S10 E8: Harry Halpin on Nym, Mixnets, Tor, and Rediscovering Forgotten Cypherpunk Inventions
Search this conversation
0:29Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 10, Episode 8 of the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is Harry Halpin, a man whom I met in Mallorca earlier this year, who is working on Nym, which aims to be like a better version of Tor, which is decentralized, which also has mixnets, which is a different concept as opposed to the usual Tor routing that we all know and use. And, you know, it's very fitting that before I recorded this episode, I've had Yuval in the previous one, in episode seven.
1:23And he mentioned that Nym is one of the projects to which he looks forward. And right now I'm getting actually the CEO of Nym, Harry Halpin. So this is exciting. Hi, Harry.
1:34Harry HalpinOh, great to meet you again, Vlad. I've seen your magazine everywhere. It's spreading like a virus throughout Bitcoin conferences. So congratulations on that. And wow, I'm actually kind of shocked someone like Yuval is watching our project. That makes me really happy. I still feel we're a bit in stealth mode, but slowly but surely we're getting there.
1:57Vlad CosteaWell, first of all, I don't think that it's politically correct anymore to talk about viruses spreading. I'm partially kidding.
2:04Harry HalpinYeah, no, it's true. It's true. I mean, this Omicron nonsense. They're gonna do another wave of lockdowns, which I thoroughly disagree with.
2:14Vlad CosteaI mean, they have to keep inflation in check somehow. But anyway, I'm surprised you know Yuval. But then again, it's kind of a small world.
2:24Harry HalpinYeah, no, I mean, there's only so many of us out there. I mean, in terms of our project, I guess we've been going since really 2018. And it's going well, but we haven't really pushed ourselves to get users right now, mainly because we really want to make sure the damn thing works. And I always tell people, you know, there's a difference between privacy technology and many other technologies, including Bitcoin, which is, you know, let's say Bitcoin, there was like a bug in your Bitcoin wallet and it somehow let someone, you know, seize your private keys or your device gets rooted.
3:09I mean, that's terrible because you lose all your money. And no one wants to lose all their money. But with privacy technologies, we're always getting these people to push us to launch earlier. For example, we have this terrible Ethereum clone copycat project called Hopper. That's, you know, basically, you know, launched what, in my opinion, is basically a somewhat scammy coin. And, you know, everyone's pushing us to launch. I'm like, look, you know, with privacy technologies, you don't want to launch till you're really sure it works.
3:40Because otherwise it's not just money, but as we're kind of aiming for usage by human rights activists and other people like that, people that have, for example, dissenting viewpoints that might be censored, we don't want to launch until we're actually pretty sure that the damn thing works. I think it's really profoundly unethical to launch prematurely. So we have a testnet, but we haven't launched what I would call a usable version of the software yet.
4:17Vlad CosteaRight, so I should start with this. What is Nym and how is it different from Tor?
4:22Harry HalpinYeah, so first, just to be clear, we're not. I mean, I like Tor. I use Tor and Tor Browser every day. In fact, I had to switch browsers for this podcast because I was in Tor Browser and it wasn't working. So Tor is a privacy project and it's based on a technique called onion routing. So, onion routing: most people know what a VPN is. So when I use a VPN, I send packets to a VPN provider. Like I personally, I like VPN sometimes, I use Mullvad, or if you're in China, you use a Shadowsocks provider, or I think ExpressVPN and NordVPN are very popular.
5:02And then the VPN then takes your packets and then ships them out. So to the receiving website or app, it looks like your traffic is coming from the VPN's IP address and not your IP address. Now, there's a big problem with VPNs. And that problem is, which is why honestly people shouldn't use them for privacy or security, maybe only some weak versions of censorship resistance, is that the VPN provider knows exactly who you are and exactly where you're going. So Tor fixes this by something called onion routing.
5:34And it's important to understand onion routing to understand Nym and mixnets. Onion routing basically, rather than send your traffic to a single VPN provider or node, you may want to say, it sends them through three hops, three different nodes. So no single node... only the first node knows where you're coming from. That's the Tor entry node. And the third node, the exit node, knows where you're going. But unless they're colluding, it's very hard to be de-anonymized. So Tor provides provably better anonymity than a VPN.
6:13And it also adds something called onion routing, where at each hop a layer of encryption... you know, I want to send my packet into Tor, I put, you know, I have three hops, I put three layers of encryption on top of it. And at each hop, a layer is peeled off, a bit like peeling an onion. That's where the metaphor of onion routing comes from. However, there's a little bit of a problem with Tor. So the nice thing about Tor is it's actually pretty fast, and the problem is this: that if I am trying to correlate, I want to de-anonymize you.
6:43I can look at the timing and volume information, essentially the metadata of your transaction, even if it's encrypted, the kind of when packets are being sent. And if I watch the first hop in the Tor, and I watch the last hop out, and I can correlate, that's a statistical disclosure attack, I can correlate those packets, I can sort of say, "Wow, it looks like these packets coming in and coming out are the same pattern of packets, and therefore it's probably the same person using Tor." And that's honestly kind of dangerous.
7:18Now it's unclear how common these de-anonymization attacks actually are, but we've seen that recent KAX17 attack, where I think 17% of the Tor routers seem to be controlled by malicious, probably intelligence agency. So it's definitely possible. And there's proof by academics that these attacks are capable of being done on even small budgets. And so what we did with Nym is we take an older technology invented by David Chaum, also famous for DigiCash and Chaumian eCash, as we see with like, I think, the new Fedimint project out of Blockstream.
7:55And what Chaumian mix networks do is they mix the traffic. So rather than the traffic kind of floating through the VPN or the Tor circuit synchronously, it's asynchronous. So I basically take a packet, I put it in my node. I wait for a bunch of other packets from other people. And then I mix those packets up like a deck of cards. I shuffle them. That's where the word mix network comes from. So they're mixing all these different packets together. They're all encrypted. The encryption is re-randomized.
8:30So the encrypted ciphertext isn't linkable. And I send it to the next mix node and he, you know, they wait for more packets. That mix node mixes them again. And then they go to the third one and they're mixed again. And this mixing means that the packets are not released in the same order as they were received. And that breaks the metadata or the traffic patterns. And then we changed Chaumian mixnets in Nym because we do a sort of statistical process where we add fake traffic.
9:03Right. That's pretty cool. So if there's not enough traffic, you have to wait forever for someone else to use Nym. We just add fake traffic into the network and then we release the traffic based on a statistical process called a Poisson process, which basically guarantees, it means that the packets are all mixed together continuously. And that provides better anonymity than a classical Chaumian mixnet. So that's kind of our technology. And the other thing, which is maybe more economically or politically interesting, is Tor is a volunteer-driven project with nonprofit funding and a little bit of government funding. And so basically, like, I run a Tor relay, but to be honest, I don't check to see if it's working very often because why would I? I mean, I don't get any money out of it. I don't get any incentives. I just pay the cost for running the node because I'm a good person. I like Tor. But with Bitcoin mining, you don't run a Bitcoin miner...
10:04You might run a Bitcoin full node because you're a good person. I run a Bitcoin full node. But you run a Bitcoin miner because you want to make money. You solve that hash puzzle, you get those leading zeros, and boom, you've made the coinbase reward. And we copied that model in Nym. We basically measure the quality of service of nodes, and while we do want to use Bitcoin as the payment rails, we kind of have our own internal accounting system for measuring, for making sure that the nodes are up and performing. So the vision is that you can run these nodes a bit like you run Lightning nodes, like a kind of slow, more anonymous version of Lightning, and you can actually make some financial profit for providing privacy to other internet users. So on this level, Nym is a much more... it's not altruistic, it's really kind of an incentivized market-based economy for privacy. We like that.
11:02We think that it hasn't been tried in a long time and we think it's now high time to give it a shot.
11:10Vlad CosteaRight, you have mentioned quite a lot of concepts there, but something which I think is of interest at this point is government funding. And you mentioned that Tor takes money from the US government and it's also based on some research papers that were published by the Department of Defense, if I'm not mistaken.
11:31Harry HalpinWell, technically, yeah, the Naval Research Lab, but close enough. Yeah.
11:36Vlad CosteaOkay. And I can see on the nymtech.net website that you took funding from the European Commission. So the question that arises in this case, if you're a skeptic, if you're someone who's very paranoid, is, does funding this kind of project grant you any kind of backdoor key, or is there any kind of privilege that governments that fund the project can get?
12:01Harry HalpinYeah, so I think that's a super relevant question, and it's one that, you know... So I think to understand our approach to this, it's good to look at the history of this work. So basically, yeah, of course we're against backdoors. Tor is also against backdoors, and there's a valid concern that, you know, a government could try to backdoor the software. And you have that concern not just with Nym and Tor, but also let's look at like secure hardware. Like Intel SGX has like, you know, basically can backdoor SGX secure enclaves because they control that. They essentially have an off switch. But I think the important thing to remember is that, you know, the internet itself came from a lot of government funding. That was DARPA back in the day, well, ARPA, now it's called DARPA. And earlier, before the Bitcoin revolution, there weren't that many options to create anonymous privacy-preserving software.
