Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S13 E14 / Transcript
Transcript · S13 E14 · 1:18:53 · 27 Apr 2023

S13 E14: Slava Zhygulin & Nick Schteringard on Stroom Network and Increasing Lightning Liquidity

With Slava Zhygulin, Nick Schteringard. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:52Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad and my guests today are working on a super interesting Lightning project, which is called Stroom. They are from Ukraine and their names are Nick and Slava. We're going to talk about Bitcoin. We're going to talk about Lightning and about bridging all of these concepts to DeFi for whatever reason. So hi, Nick and Slava. It's really nice to finally interview you.

1:20Nick SchteringardHi. Hi, Vlad. Thanks for having us. It's an honor to be on a Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. Yeah, let's do this. Let's talk about it.

1:30Vlad CosteaNo, the honor is on my side, because I very much enjoy introducing projects that are new and unusual and interesting to Bitcoiners. And you guys have decided that you want to increase the liquidity on the Lightning Network, but the way in which you decided to do it is rather unorthodox and, I guess, uncharted from this point of view, as nobody else has attempted to. So I'm going to let you talk about Stroom.

1:58Slava ZhygulinYes, great. Thank you for having us here. So, yeah, so Stroom is super interesting project that our friend came up with this idea. So it was done basically due to the fact that Lightning Network depends on the amount of liquidity that there is inside the Lightning Network. So if there is more liquidity in it, then like higher volumes of payments can be processed and the robustness is better. So success rate for payments is better. So we were thinking about how we actually can boost it. And then we figure out the fact that actually people, Bitcoin users, they, a lot of them bridging Bitcoins to use it in DeFi, and they will need to use it as a collateral and to earn some yields on top of that.

2:58And the amount of these Bitcoins is huge. It's like 400,000 Bitcoins was bridged previous year, and this year is slightly lower. It's like 150,000. Yeah, so we decided how we can actually return these Bitcoins back to Lightning to Bitcoin ecosystem. And we came up with the idea of Stroom. So basically Stroom is like a bridge combined with the liquid staking derivative approach, which allows users to actually bridge their Bitcoins in Ethereum to Ethereum. But then those physical Bitcoins that are usually stored on cold storage or bridge, they are delegated to Lightning Network.

3:46And that huge amount of liquidity is then used to boost Lightning Network liquidity. And yeah, and this liquidity can generate some yields, which is coming from routing fees from Lightning Network. And we distribute these fees back to users. So that's additional yields on top of that user can achieve just using DeFi. So it's clear competitive advantage over existing bridges. And yeah, so we hope to cannibalize market share of bridges Bitcoins to Ethereum and actually boost Lightning with that.

4:29Vlad CosteaSo how does this work? When let's say that you have WBTC, which is wrapped BTC by BitGo. That's the way that people access DeFi and Ethereum with their Bitcoin. How do you actually supply that to provide liquidity to the Lightning Network?

4:49Slava ZhygulinYes, so WBTC is our biggest competitor here. So WBTC, it's like semi-centralized solution. It's actually like more centralized. So it's like a custody. So there is a company that is keeping these Bitcoins that people deposited to WBTC and these Bitcoins on Bitcoin side are stored in cold storage.

5:20And yeah, and this is a single company that basically mints WBTC in corresponding amounts on Ethereum side. So we're kind of removing the centralized custody here. We're building like a federation or DAO that will be in charge of minting procedures. And then there is another step, like instead of storing the Bitcoins in cold storage, the federation is, or the DAO is then opening the channels. Basically, it has a routing LN hub, Lightning Network hub. So this hub is funded from those Bitcoins. So the federation opens the channel with the outer Lightning Network.

6:11So we become one or several bigger routing hubs, like similar to, I don't know, like LNBig or something like that. And yeah, and then we just route payments.

6:29Vlad CosteaOkay, so technically, it's not very complicated, but it seems like you're going to have your own wrapped BTC token.

6:38Slava ZhygulinYeah, yeah, yeah. So we create our own version, which then need to be integrated in DeFi. So there is actually a demand for that. Yeah. Yeah, so technically, it's really not that like the idea is pretty straightforward. But actually, implementation details are not that straightforward. And the reason for that is because we don't want to be like single point of failure. So we don't want to have a single entity that actually controls all funds. So we were like, for a year figuring out how we can build this solution.

7:20As decentralized as possible. Yeah, honestly speaking, it is not like fully decentralized Bitcoin, of course. Yeah, but we try to do our best here, and also as transparent as possible. So people always can track money flows. And they always can see what's the total supply of Bitcoins that we have and total supply of, we call it LNBTC, which is wrapped version of Bitcoin. On Ethereum. So there is no like, inflation of token supply from thin air.

7:58Vlad CosteaIt sounds to me as if you're building a staking pool. But for Lightning, did I get this correctly?

8:05Slava ZhygulinOh, yeah, it's a good analogy. But technically, it is very different from the staking pool.

8:16Vlad CosteaBecause you require two different networks. Is that why it's different?

8:20Slava ZhygulinYeah, like ordinary, like, for example, in DeFi on Ethereum, staking pools. They basically collect all tokens in a single address, in a single smart contract address. And then those, this pool somehow, like operates. And, for example, if it is a market, money market, then people lending money from this pool. Yeah. And, but in our solution, we actually have a bunch of multi-signature addresses on Bitcoin side. And for every individual user, it is a single address or several addresses, but which is important that for every user, it is like a separate address.

9:07And we have this set of multi-signature addresses that is controlled by Federation in multi-signature way. Yeah. And yeah, and then from from these addresses, we fund Lightning Network channels. Yeah, and the Lightning Network part happening completely without the liquidity depositor interaction. So if you just want to receive some yields based on Lightning Network routing fees, but you don't want to run any infrastructure, so you can use our solution. Yeah, you can just deposit bitcoins to our DAO. And yeah, and then we will take a small cut on the revenue generated from your bitcoins because we need to incentivize infrastructure providers.

9:57And yeah, you receive, you receive yields on top of that. So it's kind of like staking for Lightning. Yeah, it's really very similar. But technically, it's much, much more different, much different, very different.

