S16 E26: Mark Edge on Freeing Ian Freeman & Free Talk Radio
Search this conversation
0:47Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 26. This episode is sponsored by NoOnes.com, Hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News and LayerTwo Labs. And we are live with the one and only, the John the Baptist of Bitcoiners, Mark Edge of Free Talk Radio. He has been a leading voice in libertarian radio for more than 20 years. And he's also responsible with his co-host and partner, Ian Freeman, of onboarding a lot of Bitcoiners. If you've listened to the interview with Vitalik Buterin, he does mention that he heard about Bitcoin from a libertarian radio station, which I'm 99% positive it was Free Talk Radio.
1:34And Roger Ver heard about Bitcoin for the first time from Free Talk Radio and was onboarded by Ian Freeman. And it's really amazing. It all comes full circle. And now I get to interview the guy who's responsible for so many big names in our industry. So hi, Mark.
1:51Mark EdgeThank you very much. I can't take full responsibility, but I am delighted for my little piece of Bitcoin history. I would think that people like Roger Ver and Eric Voorhees, Charlie Shrem, Vitalik Buterin, I would think that these people would have found Bitcoin absent Free Talk Live's mention in 2010. But nonetheless, we did happen to be the first mention. You know, it's... I'm grateful.
2:24Vlad CosteaSo how did you guys find out about Bitcoin and why did you promote it for such a long time?
2:30Mark EdgeSure. So the story goes this way. Essentially, on December the 28th, 2010, just 2010, a caller from Australia, Jeremy West called in, and he had lived there for some time. He's an American living in Australia, and he was familiar with the show. I knew him and that kind of thing. He mentioned magic internet money, and we were very skeptical to start with, as you can imagine. Is it backed by gold? You know, we sounded like pirates back then. We cared deeply about gold. But I mean, we did talk about alternative currencies of other sorts, Ithaca HOURS, the Berkshire bucks and some other things.
3:16And a lot of credit card startups that were trying to use gold to purchase things. But the Liberty Dollar is probably another one worth mentioning. But basically, you know, we mentioned Bitcoin, we were skeptical. Then a very important person heard that broadcast, Gavin Andresen. He was one of our amplifiers, you know, our little Mickey Mouse club. There were maybe 500 of them at the time, and they were paying three bucks a month for a commercial-free broadcast, because broadcasts like this, flawed, don't just happen for free.
4:00So basically, Gavin heard it. He sent us an email that said, hey, I'd like to explain Bitcoin further. It didn't matter what. He wanted to meet in town. We were in Keene, New Hampshire. He wanted to meet and talk about it. And we would have met an amplifier to see pictures of their kids. Doesn't matter. If you come to town, you want to meet us? Absolutely. And so we did meet at the Thai Garden restaurant on Main Street in Keene, New Hampshire. We were there for about two hours.
4:31Gavin has since called that the most profitable lunch of his life and credits Free Talk Live as being the first stage in a multi-stage rocket that shot Bitcoin into the stratosphere. Now, of course, when he said this, Bitcoin was worth a few thousand dollars. I believe I looked today and it was about 105. So, you know, yay, I offered at that meeting to sell Gavin some podcast ads. We didn't sell them for much back then. Some podcast ads for Bitcoin becoming the first ad venue in the world to accept Bitcoin for ads on that day in January 2011.
5:14And then we talked about Bitcoin that evening. By the way, as I recall, Gavin did not purchase those ads that I offered. So we were not the first ad venue necessarily to successfully sell, accept Bitcoin for ads. I would have to check in on that one, too. So we talked about Bitcoin that evening. And Roger Ver, an advertiser on Free Talk Live at the time, heard that show and he describes it as sort of a manic episode. He spent three sleepless days researching Bitcoin. He was so excited about it.
5:49And Bitcoin was very exciting at the time. We used terms like anonymous, which was clearly false. We used terms like peer to peer. We used permissionless. We used a variety of terms, private, you know, to describe Bitcoin. Unstoppable, unhackable. I remember a lot of these terms. And some of them, you know, have stood the test of time. Others not as well. But I remember even back in that same year saying that if Bitcoin's worth a dollar, meaning that if it holds on to the value of one dollar, then it's worth a million.
6:28I hope to be correct one day. Obviously, Bitcoin's changed quite a bit since 2011 when we were talking about it. But basically, Roger Ver demanded at some point that he be able to advertise his, you know, well, he wanted to advertise Bitcoin. So shortly thereafter, he advertised Bitcoin instead of MemoryDealers, which was one of... which was his business at the time. And we advertised that. And I don't know how successful we were advertising MemoryDealers. They sold optical transceivers. I'm not even clear what that is.
