S13 E13: Filip Pawczyński on Bitcoin Mining in the Early Days
Search this conversation
0:51Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad, your Bitcoin influencer's influencer, and this is a very special episode with a Bitcoin OG who has been around since at least 2011. He has been mining in the early days and he even participated in establishing small mining pools, I guess, with USB devices. His name is Filip Pawczyński, Pawczyński, I hope I pronounced that well, and he is also involved in lots of organizations regarding Bitcoin in Poland. He was affiliated with some organizations. I'm not sure if I'm the most qualified to talk about that, but I will let him also introduce himself. So, hi, Filip.
1:39Filip PawczyńskiHi, Vlad. I'm very happy to be here and thank you for the invitation. It was so nice to have, very nice meetup when you was in Poland. So, hello, everyone, and super nice to be here.
1:55Vlad CosteaYeah, so I met you during the Warsaw Film Festival, which was, I guess, one of the first film festivals about Bitcoin. And it also coincided with the weekend of capitalism. So it was a libertarian conference inside of a movie festival about Bitcoin. And it was interesting. I think it was Wojtek Stopiński from Cryptosteel who introduced me to you. And I was like, OK, this guy has been mining so early before it was industrialized, before there was some guy from NASA writing research papers about how to integrate mining for national security, whatever that means.
2:37You are actually doing stuff with GPU cards, with laptops, with USB ASICs. This was before the days of Butterfly Labs. This was before the days of Antminers by Bitmain. What was it like?
2:53Filip PawczyńskiYeah, that's true. It's like so many times. But when you look at the history, you see that first three generations of the Bitcoin mining was so fast and it was like a couple of years and everybody just was looking in the future. So, yeah, for sure, from the first generation, when you have only GPUs and early miners like the developers were using that, it was very, very wild time. And I know that, you know, it's like the hashrate was so small then, then you are able to see then there is like a very nice old web page when you are able to see all the mining information about the early mining, when the Satoshi was mining, when Hal was mining, and when Laszlo was mining, and all the people who we know that were mining in early stages, like thousands and ten thousands of Bitcoins around from the mining, because they were developing the first code and was just testing all the stuff.
4:07So, yeah, it was crazy. But it's like, you know, it was more than 10 years ago and we are right now in a very different situation according to mining, you know, from every side, from side of the technology, from side of the financing, from side of the, you know, approach. And of course, like you mentioned about, you know, Jason Lowery's theory about, you know, the Softwar, about how the hashrate and hashing power according to the virtual world and to the world that we are living with the, you know, informational part, will be needed.
4:47And, you know, that kind of hashrate, like a strategic good, will be just needed to cooperate and to exist in the future. And this is like, you know, one of the strategic things that the countries should look at. So, yeah, I also, you know, I am right now reading Softwar, so I totally in it and I totally understand that because it's like I'm from the beginning and I see all the, you know, approaches and all the people and that billion of dollars that was invested in the technology in some early stages and when we are right now.
5:22So, yeah, like you mentioned, I have the opportunity to jump in the market because I was in networking. So, for me, approach to the Bitcoin was from that networking part that this is like the networks and so the miners are like routers and, you know, I finish my Cisco CCNA still in middle school. So, I understand how the, you know, hardware is important in the networking in general when in that kind of scope what we are when we are living right now. So, this was like the most interesting for me because I was working with networking and mostly with routers with the companies and like I mentioned, according to the Cisco opportunities.
6:09So, you know, the miners was something that I was starting to create when I was able, yeah. We, of course, created GPU miners before and I remember my first GPU miners, I don't remember the year, but it was in, you know, plastic basket because there was no, it wasn't the time that you were able to buy, you know, the rig for it, yeah. So, the metal construction that you are able to build the rig on.
6:38So, I remember the times and it was, you know, something new because the effort that you put to build the miner in general was, you know, financially and according to time and according to the information that you need to extract from Bitcointalk, of course, in that time was so enormous according to the, you know, the value of Bitcoin that was that day that you get from it that it was, you know, when you do that you should to have time for that and of course it was more for maybe not for fun because everybody see that potential in that but it was like, you know, in laboratory, it was like testing, it was like, you know, having fun with that when you was in IT, when you like the hardware and all that stuff, it was like, you know, something for you from that part.
7:35So, we even don't, we understand the future opportunities but because there was not so many people, we also not have an option to see much more further like, you know, for me, after, you know, 10 years generally in the market because in 2013 I produced the miner. So, before I was, you know, trying and mining and doing that but I wasn't on the market. So, after 10 years on the market, I am able to tell that it's like many things wasn't planned. It's like, you know, it's like so much faster than we think about it will be.
8:15So, on one side it's okay because the option is just much more bigger than somebody else was thinking but on the other side, the many of us just wasn't prepared to that. So, you know, it's like it's that kind of topics that when you're like a super early adopter or OG in some kind of topic but, you know, it's like we have so many things and so many time that it will be, you know, in the future. So, this is also the topic that they understand after 10 years. So, yeah.
8:47Vlad CosteaI have to ask you, how do you discover Bitcoin so early or how did you? Because I remember reading about it in 2013 but that was because of the price. I guess you were on some hacker forums or something.
9:02Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like all starts from my friend. It's like long story short, when I go to the college, it was before 2006, I also was trying to, you know, get some money and there was like the approach that in Europe you were starting to able to play poker in internet. So, it was something new then and many guys from games like, you know, the pro gamers from Starcraft, Warcraft, there was a couple names, started to, you know, change the playing from the games to the poker because it was like more income for them and of course more fun and it was like something for them.
9:48So, I have friends like that and they just introduced me to poker and I start to play with many friends when I was in the college and one of that friend started to play also in internet, but he just discovered that, I don't remember what the poker room was, but he started to play on Bitcoin there. So he told me, I told him about poker, he find the poker room with the Bitcoin and told me about the Bitcoin and we started searching how was it. How is it?
10:22So it was like, you know, it was something that in that kind of stages, the poker rooms have that kind of option because it was something for them. You know, just like a Silk Road. Many people know about the Bitcoin, about the Silk Road because it was like the utility that they need to have. So I was on that other side. I find it from my friend and he finds it from the poker games. So, but yeah, it was like, you know, only on the Bitcointalk, he was able to find some kind of more information about the topic, but it was like you mentioned, it was a geek forum.
10:59You know, when you just rewind it to 2008, when the Satoshi started and you read it's like a forum. So it was like that. It's very funny because right now Bitcointalk don't have that kind of power that it had before, but when you want to see the history of creating Bitcoin in the community, it's there. You just are able to, you know, rewind it and just go through it. So I was there also. And we started also to, you know, created some kind of opportunity for me and for my small company that I started like two years before to create some kind of income.
11:41And we started to work with our friends, creating the group buys for, you know, for miners, for equipment, for many different, you know, stuff that was there according to the hardware part of the operation, because it was easy for us. And because I had the company, I was able to, you know, import something from China and have that all stuff in place. So we run the business according to hardware. And from that, because we was on the market in 2013, we jump to the ASICs. It's maybe too early, but I will also rewind myself a little bit back.
12:23But in 2013, we have the opportunity to test Bitfury 5 gigahash chips. They were started in June 2013. And because we have opportunity to test it, we have opportunity also and good option to buy it. So from May 2013, till December 2013, my company produce and start to selling BiFury USB ASIC miner. So there are little red one, USB ASIC miner that have five gigahashes. And for that time, it was maximum that you are able to get out from the USB 3.0, not using any power hub.
13:12So it was that kind of miner that was we have in mind when creating it that it will be for every miner wannabe who have only a computer, not need to have some kind of special additional hardware will be able to run it. And so it was like in 2013, it was my the most known move according to that on the mining market. But before that, we also and after that, we also selling the miners from couple different companies. So it's like, you know, we started from the basket miners GPUs that we created ourselves.
13:53Later, we go for the FPGAs. And we also have, you know, couple different opportunities to work with the main distributor of Spartan FPGAs in Europe. So we have an option also to, you know, to get that chips, but of course, you need to have to create all the miners, but we have that opportunity. So we also buy some, you know, Cairnsmores and other different companies that was available then on the market. And of course, between, you know, FPGAs and first Avalons, because there was, of course, ASICMiner.
14:32And we also have some ASICMiner, but most, I think effort from us was the first two batches of Avalons that was in December 2012. And I think June 2013. So it was, I think, the biggest hashrate jump, that like in 2013. And later, of course, all the different companies like Bitfury, or KnCMiner, start to delivering. So in 2013, like you mentioned on the start, Bitcoin mining goes more, more professional. Yeah. So the, you know, the price and the needs of the cost of the needs that you need to create the proper mining, you know, farm to buy proper price and proper quality miners and all that stuff, it starts to need it to have, you know, on the start from more, more funds.