10:12Vlad CosteaSo as you said, there is no token inflation. It's all one-to-one to your Bitcoin. But at the same time, what's the revenue model? How do you make money off of this?

10:22Slava ZhygulinYeah, yeah. So it's really super important to have a one-to-one ratio always to maintain that. And because like, recent events... Yeah, it's like, in my opinion, it's just more fair. It's like how it should be. But recent events with Celsius, for example, showed that... So Celsius is a company that provides yields on your Bitcoins. Yeah, so the events with Celsius showed that if there is no transparency, you actually can't see what's going on with your liquidity. And it can be the situation that there is, like your obligation is much higher than you actually have in your treasury.

11:07So Celsius collapsed, people lost money. We want to avoid it at all costs. So yeah, that's why we always want to have... to maintain one-to-one backing. And we do it by allowing users to redeem their LNBTC to physical Bitcoins on the Bitcoin chain. Always. So they always can do the redemption. Yeah, and I... Sorry, what was your second question?

11:40Vlad CosteaNow, let me get to something which I think is more important than the second part of my question. Why do you compare Stroom to Celsius? Why is that the point of reference?

11:51Slava ZhygulinBecause there is not too many companies or solutions that can provide yields on top of Bitcoin. Like the solution in the box. I mean, yeah, sure, you can wrap your Bitcoin to WBTC and then deposit it to some pools on, I don't know, Curve, for example, or other DeFi projects like Compound, and start receiving some yields. But that's like additional steps from the users that they need to take. And Celsius was the solution there, where users can just deposit Bitcoins and start receiving the yields. So the business model is similar, I would say.

12:40But the technical realization, of course, is very different. Yeah. So that's a centralized company that provides yields on top of Bitcoin. We are a decentralized DAO that also provides yields on top of Bitcoin. And we fully transparent here. But what was going on with Celsius? I don't know. I don't know how they use the Bitcoins. Yeah. So comparison here is only in terms of business model, I would say.

13:08Vlad CosteaYeah. So right now I need to also engage Nick because I don't want him to feel like he only came here for the picture or something. So, Nick, what is your contribution to the Stroom project and what is it that you do? Because you're the one who set up this interview. You're the one with whom I have been interacting. And now you're quiet.

13:28Nick SchteringardYeah, thanks. So disclaimer, I'm not in the Stroom core team. So I'm the CEO of Boosty Venture Studio, and we are investor into Stroom. And yeah, my contribution is that I believe this is the next big thing for Lightning Network, for Bitcoin. And, yeah. So if we take one step back here and talk about why people will use it and why it's interesting for Bitcoiners. Personally, I think that the fact that people bridge their Bitcoins into Ethereum or other chains means that they seek some capital efficiency.

14:22So they seek to make some yield on their Bitcoins. The same is with Celsius, with any centralized exchange when you can deposit your Bitcoin and allow the centralized exchange to lend it to other actors. That a lot of retail users, they would like to have exposure to make some yields on top of Bitcoin. So I know that there are more hardcore Bitcoiners that they think that the self custody is the only way. But yes, so we see that other people use such solutions. And we found a way how to provide these Bitcoins to Lightning Network to increase the liquidity and to make some public good.

15:18Because if it brings some adoption to Lightning Network, because of liquidity, it will be a public good. And yeah, that's why I believe in Stroom. So retail depositors will get their yields in Ethereum or whatever chain they choose. But on the other hand, they will contribute to Lightning Network because in our venture studio, which is completely Lightning focused, we believe that Lightning Network is the next global thing. It's meant for payments. And we see and we think that in a few years, Lightning Network will accrue all of the payment volumes from other chains.

16:09So I mean, all the transfers that are now made in USDT, on Tron blockchain, on Ethereum blockchain, they will migrate to Lightning Network in our opinion. Because Lightning Network was architectured in that way to be a payment network and Tron and Ethereum are not. So they are smart contract platforms that are good for things like Uniswap and some DeFi stuff. But Lightning Network is the most effective payment network that exists for now, in our opinion. So I may be wrong, but I believe so. And this network, in order to be robust and stable, this network needs more liquidity and this liquidity should be managed in a professional way.

17:09So it's not only about the amount of liquidity, but it's also about how you manage this liquidity and how you allocate this liquidity to payment channels so you can achieve a high success rate that is comparable to Visa, Mastercard. And personally, I'm very excited about Taro protocol and RGB protocol that will bring other assets to Lightning Network. Because I'm not really sure that many people, like retail people, will treat Bitcoin as a payment method in the near future. I think that they need more assets they used to count as a currency. So it's not like a maxi stance, but that's like a stance from reality. That's my point.

18:12Vlad CosteaYeah, but I guess we do need to have lots of payments on the base layer to maintain the security of the chain, as the mining rewards get reduced in half every cycle. Every 210,000 blocks you get this halving, which is a big event specifically because inefficient miners are getting phased out of the network and you're only going to have the cheapest and the most efficient form of energy that's going to survive. And that's why it's such a big deal. And that's why we also need on-chain payments.

18:50I guess we can take up most of these on-chain operations with Lightning channel openings. Maybe that you guys can help with this. But you mentioned something interesting there, Nick. And I have to ask a question about how you're going to manage and optimize these Lightning channels. Because the Lightning Network basically operates on the principle of independent islands that build roads from one to the other. You can have isolated islands that only have one or two roads to connect to make a few payments, or you can have large hubs to which everyone wants to connect.

19:25And you can optimize it to get to the largest amount of people, nodes or islands. You can use any metaphor to describe it. Or you can optimize to make only large payments between large players. So what's the strategy going to be in the case of Stroom?

19:48Nick SchteringardI will pass the word to Slava because it's kind of a technical question. So please, Slava, help me with that.

19:58Slava ZhygulinYeah, sure. Yeah, it's a very good question. In the end of the day, like all these islands, we call them hubs. They compete between each other for users. So users decide to route the payment through this island. And the user, when he makes a decision how to build the route, he keeps in mind two major factors. One is the payment fee. So the amount of fee you will be paying for that. And the second is the robustness of the route. So he doesn't want his payment to fail in the middle of the payment.