12:58So there were people... Adam Back himself tried to create a mixnet. It had the great name Freedom, and they were equity-funded, and they were trying to push it off the ground with Zero-Knowledge Systems. And that didn't get enough funding. It didn't get enough users. And so they eventually turned the privacy off, and Zero-Knowledge Systems kind of pivoted and just became kind of a more normal ISP in Canada. And so, you know, when mixnets were envisioned, you know, Tor was working on mixnets and they kind of gave up.
13:33And then the US government, Paul Syverson, actually came by and he said, "Hey, I have a new system for anonymous routing, and we think it's great. And you guys, we'll pay you to work on it." And that's where the initial, I believe, the initial funding for Tor came from, was via Paul Syverson and the Naval Research Lab. And the question is, are they being malicious? And I think with Tor, the answer is not in the way you think they are. So, and not really. So, Tor is all open source code, just like Nym.
14:06If there's a backdoor, you could download it, you could recompile it, you can literally fork it and get rid of any backdoor you think is there. There's no kind of, I don't know how you say, secret proprietary code inside Tor, just as there's no secret proprietary code inside Nym. Now, so I don't think this is as obvious as the government putting a backdoor, but I think the danger is that the threat model of Tor assumes a very weak adversary.
14:34Tor works perfectly well if your adversary is someone like, I don't know, the Iranian government, or even the European Union, someone who's quite weak in terms of surveillance. But it doesn't work very well if you're assuming a powerful adversary that can watch all the inputs and outputs of the network. So that's what, for example, we know from Snowden the NSA can do. So what happened is after the NSA revelations, you know, I knew about Bitcoin. I was actually, hilariously enough, I was living in Boston with early Bitcoiners who were paying Bitcoin and taking Bitcoin rent and all this stuff.
15:14But I didn't take Bitcoin too seriously. It was just kind of a fun, cool, geeky experiment. I didn't take it seriously as a source of funding for projects. And so what happened is that, you know, I decided to quit MIT, Decided to work on Nym, but at that point we didn't have any funding for Nym. It didn't even occur to us that we could get private funding and that we could make a business out of it. And so we said, we went up to the European Commission and we said, "Hey, you know," with my friends Aggelos Kiayias and George Danezis and Claudia Diaz, we said, "Hey, European Commission. You know, the NSA is spying on Angela Merkel. Wouldn't you want a better version of Tor that's made in Europe?"
15:55And the European Commission gave us, I forget, like three to four million in research grants, and that was a project called Panoramix. It produced open source code and a lot of the R&D behind Nym. And essentially most of the people that work on Nym, a lot of us met in essentially a government-sponsored research project. Now, you can say that's terrible, but that's, to be honest, how academics often work and how we meet. And then we even told the European Commission that we were going to spin a for-profit company out of it.
16:25You know, they were okay with that. And we maintain connections with the European Commission. They, for example, fund our, I mean, it's quite interesting, they funded our critique, our privacy critique of COVID passports, and I actually did a security review, which was very negative, of COVID passports for the European Commission. And some governments like the French government say, "Hey, shouldn't we be using a mixnet?" Although, of course, they aren't using it, to kind of like hide sensitive COVID data. And so, you know, we ended the large European Commission grants.
17:02We have a few small ones going on. They're also interested in an anonymous credential system we're building. But the vast majority of our funding is now private. Now, what we said is that, you know, if anyone thinks there's a backdoor, please find it, look in our code. You can compile it yourself. We're working on reproducible builds. But I think the way to look at privacy from a big standpoint is privacy is useful and important for individuals, but it's also important even for companies and nation states.
17:30If I'm a small nation state, let's say I'm Switzerland, and the Swiss, you know, really have been very supportive towards us, you know, I can get bullied and colonized by larger nation states that, you know, I either have to choose to buy my surveillance technology from the US or Russia, maybe China, and that smaller nation states are actually victims of surveillance too.
17:43So we're building our software essentially so that the smaller nation states can also use it to defend themselves against larger nation states. But we also want the exact same level of privacy and the exact same strong guarantees to be usable by end users, because ultimately we want everyone, including, you know, for lack of a better word, self-sovereign individuals, to have access to high cryptographically backed privacy. And that makes us, to be honest, a bit, you know, what we're doing politically is we're essentially trying to play Europe and Switzerland off against the larger nation states like the US, Russia, and China.
18:33And we hope it works, you know. But we don't, you know, we don't have any, of course, secret deals. All of our funding is public. And yeah, you know, it's not surprising that R&D funding funded Tor and Nym. I think the difference is that we at Nym are trying to get off of government funding as much as possible.
19:01Vlad CosteaYou know, this is actually interesting to figure out how you decided at some point down the line that you should leverage geopolitics and you should go to that... It's not a federation, it's not a confederation, it's the European Union. It's like a very strange hybrid. But you went to them and they are trying to become a world power just like the United States. They wanted at some point to become the United States of Europe, and they want to have this kind of technology. So, of course, they funded it for the sake of building something that can be of help for them.
19:40But at the same time, I'm not trying to be condescending here, but I've asked you the question, "Are there going to be any backdoors for the European Commission?" And your first reply, the first word that you mentioned was "yeah." Because you said "yeah" in regards to the whole question, but it was as if you confirmed it.
19:59Harry HalpinOh, no, no, there's no backdoors, and we don't put backdoors in it. And like I said quite clearly, you can just basically look at the open source code if you believe there's a backdoor. And if you don't trust us, you can just run it yourself. I mean, you know, you could set up, you could take all of our code, and a few Bitcoin coders have done this and made their own instances of it. That's fine.
20:20Vlad CosteaI hope nobody's going to take that out of context and just cut five seconds of audio and, you know, say, "Oh, gotcha."
20:27Harry HalpinOh, yeah. You never know. I mean, people do all sorts of crazy things. That being said, you know, I do. I mean, I personally think the European Union as a centralized institution is doomed.
20:40You know, I do have a little bit more respect for the European Union than the United States, insofar as that I think the European Union has not been as aggressive militarily in terms of, like, essentially, you know, blowing up whole countries like Iraq or, you know... But that being said, you know, the European Union, I think, should decentralize. And I'm a big fan of the Swiss model. I would like to see things further decentralized. I would really like to see directly democratic, decentralized governance based on cryptography.
21:08So in the long term, and I said this to Tor about the US government funding, you know, all these alliances are temporary. You know, of course, Tor takes money from the US government, but as I've told Tor, you know, it's not going to last forever. At some point, if they think you're an enemy, they're going to cut the funding off. And Trump cut, you know, I think one third of Tor's funding. Likewise, I, you know, at some point, I would not be surprised at all if there's a huge conflict between us and the European Union.
21:40I'm sure, you know, various police forces, particularly the German police force and the French police force, are very conservative. And they may say, "Oh, well, your network can be used by bad people." So they're going to, you know, try to ban it.
21:54I almost guarantee that's going to happen. And when that happens, we're going to have to fight hard. And, you know, we already are making preparations to leave Europe if we have to. If things came, push comes to shove, we don't want to be dependent in any way on any particular jurisdiction. I'd recommend that approach to any Bitcoiner or anyone in general: never have all your bank accounts in one jurisdiction, never have all of your money in one place. You've got to really make sure that you can survive any possible attack. And, you know, you have to remember, it's important. Actually, today, the UK just announced that Britain was going to extradite Julian Assange to the USA.
22:38You have to remember what happened to WikiLeaks. WikiLeaks was regarded as a promoter of human rights. It got awards from Amnesty International. People really liked WikiLeaks. But as soon as some leaks touched the US government, the Iraq War, Cablegate, then, you know, all of a sudden, WikiLeaks was regarded as a foreign intelligence agency, and Julian Assange was in prison, now extradited to face death, likely at least life imprisonment if not assassination, in the United States. So, governments can change their mind about technology, you know, at the drop of a dime, as soon as it becomes convenient for them.
23:17So that's why it's important that individuals really think this through and, you know, never consider any kind of government to be a permanent ally of either Bitcoin or privacy, and basically develop a very sophisticated multi-jurisdictional game.
23:34Vlad CosteaRight. And one of the reasons why I think that the US government supported Tor, even if it enabled criminals to, you know, undergo their operations, is that their greater agenda is to spread their model of democracy across the world. And for this, they need to enable freedom fighters, they need to enable journalists to be able to communicate, to exchange intelligence and all sorts of data and information. So I think that in the grand scheme of things, this is much more important to the US government, as opposed to catching the local drug dealer.
24:12Harry HalpinYeah, or Silk Road. I mean, obviously that's been in the news a lot recently with the, what's it called, Free Ross DAO. In fact, I just suggested this morning, even though I'm no fan of Ethereum, that I would love to see a Free Assange DAO. Now, let's think about this. I think you're totally right. I mean, that's the thing about Tor, is that the internet is the greatest form of soft power the United States government has ever seen. And even though Hillary Clinton was trying to put, you know, Assange in jail, at the same point, you know, they were more than happy to fund, and I supported this funding at the time because it was the only funding game in town, to support the creation of software tools for privacy and to prevent censorship.