15:37So, you know, the cost of enter to the market was much more greater than two years ago. So, you know, it's like, on the, on the beginning, it was very interesting, because everybody was able to enter the market. And right now, if you want to enter on the market, according to the Bitcoin mining, you need to have more money or more contact, or just invest in some company that is right now very professional. And we are able to see how much professional companies to that mining Bitcoin are right now, when we are looking on the whole US market, where, where all the miners was, where most of the miners are public.
16:23So, you know, all you have all the reports, you have all the photos, you have all the data that they need to share with the shareholders. So, you know, according to that, you are able to make statistics and all that information are, you know, better to acquire, and also much more better, you know, when you are interested in that kind of investment, you are able to get the data to check if this is proper option for you. Because this is also one of the truth that, you know, most investment in around Bitcoin, if you are not making it proper, and in the right timing, you know, it's most it, most of that investment was end like, the better was that you will just buy the Bitcoin and just keep it yourself and just do other things.
17:12This is the reality, you know, also for OGs and in general, for Bitcoin users, long term users. So, you know, it's like also with the mining, and I think it will be only progressing in that kind of way, that mining will be just much more professional and, you know, that entry price will be much more higher than even it's right now. So, it will turn more to the strategic good, like you mentioned, like we mentioned about the Softwar, it's like, you know, according to progression and usage of the top notch and on the edge of the technology, it's like, you know, ASICs right now are using top notch technology and will use the best option to create and, you know, to generate also the low cost Bitcoin.
18:11So, you know, from the low cost and low print, according to the carbon source of the power. So, you know, this is also the switch, also the change that what we have like five or, you know, seven years ago, when all started, you know, from that time, the carbon footprint from that professional mining right now, it's like going to the really nice direction. And it's not even not should to be even any argument right now, you know, according to the talk about the Bitcoin and about the approach for the for the work economic.
18:55Vlad CosteaYeah, one of the common criticisms about mining Bitcoin is that it's very expensive for the average person to do it, as right now it has become professionalized to the point where you have to buy an ASIC miner to be profitable. And this is a pretty valid criticism that you only have a handful of manufacturers who make these chips, and you as an individual don't really have access to them. And it costs you about, let's say, $18,000 to get the S19 Pro, I hope I'm not mistaken about the price.
19:28But what I want to ask you right now is, how expensive was it for you to build the rigs consisting of video cards back in the day, because those were not cheap either. And I guess you had top notch video cards for computation.
19:44Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like, oh, yes, like I mentioned, according to the, you know, old times, and the effort and the price for the software, for the hardware and all the efforts to, you know, to build it and to run it stable, because it's also about the software and firmware, and you know, all that option that you have to tune in up the GPUs. So it was, it was enormous cost, you know, it's like, it was, I am not able to count it like in some kind of proportion.
20:19But in general, I think that if we just, it was like, you know, maybe 100 bitcoins, maybe even more, you know, in 2013 to build a rig. So, of course, on the start, yeah, so it was like 10,000, 10,000 euros. Yeah.
20:49Vlad CosteaAnd I guess that the rig was producing less of a hash rate, but at the same time, it was, the difficulty was lower. So also the rewards were higher, I guess. It was a different landscape.
21:04Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like, it's like, in 2013, we also have, you know, the opportunity to, because in 2013, there was also the alt season, because the Litecoin and the other altcoins popped up. So there was a very big approach to build, because the miners, the cards was start to be expensive, because of the mining, it was that kind of time, you know, before it wasn't that, with the Bitcoin, it wasn't that filled. So, yeah, it was, the card was expensive in general, but it was a normal expensive price. And in 2013, we have that option when the altcoins comes.
21:44So when we have mostly the Litecoin mining then, the cards will start to price rising up because of the need of the cryptocurrency. It was the first topic like that in that. So, you know, it was when, I remember it was not only the cards, you know, it was also the risers. I remember the risers price was like so high, you know, I just remember it was like $25 or when the risers before was like a couple dollars. And, you know, in bulk, when you buy in China, it was like, you know, cents or something like that.
22:22So not even the cards, but in 2013, even all that, you know, equipment that was, you know, the proper mainboards was also hard to get. The proper processors was also hard to get, you know, to build the proper cost miner that was suitable for, like hardware was suitable for software also. So, yeah, it was so many, you know, opportunities, but you were asking about that miner before, you know, I think it's like when you created the miner for 2000, like in 2011 and before $2,000, $3,000.
23:09So I think it was like the normal stuff that since there, but it wasn't so stable. So I think it's one of the example of the approaches that when you start to mine, when you started to mining, like you as developer and you have like, you know, thousands of the Bitcoin because of that, because nobody was mining since there. It was a totally different approach when the, you know, open GPU mining started, when, you know, when the hash rate just jump and when the new people just come in, because it was so, it was like one year, I think, or one and a half year since, you know, GPUs till FPGAs.
23:49So it, people just started working so fast on FPGAs because it was not natural from GPUs that, you know, it was like not very people was able to use it according to Bitcoin, but later that rigs people built and wasn't able to, you know, mine back because of the FPGAs. They started using to the altcoins. So, you know, the Litecoin when it jumped in 2013 to the couple of dollars, it was like, you know, something for the people who have that rigs. So, you know, according to the history, the whole economy of the mining and, you know, the flow of the equity in that Bitcoin, according to not only, you know, the value of Bitcoin itself, but also the underlying technology and the miners and the net value was also growing very fast and was, you know, very liquid.
24:49The GPUs just from get, you know, the place of the FPGAs and later the ASIC before the GPUs was just replaced with itself and GPU just go very smooth to the altcoins. So, you know, people who like we have that rigs before it was for us very easy to switch to the altcoins later. I remember Feathercoin, I remember Litecoin. It was like, you know, it was natural.
25:22Vlad CosteaAnd I guess the same happens today. For example, when Ethereum switched to proof of stake, there was at least one fork that absorbed that hashrate.
25:32Filip PawczyńskiYeah. And of course, the Ethereum Classic, the classic chain.
25:40Vlad CosteaYeah, the real one.
25:42Filip PawczyńskiYeah, the real one. The real Ethereum is still there. Yeah.
25:48Vlad CosteaSo something that I also wanted to ask you was something about electricity, right? Because you started mining from home in the beginning, but did you have a competitive electricity price or did you have to sign a special contract with the electricity company as you were expanding your operation?
26:08Filip PawczyńskiNo, you know, it was the time that, no, it was the time that we don't have that kind of option. It's like when we started, of course. Yeah. So when we started, we don't have that option. We just have, you know, when you have old houses in Poland, some of them had, you know, there was the old wood ceramic, you know, chimneys inside. And you was able to just, you know, bring the wood and, you know, make the heat inside. And later they, you know, you wasn't allowed to use them with the fire.
26:48So they put the electricity inside. And because of that, many of the old houses have on one side, the proper, you know, infrastructure to get something more than in a normal house. And on the other side, the special tariff. It wasn't a super big change, but we use it. It was like two-zone tariff, different in the night and different in the day. So we have very cheap in the normal in the day. And we just use it because of that. So we also have idea how we use it, the normal opportunity that we had.
27:24So we just rent, you know, the big apartment because in general, in that whole old homes in Poland, it's called Kamienica. So you have like the big, you know, very big spaces, like, you know, 200 meters and four meters up flats. So we just rent that kind of flat and we all use it like, you know, like a mining center. Then till we just use all the opportunity to use the power there. So it wasn't, you know, professional and we have, we don't have the option, but it was the one of the option.
28:03But of course, later we have many different opportunities, even, you know, even because when you're paying for electricity, you mostly pay like there is two substances in the cost that you're paying. There is the distribution and then the cost of the energy and of course, many different stuff. But the main two. So we even have the opportunity, but much more later and in much more professional way, we have opportunity to rent the, you know, place that was in the same, you know, premises that the electricity, the power plant that the electricity company had.
28:45So we rent the place from them so we don't have to need to pay for the distribution because we have straight from the production from them. So, you know, we always try to get the cheapest energy that we was able because, you know, we counting all of that. So we know that the energy is a margin. So, you know, it's a cost. So, of course, you want to maximize your profit. And especially when you mine Bitcoin, you want to maximize your profit and, you know, just keep your asset proper because it also need to be take care of proper.
29:21Sometimes you need to be held. Sometimes you need to be sold in the right moments to pay some costs. So it's also, you know, that kind of operation from the administration point and costs flow and the financial flow and all that stuff. So right now, all that companies that they mentioned, the public one and the new type of the companies are push, push, putting much more pressure on that part. So it's not only, you know, technological part, like you have a physics physical place with the miners and hardware and the electricity.