20:47Yeah, it's not a problem that the customer will not lose his money, but he can end up in this state where his money is stuck for a while. So that's why it's important to choose a robust island. Robust road. Yeah. So our aim here is to win customers. So our target is to provide the best service for the best price. So we can process a lot of volumes. And actually, I believe that the market will decide how the structure of Lightning will evolve. I mean, is it a very big set of small hubs or small islands?

21:40Or is it a small set of big islands? But actually, my opinion here is that this network will naturally evolve as a power-law network, much like internet did. And much like any network that is not governed in a centralized way, which is actually evolving in a people-governed way. Yeah, so I think it is okay to have a few large hubs and some big amount of smaller hubs. And yeah, when the network can process your payment, I believe it is not that important. Like how, what's the structure of network if the success rate of payment is 100%.

22:38Yeah, of course, we can speak here about the privacy. Because, yeah, privacy would be an issue for large hubs. If there is a small set of large hubs, then the privacy is an issue. But still, I believe that these two models can coexist. And if the user is super privacy focused, and he doesn't want to anyone to track their payments, then he can just exclude these big hubs from his route. And that's okay.

23:11Vlad CosteaYeah, that's certainly interesting, because we are still in the early days of the Lightning Network. There's still a lot to figure out about how this is going to be used. And it's up to us, the users, how it's going to evolve, right? Because it seems like too many users are into custodial services. And this leads to big hubs that open lots of channels to accommodate all of that use, use cases and activity. But at the same time, I think it's easier than ever to run a Lightning node for yourself at home on any computer, just install Linux on an old laptop, and you're going to have your own Lightning node that you can keep online 24/7.

23:55So that that's really cool. But at the same time, there's also the question of reliability, as even today, when the network has gotten a lot better than it was three years ago, or four years ago, there are still failed payments when you cannot find the proper route, or it gets delayed too much. And you don't know what's going on, and you have to wait. And that kind of defeats the purpose of the Lightning Network. But we have to discuss what's the purpose of the Lightning Network? Is it meant to be super decentralized and allow anyone to run a node?

24:29Or is it meant to be just a fast way to make payments? And it doesn't matter if big actors end up having the largest liquidity pools?

24:40Nick SchteringardLike, in short, I stick to the second answer, to the second theory. Because,

24:48Slava ZhygulinLike, yes, it's a payment rail, basically.

24:53Vlad CosteaBut at the same time, there's this economic problem. Of course, there's competition between big nodes. But there is this economic problem where at one point, you're going to want to make more money. And you can end up establishing cartels that raise the fees. And that's going to lead actually to a situation where you pay kind of the same fee on chain and on the Lightning Network. And what you pay for on Lightning is just speed, and maybe some reliability. But it's no longer... I had this case with BlueWallet, maybe two years ago, where I realized that they were charging me the exact same amount of Bitcoin for transaction, as I would have paid on the main chain.

25:41Slava ZhygulinNo, yeah, that's, I think it is not good. Yeah. My opinion here that Lightning, yeah, it's by design, it's a payment rail. But what is super important that is permissionless payment rail, anyone can open the channel. Permissionless is coming from the Bitcoin. Like you can set up a channel in Bitcoin and no one can stop you from doing that. Yeah. And so that basically will, I believe that will prevent cartels from appearing. I mean, just cartel will not be able to appear because, yeah, first of all, there is a price pressure on fee size from the above, like, you cannot charge more than on-chain fees.

26:39Because if you charge more than, of course, people will prefer to use it on-chain. So it's not logical to set up very high fees. And the second thing is that, which is coming from permissionless that I mentioned before, that, okay, if you set up, if you decide to build a cartel, and you even collude with some big hubs, and you decided to raise fees to some very high level. But then, always, some people will emerge, which will run their nodes, and they will set up their price lower so they can attract more traffic, and route more payments.

27:21So basically, those cartels will end up in a situation when there is no traffic. So they locked a lot of capital in their channels, but there is no traffic because there are more efficient ways, more efficient routes to pay. So it's open market. And it's nice to have a competition. And yeah, for sure, this competition will drive fees down. And I believe that Lightning Network fees will always be much, much lower than 0.1%, like lower than 0.1%.

27:57Vlad CosteaOkay, but do you see a future where you can sustain a business and grow only based on minimal fees? That means a lot of traffic, right?

28:09Slava ZhygulinYeah, yeah. So the beauty of Lightning is that you can turn over your capital, like often, maybe 100, 1000 times, several hundred times per year. And if you charge 0.1% fee, or 0.01% fee, like something like that. So you still can achieve like 3-5% APY. So 3-5% APY is really high for Bitcoin, because you're still exposed to Bitcoin price growth, and you'll receive additional 3% on top of that, which is like super nice. So 3%, like 3 or 5% would be very sustainable for people to continue to run this routing hubs or routing islands. Yeah. Nick, do you have any ideas on that?

29:11Nick SchteringardI think that, yes. So it's an open market. And when you don't have any regulation on the open market, it tends to monopoly always. So some big players, they tend to be a monopoly. And I think that those big nodes that were in Lightning Network from the very beginning, they will accrue a lot of traffic. And actually, they can raise fees. And I think if some independent players, like some retail players, will try to lower the fee and to get this traffic from them. So it's not always about the fee.

30:03It's also about the success rate and how reliable you are. And if these big players, so the cartel you mentioned, is a reliable routing partner for those using Lightning Network, that's okay. I don't think that even if Lightning fees will surpass on-chain fees, I don't think you should think of it as a bad fact. So it can happen. And there is nothing wrong with that. I think so. Because Lightning Network allows you to make millions of payments, right? And Bitcoin base blockchain will never allow you this speed and the number of transactions.

31:02So you always have, the Lightning Network always prevails over the base blockchain, not only because of fees, but because of scaling, right? So Bitcoin won't be a payment network, Lightning is.