7:03I know that on one occasion, one listener who happened to be an IT guy bought a whole bunch of them. And Roger claimed that made all the advertising worth it. But it doesn't make me proud that we only brought in one buyer. Nonetheless, we advertised Bitcoin pretty much every day after that, probably starting in maybe February or March of 2011. And then at some point, Roger said that he would like to advertise pay for his advertisement in Bitcoin. And I remember this distinctly. Basically, I allowed him to pay for his... our new day, Sunday, because we had gone from six days a week to seven days a week for a period of months.
7:49He paid for those with Bitcoin and Bitcoin was worth a dollar. I remember, and of course, we had to spend Bitcoin to pay bills and these kind of things. And but I remember taking... through Crypto X Change, was the name of the company. You can look it up. Their logo is still out there if you look for them. And somehow I went to the Bank of America in downtown Keene on that same main street called Central Square at the end. And I withdrew $1,000 that I had previously sent 1,000 Bitcoin to get.
8:27And I took these $1,000 and I fanned them, smacked them and fanned them out in front of, you know, my wife and my business partner. And I said, look, it's not just alpaca socks, VPN services and Girls Gone Bitcoin. It's real money. And that's, I think, the sum total of Free Talk Live's sort of early days in Bitcoin. Many people listened and many people found out about it and many people did far more work within the Bitcoin sphere than we did.
9:03Vlad CosteaYeah, but it's so cool. Like, I'm not aware of many other shows that were doing this at the time and you're advertising Bitcoin. And that's, I think, admirable. I think Roger did something very nice there because I think he's also responsible for propagating the meme that Bitcoin is the honey badger of money. He put an ad on some highway, which was very visible during, I guess, rush hour. And yeah, just advertising Bitcoin as opposed to your business is very selfless and cool.
9:39Mark EdgeYeah. If you look at Bitcoin as a multi-level marketing scheme. And I remember people asked me that early. If you look at it that way, then, yes, we are double diamonds or something like that. But one more thing I should mention is, is one of our co-hosts, Stephanie Murphy, was one of the founding hosts of Let's Talk Bitcoin. What I believe to be the first Bitcoin podcast. If you don't count Free Talk Live as a Bitcoin podcast.
10:09Vlad CosteaNow, Let's Talk Bitcoin turned out to become a network after I guess it branched out from Free Talk Radio. And it was sort of a big deal in the early days. It had some of the most prominent names and builders. And I think it's a treasure. The shame regarding the whole project is that I think it was taken over by Bitcoin Magazine. And I'm not sure if they maintained it properly.
10:36Mark EdgeOK. All I can tell you about Bitcoin Magazine is I met the publisher or something in the early days and Vitalik Buterin was a reporter for Bitcoin Magazine. And that's when we interviewed him on Free Talk Live many long years ago. I can't remember. You know, people can go back and find the interview. I'm sure it's search on the Internet. We have archives going back for 20 years at FreeTalkLive.com. But yeah, he was he was definitely on the air.
11:09Vlad CosteaIt's amazing. But I have to ask you, and this is sort of the reason why we decided to do this interview. Why is that only you that I'm interviewing right now? And where is Ian Freeman?
11:20Mark EdgeYeah, thanks for that. So Ian considered Bitcoin, probably still does, but Ian considered Bitcoin the best path to freedom. Ian is a passionate libertarian, as am I. And he thought that the best way to get the world to be more peaceful were founding members of Bitcoin, not bombs. And we and I think this and I love telling the story because I think it's very important. In the 40s in the United States, when the World War Two was being prosecuted, the government would come to the people regularly and say, buy war bonds.
12:02That's the whole story behind Captain America. If you've seen the first movie is Captain America was a, you know, a sentinel to get you to buy war bonds, not to go out and punch Nazis. And somewhere between that and the Iraq war, where a reporter asked Iraq war, war on terror. I'm not entirely sure if I can recall, but George Bush was asked, what can we, the American people do to support the war on terror or something? And George Bush said, go shopping. Now, something happened between 1940s and the 2000s that changed things.
12:46Now, if you want to, you know, quick lesson on that, check out the Bretton Woods Accords and, you know, those kinds of things, The Creature from Jekyll Island to understand what happened to U.S. money and world money. But essentially the U.S. dollar went from being backed by gold. And because the United States didn't want to pay France any debts, it stopped being backed by gold. And we just said, the dollar's a dollar. Essentially, it's backed by the full faith and credit of the United States government and a country, any country with unlimited funds can prosecute unlimited war.
13:24And we knew that and we'd known that for a long time. So Ian wanted to get cryptocurrency in the hands of as many people as possible. He wanted a mission. That mission included LocalBitcoins.com, Bitcoin.com slash local, any variety of ways that he could promote Bitcoin, the acquisition thereof, the investment in whatever it might be. And he, you know, in the name of our organization, the Shire Free Church, he sold, donated, I don't know, you describe it how you want, but allowed people to acquire Bitcoin.
