Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S14 E11 / Transcript
Transcript · S14 E11 · 40:54 · 7 Sept 2023

S14 E11: Pavlenex, Kukks & Anna on BTCPay App at Baltic Honeybadger 2023

With Andrew Camilleri, Pavlenex, Anna. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:00Ad voiceoverYou're listening to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast, the Bitcoin podcast for OGs and intermediaries. Make sure you subscribe, leave a comment and like this episode. Also, read the new BTCTKVR magazine. This episode is sponsored by Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, ShopinBit and Satodime. Thank you for listening.

1:14Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Drunkcast. I'm here with the contributors of BTCPay Server, who today announced that they were going to launch the BTCPay App, something truly revolutionary that's using LDK and is also using technology by Spiral, and got a lot of retweets. Elon Musk is going to pay me because I posted that and I got a lot of engagement. Thank you, Elon. Also, fuck you, Elon, for other reasons. But basically there's four of us in the shot right now.

1:46There is Pavlenex, who is the product manager at BTCPay Server. There is Anna from Hodl Hodl, who did all the hard work to organize Baltic Honeybadger. And this is the last day of the conference, that's why we are all so messed up. And she did all the hard work and she's also the product manager at Hodl Hodl. And there's also Andrew, better known as Kukks. He has been on the podcast before, a year and a half ago. And he is a brilliant coder who did the integration of Wasabi Wallet and the sponsor of the show. Download Wasabi Wallet and try it with BTCPay Server because it also works on your mobile. Anyway, now that we got the shilling out of the way, let's talk about, let's start first of all with BTCPay App and then we can go to Baltic Honeybadger and why we're here and other bear market discussions.

2:41PavlenexShould I start? Okay, so BTCPay Mobile App, I guess today we had BTCPay Day in Riga, which is a dedicated event that we organized the third year in a row here in Riga. Huge thanks to Hodl Hodl for helping us organize these events and for sponsoring also gin tonics for this specific podcast. But yeah, we had a BTCPay Day where we announced that, we had a big announcement though. So we hyped it up and we announced that we will be building, so it's not there yet, we plan to build BTCPay Mobile App, which will allow any merchant to accept Bitcoin in a non-custodial way. And maybe Kukks can talk a little bit more on how we technically plan to achieve that.

3:31Andrew CamilleriYeah, let's do this. Let's try and discuss this with some gin tonics in our brain. So the idea here is that we're actually going to be getting LDK running inside a brand new native application that we're developing as part of the BTCPay stack. We're going to be running it on desktop, mobile devices, even potentially on the web. So the idea here is that we're replacing the idea that you need to use these pre-existing Lightning node implementations such as LND, c-lightning. We want to make sure that we take full control so we can fix all the pain points we've seen over the years.

4:12I think we can make a great product now. The idea is that we want to allow servers to be run by ambassadors or just people that want to help people just accept Bitcoin. But they don't want to be custodial providers for Lightning. So people will be running a native app on their phone or desktop. It will connect and pair with a BTCPay Server hosted by somebody else and it will allow them to accept Lightning payments non-custodially. All the Lightning node stuff will be running on your phone. All the server will be doing will be just generating invoices as usual and it will act like a remote node. I think that's the basics, right?

4:59PavlenexYeah. So one thing we, well, I guess this can be a good segue into why we are here in the first place, Vlad. But yeah, here in Riga, we are attending Baltic Honeybadger conference, which is, this is like fourth conference, Anna, right?

5:15AnnaIt was the fifth edition of the Baltic Honeybadger conference and our first anniversary. We held three stages and most of the talks will be available to watch. We had the live stream. You can watch it. Some of the talks will be available only in voice recorded format and we had the Proof of Work stage powered by BTCPay where people were demonstrating their projects, showcasing their products and doing demos.

5:51Andrew CamilleriAll right. No, it wasn't us. Yeah. But yeah, we're here to basically present our stuff every year. Last year we did the same thing. We showcased what we were building, what we wanted to, what we showcased basically what we're building, how we plan to execute the plan we have and what we expect and what kind of feedback we want from you. And this year we're just trying to, we kind of figured it out, right? We know what we need to build. It's not going to be like something we just, you know, flesh out in a week or two. It's going to be a long multi-year process just to get something nice and usable by everyone.