31:26Vlad CosteaEven though I still want Bitcoin to be used for payments and to fill the blocks, because that's very much required, it's going to be interesting to see how this competing market of main chains, sidechains and second layers and third layers is going to end up. Because I guess people are going to always use the base layer for secure transactions and for stuff where they can wait and they don't care to have an immediate confirmation. And they're going to use second layers and sidechains for everything else. But let me ask you this, because Lightning Network is this two-way transaction system where if you want to make a transaction with someone or their peers, if you want to send them money, you open a channel with them.

32:16And if you want to be able to receive money from them, they need to open a channel with you. And my question for you right now is, Stroom obviously is going to open a lot of channels to enable people to send money through Stroom, but how do you incentivize nodes opening channels with Stroom?

32:38Slava ZhygulinYeah, that's a good question. Yeah, so you're basically speaking about the problem of attracting inbound liquidity, which is really challenging currently in Lightning Network. So, or we can discuss this topic like, we can frame it in this way. So there are three types of users that are connected to any routing hub or Stroom hub. So the first type is paying customers who actually use their Lightning Network balance to pay for something for goods. Second type is merchants. That's the customers that mostly receive payments. And the third type is other routing hubs.

33:26And yeah, it is important to have balanced channels with other hubs, because you want your customer to reach the whole of the Lightning Network, so they are able to pay everywhere. Yeah, so with hubs, basically your strategy is to keep your channels balanced, like 50%. So you like approximately 50% each side. So with merchants, so Stroom is super cool for merchants, because merchants, when they receive payments, they need a lot of inbound liquidity. So Stroom provides them with inbound liquidity, because it's our outbound liquidity, and we use it to open channels with merchants.

34:13So it's an ideal solution for them. And as for customers, that's an independent issue. For that, we have a separate strategy, which basically boils down to being super reliable, super connected. So they can reach the whole network from our... Connecting to us, your customers can reach the whole network in the shortest possible... We're using the shortest possible paths or routes, which basically save them some fees. Yeah. And also, the shortest paths are the more reliable ones, because the lower amount of intermediaries you have, the higher success rate of that.

35:06Yeah, so we have this. So we try to build a reliable service for them so they can connect to us and they know that they always can route their payments and have a high success rate for it at a reasonable fee amount. Yeah. And for that, we actually need to partner with wallets to describe...

35:36Because it's basically the wallet software, which decides or which suggests users to open the channel with whom. Yeah. So here, we need to clearly emphasize our unique selling proposition for them so they can suggest to their customers to open the channel with us. Yeah. And as for hubs, this is actually an algorithmic problem. Having the balanced channel there. So there are some ways how to balance channels with hubs and how to attract inbound liquidity there. You can use tools like Loop Out, Loop In. And yeah, so it's purely algorithmic problem.

36:35Ad voiceoverAre you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.

37:37Cryptosteel are innovators in Bitcoin cold storage. Back in 2013, they launched the Cryptosteel Cassette, which made it easy to back up your seed phrase, passphrase or any other form of private key on the sturdy metal which resists water, fire and earthquakes. Today, Cryptosteel offers the Motherlode, an all-in-one box which endows you with everything you need to become financially sovereign. Inside of the Motherlode, you get a Cryptosteel Capsule and a hardware wallet of your choice. All Cryptosteel products are engineered and manufactured in Poland. Order your Cryptosteel metal backup system today on cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR at checkout for a 10% discount on your first order.

38:34Cryptosteel, secure your wallet seed phrase. Are you a writer, photographer, musician or video creator who is trying to generate some revenue? Bumbee is the Bitcoin way to monetize your content. It's more censorship resistant than any other platform of its kind with a low and flat one-time fee of 10%. Bumbee is as easy to use as any social media mobile application. Sign up today at Bumbee.com and subscribe for free to the Bitcoin Takeover account to get access to some time-exclusive content. If you are monetizing your creativity, why not get paid in Bitcoin for it? Bumbee.com, the Bitcoin way to monetize your content.

39:37Shopping with your Bitcoin on the internet is easy. ShopinBit is Europe's biggest Bitcoin store with over 800,000 products, ranging from Bitcoin books, toothpaste, mobile phones, computers and watches. This month, I bought a Nintendo Game & Watch console with the classic Legend of Zelda and it arrived in only five working days. And if you can't find what you're looking for, ShopinBit has got you covered. Their concierge service will get you anything and ship it worldwide. Additionally, they also have a travel hacking service that can get you the best deals on all things travel.

40:24Flights, hotels and more for business and for vacations. Bitcoin Takeover listeners get a nice discount, of course. Use code BTCTKVR on your first order for a one-time 5 euro discount. For more details, go to ShopinBit.com. ShopinBit, Europe's biggest Bitcoin store.

40:53Vlad CosteaAlright guys, so in the first part we discussed about what the Stroom Network is and how it's going to work. But I think it's useful to look a bit into the future of the Lightning Network and the way that you see it. And the first question that I have for you as Stroom is whether or not you envision a future where there's going to be a Stroom wallet that Bitcoiners can use to send on-chain Bitcoin to open Lightning channels and make payments with your infrastructure. Something like Breeze or Blixt or Phoenix.

41:28Slava ZhygulinYeah, we thought about it. But that's not for the nearest future. We're currently focused on building our main project. But yeah, in the future, if we somehow can improve it, and if we decide that our strategy would be to build a wallet, have more user base, why not? But as for now, we don't have 100% sure plans for doing that.

42:13Vlad CosteaYeah, to me, it would be super interesting because you increase the liquidity while also engaging more of the Bitcoiners who might be interested in using a non-custodial wallet.

42:27Slava ZhygulinYeah, but it's a really interesting question how to build it non-custodial way because originally, from the technical standpoint, the first design of that solution which came to my mind is like semi-custodial or custodial way. So yeah, so we need to think more about that.

42:54Vlad CosteaYeah, I was thinking maybe to have it work like Blixt or something, where you open channels on their infrastructure. So they are your channels, they are your funds that you control, but at the same time you are using somebody else's infrastructure to route the payments.

43:14Slava ZhygulinOh, so it's like something similar to LndHub?

43:17Vlad CosteaYeah, or Phoenix or what's the other one?