24:59Now, the problem is that, you know, now with the advent of Bitcoin, you no longer need government funding. So this is, I think people who are Bitcoiners don't understand how big of a change that is, particularly for academics, particularly for researchers, for software development. And now, you know, you no longer have to depend on Silicon Valley and government funding. You can actually become completely autonomous in terms of funding. I think that's one of the most exciting developments. That's a real game changer.
25:25And that being said, you know, governments, you know, if you read Snowden's autobiography, Snowden says, you know, how did the CIA work before Tor? Well, you know, whenever they wanted to use the internet, they'd have to use essentially a kind of VPN that they'd have to destroy and disable because, you know, no one wants to...
25:44They didn't want to reveal that some traffic was coming from one of their IP addresses. And with Tor, they could basically use the internet much more freely. And, you know, CIA agents in China, for example, could use, ideally, I don't think it works anymore, could use Tor to kind of dial home. It's same with human rights dissidents in Iran and many other places, you know, and these are all, to some extent, I mean, you know, I don't care about CIA agents in China, but I do support human rights activists in general. And so, you know, I think these are laudable use cases that are very real, and that's why in geopolitics, there's a big soft power that the internet and privacy and censorship resistance give you. But at the same point, I think it's extremely hypocritical of the United States because the United States is not a particularly democratic country.
26:34You know, it overthrows democracies on a regular basis. It has a CIA which assassinates people who they don't like outside of the rule of law. You know, its declarations of war on terror and whatnot are completely absurd.
26:52And you have to remember that the reason why it's hypocritical is because they're more than happy to see freedom of speech abroad as long as it aligns with their interests. But as soon as, you know... Oh, we're happy to see freedom of information if it's, you know, a leak about Putin or Russia or even these Facebook papers. Oh, you know, they'll take that, what's-her-name, Frances Haugen, the Facebook whistleblower, and put her on stage in front of Congress to do a whole dog and pony show about how evil Facebook is. And I agree, Facebook's evil, but at the same point, look at how they treat her.
27:20But as soon as some government secrets are revealed, including ones that honestly didn't lead to any death, such as the WikiLeaks secrets or Snowden's revelation of the NSA, which are essentially, I think, public goods, the government will turn and say, "Actually, we don't want any freedom of speech.
27:40If you publish this information, you should go to jail or be killed," and it's repressed at home. So the United States, it tries to spread democracy abroad, but look at what it does even to protesters or dissidents inside the United States. It basically imprisons them for decades. It's a very dangerous country and on some level, I think, very authoritarian. And a lot of their talk of democracy is a charade. And I think that's also, you know, I'm not going to... It's also true of the European Union, it's true of most countries, but the US has a giant military intelligence apparatus attached, so to some extent it's more dangerous from the US.
28:18Vlad CosteaYes, I think this was a very important distinction to make. And I know a lot of people who would listen to this interview and be like, "Oh, this Harry Halpin is such a Russian asset."
28:29Harry HalpinWell, yeah, I'm no fan of the Russian government either. You know, I do think Russophobia is dangerous. Like all the stuff about Russia brainwashing people to elect Trump is, there's, I think there's no definite proof that that happened. And, you know, if definite proof comes up, I'll change my mind. But, you know, I think Trump got elected because people didn't like, people didn't want to vote for Hillary. It's pretty straightforward. People were worried about foreign wars and Trump ran on an anti-war campaign. I mean, I also think Trump's kind of a moron and dangerous, but at the same point, you know, Trump, to some extent, was proof democracy actually works, that the candidates that aren't kind of guaranteed to win by the establishment can win. That level, like, you know, will Putin invade Ukraine? Probably at some point. Is Putin a dictator? Sure, yeah. You can't claim that the elections in Russia are in any way fair.
29:23You know, Putin has put my Russian, some of my Russian friends in jail. He's, you know, he's not a nice person by any stretch of the imagination. So let's not pretend that he's a great guy and that Russia is, you know, Russia is equally authoritarian, if not more so than the United States. That being said, as an anarchist, you know, we should recognize that all governments are effectively authoritarian. All governments should be resisted. And we want to enable self-organized collective resistance and individual resistance.
29:59And as a technologist and crypto-anarchist, the goal should be to give people tools to have freedom and resist without basically depending on government goodwill or laws even. And I think that's a really important point that, you know, we should be equal opportunity. We should be equally against all governments all the time. And, you know, we do have to make temporary compromises for example, you know, research funding. I did that. But that being said, in the long game, you know, the government will definitely be a source of repression. And we should, you know, resist that and try to respect fundamental rights.
30:54Vlad CosteaCommercial break.
31:13Ad voiceover: Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.
31:14Vaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip, and if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
32:35Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs. After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels.
33:51Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin. Right, now let me get back to Nym and ask you something which concerns the development of the project. Did you get in contact with any of the cypherpunks and ask for advice? Or what did they think, if you asked?
34:43Harry HalpinDepends what you mean about cypherpunks. Sure, like we announced our first version of the software, the white paper on the Cypherpunks mailing list. I mean, Hal Finney's dead. Len Sassaman, who was working on Mixmaster, which was a kind of early mixnet, and many people think he's Nakamoto. Personally, I knew him. I'm a bit suspicious. I mean, we're still friends with his wife. I'm going to see her tomorrow. But, you know, I mean, from the early cypherpunks, who do you mean? I mean, we did get, you know, Adam Back has been broadly supportive and very useful.
35:18We've used Liquid a bunch. I know it's somewhat controversial among Bitcoiners, but it was viewed as better than using Ethereum. And we've, I think the cypherpunk community, if you talk about the more new cypherpunks, like the people around Prague, like Frank Braun and those types, they've all been broadly supportive just because mixnets, even though they come from David Chaum, they were highly supported by the cypherpunks. I think people forget, the history of mixnets is super interesting. The first, you know, originally, you know, the cypherpunks were being attacked a lot by the Church of Scientology. This is like in the 90s.
35:58And they made anonymous email remailers that were attacked, because they'd simply change your PGP keys and strip the headers from your mail. So they started using the first, it was Lance Cottrell and Len Sassaman made Mixmaster, which was the first implementation of a mixnet that was actually used by the cypherpunks to help disguise their email. This was followed up by Mixminion, that was worked on by Roger and Nick from Tor, who are the founders of Tor, with George Danezis, who now works with them, and was one of our original co-founding and the scientific advisors, and also worked with us on Panoramix.
36:39And, you know, to some extent, I think we found that the cypherpunks, you know, when I say mixnet, if someone's like an old cypherpunk, they immediately understand what we're talking about, which is great, 'cause otherwise it's complicated to explain. And so I think they've been the most supportive, to be honest, of most people, just because they understand the technology.
37:04Now, do I think the problem we've had with some cypherpunks, I think some cypherpunks are maybe a little bit distrustful of for-profit business models on top of mixnets, but then, you know, ultimately, we think that's the right choice. That people, in order for the mixnet to work on a long-term basis, it can't be purely volunteer-driven. So I think we've had a little bit of pushback there, but overall support from a lot of the cypherpunks. And I presented, I mean, my first presentation on what became Nym was actually at HCPP in 2017, and we had everyone from Adam Back to Jim Bell from the assassination markets in the audience, and they were all very supportive.
37:56Vlad CosteaI was kind of expecting to name drop David Chaum at some point because he had all of these ideas about mixnets in the 80s or something.
38:03Harry HalpinOh, yeah! Well, David Chaum is not as active these days.
38:08Yeah, David Chaum has his own mixnet. It's called, it's actually quite interesting. It's based on a design called cMix, and the project's called Elixxir. And, you know, David Chaum's mixnet works, it's just, it's not compatible with external blockchains, so it's not clear how you use Bitcoin on top of Elixxir. Well, we're trying to make sure that our software is actually compatible with not just Bitcoin, but things like Signal or the Brave browser or whatever. You know, we want to be very generic. And David Chaum does not, to my knowledge, consider himself a cypherpunk. I think he considers the cypherpunks to be a bit extreme, as he's fundamentally an academic and an entrepreneur and a very, very creative genius-level scientist.
38:48And we at Nym, we owe David Chaum a lot. We did have a funny situation with David because, you know, of course, we discussed Nym with him. And because we changed the fundamental design of mix networking so much from his design that David Chaum said, "Oh, well, you're just a weird statistical thing. You're not really a mixnet." You know, David Chaum, you know, if we're not a Chaumian mixnet, and he thinks that other mixnet designs like continuous stop-and-go mixing, which is what we are, aren't mixnets, then, you know, David can say that, we respect him.
39:22But then at the same point, we use the term mixnet because we do do statistical mixing. We just don't do the standard permutation-based cascade mixing, which is what Chaum does. But Chaum's been, you know, we haven't talked to him in a while. We actively support his work and we wish him the best always. I'm trying to think. But yeah, I think Chaum, personally, at least from my conversations with him, always thought that the cypherpunks were a bit extreme.
39:50That, you know, you didn't want to replace Western civilization with cryptography. And personally, I do believe we should replace Western civilization with cryptography. So I guess he might consider me an extremist as well, but we haven't really discussed that topic in depth.