29:54You also have all the administration around of that because you have a people who work on that. You have administration according to connectivity, you know, to backups, to override, to maintain the miners. It's like it's very important. And of course, on the other side, you have financial side. Yeah. There are people who need to, you know, arrange all of financial part to keep the funds, to keep the flows, to give the information, to create the reports. And especially if you have, you know, a public trade company, you need to get all the information.
30:27They need to be proper because people are using the data and they will use it for content. And also they profit. So and of course, risk reward ratio, because this is most important. So, you know, this is also we also see that professional part, not only in, you know, the creation, the production and maintenance of the hardware, but also on that, you know, management side of whole operation.
30:57Vlad CosteaDid you ever think about going to people's houses and telling them, you know, keep this device in your chimney running 24 seven, you just pay for electricity and you get heating from it?
31:08Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like we have the project in Poland. I have my friends who have that kind of project after our it's like mostly mine and like our in the group journey with the mining. He decided to create the project called Silent Miner, and they created the, you know, the sort of the bucket when you are able to put your miner inside. And I don't remember if they go off, but on the first project, it was that they put it in immersion. So you are able to put it to this miner to your water system and you have your, you know, the hot water for heat to your home.
31:57So you are connecting that to that system. So you have like silent miner, but also the hot water flow to put to your to put to your heat, you know, to the floor heat or to that wall heat. It depends what kind of system you have in the home. But in general, you know, that kind of approach they have. So, you know, we have that kind of ideas, but it's still, you know, effort and it's still investment. They need to count it. Of course, right now, when the price of the power in Europe are surging, we also have that kind of problem in Poland.
32:34So, you know, when you buy it in the last year or the two years ago, right now, all your calculations are not very proper and they are looking much more worse. So, you know, people also need to understand that. And of course, you know, miners inside. They also don't understand that, you know, difficulty is only growing. And this is like economical effort and this is the story of the game. And they just need to, you know, invest the time to time for a new miner because it will be more proper for their use and for their profit.
33:10And this is, you know, so it's not like you are able to go just put the box and they will be working. No, it needs more effort. So to me, you need to have the service, you need to have, you know, sales that will talk with the people and talk and show them all the information. So, you know, people right now are not very eager to jump on that stuff like that. Yeah. So, but it's like, yeah, we are working in that kind of direction in some point.
33:39I'm, you know, try to cooperate with many companies, like, for example, that silent miner to use that effort because, you know, it's very nice, like you mentioned. But in general, it's still work that you need to work with the closest friends or somebody who have like, you know, bigger opportunities, bigger effort. You know, people in hotels maybe have a better opportunity because they have different cash flow. And we have also ideas to put in some kind of, you know, resorts and that kind of companies, you know, that kind of project to heat the water with the miners.
34:20So, yeah, it's like we was thinking about that and we even have some kind of moves, like I mentioned, but it's still slow. It's just still slow. The people are just still not very convinced to do all of that. But of course, it's growing year by year. Right now, according to all the world and economic situation, it's just on one way helping, on second one helping because showing the real truth and in what kind of world we are living right now.
34:50Vlad CosteaYeah. And something else that I want to ask you is back in the day when you started mining, were you doing it solo or did you join pools? Because I know that Slush Pool was established sometime in 2010. So there was some time to join pools, I guess.
35:06Filip PawczyńskiYeah, for sure. For sure. You know, it was many pools and it was many different approaches. We need to remember that Slush and, you know, it's like Marek just created the Stratum with the guys and it was like very needed. But before, you know, we have different operational model of connecting to the network. So, yeah, Stratum and the pools and especially if especially I remember, you know, Slush and I was using Slush and I remember BitcoinCZ. So I remember also the early times. So, yeah, for sure.
35:47For sure. The pooling I was I was we was using mostly the pools on the early times we use, of course, the solo because because it was it was something much more proper. But I don't know, it was like maybe two, three months of my history later. It was all about the pools because, you know, hash rate just jumped on the GPUs and after FPGA just started popping. It was it was something enormous. So, yeah, people started to pooling itself before it was like, you know, I remember many different approaches to counting the shares in the pool and many different approaches to also, you know, have some kind of opportunity to get some more shares that you are that you should to have in that kind of pool approaches.
36:37So there was, you know, there was the pools before who don't have super great software. And literally the you have the possibility and some people use that to just, you know, get all the rewards for yourself. So, you know, it was also the problem of the pools in the beginning that, you know, poor software was letting people, some bad actors to just, you know, scam all the other people in the pool and just get the prize for themselves. It was that topic before. That's why, you know, all the growing and all that like approaches of the pool.
37:19It's very, very meaningful and very interesting how it's working right now. And I think the approach to the better connectivity, you know, protocol like Stratum V2, it's right now like showing and it's showing the difference and what the needs are, you know, from from from history and from experience coming out. And we should do also look on that kind of approaches because it's natural progression of all community. And it's like it should to be looked at like that.
38:04Ad voiceoverAre you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.
39:06Cryptosteel are innovators in Bitcoin cold storage. Back in 2013, they launched the Cryptosteel Cassette, which made it easy to back up your seed phrase, passphrase or any other form of private key on the sturdy metal which resists water, fire and earthquakes. Today, Cryptosteel offers the Motherlode, an all-in-one box which endows you with everything you need to become financially sovereign. Inside of the Motherlode, you get a Cryptosteel Capsule and a hardware wallet of your choice. All Cryptosteel products are engineered and manufactured in Poland. Order your Cryptosteel metal backup system today on cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR at checkout for a 10% discount on your first order.
40:04Cryptosteel, secure your wallet seed phrase. Are you a writer, photographer, musician or video creator who is trying to generate some revenue? Bumbee is the Bitcoin way to monetize your content. It's more censorship resistant than any other platform of its kind with a low and flat one-time fee of 10%. Bumbee is as easy to use as any social media mobile application. Sign up today at Bumbee.com and subscribe for free to the Bitcoin Takeover account to get access to some time-exclusive content. If you are monetizing your creativity, why not get paid in Bitcoin for it? Bumbee.com, the Bitcoin way to monetize your content.
41:07Shopping with your Bitcoin on the internet is easy. ShopinBit is Europe's biggest Bitcoin store with over 800,000 products, ranging from Bitcoin books, toothpaste, mobile phones, computers and watches. This month, I bought a Nintendo Game & Watch console with the classic Legend of Zelda and it arrived in only five working days. And if you can't find what you're looking for, ShopinBit has got you covered. Their concierge service will get you anything and ship it worldwide. Additionally, they also have a travel hacking service that can get you the best deals on all things travel.
41:54Flights, hotels and more for business and for vacations. Bitcoin Takeover listeners get a nice discount, of course. Use code BTCTKVR on your first order for a one-time 5 euro discount. For more details, go to ShopinBit.com. ShopinBit, Europe's biggest Bitcoin store.
42:24Vlad CosteaAlright, Filip, so before the commercial break, we discussed what mining used to be back in the day, and how it was different, and how you were managing all of these video card rigs, and then the first ASIC miners. But it has changed so much over the last decade, and I see that you're still interested in this industry, and it's still something that consumes a lot of your time. How would you describe the differences, and how would you characterize this leap forward? Because we went from guys who were hobbyists mining in their apartments to guys going to power plants, trying to get better deals for electricity, and now we have large farms, large pools.
43:09It's big business right now. It's kind of intimidating for the small guy to get in.
43:15Filip PawczyńskiYeah, on one side, of course, decentralization of the hashing power, it's one of the main needs of the Bitcoin network itself. It's better that the hash rate will be more decentralized, but on the other hand also, the hash rate needs to be more professional, to be more sustainable for the network, and of course for the miners itself, because it's in that kind of reward system like mining is. Of course, it's pros and cons, and right now, like I mentioned before, because there is many more information and possibility to track some even on-chain changes that were before, the possibility to make some kind of mistakes from whole conception or counting all that approach for the mining.
44:17Right now, those mistakes are just minimized. So that's why the professional approach, and that's what we are able to see with many different mining companies in the States that are public companies, like I mentioned before, this is one of the best sources of information according to how that kind of business is looking in general, and what they are searching. And on the other side, right now it's also some kind of law changes in Texas that the miners are opting not to provide. So it's still a topic that is very much more connected to the whole approach to the cryptocurrency.
45:06And right now, with that situation where the banks, so the option to on-ramp from fiat to crypto, it's like decreasing from some time. We also see that operations according to the law and some kind of stuff in Texas are right now. So on one side we need decentralization, on the other side we need to have professional amount of hashing power to make it more secure. And on the other side, we also have the old system who is fighting in every possible direction that they had. And it's like that right now.