14:05And they did. We had 5,000 five-star reviews on LocalBitcoins. And that's because people got what they asked for. Now, we know surely that in that amount of time, some people were buying Bitcoin for bad reasons, but Ian didn't want people to tell him exactly why. And they were buying Bitcoin. But when he did ask questions like, are you buying this for an investment? They would answer yes. He would ask questions like, do you know what a romance scam is? Have you ever met your boyfriend?
14:45You know, questions like this. And I was there. I know he asked these questions. I can, you know, I watched it happen over and over again. And basically one day in 2021, our studios were raided by the Federal Bureau of Investigations in a multi-force task force that ran two tanks into our building. This is essentially Ian's house. He lived upstairs. The studio was downstairs and flew a drone in. They brought in two SWAT teams. And it was really something. I happened to be in Mexico on the day of the raid, but I was there within a few days and there was still glass on the carpet.
15:32We had put plastic up over the window. And for some reason, this is the most irritating part to me, one of these FBI agents or whatever, somebody was working. One of these SWAT team members decided to come in the studio and start pulling wires out of the back of our broadcast stack. Now, Ian had set this up. It was great audio. And he helped me set this audio up that you're hearing me on now. He's a genius at this. And this guy gets going and pulling wires.
16:02They took Ian away. We didn't know how to put it back together. And we had a heck of a time getting back on the air. So I believe that there's a very good argument that the Federal Bureau of Investigation compromised the First Amendment rights of a half a million listeners by doing so. This Free Talk Live was a venue that anybody could call in and talk about anything they wanted to talk about. So when they go and they mess that up for a week, it's really hard to talk about it.
16:32Vlad CosteaYeah, that's really unfortunate when you think about it. I heard. So correct me if I'm wrong. I think the reason why Ian got arrested was his ATM business or something, something along this way.
16:45Mark EdgeSo he also had some ATMs that were, you know, I think two or three that were in different locations around Keene, New Hampshire, so that people in Keene could access Bitcoin and people would come from far and wide in order to use these Bitcoin ATMs. And yeah, basically the feds charged Ian with a whole host of things, most of which got dropped before the trial. But when he went up for trial in 2023, he was accused of, pardon me, I'm just going to scroll forward here. So I've got it.
17:28Four tax evasion charges, one unlicensed money transmission, one conspiracy to commit unlicensed money transmission, money laundering and conspiracy to commit money laundering. I sat through about 80 percent of that trial. There were dozens of people there that were supporting Ian. They were on the stands and these kind of things. But the jury was swayed by the little old ladies who came in and said that, you know, they got tricked by Nigerian princes. And so they essentially convicted the guy at the of the gun store of committing the robberies.
18:09You know, the guy selling the guns at the gun store of committing the robberies. It doesn't make any sense. But nonetheless, the one of the things I think that's most important about the trial is the IRS agent. That's for those of you who are listening in foreign lands, the IRS stands for the Internal Revenue Service. And although you quaking in your boots in other countries might fear the United States military, we, the U.S. citizens, fear the IRS because this organization doesn't abide by its own rules in any stretch of the imagination.
18:41But the IRS agent sat up on the stand and affirmed that, in fact, they did not know at trial whether or not Ian Freeman had a tax burden. They did not know what that tax burden was. And a tax burden is an integral part of those four tax evasion charges. Now, the jury found Ian guilty because that's how juries work and you should not long for these things. This is 12 ignoramuses judging you is not something to wish for. But the jury found Ian guilty on all eight charges.
19:16And I believe had he been up on Jimmy Hoffa's murder or the, you know, the murder of Mahatma Gandhi, that they would have found him guilty of that, too, just because they would have found him guilty of anything.
19:31Vlad CosteaWell, that's really messed up, but didn't this happen in the aftermath of the whole SWAT team operation? So in a way, you can argue that the jury was set up to have their minds made up before they even heard maybe the details of the case.
19:47Mark EdgeI don't know. I think that if you were going to claim that something affected him, probably all the bad press surrounding Bitcoin, which is, you know, for years, politicians in the United States were calling Bitcoin the currency of terrorists and drug cartels. Then this was right around the time that Sam Bankman-Fried was arrested. And, you know, Bitcoin just looked scammy, I suppose, to people. And I would, if there was an opportunity to, for me to run Ian's trial, I would have handled things differently than his attorney did.
20:28Obviously, hindsight's a real benefit, and I'm sure his attorney would like to change some things about what he did. But that's kind of the problem with, you know, a trial is that you go forward without knowledge of how things are going to go. And the outcome is the outcome. So currently, in February of 2025, well, I should mention that Ian was sentenced to 96 months and a very large fine, which included 100 Bitcoins. Then in February of 2025, I went to the First Circuit Court of Appeals.