40:04Vlad CosteaThat would be a fun conversation. If you ever have it, I should host it on this podcast.
40:10Harry HalpinYeah, you should invite Chaum to your podcast. I mean, he is really a genius and I think would be an excellent guest. I'm trying to think of other folks. I mean, unfortunately, you know, Len Sassaman has passed away. Of course, Hal Finney, who has passed away. I mean, there's an interesting note about Nakamoto, which, you know, one of the reasons why Nakamoto is so hard to identify with his emails is we believe he was using a mixing software to send those emails. That would, if you look at the evidence, that makes a little bit of sense, and that's actually quite fascinating.
40:44You know, the cypherpunks were one of the few groups of communities that were actually using mixnets. But the problem with the cypherpunks is the mixnets were so slow back then that you could only really use it for email. And, you know, the whole job of Nym is trying to kind of broaden what mixnets are capable of, so they can be used for Bitcoin, for even things like Signal. I think web browsing will be hard. I think Tor will probably continue to be the fastest thing for web browsing, but we would like to use mixnets for as many different asynchronous message-based applications as possible.
41:22Vlad CosteaSo would you say that if I were to switch from Tor to Nym on my Bitcoin node, it would be slower?
41:30Harry HalpinYeah, probably. Yeah, probably, but only a tiny bit slower. So it just depends what you're trying to do. So, you know, we wouldn't recommend Nym be used for like speedy microtransactions, that's more of a Lightning use case. But if you wanted a slow but private transaction, then I would recommend using Nym. It's really a trade-off. You know, Lightning has very poor privacy properties despite being off-chain because the same sort of attacks you can do on Tor, you can essentially do on Lightning. There's a paper on that by our chief scientist, Ania Piotrowska.
42:02So yeah, it really just depends what you want to do. You know, if you're okay with losing some speed to gain some privacy, then we recommend using a mixnet. If you really need to get every millisecond out of your transaction... I mean, even with Nym, we think we can provide good privacy with only a few seconds delay, maybe 10 seconds, 20 seconds. We're still running stats on this stuff. There's a paper on that I can share with you. It's by, again, Ania Piotrowska. It was published in the Workshop on Privacy in the Electronic Society this year. That being said, you know, we would like to see internet have privacy as a native property used everywhere, but realistically, it will add a little bit of latency. But this is just like Bitcoin mining, right?
42:49Bitcoin mining is not going to be as fast as some alternatives. You know, you have to solve these hash puzzles. That takes time. That takes hash power. But is the result worth it? Does it strengthen the network? Sure. And so, yeah, I'm happy to wait a few minutes for my Bitcoin transaction to go through. And because I want that security that the Bitcoin transaction provides, and I want that autonomy, which the traditional banking system provides, and I don't trust, you know, garbage like Ripple or Western Union or whatever.
43:21And it's the same thing with Nym, right? So, you know, with Nym, you're going to have to, essentially, sort of, you know, you're going to make a decision. You're like, well, am I going to, you know, am I willing to wait a bit longer to get that transaction through? And I think for some of the use cases, Lightning will be a better source. For some use cases, Tor could be better. But for use cases where you really care about privacy against powerful adversaries, you're willing to bite the bullet, take a few more, a little bit more latency for that transaction, then yeah, I think Nym will be the right choice. It's at least a choice that people should have. And if they don't want to use it, that's fine. We'll discover in a few years if anyone bothers to use this thing.
44:03Vlad CosteaRight. So I've actually spoken, I'm not sure if you know John Carvalho, BitcoinErrorLog.
44:08Harry HalpinOh yeah, hey, smart guy.
44:10Vlad CosteaHe's running a company right now that's called Synonym, which is kind of funny. But I've asked him about Nym this summer. I think it was September though, so it was not quite summer. But anyway, I've asked him what he thinks about it and he was like, "Oh, I don't like it because it has mixnets and I don't like it because it has a token." But at the same time, I've mentioned John because right now you mentioned that Lightning has very poor privacy, Which a lot of Bitcoiners disagree, and they're going to be like, "No, Lightning is private." And John has built his business on the Lightning Network. So really, what is wrong with the Lightning Network in your views?
44:50Harry HalpinWell, it depends what you want to do. I mean, I think the Lightning Network also has a token. It has that authentication token, which is similar to our credential system. And whether or not it makes sense to do the bonds in Bitcoin or a native thing, I think is a, I don't know.
45:15I personally feel uncomfortable leaving a Bitcoin hot wallet open. I like Bitcoin as kind of gold. That's how I think about it, as digital gold, and maybe a replacement for payments if things stabilize a bit. But the problem with Lightning is that people are confused. So just because something is off-chain doesn't mean it's private, right? So of course something that's recorded in plain text on-chain is not private, because anyone can just retrieve the chain and look at it. And you know, at least the early cypherpunks, Hal Finney and Len Sassaman, all were worried about the privacy of Bitcoin.
45:59That was their first commentary on it. You can look at their old tweets and old emails. And I think Nakamoto was a genius on many levels, but, because privacy is really hard to understand and it's a very hard property to achieve, didn't really have a good scheme for Bitcoin privacy. And using pseudonymous keys only gets you so far when you're up against mass machine learning like that ran by Chainalysis or Elliptic. So the vision is, hey, if we take things off the chain, then they're private, but that's just not true, right? So how do we know that's not true? Because the NSA, you know, they can make their own quote unquote chain by just recording every transaction that you send through your internet provider.
46:42Your ISP can record without your knowledge every single transaction you do. It doesn't matter if it's a Lightning transaction or a Bitcoin transaction or an HTTPS transaction. All those transactions can and will be recorded. To our knowledge, there's a lot more recording of internet metadata going on. In fact, most European governments even have regulations forcing the ISPs to do it. The US, I think the government probably just does it directly. That's what that giant NSA station in Utah is doing, that and breaking small keys, probably. So I would argue that it's a confusion to think that just because something's off-chain, it's private.
47:24Because any transaction, even if it's not recorded on a blockchain, can still be recorded on a hard drive by someone. And you may not know they're recording it, but that doesn't mean it's not happening. And those are precisely the kinds of attacks that Lightning kind of falls victim to. And the Lightning Network isn't that big. So obviously, if a company like Chainalysis can monitor Bitcoin full nodes effectively, which they do, and they've been running a lot of kind of full nodes to kind of gather those peer-to-peer broadcasts, we can imagine that similar things are pretty easy, if not easier, on Lightning.
48:00So it's fine. I understand why Lightning advocates think Lightning is private, but it's obviously, you know, upon consideration by kind of people who are a bit more expert in the field of surveillance, not private. Now, that being said, Lightning advocates, you know, aren't stupid, particularly Lightning Labs and Blockstream. Lightning Labs and Blockstream have a very good understanding of privacy, and they know how private Lightning is and how private it isn't. And it's definitely also true that Lightning will always probably be faster than a mixnet. But if you look at the design decisions taken by Lightning and Lightning Labs, now I'm not, I mean, I know Tadge and what's the other fellow?
48:41I mean, Joseph Poon, they all seem very nice, but they're not privacy experts, let's put it. But some of the people at Lightning Labs are. So we've had discussions with folks at Lightning Labs. You ever heard they use the Sphinx packet format? That's the packet format invented by the Nym employee George Danezis, which was used by Mixminion. It's a mix network packet. So Lightning uses a mix network packet to get better privacy properties. Folks involved in Lightning have said they're always interested in mixnets. They're interested in kind of making maybe a version of Lightning where you can make it slower to be more private or faster to be faster.
49:17Of course, everyone's focused on speed and micropayments right now. And you know, Blockstream definitely also understands a lot about mixnets. So I think I would definitely say that, you know, your average, I don't know how you say, your average Bitcoiner in the street may be a little bit confused, and that's understandable. But the people that are designing the software around Lightning have a lot of knowledge of privacy, and I think would accurately describe its privacy guarantees: that's better than putting it on chain, but not as good as a mixnet, somewhere in the middle.
49:48And you know, that's fine for some people. If I'm buying, I don't know, like a piña colada on Bitcoin Beach, do I, honestly, really want to hide that from the government or from El Salvador's police force or from the CIA or from a cybercriminal or from the store I'm buying it from? Probably not. Unless I'm hiding the fact that I'm in El Salvador, I'm like John McAfee or something. Fine, I'll just, why not use Lightning and get that micropayment with a minimum fee through and buy that piña colada? So I think, again, it's all about using the appropriate technology for the appropriate use case. And I think, again, sophisticated Bitcoiners understand that.
50:35Vlad CosteaRight, so basically you are using a different point of reference, because in the case of Bitcoiners, their biggest concern is maybe chain analysis or something, but you're referring to a lot more sophisticated surveillance mechanisms, which are held and used by the NSA and by the US government and China and Russia, and you know, these three world powers that are very much interested in recording everything that's going on the internet.