45:51I know what I'm talking about according to Poland, because we feel that our community in Poland feels that, how it's to be erased from the possibility to keep working in some kind of country. So we see that. We also have a couple hundred kilometers more. We have Estonia or Switzerland, where you have that opportunity to work with that kind of businesses. So it's like this is the main topic, the digital gold that Bitcoin is and the possibility to acquire it. And of course, managing the transaction and get the fee from the transaction in the future, that it will be the 100% of the business, of course.
46:44So it's like that kind of approach on the many layers of that. It's something that's why I will once again mention about the software and about the need for the hashing power. So it's like we are going to that kind of direction. It will not be super soon, but it's all about all the systems, how they will work right now and how they will behave according to what is happening. So it's really hard to get the decentralization in that kind of hostile environment. And for the last 10 years, I was personally thinking that in kind of adoption of the centralization of miners of point of the payment according to the Lightning Network will be a little bit bigger for sure.
47:40And to compare it to the price, it should to be bigger. But right now we already have a time to just work on the new possibilities, new options, smart contracts, inscriptions and all that new possibilities for me. It's also showing that we have the blockchain and right now we are able to work on that with many different opportunities that we have. And they are like have that kind of base according to the code and, you know, architectural approach to the security and usage of cryptography in general.
48:25So, you know, like Taproot or SegWit before, it's like it's very proper. So right now, in my opinion, the mining should do, you know, brave self and we will see what will happen after that cycle. So after the next halving, I'm just waiting according to that. But in general, you know, it's like it will be really hard to be a solo miner and get the opportunity to be a super proper miner. But of course, like we were talking, you know, the heat, the option to, you know, stack some sats.
49:11It's always good if you have opportunity, you have some, you know, old miner and you have some kind of option for free electricity. We see that kind of option. It's always better to run the hardware than not run it. Even if you have some GPUs and you are able to mine some kind of shitcoin just to exchange for some sats, it's also OK if you have, you know, hardware and proper opportunity.
49:40So I think, you know, that decentralization and that right now with all that additional things, you know, according to the Lightning and even with the Ordinals, they will acquire more people who will just, you know, join to the movement to to stack sats and this will be also the new thing for the decentralization of the mining that you are mentioning and I am mentioning and I really... I'm more eager to, you know, that branch will be also open, but we just need to wait a little bit more because, you know, the adoption will go through and the mining will also have the utility there. But it's all according to the usage of some kind of good source of the... energy. It will always be like that.
50:32Vlad CosteaSo before we get into geopolitics and all of that discussion about where it's best to mine, which countries are currently mining, whether or not there's government intervention in Bitcoin mining, I think that that's a very nice topic to unwrap. But before that, why do we need mining at all? Because there seem to be lobbyists from Greenpeace, from the US government. I saw some recent report in which they said that they... expect some kind of move for Bitcoin to go proof of stake. And my question for you right now is, how would you describe the difference between proof of work and proof of stake?
51:10Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like from... from conception, it's like, I think here... here again, Lowery, it's a very good example of how you can just show the difference to ordinary people. So you have like the imaginary power. So... so power of... of... of the rules that are... that set, of course, in some kind of way, but it's still the agreement between the people and it's like more... creatable than natural. Yeah. It's not in the nature we create that between ourselves. Yeah. So this is like proof of stake and proof of work.
51:55It's more like real power. So you have that mining, you have that electricity, you have that real power, real hardware that they, you know, there is some kind of work that you need to prove it to the system. So you need to deliver work to the system to get the rewards. This is the reward system that I was mentioned before. It's natural also. It's always like that. Nature is also like that, you know, so if you deliver something to the plants, they will just grow. So this is like more natural and also the treat from it's also more natural.
52:33Yeah. Here you have people who will give you... like you... you have the people who have a right to tell you what kind of law is it and you need to obey to them, like police, like courts and all that stuff. And here you have the little tree who is like, you know, the rock that can kill you in nature or some bigger animal can kill you in the nature or something like that. So it's... it's... it's more for me, it's more like that. And this is how how mentioned Lowery is mentioning about that. And I think it's very proper to mention.
53:10And of course, from... from technical part, from technical side, it's like we have like, you know, proof of work about... from the hashing power, so from the real technology, from the real spend, you know, economical effort, time. And of course, it's a progression with our growth, like... like the whole, you know, technological approach to humanity, because we are also beyond the peak of the technology of the logical, you know, processing power in general.
53:37Yeah. So... so it's more natural with the growth and, you know, proof of stake. It's more about the rules that you set the rules and it's more understandable because we right now are living in that kind of proof of stake world. Yeah. About the rules, about the governments, about, you know, all that geopolitical stuff, about the banks. Yeah. It's also some kind of agreement between the people and between the IT systems right now. And, you know, approach of the Bitcoin like a digital gold, it's totally different.
54:13And we know how the blockchain is working and how, you know, that common transaction book it will be able to use. Yeah. Right now we have mentioned Taproot, so we have a little bit more option to... to provide more use cases for that databases. And of course, we also have the approaches like Ordinal Theory that also give us additional layer of information that we are able to extract from... from... from that ledger. So this is more natural than creating some other stuff that it's more artificial. And again, based on agreement right now, not on the real hash power.
54:58But we need to remember that some project started from that natural proof of work approach and right now go to the proof of stake because of the lobby and because of the understanding that this is more proper. But it's not more proper. It's more understandable and useful for, you know, Web3 products in general, because they are like between crypto and blockchain.
55:28Vlad CosteaYeah. To me, it's still very difficult to figure out how a proof of stake system can be decentralized, because if you enable it to be decentralized, then it's not secure. You have no coordination. The incentives are pretty poor. In the absence of a concentration of wealth, which takes the coins and secures the network, you're not going to make it be secure. So for sure, in my understanding, at least proof of stake requires a lot of centralization, which is not desirable for Bitcoin, because in proof of stake, one coin means one vote. So the more coins you have, the more votes you have and more control you have over the network.
56:14Filip PawczyńskiYeah, for sure. And, you know, many different like government system, because it's hard to tell a real doubt about the, you know, many systems with the government, with the utility token have the government options. We can, we were able to see many different approaches, like there's some kind of big party was have that, you know, voting time period, and they just decided by themselves. Yeah, it was before also with the Ethereum, according to the DAO. We see that before. So yeah, we see that this is not working.
56:55And this is also mimicking that existing, you know, banking system right now and all that approaches to the government, because it's like, you know, it's more mimicking the existing environment that we have right now. But it's just switching the power to the other people. But the approach for the controlling the power is the same, like you mentioned, it's all about votes. And it's much more complicated than only votes. That's why the layer of the complicated, like, complicity that you are giving from proof of work, from geopolitical, you know, operation.
57:35And that's, in general, many different, you know, economical approaches and many different, you know, that kind of power up and different stuff that you have from the theory of the game in Bitcoin. That they are, like, really mixed with our economical situation because of the proof of work, because of the technology, because of the creation of the chips, because of the, you know, all the production, where is it, how is it working, you know, all the chain of supply and all the different, you know, part that it's in the real world.
58:19It's creating, you know, it's much more real and much more hard also to control than proof of stake. So it's not only about the vote. Yeah, it's not about the vote when you have Bitcoin. You need to vote by very many different stuff, experience on the market, you know, hashing power. And of course, you also have the network. It's not only about the network of verification of miners. It's also about the network itself, about nodes, about the connection and all the protocols. So we have the layer that it's on the different base, not that much connected to the economic and creating the hardware that it's in real world and consuming real world power that that it's using real world resources.
59:09But we also have the layer of the networking that is more connected with the Internet and how is Internet working? How the decentralization is working, how the storage is working, VPNs and all that, all that stuff. So, you know, it's you have a different people who are working on networking and you have a different people who are using network networking and even are miners, you know. So it's like it's also different set of the skills. So it's like, you know, much more complicated to control all of that points here.
59:42And of course, we have developers and have all that, you know, bits and all that procedure to get the bit done and all that stuff. So, you know, it's like another layer. So it's much more complicated. And because of that, it's much more nature for our world.
1:00:05Vlad CosteaYeah, it makes sense right now. I'm working on an article which is exactly about this. It's going to be part of my new magazine, which I hope I'm going to send to you. I'm not sure if you're coming to BTC Prague or Pizza Day or some other event in Europe, but I'm going to have some copies of the magazine there. And one of the articles is exactly about this, because one of the most common sources of FUD about Bitcoin is the energy consumption. Coincidentally, we also have the debate nowadays, which is happening in the United States, where lots of representatives of various states want to ban Bitcoin mining.
1:00:41And it seems to get very political at this point, where to some point, it's super absurd, as during the years when most of the mining was taking place in China, I guess it was much more peaceful than it is right now with U.S. politicians and regulators, each of them trying to get their own share of what's happening in mining or trying to ban it outright. And I don't think in the long term the United States is going to be a major player in mining. That's just my impression. But I'm curious if you know anything else and what you think about the situation.