21:11This is the step down from the Supreme Court. For those who don't know, this is in Boston. Ian's trial occurred in New Hampshire. And, of course, the three judges who were there mentioned the IRS situation, which I thought was very promising. Also taking into consideration that the United States is founded on the notion that it is better that 10 guilty men go free than one innocent man is incarcerated. So this expedited appellate bond that Ian had asked for, I expected within weeks. I was told two to eight weeks, but expect it closer to two than eight.
21:52It's been 13 or 14 weeks since then. And, oh, by the way, these three judges, none of whom was ever a prosecutor in the United States or anywhere else. So I thought that was also very good, but I haven't seen anything from them. And one of Ian's lawyers speculated that perhaps cryptocurrency is now considered a Republican issue. And because the judges are in Boston, maybe they're more on the liberal side and they don't want to rule in favor of cryptocurrency and thus orange Hitler, you know, and whatever. So is it politicized? I don't know. But I think the short answer is everything, everywhere is politicized.
22:46Vlad CosteaWell, that's sort of messed up. It destroys this fairy tale of the state of law, right? Where politics is not involved and then there's due process and you have precedents and legal situations which are followed accordingly. Like, I'm not sure if Ian's case has a precedent. I'm not aware of it. I'm not a lawyer in the US. I do know that in civil law systems like in Europe, except for the Great Britain, it's a lot simpler in some ways. And you're not subjected to the whims of a judge or the jury. It's all about what the law says. And if there is no law, basically, there is no crime, you know?
23:27Mark EdgeYeah, I think that in the US, essentially, you know, the bureaucracies have said that Bitcoin is funds. Now, we would make, Ian would make the argument, and I think that it's a fair argument, that Bitcoin is code. It's ones and zeros. And since it's ones and zeros, it's protected by the, I think, 1996 Microsoft ruling. Where the Supreme Court said that code is speech. And since speech cannot be infringed, Bitcoin cannot be infringed. Now, the judge did not allow Ian to bring this up in trial.
24:11As I understand it is brought up in the appeal. But, you know, that wasn't my major concern with the appeal. My major concern centered around the tax evasion charges. Because, interestingly, the jury found Ian guilty of that money laundering charge. But about a couple of months later, the judge came in and said that the jury was in error and pulled that out. So Ian only went to the circuit court with seven of the eight charges that he was guilty of. And if that court overturned four of them, he would be remanded back to trial on a bond to await something. Some change.
24:55Vlad CosteaWell, it sounds like a very messy case. Is there any page where I and everyone else listening can read the details or I know that you have a petition going on, but is there any place where you also have all of the legal information to get informed about this particular case?
25:16Mark EdgeFreeIanNow.com should have a great deal of information for those that wish to research more fully. You can also look up the Crypto Six. This is what we were calling the six people that were arrested on that day. All of those people have basically completed or were never sentenced to, you know, either had charges dropped or had, you know, whatever the problem was taken care of, essentially. One other person, Aria DiMezzo, did some time, but everybody else got, like, probation and that kind of thing. Aria DiMezzo, I believe, got 18 months. Ian got 96 months. So there's a stark difference between their two sentences.
25:55Vlad CosteaIt's still a very long time for. So 96 months is eight years.
26:01Mark EdgeYeah, it's, yeah, the, I would say the United States judicial system is largely broken. Aria DiMezzo took a plea bargain and got less time. Now you could say that those are two unrelated facts, but the fact is, is that the vast, vast, vast majority, far less than 1% of cases in the United States make it to a jury trial. They're either dismissed by the prosecutor or a plea bargain is reached. And a plea bargain doesn't give the public the opportunity to try a bad person for doing something bad.
26:42It doesn't give the accused an opportunity to, you know, have a jury of their peers, as we're told, is this wonderful thing. And basically it only serves the people who committed real crimes, right? So you get a less lesser sentence. It is called a bargain. After all you get a lesser sentence if you've done the crime and it serves the bureaucrats, the lawyers who are hired to do trials. So, you know, one could say there's far too many charges in the United States to run through the court system, but I'd say there's far too many things illegal in the United States.
27:20Just like, as you said, in Europe, it was legal for quite some time to do, to sell Bitcoin. And I don't, I wouldn't, this is not legal advice. I'm not advising anyone to sell Bitcoin in Europe. I don't know. But, you know, essentially Ian would have been fine if he'd have been a resident of Romania or Holland or wherever.
27:44Vlad CosteaYeah. Sometimes I feel sorry for citizens of the land of the free, because for all of the freedoms that you enjoy, sometimes mostly the ones protected by the first and the second amendments, you also have some trade-offs, especially due to the legal system and the fact that sometimes there are some laws that apply retroactively in a very non-fair way.