43:22Slava ZhygulinBreeze. Breeze. Okay. Yeah, yeah, might be, might be. Yeah, still there are some technical details to be worked out because our hubs, they are kind of special hubs because we have this module that approves transactions by the Federation to prevent the infrastructure runner from stealing the funds from the routing hub. So yeah, we need to, we need to work out a way how to unite these two, basically. Yeah, yeah. So that's definitely not for the nearest year, maybe in the next year or so.

44:12Vlad CosteaI'm going to break character for a minute here, just to observe that I very much like your Eastern European attitude. If I interviewed an American who is doing the same project, you'd be like, yeah, we are the greatest. We are going to do this. Yes, it's definitely on the roadmap. We're going to do that. Look out for that, of course. And then you're like, yeah, we have to look for a good way to make people not lose their money and use our proper security. And that, you know, to me, that's how I know that you're honest and real about the project, because you can get very good marketing and you can hype up people.

44:49But this is also why I like interviewing developers as opposed to marketers. No offense, Nick. Okay. So let me ask you this. What do you think about privacy on the Lightning Network and how would you describe the difference between a normal channel and the private channel?

45:14Slava ZhygulinLike a private channel, it's a channel that is not advertised to the overall Lightning Network. So usually it is not visible to other hubs and other participants of the Lightning Network. So actually it cannot be used to route others' payments. So it's a private channel where you can just send payments or maybe receive payments if you tell somebody that there is a channel there to receive payment. Yeah, so this channel definitely is not good for our routing. But it is good if you just have your Lightning Network node and you use it to pay for something or maybe receive payment for something.

45:59So it's kind of like private. I mean, that other hubs will not see the destination, final destination, except the one that you have a channel open with. Yeah, but still it is visible on chain. Yeah, it is visible on chain, but no one can tell who this channel belongs to.

46:26But in my opinion, if we speak about the broader problem or issue of privacy inside the Lightning Network. So it basically boils down to the decentralization question. So if you have only several large hubs that process 95% of all payments, then these hubs can build all roads. So they can track all payments and they can extract the information about the final destination and about the source of the payment. And we actually know that some companies are already doing that. They collect that information. Yeah, which is not good for privacy.

47:16I am a strong supporter of privacy and at least the government shouldn't know what you're paying for. And if this information is stored somewhere, then it is easy for the government to go there and see what you are doing.

47:38So that's why I believe that in Lightning there always will be a periphery part of the network that is far away, that is not connected to large hubs. So there are no large hubs. There are a lot of small hubs run by ordinary people. And on that small hubs, it's really hard to track payments. And it is good. I mean, not all users always care a lot about their privacy. And it's okay. So it's okay to have two partitions of the network. One is super private and another is super efficient but less private. Yeah, I believe both can live together.

48:31Vlad CosteaNo, I know that a lot of users, including myself, are fearful in terms of revealing the location of their node because it might be a home node. So it's not ideal to have your IP address associated with your node. So we look into ways to hide that IP address and we can do that with Tor. And that usually slows down transactions. I have been told by multiple parties that it's kind of a terrible idea to use Tor, even though it's the most accessible way. And the other one is to use a paid VPN service.

49:08And you connect to another server and that one is going to be your IP address. So it's useful when you want your physical address to be some server farm where the VPN company rents some computers. What's your take on that? Do you believe there is any better technique?

49:31Slava ZhygulinNo, I'm not aware of any other technique. And actually in Stroom, we have both a clearnet IP address and also a Tor address. So first of all, our node is good for paying from the Tor network to the clearnet network. It's kind of a bridge between these two networks. Like the nodes with only the Tor addresses and the nodes with clear IP addresses. So yeah, I don't know any other way how to tackle that issue.

50:13Vlad CosteaI spent some time looking at two very interesting privacy projects that are built on top of Lightning, so they are sort of layer three. One of them is called Fedi, and it creates these Chaumian mints where you have transaction privacy. And the other one is called Cashu or whatever, and it's more recent. I think it was launched in October of last year. And it's also a Chaumian eCash system that allows you to make your Lightning funds private, even if they come from a custodial wallet. Did you have any time to look into these solutions?

50:57Slava ZhygulinNo, actually, it's the first time I hear about them. So it would be nice if you can share links after the call.

51:05Vlad CosteaYeah, I will. I mean, if I'm helping you improve your service, I think it's a benefit for everyone involved.

51:13Slava ZhygulinYeah, sure. That's for sure.

51:16Vlad CosteaSo is there anything about the Lightning Network that you don't like and you wish would be better?

51:22Nick SchteringardUser experience, right? I think that's a really big problem for Lightning Network adoption. And when you asked about how we envision the future Lightning Network, let's imagine that there is enough liquidity, it's allocated in the right way, and we basically achieved 100% success rate for all payments. And there is USDT and other assets that people actually use for payments inside the Lightning Network. But still, almost nobody uses it compared to some more traditional ways of making payments. And that would be because of UX. And it's really better now than it was three years ago.

52:15And even non-custodial wallets like Breeze and like Phoenix, they are good. They are very convenient for me as a user. But I can't say that I am like a newbie. And maybe for some people that are not familiar with Bitcoin and Lightning and whatever stuff in crypto, it is hard. It is still hard to onboard. And if we envision that Lightning Network will be used for remittance between Philippines, United States, Latam countries, Africa, there are a lot of people who don't know about Bitcoin, Lightning Network, and crypto.

53:03They know nothing about that. But they can use Lightning Network as payment rails for transmitting their fiat currencies from Nigeria to the United States. They already use Strike for remittance. And Lightning Network is only a payment rail. They don't even know about the existence of payment. But many users don't even know how it works. We need really good wallets with really good UX to onboard more users. Because if we fail on that track, nothing else matters, really.

53:46So even if we onboard many merchants to accept Lightning payments and users will not be able to understand how they actually can transact, that's a huge problem. And I think we need to do a lot to work on this track. And actually at Boosty Venture Studio, we are now looking... So we are now building Kaminari, a company which is actually a Stripe-like payment processor for merchants in high-risk businesses. And the next thing we are going to build, I guess it will be a wallet. Because we already have this Lightning API.

54:33And we need to figure out what the proper interface should be for users. And stay tuned, as marketers say. Yeah, right? Yeah, it's on our roadmap.