1:01:20Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like I mentioned about the situation in Texas right now. There is, you know, Pierre is there on the daily basis, so it's like it's good to look what he's right now doing. But in general, and I was checking before the Easter, the situation was that they are fighting for some law that, you know, some lawmakers want to. To push in Texas that the mining will be much more affordable, I don't know, really, but it's like this is one of the topic right now. So, you know, I think it's like with the full agenda, according to what states are doing right now, because it's like it's cooperative work, because it's like, you know, right now, I don't know, it started in February, I think.
1:02:25But in general, I think that kind of stuff, it's also hard because, you know, according to that case in Texas, you know, you have many people who lose the work in some kind of, you know, I was reading. I don't remember the company, but I was reading that the aluminum melting plant was closed and many people was fired and they just, you know, rearrange it and just create the mining center there. And, you know, in general, they just get the people to work there. So, you know, it's on one side, we have a lobby that see that, OK, we have cheap electricity, we have work power, we have plants and we are not using that.
1:03:06And they are giving our state money and to work for the people. So, you know, it's states are states. So I don't know from what kind of direction it's that, you know, law is coming. But in general, it will be very hard because the people also, you know, to go through with it in 100 percent with nothing, because people just have the work there. And, you know, it's even about the ordinary people who work in the mining plants right now in the Texas. So, you know, you have many different levels.
1:03:39You have the plants, you have the people who are owners of the land, you have the companies who are working there to creating all the plants. You have, you know, the electricity producer who are working there also to survive and all that stuff. So, you know, it's like many layers of the people who are working to just keep that sustained and to bring more businesses like that to Texas. So I this is one of the topics that it's very worth to observe, because right now it's like, you know, states have so many hash rate and so many of them.
1:04:16It's like in Texas. So it's like I remember that was that same topic in China when they, you know, provide that law where the miners have, you know, higher fees for electricity. So and we know what happened next. So right now it's like that if that this is the approach that states have. So they have it clearly from the Chinese approach. Maybe not clearly, but, you know, it's very it's very similar. So this is, I think, not good direction, like you mentioned. And if it will be successful, that change in Texas, it will it will be something that it will be very hard for mining in states for sure.
1:04:59And I don't know what's happening later in that kind of scenario will will be play out. I really don't know. I will be observing that. So this is from the situation. And I think this is very matter right now.
1:05:16Vlad CosteaThe two examples that we have in this tiny story are superpowers, probably the two biggest of the world. But I was thinking, are there any legitimate reasons for a smaller and developing nation state to mine Bitcoin to secure its access to the global financial system or to escape sanctions or to try to attract some sort of innovation and technology development in their country?
1:05:48Filip PawczyńskiYeah, for sure. You know, we have a great example here of El Salvador. And, you know, all that proceed with making Bitcoin a legal payment tender and in general, you know, volcano bonds. This is very nice idea and very nice use case. You have clear you have you have clear power. And for you know, for them, it's only cost of creation of that. So if you know, this is this is one of the great idea. Of course, it's not easy to build it, but for, you know, for developing country that they have, you know, opportunity, they have will, they have power and they have financial option to set it.
1:06:36It's just about the building right now, the business opportunities for other actors in the system to just provide the option. So here, like I mentioned, the perfect example is El Salvador. And I think many countries are looking for them and they will also be a very good example for many countries, especially in Africa and especially in Asia.
1:07:03Vlad CosteaWhen we tell these stories, it seems like mining has become mostly a nation state or big business affair. So I want to ask you right now, do you see any reason for the average Bitcoin user to start mining? And if so, how should they do it?
1:07:23Filip PawczyńskiYou know, I think it's like I mentioned, if you have proper amount of time because it's consumed some time to prepare yourself to set up and just later to maintain it's maybe the much more time, much less time affordable. But it's like also needs to be, you know, you need to care about to be well connected and all that stuff. So I think when you have the proper, like you mentioned, electricity option, it's always good to have the idea to spend it on some miner and later you will need to choose what kind of miner.
1:08:09If you have the option to put loud miner like Antminer, you should go for that and just stack some sats from that free electricity. Of course, you have many calculators, so you count that and to be sure and you need to remember about that, you should to put into your have your finance in some kind of spreadsheet to maintain it. And because, you know, gathering the data, it's very important in every operation like that. But you need to be aware what's happening. So you also need to maintain it.
1:08:43So it's consumable. If you don't have the people who do it, you need to do it yourself. So you need to have a time and you need to have that option with electricity. If you have that, for sure, it's all accountable that you need to just invest in miner. And it's like you mentioned, depends what kind of situation you have. If you have a house and you have your house and you are also heating your water or you're heating your house by the proper system, you are able to buy that kind of miner that I mentioned.
1:09:18There is also many companies around the world who have approaches to that. But in general, that kind of option, it also needs to be counted because it's also a different approach. You need to count how much your house is using the power and how much the house is costing you, because you will be saving also on the cost of the house. So this is an approach for the families. So it's like, you know, everybody has an option to jump into the mining, but it needs to be in the right manner.
1:09:53And you need to just be aware that it costs you some time and some effort to set up or pay for some kind of company who will do that. So in general. I think this is like the first steps. And of course, later, according to the situation, you're buying the miner. If you are not able to buy ASIC miner or not have money, you're also able to think about some kind of GPU from the secondary market. And this is a little bit more harder way because you need to spend some more time to thinking about what kind of coin to mine to be more profitable and to just not adding to all the business because this is the theory of the game in mining, according to shitcoins and altcoins in general.
1:10:46So this is a little bit more harder, but the GPUs are much more quieter, so you're able to put it in much more places. But I also need to remember it will always bring the heart. So we always bring the heat. So try to use it. This is much more proper. So it's still not easy. It's still not easy. But right now you have proper options for payment or delivery and all that stuff that I remember when we were delivering the first Avalon. We go for the DHL pickup.
1:11:22It wasn't the pickup point, but it was the DHL warehouse that was the central for whole place in Poland that you have like the city and around of that. So and it's like, you know, we run that we go to get the phone that the package is there and run that because if not, it will be a day later. So, you know, we will have to do the things like that because one day it was like, you know, three bitcoins or something like that. So it was like a couple hundred dollars. So it was nice. Yeah.
1:12:05Vlad CosteaSometimes I think that it's comfortable for us to rely on the idea that geopolitics will make other places embrace Bitcoin mining. But at the same time, I think that as a Bitcoin user and someone who wants Bitcoin to succeed on the long term, we should all be ready to mine at one point to fire up some sort of device and secure the network just in case everything else fails. And stuff goes wrong with Bitcoin mining worldwide. It gets banned on a larger scale or whatever. We should be prepared to mine with our laptops or whatever, or at least have a device, maybe not the BiFury devices that you produced.
1:12:50I'm not sure how efficient they are in comparison with modern processors, but still be prepared with something.
1:12:55Filip PawczyńskiYeah, for sure. I think we should be prepared with the knowledge, you know, about how to mine and what we need to use to mine. It's like in the real world, you should have, you know, knowledge, especially if you are walking to the woods or some kind of camps, how to start the fire. It's not easy, it's not super common, but you should have to know that if you are walking for some kind of long walks and other stuff, because it's normal for that kind of people, but it's also common.
1:13:37So, yeah, it should be mining, creating the full nodes, Lightning Network nodes right now. There are many different layers that we should engage ourselves and people around to set up that. Yeah, you know, businesses, it's natural that they should have nodes and they should have nodes and we know why. So it's like, you know, many different layers and all of that should to be also known. And yeah, this is true. This is true. There is right now, there's many options, you know, to create from Raspberry Pi or other computer, like very fast node and all that stuff.
1:14:17It's a little bit of trade off or some kind of option, but it's better than nothing. Yeah. So we also have that kind of phase that we are going to the easy way, because when we go further, we can go that full way. You know, it's always like that. I remember also before approaches with the SPV was like normal, they are right now also use it. But, you know, custodians also have best ways from the OK, we're using custodians because it's useful. And right now it's like we should, everybody, we should do not custodian.
1:14:52And this is it's also some time to grow and to mature. And I think with mining and noding in general in like, you know, that hardware piece of the network will also have the time. More people will come because, you know, they will not have the opportunity to work with the software like I don't have from the beginning. But they will have option to work with the hardware and then they will mine with everything.
1:15:22Vlad CosteaSo let me ask you this. If you possessed the knowledge that you have now, 10 years ago, when you started your business with mining, what would you change or do differently?
1:15:33Filip PawczyńskiWell, you know, a couple of things, you know, a couple of things. But I think the most things that I will change, it wasn't on it wasn't about the device. It wasn't about the approach, because I think it was all that I was able to get in that period of time. But, you know, approach to the things that I wasn't know then about, you know, sales, about the approach to the people, about approach to the making orders and all that stuff. This was something new to me.