6:34I'd say one year, two year... one year, one year, one year, yeah, maybe two years. So, two weeks. Oh, shit.

6:50AnnaI think we did a test flight at this year's Baltic Honeybadger, didn't we?

6:57Andrew CamilleriWell, we did, we did a demo basically of how we want things to operate, but that's like, so all the merchants at Honeybadger were running BTCPay. They had a dedicated point of sale terminal, but there's still the issue that they were running everything in a custodian manner. They were trusting the central server for everything. We could have rug-pulled everyone.

7:23PavlenexMaybe that's not redacted, redacted.

7:26AnnaNo, no, no, these guys never, never, never, never going to happen.

7:30Andrew CamilleriBut we have, this is basically the plan for it. We want to remove this problem. That's why BTCPay App is coming. The idea, yeah, that's why we want to build BTCPay App so that each merchant can have the Lightning node running on their device. They can accept payments incoming to the server and they can have the BTCPay Server managed by an ambassador that can help them, you know, get everything set up without having them completely acquainted with how Bitcoin works and the Lightning Network and channels. One thing we want to also state is that basically channel management is still there, right? So we'll be doing an integration of the LSP spec that is going to be available at some point. You want to join in, Dennis?

8:22Vlad CosteaWhat's up?

8:23AnnaIt's a podcast. We need your comments.

8:27Ad voiceoverWasabi Wallet is unfairly private. It's the most advanced and most used Bitcoin privacy wallet with half a million downloads across Windows, macOS, and Linux, as well as thousands of fresh new Bitcoins getting mixed every month. Wasabi makes use of the new generation WabiSabi engine to create mega CoinJoins, thus mixing your Bitcoins with those of hundreds of other users. For amounts lower than 0.01 BTC and remixes, you pay no coordination fee. Even if you don't use CoinJoins, Wasabi Wallet has a native Tor integration and downloads block filters to help you keep your network level and public key privacy. Download Wasabi Wallet for free today at WasabiWallet.io and experience the future of Bitcoin privacy.

9:24Vlad CosteaWe're going to have Dennis from BTCPay Server who will be taking Andrew's place to talk about the BTCPay App. No, no, get on, Dennis. Now you can add your commentary to the whole situation. What was your contribution to the BTCPay App and when do you see it launching? They established a term, but we want to see if there is consensus among contributors.

9:49Dennis ReimannI think having it available to show today was already a great success. So yeah, one year, hashtag two years, maybe.

10:04Vlad CosteaWhat was it that you did for the application?

10:08Dennis ReimannI showed it and made people aware that this is not some kind of vaporware.

10:17PavlenexPeople in the audience are laughing.

10:19Dennis ReimannThat's also very important, I think.

10:24Vlad CosteaRight, so why did you choose Baltic Honeybadger to show this off? What is it about this conference that you like so much? Why did you not go to Miami where you could have had a larger crowd or why did you not do this at BTC Prague? No, I'm not trying to diminish the role of these conferences. I'm just trying to figure out your thought process for choosing an event like Baltic Honeybadger, which is like medium sized.

10:47PavlenexYeah, I can maybe start with that one. We love Riga. We love all the guys. They're always very welcoming to the BTCPay team specifically and we build great relationships over the years. So this is our third event that we are organizing here. As we already said on the BTCPay Day, BTCPay is a movement, it's a family, one big family. When we are doing big announcements, I guess we prefer to do it within circle of friends, family and our own bubble so that we can get early feedback, early input on why this may or may not be a good idea. So that was the goal. Announce it within the very focused group of people who really like BTCPay Server and use it. And then from there, we will see how things move from there, I guess.

11:37Dennis ReimannAnd it's also a thing of showing people, well, we are right now starting with it. We haven't... So this is a project that's further away and so the Baltic Honeybadger crowd feels like the better group of people to announce this to and have a closer group of people who can then go on and test it early on.

12:02Vlad CosteaAre you happy about the answer, Anna? Did they flatter the organization?