54:48Slava ZhygulinYeah, Nick's right about the terrible UX. And I believe that the most important... The most significant reason for that is the very design of Lightning Network. That payment channel is not an intuitive thing to deal with. And for ordinary customers, like not technically savvy, it is really a nightmare. So I believe this is the reason why people move from non-custodial Lightning wallets to custodial ones. Because in custodial Lightning wallets, you don't need to deal with channels. So for many people, it is really a nightmare.

55:29But here we trade off security and the trust issues, which is bad. I don't like it for Lightning. If so, it would be nice to have that Galoy-style wallet or solution, which works in a non-custodial way. It would be super, super cool. But as far as I know, people didn't come up with such a solution yet. But I personally think that maybe channel factories will help with that. And maybe something like Coinpool. Coinpool is a solution developed by Gleb Naumenko. He's a core Bitcoin developer. Actually, he is our friend, and he is a big proponent of Lightning Network.

56:19Vlad CosteaOK, I was actually curious to hear if you have any opinion on this battle between Lightning implementations and which one you prefer for your own use case, if you're going to be using LND by Lightning Labs or Core Lightning by Blockstream or Eclair by ACINQ. And I think there's also Nayuta and there's also an implementation by Electrum.

56:46Slava ZhygulinYeah. And also there is some implementation in Rust. And I forgot the name.

56:51Nick SchteringardLDK by Spiral.

56:53Slava ZhygulinYeah. Great, thank you. Yeah. So for me, as a CTO of a tech company based on Lightning Network, I know that Eclair is super efficient in terms of computational limitations. It basically can process more transactions than other realizations. But LND is much more wider, has much more wider adoption. And it is developed by actually Lightning Labs, who was the very first company in the Lightning Network space. And the inventors or the authors of Lightning Network white paper, they originally worked at Lightning Labs.

57:43So most innovations, I would say, are coming from LND side and the basically Taro protocol, which I believe will be a very huge boost for Lightning Network adoption. So we choose to work with LND, mostly because we had experience with that. I mean, our developers had experience with that a few years ago. And also because it's widely adopted and because of the innovations. And because Taproot will be there, maybe that's going to be the first realization that will add Taproot, which is important for us because our design is heavily based on Taproot.

58:34Yeah. So we decided to choose LND. But because of the performance, we might switch to Eclair later when we have resources to do that. Yeah. So that's my take on the battle between different realizations.

58:54Vlad CosteaYeah. You mentioned something interesting about the founders of the Lightning Network and none of them, as far as I know, is still involved in developing. I mean, the writers of the Lightning Network white paper. That's what I'm talking about. Joseph Poon in particular, he has worked on something similar and he mentioned that it would be a better version of Lightning. It was called Raiden and it was built on Ethereum. Can you explain why that one didn't turn out to be better and it failed and nobody uses it anymore?

59:29Slava ZhygulinThat's interesting because from my information that I have, he actually worked at Go... Okay, I forgot the name. It was not Raiden, but he was an advisor there. So he did not... Okay. But I don't know. I spoke to him last time, like four years ago or something like that. So I don't know exactly where he moved, but as for Raiden... I don't know. It's a good question. Yeah. It made a lot of noise three years ago when it was introduced. And I don't know why it did not succeed. Maybe because Ethereum is not designed to be a payment rail. I mean, not meant for payments. It's a purely smart contract platform. So you don't need to have some scalable, horizontally scalable payment rails there, because...

1:00:35Vlad CosteaOh, it was Plasma. Sorry. I said Raiden, but it was actually Plasma.

1:00:41Slava ZhygulinOh, Plasma. Plasma, yeah. So Plasma is a way to scale Ethereum. So there are two concepts or two directions how to scale Ethereum. So Plasma was one of them. It is something like ZK rollup. But it's more like a Lightning Network-style thing, where you don't have an anchoring feature, but you have this smart contract that process redemptions. You can exit from this Plasma chain or sub-chain to original Ethereum with some revocation transactions. I mean, not revocation, but...

1:01:28So it's like Lightning-style. So you have basically lots of islands that are multi-party channels. And you're kind of bounded there. So the second way to scale Ethereum, it was a sharding. So Plasma is like an off-chain solution. Sharding is like when you split your chain into several shards, and then you allow the communication between those shards. And the Ethereum community decided to choose a second path to scale Ethereum. So they decided to move forward with sharding. So Plasma didn't receive much support from the Ethereum ecosystem and Ethereum companies and Ethereum developers.

1:02:16So that's my opinion, why it was not successful. Because for Lightning, it is a different story. For Lightning, everybody from the Bitcoin ecosystem believes that the Lightning is a correct solution. It is the right way to scale Bitcoin because they don't want to build any shards. They don't want to increase block size. They want to have it like in a soft-fork-style development where you're kind of inclusive to everyone and everyone can... So they decided that Lightning is the right way. So Lightning received a huge support from Bitcoin Core developers. So that's why Lightning is successful, one of the reasons. And for Plasma, they did not. They did not receive that. So that's my opinion.

1:03:10Vlad CosteaNow, I also noticed that there were proposals in Bitcoin before Lightning. And to some extent, they all had their trade-offs, right? But when they read the white paper for Lightning Network, they decided, okay, this is the best implementation. And even though the proposal did not come from a core developer or someone who was very deep into Bitcoin, and those people actually made some proposals. It was this one that won the war, to call it so, the scaling proposal war. And to me, it's interesting that there is this selfless dimension to building protocols and layers where it's the best design that wins, not the one with the most amount of advocacy or the most money behind it and stuff like that.

1:04:00Now that I think about it, there was a lot more money behind the Liquid sidechain in Bitcoin, and that one did not get much traction. I think there are lots of companies that are federation members. But if you look at their blockchain, they barely have any transactions at all, while Lightning is unexpectedly successful, even though the people who understood Lightning in the early days are the ones that right now are some of the biggest nodes that operate it. Yeah, it's really interesting.

1:04:39Slava ZhygulinYeah. And I really like it, the best design wins always, because it makes everything more efficient.

