S16 E25: Chandra Duggirala & George Burke on Portal & Making Exchanges Obsolete
Search this conversation
0:45Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 25. We are live with two of the co-founders of the Portal project. And this episode is sponsored by Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, LayerTwo Labs and NoOnes.com. It's really good to have you guys once again. I think it's the third interview that I do about Portal. And the project has grown over the last, I guess, five years since I met you. And you've been doing a lot of stuff with swaps. And it's really exciting that you're bringing something trustless into an industry that seems to bring back trusted setups.
1:29Chandra DuggiralaThank you very much for having me on the podcast. I'm Chandra, co-founder, CEO, chairman of Portal. And I'm glad to be here with my friend and co-founder, George.
1:44Vlad CosteaYes, that's important for the people on Spotify. That was Chandra Duggirala. And the other voice is George Burke, the builder.
1:54George BurkeYeah. For the people who don't have their video on, I'm playing around with filters on Google Meet. And so I found this construction hat. It was either that or the wizard, the wizard beard, but I already have the beard.
2:09Vlad CosteaYou're already a wizard. Now you're building wizard. So let's talk about Portal. What has been happening lately? Last time you were on the show, I saw this demo in which you were able to swap trustlessly between Lightning Network on Bitcoin and, I think it was the Raiden Network on Ethereum.
2:30Chandra DuggiralaYep. So I'll give you a brief update. So we started with a mission to actually create what we call trust minimized exchange. Because when we started, as you know, the word decentralized exchange didn't exist. And our big problem with terminology is that, as someone very smart said, if you start with absurd definitions, you're going to reason yourself into complete nonsense. And so we don't really care about decentralization. We actually care about trust minimization and cross-chain operations. So we called it T-MEX, unfortunately, T-M-E-X. That didn't take off. DEX took off.
3:14So we don't care. We go with the flow. But our core mission remains trust-minimized cross-chain operations, which means, other than trusting the security properties of the blockchains that you are swapping or doing complex contracts across, you don't have to trust any other primitives extraneously. So no multi-sigs, no vaults, no bridges, no wrapped derivatives, none of those shenanigans which claim to be trustless. I mean, we all know that this industry is full of scammers who try to hide their security vulnerabilities and their own personal insecurities under a lot of computer science jargon.
4:06And we took the opposite route. We said, look, we want to go for simple. And so the first iteration of that was, like you said, in our view, there's a lot of projects that claim to be layer 2s. In our view, true layer 2s are off-chain settlement mechanisms like Lightning, Raiden, state channels, payment channels, Mercury layer, that sort of an approach. Everything else is a sidechain LARPing as an L2. Right? Bitcoiners will understand this. Altcoiners will frown. But we really don't care. So how do you do this?
4:48The first iteration attempt at this was actually trying to fix Raiden. And then we figured out that there is no point in trying to resuscitate a dead project because everybody left. And we actually were left with holding the bag of trying to fix all of the problems with Raiden and removing the token from that and all of that stuff. So we said, you know what, screw this. Not screw Raiden, but screw that approach. Let's get back to what's real. And so we built the second iteration, which was actually peer-to-peer without an order book, had a lot of problems. It worked.
5:21But the problem was there was almost infinite amount of user friction for you to be able to find the counterparty, know their public key hash, be able to do the hash time lock swap. And then you get back to these same problems as atomic swaps on L1 always had, which is one, the lockup griefing problem, the free option problem, the same thing. So we eventually came up with this brand new architecture, which we call BitScaler, which is compatible with Lightning. It is not Lightning. It is actually a solution to several of the problems that Lightning had, which is you can't do an AMM-based multi-channel, multi-chain AMM-based DEX that actually reaches parity with the best centralized user experience, which is what people are used to and they want.
6:24Lightning doesn't allow us to do that because two-party multisig and then, you know, the parent-child thing, and then you can't have multiple counterparties and you can't, you know, know all of their public key hashes in advance and do these hash time contracts on L1. Everything is an on-chain transaction. So a lot of research went into developing BitScaler, but a huge credit to where credit is due. Christian Decker and Roger Wattenhofer, they came up with this concept of a channel factory. So we built and modified the channel factory to fit the AMM design on multiple chains.
6:59And so what do you get with that? You get multi-party, one transaction can create multi-party off-chain channels essentially, and then you can slice and dice these channels off-chain and the on-chain footprint is 96% less than even Lightning. That allows for us to actually have a trustless way to hold the liquidity provider funds as well as the traders to trade against them using L2 atomic swaps, just like what Lightning does when you do payment forwarding on Lightning. What you're essentially doing is you're doing L2 atomic swaps through the route from the recipient, from the sender to the recipient.
7:45And as soon as the recipient gets the right amount, the secret is revealed, you just clear out your channel. You don't need to have all of that junk stored. You just keep the state of your channels in your RAM or wherever you store your state.
8:02George BurkeAnd the technology is difficult, right? But we have to go into why it's even been created in the first place, right? Why atomic swaps?
8:11Chandra DuggiralaThat's a great point. So the goal is to create the absolute best exchange in the world. And why? First, it is trust minimized. We don't use the word trustless because there's nothing trustless, right? Including Bitcoin. Trust minimized. Number two, it has to have the absolute best user experience because without that, all of your techno wizardry is useless. Everything goes in reverse order from the user experience, user benefits, all the way back into the backend tech stack, right? That's the way I look at products. That's the way I've been trained to look at products.
8:54That's the way every successful company works in Silicon Valley. Number three, and this is what we'll get into, we've changed a lot, the AI element of this, which is something that most people don't associate Portal with. When we actually acquired Rafa and we said, this is the future of financial markets, bringing efficiency to whether it's TradFi or DeFi. Most people, including our investors, said like, well, you guys were doing a DEX, like, what the fuck is this? I'm sorry for the language, this AI thing. Three months after that, ChatGPT 3 comes out and now everybody is trying to create like first grade level, oh, we have an AI bot that can actually do this, which is a thin wrapper on ChatGPT.
9:40To give you a little bit of a background on Rafa, Rafa was built by a long time acquaintance and friend and a team that we highly respect and love that came out of Nvidia. They... I mean, the head of our AI, Abhinav, who was at Nvidia for nine years as a Senior Systems Architect, big data and machine learning, worked on CUDA. So there are very few people in the world who know how to do these things with the right tools, with having mathematical accuracy, with having almost no hallucinations, and so on and so forth, and build it and integrate it and build the agentic software that becomes your personal hedge fund in your pocket, right in the exchange where you actually hold your tokens non-custodially and trade non-custodially. Right? It all makes sense now.
10:40It didn't make sense to anyone two years ago. That's always the way it works. So we took a large directional bet and bet the future of the company on that. And as you will see, everybody, you know, the latest report from ConsenSys is that all the TradFi and DeFi companies now want to have AI bots, but they don't know how to build them. So yeah, those are the big 10,000 foot view changes on what happened with Portal over the last couple of years since we last spoke. And I'll stop there and I'll be happy to take questions about whatever direction you want to take this conversation.
11:21Vlad CosteaYeah, you mentioned something about building a better Lightning Network. I'm curious how that works.
11:27Chandra DuggiralaWe're not trying to build a better Lightning Network, we're trying to solve a specific... Lightning was built for micropayments, right? That's a huge need, hopefully in the near future or in the far future. Who knows? Once Bitcoin becomes the currency, money. And we have strict definitions for all terms. What is money? Money is a generally used medium of exchange. Bitcoin is not money yet. We're all betting that it'll become money at some point. We call it proto-money or pre-money, right? And some people argue that no, no, no, no, no, anything that is used in medium of exchange is money.
12:04By that stupid logic, cans of expired sardines in prisons and cigarettes can also be considered money. That's a stupid definition. You know, that's like saying, I play basketball in my backyard. And therefore, when people ask me what I do, I'm a basketball player. That basically entirely destroys the value of the definition in the first place. So we don't call Bitcoin money. Once Bitcoin becomes money, Lightning Network will be the greatest thing in the world. We have a lot of respect for the team there. I think they're 20 years ahead of anybody else.
12:35We focus on here now, maybe like five to 10 years from now. So what is the biggest need for the world right now? It's to have trust-minimized exchange. How do we know? Where is the volume? What are the users actually wanting? Where is proven demand? The proven demand is for cross-chain exchange. And so Lightning doesn't fit that mold. It was built for a different purpose. We tried it. But what we've built, the Channel Factory, is not a better Lightning. It's an alternative interpretation of off-chain scaling mechanisms for Bitcoin.
13:11And when the first paper came out, I think in 2018, when Christian Decker was still at ETH Zurich, people called it the Holy Grail of Bitcoin. Then he went to Blockstream. And we were fortunate enough to be able to collaborate with him in building BitScaler. And we have some ex-Blockstream people, as you know, Eric was here, Johnny Dilley was with us, and lots of great Bitcoin engineers. And it is not trying to compete with Lightning. Lightning is trying to do one specific thing. And we are not interested in that use case now.