12:07AnnaI'm very happy and I appreciate all the credits were given and I'm happy with how it all went. I'm bullish and looking forward for the next year and the things we can build, because I see that even our test flight with the merchants and everything went perfect. So yeah, just looking forward for doing more.

12:30Vlad CosteaWhy should people come to Baltic Honeybadger? What's special about this event in this European city of Riga?

12:37AnnaI think guys already brought most of it up. Baltic Honeybadger is just a community gathering, the family gathering, if you can refer to it like this, that we've been doing since 2017 actually. And every time you're here surrounded by the people, people who share your values, people who've been doing that journey with you for quite some time, you get that special vibe. You're inspired, you're motivated to do and build more. You come here and you just work on new ideas and brainstorm and deliver.

13:17Dennis ReimannWe deliver, yeah.

13:19PavlenexCan I just add, Baltic Honeybadger compared to other conferences, in terms of budgeting, is really uncomparable. You guys have way less funding in budgeting, but yet year after year you manage to make conferences better, learn from all these things you learned from previous years and you guys keep improving. And somehow the atmosphere in Riga is always very special. It doesn't feel conferency, it really feels like you're within a circle of friends and just enjoying. And it's also very loosely organized, which we tend to appreciate because, I mean we work in open source, so we appreciate loose organizations and not too much structure. So that sometimes can mean that panels are late and that people miss the panels, which happens, but at the end of the day, yeah, it's really well organized and just that vibe that we have in Riga is very special.

14:17Dennis ReimannLet me also stress this point of we're building and all of us are building together. So for instance, last year at Baltic Honeybadger, people could not pay with Lightning. At BTCPay Day, Stig approached us and showed us this POS device that this year now worked almost flawlessly and it's been a great collaboration at this conference, but also beforehand to make all of that possible. And that also shows that Riga and Baltic Honeybadger, everyone here is so motivated to deliver and it's also for us as a team, being able to have the BTCPay Day here and being able to be a part of that is also great.

15:05AnnaYeah, as you mentioned, we get it solved together and I really appreciate all the help that I'm getting from everyone and that we are getting as a conference that everyone wants to contribute, everyone wants to do it better, everyone wants to deliver something, not just for their own company, but for a greater purpose.

15:25Vlad CosteaI very much appreciate the enthusiasm, but I want to get back to the BTCPay App and people are going to have technical questions about how the backend works, because basically you are going to be running LDK on the app directly, there is no server per se involved, you're not connecting to somebody else's Lightning node or something, right? But you're going to have some sort of Lightning service provider, LSP, to which you're connecting to provide the channels and everything else, how is that going to work?

15:58PavlenexYeah, so the whole idea is that currently, in order to accept payments through BTCPay, you have to run a Lightning node on a server of some sort and you can't do it in a non-custodial way if you're sharing this server with other people. So with this technical approach, what we wanted to achieve is basically eliminating, I guess I'm the only one left now at a podcast, so even without a host, even Vlad left. Kukks, come on. Yeah, this is what happens in... Vlad is going to have a hard time editing this one out.

16:40Vlad CosteaI have to do some explanations to the people listening to this on Spotify, they're not going to be able to see, but the seats have been changed multiple times. People joined, people left, but we are back here with Andrew, Kukks, who's going to tell us about how this magic application works in the background with LDK and all of that.

17:01Andrew CamilleriSo it's actually really simple, right? The whole idea is that people want a point of sale app native on their phone that makes them very easily able to just spin up a nice UI, a nice simple UI to just say, I want to accept 5 euro in Bitcoin and payments. You click charge and it works, right? That's really straightforward. We have that through a Chrome browser tab that you can just add to your home screen, but there's nothing fancy about that.

17:30You don't have a Lightning node on your phone, so we're going to basically take that approach and add it natively to a native application on the device. The native application on the device is going to be running LDK. At this point, it's been really proven to be quite solid. Everyone is really talking about this. Everyone is proving that it's actually very useful. It liberates them to be able to build a Lightning integration. That's really exactly how the developer envisioned it compared to all the pain points that we've had in the past. I think we're going to do great.

18:07Two weeks is probably not an ideal target, but one year we'll probably put all the experience we've had over the merchant's feedback over the past five, six years, and we're just going to pimp it out.