1:04:47Vlad CosteaYeah. So what are rollups? Because we got to this point, and that's not a super discussed topic in Bitcoin. Because I read the proposal that was leveraging ordinal inscriptions to create rollups on top of Bitcoin. So what's that? How does it work?

1:05:06Slava ZhygulinI'm not a big expert in it. But that's basically a technique that leverages zero-knowledge proofs. That's a smart way to prove something to somebody without storing that information on-chain. So you basically can keep on-chain only one single hash or one single line that stores the Merkle root tree of all states. Like for example, that could be records about your balances of users, a really huge database. And you don't need to have the database on one chain. You can leverage that hash to prove some transaction happened to somebody.

1:06:06Yeah. And based on this technique, lots of scaling proposals were proposed. Basically, the idea comes down to that lots of information can be removed from on-chain and stored somewhere. It even can be not a blockchain at all. It could be only like some, I don't know, GitHub repo, for example. Yeah. And then if there's some transaction happening, you just update that hash. Yeah. Which is nice, I guess. It's also very innovative. It's cool. And it's really a shame for me that I didn't dig deep into that technology yet. But I plan to.

1:06:52Vlad CosteaI've heard this joke, which might turn out to be technically possible, from Andrew Poelstra from Blockstream, who said at one point that if they want to make initial block download faster in Bitcoin when you synchronize your node, they can roll up the entire history of the Bitcoin blockchain in one ZK rollup and basically just ask the question, are the transactions there valid and correct? Yes. Then you download that one piece of information and you have no reason to store everything anymore.

1:07:25Slava ZhygulinYeah. It sounds very reasonable. Yeah.

1:07:30Vlad CosteaBut it does help with scaling.

1:07:34Slava ZhygulinNo, I think that Bitcoin must stay as it is, like without any changes. So that means that always should be a full nodes that keep the whole record. So all transactions that happen. Yeah. But for someone, it's like an SPV wallet, very similar thing. So if you don't want to download the entire chain, you're just a customer, then this approach is reasonable.

1:08:06Vlad CosteaSo let's get back to Stroom because we got sidetracked a bit. I guess we are getting close to the final part of the interview. So how would you describe it to someone who is not technical and has been listening to this passively trying to figure out what this is about?

1:08:27Slava ZhygulinIt's a really hard question. Yeah. I always, when trying to explain to my friends who are not in crypto what I'm doing, it's like, no, I can't do this. Yeah. But I would say, yeah, when we describe, for example, Stroom to potential investors who are not deep into Lightning, we say that Stroom is liquid staking derivative for Bitcoin Lightning Network. But if the people are not tech savvy at all, so we say, okay, so we're building some protocol that helps Bitcoin scale. And we are achieving that by allowing some portion of users who are using their bitcoins in other chains to actually still use it in other chains as they want.

1:09:30But at the same time, simultaneously support scaling of Lightning by using their liquidity in Lightning. And then I say that Lightning is just a scaling solution for Bitcoin.

1:09:45Vlad CosteaOkay. Nick, do you also have your own explanation?

1:09:49Nick SchteringardOh, if we take non-tech-savvy people, so like my grandma, I would say that Stroom is like... If you want to make a payment to another person into Lightning Network, which is a payment network, Stroom is like... I don't like the word intermediary, but it's like a professional intermediary that makes this payment possible in the most efficient way. And it ensures that this payment will be made with 100% success rate instantly. That's how I would explain it to a 5-year-old kid or my grandma.

1:10:46But if we are talking about some more sophisticated explanation, that's right. Slava already told you that it's a liquid staking derivative for Lightning Network. Something else that... Oh, sorry. I interrupted. Sorry. Yeah. It's a Lightning Service Provider, actually. If we are talking about... In Lightning terms, Stroom is a Lightning Service Provider in Lightning Network. Yeah, but it's raised capital from ordinary users. Yeah, something like that.

1:11:24Vlad CosteaSomething that you told me, Nick, and part of the conversation that we had before this interview was that you guys are going to be present at the hackathon before BTC Prague. Is that correct?

1:11:37Nick SchteringardI will be in Prague on the dev day before BTC Prague. Boosty Venture Studio is actually a sponsor for a Lightning Network track on this dev day. And the day after, there will be a pitch contest for Bitcoin startups. And I will be on the jury board. So I urge all Bitcoin projects to apply, and we'll be happy to see them. And talk about Bitcoin stuff, right?

1:12:10Vlad CosteaRight. So Stroom does not have a direct presence.

1:12:15Nick SchteringardYeah, that's correct.

1:12:19Vlad CosteaI made this association, which I guess was wrong.

1:12:23Slava ZhygulinYeah, we actually cannot leave Ukraine. So that's the reason why we cannot go to BTC Prague. I mean, personally.

1:12:32Nick SchteringardI will be present. I will represent Stroom as well at the event.

1:12:38Vlad CosteaAnyway, I look forward to your launches. I hope that you guys are going to be safe and sound and, you know, physically capable to pull off this project, which is pretty ambitious, is something that I haven't heard about prior to talking with you guys. So it's useful for me to learn how other liquidity can come into the Lightning Network. How can listeners of this podcast follow you guys personally and follow your project Stroom and Boosty?

1:13:11Nick SchteringardYou can find us on Twitter where all the Bitcoiners are. So it's Nick Schteringard. You can find me on Twitter. And Boosty Studio and Stroom Network. Yeah, it's easy.

1:13:28Vlad CosteaWhat about you, Slava? Do you have a social media presence?

1:13:31Slava ZhygulinYeah, but I'm not very popular there. Not yet. Not yet. Yeah. So you can find... Yeah, you can subscribe to Stroom Network Twitter or Stroom Network Telegram group. And actually, there are some discussions happening in Telegram group. So if you have any questions about the project, then you can post it there. Yeah.

1:13:59Vlad CosteaOkay, that's really nice. So really, thank you guys for doing this interview. I know that it took longer than you would have liked, and you're late for another call. So I appreciate your time. I appreciate your input. And I wish you best of luck with Stroom. And I hope you're gonna succeed with this because I haven't heard of anything like it before.