1:16:09So definitely the stuff like that. And of course, I will just more eager myself to orange pill more people, because, you know, I was many I was doing many conferences, I was doing many different, you know, creating many content in that time. You know, it was like more about the real meetings and about the conferences and about some, you know, talk with the experts and all that stuff, than providing the daily content like it's right now. So right now it's better because you have opportunity to get that knowledge, you know, in a very nice way.
1:16:49Before it was a little bit more difficult because it was the geek stuff. It's like it wasn't, you know, that kind of adoption. So not that many people want to listen about that. But in some areas, yeah, yeah, it was many people around that.
1:17:10Vlad CosteaSo you're saying that you wish you produced more education for the people around you with YouTube videos or whatever?
1:17:14Filip PawczyńskiI think more centralized, maybe not centralized. It's not a good word. More centric. Like, you know, I was always like, OK, I talk to I talk with the people who have opportunity that I don't have. And I wasn't like, you know, I wasn't like orange pill them. I was telling them about that. I was asking the question, but I was very polite and nice. And it was just not, you know, but I right now know that I should to have that orange pill. Just, you know, push it in the throat because it will be good and proper for me, for them and for home, for community, for example.
1:17:56You know, I was always, I think, more polite than than than toxic. And I should to be toxic in some times. So I will change that. But in general, you know, many things should maybe not to should to be, but can be done different. But it was also, you know, something because we started from nothing and we ended in the Ministry of Digital Affairs. We have our it wasn't the certification, but it was the canon of good practice of cryptocurrency business in Poland. So, you know, we have that kind of approach from community.
1:18:35But we ended, you know, on exile. But because of that. But right now we are getting back and there is right now there is new opportunities. So that's why that's why I'm thinking that, you know, the work for the adoption is a very, very long process. And I just know that from that last 10 years that it will be even longer than anybody thinks. So, you know, in this year we have 10 years of Polish Bitcoin Association that I am chairman. So we started in 2013. Later in 2018, we started the Chamber of Commerce.
1:19:17So it's like we have the opportunities right now. We just searching new projects and new cooperation because, you know, we need to build up the community. And like you was able to see in Warsaw, we are starting with that kind of projects and some kind of conferences and small meetups and bigger meetups. So, yeah, we are also working and we also will be on BTC Prague. So definitely that definitely we will see each other there.
1:19:47Vlad CosteaAll right, Filip. So what do you have there on in front of the camera?
1:19:53Filip PawczyńskiSo this is this is the miner. This is BiFury. This is the miner that I produce. And it's not very big. We're creating that on the shape of USB Erupter from ASICMiner. It's the perfect shape, but it's a little bit more bulky because we have a radiator here. But it's not very big and it has two Bitfury chips. So two and a half gigahashes each. They should be five gigahashes. Yeah, it should be five gigahashes. But the model was named five gigahashes, but it came like two and a half.
1:20:43Vlad CosteaThat's a nice fact. Are these still up for sale somewhere?
1:20:51Filip PawczyńskiThe BiFurys? No. Right now I have just a couple of them. I don't know, maybe ten pieces. Most of them already still work, of course. But it's like, you know, I'm not selling it. It's a token of appreciation. But when I will be in Prague, I will bring you one of that.
1:21:14Vlad CosteaOh, I appreciate it. Because they're like lottery tickets nowadays. You run them and you hope for the best.
1:21:18Filip PawczyńskiYeah, it's like, yeah, for sure. But, you know, Con Kolivas, so the creator of the CGMiner, it's running his pool and his pool is working like solo mining. So you are able to get the blocks. And I think the lowest hash rate from last year or something like that was about 100 gigahashes to get the solo mining block. So five gigahashes is a little bit too small to get to statistics. But in general, when will be the situation like you mentioned, that they will be power offing and cutting the hashing power, it will be still five gigahashes. And working for USB. So yeah, it can be, you know, behind the "break me if needed" glass.
1:22:19Vlad CosteaSo let me ask you more about your current work, because I feel like I got a lot of information from you, but you did not get the chance to talk about what you're doing in Bitcoin these days. You mentioned something about the Polish Bitcoin Association, and I guess you also have a few businesses.
1:22:36Filip PawczyńskiYeah, for sure. You know, in 2013, we started Polish Bitcoin Association because of the needs of, you know, connecting ourselves and showing ourselves like a community, not like a separate businesses because it was too small. And we also need to have some kind of body who will, you know, go publicly and talk about the mistakes and errors that some kind of, you know, professors and doctors was telling sometimes even in media about Bitcoin. So we need to we have that clarification role because we also have, you know, professors and doctors in our board and all that stuff.
1:23:14So it's like, yeah, we was working there. And I, of course, in that time, I was still selling the miners and start to producing also the software for in general for payment processing company on, of course, on Bitcoin. And later we also add the Litecoin there. And we also have the software and have it right now also for the exchanges. So since there we have the clients and sell the start to also selling the software. And right now, in 2000, of course, later was that episode in Ministry of Digital Affairs in 2016.
1:23:54And in 2018, when the whole community was, you know, throughout Poland because the commission of financial authority in Poland. So the financial authority in Poland just put most of the companies, the crypto companies in Poland, just put them on the warning list. And because of that, all the companies just lose the bank accounts. And because they have thinking that the companies was running without the license from them. So it was in 2018, it was the end of that kind of normal working of the business, crypto businesses in Poland.
1:24:42Because since then, there is a problem with the bank accounts in general. And this is the point of the pressure. So if you are working with crypto, your bank account will be not open in Poland or you will be not able to run it after some time that they will just spot it. So this is the general of the situation. So we have that kind of problems. And from 2018, I moved myself to Switzerland to Zug. And right now, from 2018, living between Switzerland to Zug and Warsaw and working on a couple of different projects like advisor.
1:25:20I'm just not taking a big stake in any project, just choosing the project that I want to work with. And right now I'm working according to Bitcoin on some Ordinals product. This is the fresh topic that we have. So this is also interesting because we have cooperation with my company, have a cooperation with the big brand in sport. And we have just utility for that. So we want to create the digital asset based on that brand. And the Ordinals are just natural for us. So this is one of the examples of the project.
1:26:04I have also a company that I'm working also with that one startup that is creating the Lightning wallet. But this is something small, but in Poland. So we are so eager to work there. And of course, I'm working also with the gaming, with the one company to create the digital economy around gaming and entertainment industry in general. So I'm also working with the gaming marketplaces and provide them the opportunities to create the digital economy and some kind of common assets or the approach for the digital assets in gaming.
1:26:52In general, the approach not in Bitcoin, but in gaming. And right now, because of the projects like ZBD, we have many opportunities to also integrate the Lightning payments and in general, Lightning wallets in games. So this is also a project and I'm also working in that scope, for example, according to the connection with the gaming. And of course, we are still trying and running the association and the Chamber of Commerce that we started in 2018. We are preparing ourselves to MiCA and just want to cooperate according to that we have with the companies that will be able to provide and to start the services in Poland.
1:27:46So this is the idea according to the Polish business opportunity, according to crypto and blockchain in general, because it's like they're not looking on what kind of, but if it's Bitcoin, it's something else. They're just looking on the connection to the exchanges. So this is very crucial right now here.
1:28:11Vlad CosteaYou mentioned something about gaming and I should have guessed when you mentioned in the beginning of the interview something about going from Starcraft to poker. Are you into video games? And if you are, how does it make sense to integrate a type of currency that cannot be controlled by the developer? Because I actually got to talk to John Romero, the creator of Doom, and I tried to pitch him the Lightning Network for games. And he was like, why would anyone want that? Because every company can create their own virtual currency in the game and have control over that and sell it themselves.
1:28:50And why should anyone want to use a third party global currency over which they have zero control?
1:29:00Filip PawczyńskiYeah, yeah, that's true. That's true. You know, it's like gaming. It's like I'm in the gaming camp. Of course, I was, you know, in my time you mentioned about the Doom. I think the Doom was first FPP shooter back in 90, I don't remember, 92, 94, 93 it was, or 91 it was, I don't remember. But I remember that to play it, so I remember the game very good. I, of course, go of the games and of the software parts to the hardware, like I mentioned before with the networking.
1:29:33But of course, I always remember the games and always like the economic, you know, approaches in the game. And like so, you know, I remember Civilization 2 when I was playing. I don't remember how many years ago it was. But I was to remember that it was something that very eagerly that, yeah, that kind of economies. But, you know, you can just creating your own economies. And I was always with that. But right now, well, you know, I'm like after two years working with the gaming industry and I see that they're still very early to understanding how they are able to unleash the potential of that, you know, connecting the economy in the games with the open economy.