18:22Ad voiceoverCryptosteel is the original Bitcoin cold storage backup, and it's been innovating self-custody since 2013. Designed and manufactured in Europe from the finest and most resistant stainless steel, the Cryptosteel cassette and the Cryptosteel Capsule are industry standards. These cold storage devices are made to resist house fires, extreme floods and physical shocks. You can also use Cryptosteel to store your important passwords, BIP39 passphrase or Nostr private keys. Buy your Cryptosteel today from cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR to get a 10% discount. Cryptosteel, secure your Bitcoin like an OG.

19:07Vlad CosteaThere are at least two other projects that aim to accomplish similar goals that I have been interviewing in my podcast. One of them is called Lipa, and there's a service from Switzerland that aims to be a lightweight client, just like BTCPay, but for people who only want to use mobile phones. So I guess they have an overlap with the BTCPay App. And the other one is, I guess, LNbits, which tries to be this modular wallet on top of which you can add any sort of application or use case, just like on WordPress. How do you compare BTCPay with Lipa and LNbits?

19:45PavlenexSo I'm not quite familiar with how Lipa technically does things, but my understanding is that it is a centralized company which onboards merchants and then does the fiat conversion for them as well. And I'm not sure if they're approaching the LDK in the same way we are, to be honest. Is it like every device is a node in Lipa or no?

20:13Vlad CosteaWhich one? Lipa?

20:14PavlenexYeah, every.

20:15Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if they use LDK.

20:18PavlenexI think they use LDK and BDK, but they approach it differently. I think they have like this centralized, sorry if I'm misunderstanding this, I'm just trying to guess what they may be using. My understanding is that they're using a server, so I don't think every mobile is a node on its own.

20:38Andrew CamilleriI would imagine they just have a backend server, right? They would have a backend server with some LDK integration there and they have a Lightning node running there, but it's still a centralized company as far as I know, right? So it wouldn't make sense for them to be deploying a Lightning node for every user. I think they still require KYC to some degree, so it would be, I don't know, I think it wouldn't be very beneficial to them. But again, we don't know the details.

21:06PavlenexI think a better comparison here would be what Breez and Phoenix are trying to do. But with the difference that we at BTCPay Server are heavily merchant focused, so we will be trying to address all the needs of merchants, such as having the ability to issue refunds, having the ability to accept payments through NFC cards, having the ability to handle accounting and things like that. So we are trying to incorporate six years of experience we had with merchants thus far into an application that is not just a wallet per se. Yes, of course, at a very high level, it is a wallet, but it is heavily focused on merchant as a user. So LNbits, for example, that comparison is more relevant if you compare it to the BTCPay Server and our plugin system, not really to the BTCPay App, which is something completely different.

22:07Our goal with this is honestly just to allow easy experience for merchants, especially in retail, so in person-to-person payments and physical stores to accept Bitcoin payments in a non-custodial way without an intermediary. And as Kukks explained, by incorporating as well LSP specs into it, because we as a decentralized in a way project, we don't really want to incentivize all of these. For example, we don't want to be tied to one LSP. We really want to allow as many LSPs as possible to be integrated within our app and then customer can decide or merchant can decide whichever of them provides the best experience for them. Or maybe we will be smart enough to detect whichever one provides best experience.

22:54Andrew CamilleriWe literally want to make it so that the merchant doesn't have to think about channels and whatnot. The feedback we've gotten about the Lightning integration we've had in BTCPay for the past four or five years has been that it's too complicated for them. They don't want to be managing channels. They don't want to think about liquidity. They just want something that works. They want to press a button, enable it, get their store set up, make sure that the POS system is running and that they can click charge and everything will work for the customer. They don't want failure rates. They don't want to see an error message saying no inbound liquidity. They just want it to work. So we'll get there. We have to do that, for sure.

