automatically, basically by CoinJoining in background, and also selecting the best coins for each payment based on how anonymous those coins are, right? And all what it already had, like, you know, network privacy and so on. Well, honestly, I would like to have a release date, but we don't have one yet.
1:34:33Vlad CosteaI mean, that's fine to just release it when it's done, as opposed to rushing it. And, you know, there's a lot of hype, so I suppose you guys are under a lot of pressure to get this right. And I would rather, you know, see a version that's ready to deliver what you have promised, as opposed to something that only delivers half and promises to get better in the future. It doesn't mean that, you know, you should never release it, because, as you say, the perfect software is the one that was not released yet. But still, you know, I'm excited for this.
1:35:18I'm going to run it just like I ran the first version of Wasabi and see how it's performing, how it's going. I'm very much a fan of making Bitcoin private, and I would like to thank you guys because you have been working, so you have been the first, you are the first employee of Wasabi Wallet, and you have been working on the project since 2018 or something.
1:35:48Lucas OntiveroYes, 2018.
1:35:50Vlad CosteaYeah, because it launched on the White Paper Day, in 2019, in January. No, not on the White Paper Day. It was announced on White Paper Day, I think, but it was launched on the third of January of 2019, on the same day when Bitcoin turned 10 years old.
1:36:14Lucas OntiveroAmazing, right?
1:36:16Vlad CosteaYes, it was very good timing.
1:36:19Lucas OntiveroAnd you know, at the time, I remember, for example, the Bitcoin price was more or less $3,000 each, right? And we had these really modest goals of one CoinJoin a week, I think, or something like that. So imagine the trend, right? The trend in whatever metric you want to use. It's going really, really, really well. I think people are using it more, and they want more privacy on-chain. Now we started the research of Lightning Network, how to guarantee privacy on Lightning Network. It will be a long research because, honestly, we don't know about...
1:37:22I mean, how to implement, how to guarantee some level of privacy on Lightning. So it will take a while, the research, and after that, the implementation. We are starting with that. So it will take a lot of, a few years, I think, before we have something, a product that integrates Lightning Network into Wasabi Wallet.
1:38:01Vlad CosteaYeah, and I have seen that there is a bounty. I think it's of half a Bitcoin or one Bitcoin for whoever has an interesting proposal for privacy on the Lightning Network. So once again, this is something I like about zkSNACKs. You don't just think about CoinJoins. You're thinking about Bitcoin privacy at large.
1:38:22Lucas OntiveroYes, that's the idea, because basically it's a system, right? Whatever you, if you, for example, participate in a CoinJoin, then it is important how you spend, or what's your next behavior, or how you, I mean, the solution doesn't work in isolation, right? That's basically why we are taking care of how you broadcast the transaction, how you synchronize the wallet, how you select your coins, how you create the outputs on the CoinJoin, right? What are the denominations, that they have to be composable, so you can in many cases spend them without getting change.
1:39:19I mean, for example, you can make a payment and if you have enough UTXOs, you have a good chances of creating that payment without change. Of course, we are still working on that, but I mean, it's sort of a system, right? It's not CoinJoin and that's it and then spending something different. It's all part of the same system. You cannot make a mistake. Of course, you can make mistakes, but it is good if you consider all the variables, or as much as possible, at least.
1:40:08The user can always find a way to make a mistake that you didn't have in mind or you believe it was not so easy to make, but anyway, the idea is to create that privacy solution. Not... Honestly, right now, Wasabi Wallet 1, I know many people uses Wasabi as a mixer, right? It is clear that pattern because in the support ticket they say that, right? "I mean, I send money to Wasabi, I CoinJoin my coins, and then I send it back to my original wallet."
1:40:54You say, "Well, but that's a problem. That's not how this works. I mean, you're doing it wrong," right? But that is basically because Wasabi was designed with a user interface that allowed you to do that, right? Wasabi Wallet 2 will not provide that. It's not that you have to... You will not have a console that you select your coins and you mix, no. Nothing like that. You just receive a payment and in background, that or those coins will be candidate for participating in a CoinJoin, and you will see nothing, right?
1:41:43And when you spend, well, the wallet will select the best coins for you and you have a penalization cost for consolidating coins, etc. So it's basically an integrated privacy solution, but that looks like any other wallet, basically.
1:42:06Vlad CosteaYes, so Lucas, we have learned a lot about what WabiSabi does and what this CoinJoin implementation will do. Now, let me ask you about what it doesn't do and something that you wish it did, but it will not, at least not now, but maybe in the future.