13:52Our use case is the exchange. So we built something that is compatible with Lightning so you can actually move your liquidity seamlessly across from Lightning and do your trades and do your options and perpetuals and all that stuff and get right back into your wallet. And nowhere along this chain or this lifecycle of your user activity will you have custodial risk. So that's our differentiator along with the AI agent investment copilot built right into the DEX. So the huge differentiator is it scales well beyond what Lightning can do.
14:28It is compatible with Lightning. And you'll have absolutely no custodial risk while you have your coins in the wallet, while you're trading. After you trade, nowhere along the lifecycle will you have custody risk. So yeah, not a better... I mean, I wouldn't characterize what we built as a better version or competitor to Lightning. It is compatible with Lightning. It solves a different use case. But it uses similar off-chain settlement mechanisms as Lightning. As you know, there are many different interpretations of Lightning, C-Lightning, et cetera, et cetera. Channel factory is not that. Channel factory is a different off-chain settlement mechanism.
15:10Vlad CosteaI was going to ask you about that because I guess the listeners are already familiar with how Lightning works. But BitScaler sounds with all these channel factories and you said it solves some inefficiencies of the Lightning Network design.
15:27George BurkeLightning is, unfortunately, only peer-to-peer. You can only have channels between two peers. And so you have to open up and close a channel every time you want to change those peers. But instead with BitScaler, you have the ability to, let's say, have 5,000 different peers in the same channel. And that means just one anchor transaction that opens that channel for 5,000 people, 10,000 people. We don't know how far it can scale. I'd love to find out what that top number is.
16:01Chandra DuggiralaRight. And all of the peer-to-peer channels are formed off-chain, right, and closed off-chain. And the settlement happens on-chain with one transaction. So the fees are spread across all of the users in that n-of-n multisig. So that's the big difference. And I highly recommend, I can post a link to that original paper and the BitScaler paper. They're both on our publications, portaltobitcoin.com/publications, I believe, or docs, publications. The original channel factory paper, and then there was a follow-up. Nobody actually dared to implement it because, you know, I mean, altcoiners don't really care about what's happening in Bitcoin.
16:43We don't care about what's happening in the altcoin land. And so we have this nice little space to ourselves where we bring the product sensibility, distribution mindset, and also understand Bitcoin at its deepest level and the ethos and the values of Bitcoin and what Bitcoiners want. So that's the niche we carve for ourselves. And it turns out that's pretty big and pretty huge and pretty important.
17:13George BurkeYeah, I'll take a look at...
17:16Vlad CosteaGo ahead.
17:18George BurkeNo, you go ahead. When you take a look at the implementation of what BitScaler is meant to do, at least for Portal's applications, we built the first cross-chain AMM that is as trustless as can be. And when you look at how AMMs work, and maybe we can get a little technical, but the way AMMs work, automated market maker, that's right. So anytime you go on most of these swapping services, you'll see that there are liquidity providers and there can be hundreds of liquidity providers providing coins that are typically two-sided coins. They can be Tether and Bitcoin or USDC and Ethereum, and they'll put that into a pool locked up because you need both of those coins for people to be able to trade as the counterparty against that pool.
18:29And so because you can have either one liquidity provider or hundreds, maybe even thousands, this is where you want to have channel factories really shine. Because if you're going to have thousands of peers with tokens that are locked non-custodially, channel factories is, as far as we can tell, on the Bitcoin side and other UTXO type transaction networks. That's the only way to do it.
19:03Vlad CosteaRight. It sounds like you can basically serve hundreds if not thousands of users in one on-chain transaction. Is that correct?
19:12Chandra Duggirala100%. Yes. We hope many thousands of users, many, many thousands, hundreds of thousands of users, because there's not just one liquidity pool. If you look at the DEXes, there are several liquidity pools that are continuously forming, and then they settle and then they're done. I have to give credit where credit is due. A lot of the AMM research was done by the Uniswap folks and Paradigm guys, who we actually disagree with on several things, and Robinson. But even before then...
19:46George BurkeDon't forget Bancor. Oh, that was really where that...
19:52Chandra DuggiralaDon't get me started on all of the scams that exist in this industry. This podcast will never end, so let's forget about Bancor.
20:03Vlad CosteaOkay, I was going to mention that one of the show's sponsors is SideShift, and they are the swapping service, which, for example, if someone offers to pay you in stablecoins, you can just send them a Bitcoin address from SideShift, which means that SideShift does the swap and sends the money to your Bitcoin wallet. It's a pretty cool use case, but SideShift is centralized, meaning that they're the ones buying the liquidity. They run as a company to balance whatever they need for various coins, and they might also filter some transactions if, I don't know, it comes from North Korea.
20:36George BurkeWe're happy to have people use SideShift.
20:39Chandra DuggiralaAnd that's actually a great point that you bring up, because, look, there are three ways of doing cross-chain transactions, right? From 2010 to 2019, the only way to do them was actually to use an off-chain custodian of your coins, which is a centralized exchange. It's three steps, right? You send your coins to a CEX, George sends his coins to the CEX, you guys are basically adjusting entries in their database when you're trading, and when you want to withdraw your coins, they batch up transactions and send what is due to you, hopefully.
21:16The third step is where it fails, because exchanges fail every day. We all know from Mt. Gox to FTX and the recent multisig hacks to everything, off-chain custody has proven to be a terrible disaster and lost tens of billions of dollars of users' money over the years, OK? And in 2019, people invented this stupid, almost a con job where they claim it is trustless while it is decentralized, which means instead of one centralized exchange entity holding your coins, now you have like these seven different people in the multisig validators that are holding custody of your coins, and therefore it's somehow more secure.
22:01Just look at THORChain, which got hacked three times in a month, and recently almost bankrupt and they were trying to do an on-chain DAO bankruptcy like Chapter 11 or some crazy nonsense like that. So that's one way of doing things, right? On-chain custody, off-chain custody, they both failed, and I don't have to go into all of the bridge hacks and bridge failures from Wormhole to Ronin, etc. The most plain way of doing things is atomic swaps, but before we get there, what you mentioned, SideShift, to me sounds like ShapeShift and Changelly, which existed for a long time, which is like, okay, I send my money to Erik Voorhees, I trust his name, I trust his reputation, and I hope that he sends me the appropriate amount of Bitcoin we agreed on and it worked.
22:50He's a good guy. But we actually take it literally that trusted third parties are security holes, intentionally or unintentionally. So the cleanest, purest way to do this is atomic swaps, which again, like all innovations, major innovations in crypto, go back to Bitcoiners and Bitcointalk forums. So atomic swaps were invented by Tier Nolan, a pseudonym for some guy who we are eternally thankful to. Unfortunately, L1 atomic swaps don't work because they take too much time, they're too expensive, and then there's all these problems about finding your counterparty, knowing their public key hash in advance and doing the hash time lock contracts and doing the, you know, key exchange, Diffie-Hellman, whatever.
23:38It's a pain in the ass. It's a mess. That's why nobody adopted it. A lot of people tried. We tried too. It just doesn't work, can't bring the user experience to the level that you actually need to have a product that will have real world adoption instead of some bullshit that you make up to convince people to dump your tokens on. So that's why it took like five years of R&D and we can, and then there's this other thing that I will mention in passing, there's this cross-chain message passing protocols, right?
24:10Like it's the worst of all approaches. It guarantees nothing. Bitcoin doesn't give a shit about the state of Ethereum network. Ethereum doesn't care about the state of Bitcoin network. And so you have these messenger pigeons passing through these bunch of validators, which are like five DVNs or whatever, like LayerZero claims. And then somehow that is supposed to be more secure than just trusting a centralized exchange or a bridge where they're at least honest that they have like, hey, trust us. We are Jump. We back it with our money.
24:43Okay. So it's the worst approach of all. Bridges, sort of, right about that. CEXs, I actually have a lot more respect for, at least the good ones, because they take their opsec seriously. Of course you can never secure them because they are always trusted third parties and magnets for hackers and stuff like that with what happened with the Lazarus group recently. So you know, with what we've built, you don't need to trust us. You shouldn't trust us. You should actually verify everything.
25:13Vlad CosteaWell, I was going to crack a joke about Bitcoiners not verifying too much lately, but I guess it will not age well.
25:21Chandra DuggiralaThat's a great point. And I have my bones to pick with that as well. Like, look, there are true Bitcoiners like, you know, Eric Voskuil and like maybe Zooko and some other folks who, and people at Blockstream who literally take some folks at Blockstream who literally take the ethos and take it to the max, right? Like they never compromise on the principles of true self custody, stateless money, those things. And there are all of these hangers on like fleas on a beast that actually come on and they pump everything that they can pump and say like, Hey, Michael Saylor is buying all of the Bitcoin.