23:30PavlenexIf you take a look at the last few years, Lightning has gone a long way. If you remember us trying to pay within Lightning wallets, it always caused some amount of stress. But now we do have a few wallets and their nodes are pretty well connected and just payments just work. For example, what we did here with merchants was very impressive. I was really skeptical of this, but we really didn't have any problems with actual nodes, liquidity or channels. The problems that we had with merchants were poor internet connection, for example, in the first day, which we managed to fix by adding SIM cards to these devices and having better internet. What was the other question? Well, we had some problems with NFC cards, but that wasn't really related to Lightning itself. It was most likely to the server infrastructure that was running in the backend.

24:21We noticed that merchants, for example, when we gave them these out-of-the-box devices who already had point of sale installed, for them it was pretty trivial. Onboarding took less than three minutes per merchant. They asked what we need to do. We just tell them, okay, you type in the amount, you click charge, you can print out the receipt, here's how you can take a look at your balance and invoices, and they're like, okay, that's it. Oh, that's pretty similar to the credit card experience.

24:46I guess with the app, we will try to make that even easier because imagine you install a mobile app, you don't have to think about channels, you just get the point of sale app, you enter the amount, and it just works. That's our goal. Now, if we will be able to get there quickly, I'm not sure if we can make those promises, but let's say that in one year, next year for Honeybadger, we will do our best to have a mobile app experience so that every merchant can even run Lightning node on their device.

25:16Andrew CamilleriYeah, I mean, I don't think that we will be making it easier. I think it's basically just keeping the simplicity that we have right now, but making it the correct way, you know? Making it non-custodial, making it unruggable, making it smooth, you know, we can make, Lightning can be visibly very smooth, but underneath you could be running custodial nodes, sub-accounts, you can have the layer tree kind of mechanics of sub-accounts on a Lightning node, which mimics a great experience, but it's not the correct experience. And we're aiming to fix that, you know? It might not be smooth at first, but we'll catch up. I'm hopeful of that at least.

26:01PavlenexYeah, because if you think about it, if we as Bitcoiners are building tools that are at the end of the day mimicking banking experience and introducing third parties, trusted third parties to take care of all of these things, in my view then we fail. What are we building for? If we are replacing banking system with yet another similar system, then in my opinion that's not the financial freedom that I want to be part of. So I guess the app is one more attempt to make things simpler for everybody, but also like just have non-custodial Bitcoin in a very usable way for merchants, and yes, it may mimic existing experience, you're right about that, but we really think non-custodial is the way. And what we did with this BTCPay Server part is we allowed all of these merchants in retail to accept Bitcoin like that, but, sorry, online to accept Bitcoins like that, but we are targeting to do that in retail as well.

27:01Andrew CamilleriYeah, it's a multi-step process, multiple audiences, we have to focus on that. Going back to the question about LNbits, we're not trying to compete or become some competitor with them, I think they have their own use cases, we're very much merchant oriented, they focus on a lot of different stuff as well. Funny thing is that with the BTCPay App, you can hook up the mobile app as a Lightning node to your store on BTCPay Server, and we have a plugin in BTCPay Server that lets you hook it up as a Lightning node to your LNbits hub, to your LNbits system as a funding source, so you can actually daisy chain all these crazy technologies together and create a whole experience. Your LNbits system can be powered by your BTCPay App running on a desktop or a phone.

27:57PavlenexYeah, and that's a great point, what we are trying to do with BTCPay Server is not to try to be competitors with people, of course, when you think about it, yes, we are competitors with gazillion of projects, but Bitcoin is still in such a bubble that we are all each other's users and we are all each other's competitors, but what we are trying to do is make our stack flexible and modular, as you're saying, so that it actually integrates and allows people to use as many projects as they can, and not just be competitors and try to beat everybody, we are not trying to be best at everything, our core mission is allow people to accept Bitcoin payments now in a non-custodial way, so we are sticking to our mission, but if there are users who want to use other projects and we can allow them to enter all these different ecosystems easily, why not, Bitcoin, that's the open source way, just allow everybody to use software in a flexible way in a way that they want.

28:59Vlad CosteaI was going to mention that the Lightning Network, as you told in your story, has become much more reliable, the payments during Baltic Honeybadger have been, I guess, successful to a 90 plus percent rate, if there were issues because of the Bolt Cards or whatever were being used, but my question for you concerns the fact that the network, while it became more efficient, it became also more centralized, I guess in 2017-2018 we were talking about having one node in every home and opening channels with each other to bypass central liquidity pools or whatever, and gradually it seems like we are gravitating towards these Lightning service providers, who have all the channels are very well connected, we pay maybe 1% fee for every, what's it called, subatomic swap, when we deposit funds from on-chain to a Lightning channel.

