Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S14 E14 / Transcript
Transcript · S14 E14 · 56:42 · 11 Oct 2023

S14 E14: Michael Bumann on Building Alby, Nostr & Lightning Network Development

With Michael Bumann. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:00Ad voiceoverYou're listening to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast, the Bitcoin podcast for OGs and intermediaries. Make sure you subscribe, leave a comment and like this episode. Also, read the new BTCTKVR magazine. This episode is sponsored by Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, ShopinBit and Satodime. Thank you for listening.

1:11Michael BumannWhat do I need to know?

1:13Vlad CosteaEverything. Everything. Three, two, one. Hello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. I am Vlad, your Bitcoin influencer's influencer, and I'm here with Michael Bumann, better known as Bumi. Bumi.

1:31Michael BumannHey, everybody.

1:32Vlad CosteaDid I say that correctly?

1:33Michael BumannAwesome. Thank you so much for having me. Super excited.

1:36Vlad CosteaYou are the creator and lead developer of Alby. And before that, you also worked on another Bitcoin Lightning wallet that was about identity, if I'm not mistaken.

1:48Michael BumannI mean, I'm working on Alby, exactly. I started the first lines of code in Alby actually at a Fulmo hackathon around Christmas, I think now two years ago, more than two years ago now. So quite a while. Before that, I was also contributing to the Joule browser extension, which was quite similar, but focused on LND, fueling kind of things. So shout out to that. So yeah.

2:18Vlad CosteaI do remember using Joule, maybe it was 2018 or 2019, and it was an extension that you could add to your Chrome browser, I think also Firefox. And it was meant to be basically Bitcoin's version of MetaMask, a way in which you can log into different websites or applications using your node identity. What happened to that project?

2:44Michael BumannThe development kind of stalled there. There were a few... it was a bit of abandoned, it was a bit of a pity actually. And I mean, maybe we can talk a bit about the history of also how Alby became, how I started Alby actually, is because the Joule development stalled. And especially Joule tried to be a frontend for LND. And it was focusing on LND, and it had also peer management and channel management and all these kind of things within the extension.

3:18And there were also some architectural issues around some things that I tried to do. My vision was actually that the browser extension should be a small bridge basically between what happens in the browser within the web application and the Lightning nodes. It shouldn't do full channel management and these kind of things, because there you will have specialized tools, you don't do that in a browser extension. And even if you do it in the browser, then you should do it in a full web application that then connects through the extension to your Lightning node.

3:59And at the same time, I also didn't want to have it only be a frontend for LND. But basically, the user should be able to choose whatever node they want, so it should be able to connect it to Core Lightning, Eclair, or even custodial setups, or even accounts, whatever you want to do. But yeah, the general idea is to teach the browser Lightning. This is what kind of MetaMask does in the Ethereum space, teach the browser to talk to the Ethereum network or whatever it is. So the concepts are similar, you have your wallet, including your identity, which are the keys in the browser, you own it, and basically you allow web applications to talk to that and request payments, request signatures, and so on.

4:54Vlad CosteaI think it's a really cool project. I think I saw it for the first time last year, which was 2022 in February, when we were in Istanbul and you showed up, not just Alby, but you also had your own tipping service and your own service to split the bill. I thought that was really cool when we went to a restaurant and you're like, let me take care of the bill and you can send your Lightning payments to this application that I set up. And I have also heard a lot about Alby lately when Nostr got launched and people started wanting to zap each other.

5:29And I think Alby, I'm not sure about the ranking, but I think it's just as popular as Wallet of Satoshi for Nostr right now. People even get their own Alby NIP-05s, if I'm not mistaken.

5:40Michael BumannYes. So we offer users a Lightning address to be able to easily receive Lightning payments. And especially we have the Lightning address because you can add the Lightning address to your Twitter profile, to a YouTube video, to all these kinds of services. And with the Alby browser extension, users, when they visit, for example, a video, can automatically send sats to these Lightning addresses. We kind of try to make it easy and bring Lightning to wherever users are currently at. And yes, this is Lightning address. Users can also get a NIP-05, so they can add their Nostr public key to the Lightning address that allows them to then be discovered in the Nostr network more easily. So yes, this is possible. A lot of people are using it. I mean, Nostr is a super exciting space.

6:52Vlad CosteaIt's an entirely new endeavor to explore. It's built not necessarily as a Bitcoin layer, but it's built as something that uses Bitcoin. And it's developed by Bitcoiners, not necessarily for Bitcoiners, but we turned out to be the first adopters. But it's growing and it's banned in China, which is funny. I mean, not Nostr, but some applications that access Nostr, because it's a protocol. You cannot ban that.

7:17Michael BumannThat means you do something correct, I guess, right? So...

7:20Vlad CosteaYeah, you're poking right there. You're poking.

7:23Michael BumannYeah, yeah, exactly. The exciting thing is, maybe if I can say that, is, you know, generally my point of view, so we have Bitcoin as the asset and we have the Lightning Network as the payment network, but payments do not stand on its own. You do not wake up in the morning and think, today I want to pay. I mean, maybe we do because we are super excited about the Lightning Network and the development there. But, you know, normally you don't wake up and think, like, I want to pay now something.