28:10Mark EdgeThat's another thing, fair thing to mention. They brought up Bitcoin sales from 2015 in 2021, excuse me, 2023 at a trial. So it didn't look right to the jury's mind because other rules and regulations were added along the way. Now the prosecution would say, this wasn't a trial about regulation. This was a trial about, you know, Ian knowingly ripping off little old ladies, which of course they provided no evidence for because it wasn't true. You know, as a guy who was there day in and day out, I wasn't even allowed on the stand.
28:56Vlad CosteaIt's messy. And I do wish all the best for Ian. I got to tell you that I have this privacy magazine behind me and let me grab it because there's a page where Ian is actually mentioned alongside all of the other freedom causes in the space. I messed up the Pepe in my background, but I got to look this up. Pepe will be back, folks. Don't you worry. There is this other Pepe.
29:24Mark EdgeDon't worry. As long as we got a Pepe.
29:27Vlad CosteaOh, no, it's not this one. Wait.
29:29Mark EdgeYeah, I thought it was a different cover. I remember seeing the wrong magazine. I remember seeing the article and it was at, of course, ETHDam, or "Eeth-dam," whichever you prefer, in Amsterdam just a couple of days ago. And that's it.
29:45Vlad CosteaYeah, it's this one. This is the old one, actually, and all of them are open source. You can download them.
29:50Mark EdgeCan you explain the cover to me? Because I'm not entirely sure I understand.
29:54Vlad CosteaSo are you aware who this is? I have seen his name connected to Bitcoin. Right. This is Michael Saylor. Just today, he was sued by some investors because they're not happy about the performance of his Bitcoin strategy. Anyway, he's always saying that there is no second best. You're going to get rich. One Bitcoin is going to be like $100 million and whatever. He's orchestrating a scheme where he gets into debt and then buys more Bitcoin and then gets, I guess, another loan and uses the Bitcoin as a collateral and then gets people invested in his stock and uses the money from dividends to buy more Bitcoin.
30:37And it's just this. I don't want to call it anything. I don't want to give it a specific name, but it smells like something.
30:45Mark EdgeYeah, it allows people to presumably purchase Bitcoin through the stock market, I think is what he's trying to create. And again, I won't use any terms because I am not a lawyer or a finance guy, but yeah, I don't know how his stock has performed against the actual coin. And if people want to invest in Bitcoin, I'd recommend getting a wallet and investing in Bitcoin.
31:15Vlad CosteaWell, his stock actually did pretty good because it entered S&P 500. It was dead for like 20 years. And then he started buying Bitcoin and telling people that they should buy Bitcoin too. And anyway, he's always saying there is no second best. And at the same time, this Pepe character, which is best known in pop culture for saying it feels good, man. He's right here in his private moment, taking a leak and watching this guy even in his private time because he's so obsessed with his investment. And he has a security camera in the room that's watching him. And his line is, it feels bad, man. It feels so bad.
31:58Mark EdgeIt clearly is speaking about privacy and presumably the lack thereof when it comes to Bitcoin transactions. If anybody wants to find out more about how transparent Bitcoin transactions can be, I'd encourage them to read, or just watch... listen on Audible, Tracers in the Dark. This goes over the Ross Ulbricht case and a variety of other cases and just talks about how not private coin transactions can be.
32:33Vlad CosteaRight. And on the back cover, there is the same character. You see that his face looks happy. He's getting rich. He's going to be a millionaire. But if you look around, there is no door for him to exit. He's stuck. There is no door here. You can see in front of him there is no door. There is no door in the back. He's stuck and he's being surveilled at the same time. I see. And it's a very nice metaphor for the state of Bitcoin. You feel captured.
33:03You feel like you've been entrenched by mainstream financial system by the same people you're claiming to replace or make obsolete or whatever. And now they are in control and you're getting rich. But at the same time, your freedom and your privacy are at stake. And it's a matter of morals and principles. But I did mention the page. I think it's number 97, which has Free Ross. So the magazine was published in November. So, of course, it has Free Ross before Ross was actually liberated in January after Donald Trump became president.
33:48There was also Free Ian Freeman. He's right next to Ross. I hope that he's next. Pardon Snowden, another important cause. Edward Snowden is maybe part of the reason why I'm into Bitcoin today. Before his revelations, I was very oblivious of a lot of stuff happening on the Internet. And then I realized that I need to change my patterns and behavior. And I became interested in privacy. There's also Roger Ver. Like him or not, he was instrumental in spreading Bitcoin in the early days. And the crime for which he's being, I guess, held right now in exile in Spain is a bit ridiculous.
34:37He's not even aware of the amount of money that he must pay to the IRS for his freedom. It's a bit silly.