26:01And so buy MicroStrategy's common stock, like, do you, do you actually know how to evaluate the cap structure of a company and do you know what rights the common stockholders have? They have no idea. These are just people who picked up a, you know, $100 note on the street and they got rich. Good for them. And the hardest problem for them is they confuse their luck for skill. And now they're all about like ETFs. They're all about MicroStrategy and the Bitcoin accumulation strategies and all of this nonsense. Where does self-custody figure into all of that?
26:40Vlad CosteaWell, I'm pretty sure that they're going to show you a price chart and say, Oh, I'm making so much money. You're just talking.
26:46Chandra DuggiralaYeah. We don't give a shit about that. I mean, there's a lot of rich people. I know. I mean, you know, we respect people based on what they do, not based on where they stand for part of their day. There's a lot of scammers who can show you price charts or their bank accounts. There's probably millions of them, even in TradFi. We just ignore the noise. We don't care.
27:11Vlad CosteaIn principle, I agree with you, but once you dig deep into the community, you're gonna be in for a disillusionment and realize that some of the values that were presented maybe 10 years ago don't apply as much or not to the same extent. I mean, Lightning Network, for all the great research that it did, it made some people complacent with custody because the most popular use cases like zapping on Nostr or whatever rely on custodial services. And...
27:42Chandra DuggiralaWe don't use Nostr.
27:45Vlad CosteaWell, I appreciate your toxic approach. I think it's very much in line with...
27:50Chandra DuggiralaToxic. I mean, we give it to you straight. I don't hate on people. We don't really... I'm telling you, we don't hate people. We just don't care, meaning we don't pay attention to them. We ignore them.
28:03Vlad CosteaSo what do you think? Let me ask you about some of my sponsors. What do you think about BIP 300 drivechains?
28:09Chandra DuggiralaI don't know about them, frankly.
28:13Vlad CosteaSo conceptually, if you have a side chain that's secured by miners and you need the miners to vote on which side chain is going to get deployed and what's going to happen with the funds, do you think that's good enough to bring it to you and some other use cases?
28:30Chandra DuggiralaPaul Sztorc's drivechain approach?
28:34Vlad CosteaThat's what it is.
28:36Chandra DuggiralaYeah. So, okay. Well, I mean, I've done my digging into drivechains. I like Paul. I think it has merit. You know, the proof is in the pudding. Let's see adoption. Let's see... Let's see a lot of user activity, lots of user transactions. Let's see them bring a lot of miner revenue and then we'll see. I mean, you don't need my opinion on that. The opinion, it comes from the market. That's the truth.
29:01Vlad CosteaRight. But in order to let the market decide, you need to pass some sort of soft fork and you need consensus for that.
29:09Chandra DuggiralaYeah. Good luck to them.
29:12Vlad CosteaDoes Portal require any soft forks to work?
29:15Chandra DuggiralaAbsolutely not. Not even a single opcode change.
29:19Vlad CosteaBut is there any benefits to opcode changes that can help Portal products become better?
29:26Chandra DuggiralaLook, this is a topic that can go on for like 30 days if you really want to get into like the, I mean, Jesus Christ, when I open my Bitcoin dev mailing list emails, that's like a huge time sink for me. And they're all great arguments and people have good faith arguments on there. So one soft fork, Jameson Lopp actually wrote a very comprehensive and thoughtful piece about why we need to actually do a quantum-secure soft fork for basically OP hash signatures. That, I think, has merit.
30:04We don't need OP_CAT. We don't need any of this other shit. In my view, obviously, I could be wrong. But the reason for the way he articulated it actually resonates with me very well is that I don't actually think I'm not a quantum physicist. Okay, disclaimer. But the fact that the proof of quantum computing comes up every three, four years and Google claims quantum supremacy and then every PR agency runs with it because it's a big piece of news and it's a threat to everybody and obviously everybody wants eyeballs.
30:48You got to understand the incentives of the people behind this machine. Okay. There's a project manager or a product manager at Google who's in charge of making sure that quantum computing actually works and they can deliver results. His job is at risk. So they produce something, they push it out through their PR channels. It's the greatest marketing machine the world has ever seen, obviously. A couple of months from then, someone from Stanford or some academic publishes a paper saying, we replicated the exact same performance with just classical computers. All you need is a little bit bigger cluster.
31:22But that doesn't get the PR. It happened a couple times in the past. So this whole thing about quantum supremacy we don't believe. However, even... in the unlikely scenario, right, these are true, unknown, unique, uncertain, or UUU scenarios where someone actually cracks the code. Maybe it's D-Wave, maybe it's someone else, maybe it's Rigetti, who knows? IonQ, who knows? And they actually produce this that can break the public key cryptography, right? ECDSA-based signatures, Schnorr, et cetera. We don't know when that's going to happen or if it's going to happen, but that threat is non-zero, right?
32:07The probability of that happening is non-zero and the timeline of that happening, we don't know. So how do you proof against that? It's very simple. Just make sure that, you know, in our wallet, we actually have that already, you know, in our type of signature things. Whenever OP hash signatures is implemented in whatever quantum secure signature scheme you do, because hash functions are quantum secure, so it's a double layer security, we're ready for it. That's all I can say about that topic. That's the only thing I actually think is meaningful.
32:41All the other stuff, the layer two, the sidechains LARPing as layer two guys are pushing. I don't think you need it. Bitcoin should be ossified.
32:53Vlad CosteaSo what do you think about this invention that came from Ethereum land, which is called the ZK rollup? And there are a bunch of them coming to Bitcoin. And what they're going to do is to inscribe pieces of data containing zero knowledge proofs, which they will use under layer twos to operate.
33:12Chandra DuggiralaYeah, we ignore a lot of noise along with that, ZK rollups, all that stuff. If you bring to me a fully homomorphic encrypted system and show that it is actually efficient, economically efficient and has a use case and has adoption, then I'll pay attention. No, you're not going to get any comments from me. We ignore the noise. That's just another one of these. ZK is one of these fancy terms people use to bamboozle people into buying their tokens. We don't care.
33:40Vlad CosteaReally? So you disagree that ZK rollups can help scale Bitcoin or bring Ethereum type of operations that currently we don't have?
33:52Chandra DuggiralaYeah. Do you want Bitcoin to become Ethereum, Vlad?
33:56Vlad CosteaWell, I think it's useful to onboard some of the Ethereum users and have some of the use cases like I'm not against more users.
34:04Chandra DuggiralaYeah, neither are we. I mean, we built... Okay, let me ask you this. Where are the most users and where is the most usage in crypto generally?
34:16Vlad CosteaI think right now whatever is USDT, whatever network is sending that has the most users.
34:23George BurkeUSDT, so it's Tron. That's Tron in Latin America.
34:29Vlad CosteaAnd Solana and whatever. They're the ones that process most transactions.
34:32Chandra DuggiralaThat's right. Okay, so the biggest use case, just based on the biggest businesses with the biggest revenues, which are proxies for each other, right? If you follow the chain of logic, is exchange. Whether you're trading USDT and Solana against Bitcoin or Ethereum or some other altcoin, exchange is a proven use case with proven demand. No disagreement for me there. How do you bring all of that to Bitcoin? Bitcoin block space, we want to transform Bitcoin block space into the settlement layer for millions of markets. So we're absolutely for bringing a ton of more users to Bitcoin and expanding the use cases.
35:22But we don't want to corrupt the system. Bitcoin was built with the ethos of nuclear-grade security, right? All of the design trade-offs and decisions that have been made in taking Bitcoin to where it is today are based on that one principle of reasoning and arguing and being disagreeable and actually getting to the truth of that trade-off of not compromising those values. So when you say, do you not want Bitcoin to become Ethereum? Do you want Bitcoin to become Ethereum?
35:55Vlad CosteaWell, you can't argue against 128,000 Bitcoin that's wrapped on Ethereum right now as WBTC.
36:03Chandra DuggiralaThat's why we're building Portal to Bitcoin. You don't need wrapped derivatives. Like I said at the beginning, we don't need wrapping. We don't need multi-sigs. We don't need any of that stuff. And you can do all the stuff that you're doing on Ethereum natively with native assets. You don't need wrapped derivatives.
36:18Vlad CosteaOh, my point is that there is demand for this sort of use case, and it's much higher than Lightning and Liquid and everything else combined. And it's better to bring these users to a point where they pay transaction fees to the Bitcoin miners.
36:34Chandra DuggiralaYes, that's exactly what we're doing. But you don't need ZK rollups for that. That was your original question.
36:43Vlad CosteaRight. So how is Portal going to pay the miners?