30:01Andrew CamilleriSubmarine swap?

30:02Vlad CosteaSubmarine, yeah. Sorry, this is the Drunkcast, so I had a little bit too much of this. Actually, no, I only had one. I'm joking.

30:11PavlenexI guess we need to set a disclaimer as well. We are very tired.

30:13Vlad CosteaIt's been a long day. So where I'm going right now is that the network becomes more centralized and what is your take on the fact that we're going to end up having these large hubs and we're not going to have too many independent nodes run by regular users?

30:27Andrew CamilleriI see that happening actually, it's unfortunate but that's the reality of it. The most important part is that even though we end up in this situation where you have a hub and spoke model, you're still able to be a spoke to connect, being able to connect to another spoke. Just because the network is interoperable, running a Lightning node and somebody else running a Lightning node, you should be able to open a channel regardless of whether they're a huge node or a small node, that's the most important part.

30:57If you're in a node, if you're in part of the network where the main node that you're connected to is censoring people, there has to be a way for you to be able to open a channel and circumvent that. Regardless of fees or whatever, as long as you can do it and circumvent it and make payments pass and flow, then you're okay. Obviously, it's not ideal. I wish we could have a real, huge web of Lightning channel, like a nice graph, but it also works. Hub and spoke is very reliable in terms of network usage of how things work. Realistically, you need something like that.

31:33You can't just rely on people opening random channels between each other. People have been trying it. When the fees go up, people just avoid that. They start closing channels, they're like, we don't want to make sure we don't lose a buttload of money later on. It happens. I think it's okay. It's natural for things to form in this way. Roger Ver was right. We did end up with a hub and spoke model, and that's okay because it's not a centralized problem. As long as you can circumvent censorship, you're fine.

32:06PavlenexAs long as people have options to switch and use and have options in general, that's not really a danger for the network. But yeah, you're right, Vlad. For this setup to work for us, we couldn't allow every merchant to run the node in the current setups in BTCPay that we had because we just cannot manage channels for them. We don't have LSPs integration in a proper way yet in BTCPay Server. In order for this experience to be very smooth on the conference for the past three days, indeed, it was just one centralized node running and allowing all of them to accept payments.

32:46Then we were separating those payments and did actually quite a lot of work in the background to also allow hedging against volatility for all these merchants because that's what Kukks did with his Prism plugin. Maybe that's the story for some other time because it's a very deep topic. You're right, and we also realized that. Just imagine if all of these guys could be running their own nodes, and then if we as a project can provide them with an experience which is smooth and just does not require any of the tinkering, and that's what we are aiming to.

33:20Hopefully with app, we will be able to distribute and decentralize that power. Let's see. Let's set up a goal that maybe next year, in this time, we may have a proof of concept for this, and hopefully payment ratio will be as equally successful. That will be really important. I'm not sure if we can guarantee that, but let's say that that's our goal to have next year equally successful payment experience but in a more decentralized way.

33:47Andrew CamilleriIf we can recreate the exact payment success rate that we had this year with a node on every point of sale terminal, that would be insanely perfect. That would be such a good target.

34:01Ad voiceoverRemember the paper wallet? Ah, yes, the good old days when you printed your Bitcoin private key on an offline computer. It was so fun, but not really easy and totally not secure. Today, we have Satodime, a chip card that acts just like your good old paper wallet, but with all the modern security features and top notch functionality. It turns your Bitcoin into a bearer asset, which you can easily trade in person. Thanks to NFC, you can use the Satodime card with your smartphone. Creating a new pair of Bitcoin keys takes just two swipes. Check your balance in real time, create multiple key pairs. Whenever you want, you can reveal your Bitcoin wallet's private key with just a single click. The simple uncluttered interface lets you quickly see if a key pair has been unsealed. Finally, the cold storage you've been looking for. Available now on satodime.io.