51:06Harry HalpinYeah, I mean, that's your most interesting, but I mean, I think you're shortchanging Chainalysis a bit. I mean, Chainalysis was running a sophisticated, in 2015, kind of Sybil attack on Bitcoin, running a lot of full nodes in order to get those, copy those peer-to-peer broadcasts, or de-anonymize the IP addresses of Bitcoin users. So that's 2015, it's 2021 now. Can Chainalysis do sophisticated attacks on Lightning? Sure, I would be surprised if they can't. You know, is Chainalysis doing increasingly sophisticated attacks on even Monero?
51:41Of course. The problem with mass surveillance is that, and to be honest, it's a bit cyberpunk, as time progresses, the ability to do these attacks gets cheaper and cheaper. You know, cloud storage, AWS, all the computing costs and the storage costs of data go down. And so that, I think, really means that we're going to see what we thought only the NSA could do, like in 2014. In 2021, can Chainalysis do these kinds of attacks? Sure, of course they, I mean, I wouldn't be surprised if they can.
52:16That being said, you know, I also want not to make everyone completely paranoid all the time. I mean, like I said, if I'm buying a piña colada on Bitcoin Beach, which I'd love to do one day, I'm quite sad I missed that LA Bitcoin Conf, but I was teaching Bitcoin in Beirut, of all places, at the same time, I don't really care if anyone knows if I'm buying that piña colada. I highly doubt I'm leaking sensitive information on Bitcoin Beach.
52:43But that being said, people need to kind of be able to assess their own threats and use appropriate technology to defeat those threats. And so there are many, many use cases where Lightning is appropriate, where Bitcoin without any privacy protection may be appropriate. I mean, I'm a privacy advocate, but I think there's a place for transparency, right? There's a place for it. It's nice, like, you know, it's nice that I can look at Bitcoin. I can say, look, there's only 21 million Bitcoin ever printed, and I can prove that there's no secret inflation going on.
53:19And doing that is much harder on some quote unquote privacy blockchain like Zcash or Monero. So I think there's a place for privacy. I'm actually a big fan of sidechain designs like Liquid, where you have a private sidechain to the main Bitcoin chain. That's a great design. I'm a big fan of, you know, I think Lightning is not the magical solution to all Bitcoin problems, but in terms of fast micropayments that don't require much privacy, yeah, it's a great solution. And so, you know, I think it's just more about figuring out what the appropriate pieces of the stack are.
53:51I mean, personally, you know, I'm still waiting for Simplicity. The ability to do somewhat complex smart contracts on Bitcoin would be great, and I'm happy to see Taproot and Schnorr finally push out.
54:08Vlad CosteaOh yeah, there is a lot to look forward to in the case of Bitcoin, and I was about to ask you, well, one of them is like a small request. Could you please stop playing with your pen? Because that gets recorded.
54:17Harry HalpinOkay, sorry, no problem.
54:19Vlad CosteaAnd the second one concerns Drivechains. It's a proposal by Paul Sztorc, and the idea behind it is to merge mine all the shitcoins that we have today. And the argument is that this is the ultimate form of maximalism, where Bitcoin incorporates everything into the most secure network with the hardest form of money. So basically have stuff like Zcash as a drivechain, which provides this trade-off of decentralization in exchange for privacy?
54:54Harry HalpinWell, I mean, I have to admit, I think I heard of Drivechains like, I don't know, five years ago.
55:00Vlad CosteaOh, yeah, it's been a long time.
55:02Harry HalpinMaybe seven years ago. I haven't heard of them since. So this is a new proposal by me. I mean, I don't know. I don't really... I would say I'm pretty neutral on that proposal. I mean, Bitcoin is hard money. That's its use case. It's the best hard money there is. And I, in terms of tokens or cryptocurrency, I hold only Bitcoin, and I probably would hold other stuff if people gave it to me for free, but I'm not going to pay for it.
55:29And in terms of merge mining, I mean, it's tricky, right? I think Rootstock, some Latin American project, already has something like that. I actually quite like Counterparty. I think people, Theo Goodman, our old, who now works for Nym, used to work on Counterparty. I think there's cool stuff you can do on sidechains. I honestly don't know enough about Drivechain to really give a solid answer. I would say that, yeah, merge mining is fine. I mean, why not? That being said, you know, Bitcoin is its own thing.
56:03Bitcoin doesn't need, I mean, to be honest, like even with Nym and mixnets, we don't expect people to use Nym for most Bitcoin transactions. We only expect people to use it for ones they really want to be private on. And, you know, I think Bitcoin doesn't really need all these other tokens or whatever to succeed. And I'm happy for Bitcoin to continue just being its own thing and being the hardest form of hard money imaginable. I do think its value will likely increase based on that alone.
56:34I don't think it needs this other stuff to increase. I do think it would be nice if it was easier to build on top of Bitcoin. That's why I really like Taproot. I really like large multisigs like Schnorr enables. And, you know, if Drivechains do make it easier for people to build on top of Bitcoin, I would generally be supportive. I do think privacy-enhanced sidechains is something I'm very interested in. I would like to see more work on that rather than less. Nym does not really focus too much on the blockchain itself. We have a little kind of directory authority system that we run, which has its little sort of chain-like system.
57:14We were using Liquid for it. Now we're using, what is it, Tendermint, just because we needed to have Rust running on it. We couldn't do that on Liquid, but we still plan to support Liquid for transactions and eventually integrate more fully on top of it.
57:35You know, so I think it would be nice to have better privacy, and it'd be good also to not just look at coins. I mean, I don't know, maybe I'm old-fashioned. I think that privacy and identity is a big issue. I'm really unhappy with some of the blockchain identity proposals I've seen, particularly those based on what's called DIDs, or decentralized identifiers, so they have very poor privacy. I'd really like to see work focused on another David Chaum invention called anonymous credentials. Adam Back had this great software called Credlib back in the day. It's centralized. Nym has a decentralized anonymous credential.
58:08And these are more like, help me build privacy for use cases outside financial use cases, such as identity use cases or e-voting or whatnot. And I'd love to see some of that stuff grounded in Bitcoin, but, you know, do I need my voting system grounded in Bitcoin? I don't know. I mean, maybe not.
58:25I don't want Bitcoin to become so unfocused that it somehow loses its value proposition as hard money, which is, I think, an absolutely wonderful value proposition that we'll need because of all the inflation happening. I just got back from Lebanon and I mean, inflation is terrifying. It wiped out everyone's savings. Rich people were able to nuke their debts and become even more hyper rich, while the vast majority of people that didn't have anything like Bitcoin or accounts overseas, they really got wiped out. And I think people should be aware that hyperinflation is definitely coming, and particularly to the West.
59:04Vlad CosteaYep, it's pretty terrifying what's going on, but at the same time, so you mentioned Counterparty. I've become a fan in recent months. Like, it's really cool what it does. And the fact that you pay a subsidy to Bitcoin security by your fees whenever you transfer or you create a token. I mean, that's pretty cool. It's like the Ethereum design that actually works. It's not scalable, but I don't think it's supposed to be scalable. I think it's supposed to be a market for collectors who are willing to pay that high fee.
59:39Harry HalpinYeah, I'd much rather buy an NFT on Counterparty than Ethereum. I don't personally buy any NFTs.
59:44Vlad CosteaI'm gonna give you one for free on Counterparty.
59:46Harry HalpinOkay, cool. Yeah, I know, like, Theo is a big fan of Counterparty and it's a pretty amazing piece of software. I don't think anyone, you're the first person besides Theo I've heard mention it. I don't know. I honestly think that, you know, there's a lot of good technology that people forgot about, and that I think it'd be good to revisit.
1:00:11So, you know, again, anonymous credentials by Chaum and Stefan Brands is great technology. Everyone just forgot it existed. Now that we have Bitcoin, we should revisit it. Mixnets, what we're working on, was a forgotten technology. Everyone just got really obsessed with Tor, but why not? Now that we have the time and the money, let's revisit mixnets. And, you know, same with things like Counterparty. Like, let's revisit, you know, Bitcoin sidechains. Let's get people excited about things like Liquid. Let's get people working. I mean, everyone is excited about Lightning, which is good. But I think there's a lot of unexplored potential.
1:00:45And I hope that the larger Bitcoin community can support all of this. And we'll see. We'll see. Yeah. I mean, I haven't used, Jesus, I haven't used Counterparty in, I don't know, four years or something. I'll look into see if I can even, I'll restart everything and see if I can receive your NFT. But yeah, no, it's much better, I think, to pay transaction fees to something that gives value to Bitcoin than not. That being said, I don't think everything has to be built on top of Bitcoin. I mean, I don't really want my web browser built on top of Bitcoin. That's a bit crazy.
1:01:21Vlad CosteaYeah, I've actually ran an experiment and so far it proved to be kind of successful. So I created a Counterparty dispenser with a magazine NFT and basically you buy the NFT and you get the magazine delivered to your door. So that's kind of the idea behind it. I don't set up an e-shop or something. It's just something decentralized that's out there. It's with Bitcoin. It's kind of cool. I think 10 or 11 people got one so far.