34:45Mark EdgeIt doesn't make any sense, the Roger Ver situation, either. I visited Roger, I think, in November of last year in Spain. He is free-ish in so much as he can wander around the province of Spain that he's in. But he is not free in the sense that he can leave there. And he's also facing 109 years. The Spanish government has ruled on his extradition saying that he can be extradited, which appears to be contrary to their constitution. But nonetheless, if you're being threatened by the biggest guy on the block with a baseball bat in his hand, then maybe you'll just go ahead and break your own rules, too.
35:32But Roger, his situation just doesn't make any sense from a legal standpoint, from a lawfare and retributive standpoint. Oh, absolutely, it makes sense. But from a legal standpoint, the idea that you're going to go after a guy who used two of the major tax attorneys, tax attorney firms in the United States to file his returns when he gave up his citizenship, that doesn't make any sense. I mean, you would go after these tax agencies. You'd talk to them about the problems. You'd discuss it with Roger, how much he owed.
36:15He would know what the expectation was. And then maybe you'd go after him. But they just nabbed him. And it's like, we'd like to bring him back to the United States for trial. What's he accused of exactly? If you don't have a dollar amount, you're not accused of anything specifically.
36:37Vlad CosteaIt was also interesting to me when you mentioned that Ian Freeman had to pay 100 Bitcoin. Like, does the federal government charge Bitcoin for stuff or was it 100 Bitcoin worth of dollars?
36:49Mark EdgeSo it was an interesting situation Ian had. Previously, he had had a vault in a different location, but he, for, you know, just... he ended up keeping this item. It was a 100 Bitcoin Casascius bar that was gold-plated. He kept it in his... he was... On that day, it was in the safe in his house. So when they came in and they busted open the safe, which, of course, nothing's safe when the federal government's around. Bitcoin, you know, Bitcoin's secure. But if you've got a 100 Casascius bar, they can pick it up and take it. He also had in that safe two of the two Trezor wallets, which I guess that they weren't able to get the Bitcoin out of in that particular circumstance.
37:42Vlad CosteaSo that's such a good advertisement for Trezor.
37:47Mark EdgeWell, I don't I think Trezor has gotten better since then, but maybe they didn't react quickly enough and the wallets were emptied. I'm not entirely sure how it worked. I am not here advocating for Trezor in this particular case.
38:03Vlad CosteaComing back to the page, which I showed to you, there is also a mention of Tornado Cash, which is not a Bitcoin specific cause. It has to do with Ethereum, but it does have to do with open source developers building privacy tools. And it feels like we're going back to the 1990s with the crypto wars, which Phil Zimmermann and his PGP had to fight. And also Free Samourai, which is a privacy tool for Bitcoin. The two creators of Samourai Wallet were arrested last year. I think within a week it will have been a full year since they have been held captive.
38:43And their case is also sort of ridiculous because they were accused of being money transmitters, which they were provably not. Their wallet was not custodial in any way. They were not holding users funds. And all of these, to some extent, maybe with some exceptions like Snowden, they feel like just situations. I don't want to call them something else or victims of the Biden regime. There was that war against crypto. Maybe it wasn't just Biden. It was Elizabeth Warren or something when she decided to start that anti-crypto army.
39:22But all of these were prosecuted around the same time. And it's interesting that today, how many of them were actually freed? There's Ross. I think some of the Tornado Cash developers were freed, but they did not have to deal with American courts. I think that their case was settled in other countries in Europe.
39:48Mark EdgeRight. So Ian specifically asked me before I came on to talk about Tornado Cash and Samourai Wallet. And you've done so far more intelligently than I can. I can't say I know everything about their case, but I did use Samourai Wallet in the past and I can assure you it is non-custodial. But that's one of the things about Bitcoin is you need to take responsibility for the holding of cryptocurrency generally, instead of turning it over to some wallet where they hold the wallet for you. I would recommend that you have your own non-custodial wallet, not your keys, not your coin.
40:36Vlad CosteaThat's the best advice. There's actually a sponsor that deals with this. If you hold a lot of Bitcoin and you don't know how to manage it, they're based in Switzerland and they provide the service of advising you what kind of setup you should be using. They're called Hodling.ch. That's what their website is. And they also did an interview in the previous season of the show. I think it's season 15, episode 60 ish. And they give you some free advice. They give you some advice on how you should manage your backups to make sure that you have at least one backup outside of your house, to have at least three... how should I put them, slices of the pie that you are distributing.
41:21Mark EdgeMultisig wallets, yeah.
41:22Vlad CosteaYeah. And for example, if you're a company that's buying Bitcoin, they will explain to you how you should share the keys with the shareholders to make sure that your CTO or the IT guy is not going to be able to steal all the coins whenever he wants. Or if you're like a whale, someone who got in very early and just slept on this Bitcoin stash and now you recovered it, maybe it's scary for you to keep it in your house at all times.