36:49Chandra DuggiralaThe one flaw in Bitcoin design is the fungibility of block space, right? So one of the things that we have to appreciate is that Solana, the miners can discriminate against certain kinds of transactions and certain contracts and say, you're getting a lot more value from this and therefore we're going to charge you higher fees. That change I would actually be in favor of, because when we are talking about Bitcoin block space becoming the settlement layer for millions of markets and the fee per byte is the same, no matter how much value is actually captured in the security of Bitcoin, the miners will never be able to capture that revenue. Make sense?
37:35Vlad CosteaYeah, sorry, I muted my microphone.
37:39Chandra DuggiralaSo that design change, I think, in some way, shape or form will happen eventually through either a soft fork or a consensus change. And so miners, this is just markets working. This is value based pricing. This is how everything works.
38:00So when people adopt all of these things and use Bitcoin as a settlement layer for all of these different markets, whether it's DeFi, whether it's NFTs, meme coins, real world assets, in-game assets, whatever it is, fees will be raised by miners eventually because of the deflation in the block subsidy. It has to. We actually want that to happen at an accelerated pace. So miners get more revenue, which attracts more miners, which produces more hash power, which is actually what secures Bitcoin network against repeated 51% attacks.
38:38So that's the flywheel we want to spin up. And that's why we're doing this. So I'm not against bringing up, see, we called our project Portal to Bitcoin and not Portal away from Bitcoin for that specific reason. We want to bring all of these altcoin users, Ethereum, blah, blah, blah, to Bitcoin. But we never said, I heard about Bitcoin yesterday, I'm here to change it. Okay? We're not there for that.
39:05Vlad CosteaYou have a question from the audience. There's Adam Borko who says, how does Portal solve the free option problem with HTLCs?
39:15Chandra DuggiralaYeah, great question. So when I say L2 atomic swaps that actually happen almost instantaneously, Lightning doesn't have that problem because it's just one asset, right?
39:26George BurkeWhy don't you describe the free option problem?
39:28Chandra DuggiralaOkay, well, I assume the audience knows. Vlad, what do you say?
39:33Vlad CosteaWell, it's useful to describe it, just to make sure that we're talking about the same thing.
39:39Chandra DuggiralaOkay. So in L1 HTLC Tier Nolan atomic swap, the free option problem is you and I met and we agreed upon an exchange rate between your Bitcoin and my Ethereum. And so now I create a secret. I send you the hash of the secret along with my public key hash, and then you lock it up in an HTLC on Bitcoin with a time lock, and then I do the same thing with my Ethereum, right, on this. And so what happens is, because of the difference in time locks, when you claim, or when I claim, because I created the secret, when I claim your Bitcoin, I have to reveal the secret.
40:20The hash of which is locking the encumbrance on the Bitcoin blockchain. And then you have a certain amount of time between that, when that happens, to take that secret and claim my Ethereum. That's the basic tier null and atomic swap, very basic level. In that, the first step, after you made me lock up my Bitcoin, right, you could just disappear and say, oh, you now have a period of illiquidity, and you never hear from me again. That's called lockup griefing. The free option problem is after I locked up my Bitcoin, the guy who has to reveal the secret, if the price of Ethereum moves in the opposite direction of when I made my trade, okay, I don't have to reveal the secret and take your Bitcoin, right?
41:20If Ethereum is appreciating against Bitcoin, I don't have to reveal the secret. So I made you lock up your coins, you have an illiquidity. I have the option of taking your Bitcoin and giving you my Ethereum or not, and I haven't paid for it in any way, shape, or form. That's the free option, right? Options have a price. The reason why is there's uncertainty, there's, you know, lots of things go into option pricing, and I'm not going to go into that. But the way we solve it is because these are instantaneous L2 atomic swaps, when you compress the option time period to milliseconds, okay, the premium collapses to zero.
42:09Does that make sense? If it is a one year option, there's all sorts of things that go into it, the theta decay, et cetera, et cetera, that go into pricing that option. When the option expires in milliseconds, just go to 0DTEs, okay, and markets close at what, 4 p.m. Eastern Time? Look at the option prices for 0DTEs one minute before the end of the market and see how they rapidly collapse towards zero, and then they become zero. So when your settlement time, just like Lightning, is near instantaneous, you can't price that option.
42:55The premium for that option collapses to zero, and that's how we solve the free option problem. And that's why we got away from the original iteration was we were actually able to calculate with some range the premium for that option, and that the price of that option was actually included in the original HTLC. Whoever gets the free option actually pays the fees, and that gets included in the HTLC. But that was peer-to-peer, like I said, it didn't work for the user experience purposes. So we had to move to this system, and it solves the problem.
43:33Vlad CosteaThere is a follow-up question from the same person, Adam Borko. He says, how can you compress them to milliseconds? Even on Lightning, the HTLC timeouts are pretty high because they need to be enforceable on chain.
43:45Chandra DuggiralaYeah, but the state changes and the atomic swaps are not limited by on-chain transaction time, okay? They're actually limited by network bandwidth and throughput, which means latency. They're not limited by on-chain settlement, so L2 atomic swaps. If you look at Lightning, atomic swaps in Lightning for payment forwarding, they never touch the blockchain. So they don't care about the block settlement time on Bitcoin.
44:21Vlad CosteaOkay, is there any way to run a demo of the product?
44:28Chandra DuggiralaNot right now, because the testnet V2 node will be live by Wednesday next week. We can show you the videos of internal testing that we're doing, but there's a lot of node optimizations that we have to do, which are being done right now. I mean, look, there's like thousands of videos on our Twitter feed of doing Bitcoin to Ethereum swaps. Right now we're working on Solana. I don't need to prove that the product works. You have enough proof on our Twitter timeline, and like hundreds of thousands of users have used it.
45:07Vlad CosteaOkay, I was just curious if there's anything we can show in terms of user experience, because you said you have developed this. Huh? You said you have developed this by starting with the user experience, and I was curious how this actually works in practice.
45:21Chandra DuggiralaYeah, let me show you. Can I share my screen?
45:34Vlad CosteaYeah, you can.
45:37Chandra DuggiralaAll right, let's try this. Share my screen.
45:59Vlad CosteaUntil you make it work, let me plug the last few ads.
46:04Chandra DuggiralaActually, can you share your screen and go to our Twitter? The pinned tweet shows the exact swap in real time.
46:13Vlad CosteaI'm not logged into Twitter from this laptop.
46:17Chandra DuggiralaOkay, let me try one more time. It's not allowing me to...
46:22Vlad CosteaThat's weird.
46:24Chandra DuggiralaYeah, okay, okay, you know what? I think I can.
46:25George BurkeYou don't need to be logged into Twitter to see the one tweet.
46:32Chandra DuggiralaCan you see that now?
46:32George BurkeYes, I do. Well, I see it, but maybe not on the live stream.
46:38Chandra DuggiralaVlad, can you see it?
46:40Vlad CosteaYeah, let me make some adjustments so everyone can see this too. It's on the screen right now.
46:50Chandra DuggiralaYeah, it is on the screen right now. Okay, so that is our pinned tweet. Just type in the amount you want to swap.
47:12Vlad CosteaSo this is a swap between which assets?
47:15Chandra DuggiralaBitcoin and Solana. Bitcoin and Ethereum, I mean, we've demonstrated it a million times, actually 13 million times.
47:31Vlad CosteaSo how long does it take to swap between Bitcoin and Solana and what are the trust assumptions involved?
47:39Chandra DuggiralaYou're actually seeing a live screen recording, that's how long it takes. What was it, like 11, 13 seconds? In terms of trust assumptions, atomic swaps have no trust assumptions other than the primitives that you trust, right, in the blockchain itself. What are the trust assumptions in Lightning?
48:07You just trust the security of Bitcoin, you trust the hash time lock contracts, you trust the security of the hash functions, and that's it. Same thing here. Whatever the alt-chain is, Solana, Ethereum, you trust the security of that blockchain. We have no control over that. We are the cross-chain infrastructure layer, right? We're the mesh. We don't make any guarantees about the security of the blockchains themselves, Ethereum or Solana or Bitcoin. But if you do trust them, which is why you're actually doing these transactions, there's nothing else involved, there is no custody.
48:42We don't custody anybody's funds. None of the validators custody any user's funds. The key differentiator between us and any other bridge or cross-chain infrastructure projects like LayerZero, Axelar, THORChain, Wormhole, and whatever you mentioned, one of your sponsors, is that the worst case scenario in those approaches is the validators collude, they take your money, or the custodian just takes your money and runs, and you have permanent loss of your capital. In our case, let's say the validators who are a distributed network of watchtowers, and that's all they are, they only guarantee liveness.