1:01:52Harry HalpinWell, cool. Let's start a Counterparty revival. And maybe for your next guest, if you're doing Counterparty stuff, why don't you interview Theo? Theo Goodman was... Oh, you already did. Okay, great. I missed that one. I mean, that Rare Pepe stuff. I mean, he really deserves a lot of credit there. You know, I think, I mean, I don't honestly know too much about art. And I know even less about NFT art than I know about regular art, but, I don't know, things you see in museums. But whatever, you know, all I know is that all my friends who are artists, they're always broke.
1:02:25They're always starving and anything we can do to help them out is great. I'm a huge supporter, even though I think it is controversially on Ethereum, I'm a huge supporter of things like the Free Ross DAO. Fundraising for Tor, they did an NFT fundraise. Snowden did an NFT fundraise. I don't really care if someone who's already, I don't know, rich does a fundraise with NFTs. But, you know, there's a lot of people in the world who need money for good causes. And there's a lot of artists who are actually pretty good, but they don't have, I don't know, the connections to the corrupt gallery-driven art world.
1:03:05So why not? Let's get these people money. You know, the thing about Bitcoiners is this is the largest non-state-driven capital accumulation, I think, at least I can ever think of. This is a really revolutionary moment in human history. Let's use all this money not just, I don't know how you say, not just for holding it forever, because that's very, you know, I mean, at some point you're going to die. You know, I mean, your kids should probably get some Bitcoin too. And I actually really like these projects that look at how do you manage your Bitcoin after your death. That's an amazing topic, a little bit morbid, but amazing.
1:03:41But that being said, you know, let's help out all the people like Ross Ulbricht, Julian Assange, Snowden. You know, we've been helping Chelsea Manning, that have been, like, basically struggling for freedom, often with very limited finances, for a very long time. And, you know, I think NFTs might be some way to do that. So I'm a pretty open-minded guy when push comes to shove.
1:04:04Vlad CosteaYeah, so I'm not, of course, you're not aware of this. And of course, you haven't heard of the Theo Goodman episode, because right now I'm recording 10 episodes in a row as a season, and I'm going to publish them all at the same time, just like Netflix on Christmas Day.
1:04:18Harry HalpinOh, wow.
1:04:19Vlad CosteaAnd so far this season, it has been quite interesting because I've had Eric Martindale in the first episode. And he spoke about building DeFi on top of Lightning Network with atomic swaps.
1:04:31Harry HalpinWell, that's a great idea.
1:04:34Vlad CosteaI thought that was really cool. Like, yeah, that should be done because it's scalable, it's fast. It makes sense. And it's being built by someone who's actually, you know, worked for Blockstream and has actual experience, as opposed to all the web developers who build DeFi apps and then they say, "Oh no, we got rug pulled." But I saw a story, I think it was yesterday, that two quote unquote DeFi developers on Ethereum, they exchanged their private keys on Facebook in messages.
1:05:06Harry HalpinOh geez, that's terrifying.
1:05:08Vlad CosteaAnd then they were surprised that they got hacked.
1:05:12Harry HalpinYeah, you know, one of our ex-employees, sorry, one of our current employees is an ex-Facebook employee, Dave Hrycyszyn, our CTO, and he basically said, and it's public, he said in Wired that, you know, the first thing you do when you work at Facebook is you get access to everyone's instant messages. That's quite terrifying. So, you know, your instant messages on Facebook are not private at all. Like the Facebook...
1:05:35Vlad CosteaAren't they end-to-end encrypted these days?
1:05:37Harry HalpinNo, they're not. There's some vague plan to get them end-to-end encrypted, but they're currently not encrypted. And WhatsApp does claim to be end-to-end encrypted, but I've witnessed with my own eyes the fact I believe it is backdoored. I was actually, weirdly enough, visiting Amir in Syria and there was concerns from the Kurds there fighting ISIS that WhatsApp had a backdoor, because they would give the WhatsApp numbers of ISIS members to the US military, who would then proceed to find all their contacts and read all their messages. So I don't think, I think WhatsApp is end-to-end encrypted, but it's probably backdoored.
1:06:16I don't think Signal's backdoored. Moxie is a trustworthy guy. Although I have to say I have mixed feelings at best on MobileCoin. But yeah, like, you know, you shouldn't trust any of these messaging apps except maybe Signal. And I do personally trust Signal. I don't really trust anything else.
1:06:36Vlad CosteaWhat's your take on Telegram because it's so popular?
1:06:39Harry HalpinWell, the thing that Telegram does is it allows you to have big groups. And it's hard. And Telegram's not encrypted. And it had this crazy encryption scheme called MTProto, which actually an old research lab I used to work at broke.
1:06:54And then they refused to pay the bounty. Eventually they did. It took them a while. I think Telegram is mainly popular because it has large groups. And Signal, because of end-to-end encryption, they don't support large groups. And WhatsApp also doesn't support large groups. I would like to see in the future something like Telegram that supports end-to-end encryption over large groups. And there's actually a standard coming out of the Internet Engineering Task Force called Messaging Layer Security, which I think would allow large end-to-end encrypted groups, but then someone actually has to build a product and encrypt it.
1:07:36But we'll leave that to the next startup. I'm too busy with mixnets, but it'd be great if someone did that. There's a real good... To build a competitor which is end-to-end encrypted, maybe Signal will evolve into this, or maybe there'll be a new messenger. Would be great. I really support that. But yeah, Telegram, like, the main advantage Telegram gives you is that you're not going to be instantly backdoored by a government, because I do think that Pavel Durov kind of resists government interference in Telegram. But you're basically relying on the goodwill of Telegram, the company, not encryption, for the privacy of your messages on Telegram.
1:08:15Vlad CosteaRight, so before this I mentioned that I had Eric Martindale on the first episode, and then I had a series of interviews with people who worked on Counterparty NFTs, Rare Pepes, Spells of Genesis. And I think there is another one and I'm missing, I'm not remembering exactly what it's called, but it's really fascinating just to know that these NFTs mostly originate from the fact that in 2016, 2017, even 2015, there was heavy censorship on Reddit, and they were creating memes and they were getting banned from Reddit. So they would just use Bitcoin and Counterparty to put their memes out there as a way of showing to the world, you know, "We are Bitcoiners, we can do this in a permissionless way. We can host our own memes and send them to people we like," and stuff like that. And it just so happened that they started receiving market valuations.
1:09:20Harry HalpinYeah, I mean, that's crazy. Again, I find it almost hard to believe this NFT stuff, but I am a big... You know, again, mixnets were created and used and implemented by Lance Cottrell and Len Sassaman to prevent the censorship by the Church of Scientology over, you know, Usenet and stuff back in the day. Their quote-unquote secret teachings were released on the internet. And so, you know, anti-censorship is something that's like really close to my heart. To be very frank, I'm a pretty left-wing guy, but I think the left is now trying to censor people, and that's a huge mistake.
1:09:58And censorship always leads to authoritarianism. And even soft censorship, like the censorship you're seeing now, which isn't like, you know, Stasi levels, but is bad. You're seeing it on Facebook and Twitter and I guess you're seeing it on Reddit, you know, that is ultimately destructive to human freedom and autonomy and must be resisted at all costs. Nym is still working. I mean, we are decentralized on some level. We're not so easily censorable, but we're working now with coders looking at technologies for obfuscation. So can we make, for example, the first hop into Nym look like, oh, you're just visiting Gmail or something innocent like that that has no privacy ramifications?
1:10:43And so, yeah, I think, you know, anti-censorship is a great use case. The peer-to-peer broadcast of Bitcoin, even though it's a bit, I would say, a little bit cutting edge 1990s technology, is good. And there's something to be said for just any kind of technology that resists censorship. But the one thing that has to be remembered, which is often forgotten in censorship discussions, is that there's a difference between censorship resistance, decentralization and privacy. These are actually three distinct technical properties. So I can be private.
1:11:15I can deliver you something anonymously, but use a centralized mixnet. That was what the early Mixmaster software did. I can be decentralized and not private, right? So Bitcoin is decentralized and not private, right? So, you know, my transactions are recorded publicly on a blockchain, but this blockchain is decentralized, it's not a single trusted third party, like a bank or whatever, running it. And censorship resistance is a very confusing term. So decentralization helps with censorship resistance, because obviously if you can take out a third party, take out a centralized trusted party, then you're easily censored.
1:11:49But you know, a lot of censorship now deals with AI reading your text and deleting things and so on. On one level, the permanent archives that the blockchain provides, like the Len Sassaman memorial in the Bitcoin blockchain, this ability to permanently archive stuff and get it spread is a really good technique for censorship resistance. But there's a whole other group of techniques for censorship resistance that, you know, hide, make traffic look like something else, and that's obfuscation technologies, which are also worth looking into. I think they are a little bit underexplored right now.
1:12:25I have to, I'm always surprised that China hasn't censored Bitcoin. I mean, it's shutting miners down, but you can still do Bitcoin transactions from inside China while, you know, so their deep packet inspection powers aren't going after Bitcoin per se, but they're going after Tor. That's kind of an interesting and a somewhat confusing thing for myself.
1:12:48Vlad CosteaYeah. Anyway, I think I ran out of questions for now about Nym, except for one: ICO.