1:42:22Lucas OntiveroOkay, well, I think it is difficult to say. I think in, you know, Wasabi is a very transparent company and that means that we don't have to all agree in the same vision, right? So, what it does and what it doesn't do depends on your vision. Some people love the Wasabi, a really hacky wallet that you can, for example, see the public key, import, export. Some people would love to have output descriptors, Taproot.
1:43:11Make these payments in CoinJoins and have a programmable interface so other processes can interact with Bitcoin, you know, that kind of things. And those users, let's call it superpower users, right, love really, really advanced features that nobody else cares about, right? That is one, let's say, one vision: super advanced users, mostly Linux users, right? And now Ubuntu users. Then there is the vision of providing privacy to more people, as much people as possible. In that branch, for example, is nopara73. The idea is to make Wasabi a wallet really easy to do, that provides you privacy effortless, frictionless, right?
1:44:18It has to be easy to install, it has to be easy to run. The UI have to be beautiful, fast, right? Well, that is another branch, right? Of course, for example, super advanced users and friendly user interface teams have problems, right? Because they don't agree in the vision, basically. So, and then there is another branch, like my branch, let's say, perhaps there are others that agree with me, I don't know, that for me, the wallet is only like a bridge.
1:45:11to the service that is the WabiSabi CoinJoin, right, and all what the WabiSabi protocol provides, right? For me, the wallet is not so important because we can... For example, let's say Breez or BlueWallet or whatever, they could integrate WabiSabi in their wallets, right? So people could have mobile wallets, right, that they love, they think are good, that also provide CoinJoins or other features, right? To me, I always have seen Wasabi, or in this case the WabiSabi coordinator, as an infrastructure solution for others to use.
1:46:04So in my mind, for example, it's not important what the Wasabi client can do, but what the service allows to the consumers, the API consumers, to do. And that, we don't know what someone can do, right? Given it's a public API and the code is also public, you could create a solution on top of WabiSabi to do I don't know what, whatever. And that is what I like more.
1:46:44From my perspective, let's say, all what Wasabi does, or what Wasabi doesn't do, it's irrelevant because, for me, it's like a tool. You have the service, you have the client, the code, you have to build your solution on top of it. So it's more or less like Taproot, right? It's not the solution, it's the tool, and you have to create the solution and use the WabiSabi protocol and the WabiSabi coordinator.
1:47:35So there are many camps and we think all in different ways. Of course, we are very aligned behind the official, let's say, goal, that is providing privacy to as much people as possible in the easiest way, with a frictionless wallet that installs easily, you know, and looks good, and with a great user experience, and that's it. I don't know if I answered your question.
1:48:15Vlad CosteaNo, not really, but you explained, you know, the considerations behind the questions, so I think it makes a lot more sense now after you provided some background for what, you know, adding more features involves, and you basically distinguish between the wallet and the protocol on which you can build other stuff with the wallet or without it. So still, this is useful privacy research that's going on and nobody really knows how far it can get and how good it can really become when it's fully optimized.
1:48:51Lucas OntiveroYes, basically, sorry, because I would like to answer your question. The thing is that when you say, for example, what Wasabi doesn't do, the problem is that Wasabi is like one thing, right? But it is not. Basically, Wasabi is two things, right? A software product that is the wallet that people installs in their machines, right? And a protocol that is implemented by a coordinator, right, that provides a service. So it's a product and a service, two completely different things. So if we are talking about, for example, the client, what the client doesn't do, well, it doesn't do a lot of things.
1:49:46It doesn't provide, I don't know, multisig. It doesn't allow to work with other script types that is not SegWit version zero, right? And it doesn't... Now it will not allow you, I think it's a very good thing, but it will not allow you to select your coins, because basically the wallet is smart enough to decide for you better than what you can do, right? So it's a big step forward, but for example, for the advanced users camp, they don't like that because they want to see the coins, right?
1:50:33The UTXOs there in a list and be able to select them. Well, you know, that is basically what the client doesn't do. The service, what the service doesn't do, I think the service is very, very flexible. In fact, we are restricting the service, for example, for one specific script type, but just because Wasabi only uses that, I mean, the Wasabi client only uses that script type, but in fact it's an artificial restriction. The coordinator and the protocol is really, really flexible, so I don't know what it doesn't do. I think it can do whatever you want. Basically, that's the point.
1:51:29Vlad CosteaYeah, but I think my question was about something that you wish it did, you personally, not, you know, other users.