7:55So the payment actually is most of the time more of a necessity. I might want to consume something, I want to buy something, so I need to pay for it. Or I want to support somebody or I like some content that I see, so that's why I'm actually supporting, doing a payment. But it's always... it cannot stand on its own, in my point of view. And in Nostr, we see, like, the nice thing is, you know, Nostr right now is used mainly for a social network, more or less, right?

8:30But it has native Lightning payment integrations with zapping and so on. And that's kind of the nice combination here. So we have a social element there's a human interaction, users are interacting with each other, and directly in there we also have the payments, the zapping, and so on. So this is actually, I think, a very natural fit and a great fit. And I think a lot of the other platforms are missing that. We never had this opportunity to have a platform, a decentralized open platform, that has native payments integrated, because payments always had to be closed.

9:08They always had to be on the same platform. It couldn't be open and interoperable. So that was always missing, and with Nostr for the first time we have this now, I guess.

9:20Vlad CosteaI'm excited about Nostr, but I know that the main topic about which we're about to talk is Alby. But before we get back to Alby, I just want to say that I'm excited about this social media protocol on top of which they built lots of applications, and which turned out to be an unexpected success after a while in which it has been, I guess, ignored, largely. It was still under development. I think I signed up to Nostr on fiatjaf's application that was called Branle or something.

9:55And I was kind of OG at the time. I was one of the first 100 people to try Nostr. But I realized, OK, I can follow people, they can follow me back. I can post stuff. But it's so bare-bones, so basic. So I forgot about it. And then I lost my keys. And I created a new account. And I was a bit upset because I still have the public key. And I'm not sure to which extent I can brute force the public key to get that OG account.

10:20But still, it's kind of nice. In the early days, we were trying new stuff. And Alby happens to be in the middle of it all. And I'm pretty sure that during the next bull market that we're going to have, this type of grassroots adoption that starts from people actually using Bitcoin as opposed to speculating on Bitcoin is going to be very important and it's going to play a major role in the perception of people and how they think of Bitcoin.

10:49Michael BumannYeah, I think so, too. I mean, the exciting thing is, and I think a lot of people come to Bitcoin because number go up, right? So that definitely gets some attention in the bull runs. But that's maybe how people discover Bitcoin and then fall into the rabbit hole. I guess I would have a similar story there in terms of how... everybody has a story, how we fell into the rabbit hole and then discover one thing after the other and suddenly realize, oh, wow, this is what we can suddenly do with the network.

11:26And we'll see when the next bull run is and how it will be. But we have to make sure that tech is ready for the next phase of adoption, I guess.

11:36Vlad CosteaYeah, we got to scale and we got to provide stuff that people want. I guess people don't wake up in the morning and say, yeah, I want some sound money in my life. I'm not happy with my fiat. Unless they have a huge inflation, that's not going to happen. And yeah, we need to build use cases that cater to these people who don't care necessarily about sound money and they only want to do cool stuff on the Internet. And I think Nostr is a pure project. It was launched with the best of intentions.

12:08It was developed very cleanly and very organically. I'm kind of proud of it. And I'm happy that Alby is in the center of all that to make the experience simpler for people who want to tip each other.

12:20Michael BumannThat's great to hear. Awesome. I mean, for me, it was also quite early when we experimented with Nostr and we thought, OK, how does it fit and what it is? But it's actually a quite nice fit, because we see, like, for my non-Bitcoiners, I generally like the comparison with your wallet that you have in your pocket. So it might have your money, but it might also have some, you know, your identity card. Let's say your ID or the ID to your local library or something like that, that you can use.

13:04And we didn't have this in the digital space. But if you combine now your Nostr key and your Lightning wallet, then it's kind of a similar setup in the digital space. You have your money there. You have your identity there that you bring to applications. And now you can say, hey, this is me. This is my account. I log into it and I can also use the same wallet to pay there, right? And yeah, this is where the fit was there. And we experimented with how it fits together.

13:35And actually, yeah, we were super excited about the adoption. So, yeah, because, as I said, always, payments don't stand alone. And this is a good combination there.

13:46Ad voiceoverWasabi Wallet is unfairly private. It's the most advanced and most used Bitcoin privacy wallet with half a million downloads across Windows, macOS, and Linux, as well as thousands of fresh new Bitcoins getting mixed every month. Wasabi makes use of the new generation WabiSabi engine to create mega CoinJoins, thus mixing your Bitcoins with those of hundreds of other users. For amounts lower than 0.01 BTC and remixes, you pay no coordination fee. Even if you don't use CoinJoins, Wasabi Wallet has a native Tor integration and downloads block filters to help you keep your network level and public key privacy. Download Wasabi Wallet for free today at WasabiWallet.io and experience the future of Bitcoin privacy.

14:39Vlad CosteaGoing back to the creation of Alby, how would you describe the difference between Joule and Alby? What do you think is radically different in their design?

14:49Michael BumannI mean, the most radical thing, as I mentioned, is that Joule was for LND and only for LND and tried to be the full node management tool. Whereas with Alby, we do not want to do that at all. We just want to be the connecting layer towards any Lightning node and also allow the users to use any node and any account they want. And then just allow developers, web developers, to use APIs, like specifically the WebLN interface, to talk to these nodes. And I think this is the most important thing.