49:24They do not guarantee fault tolerance, okay? They do not guarantee anything else because they don't have any custody of your funds. The worst case scenario is your liquidity and your trades are DDoSed for a maximum of 30 days, which is one epoch. After that, because you have the pre-commit of whatever funds you put into the blockchain in your hands before you put it in there, just like Lightning. You broadcast it to the L1, you get your funds back. So the risk of custodial permanent loss is eliminated. The one risk that still remains is that you may have a period of illiquidity, but that's nothing compared to the status quo.
50:20Vlad CosteaRight. You have another question from the chat from Hardy, who says, are we getting V2 swaps next week for real?
50:28Chandra DuggiralaYes. Well, public testnet V2 swaps by Friday for real, unless we discover some other kink in the system that we need to fix, which we don't think is likely. Very unlikely, yes. Friday next week is the internal deadline.
50:48Vlad CosteaWhen do you think that you're going to have these on the mainnet?
50:54Chandra DuggiralaGreat question. We will be ready for mainnet by the end of this month, so anytime between the end of the month. I can't give you timelines on that, because there's a lot of extraneous factors that are nothing to do with the tech, but extraneous considerations.
51:17Vlad CosteaRight. So after you launch on the mainnet, what do users need to do? Do they go to portaldefi.com or portaltobitcoin.com, I think is the URL right now, or do they have to install some sort of application?
51:31Chandra DuggiralaYeah, portaltobitcoin.com and download the Chrome extension or download the iOS app, whatever your platform is, and then just move your money into the wallet and do your swaps and use the AI agent to actually invest a team of AI agents to trade much better than just being a pleb that loses all of their bags to the sharks.
52:02Vlad CosteaYou might have mentioned this before, but which AI agent are you using and is it open source?
52:09Chandra DuggiralaIt'll never be open source. Rafa.ai is the proprietary technology that we acquired and built on top of. It is a system of hierarchical AI agents, many of them built in-house. So when people talk about these models, everybody knows that there are foundational models that are open source and you can put a thin wrapper on it and make it look good for a week on Twitter. We know how the marketing machine works. This is a multi-agent architecture with lots of layers. I'll give you a very brief description of this.
52:44There are quant agents, quant models that are proprietary and internally built, never be open source and will never be exposed to the outside world. On top of that, we have specialist agents with tools. For example, there's a deep learning model for unstructured data, limit order book analysis. There's a strategy model that is specially built for portfolio construction. You can go to Rafa.ai right now and actually look at all the agents and test them all. I don't have to market it. It's its own machine. And so there's all these agents.
53:23The LLM, whatever LLM we use, is just the orchestrator of the system. Below that are the tools that the agents use, which guarantee the mathematical accuracy, zero hallucinations, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. The LLM is just the wrapper. So what we did is the inverse of what everybody else is doing, writing a thin wrapper on top of an LLM. We use the LLM as the thin wrapper on top of everything else below. So it'll never be open source. It's proprietary technology that we took years to build. It'll never be open source. Use it. If you don't like it, don't use it. And don't pay for it. That's it.
53:58Vlad CosteaYeah, but the question is, when it's not open source, how do you make sure that it does what is best for the user as opposed to what is best for the builder of the software? Because it's going to be used for finding the best deal when it comes to swaps, right?
54:13Chandra DuggiralaYeah. How is that different than any software that you buy, any SaaS or any other software product or any other app that you buy? Is it doing what is best for you, or is it doing what is best for the software developer? Look, there's this old saying by Paul Graham that users are like sharks, okay? They only have two modes, blood, no blood, which means the product provides value to the product doesn't provide value. The proof is in the pudding. The fact that we are the number five product on Product Hunt in the entire financial sector in 2024.
54:55And number two in 2025 in investing proves the point that people do find it valuable and continue to pay for it for months, months and months on end. I don't have to prove to anybody by doing an open source audit of our proprietary stuff. No software company in Silicon Valley does this. That's really like, you know, I'm not trying to be insulting or abrasive, but the proof is going to be in the pudding. If people find it valuable, they'll use it. If they don't find it valuable, they don't have to pay us. That's all there is to it.
55:26Vlad CosteaThat's fair. But this is Bitcoin, not Silicon Valley.
55:29Chandra DuggiralaI don't care. You're using our AI software to trade Bitcoin against anything else. The trust minimized aspect of it is completely separate from the AI agent, which is a service that you pay for. We're not saying that the AI agents are trust minimized. We don't make any stupid claims like that. It is a service that you pay for. If you get value out of it, you pay for it. If you don't get value out of it, you don't pay for it. There are two components. It's a completely Web 2 product that helps you utilize our trust-minimized software to the best of your abilities.
56:07We're not saying, we're not making any stupid claims like Bittensor or anything else where they're saying, oh, open source AI agents, blah, blah, blah, so buy my token. We're not doing that. So we don't have to prove anything to anyone. All we have to prove is that if it is useful to you'll pay for it. If it is not useful to you don't pay for it. End of story.
56:26George BurkePortal wallet is open source. Rafa.ai is not a wallet. It doesn't hold money.
56:36Chandra DuggiralaYeah, it does not hold money. It is a co-pilot. If you're paying money to ChatGPT, you're doing so because it is useful. If you're paying money to Gemini, you're paying money because it's useful. In the financial space, we have the best co-pilot. If you find it useful, pay money. If you don't, don't. I don't really care about what Bitcoiners think about this. Users are users. If they find it useful, they'll pay. If they don't find it useful, we fail.
57:08Vlad CosteaThat's fair. But at the same time, you have to take into account that this is about swaps. And when you do swaps, you want to get the best deal for yourself. And there's the risk that the AI will find the best deal for the service provider as opposed to the user.
57:24Chandra DuggiralaOkay, but we're not living isolated in our own ecosystem, right? Like when it tells you to do this swap against that swap, people know what the prices are on centralized exchanges in real time. We actually provide that directly right there. People know what the fees are on other centralized trust, centralized alternatives. And so they can make their own decisions. We're transparent about that. This is a real market, man. We're not trying to actually steal people's funds by actually making the AI give you terrible advice. Because think about this way. If the investment co-pilot continues to give you terrible advice, do you think we'll survive long term as a company that makes profits?
58:19Vlad CosteaOh, I don't know about that, because, for example, on Uniswap, sometimes you have terrible rates. On MetaMask, it suggests you to send transactions at very high fees instead of telling you, well, you should wait just a few more minutes because there's this number of transactions that will clear. I mean, there are a lot of bad decisions that people make with user experience in this space. Also, Bitcoin wallets on mobile. There are people who just paid the next block fee without thinking that if they broadcast a slightly smaller fee or even half of that fee, they can just wait.
58:53Chandra DuggiralaYeah, we don't actually optimize for any of that stuff. What we optimize for is the technicals and the fundamentals. The agents actually tell you what your portfolio is, how they're doing, how each one of your tokens on the portfolio are doing, and what will give you the highest probability of success based on the best analysis possible, which you can't do in your head. That's all it is. You can take that information and go trade on Binance if you want. It doesn't direct transactions to our DEX. So maybe that's the disconnect you're having.
59:30Vlad CosteaNo, it's fine. I'm just trying to ask a question from the perspective of a user. I'm going to be paying for that AI, and I want to understand exactly what are the incentives and whether or not I can audit the code behind it to be sure it does what is best for myself.
59:44Chandra DuggiralaYeah, the incentives are if our customers don't get value, we don't get paid. That's it.
59:52Vlad CosteaThere's a question from Onyx, who says, will Portal to Bitcoin do another funding round before TGE and mainnet?
1:00:01Chandra DuggiralaWe don't have any plans to and we don't have any need to. But tomorrow if Marc Andreessen descends upon us and gives us a couple hundred million dollars, we'll take it. Just a joke.
1:00:14Vlad CosteaPharmacist is saying why is Portal taking much more time?
1:00:19Chandra DuggiralaYeah, because we're building shit that nobody's ever attempted to build or dared to build, and we've actually built it. So it takes time, man.
1:00:28Vlad CosteaFair.
1:00:29George BurkeSo you said that. By the way, we're the ones with the machetes who are, who are trailblazing into the forest.
1:00:37Chandra DuggiralaThat's right. He's wearing the hat, by the way.
1:00:44Vlad CosteaYou said that by the end of the month you're gonna have the product on mainnet, hopefully.
1:00:51Chandra DuggiralaYou'll be ready to have it on the mainnet. When it actually gets deployed on the mainnet, like I said, has a lot more considerations than just the technical: audits being completed and all of that stuff, and I can't, for good reasons, go into all of what those extraneous considerations are. But it will be ready technically. If Bitcoin drops to 20, timing changes, right? So there's extraneous considerations.
1:01:22Vlad CosteaThe swaps that will be available will be between Bitcoin, Ethereum and Solana. Is there anything else involved? Do you do USDT or something?