34:52PavlenexYeah, just imagine that every merchant could run their... running a node without even having to think about it. Like, that's really, really powerful. One thing that we forgot to mention, I guess, is the amount of transactions that these merchants had. And this is unfortunate. We ran essentially a server for them, and this is how we know how many... well, it's not us that we're running, but somebody who set them up with a server, they knew how much each and every merchant made, and they knew specifically how many transactions there were. So we have data which says, do you want to talk a little bit about data?

35:26Andrew CamilleriI mean, for once we actually have data, which is actually really good. We've been building a product with no feedback, no real actual usage statistics from day one. This is actually the first time we have some data to actually build and fix the UI. For example, the point of sale graphs were showing empty. Why? Because they're using the keypad and not using products that they've defined in the configuration. So now, by the next version, we'll have a whole different dashboard for this alternative usage of the point of sale. They've had thousands of payments going through, many of them going many times per minute almost. Huge amounts, which is actually really impressive because in 2019, you wouldn't have a payment of over 20 euro passing through, it would always fail. It was like, oh, okay, I'll send you 100 sats, woo-hoo, Lightning works, but that's really just a joke. Now it's like hundreds of euros, even I think we had payments of what, 600, 500 euros?

36:30PavlenexYes, just going through Lightning without any problems. As builders in this space, we use Lightning every day, and maybe we sometimes don't see this. You're using it, you get annoyed, but if you just zoom out and see where we were two or three years ago, and where we are now, there is progress, and I'm sure that in a few years, it will just keep getting better.

36:52Andrew CamilleriYeah, I mean, Lightning sucks, but it's getting better.

36:56PavlenexI agree.

36:58Vlad CosteaIt seems like you guys can never do an interview alone. The last time I interviewed you, there was also Simon from mempool.space, and this time we also have Anna, who has been to my left, sitting casually waiting for her turn, and this is a double feature interview. On one hand, it was about BTCPay and the new app. On the other hand, it was about Baltic Honeybadger, and I think Baltic Honeybadger provides a larger context to the entirety of events, and you should have been here.

37:31So if you're watching this or you're listening to this, you should feel that FOMO burning you and not letting you sleep at night, and making you cry sometimes because you realize you missed such a great conference, and it was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that you have missed. So I'm going to let Anna take over here. She's also going to get on camera.

37:55I'm going to move aside, and I think she has some closing remarks to make about this interview, about this conference, about the meaning of life, about what you should be doing with your own life, about what it means to be financially successful, and what it means to be an authentic human being. So Anna, no pressure there. You have to talk about these topics.

38:21AnnaI guess this interview is not supposed to be about Baltic Honeybadger, neither is it supposed to be about me. I just want to give the credits to the BTCPay crew who made it all happen. And yeah, it was an amazing experience, helping guys setting everything up, being able to witness how it works, and being able to contribute. Just thank you guys. Thank you very much, and we're looking forward to what we can do next year. On a side note, I want to just thank everyone who contributed to this conference. It's really a lot of work to make it all happen, but I'm glad we did it for another year, and thank you so much.

39:05PavlenexYeah, I just want to say thanks, Anna, for organizing all this for us, for making sure that BTCPay Day is also well organized each and every year, for helping us with the merch, stickers, and everything we need, and yeah, for giving us a chance to stress test our product as well, hoping that next year things will be on the same level or better, yeah, let's say. Like, one thing is that people don't realize, like, I need to emphasize this one more time, like, the amount of work that Hodl Hodl guys, specifically Anna, does in the background to make sure that everything works is impressive, so thank you for always being there. I don't know how you managed to organize this and be sane 24/7.

39:46Andrew CamilleriYeah, thank you, Anna.

39:48AnnaThank you, guys. Lots of love. [unclear speaker]: That's a wrap. That's a wrap. Love is not compressed.

40:01Ad voiceoverShopinBit is the online store where you can buy anything with your Bitcoin. Choose between more than 800,000 products, book flights and hotels, and order everything else through the concierge service. With ShopinBit, you can buy your weekly groceries, get the latest iPhone, upgrade your computer, buy something sexy for your new girlfriend, book a trip to El Salvador through the travel hacking service, and also grab a copy of the latest Bitcoin Takeover magazine to read in the airplane. Everything is integrated with a familiar shopping experience that doesn't track you and deletes your data after the order gets completed. You also get a 3% discount if you pay in Bitcoin. Try ShopinBit today and use promo code BTCTKVR for a 5 euro discount on your first order.