15:32And then also have specialized tools that users need to interact with these web applications, basically to, for example, manage budgets. That I can say, hey, on this website, let's say even on Snort or Primal, one of the Nostr web clients, I can say I want to allow this website to spend up to $5. And once a $5 budget is used, or $10, whatever it is, then ask me again. But before that, when I click pay, when I click zap, basically the payment should happen automatically in the background.

16:09I don't want to be bothered with that anymore. So we really try to reduce the mental overhead there. The mental transaction cost needs to go to zero. And this is what we can do there. So these are the features that we want to focus on, and not be a frontend for one specific node implementation, basically.

16:29Vlad CosteaSo you are saying that Alby works also with c-lightning, which is now called Core Lightning, with Neutrino or Eclair or LDK and all the others?

16:41Michael BumannYeah, it works with Core Lightning, yes. So you can easily connect your Core Lightning node to it. You can connect your Eclair node. I mean, Eclair is a bit less used, but you can do it. You can also connect, for example, you can use an LNbits account in Alby. We also provide an account for new users to get started, just to make it easy to get onboarded and try it out. And I think the great thing about the Lightning Network is that you don't have a lock-in, right?

17:17So you can even start with an LNbits account or an Alby account or some, you know, a lot of people used BlueWallet LndHub accounts in the beginning, and then you might grow out of that. You use it's easy, and you grow out of that, and then you say, okay, now I want to run my own node, and I set up an LND on my RaspiBlitz or an Umbrel or something like that, and I connect it to that one, or even use both at the same time.

17:41So we want to have this option for everybody. So, LDK, good that you mentioned it. This is what we do not yet have, but I think this is where things are moving towards, with developments like LDK or also Greenlight or the Breez SDK that's on top of Greenlight there, is that it becomes easier to have full nodes, like full Lightning nodes, in our case in the extension, in the browser directly, or in other applications. But this will still take a little bit more time.

18:23Vlad CosteaI think you opened up two of the questions that I was about to ask you, and I'll start with the beginning and then evolve from there to cover the newbie users and then the advanced users. So for a newbie user, what is the best way to experience Alby and to experiment with it?

18:41Michael BumannSo they just have to install the browser extension. They will be greeted with an onboarding flow to add encryption, like a password, an unlock password, because all the data is basically stored encrypted, managed by the browser anyway. But they then have the option to create an Alby account, which is the most easiest for any newcomer. So you basically just create an account as you know it from other applications and you're ready to go. You have a Lightning account and you can use the Lightning apps, you can pay.

19:26Tricky part is still onboarding, but this is something... onboarding in the sense of converting fiat into Lightning. What we there currently have is that you can send on-chain Bitcoin, you get an on-chain address with an account that then automatically swaps on-chain Bitcoin to Lightning, so that you can use it. And there is an integration also to do that with MoonPay, like many others, that allow you to use a credit card to top up your account initially. So that's, I think, the most easiest step for newcomers.

20:04Vlad CosteaSo in terms of browsers in which you can install the extension, I think I tried Alby on Safari and it said it's not supported. Which are the ones on which it works? Is it Chrome? Is it Firefox? Is it Brave? Is it Opera?

20:21Michael BumannIt's all the Chrome- and Firefox-based browsers, mainly, currently. So that would be like... Brave is Chromium-based, so there it definitely works. Firefox and all the derivatives from that one. Opera too, I don't know much users to use Opera actually. And Safari is a little bit tricky. It is kind of supported, but we don't have much... like, you need to install a native application, and through the native application you need to get extensions, because Apple likes to have the Apple ecosystem, so they don't allow you to install the normal extensions from a Firefox add-on or from a Chrome Web Store.

21:12So there it's a bit trickier. And we don't have much request for that, so that's a bit like sitting on the side. But actually most of the browsers should be supported. I think even Edge, is it Edge? The Microsoft one, right? Because it's also Chromium-based, for example. So you can install the normal Chrome extensions and with that also Alby. It's all, by the way, to say that these extensions are built on the WebExtensions standard. So it's kind of a standard that browsers are implementing. On different levels, obviously; there's always, like with a standard, different interpretations in the different browsers, but generally it's a standard, a web extension standard, that these browsers are supporting, and that's why it works on these different ones.

22:03Vlad CosteaBefore I ask the next question, I just want to thank the people from Paralelní Polis for letting me use this studio. I saw Mario, who's outside watching us, and I want this to be on record. He opened the door next door and he was like, what's happening there? And that's why I got lost during my previous question, because I was thinking, do I need to explain to him? But he left us alone. I want to thank them for letting us use this studio. It's very cool. We have the lights.

22:29We have enough quietness to record this. And come grab a coffee or a drink or a beer or whatever you like. If you are in Prague, search for Paralelní Polis and you're going to find lots of Bitcoiners around here, because they tend to work in this space. It's also a co-working space. It's a cafe and they have events. Check them out.

22:47Michael BumannIt's the spot. Yes, yes. I love it. Whenever I come here, whenever I come to Prague, Paralelní Polis is the spot to be, I guess. Also with all the events that are happening here. Every single event here is like one of the most inspiring ones that I've been to. So yeah.

23:03Vlad CosteaWell, except for the one from last year... last week. Sorry.

23:09Michael BumannI've not been there. No comment. But we can learn from others too, I guess. So, but yeah.