1:01:31Chandra DuggiralaOh, 100%. USDT, see, Bitcoin, Ethereum, Solana and all of the ERC-20s and SPLs that are on those chains. So when we say we support a network like Sui, all Sui-based tokens will also be supported. So it's not just the base currencies. It's all of the tokens that are issued on those.
1:01:54Vlad CosteaDo you believe you're competing with swapping services or centralized exchanges, or what is the endgame for Portal?
1:02:02Chandra DuggiralaYes. All of them. We want to eat all of them.
1:02:07Vlad CosteaThen why do you think businesses like Coinbase are financing your project? Is it because they're afraid of the competition and they want to control it, or...
1:02:17Chandra DuggiralaThey have no control over us. This is publicly broadcast. I know Coinbase Ventures is listed. They have no control over us. We told them right off the bat, if we succeed, your business is gonna go to shit. And we were very transparent with all of the exchanges, other exchanges that invested as well, OKX as well. And you can't stop us. Money is a commodity, if it's not your money, if it's somebody else's money, okay? So you might as well get a piece of the action, with the thinking that if we do succeed, they're benefiting; if we don't, they write it off, just like any other venture fund. But if not us, somebody else will solve this problem. You can't stop this. Technology doesn't stop for anybody else, no matter how much they try.
1:03:06Vlad CosteaAt the same time, there are some use cases which I don't think Portal can be able to incorporate, for example, buying Bitcoin with your credit card or DCA-ing with it, or custody for ETFs.
1:03:20Chandra DuggiralaYeah, you can. So, okay. So trust minimization stops at the end of the blockchain boundary. You can have fiat on-ramps through MoonPay and stuff like that, which we're incorporating, but we're not claiming that it's trust... you're actually trusting somebody else, a credit card company. Like, that's a different world. We don't make any security guarantees about that. That's up to you. You can, you can with politics.
1:03:45George BurkeDCA-ing is possible through that partner. DCA-ing is also possible from other stablecoins into Bitcoin.
1:03:52Chandra DuggiralaYeah, through the Portal DEX, for example. You can go to Coinbase, buy USDC and then, then do everything else on Portal, right?
1:04:04Vlad CosteaSo yeah, but you're not really replacing Coinbase if users are still gonna be buying with their credit cards on Coinbase.
1:04:10Chandra DuggiralaWe never made the claim that we're gonna replace the fiat bridge, because the fiat system is completely centralized, and anybody who makes the claim that their trust-minimized fiat bridge is... is lying to you. We never made that...
1:04:25Vlad CosteaNo, of course not. But you said that their business is gonna go to zero or something, which will not happen, because there is no way you can replace every other use case from which they're making money. Maybe you can make them smaller, but...
1:04:37Chandra DuggiralaYeah, maybe they'll just serve as a fiat on-ramp to the DEXes, you know. That's still a good business. And then maybe their, their custodial... See, I was specifically talking about, let me clarify, their exchange business. They still have other lines of business, right? Like their fiat bridge, fiat on-ramp, off-ramp. There's still a... I'm talking generally, not about... Centralized exchanges still have a custodial service, qualified custodial service for digital assets. That's a revenue producer. So they've diversified enough. I mean, I'm not worried about them. Neither should you be.
1:05:14Vlad CosteaI got another question from Hardy, who says, "Just the last question by me. Don't you think if Portal DEX will launch, all other DEXes are gonna be trash? We all getting everything at one place. Isn't competitors creating trouble for Portal to list themselves on other sexes?" CEXs, I think, is a better way to ask. Thank you for asking this question. So there are two sides of it: if the other decentralized exchanges are gonna be trash in comparison to Portal when Portal will launch, and are we getting everything in one place? Isn't competitors creating trouble for Portal to list themselves on other...
1:05:59Chandra DuggiralaLet me address that. I don't know what he means by creating trouble.
1:06:03Vlad CosteaI'm also trying to figure out.
1:06:04Chandra DuggiralaYeah, trouble is like, you compete in the market. You do what you can with your strategy to compete against us, and we do what we can to crush you, and that's how markets work. I mean, what more can I say, you know? We built a superior product, and if we are good at distribution and marketing and actually delivering on the promise, they will be trash. That is our stated goal. It's not like we're hiding it from anybody else. That is our stated goal. That is our mission, to conquer this space.
1:06:35So yeah, they can try to create trouble. I mean, hopefully they won't try to kidnap anyone in our company and do all sorts of shady shit. If they do, there's nobody we can't reach out and touch. Trust us on that.
1:06:53Vlad CosteaOkay. I don't know how to respond to that, especially the last part.
1:06:57Chandra DuggiralaThis is just to his, to his specific question, which is very unlikely. They can create trouble by creating a superior product, which is, which is how competition works, right? That's okay. They can create a better product. They can compete with us on different dimensions, better distribution, all of that stuff. There's nothing we can do about that except being better.
1:07:20Vlad CosteaI know that you guys have quite a lot of users on Discord who have been testing the product for many years.
1:07:27Chandra DuggiralaYes.
1:07:28Vlad CosteaAnd I was curious if the users have steered the development in any way, or you stuck to your roadmap.
1:07:39Chandra DuggiralaCan you say that last word again, last statement again?
1:07:42Vlad CosteaSo I was curious if the feedback from users has delayed development in any way, because they discovered something that was important, or it was just following the roadmap all along.
1:07:53Chandra DuggiralaIt has helped us tremendously. It has also delayed the launch of the product by a lot. But that's how you actually iterate and fix. We are fortunate enough to have a lot of users that are heavily, heavily invested in testing the product to the max and making sure that we solve... Like, when we ran our testnet, we solved almost like seven, eight hundred tickets in the span of six weeks. That was only possible because of the crowdsourcing of the testing to our heavily engaged user base, for which we are eternally thankful. Okay, so of course, yes, they made the product a thousand times better. That also takes time, obviously.
1:08:38Vlad CosteaI remember a few years ago that the conversation was also about building an operating system for Bitcoin. Is that still part of your design?
1:08:51Chandra DuggiralaThat word is actually... Well, what does the operating system mean? We kind of moved away from that, because there's a lot of terrible marketing noise in this space about Bitcoin OS and this and that and all the other stuff. And so we moved away from that. The question is, what is the need for an operating system on Bitcoin? We're solving a specific use case, right? We're solving trust-minimized cross-chain transactions, whether they're swaps, perps, stables, options, whatever it is, right? When you say operating system, are you talking about like a personal financial computer? Like, I don't even know what that means.
1:09:39So, you know, that was Eric's vision, to build an operating system on Bitcoin. I'm still not sure what that actually means, so I can't comment on that.
1:09:51Vlad CosteaThat's fair. I'm taking a look right now on the partners on your website and these are going to be integrating Portal infrastructure. I noticed that you're going to be working with BRC-20s and Stacks, which is formerly Blockstack.
1:10:08Chandra DuggiralaYeah, yeah, I mean so when we started last year the biggest demand for integrating trustless swaps was from these wrapped coins on sidechains like Stacks is a sidechain right. They have sBTC, so you send BTC into a multisig wallet, they issue sBTC, hopefully pegged one-to-one. All we said to all of these L2s that were coming out last year was look if you integrate Portal. using our swap SDK or actually the liquidity router it's a separate product for SDK integration. Your users will be able to trustlessly or trust minimize atomic swap sBTC right back into BTC.
1:10:52It's an exit pathway with no risk because the problem with all of these wrapped derivatives is when the peg breaks and the question is not if the peg breaks it is when the peg breaks. Okay so no derivative should be priced at par with the underlying asset if there is a even a tiny non-zero risk that the peg will break. Does that make sense to you?
1:11:21George BurkeSo you're not creating a market between sBTC and natural BTC.
1:11:28Chandra DuggiralaRight so what we're allowing people to do is actually discover the price between how these wrapped BTCs should trade against native Bitcoin and we're not pricing it the market will price it.
1:11:49Vlad CosteaRight now I was thinking about how this is going to work in practice because you want to turn Bitcoin into a settlement layer for a wide array of financial operations. So you're going to have data about these operations being added into the Bitcoin blockchain is that correct?
1:12:08Chandra DuggiralaNo, all we're saying is that eventually when let's say let's take Stacks for example right like let's say Stacks conquers the DeFi space on the L2 it's let's say it becomes the dominant L2 where all the DeFi things that can happen on Ethereum can happen on Stacks. Right? You can trustlessly then swap STX into Bitcoin, right? Or sBTC back into Bitcoin because eventually it's the most not eventually but for the foreseeable future and now it is the most secure globally seamless settlement system ever devised.
1:12:54I don't think anybody will disagree with that. That's what we mean by making it a settlement layer for millions of markets. It's not about taking the data and putting it on the blockchain and basically spamming the Bitcoin block space. The transactions will be will all be compressed into whatever they can be compressed into. And therefore the miner revenue should actually increase which like I said will secure Bitcoin make Bitcoin more and more secure.
