S16 E25: Chandra Duggirala & George Burke on Portal & Making Exchanges Obsolete
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript13,948 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
"Everything else is a sidechain LARPing as an L2." That is Chandra Duggirala's one-line review of the cross-chain bridge industry, delivered about four minutes into our Google Meet call with the two co-founders of Portal. Chandra is the CEO and chairman, George Burke is the co-founder who also runs the Silicon Valley Bitcoin meetup, and it was the third time I had interviewed people from the project.
The pitch is a cross-chain exchange protocol that moves value between Bitcoin and other chains without multi-sigs, vaults, bridges or wrapped derivatives, and it was supposed to be on mainnet by the end of the month we recorded. I wanted to know how that squares with the claim that Bitcoin should be ossified, whether an AI copilot that will never be open source belongs anywhere near a Bitcoin project, and what happens to the project when the exchanges it wants to replace get angry. George opened by pointing at his own face ("I already have the beard"), and the conversation did not get softer from there. It ran an hour and a half.
"We don't really care about decentralization"
The first thing Chandra did was throw out the vocabulary I had prepared. Portal's earlier incarnation was a decentralized exchange effort that, as Chandra put it, "didn't take off. DEX took off." The current goal is stated differently: "We don't really care about decentralization. We actually care about trust minimization and cross-chain operations."
The word "trustless" goes in the bin along with decentralization. "We don't use the word trustless because there's nothing trustless, right? Including Bitcoin." What you trust in a Portal swap, as Chandra laid it out, is "the security of Bitcoin, you trust the hash time lock contracts, you trust the security of the hash functions, and that's it." Against that Chandra set the usual alternative: "no multi-sigs, no vaults, no bridges, no wrapped derivatives, none of those shenanigans which claim to be trustless."
George was a little more generous with his own wording at one point, saying "we built the first cross-chain AMM that is as trustless as can be," so the two of them do not agree on the adjective. Chandra's broader complaint about the industry was that it is "full of scammers who try to hide their security vulnerabilities and their own personal insecurities under a lot of computer science jargon." Chandra had a specific target in mind, which was ZK, "one of these fancy terms people use to bamboozle people into buying their tokens."
One anchor transaction, ten thousand users
The scaling design is called BitScaler, a channel factory built as an automated market maker. George explained the mechanism, and it starts from a limitation of the thing most people reach for first: Lightning "is, unfortunately, only peer-to-peer." A channel factory changes the arithmetic, because you need "just one anchor transaction that opens that channel for 5,000 people, 10,000 people."
I asked how far that goes. George did not claim to know: "We don't know how far it can scale. I'd love to find out what that top number is." Chandra's hope was bigger and vaguer: "many, many thousands, hundreds of thousands of users." The on-chain footprint, Chandra said, comes out at "96% less than even Lightning."
Then Chandra declined the comparison I was setting up. "We're not trying to build a better Lightning Network," Chandra said, and described Portal as "an alternative interpretation of off-chain scaling mechanisms for Bitcoin." Chandra's reasoning is that the proven demand lies elsewhere. "The proven demand is for cross-chain exchange." On the money question Chandra went further: "Bitcoin is not money yet," and the usual definition of money Chandra called stupid, since by it "cans of expired sardines in prisons and cigarettes can also be considered money."
I got the usual instinct wrong at one point and it is worth saying so. I leaned on the Lightning framing for most of the first half hour, and Chandra kept steering me back to swaps. The reason Lightning keeps coming up in these conversations is that it is the thing Bitcoiners already know. I covered LNBits V1 in S16 E17 with Ben Arc.
Swaps at the speed of the network
The claim I found hardest to picture was the swap time. Atomic swaps are normally gated by block confirmations. Chandra said Portal's are not: what limits them is "network bandwidth and throughput, which means latency," and "they never touch the blockchain."
The option-pricing angle was new to me. A swap, in Chandra's telling, is a kind of free option, and "when you compress the option time period to milliseconds, okay, the premium collapses to zero." That, Chandra argued, is why speed is the answer to the griefing problems that plague slower atomic swap designs.