1:51:39Lucas OntiveroOh, okay. In my case, the client side, to me, it could be good if we could have, like, a daemon, like a process that can be consumed and integrated in other wallets, right? Because again, I really care about the service part. But that is on the roadmap. So yes, it doesn't do it, but it will do it. So I don't think there is something that the wallet doesn't do. For me, I think it's the wallet that I use because for me it's the best wallet.
1:52:34And yeah, honestly, I cannot say that the wallet doesn't do something. Well, perhaps, well, I don't know, it could be good... The problem is that Wasabi only uses SegWit version zero, right? So it makes not a lot of sense to implement output descriptors. But I think sooner or later we'll switch to it. I'm pushing for that. I provide like a training session for the developers, because, you know, we have developers with different seniorities, so some of them are not aware of the last technology, let's say. So I was explaining output descriptors and how we can implement Taproot using output descriptors and how that works, and it's convenient for interoperability.
1:53:44Also, it could be good if you, for example, can import descriptors from other wallets so you receive your transactions in Wasabi and Wasabi can mix those payments automatically. All that stuff is something very cool that I would like to have. Yes. And finally, other thing that is in the roadmap, so we will have it sooner or later, but it requires a lot of time, is the Pay-to-Endpoint feature, that is basically that you can pay without having to use the Bitcoin address, basically. Just to super simplify things, right, for example, I could have a contact list, so I select...
1:54:54"Pay to Vlad," for example, right? And I just pay you. Now, what's the address or what's the output? Well, there are many, many, many ways to do it, right? Basically, Pay-to-Endpoint means that my wallet can communicate with your wallet and agree on the payment, right, and all the details of the payment, and pay. So that is only possible if your wallet and my wallet are online. But there is a trend also that we observe, that most devices, or the trend is that devices are more time online now than offline, right? Especially, for example, mobile phones, right? But also computers. Computers sometimes are running all the time. So we believe that in the future, devices will be on all the time.
1:56:05And in fact, for example, Wasabi Wallet 2 is designed with that concept in mind, so when you close it continues running on background, right? So it could be possible to implement Pay-to-Endpoint with Wasabi. Of course, there are other considerations, because it is not good if you can only pay from Wasabi to Wasabi, right?
1:56:37Because we should be able to pay to... I mean, it doesn't matter what wallet. But that is something that I would love to have, but it is a bit futuristic still, and requires some extra work. It will not be developed anytime soon. But anyway, there are some intermediate solutions like the contact list, right? So you can, for example, say "pay to Lucas" and you have ways to generate addresses for me, so I can receive the payment. You don't need that I send you my address, for example, or things like that. It's not the same, not at all.
1:57:36Because there is no agreement about the payment, what to use, can we use a PayJoin or not, right? Who pays who, what? It's not the same, but at least goes in that direction, making payments easier, right, much easier, to improve the usability. Because usability is, you know, having to scan the QR code or receiving an address from WhatsApp or Telegram is not good. It's not good user experience. And it seems like nobody's working on that. And the solutions that I've seen are from the same wallet. So it's like this, from Wasabi to Wasabi, and that makes no a lot of sense, but, well, I don't know, it could work.
1:58:37Vlad CosteaI very much appreciate your honesty, Lucas, because you could give me a very short answer, but you went into detail and you explained how you would prefer to have pay-to-endpoint and how this payment to somebody would work without having an address that somebody generates. But I got to ask you for that kind of setup with the address book where you choose to whom you want to send the transaction. Would not that require for you to have the xpub or, you know, the master public key of the person to be able to generate addresses for them so that you can send them to a different address each time?
1:59:18Lucas OntiveroNot necessarily, right? Because, for example, I could have, for example, Vlad, and then next to the name an onion address, for example, right? So I know that your wallet is listening on that onion address. So my wallet can connect to your wallet, right, and say, "Hey, I have to pay you, I don't know, 0.1 bitcoins," right? And if you agree on providing some fees, we can do a PayJoin. I mean, our wallets can have this conversation, right? So your wallet, depending on how it was configured by you, it can say, yes, I want to receive payments with PayJoin or not, right?
2:00:19So imagine the answer is no, I don't accept PayJoin. Okay, so then give me an address that I can use, right? So your wallet provides an address to my wallet and that's it, basically. It's the same, but for you it's transparent, right? You receive a payment. Someone pays you don't know how, you receive the money. It's not the same that the current workflow that I have to say, "Hey, Vlad, I have to pay you. Please don't forget to send me your address, right?" And you have to...