23:18Vlad CosteaWhat if you want to use Alby in a non-custodial and sovereign way? Is it possible for you to connect your own node and do everything without relying on any trusted third party?

23:29Michael BumannYes. The extension itself is a complete client-side application. Once you download it, there is no connection to any server. So you can use it with whatever node you want. So yes, you can do that. And generally, we also want to work towards that. I think the whole Lightning ecosystem is working towards that. A lot of the tools. You mentioned LDK, for example. These libraries or these tools will make it easier to build Lightning nodes into various apps and whatnot. We think we need to find use cases where Lightning excels, or where Lightning is great.

24:16And that cannot be done with other fiat payment systems. Because the great thing is we have an open network. You as a developer, you don't need to sign up for an account with some acquirer or card payment processing tool. You can just use a little bit of JavaScript and basically integrate and orchestrate payments within your application. And with that, also, for example, monetize it. So that's great. And so I think that's where the innovation is and where the innovation is happening. And we want to focus on that and build tools for that.

24:52And that also then feeds back to what we need from the more underlying, more infrastructure tech that is closer to the node itself. So because, you know, we could have the best node implementations in the browser or wherever it is, but if nobody's using it, that doesn't make sense. So we want to try to figure out, OK, what kind of use cases make sense? What kind of use cases are useful for users? And from there, we can go backwards to make the technology then more usable.

25:29Ad voiceoverCryptosteel is the original Bitcoin cold storage backup, and it's been innovating self-custody since 2013. Designed and manufactured in Europe from the finest and most resistant stainless steel, the Cryptosteel cassette and the Cryptosteel Capsule are industry standards. These cold storage devices are made to resist house fires, extreme floods and physical shocks. You can also use Cryptosteel to store your important passwords, BIP39 passphrase or Nostr private keys. Buy your Cryptosteel today from Cryptosteel.com and use promo code BTCTKVR to get a 10% discount. Cryptosteel, secure your Bitcoin like an OG.

26:14Michael BumannAnd more accessible.

26:15Vlad CosteaIs Alby also available on mobile?

26:19Michael BumannThat's a tricky question. So first of all, extensions on the mobile are not as supported as they are on the desktop, just because, like, the screen space is a much different one. The UX is a different one. On the desktop, you use much more things in your browser, whereas on the mobile, typically you have more things in a native application. But there we also experiment on how Lightning integrations in these native applications can look like. And one thing to mention there is, for example, or two things to mention there, actually: number one, the Podcasting 2.0 ideas, where quite some podcasting... mobile podcasting players, Podverse, to name one, for example, allow you to connect your Alby account within that player.

27:18And then while you're listening to a podcast, you can stream satoshis to the podcaster. So there you have this native integration. There are many other players that support that. Generally, that support Lightning; Fountain is one to mention here, I guess, like all your listeners probably know that. Breez, probably the first one pushing that forward a lot. But also, a lot of things happen in that space in Nostr again, where Damus and Amethyst and others are also integrating a concept, an idea that we pushed, which is Nostr Wallet Connect.

27:59That basically allows Nostr mobile applications, or generally applications, to connect to a wallet through Nostr itself again. So you do not need to use the browser, but you can use your native application, but still connect Lightning to that. So there you can use Alby in that sense, the Alby account, but the extension is still a bit tricky. There are browsers like the Orion browser, that quite a lot of users are using, that supports extensions, and there you can use Alby. But it's coming, so it will just take a little bit more time.

28:43Safari also on iOS, for example, since one of the latest versions, is supporting extensions, so there we can integrate it. So these things are slowly evolving there.

28:57Vlad CosteaWhat about the Tor browser? It's based on Firefox, as far as I know. Do you think Alby would work on top of Tor?

29:05Michael BumannThe Alby extension works in the Tor browser, yes. We always try to make sure that it works there, and it worked really great. One of the recent releases had a little bit of change in the default settings. So right now the Tor browser, when you close it's not persisting anything. Which means if you restart it, you have to add your node connection again in the default setting, or you need to enable that extensions are allowed to persist something, so that you don't have to do it anymore. But actually, yes, we try to make sure that it works in the Tor browser.

29:55I know quite a lot of people are using it. We actually also got, initially, when Edward Snowden started using Nostr, we got also quite some feedback from him and others around that, that are using the Tor browser to talk to, or to use, Nostr clients. So it's important for me, and I think that we try to make sure that it works there.

30:26Vlad CosteaIn terms of Nostr tips, which are called zaps, is there any way that you can do that without a custodial wallet? Because this has been a big discussion, that you can't really make that work unless the other side is online all the time to receive the payment. Do you think there is a way to optimize this or to make it happen, so that you can send someone a tip even if they're not connected at that moment, like useful nodes or something on Nostr?

30:55Michael BumannSo you have the two sides, right? So first of all, you have the sender side. And basically these zaps are just BOLT 11 invoices that you pay. So there you can use anything, any wallet that you want. In the Nostr Wallet Connect idea, that allows native applications, or Nostr applications, Nostr clients, to talk to a node... this Nostr Wallet Connect concept actually works really well with your own node, because you have... not sure how deep we should get into that, but it's actually quite easy to connect your own node that runs at home, like your RaspiBlitz, for example, to these applications, because you have the Nostr relay in between.