1:30:18And like you mentioned, I also don't see that. And I properly know because creating the games for entertainment and creating the games for the economical approach is totally two different things. And you also need to know how to create the economy. From the outside of the system, so in the open economy, to combine it between itself. So this is like at least two different sets of the skills to create the games and create the economy. You know, so it's like especially connected with the open economy. So this is most the problem.
1:30:56But, you know, I see many opportunities that they are able to provide better services in the meaning of the service for the users with technology, you know, that it will be under the hood. And in some time it will just grow naturally with the need of the gamers. This is the approach that I am eager and I see that because this is the approach of the this is how the gamers are approaching and what they want. They right now trying to get that when they will build their own profile in some game and they will be able to put it out of that game.
1:31:36And nobody will control it. It will be in the blockchain. They understand that they will spend some time, they will create the character and now nobody will be able to take that on one site, another site. They will be able to profit from that because they will be able to sell it. In market for operation, like from hand to hand, not by that some kind of, you know, allowance from creators or the developers or distribution. So they start to understand that. But, you know, the payments and the currencies and all that stuff, it's not that way right now.
1:32:19And I totally understand that for sure. They just need that time. But, of course, if you connect... It was mentioning about the Litecoins, but if you connected... Sorry, Litecoins. Satoshis, yeah? So if you connected the satoshis to the game and you were just playing the game and giving that satoshi for your time, it's like, you know, you are also watching the commercials in some of the games. So it's more like value to value approach. And this is also a different thing to teach to the people. What kind of value to value system is working and why you are making and doing some things and getting additional satoshi for that.
1:33:03This is like totally different approach for the game itself. But, you know, paying with the satoshi in the game, it's something that Romero wouldn't understand. And sure, the game would have its own asset, but it should have its price also in crypto. This is the swap point. It's the enter to the economy. When the economy is mixed, when you want to have that step, you need to be prepared to that. Like a game developer, like a community of that game needs to be prepared for that kind of step.
1:33:39Because if not, it will not have any additional profits or additional pros from that. So, you know, games are very much from the theory of the game. You need to work with gamers like they like to and just, you know, maybe not trick them, but give them what they need. But build opportunities for you, like developing the future approach under and beneath that. And this is something that I know from experience.
1:34:13Vlad CosteaYeah. So the reason why you don't see me right now is that my camera died and I'm going to recharge a little bit. But I was thinking right now that there is an example in the gaming industry that came out very early. And it allowed people to trade in-game items and in-game characters with each other peer to peer. It was Pokemon Red and Blue on the Game Boy. If you had one cable to connect to Game Boys, you could transact Pokemons from one device to the other.
1:34:47And that was one way in which you could have this economy where players were transacting items from one to the other. Of course, MMORPGs are another example where you have these in-game economies and the players dynamically interact with each other and make trades. But the issue, I think, is that they rely on centralized servers. Your items are only going to be there for as long as someone maintains the server and keeps it online. And also, you're not able to save anything of what you have. And the currency is also controlled by, for example, the World of Warcraft developers.
1:35:31If you have a lot of gold, it might be super valuable right now, but you know nothing about the monetary policy of the server. At one point in the future, they might create more inflation. So there are lots of uncertainties there. And I can see why there is some value in putting this data about what you have on some public decentralized ledger. I'm not sure if it's a good idea to put it on the Bitcoin blockchain directly. Maybe with ordinals, but even that doesn't really scale. But, you know, it's still super interesting.
1:36:10Filip PawczyńskiYeah, I think, you know, that the topics like that will be covered in some, you know, some type of assets like Taro or others. So I think it will be much more complicated, but we still need to unleash the power of the technology and just make it much more easier for all the development. So this is the topic also that we are going, you know, the adoption is also going from the people who are able to use the code and integrate the tools. So, yeah, this is one of the crucial things.
1:36:49But the opportunities right now, you know, it's like it's not a problem to do that in some kind of way that it will be working. And, you know, always have the idea to put that also on the blockchain layer later. Because if you integrate the payment of the Bitcoin or of course the Lightning right now, it's most proper, you already have the expansion to that. So it's only always about how you want to, you know, develop your system further.
1:37:21Vlad CosteaYeah. And something interesting that happened this year, I guess a lot of Bitcoiners are unhappy about Ordinals inscriptions. But they proved that the way that we use Bitcoin can still be disrupted to some extent. Because what happened after that is that some people who did not care much about the store of value or sound money function of Bitcoin came to Bitcoin because they wanted to do collectibles.
1:37:51Filip PawczyńskiYeah, sure. Yeah, of course. Of course. You know, it's also a way of adoption. And it's like, you know, on the other way, like I mentioned before, it's the theory itself, it's created in that way that it's very organic and natural interpretation of the data that you already have in the blockchain. So it's something that's really growing, you know, on the network. And we have a technology of inscription to just, you know, use it properly. But in general, it's, in my vision case, then great work to create a system that's very useful for Bitcoin in general.
1:38:31And it's providing very much output on the different layers like adoption on one side, you know, adoption of the new people that, like you mentioned, don't, you know, thinking about monetary base, but wants to have that kind of base in usage. You know, I remember last year in Baltic Honeybadger, Dan Held told, you know, told that the Bitcoin, it's poker. And we right now have many different games in that casinos, you know, NFTs, it's a blackjack and all that stuff. So I remember it because it's showing us that, you know, everybody have own game.
1:39:09And it's like we don't shoot to, it's open protocol. So when you are not, you know, disrupting the protocol in that way, it's not able to work anymore. But you are using the natural idea to interpret the data and you are not changing it in that way. It's something natural and that kind of disruptive way, like you mentioned, it will be in the future for sure. Because, you know, Taproot will give many more opportunities and many more different approaches that we are not know right now. So, yeah, definitely is disruptive and it should to be like that because it's another different layer of the security.
1:39:54And, you know, the more the more the more stuff we have in this in this world to attract more people, it will just bring more adoption. And adoption is always healthy because, you know, it's always healthy.
1:40:13Vlad CosteaNow, at the same time, I saw a lot of people who are not happy about the way in which Bitcoin is being used, as they were hoping that Taproot and SegWit and everything else would not bring collectibles to Bitcoin, but make people open more lightning channels, do multisig setups and stuff like that, which sounds more conservative.
1:40:38Filip PawczyńskiYeah, I know. I know. I was also, like I mentioned before, I was also thinking that it will be more, you know, nodes, more people who are who is running, you know, software, more people who are using wallet properly and all that stuff. I was thinking also that after, you know, 10 years, it will be more. But, you know, we have other competitors like, you know, shitcoins on the market and they have many people bring on the market and go from the shitcoin to Bitcoin. It's also a way, how is it in, you know, in general, in society, people are just trying to learn on their mistakes.
1:41:17If they are not learning, they will just not survive on some point or they will be just controlling, like many other people, letting their self-control about the government work and, you know, family and all that stuff. So we need a couple, I think couple, because I think one episode right now, it will be not enough, according to that, you know, possibly to maintain the information by the government media and all that stuff. So I think the couple events in the financial world will be needed, you know, some melt off on some big currency or something like that.
1:41:58Then we'll go the hyperbitcoinization and then we'll be more people that the people will be able to teach them. And we will also see that time like that for sure. But I still don't know when it will be. You know, 10 years ago, I was thinking that it will be like 100 years. But right now, I think it's like, you know, maybe next 10 years, maybe next 20 years, maybe in next 50 years. But I think it will be faster according to what happened right now and in the global economy and, you know, with banking and all the debt, all the situation, even according to the, you know, political stability and peace in general.
1:42:49Vlad CosteaYeah. And you basically foreshadowed my question. I was about to ask you how you see Bitcoin in the next 10 years based on what you saw this past decade. But I guess you provided a pretty good answer without even this question. So I'm going to ask you also, how can people follow you and keep up with your work?
1:43:10Filip PawczyńskiYou know, it's like I'm on Twitter. I also LinkedIn, but I have my pawczynski.pl web page when there is all my social there. You have a Nostr there, you have LinkedIn, you have Twitter. So I'm trying to be on the Twitter and on the Nostr. I'm starting to be also on the Nostr. And of course, everybody can find me also on Telegram at @Filip because I was very early with the telegram. So I was I have that option to get my name, like my handle.
1:43:51So you can just contact me if you wanted. I, of course, will be if I will be able to answer, I will be always to help. And of course, I also trying to be in some kind of conferences, mostly Bitcoin conferences around Europe. So I am available in general. So if somebody wants to have a contact or have some ideas or some comments to what I told and what the thinking that I have after the 10 years, I'm very happy to discuss some topics and also always to talk. So you can always find me in my social and I will just give Vlad the link. But it's like pawczynski.pl.