40:48Make sure you subscribe, leave a comment, and like this episode. Thank you for listening.

40:48================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Recorded as a "Drunkcast" on the last day of Baltic Honeybadger 2023 in Riga, after the BTCPay App announcement at BTCPay Day; people swap seats during the recording (Dennis Reimann takes Kukks' place from 09:24 to 16:40; Vlad briefly leaves at 16:30). Base: a fresh local faster-whisper medium.en (int16, beam 5, keyword prompt) transcription of the published mp3, which replaced the pipeline's Whisper-Large-V3 transcript because Large-V3 dropped the Wasabi Wallet ad and several passages and inserted hallucinations ('Transcription by ESO', 'www.bctr.com/bctr.com', 'Subtitles by the Amara.org community', 'transcript by rev.com', 'I'm a big fan of the company'). The Large-V3 text was used as a second opinion, word-aligned to the medium.en text; every disagreement of 4+ words was reviewed and 25 doubtful stretches were re-checked from the mp3 with local faster-whisper small.en on short clips. Restored from the audio: Anna's 'I just want to give the credits to the BTCPay crew who made it all happen' (38:21; medium.en had 'I just happened'), Kukks' 'So, two weeks. Oh, shit.' (06:34), 'you're right, Vlad' (32:06), 'in the first place, Vlad' (04:59), 'I'll send you 100 sats, woo-hoo, Lightning works' (36:12; medium.en had '100 cents'), and the closing 'That's a wrap'. No other rough transcript of this episode exists in the project folders, and YouTube captions (video kZmIF-4dHNI) could not be fetched (bot check). Speakers were assigned with local TitaNet speaker embeddings (1.5 s windows, 0.5 s hop) against hand-picked reference stretches for each of the six voices (Vlad, Pavlenex, Kukks, Anna, Dennis, ad voiceover; Vlad confirmed against the pipeline's Vlad reference at 0.76), Viterbi-smoothed, then checked by hand at every short turn: e.g. Pavlenex's 'Maybe that's not redacted' vs. Anna's 'No, no, no, these guys never' (07:23), Pavlenex's 'People in the audience are laughing' vs. Dennis' 'That's also very important' (10:17), the Lipa exchange (20:13-20:15), Kukks' 'Submarine swap?' and Pavlenex's disclaimer line during Vlad's Drunkcast joke (30:01-30:13), and many turn boundaries where the diarizer moved the last word into the next speaker. Name/jargon fixes: broadcast/Dronecast/drone cast -> Drunkcast (the show notes call it a 'drunkast'); BTC pay/BTC-based server/B2C pay -> BTCPay Server, BTCPay App, BTCPay Day; Kux/Cooks -> Kukks; Hologuys/HuddleHuddle/Hold the Holocaust -> Hodl Hodl; EllenBits/LnBits -> LNbits; LIPA -> Lipa (Swiss Lightning wallet); Breeze -> Breez; C Lightning -> c-lightning; Spyro -> Spiral; Rigo -> Riga; Baltic Honey Badger -> Baltic Honeybadger; non-costal -> non-custodial; road pulled -> rug-pulled; Simon from mempool.space (softsimon; S11 E1); Prism plugin; Bolt Cards; submarine swap. Sponsor reads (Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, Satodime, ShopinBit) are labelled "Ad voiceover" and spelled as in the other S14 finals; promo code BTCTKVR. Light clean verbatim: ums, stutters and some false starts removed; speakers' own wording and slips are kept (e.g. 'custodian manner', 'subatomic swap', which Vlad corrects himself). Intro music is omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess: the name of the person who brought the POS device to BTCPay Day (14:17, 'Stig'/'Stick' in all ASRs; the 2023 devices came from Bitcoinize), 'already' (10:47), 'layer tree' (25:16) and the closing line at 39:55, whose speaker could not be identified.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00