31:50So this makes it easier to connect your own node than before, where you had to go through Tor, for example. You can still do that obviously, but you don't have to. So that's where it's easier to connect these kinds of things. So there it's possible. Yes, totally. And the second thing is the receiving part. To receive zaps, you need to have a Lightning address. So it basically works with anything that kind of supports LNURL. The problem with LNURL is, I guess, as a lot of people criticize it, is that you need a web server to do it, which is a little bit harder, and you need to be accessible in the network, in the open net, basically.

32:35But if you can run that, then you can connect, again, also any node for that. But yes, you are very right. It's a bit more effort. And that's why a lot of people use tools that are custodial to get a Lightning address. But I think this is, you know, again, here we learn what people need and we learn what people want. And from there, we can then try to say, OK, how can we optimize that in terms of technology, you know, potentially if, you know, a lot of people mention BOLT 12 in that regard, or how can we make better tools so that it gets easier to set up.

33:17It's a process, in my point of view.

33:19Ad voiceoverRemember the paper wallet? Ah, yes, the good old days when you printed your Bitcoin private key on an offline computer. It was so fun, but not really easy and totally not secure. Today we have Satodime, a chip card that acts just like your good old paper wallet, but with all the modern security features and top notch functionality. It turns your Bitcoin into a bearer asset, which you can easily trade in person. Thanks to NFC, you can use the Satodime card with your smartphone. Creating a new pair of Bitcoin keys takes just two swipes.

33:49Check your balance in real time, create multiple key pairs. Whenever you want, you can reveal your Bitcoin wallet's private key with just a single click. The simple uncluttered interface lets you quickly see if a key pair has been unsealed. Finally, the cold storage you've been looking for. Available now on Satodime.io.

34:11Vlad CosteaNo, it's interesting, because many people criticize the idea of zaps on Nostr and say they're just numbers in some sort of private ledger that move from one wallet to the other, because it's custodial. And these critics also say that custodial Lightning kind of defeats the purpose. Do you think it's a dangerous point of failure? Or would you say that it's just a phase of adoption that's going to get improved massively in the coming years?

34:39Michael BumannI very much believe that it's a phase of adoption. The excitement about zapping... it needs to be easy. We need to onboard people and people need to experiment with it. And yes, sadly, currently the easiest thing is still that you get an account, or that you download Wallet of Satoshi on your mobile phone and press receive and you got it, and you don't need to manage channels and so on. So if you would need to do that, you're losing users, like, we have to say, right? So if the barrier of entry is too high, then you say, oh, I don't have time now.

35:18I will do it tomorrow. And you will not do it tomorrow. You will also not do it next week. The barrier of entry is just high. So if you lower the barrier of entry, we can learn what users want and what they adopt. And again, here, that's why I think it's a phase of adoption. It's a phase, because now we know people like zaps and it's exciting. So the question is now, how do we make that more easy, in the sense that more wallets support it and more self-custodial wallets support it?

35:50So I definitely very much believe that it's a phase, and I value very much the learnings that we have there, the use case learnings there.

36:06Vlad CosteaGiven Bitcoin's limited block capacity, and the fact that it can only include a certain number of transactions per block, how do you think Lightning can scale to enable everyone to use it in a non-custodial and sovereign way?

36:28Michael BumannI have to say, I like to discuss these kind of things at conferences and learn about these kind of things. But for me, sometimes this is like five steps ahead. In my point of view, we first need to get the first step done in terms of adoption. Because if we don't do that, we don't even need to discuss that all the people in the world will have a Lightning wallet. So we need to get us all a Lightning wallet and get it adopted, and from there grow.

37:07And then I very much believe that we have so many smart and the brightest minds in this ecosystem that we will find solutions to these kind of things. There are many to mention actually there, but I'm not that deep into that thought. I'm more thinking, okay, how can I get all the people around me and more people onto that? And I would like to solve this when the problem becomes bigger.

37:39Vlad CosteaWhat is your take on BOLT 12 and all of the proposals that have been made for Lightning to improve it?

37:52Michael BumannSo BOLT 12 definitely tries to solve a lot of the issues that we already mentioned. For example, with LNURL, that you need a web server. Again, here, this is for me a good example, because LNURL enabled a lot of applications to use Lightning. And so we learned this is something that is needed. And now the protocol can also adapt, and we now know, okay, we need something like BOLT 12 offers to get this more native into the network, to solve this. I'm not that deep into that.

38:37Ultimately, challenges are always adoption among the different implementations. And there it's the typical discussion. What I sometimes feel like: BOLT 12 is this magic. When we have BOLT 12, it's all rainbows and unicorns. If that's going to be, we don't know. But yeah, it's a progress, right? So it's a process. Bit by bit we implement, we get there.

39:05Vlad CosteaI think I like your pragmatic optimism. We need to get this done before we get to think about bigger problems. And you're more of a builder who focuses on developing stuff. And that's the reason why I decided to interview you, because I liked your work since I first saw Alby in Istanbul in February 2022. And I'm super bullish about your work and Alby as a project. I think it's really great.

39:34Michael BumannThank you. That's great to hear from you, actually. Means a lot.

39:37Vlad CosteaI've been trying Lightning projects since 2018, I think. And it's nice to see them improving in time and getting better. And I was going to ask you, okay, I tried to lure you a bit into the BOLT 12 debate, you avoided. But is there anything on Lightning that you wish there was, or would get added, to make your life easier?