1:13:26Vlad CosteaRight now I'm looking at your website you have this very nice network architecture diagram that shows interaction between the BTC chain the Ethereum chain and there's also Portal in the middle which I'm not sure if it's supposed to be your service or it's also a token of sorts that participates in this economy.
1:13:48Chandra DuggiralaWhich is the network of validators that serve as a distributed network of watchtowers. So if you're familiar with the watchtower functionality on Lightning that exists because you don't actually think that the clients are going to be live at all times and someone doesn't broadcast a previous state that was invalid and then try to steal your coins. That's why watchtowers exist. It's the same it's the same it's essentially the same function. So that's the Portal network. It's an app chain. It doesn't hold custody of anyone's coins. It only guarantees liveness of the functionality of these cross-chain transactions. Not the trust assumption. It is not about the fault tolerance. Only the liveness.
1:14:43Vlad CosteaSo my follow-up question is where's the data about these swaps being stored? Is it on the Bitcoin chain on Ethereum or the watchtowers?
1:14:53Chandra DuggiralaIt's going to be stored on the Portal chain. That's why it exists. It's called the Notary Chain for that reason, because we don't want to clog the Bitcoin block space with all of these swaps data. Do we need to store it? For several reasons including legal yes I believe that the design is appropriate and so therefore it was built to store that data outside of the Bitcoin blockchain. But once the settlement is done you only need it for audit purposes. That's why it's called a Notary Chain. You don't need it for settlement.
1:15:22Once your swaps are done your settlement happened on the Bitcoin blockchain. You're done. This is just a record of what swaps happened between whom.
1:15:30Vlad CosteaOkay, so Portal is running a basically independent chain that is...
1:15:37Chandra DuggiralaIt's an app chain, yes. It's specifically built for an application purpose. It's not another L1 or anything like that. The world doesn't need another L1 for god's sake.
1:15:48Vlad CosteaNo it doesn't. Yeah it's an interesting design. I can see why you took shots at THORChain which by the way is not my sponsor and it's not related to SideShift.
1:16:00Chandra DuggiralaOtherwise you would have had to cut this cut this interview short.
1:16:05Vlad CosteaNo. Criticism is fine. Competition is also good.
1:16:09Chandra DuggiralaYeah appreciate it. We agree.
1:16:12Vlad CosteaThere's no reason for me to make radical decisions because we disagree about something. There is a question from Moonlight on the chat. He says how can we trust on protection of funds from Quantum attacks? What proof is Portal gonna give that they are truly secured from Quantum attacks? I guess he meant.
1:16:33Chandra DuggiralaRight now nothing because Bitcoin is not Quantum secure. When OP hash signatures opcode gets actually implemented, right? Then we are ready for it on day one. That's all we're saying.
1:16:50Vlad CosteaYeah it's a good question and also a pretty good answer. We do need some sort of Quantum security in Bitcoin even as you said. Even if the threat is small.
1:17:03Chandra DuggiralaIt's small, but it's not zero. So, you know, as a wallet, we have the unique privilege of actually enabling the OP hash signatures on day one. So whenever Bitcoin is quantum secure... as long as the underlying chains are not, we can't claim that we are.
1:17:20Vlad CosteaI don't think I have any more questions about Portal at this time. I'm very excited to try the product when it comes out.
1:17:28Chandra DuggiralaWe'd love to have you as a beta tester and if you like it, tell your audience about it if you want to.
1:17:34Vlad CosteaBut I do have a question which sort of comes from Bitcoin.com which right now they rebranded their BTC-only website. But they still support Roger Ver's cause, and I was wondering what you guys think since I think Roger was one of the first participants to the Silicon Valley meetup.
1:17:53George BurkeHe created the meetup that's right along with Andreas Antonopoulos. And he still owns the meetup but from afar and I hope he's not still owning it from the inside of a jail cell. I hope that goes away.
1:18:13Chandra DuggiralaI don't have any comments on that. I don't know what Roger Ver's cause is, so I can't comment on that. But if you're talking about what happened to him legally. Is that the cause you're referring to?
1:18:26Vlad CosteaNo, I mean this whole situation with the IRS because right now there is a petition going on and he's trying to get clemency I guess from the Trump administration. That sort of sucks because according to his claims there is no price that he can pay for his freedom. Like the IRS did not ask for an amount. They're just trying to put him in jail.
1:18:48Chandra DuggiralaI mean, look, I think he's well intentioned. I think he tried to solve the problem of the block space debate in his own way with Bitcoin Cash. We may have disagreements there. I do believe that he was well intentioned. I don't know the details about his case or what he did or how they actually got him or what they charged him with and I'm not a lawyer. So I can't comment on that. I wish him well. I wish everybody well. But beyond that I don't know much.
1:19:23Vlad CosteaYeah. Anyway, for those of you who are not familiar with it, you can check out the documents which have been publicized on. I think it's FreeRogerNow.org, if I'm not mistaken. But also Bitcoin.com has had a major rebrand. So if you check it out now, it's very different from what you remember. Especially the news section.
1:19:45Chandra DuggiralaThank you. I appreciate that. We'll check it out. Like I said, I hope it ends well for everyone.
1:19:57George BurkeYeah, I don't want to see innovators like Roger, who Bitcoin owes a debt of gratitude to for what he did in the beginning to be suffering like this. But also, I'm not in his wallet, and I don't know what he did or didn't do.
1:20:18Chandra DuggiralaThe problem with questions, I mean, I'm not saying I'm critiquing you for asking the question or your audience. But the issue with the problems with issues like these is these are deep, deep, deep dives one needs to have to have a strong opinion on. And I don't know anything at all about what he did, what he didn't do. Did he violate the law? Did they actually try to make him a scapegoat? You know, what they charged him with, what the laws are. I have no idea.
1:20:44Vlad CosteaI think I've mostly asked the question for George, because I know that he attends the meetup in Silicon Valley, which...
1:20:53George BurkeYeah, the meetup had been on hiatus for quite some time. I've spent a lot of time away from Silicon Valley and I live in Puerto Rico now. And I actually do want someone to take over the Silicon Valley Bitcoin meetup. It's the first ever meetup about Bitcoin and the greats in Silicon Valley who turned Bitcoin into what it is today. Maybe not today, because people like Michael Saylor are what are driving that type of Bitcoin adoption today. But in the early days, man, that was very much centered around San Francisco and the Bay Area. And yeah, hopefully someone good will be able to take that on.
1:21:46Vlad CosteaYeah. Anyway, I got to give thank you to NoOnes.com for also sponsoring. They're this peer to peer exchange that's trying to bring empowerment to the global south. And also Hodling.ch, a Swiss service that's trying to provide assistance to those who need help with their self custody, especially companies if they want to do multi-sigs for buying Bitcoin on their balance sheet. So check them out. Yeah, very important. It's, I guess, the newest trend right now with companies buying Bitcoin. Are you guys identifying with this new crowd of people who only care about who's buying Bitcoin and how much they own?
1:22:29Chandra DuggiralaNot sure. Are you talking about MicroStrategy imitators, or?
1:22:34Vlad CosteaYeah, pretty much.
1:22:35Chandra DuggiralaOK.
1:22:38George BurkeIt'll reduce the supply.
1:22:41Chandra DuggiralaFine by me. Well, I mean, it's a, it's an interesting strategy in the sense that Michael Saylor is probably the greatest sales, second or third greatest salesman that or maybe sixth or seventh in the world. But he's able to sell his convertible debt and actually able to market his common stock that holds no rights and no value to a lot of people and produce returns. So kudos for that. It's like I don't have any grudge. You know, you know, if it works for them, good for them. Obviously, there's competition because it is working for him.
1:23:24And we recently found out that David Bailey is doing the same thing. And there was another one called DeFi Development Corp that a friend tried helped bring to fruition for accumulating Solana and so on and so forth. So it's the market seems to like it. So, yeah, that's my observation. I don't have any strong feelings about that.
1:23:47Vlad CosteaIt's just about the narrative of never selling your Bitcoin, never using it for anything else other than speculation. I think it's detrimental to the entire space and a lot of builders suffering from it.
1:23:59George BurkeAnd you're saying that, Vlad, because, because the name of Satoshi's white paper is a peer-to-peer cash system.
1:24:05Vlad CosteaI'm not going to go into that. People will think I'm a big blocker. But my point is that most of us got into Bitcoin because we saw this as a better form of money. And now we're being told, well, it's not supposed to be used as money. Just hoard it, get as much as you can and just sit on your stack.
1:24:22Chandra DuggiralaYeah, I'm with you on that 100 percent. People who make those stupid claims really don't understand the Bitcoin network architecture. If nobody transacts on Bitcoin, the miner revenue goes to zero. And then what secures the network after the block subsidy expires? I don't think which is what my problem with these hangers on these fleas on the body of Bitcoin is that they're primarily marketers clinging on to a trend. And you can't expect them to really understand the game theory and the mechanics and the design and the beauty of Bitcoin.