41:48Mark EdgeIt ought to be. You know, we just had somebody kidnapped in Europe and not too long ago, like last week. This is happening over and over again. If somebody finds out that you're an early adopter of Bitcoin, then they may target you and you want to very publicly inform people, I don't keep private keys on me or in my home. There's no way I would let my family sleep in the same building where private keys were kept, because anything awful could happen if people find your address. Obviously, I try very hard to keep people from finding my address.
42:33Vlad CosteaOf course. Also, don't tell random people on the Internet where you live. If you win a free T-shirt from some company, think twice.
42:42Mark EdgeIndeed. I hadn't even considered that. People send me free T-shirts all the time. But yeah, it's one of those things. Books, T-shirts, when you're on the radio, people send you a lot of stuff.
42:54Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. So check out Hodling.ch. They're pretty good at this.
42:59Mark EdgeI keep a private mailbox. I don't know if you guys have these in Europe, but essentially at what we call UPS stores and a variety of places, you can get a little mailbox and they'll accept your packages and that sort of thing. And I find that to be a better system than handing out the place where I'm going to sleep tonight.
43:17Vlad CosteaYeah, I actually got that. It's called the Post Office Box. Unfortunately here, this only works with the National Post, which is not always the fastest, but it's not expensive. It's like $30 per year and I have my own box. I go there maybe once a month. I check it. I see if I got anything. I'm usually relieved when I didn't get anything because it means I don't have to do any extra work. Sometimes I do receive something. I've been sending magazines all around the world. Sometimes they come back because I put that address as the sender.
43:50And it's also convenient from a practical point of view, because if I put my mailbox from where I live, I have a very tiny mailbox. I don't want the postman to try to stuff that package inside of the tiny mailbox and destroy the contents. I have a larger space. It's convenient. I definitely recommend getting a Post Office Box. Go to your local Post Office. Talk to the lady behind the counter. Maybe that she's using Windows 98, but I guarantee you that the service is not going to be that bad.
44:22Mark EdgeSo we have Post Office Boxes in the United States too, but they're run by the Post Office, which is a quasi-governmental organization. And I find that I would rather have a box that, well, the address is different. So, for instance, it would be Mark Edge, Post Office Box 123, Keene, New Hampshire, and then the zip code 03431. Whereas the private mailbox will be an address. So say 63 Emerald Street, number 301, Keene, New Hampshire, and blah, blah, blah.
45:05Vlad CosteaYeah, that's so cool. I was responding to someone who seems excited about our interview, and I sent him the link to check it out on Twitter.
45:14Mark EdgeI don't find that I can do both, talking. This is the new thing that broadcasters have to be able to do that I am not prepared for. The idea that you look at people talking on the internet and respond to that while talking to the host or whomever. Anyway, I have retweeted this interview, and I hope people enjoy it greatly. And I hope Free Talk Live listeners get a chance to listen, too.
45:45Vlad CosteaI hope so, too, because there is a lot that they can learn, even though if they're regular listeners, I guess they already know about Ian and they know about your story with Bitcoin. But let's insert something new into the conversation. But before that, I have to plug two more sponsors. So I said Hodling.ch. There's also SideShift, a service that swaps coins very fast and with low fees. For example, let's say that someone wants to pay you in stablecoins, USDT or whatever, and you're going to be like, I don't want to hold on to that CBDC wannabe.
46:17I want free market money. So what you can do is to put your Bitcoin address in there, and then you're going to get for this swap a USDT address that you send to the person who's going to basically transmit to you the CBDC wannabe. And what you're going to get after this transfer is just BTC in your wallet the way that you want it. The fees are pretty low. The liquidity is pretty good. Check it out. It's SideShift.ai. And there's also Bitcoin.com news, which is one of the websites which champions these freedom causes.
46:52I think the domain is owned by Roger Ver, but the editorial board and the content is no longer BCH friendly. I also want to ask about that, by the way. But I did see over the last few months that Bitcoin.com has underwent a transformation where they're moving on with the market trends. They're not trying to be dogmatic about which side of the block size wars is right and which one is wrong. And they have pretty good articles nowadays. If you look at their website, they cover geopolitics, they cover what's happening with gold, they cover what's happening with Bitcoin around the world.
47:27I honestly have a lot of respect for their journalism, and it was my idea to reach out to them and say, hey, I want to promote you guys. Let's make a deal.
47:36Mark EdgeIs that Jamie Redman there, still the publisher?
47:40Vlad CosteaI'm not sure. Okay. I know of two guys who are working there and none of them is Jimmy. Jamie. Yep, Jamie. Okay.
47:51Mark EdgeYep. Still, I can't speak intelligently about what Bitcoin.com's philosophy is these days. To me, I would say the Bitcoin wars, what I call World War geek, it's over. And the sides that have won have won. And I don't think there's any reason to continue shooting in this war. That everybody's got their coin. Their coin does what their coin does. It does it better or does it worse, whatever it might be. And you can have your favorites. I think that the best thing to do is to acknowledge the truth about everybody's currency, rather than saying unnecessarily negative things about it.