39:58Michael BumannI mean, it kind of fits a bit into the BOLT 12 debate. What we, I think, need to do is that we need to make sure that we all try to build more on common APIs that we have, that we keep the interoperability on various levels. And this is on the Lightning spec level. This is BOLT 12. Yes, we all should, you know, have the same APIs there. But it's also then how I can talk to a node. So for example, if I want to support any application that... or if I want to have an application that supports LND and Core Lightning, I need to basically implement two very different APIs, which I think is always a bit, you know, a lot of friction, and a lot of developer hours get lost.

40:49But that's also on the application level, it's the same thing. So for example, the Podcasting 2.0 space, they work with keysend payments, spontaneous payments there, because that's what was available. And they, you know, again, here, it was a very pragmatic approach, I guess. And then Nostr, they use zaps with Lightning addresses and LNURL, but also with a bit of an adaptation there, that you need to have Nostr implemented in that thing. And one thing that I fear sometimes is that we get a bit too much fragmented.

41:24And so there, I wish that we would try to learn from each other, I guess, and try to say, hey, let's try to use common APIs that push for interoperability, because that's ultimately pushing or fostering innovation. It makes it easier for developers. And with that, more ideas can be implemented. And more ideas is what we need to push the adoption.

41:53Vlad CosteaCan you name a good Lightning wallet for beginners and for advanced users, on both mobile and desktop? So basically four wallets, unless they coincide to be great on mobile and also desktop.

42:07Michael BumannIt's always hard to endorse the right one or to recommend one, because everybody, do your own research, right? And learn about the differences. I think that's important. I think there are a bunch of also nice sites that compare the different, you know, properties of wallets. Don't know a link from the top of my head, but we should add one of these in the notes somewhere, because all of them have, I guess, trade-offs, and it all depends on what you want to do. And I guess maybe we can name a few together. It's like we were chatting about Phoenix, for example, as a great mobile one. I also like...

42:58Vlad CosteaYou also mentioned Breez, that they were the first ones to integrate Podcasting 2.0.

43:02Michael BumannBreez, exactly.

43:02Vlad CosteaThey're on par with... I mean, they're a bit different, but on par with Phoenix.

43:10Michael BumannYeah, totally. I mean, so if you want to use, if you want to have a wallet on the mobile, you know... I mean, I guess with Breez you can do even much more, you know, open your own channels, for example, if you want to do that. I think you cannot do that with Phoenix. Then the question is, again, do you want to do that? If you don't need to do that, then it doesn't matter. If you want to do podcasting stuff within your mobile wallet, then you can use Breez again. So it depends a little bit. Also in terms of usability, I guess it's always a bit of a personal taste.

43:53So I don't have a clear opinion there, I would say. I use both. I mean, I use all of them, to at least try it out and learn what's going on in the different wallet scenarios. So, and I hear, like, I don't know, what do you think?

44:16Vlad CosteaWell, on mobile, I think that Phoenix and Breez satisfy the needs of both advanced and newbie users. There's also Blixt. And I did not play enough with it, but I've heard a lot of good stuff about it. Some people showed me that it shows more advanced statistics about transactions, where they were sent, how fast your transaction confirmed on the other side. That's, I guess, nerdy stats. But we are nerds and we love those stats. On mobile... on PC, not PC, on desktop...

44:54Michael BumannMaybe to add on the mobile too is like Zeus, where, when you have, like, your own RaspiBlitz or Umbrel running, then you can connect there. So they do a great job there. You can also use Zeus with your Alby account, for example. So there you can have the mobile Zeus application connected to your Alby account and have then the same account, the same, like, sats paid, like, at the point of sale with Zeus, but then also use a podcast player like Podverse to use the same account, or connect Damus, as you said before, like, as a Nostr client.

45:30And one thing to say also, in terms of the Blixt ones and Breez and Phoenix, is, like, the different services that the LSPs basically provide to you. Because in terms of your... I mean, it's amazing that it's actually possible that you can open the app, you get a new wallet, and you can instantly receive Lightning payments, because they open channels on the fly to you. So these are great, great services, I think, where we also will see a lot of innovation. But yeah, to the desktop ones.

46:03Vlad CosteaI think the best one there, I mean, the one that I use the most, and that I remember using for a long time, is Run the Lightning, RTL.

46:14Michael BumannRTL, yeah. Yeah. I mean, that's a full... some of them are, you have full node management tools, right? So if you run your LND node or Core Lightning node somewhere, then you have some UIs like RTL, what is it, ThunderHub as another one, that you need to install. Obviously, you can use the Alby extension with them. You don't do the full management in the extension, but then in web apps there. Do you use another one on a desktop?

46:50Vlad CosteaI tried to use command line LND a few times. It's not really for me. I mean, I know how to paste invoices and pay them and stuff like that. But otherwise, it's not the most efficient. But at least I can get some feedback to see if the payment went through and stuff like that. I don't need to rely on an interface. I can read what actually happens with the broadcasting of the transaction. I guess I should play more with Core Lightning, because I heard a lot of good stuff about it.

47:20And I guess it's the more conservative client. They don't change as radically, but they built it, I guess, in a more modular way, if that makes sense.