Chandra supported it with numbers. Chandra said the system had been used "actually 13 million times," a figure Chandra attributed to Bitcoin-to-Ethereum swaps, and that on screen you are "actually seeing a live screen recording, that's how long it takes. What was it, like 11, 13 seconds?" That 13 million is Chandra's claim, and I could not verify it from my side of a video call.
Custody and failure modes got their own stretch. "We don't custody anybody's funds," Chandra said. The worst case Chandra described is a DDoS: "your liquidity and your trades are DDoSed for a maximum of 30 days, which is one epoch," after which funds can be recovered on L1. Chandra's comparison point: "but that's nothing compared to the status quo." The public V2 testnet swaps were due shortly after the V2 node release, and mainnet readiness was set at the end of the month, with a caveat: "We will be ready for mainnet by the end of this month." No firmer deployment date was offered, citing external factors.
The community testing, by Chandra's account, produced "solved almost like seven, eight hundred tickets in the span of six weeks" from Discord testers, and also "it has also delayed the launch of the product by a lot."
Ossified Bitcoin and 128,000 wrapped coins
Here I pushed hardest. Chandra had said "Bitcoin should be ossified," and also that Portal wants to "transform Bitcoin block space into the settlement layer for millions of markets." I asked how those sit together. Chandra's first answer was a direct one on soft forks: Portal needs "Absolutely not. Not even a single opcode change." On OP_CAT: "We don't need OP_CAT."
Chandra was relaxed about the other camps. On covenant proposals and the people behind them Chandra said "I don't know about them, frankly," and "Good luck to them." Paul Sztorc's drivechain work got a different reaction: "I like Paul. I think it has merit." Paul made his own case on this show in S15 E68 on activating drivechains via CUSF. Chandra's only other kind word for a protocol change was for hash-based signatures: "OP hash signatures. That, I think, has merit."
Chandra's answer on quantum risk was a person-shaped one. "There's a project manager or a product manager at Google who's in charge of making sure that quantum computing actually works and they can deliver results. His job is at risk."
I then brought up wrapped bitcoin. "You can't argue against 128,000 Bitcoin that's wrapped on Ethereum right now as WBTC," I said. Chandra answered with a question: "Do you want Bitcoin to become Ethereum, Vlad?" Then Chandra turned the point around. Portal's answer to those wrapped coins is, in Chandra's words, "Yes, that's exactly what we're doing" (Chandra said it right after I described the demand for BTC liquidity elsewhere), followed by "You don't need wrapped derivatives." On the project name Chandra added: "we called our project Portal to Bitcoin and not Portal away from Bitcoin for that specific reason." They want to "bring all of these altcoin users, Ethereum, blah, blah, blah, to Bitcoin."
Chandra also named what Chandra thinks is the one design flaw: "The one flaw in Bitcoin design is the fungibility of block space." Chandra started a sentence that began "I would actually be in favor of," and I will leave it where it stopped in the audio.
On the sidechain world Chandra was blunt in a way that fits the earlier line: "the question is not if the peg breaks it is when the peg breaks." And on the layer-1 question: "The world doesn't need another L1 for god's sake." Swap data stays off-chain, Chandra said, "because we don't want to clog the Bitcoin block space with all of these swaps data." The Notary Chain exists for audit and record-keeping, not for coin settlement.
A closed-source copilot and the Silicon Valley defense
Portal also ships Rafa, an AI investment copilot, and the exchange over it was the tensest one of the show. Chandra's position: "It'll never be open source." Chandra's reasoning leaned on what Chandra called industry practice: "No software company in Silicon Valley does this."
I said what I figure most of my audience would say: "But this is Bitcoin, not Silicon Valley." The reply was two words: "I don't care."
George separated the pieces for me. "Portal wallet is open source. Rafa.ai is not a wallet. It doesn't hold money." Chandra added that the tool is deliberately thin: "We use the LLM as the thin wrapper on top of everything else below." Chandra was also careful about what the AI agents are not. "We're not saying that the AI agents are trust minimized." And it does not steer you into Portal's own market: "You can take that information and go trade on Binance if you want. It doesn't direct transactions to our DEX."