1:12:56Harry HalpinOh, Jesus. Yeah. I mean, we're not going to do a traditional token launch. So we are going to do, you know, we do our system, I mean, it does controversially have a token, but, you know, the token is used as our kind of reputation system inside Nym. It's not supposed to be used outside the network and it's not supposed to be used, we definitely don't want to compete or even claim to be competing with Bitcoin. I'm really against these ICOs that want to build a more hard, a better hard money.
1:13:32I think Bitcoin is the best hard money. So what we want is more of an internal system that maintains the reputation of mix nodes. We will, of course, because we're not scammers, have a fully registered prospectus-driven offering. And I think that's the right thing to do. We're seeing similar offerings with things like the Volcano Bonds out of El Salvador. And yeah, that's, I think, the right approach. I mean, I think in terms of initial coin offerings, again, I'm impressed with how much money they raised. I'm sad most of it has been wasted on total scams.
1:14:09Reading about things like, what was it called, OneCoin, it's quite tragic, just people ripping off people in developing countries. This should be avoided at all costs. And I think the way you avoid that, this is where actually I agree with Gary Gensler. I disagree with Gary Gensler on many things, but I agree with him on one thing, which is that it's important whenever you buy something to not have information asymmetry. So what is information asymmetry? That means that the seller knows something you don't know. So the seller, you know, may have, for example, a bunch of tokens that he's going to dump, and you, the buyer, don't know that.
1:14:43Or, for example, you know, the seller may, you know, a lot of these, like, crazy ICOs, you didn't even know what country or who is behind it. That's why you have these rug pulls, like, I don't know, SushiSwap or whatever. This is all very dangerous. And we, even though I am an anarchist, I don't support, you know, scams basically. So we should, or the right to scam people or something ridiculous like that.
1:15:10I think it's important for Nym to be as white gloves and as transparent as possible. And it's one of the few cases where I'm like, yeah, actually, we should obey all government regulations in terms of anything like a public offering. So will we do one? Yeah, sure. We're probably going to have to. You want to get the system working. Will we be transparent and have a prospectus and all that good stuff? Sure.
1:15:35Yeah, 'cause we're not, you know, we want people, you know, we're not gonna push, and we don't want, to be honest, I don't want people to invest in Nym in a speculative way at all. That just damages the system. Our goal is, you know, for privacy to be number one, right? We want people to have high privacy. We want to have the system be properly tokenized so that we provide high quality of service on privacy and high privacy for the users. But what we don't want is exactly what people tend to do, particularly with ICOs, but they also do this with stocks and other things.
1:16:16And some people even do this with Bitcoin. You can tell people do this with Bitcoin because they flip it. They don't hold it. We don't want people to invest in something with the wanting short-term returns and to flip things. We want people to basically care about privacy and to say, you know, "I want to use this system. I want to access this system. I want to run a node."
1:16:38Just as, you know, people who just want to, like, I don't know, who get really excited about Bitcoin ETFs and whatnot. I don't honestly get excited by that stuff. I think further speculative activity on Bitcoin is actually dangerous for the value proposition. And I think that's the same with Nym. We don't want a bunch of speculative activity on top of privacy. That actually can be dangerous. And that's something that maybe we're wrong.
1:16:43One of the reasons why Tor... So the people who worked on Tor originally were working on reputation systems, reputation tokens for mixnets. So the concept behind Nym predates Bitcoin by, I think, the early mixnets for permanent, censorship-resistant file storage, like Ross Anderson's Eternity Service in 1996.
1:17:26The works of Roger and Nick on reputation systems for mix nodes was, I think, in like '98, '99. So these are very old problems. Adam Back used to work on this problem. And, you know, we want to see this problem solved. We want to see reputation systems for privacy. Now, people that worked on it, I think Adam still believes it's a solvable problem, but folks like Roger and Nick, they don't think it's a solvable problem. So the reason why Tor doesn't have a reputation system inside Tor is because they don't think it could work. And, you know, it's very possible they're right. You know, the Tor guys are pretty smart. I'm not gonna hold it against them.
1:18:05And so, you know, we don't want people to in any way think that there is some sort of financial return at the end of the tunnel. You know, the whole thing could just easily fall apart. That's why we really want to be transparent with people. But that being said, there's a chance it could succeed. And I'm willing to take that chance. And we would like to see it work. But maybe there's some technical issues or economic issues that just somehow make it impossible to, you know, maybe privacy is a type of good that you can't put in a market. Then maybe. It's possible. I hope it works, but nothing in life is guaranteed.
1:18:51Vlad CosteaCommercial break. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.
1:19:12Vaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack. So since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
1:20:33Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs.
1:21:02After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels.
1:21:48Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin. I appreciate the honesty. And has anyone ever told you that your high register... Sorry. So has anyone ever told you that your high register sounds a lot like Chris DeRose's?
1:22:37Harry HalpinNo, no, I don't. I didn't, I don't know that. I'll tell you something funny. We can end on this. So you're from Romania, correct?
1:22:46Vlad CosteaYes.
1:22:47Harry HalpinSo I think, if I remember correctly, Romania had the most advanced information-centric intelligence agencies in the Soviet Union. So...
1:23:01Vlad CosteaYes, we did.
1:23:03Harry HalpinExactly. Most people forget this, but the Romanians, and I actually have friends who are Romanian that collect these books, these kind of digital surveillance books from the Romanian intelligence agencies.
1:23:15You read this stuff, you're like, man, these guys, they would have created the Soviet version of the NSA first, had they just had a little bit more money and the Soviet Union had kept going. So I think I would love that at some point, if you know anyone in Romania who knows about this history, even though it's nothing to do directly with Bitcoin, I do think that people forget that every government, be it socialist or capitalist or whatever, has a tendency to develop an authoritarian surveillance system. Historically, the Romanians were kind of, I don't know how you say it, more advanced than the Americans, I think, in the early days.
1:23:54So I would love to hear more about that. That's one of the most fascinating bits of computing history that I think is not well known. And I think it's not well known because the documentation is all in Romanian. There's not enough people who know Romanian working on surveillance.
1:24:09Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know much about computer surveillance, but I know that this whole intelligence system relied on well-meaning citizens and a lot of Karen-ing. So Americans right now have developed a very strong Karen culture where they complain and they turn on their neighbors. They call the police on them because they had an extra guest at the Thanksgiving dinner or something.
1:24:34Harry HalpinOh, yeah. I got arrested at a party in France. We were against COVID rules. And the police came in with dogs and whatnot. It was completely crazy.
1:24:46Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. And there's this whole culture about reporting your neighbors and trying to keep them in check according to whatever the government tells you. And this is how you get authoritarian. Because you get rid of any kind of local values, and you no longer care about the person next to you only care about the central values, the ones that are top down. And once you play that game, you're going to end up in a system where someone else is going to turn on you because obviously you can't be a perfect citizen and you can't be everyone's friend.
1:25:19And the more of this you do, you know, the more likely you are to get exposed and become a target at some point. But, you know, right now I'm looking at the American experiment because it has been an experiment with democracy since 1787 and I see it falling apart specifically because you got rid of some of your fundamental values and you're trying to replace them. And it can work, but then again, you know, it's kind of radical. It happened over the last maybe two or three decades. So...
1:25:55Harry HalpinYeah, I mean, I focus on digital surveillance because I'm a computer scientist. That's the sort of thing I understand. But I think the real danger of surveillance exactly is this culture of snitching, this culture of turning your neighbor in, this culture of virtue signaling, which destroys the local bonds of friendship. And people should, I mean, look, everyone's going to make mistakes. You know, Nym may just be a giant mistake. I'm sure a lot of, you know, Bitcoin maximalists will be, you know, don't like Counterparty, they won't like Nym, and I, you know, I'm okay with that.
1:26:26People are entitled to their own opinion, and I think people arguing and having polemics is part of a healthy society. But what's not healthy is this ability, this desire to basically attack people based on their beliefs in a way where you want the other person to be canceled or imprisoned or fined. Censorship, I think, generally never ends well. You can say, "Well, we're just doing, you know, we're trying to do it for the greater good." And that may sound plausible, but the long arc of all of this, of censorship and snitching and turning your neighbor in, is a form of social surveillance, which is more dangerous than digital surveillance, which will lead to authoritarianism.
1:27:25And authoritarianism combined with digital surveillance is an incredibly dangerous force. It is the most dangerous, I think, threat to freedom.
1:27:38And people have fought for thousands of years for freedom. Our ancestors have died fighting for freedom. We should not in any way forget that. And we could lose it overnight. And I'm seeing, particularly with COVID and, I don't know, COVID and cancel culture and all of this insanity, we're seeing a return of a kind of soft authoritarianism. And what worries me just as much as digital surveillance is the fact that people believe that snitching and canceling and censorship is somehow okay and justified. And I think we should resist that at all forms. That being said, it's a harder problem than what we at Nym are doing, so I'll leave that to other people to work on that.
1:28:27Vlad CosteaRight, so Harry, I know that you said you had only one hour.
1:28:31Harry HalpinYeah, we went a bit over time.
1:28:33Vlad CosteaThat's fine, it was an enjoyable discussion.
1:28:36Harry HalpinLikewise.