1:14:22Slava ZhygulinThank you. Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you for your time. It was a really cool discussion. I like it.

1:14:34Ad voiceoverAre you concerned that your friends, neighbors, or KYC exchange might know how much Bitcoin you own? It is time to take your financial privacy seriously with Wasabi Wallet, a free and open-source wallet solution which makes use of mega CoinJoins to mix your coins with those of hundreds of other strangers. Thanks to the groundbreaking WabiSabi engine, your coins get divided in smaller untraceable units, which grant you great anonymity for both hodling and spending. Download Wasabi Wallet 2.0 today at wasabiwallet.io and take advantage of the mega CoinJoins. It's free and it's open source, so don't trust, verify.

1:15:35Cryptosteel are innovators in Bitcoin cold storage. Back in 2013, they launched the Cryptosteel Cassette, which made it easy to back up your seed phrase, passphrase or any other form of private key on the sturdy metal which resists water, fire and earthquakes. Today, Cryptosteel offers the Motherlode, an all-in-one box which endows you with everything you need to become financially sovereign. Inside of the Motherlode, you get a Cryptosteel Capsule and a hardware wallet of your choice. All Cryptosteel products are engineered and manufactured in Poland. Order your Cryptosteel metal backup system today on cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR at checkout for a 10% discount on your first order.

1:16:33Cryptosteel, secure your wallet seed phrase. Are you a writer, photographer, musician or video creator who is trying to generate some revenue? Bumbee is the Bitcoin way to monetize your content. It's more censorship resistant than any other platform of its kind with a low and flat one-time fee of 10%. Bumbee is as easy to use as any social media mobile application. Sign up today at Bumbee.com and subscribe for free to the Bitcoin Takeover account to get access to some time-exclusive content. If you are monetizing your creativity, why not get paid in Bitcoin for it? Bumbee.com, the Bitcoin way to monetize your content.

1:17:37Shopping with your Bitcoin on the internet is easy. ShopinBit is Europe's biggest Bitcoin store with over 800,000 products, ranging from Bitcoin books, toothpaste, mobile phones, computers and watches. This month, I bought a Nintendo Game & Watch console with the classic Legend of Zelda and it arrived in only five working days. And if you can't find what you're looking for, ShopinBit has got you covered. Their concierge service will get you anything and ship it worldwide. Additionally, they also have a travel hacking service that can get you the best deals on all things travel.

1:18:23Flights, hotels and more for business and for vacations. Bitcoin Takeover listeners get a nice discount, of course. Use code BTCTKVR on your first order for a one-time 5 euro discount. For more details, go to ShopinBit.com. ShopinBit, Europe's biggest Bitcoin store.

1:18:23================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Remote interview. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization ('Guest A' = Slava, 'Guest B' = Nick; ads were labelled as Vlad). Second opinion: YouTube auto-captions of the published video (xX8_YIhISzw, English original track 'en-orig', fetched read-only with yt-dlp; offset about +0.0 to +0.5 s, steady across the episode), word-aligned to the ASR; about 650 non-filler word differences reviewed. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed from the published mp3 with local faster-whisper (medium.en, int8) on 52 short clips (about 19 minutes); speaker turns checked with local TitaNet speaker embeddings on 24 short windows (references: Vlad's stored voiceprint, Slava at 2:05-2:55, Nick at 13:30-14:30). No other local second-opinion transcript exists for this episode. 0:00-0:52 is intro music. Restored dropped passage: Vlad's 01:30-01:57 introduction ('No, the honor is on my side ... as nobody else has attempted to'); removed a Whisper hallucination at 34:18 ('That's it for today, see you in the next one.') and a looped phrase at 28:22 ('0.1% per year, you can turn over your capital'). Speaker fixes: trailing words moved to the right speaker at 19:47 ('I will pass the word'), 27:55 ('Okay, but do you see a future'), 42:13, 68:06 and 69:44 ('Okay. Nick, do you also have your own explanation?'); Vlad's turn after the ShopinBit ad split out at 40:53; 24:48 is Slava; 43:22 ('Breeze. Breeze. Okay ... might be') and 51:13 ('Yeah, sure. That's for sure.') are Slava; 56:51 'LDK by Spiral.' is not Vlad and is attributed to Nick (weak embedding match); 72:19 'I made this association, which I guess was wrong.' is Vlad; ads relabelled 'Ad voiceover' (Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, Bumbee, ShopinBit from 36:35 and from 74:34). Notable fixes: Scroom/stream -> Stroom; Boost Adventure Studio -> Boosty Venture Studio; Telsys/self-heals/services -> Celsius; Nik/Nix -> Nick; Steringard -> Schteringard; double LNBTC -> WBTC; basically means WBTC -> mints WBTC; LNB -> LNBig; integrated in the device -> integrated in DeFi; found Lightning channels -> fund; 200 and 1000 blocks -> 210,000 blocks; flight and network sheets -> Lightning Network fees; beauty of flight -> beauty of Lightning; throw out the payment -> route the payment; passes -> paths; terrible idea to store -> terrible idea to use Tor; Chomian/Chom unique cash -> Chaumian mints / Chaumian e-cash; Kashu -> Cashu; Phonics -> Phoenix; STRIKE -> Strike; Galois-style -> Galoy-style; Gleb Nomenko -> Gleb Naumenko ('He's a core Bitcoin developer' restored); L&D -> LND; Eclair by Async -> Eclair by ACINQ; Nejuta -> Nayuta; LNG Hub -> LndHub; serializations -> realizations; zkrelab -> ZK rollup; Plasma won one -> Plasma was one; did receive -> didn't receive; soft work-style -> soft-fork-style; Andrew Polstra from Blackstream -> Andrew Poelstra from Blockstream; Lightning received support 'from Bitcoin Core developers' restored; liquid sidechain -> Liquid sidechain; Blue Wallet -> BlueWallet. Taro (Taproot Assets' 2023 name), LNBTC (Stroom's token name at the time) and the guests' 'realization' (implementation) are kept as spoken. Remaining doubtful words are marked ... (14 marks). Ad reads were normalized to the sponsor copy used in other corrected episodes of this season.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00