2:00:53Paste your address somewhere, right? It's completely different. Well, that is an idea. Of course, there are many details that have to be taken into account. It could also work, of course, if I have your xpub key, right? It doesn't have to be the xpub key, it has to be just one xpub key, right? For a specific account, for example, right? Yes, it can work. It has many, many good things, but of course, pay-to-endpoint is, if your wallet is online, is much better because there are many things we can do.
2:01:41In fact, I can say I have to pay you, right? Could you agree if I pay you with a WabiSabi credential so you can claim your money in a CoinJoin? Right? I mean, pay-to-endpoint is the best. But there is no standard. So yes, we could implement it for Wasabi to Wasabi, but, well, that requires some extra study and considerations.
2:02:25Vlad CosteaYeah, so that's actually interesting to know how that can be implemented. But as you have described it, you still require a certain amount of trust in the person. So you need to build, if you have something like an address book, you need to build this network of trust because you're going to give away your IP address to somebody else so that they can send coins to you. Or you can share one of your xpubs from one wallet, which you think is okay to get shared to the rest of the network.
2:03:01Lucas OntiveroWell, first, I think this is not good to implement directly to an IP. That's why I mentioned that I can have an onion address, right? So an onion address means that I don't know the IP address of the payee, right? That's one thing. Then, depending how I configure my wallet, how you configure your wallet, right? There are many ways to make the payment.
2:03:42Right, so I really don't need to trust you and you don't need to trust me. And finally, something that is more important, no, no, it's not more important, but it is important, is that if I know, for example, your xpub or one of your xpubs, right, and I decide to pay you, I don't know if you still control that address. I can assume that you control that address, but I'm not sure. However, if your wallet and my wallet agree on the payment, well, that is safer, right? Because your wallet gave me the address. I mean, the Bitcoin address, right? So I can pay and I'm sure you receive the money.
2:04:35Of course, again, my dream is pay with credentials, right? Because I can give you a credential and, of course, I know that I pay you, right? But I don't know where your money went, right? Because I don't know the outputs that you register with those credentials. That, for me, is the best because there is no other solution that can provide that level of privacy. I mean, even a PayJoin, if we participate in a PayJoin, okay, we...
2:05:20Both, you and me, are playing together in order to fool a third one that is the observer. We agree on this trick, so an external observer cannot understand what is happening there, right? But I know the payment, you know the payment, and I can follow the trace if I pay you, right? And you can follow the trace back from my coin back, right? So yes, it's okay. But if we implement something like this, for example, payment with credentials, well, I don't know where your money went and you don't know where my money came from, right? So it's unlinkable.
2:06:17Vlad CosteaThat's pretty cool, I think. One last question that I have for you concerns your, I don't know, hobby for cypherpunk culture or literature. I know that at some point Adam, nopara73, became very interested in studying the works of David Chaum and trying to understand how he described mixing and how other cypherpunks came and improved this methodology. Do you have any sort of preference for cypherpunk literature, or where do you begin if you want to start exploring this whole world of mixing?
2:06:54Lucas OntiveroLook, I think studying history is good, but if you want to start with something, I could start with the current state of the art, right? And then go back to understand better. So I could start with WabiSabi or with ZeroLink, if you want. And once you understand that, right, it's what many, I mean, it's what at least Wasabi and Samourai are running, so it's something that is not old, right? And then I could understand, I think it's necessary to understand JoinMarket. Right? And after that, WabiSabi. And then you can go back or what you want.
2:08:01Vlad CosteaOkay, that's a simple answer. Even though, you know, I've read a few years ago, I got very much obsessed with cypherpunk stuff. So I have read Cyphernomicon, which is a cypherpunk FAQ published by Tim May. And there seemed to be a lot of discussions back in the early 90s, mid 90s, about all of these ways to basically gain privacy on a network that is becoming increasingly popular and is also public. So there were a lot of talks, even by people who are superstars right now in the field, like Nick Szabo and...
2:08:45There was something by David Chaum. There was something by Hal Finney. So if you're into reading history, you can start with that. If you want to look at the state of the art, do what Lucas says and look at the history. Lucas, I'm very happy that we did this interview. And in spite of the technical difficulties, we were able to have this conversation, which I think is really useful to anyone listening. How can people follow you and your work?
2:09:14Lucas OntiveroOkay, honestly, I don't participate in discussions in Twitter, or I have no Facebook, I have nothing. So if someone wants to follow my work, the best way is to subscribe to the Wasabi Wallet GitHub repository and to contact me on Twitter. I'm at lontivero, L-O-N-T-I-V-E-R-O. And that's it. But I try to be as low profile as possible.