1:28:37Vlad CosteaI'm always happy to, you know, end interviews when I run out of questions. But my last question to you is, how can people follow the Nym Project and yourself?
1:28:48Harry HalpinI mean, you know, we're on Twitter at Harry Halpin, at Nym Project. The website is nymtech.net, although we recently bought nym.com. If you can't remember that, it's N-Y-M dot C-O-M. And so we're pretty easy to find. Our code's on GitHub. We'd love people to try to use it, write bugs. We have a testnet, which you're more than welcome to join, play around with it. If people are interested in Bitcoin, we're trying to get a Liquid-enabled Bitcoin wallet working over Nym. That's something folks are working on now. And yeah, there's just lots of work to do. And we're always hiring, so if you're a good...
1:29:33Our whole codebase is built in Rust. If you're a good Rust coder, that's something we're particularly interested in. And yeah, we look forward to getting more people involved. We do hope that... You know, it's been very intensive for the current team, so spreading out this help, this technology would be great. And we are very enthusiastic to actually get it to market as soon as possible. I'm not going to give you a date on when we're going to actually launch it because we don't know ourselves and we have to wait for various things like government prospectuses approved and so on and so forth.
1:30:11So, yeah, it's been great. And I really appreciate your magazine. I'm a proud owner of one of the originals from Mallorca.
1:30:17Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. And you have one copy from, I think, the first 50 of the first.
1:30:23Harry HalpinExactly. Yeah. I'm not going to sell it on eBay or some weird NFT site. But yeah, keep up. I look forward to the second magazine and hope to see you at some Bitcoin event later unless they lock us all down again, which I believe is probably coming.
1:30:37Vlad CosteaI'll probably come next year to Mallorca, and it's likely that I'll go to some conference in France, which is somewhere on the West Coast.
1:30:48Harry HalpinOh, yeah, the Biarritz conference. Yeah, I didn't go to that, but I'm interested.
1:30:53Vlad CosteaYeah, they invited me next year, so I think that would be interesting. But, you know, it's also uncertain. I thought we would never have green passes here in Romania, and that was still applicable in August and September. And then in two weeks, everything just switched.
1:31:09Harry HalpinOh, yeah, yeah.
1:31:10Vlad CosteaWe had to adapt.
1:31:11Harry HalpinI'm completely against these green passes. People underestimate the surveillance and privacy threats of these green passes. I know you're skeptical of the European Commission, but I wrote a whole report to the European Commission outlining, before they were launched, the privacy dangers of the green passes. We've been trying to look for some kind of alternatives based on anonymous credentials. None of that's, of course, been adopted because it's not ultimately in government's best interest for their citizens to have privacy. And these green passes are definitely a step in the wrong direction for society. And they always say it's temporary, but passports were originally temporary.
1:31:52And I'm sure this digital infrastructure, once they built it, they're going to keep reusing it for more and more surveillance. And I hope people can resist these sort of oppressive mandatory measures as long as possible.
1:32:09Vlad CosteaYes, and I hope that Nym is going to help us resist.
1:32:12Harry HalpinWe'll try.
1:32:13Vlad CosteaTake care.
1:32:15Harry HalpinSee you around.
1:32:25Vlad CosteaCommercial break. Gold and Bitcoin on Vaultoro.
1:32:47Vaultoro is the exchange where you deal with honest and hard money. There is no fiat on-ramp or off-ramp and you get to diversify your Bitcoin portfolio into gold or silver when you sense that a bearish moment is coming. Also, you can instantly trade your gold for Bitcoin to buy the dip. And if you're into gold custody, Vaultoro can also send you the gold that you own directly from their insured Swiss vaulting facilities. Vaultoro was launched in the aftermath of the Mt. Gox hack, so since 2015, they have published monthly glass books to prove that they own all the gold reserves and all of their customers' money. Sign up today by going to vaultoro.com/bitcointakeover. Keep in mind that this is not financial advice and you are responsible for your own decisions.
1:34:08Wasabi Wallet is the perfect Bitcoin privacy wallet. It's free, it's open source, it's available on Windows, macOS and Linux, and it offers groundbreaking Chaumian CoinJoins, which mix your Bitcoin. Even if you do not use the CoinJoin feature, you still benefit from a trustless experience with block filters, a hidden IP address via Tor, and easy management of your wallet outputs.
1:34:36After you deal with KYC exchanges like Coinbase, like Kraken, Binance, Gemini, or Bitfinex, you can remove the association between your identity and your Bitcoin address by performing a few rounds of CoinJoins. To find out more about the privacy benefits and limitations of CoinJoins, listen to Bitcoin Takeover Podcast Season 6 Episode 6 with Max Hillebrand. And if you want to give Wasabi a try, go to wasabiwallet.io and download the wallet for free. Wasabi Wallet, a Bitcoin privacy wallet for the citadels.
1:35:23Bitcoin Reserve is Europe's destination for buying Bitcoin simply online. It's the first Bitcoin-only venue in Europe that allows serious beginners as well as professionals to make daily purchases larger than 1,000 euro per day from bank account or via credit card. Learn more about Bitcoin Reserve by heading to bitcoinreserve.com. Bitcoin Reserve, where Europe buys Bitcoin.
1:35:23================================================================================ Production notes: Remote two-person interview in English (recorded in late 2021 as part of a 10-episode batch), with a music intro and three identical pre-recorded sponsor blocks (Vaultoro, Wasabi Wallet, Bitcoin Reserve) read by Vlad, at mid-show, after the ICO discussion and after the outro. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (130 chunks) and 51 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; second opinion: /workspace/bitcoin-takeover-best-quotes/s10-transcripts/s10e8.txt (read-only); [unclear] resolve pass: 1 of 1 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "♪ © BF-WATCH TV 2021", "The following is a question from a viewer.", "Welcome to the Nym Podcast."; restored dropped speech (Vlad 01:23 "looks forward... CEO of Nym", question end + Harry answer start at 00:12:01, Syverson quote 00:13:33–00:13:59, coinbase/model gap 00:10:19, "and it also adds" 00:06:13, "MIT" sentence) from second ASR/re-check; moved "Yeah, no," to Harry; fixed Nym, Omicron, Mullvad, KAX17, David Chaum, DigiCash, Chaumian eCash, Fedimint, mix networks, VPN, Poisson, Snowden, Paul Syverson, Zero-Knowledge Systems, testnet, nymtech.net, coinbase; Speaker fixes: Guest A → Harry Halpin; split Vlad/Harry at 00:19:56 using second ASR ("yeah" question). Names: Aggelos Kiayias, George Danezis, Panoramix, Frances Haugen, Free Ross DAO/Free Assange DAO, Tor. Removed "Subtitles by the Amara.org community" hallucination. Restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (US/Russia/China surveillance line, "more respect for the EU", "not going to last", "survive any possible attack", "Julian Assange", "Silk Road... with the", "dissidents in Iran and", "look at how they treat her"). Fixed "Internet of Privacy" → internet and privacy, "war and terror" → war on terror; "democracy at home" → abroad as context requires; Labels Guest A→Harry Halpin; restored dropped speech from second ASR (Hillary lead-in, Vaultoro ad middle, Wasabi/CoinJoin lines, Mixmaster/Mixminion/Danezis passage, Elixxir, mixnet email, Bitcoin mining lead-in); removed hallucinations ("Cypherpugs podcast series", "podcast about Bitcoin mining", "Thank you"); jingle as Ad voiceover; fixed Chaum/Chaumian, Nym, Len Sassaman, Lance Cottrell, George Danezis, Panoramix, cMix, Ania Piotrowska, Vaultoro, Russophobia, Hillebrand; split Harry's "Oh, yeah!" and "Oh yeah, hey, smart guy" interjections; Restored dropped speech (Chainalysis/NSA Utah, Simplicity-era lines, 00:57:35–00:58:25 identity section) from second ASR/re-check; removed "Welcome to the episode of the Nym Podcast" x2 and spurious "Thank you"; split Harry's "Okay, sorry, no problem" and Vlad's "Oh, yeah, it's been a long time" interjections; fixed Nym, George Danezis, Mixminion, Tadge, pseudonymous keys, Paul Sztorc, shitcoins, Tendermint, Drivechains, mixnets, Chainalysis, Sybil, Bitcoiner in the street, "Tor" → Taproot (context: building on Bitcoin); 00:44:38 labelled Vlad; Removed hallucinations "The end." and title echo at 01:04:03 (timestamps dropped), "This podcast" → Telegram; restored dropped text (Chelsea Manning passage, "than not. That being said..." web browser lines, Counterparty sentence at 01:09); split interjections (Vlad's free NFT offer, "Oh, wow", "Well, that's a great idea", "Oh geez", end-to-end and Telegram questions); fixed Nym, Counterparty, Chaum/Stefan Brands, Free Ross DAO, Snowden, Dave Hrycyszyn, MTProto, Messaging Layer Security, Pavel Durov, Rare Pepes, Lance Cottrell, Len Sassaman, Usenet, Stasi, MobileCoin, high fee; Speaker repairs (Guest A → Harry Halpin; split Vlad/Harry interjecti