1:24:55So they can have their stupid opinions. We don't care. You know, we don't have time to go through every one and refute everybody else. I'm with you on that. Bitcoin as a currency, if it is not transacted and used and holding it is not used in the strict sense of the term. That is not what it was built for. It was built. I'm with you on that. It was built to separate money from the state. End of story.
1:25:21Vlad CosteaDo you still believe we're going to accomplish this or are we just going to get USD rich?
1:25:28Chandra DuggiralaI'll take USD rich. Don't get me wrong. You know, I want to get USD rich. Who doesn't?
1:25:38Vlad CosteaYeah, I don't know. I'm a bit confused about what I see around myself. And when I check Twitter, I don't feel like I'm part of this movement anymore because I have different ideas.
1:25:50Chandra DuggiralaWell, you feel like an old soul, like me. Like, we still believe in the original ethos. And it's like, look, the world is always going to be noisy, my friend. I mean, you know, you're never going to have purity and purity spirals don't help you psychologically or mentally or physically. So it's like forget about all of the noise. Stick to what you believe in and do your thing like you're doing right now. It's like, you know, what else is there? You know, why do you why do you need to care about all of these useless people with stupid opinions?
1:26:24George BurkeUSD on chain was such a novel concept to me. And being in Bitcoin since 2013, building a Bitcoin debit card in the U.S. where people would spend their coins converted into USD at the point of swipe. The concept of USD on chain was really foreign to me. And even the Tether founders had pitched me on investing. I was I was like, I don't I don't get the I don't get the concept. You're telling me this US dollar coin is meant to do what? He's like, well, it never goes down. And I'm like...
1:27:08Chandra DuggiralaFor the value of the service, because people want to have this friction-free transactions into something that is stable and is money today, which is US dollar in terms of volatility. And so it does provide a valuable service. So that's great.
1:27:26George BurkeThat's right. And the times have changed, right? The market has proven what it wants.
1:27:32Chandra DuggiralaYeah, that's...
1:27:33George BurkeThat's what I'm getting at.
1:27:34Chandra DuggiralaWe're building a product that the market wants, you know, all the entrepreneurs that build products that the market wants and desires and they succeed. They'll always have my respect.
1:27:49Vlad CosteaOK, thank you very much, guys. You told me you only have one hour. I've held you for one hour and a half. If there's anything I didn't ask you about, but you really wanted to mention, this is your chance.
1:28:03Chandra DuggiralaOK. Yeah. So I got something. OK, so go to portaltobitcoin.com, or x.com/portaltobitcoin, and join our Discord community. And then you'll be you'll be amazed how many wonderful people there are who actually believe in what we just spoke about. So you'll be part of a wonderful community and we're going to, we're going to shake up this space.
1:28:36Vlad CosteaAre they trying?
1:28:38George BurkeSounds good. I'll end this with why we built what we built. The crypto ecosystem, The community has a short memory. And because I've been in this space since 2013, I've seen exchanges hacked year after year after year. And the security often gets better, but the hacks get larger. Right. We recently saw a 10 figure hack, the first ever, and that will continue to happen and it will get larger. Thank God the industry did not did not die as a result of it. And thank God that the company that it happened to was able to cover those losses.
1:29:27But that won't always be the case. So what we built is meant to prevent robbing. It's meant so people can can take what is the weakest link in crypto, which is exchange between chains and make it as safe as possible. So that way, that can now be a reliable method of interoperability.
1:29:56Vlad CosteaSounds good. And also, will you guys be attending any conferences over the next few months?
1:30:03Chandra DuggiralaWe try not to. Sometimes we are forced to. But, you know, our focus is getting to mainnet ASAP, getting the mainnet ready, getting as many users to adopt the self custodial solution and the AI-enabled better trading solution, Rafa, as possible. I'm sure someone from our BizDev team will attend. But yeah, I mean, I personally am not a big fan of wasting time at conferences unless unless it's like you go somewhere, you set up all of your I shouldn't give out the secret sauce, but probably everybody knows this by now.
1:30:43Set up set up all of your meetings close to the venue and just get out of there. You know, I don't like to waste time at conferences generally.
1:30:53Vlad CosteaPro tip, just spend your time in the hallway and talk with people. It's more productive. Yeah. You can watch the presentations on YouTube when you get home.
1:31:02Chandra Duggirala100 percent. That's actually my strategy. But being in the hallway. But also the problem with conferences is everyone meets 500 people at a conference. So your your mental bandwidth of memory, how many people you remember, how many you can actually follow up with and get a follow back. It's not the most the most efficient use of use of time, in my opinion. But hey, those who attend and get value out of those...
1:31:30Vlad CosteaThank you very much, Chandra and George. I wish you best of luck with the launch of Portal to Bitcoin and its latest iteration, which sounds very promising. And you made some bold claims right there. I look forward to seeing the users migrate from centralized exchanges to Portal. And thanks to the sponsors. Once again, NoOnes.com, Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, citrea.xyz, Bitcoin.com News and LayerTwoLabs.com. Thank you very much. And I'll see you in the next one.
1:31:30================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization (Guest A -> Chandra Duggirala, Guest B -> George Burke, Vlad Costea). Unlabeled continuation paragraphs inherited the previous speaker. Speaker turns were checked with local TitaNet speaker embeddings (4 s windows over the whole episode, plus 1.5 s windows at about 25 ambiguous spots), which moved or split: 'Yep. So I'll give you a brief update' (Chandra), the 17:13 crosstalk ('I'll take a look at... / Go ahead. / No, you go ahead'), 'We're happy to have people use SideShift' (George), 'Toxic.', 'some other use cases?' (end of Vlad's drivechain question), 'It's on the screen right now' (Vlad), 'Yeah, we don't actually optimize for any of that stuff' (Chandra), 'That's right. He's wearing the hat', Chandra's 'Yes' at 1:07:27, 'That word is actually' (Chandra), 'It's small, but it's not zero', 'The problem with questions' (Chandra), 'It'll reduce the supply' (George) / 'Fine by me' (Chandra), and the 1:27 stablecoin exchange between George and Chandra. Second opinion: YouTube auto-captions of the published video (read-only copy from the Zcash documentary project, S16E25.en.vtt / S16E25.timed.txt; YT time = mp3 time + about 18 s), word-aligned to the ASR; about 600 non-trivial word differences reviewed by hand. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed from the published mp3 with local faster-whisper (small.en, int16, no prompt) on 88 short clips. Restored dropped stretches: the opening 'Hello there and', 'the parent-child thing, and then you can't have multiple counterparties', 'we're trying to solve a specific...', 'So yeah, not a better... I mean', 'someone from Stanford or some academic publishes a paper saying' (ASR gap), 'I mean, we built...', 'Where does self-custody figure into all of that?', 'store that data outside of the Bitcoin blockchain', 'We don't care', 'Who doesn't?', 'an old soul, like me', 'That's right. And the times have changed'; punctuation and casing restored for the unpunctuated 1:00-1:10 stretch. Notable name/jargon fixes: Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, Citrea / citrea.xyz, Bitcoin.com News, LayerTwo Labs, NoOnes.com (sponsors); Portal to Bitcoin / portaltobitcoin.com / portaldefi.com; BitScaler; channel factories, Christian Decker, Roger Wattenhofer, ETH Zurich, Blockstream, Johnny Dilley, Eric (Martindale); Raiden; Rafa / Rafa.ai; TradFi; proto-money; C-Lightning; n-of-n multisig; Tier Nolan; HTLC; lockup griefing / free option problem; L2 atomic swaps; 0DTEs; theta decay; THORChain; Wormhole, Ronin, LayerZero, Axelar, Jump; ShapeShift, Erik Voorhees; Bitcointalk forums; security holes; Eric Voskuil, Zooko; MicroStrategy, Michael Saylor; Nostr; BIP 300 drivechains, Paul Sztorc; Jameson Lopp, quantum-secure soft fork, OP_CAT, D-Wave, Rigetti, IonQ, Schnorr; ZK rollups; WBTC; Binance; Bittensor; Product Hunt; Marc Andreessen; Sui, SPLs, ERC-20s; Coinbase Ventures, OKX, MoonPay, DCA-ing; Stacks, sBTC, STX, BRC-20s; Notary Chain; Roger Ver's cause, FreeRogerNow.org; Andreas Antonopoulos; Bancor, Uniswap, Paradigm. Kept as spoken: 'OP hash signatures' (Chandra's term for a hash-based, quantum-secure signature opcode), audience handles (Adam Borko, Hardy, Onyx, Pharmacist, Moonlight). Leftover uncertainty is marked in square brackets with 'unclear:' and a best guess.