2:09:57Vlad CosteaYeah, like a true cypherpunk. So thank you very much, Lucas. And I look forward to hearing from you when Wasabi 2.0 launches.
2:10:07Lucas OntiveroYes, I want that too.
2:10:20Ad voiceoverGold and Bitcoin now, Vaultoro.
2:10:41Vlad CosteaVaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured...
2:11:10Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
2:12:02Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free.
2:13:08Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels. Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.
2:13:08================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video interview in English (guest is a non-native speaker from Argentina, some technical difficulties and host briefly muted), with a music intro and Vlad's pre-recorded sponsor reads for Vaultoro, Wasabi Wallet and Bitcoin Reserve inserted at roughly 00:19, 00:58 and 02:10. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 7 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (179 chunks) and 37 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; second opinion: /workspace/bitcoin-takeover-best-quotes/s10-transcripts/s10e5.txt (read-only). Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed hallucinations (BF-WATCH, YouTube channel, Amara, "Bitcoin strategy", "very important topic", stray Thank you/Amin); split Lucas's greeting and Vlad's "Of course I allow you"; Guest A/Unknown → Lucas Ontivero; restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (version one 0.1, four 0.2 outputs, 0.1 denomination, Vaultoro ad middle, Wasabi ad Tor/block filters, Hillebrand); fixed "an equal"→unequal, WabiSabi, CoinJoin, ZeroLink, Vaultoro, Chaumian, sats; jingle labelled Ad voiceover; Labelled Bitcoin Reserve ad as Vlad and restored "by heading to bitcoinreserve.com"; Guest A → Lucas Ontivero; moved "Oh, you have to pay me" into Vlad's interjection; fixed WabiSabi, zkSNACKs, nopara73, Matthew Haywood, Litecoins, HiddenWallet, CoinJoin/CoinSwap, statechain, Lightning; restored "outputs with" from other engines; removed hallucinations ("Amen", "Thank you.", Amara.org, "Tutu", "I am.", "This is a video that was recorded...", "The following"); split long monologue at 00:26:25; Speaker fixes (Vlad's fungibility monologue, Lucas turns, removed bogus inline label at 00:49:22, 00:52:48 boundary); restored dropped speech from second opinion/ASR (52:09 Lightning/batch, Taproot hype/Lightning channels, Vaultoro gold custody, Wasabi ad tail); fixed JoinMarket, Samourai, KYC, Schnorr, ECDSA, Trezor, Monero, WabiSabi, Vaultoro, Chaumian CoinJoins, Max Hillebrand; removed hallucinations (Amara, "video is a bit long", "Signature of Bitcoin Privacy", "Episode:", "The end... Bye", jingle); Fixed ad attributions (Max Hillebrand, bitcoinreserve.com restored); restored dropped Taproot/UTXO/range-proof text from second ASR; removed hallucinations (Thanks for watching, LibreOffice, "world's largest exchange", "Bitcoin is a very important asset", Amara, subscribe loops, Episode:, Let's get started, Mmm sweet, Noticia, Amen, Bye); fixed Schnorr, ECDSA, Breez, LND, Zcash, Chivo, CoinJoins, Lightning, wars; reattributed 01:07:00 and 01:18:34 turns, Lucas speaker label; Removed hallucinations (sponsor/EU/State Dept/"Wabisabi Podcast"/"Bigger Story of Bitcoin"/Bitcoin Privacy Project lines, "Thank you", "Bye", "Amen", "H&M", "Cheers", subscribe line); restored dropped speech from second opinion/Qwen (uncle, "right person", "freedom... use Bitcoin", "release it when it's done...", "one CoinJoin a week", bounty sentence); fixed speaker errors (01:22 inline Lucas tags were Vlad; 01:34:33 Vlad; 01:35:48–01:36:19 split Lucas/Vlad); fixes: KYC, Bitcoin (VidCon), bankrupt, new bond, Breez, Tor/Orbot, Lightning, zkSNACKs, CoinJoin, WabiSabi, unequal outputs; Removed hallucinations ("Episode:", "Thank you.", "The first thing you need to do is to create a coin", "work of fiction" x2, "Thanks for watching/subscribe", "Bye-bye", "European Union", "I'm not going to go into too much detail"); restored dropped/garbled phrases from second opinion and Qwen ("candidate for participating in a CoinJoin", "depends on your vision", "now Ubuntu users", "select your coins", "And when you spend");