How it makes money is a user-value argument, quoting Paul Graham: "users are like sharks, okay? They only have two modes, blood, no blood, which means the product provides value to the product doesn't provide value." And in Chandra's own terms, "if our customers don't get value, we don't get paid."
My objection that code you cannot read is a hard sell in this community did not move Chandra, and I did not expect it to.
Eating the exchanges
The ambition is not subtle. Portal aims to replace the centralized exchanges, and Chandra said it in so many words: "We want to eat all of them." Chandra told me what that means for the incumbents in the same breath: "if we succeed, your business is gonna go to shit." As for their response, Chandra predicted it too: "we do what we can to crush you, and that's how markets work." I admitted I did not know how to respond to the last part. Chandra has a separate warning, which I will paraphrase rather than endorse, that competing exchanges should not try anything physical against Portal's staff, kidnapping included.
George supplied the history that shapes the thinking. "The crypto ecosystem, The community has a short memory," he said, and he has "been in this space since 2013," long enough to have "seen exchanges hacked year after year after year." The industry's first "10 figure hack" was his main exhibit. He also told me he passed on an early investment chance in Tether in 2013, which he mentioned as a different kind of centralized-risk lesson. What Portal fixes, in his view, is "the weakest link in crypto, which is exchange between chains."
I pressed on the fiat side, because a swap protocol still needs people to get dollars in and out. Chandra's concession: "maybe they'll just serve as a fiat on-ramp to the DEXes," and "trust minimization stops at the end of the blockchain boundary." I recorded a separate episode with Andreas Brekken about SideShift. Chandra said: "trusted third parties are security holes, intentionally or unintentionally." Chandra described the Bitcoin and Ethereum bridge model as "messenger pigeons passing through these bunch of validators."
Pizza, funding, and why Bitcoin has to be moved
On fundraising, Chandra joked about taking money from Marc Andreessen if offered. On rival projects and critics: "I mean, we give it to you straight. I don't hate on people. We don't really... I'm telling you, we don't hate people. We just don't care, meaning we don't pay attention to them. We ignore them." The rest of the hour was looser. Chandra said "Well, you feel like an old soul, like me," when we landed on the question of whether Bitcoin should be spent at all.
That was the argument I wanted to have. Bitcoin, I said, was always pitched as money, "And now we're being told, well, it's not supposed to be used as money." I added that "People will think I'm a big blocker." Chandra's answer was an economic one: "If nobody transacts on Bitcoin, the miner revenue goes to zero." And on the purpose of the thing: "was built to separate money from the state."
Chandra had a line on holders who rode the price: "confuse their luck for skill." Asked about being rich in coins versus dollars, Chandra said "I'll take USD rich." George had a different view on supply: "It'll reduce the supply," meaning the effect of locking coins into channel factories. The conference circuit did not appeal to Chandra: "I don't like to waste time at conferences generally."
The practical side of the conversation came down to an invitation and an admission. The invitation: "We'd love to have you as a beta tester and if you like it, tell your audience about it if you want to." The admission came when I asked about proof: "I don't need to prove that the product works." Chandra then allowed that the security isn't absolute: "It's small, but it's not zero." And on the larger claim: "we can't claim that we are." Chandra wished other projects well: "I wish him well. I wish everybody well."
George's last practical note was about his own calendar. "I actually do want someone to take over the Silicon Valley Bitcoin meetup," he said.
Asked what Portal is, Chandra stuck to a description of effort and said: "building shit that nobody's ever attempted to build or dared to build, and we've actually built it." George's version is lighter: "By the way, we're the ones with the machetes who are, who are trailblazing into the forest."