47:33Michael BumannI should. Yeah, you have, like, the Core Lightning plugins, actually, that a lot of people build, or extend the Core Lightning core functionality quite nicely. I mean, generally, I think having options is the great thing and is important. And that's why, yes, I also try to look at, you know, the different node implementations as much as possible.

47:57Ad voiceoverShopinBit is the online store where you can buy anything with your Bitcoin. Choose between more than 800,000 products, book flights and hotels and order everything else through the concierge service. With ShopinBit, you can buy your weekly groceries, get the latest iPhone, upgrade your computer, buy something sexy for your new girlfriend, book a trip to El Salvador through the travel hacking service, and also grab a copy of the latest Bitcoin Takeover magazine to read in the airplane. Everything is integrated with a familiar shopping experience that doesn't track you and deletes your data after the order gets completed.

48:32You also get a 3% discount if you pay in Bitcoin. Try ShopinBit today and use promo code BTCTKVR for a 5 euro discount on your first order.

48:44Vlad CosteaThere was also a wallet by Pierre Rochard, Node something. I do remember it. It was super basic, 2019, early 2019. It was running on all operating systems. It was connecting directly to a full Bitcoin node. You could also add Lightning on top. Really interesting.

49:05Michael BumannYeah, I don't remember which one you mean now, but ultimately I also think that Lightning should be integrated into the operating system directly, like we integrated it into the browser. But maybe we see a time where Lightning is deeply integrated into your operating system, and whatever that will enable then.

49:30Vlad CosteaThat should not be too hard: to fork some Linux distribution and experiment a bit with that, and get other Linux distributions to also do the same, to prove to them that it works well and it adds some features. I don't think Microsoft will do that with Windows, and Apple, I guess, will do it last and pretend that they did it better and they have the most refined experience. But it's all up to you guys, the ones listening, who are proficient in coding and want to create a Linux distribution which includes maybe Alby.

50:06The browser extension directly, and some integration that makes Lightning a lot more seamless since you installed the OS. And I was going to ask you, how can people contribute to Alby? Do you need more pull requests? Do you need code review and stuff like that?

50:23Michael BumannAll of it. All of it. I mean, as any open source project, there are like so many ways to contribute to it. I get asked this question a lot. And I mean, that's true for any open source project out there. Typically, people think you have to be kind of a coder to do that. But that's definitely not the case, because the easiest thing that you already can do is give feedback. You know, you use it, something's not working for you, write it down, create an issue, share it with the community there, because that's where the developers, the designers need to learn from.

51:04But then also, like, often it's documentation, guides. It's like everybody, you know, you install it works for you learn how to use it, write it down and explain it to your friends. That's, you know, a super simple contribution to any open source project that everybody can do, if you're interested in. Translations is another one. Actually, we got a lot of translations contributed, to translate the user interface to the different languages. Because, again, there not everybody is fluent, super fluent in English. Having it in a local language also makes the adoption easier.

51:43But then also, obviously, design, pull requests; there's, like, on various levels, to contribute in that regard. And I actually think also these projects that are closer to the user, to the application layer, they are a really good start to get into Lightning development also. Because if you look at the Core Lightning code or the LND code, it's like, you know, it's much more complex, it's super complex, it's like the raw infrastructure. So, but we are sitting a little bit more on top of that.

52:21So it's a good entrance point for the development, I think. So, yeah. And I'm super excited about the community, development, design community that is happening around that, because it's super, super welcoming and super helpful. Is that the right word? So, if somebody has a question, it's like, yeah, people are happy to help and, you know, help each other where you get stuck, and to learn. So ultimately, it's always about, for everybody, to learn.

53:00Vlad CosteaWhat are some use cases or features that you want to add into Alby in the next... in the near future, and maybe the far future?

53:14Michael BumannThere are a bunch of them. So I mean, we talked about the idea of using your Lightning wallet within different applications. So this is an important one that we pursue. There is also generally the idea of optimizing, for example, the budgets feature, getting more, like, Nostr more connected there. Though, I mean, if people are interested in there's a lot of GitHub issues that are open, where a lot of the features and the roadmap is discussed. So the funny thing is here, the space is moving so fast. Quite some things where I would have said, like, I don't know, three, five, six months ago, have changed, because the space has also changed quite a bit. So it's generally still a lot of experimentation that's going on.

54:19Vlad CosteaAll right. Michael Bumann, creator of Alby, you can call him Bumi. You can send pull requests and feedback about Alby after you use it. Don't do that without using it. Or maybe you can look at the code and see if there's anything wrong with that. Do you receive donations?

54:39Michael BumannWe have a bounties program, actually. Yeah. So we have bounties where we receive donations and where we also give out, try to give out, bounties for people to, for example, contribute, I don't know, a small feature or a translation. Or people can set up a bounty if they want to see a feature being pushed and developed within the ecosystem. So yes, that's always like a great way also to contribute in that regard.

55:06Vlad CosteaThis is the beauty of open source. You always have ways to contribute and make a name for yourself in a project that you may like. So how can people follow you and pay attention to the project, or maybe see what you're thinking about Lightning or whatever?

55:22Michael BumannSo you find on GitHub the Alby organization, it's called getAlby there. I'm bumi on GitHub. I mean, we talked a lot about Nostr. You can still follow us on Twitter if you want, on getAlby and bumi there. And you find us obviously then also on Nostr, bumi@getalby.com, if you search for that.