1:44:39Vlad CosteaI'm going to put that in the description of the video on YouTube. So thank you very much, Filip. And I look forward to seeing you in Prague at BTC Prague, where I'm going to show you the magazine on which I'm working, which, by the way, is open source. So anyone around the world can download it, can print it, can sell it to make money off of it. It doesn't matter. It's going to be called Breaking FUD. And it takes some of 10 of the most popular misconceptions or FUD about Bitcoin and explains why it's wrong and whether or not there's some truth in it.
1:45:18Filip PawczyńskiGreat. Great. I will be more than happy to read it. And of course, you know, to put some some some kind of effort from my side, I will be very pleased, of course. And later when you will set it up, we also will be very happy to translate it to Polish and to just, you know, put it in our community also in Polish language.
1:45:41Vlad CosteaNo, I would love that. Last year I had it in French and Spanish, and it was successful not necessarily in France and Spain. It was successful in Dakar. I need to figure out which country it is to my real shame.
1:46:00Filip PawczyńskiIn Morocco, I think, or in general in Saharan countries. I don't know if it's in one.
1:46:08Vlad CosteaYou're thinking about Dakar, yeah, Senegal. Yeah, I was thinking about that. Yeah, there's that rally, Paris-Dakar, which takes place in lots of countries. But it was popular there with the French edition and with the Spanish edition, it was super popular in Argentina. I had 200 copies at LaBitConf and it was also super popular in El Salvador. So I look forward to having more translations because it's sad when the education about Bitcoin is so abundant in English, but it escapes all of these areas where a lot of this information gets through and a lot of shitcoiners take advantage of the situation to step in and tell stories that are borrowed from Bitcoin.
1:46:58But about the shitcoin that they created, that's how they scare people.
1:47:03Filip PawczyńskiYeah, it was with many that kind of project that I did not mention the name, but it was in Poland also. Before 2015, I think we had like two or three that kind of projects in Europe that we were also fighting like an association to show the differences. So, yeah, I definitely know what you mentioned. This is also very needed. We are also trying to do that, but it's all about the operational and the companies that are here to help our effort.
1:47:35Vlad CosteaYeah, of course. What I can offer with the magazine is that after each article, I leave a page for an advertisement and someone who forks the magazine from GitHub or whatever can take it and talk to companies to advertise and get some revenue from that. So that they can make some money to print it, to produce it, to spread it, do whatever.
1:48:02Filip PawczyńskiGreat, great, great. For sure, I will be very happy to work on that on behalf of ours and, of course, the Polish community.
1:48:13Vlad CosteaThank you very much, Filip, and I'll see you in Prague.
1:48:17Filip PawczyńskiYeah, thank you very much, Vlad. See you in Prague and thank you very much all for your time. Have a great day and see you in Prague.
1:48:31Ad voiceoverAre you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.
1:49:34Cryptosteel are innovators in Bitcoin cold storage. Back in 2013, they launched the Cryptosteel Cassette, which made it easy to back up your seed phrase, passphrase or any other form of private key on the sturdy metal which resists water, fire and earthquakes. Today, Cryptosteel offers the Motherlode, an all-in-one box which endows you with everything you need to become financially sovereign. Inside of the Motherlode, you get a Cryptosteel Capsule and a hardware wallet of your choice. All Cryptosteel products are engineered and manufactured in Poland. Order your Cryptosteel metal backup system today on cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR at checkout for a 10% discount on your first order.
1:50:31Cryptosteel, secure your wallet seed phrase. Are you a writer, photographer, musician or video creator who is trying to generate some revenue? Bumbee is the Bitcoin way to monetize your content. It's more censorship resistant than any other platform of its kind with a low and flat one-time fee of 10%. Bumbee is as easy to use as any social media mobile application. Sign up today at Bumbee.com and subscribe for free to the Bitcoin Takeover account to get access to some time-exclusive content. If you are monetizing your creativity, why not get paid in Bitcoin for it? Bumbee.com, the Bitcoin way to monetize your content.
1:51:34Shopping with your Bitcoin on the internet is easy. ShopinBit is Europe's biggest Bitcoin store with over 800,000 products, ranging from Bitcoin books, toothpaste, mobile phones, computers and watches. This month, I bought a Nintendo Game & Watch console with the classic Legend of Zelda and it arrived in only five working days. And if you can't find what you're looking for, ShopinBit has got you covered. Their concierge service will get you anything and ship it worldwide. Additionally, they also have a travel hacking service that can get you the best deals on all things travel, flights, hotels and more.
1:52:24For business and for vacations. Bitcoin Takeover listeners get a nice discount, of course. Use code BTCTKVR on your first order for a one-time 5 euro discount. For more details, go to ShopinBit.com. ShopinBit, Europe's biggest Bitcoin store.
1:52:24================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Remote video interview. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization (Vlad Costea and Filip Pawczyński; ads were labelled as Vlad). Second opinion: YouTube auto-captions of the published video (UPwXBUED3Og, English original track 'en-orig', fetched read-only with yt-dlp; offset about +0.2 to +0.6 s, steady across the episode), word-aligned to the ASR; about 850 non-filler word differences reviewed. No other local second-opinion transcript exists for this episode. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed from the published mp3 with local faster-whisper (medium.en, int16) on 49 short clips (about 18 minutes); speaker turns checked with local TitaNet speaker embeddings on 13 short windows (references: Vlad's stored voiceprint, Vlad at 18:56-19:26, Filip at 3:00-3:50). 0:00-0:50 is intro music. Restored dropped passages: the opening words 'Hello there and' (00:51) and the first sentence of the Wasabi Wallet ad at 38:04 ('Are you concerned ... mega CoinJoins'), plus 'for a one-time 5 euro discount' in the closing ShopinBit ad; removed a trailing repeated 'Bumbee.com, the Bitcoin way to monetize your content.' after the final ad (not in the audio). Speaker fixes: turn-initial words moved to the right speaker at 08:46 ('So, yeah.' is Filip), 09:02 ('You know, it's like all starts' is Filip), 21:02, 1:00:05 ('Yeah, it makes sense right now' is Vlad), 1:12:55 ('but still be prepared with something' is Vlad), 1:15:20 ('So let me ask you this.' is Vlad), 1:17:06 ('So you're saying that you wish you produced more' is Vlad), 1:21:11 ('Oh, I appreciate it.' is Vlad), 1:29:00 and 1:37:50 ('Yeah, sure.' is Filip); 1:20:27 'They should be five gigahashes' stays with Filip (embedding match); ads relabelled 'Ad voiceover' (Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, Bumbee, ShopinBit from 38:04 and from 1:48:31). Notable fixes: Bitfury USB asset miner -> BiFury USB ASIC miner (product name per show notes; Bitfury for the chips); USB A6 -> USB ASICs; Ant Miners -> Antminers; Crypto Steel -> Cryptosteel (Wojtek Stopiński); software -> Softwar (Jason Lowery's book), Laurie -> Lowery; Bitcoin talk -> Bitcointalk; monies -> miners; Spartans FPGAs -> Spartan FPGAs; change more -> Cairnsmores (Cairnsmore1 FPGA miners, audio 'Chainsmores'); I think miners -> ASICMiner; K&C miner -> KnCMiner; lighting -> Litecoin (21:12) / Lightning elsewhere; thousands of the details -> thousands of the Bitcoin; weeks/risk -> rigs; two-stroke tariff -> two-zone tariff (Polish 'taryfa dwustrefowa'); wrappers -> reports; slash pool -> Slush Pool, Marek (Palatinus) and Stratum, Bitcoin -> BitcoinCZ (audio 'Bitcoin CZ'); Stratton, too -> Stratum V2; low changes in taxes -> law changes in Texas; stats -> sats; the coordinator -> Ordinal Theory; original -> Ordinals; DDAO -> the DAO; proof of state -> proof of stake; sources of thought -> sources of FUD; bull canal bonds -> volcano bonds; alike and miner -> like Antminer; size -> sats; war house -> warehouse; bifuriate -> BiFury; orange peel -> orange pill; history of digital affairs / Ministry of Social Affairs -> Ministry of Digital Affairs; Eruptor from Aztec miner -> Erupter from ASICMiner; Konukovilas / CG miner -> Con Kolivas / CGMiner; ZDD -> ZBD; Mika -> MiCA; Tarot -> Taro; technology of description -> technology of inscription; Baltic Horny Badger -> Baltic Honeybadger; landing -> learning; Noster -> Nostr; Pavchinski.pl / Povchinsky.pl -> pawczynski.pl; Telegram at Philip -> @Filip; Philip -> Filip; La Bitconf -> LaBitConf. Filip's non-native phrasing is kept as spoken. Remaining doubtful words are marked ... (12 marks). Ad reads were normalized to the sponsor copy used in other corrected episodes of this season.