Listen to Chandra Duggirala & George Burke on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:01:02– Introducing Chandra & George
- 00:02:26– Portal's Mission
- 00:03:32– Trust Minimization Explained
- 00:04:55– Evolution of Portal's Technology
- 00:06:08– Bit Scaler
- 00:08:28– Removing Trust in Exchanges
- 00:09:44– AI Integration in Financial Markets
- 00:11:39– Clarification on Lightning Network
- 00:12:04– Bit Scaler vs. Lightning Network
- 00:15:27– Channel Factories Explained
- 00:18:04– Automated Market Makers Overview
- 00:20:57– Centralized vs. Decentralized Exchanges
- 00:24:15– Challenges of Atomic Swaps
- 00:25:17– Critique of Cross-Chain Solutions
- 00:26:22– Understanding Cap Structure
- 00:26:57– Self-Custody in Bitcoin
- 00:28:03– Toxic Approach to Bitcoin Values
- 00:28:20– Drivechains Discussion
- 00:29:29– Does Portal Require Any Soft Forks?
- 00:30:43– Quantum Security in Bitcoin
- 00:33:10– Critique of zk Rollups
- 00:34:33– User Demand in Crypto
- 00:35:25– Bitcoin as a Settlement Layer
- 00:39:33– Free Option Problem Explained
- 00:44:45– Demo of the Product
- 00:51:11– Launch Timeline for Mainnet
- 00:52:26– Proprietary Technology Overview
- 00:54:05– Is the RAFA AI Open Source?
- 00:55:22– Value Proposition
- 00:56:16– User Experience and Trust
- 00:58:37– Market Dynamics
- 01:00:03– Incentives for Value
- 01:00:10– Funding Round Speculation
- 01:00:37– Development Timeline
- 01:01:04– Mainnet Deployment Expectations
- 01:01:49– Supported Assets for Portal Swaps
- 01:02:19– Does Portal Compete with Exchanges?
- 01:02:37– Investor Relations
- 01:03:37– Trust Minimization Limits
- 01:07:45– User Feedback Impact
- 01:09:08– Operating System Concept
- 01:10:14– Integration with Other Platforms
- 01:12:25– Bitcoin as Settlement Layer
- 01:15:10– Data Storage for Swaps
- 01:15:57– Independent Chain Functionality
- 01:16:29– Quantum Security Discussion
- 01:17:38– Beta Testing Invitation
- 01:18:02– Roger Ver's Legal Situation
- 01:21:10– Silicon Valley Meetup Insights
- 01:22:30– Bitcoin Adoption Trends
- 01:24:00– Market Strategies and Competition
- 01:24:40– Bitcoin's Original Purpose
- 01:26:40– USD on Chain Concept
- 01:28:22– Community Engagement
- 01:29:56– Security in Crypto Exchanges
- 01:30:20– Conference Attendance Strategy
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
e57cfbd6ddfc3a7d5e5da7c12793b782aa01610ff55ebf2ef0b2215d5284aab5- Proof
- 2025-05-18_s16_e25_portal_to_bitcoin_with_chandra_duggirala_george_burke_-_18.05.2025_14.08.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 18 May 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-05-18_s16_e25_portal_to_bitcoin_with_chandra_duggirala_george_burke_-_18.05.2025_14.08.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-05-18_s16_e25_portal_to_bitcoin_with_chandra_duggirala_george_burke_-_18.05.2025_14.08.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-05-18_s16_e25_portal_to_bitcoin_with_chandra_duggirala_george_burke_-_18.05.2025_14.08.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-05-18_s16_e25_portal_to_bitcoin_with_chandra_duggirala_george_burke_-_18.05.2025_14.08.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
Portal Presents Ordinal Atomic Swap Tech Demo
For a couple of years now, the Portal team has been working on “DeFi on Bitcoin layer 3”. The project, which was…
S10 E1: Eric Martindale and George Burke on Portal and DeFi on Bitcoin Layer 3
Eric Martindale and George Burke on Portal, atomic swaps over Lightning, what a layer 3 is, privacy by default, why Bitcoin Core…
S14 E18: Lisa Neigut & Calle on Scaling Bitcoin & Free Open Source Software
During the 10th edition of Hackers Congress at Paralelni Polis (HCPP), I’ve had the pleasure to meet Lisa Neigut and Calle. The…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.