55:47Vlad CosteaOr npub1-X-Y-A-B-3-11.

55:52Michael BumannPlease remember that quickly.

55:55Vlad CosteaWrite that down.

55:56Michael BumannYeah, actually, at Alby we have a vanity npub. So I think it's npub getalby... I don't know if there's a B, is not in there, right? That's maybe a six. I don't know. Anyway, so René mined a vanity npub, which is quite nice. But the discovery is still an issue. We will see how that will be in a few months' time. But you will find us.

56:24Vlad CosteaOf course. Thank you very much, Bumi. And good luck.

56:28Michael BumannThank you so much. Thank you so much. Love what you are doing here. Pleasure to be part of this.

56:36Ad voiceoverThank you for listening! Make sure you subscribe, leave a comment, and like this episode!

56:36================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization (Guest A -> Michael Bumann, Guest B -> Ad voiceover, Vlad Costea). Unlabeled continuation paragraphs inherited the previous speaker. Recorded at Paralelní Polis in Prague. Second opinion: YouTube auto-captions of the published video (mkdEgKX7UHY, fetched read-only with yt-dlp; YT time = mp3 time + about 0.3 s, steady across the episode), word-aligned to the ASR; about 500 non-filler word differences reviewed by hand. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed from the published mp3 with local faster-whisper (medium.en, int16, no prompt) on 45 short clips, including a full re-transcription of 52:50-54:30. Restored from the audio: Michael's dropped passage at 53:44 ('getting more, like, Nostr more connected there. Though, I mean, if people are interested in there, there's a lot of GitHub issues that are open, where a lot of the features and the roadmap is discussed'), the pre-roll exchange 'What do I need to know?' / 'Everything. Everything. Three, two, one', Vlad's 'Going back to the creation of Alby, how would you describe the difference between Joule and Alby?'. Speaker turns were checked with local TitaNet speaker embeddings (1.5 s windows at 0.75 s hop over the whole episode, plus short targeted windows) and caption word timestamps; repaired turn boundaries include Michael's 'Hey, everybody' / 'Awesome. Thank you so much for having me', 'I mean' (01:48), 'So yeah' (02:17), 'they can add their Nostr public key' (06:33, wrongly given to Vlad), 'That means you do something correct, I guess' / Vlad's 'you're poking right there', 'That's great to hear. Awesome' (12:20), 'Yes' (23:29), 'It's the spot... Paralelní Polis is the spot to be' (22:47) and 'I've not been there. No comment' (23:09), 'The Alby extension works in the Tor browser', 'Thank you. That's great to hear from you' (39:34), 'And more ideas is what we need to push the adoption', the Breez/Phoenix exchange (42:58-43:10), 'Maybe to add on the mobile too', 'But yeah, to the desktop ones', 'Do you use another one on a desktop?' (Michael asking Vlad), 'This is the beauty of open source' (Vlad), the npub exchange at 55:47-55:56 and the closing 'But you will find us' / 'Of course. Thank you very much, Bumi'. Notable name/jargon fixes: Albi/LB/LBB/IB/Albee/Zalbi -> Alby; JUUL -> Joule; L&D -> LND; Fumo -> Fulmo (hackathon); NoSir/NoStir/Noster -> Nostr; NIP5/NIPL5 -> NIP-05; sapping/SAP -> zapping/zap; Fiat Jeff's -> fiatjaf's; Bronle -> Branle; cold -> cool stuff; WebLN; CLightning -> c-lightning, CoreLightning -> Core Lightning; LNbits; Blue Wallet LND hub -> BlueWallet LndHub; login -> lock-in; RaspiBlitz/Raspberry Blitz -> RaspiBlitz; Umbral -> Umbrel; ADK -> LDK; Priest SDK -> Breez SDK; Greenlight; MoonPay; Chrome Web Store; WebExtensions standard; Paralleling Police -> Paralelní Polis; Podworx -> Podverse; Fountain; Breeze -> Breez; Damos -> Damus; Amethyst; Nostr Wallet Connect; Orion browser; Edward Snowden; Bolt11/Bolt12/both 12s -> BOLT 11/BOLT 12; LNOL/L-N-U-L/LNUL -> LNURL; 'used for Stodio' -> custodial; face of adoption -> phase of adoption; Blixxed -> Blixt; SUSE -> Zeus; ThunderHub; notifications -> node implementations; Pierrot-Chard -> Pierre Rochard; LNG -> LND; GetAlbiThere -> getAlby; Bouman -> Bumann; N-PUB -> npub; vanity npub mined by René (René Aaron of Alby; the Alby npub starts 'npub1getal6', hence 'that's maybe a six'). Sponsor reads (Wasabi Wallet, Cryptosteel, ShopinBit, Satodime) are labelled "Ad voiceover", spelled as in the S14 finals; promo code BTCTKVR. 'Run the Lightning' (RTL is Ride The Lightning) is kept as spoken; all three transcriptions agree. The npub characters Vlad reads at 55:47 do not match Bumi's published npub (npub1xv8mz...) and are marked unclear, as are the unidentified implementation name at 16:33 ('Nejuta' in both ASRs) and a few short words at 26:14, 47:33 and 55:55. Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; speakers' own slips are kept as spoken. Intro music is omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess.

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00