48:42And this goes for both sides. This is the maxis and the, I don't know what we're calling the S-coiners, whatever we want to call ourselves. I definitely, I still feel a little bit of frustration when I think about the Hong Kong Accords and how raising the block size from one meg to two megs. And the suggestion that somehow this was going to ruin everything just doesn't make any sense to me. But if everybody wants more nodes, more mining nodes, if you want to really secure the network, you would go after Bitcoin and you'd reduce the difficulty.
49:29The reason that Bitcoin miners are so powerful right now is because they're the only ones with computers that can do the job. You have to have specialized machines. You have to have a lot of them. And by a lot, I don't mean dozens. You need to have thousands of them in order to be able to play this game. And the average person just can't play it. So if you want more nodes and you want more security for BTC, you should be advocating for... in my opinion, and this is no one else's opinion, I haven't heard this from anybody.
50:02And frankly, is you should be advocating for less difficulty. Now, I'm sure that there are some people who understand cryptocurrency better than I do that might have an argument against this. But it's it was the lack of flexibility that caused all this proliferation of altcoins in the first place. And we can look at politics all over the world. And we can see that people who get their way 100 percent alienate other people. And that's what happened with Bitcoin. They were alienated.
50:40Vlad CosteaYeah. FYI, you mentioned something about mining. I have this tiny home device, which is called the Braiins Miner. I've been holding it in the box because I've been meaning to do a proper review of this. But what this is, is a home miner. It's not as competitive as what you find in industrial scale mining facilities. But consider it a lottery ticket. And it's like $250. You put this in your background, shows you the Bitcoin price. Every day. I mean, not every day. All the time it shows you the Bitcoin price and you have like a one in a few hundred million chances to get a block reward every 10 minutes.
51:22Mark EdgeThat's a lot more often than you would pay for a lottery ticket elsewhere. I mean, if you're comparing it to a lottery ticket, I think. And by the way, the picture is almost ticket shaped. It's, you know, it's a great comparison. Right. So you have in the United States anyway, your Powerball chance is like one in 50 million of winning once a week. And you pay a dollar for that. You know, this thing is going to give you that opportunity for $250 is going to give you the opportunity to win every 10 minutes. That's pretty nice.
51:55Vlad CosteaI know some guys who paid like $400 for something that's called the Blockclock. And that one is basically a mechanical price, whatever that you put in your background and you look fancy. This is $250, $300. And that actually mines and shows you the price. So I think it's more useful to have around. And I heard it's quiet. I still have to review it. But
52:20Mark EdgeWell, I'm interested, frankly, I'd like to hear more about it when you do do the review. It's, it sounds fascinating. And for those in the colder climes, it's like a little space heater too.
52:34Vlad CosteaNo, this one is not. No, it's really not. It's designed for efficiency. It's quiet. It doesn't generate much heat. It's just like an accessory that you keep in the background in your living room. And that's kind of the point.
52:49Mark EdgeWell, I've done some mining in the past. And I will say that the miners were warm.
52:55Vlad CosteaYeah, those were the industrial scale ones that you're supposed to stack together and keep in a mining farm. And those are also the ones that are, I guess, more powerful. This one is optimized for efficiency. It gives you one terahash per second, I think. And it generates no heat. And it's also quiet.
53:19Mark EdgeI think it's important to have a computer that's optimized for mining because you're, you know, this isn't the good old days, you can't just, you know, pop open your computer and mine.
53:30Vlad CosteaNo, but you're right overall about your criticism of mining. The solution would be, I mean, it's the most radical one. You can't magically lower the difficulty.
53:42Mark EdgeNo, no, it's a hard fork.
53:44Vlad CosteaIt's not just a hard fork. What I mean is that if you lower the difficulty, you'll just get the miners to bring it up once again. It's a supply and demand kind of thing. If you have a lot of hash power getting deployed, you're going to have the difficulty readjustment every 2016 blocks, which means two weeks in Bitcoin time. And then you're going to get more difficulty for finding new blocks. So it's something that happens organically. What you can do is change the mining algorithm to something else.
54:17Mark EdgeWell, maybe that's what I mean when I say it. And I appreciate any critique. I haven't premiered this anywhere. This is my really first time talking about the idea. But the difficulty is artificial. If one was to move the artificiality of the difficulty, there would still be some difficulty in doing the math of all the Bitcoin transactions in that given time frame. And then you could just, as they currently do, have a lottery and decide who gets the reward and who doesn't. It would go up. The miners who have paid a great deal for these computers would be like, darn you, we're angry because they paid a bunch for the computers and they're not having the opportunity.
55:07But if Bitcoin is truly trying to secure the network, way more people, 10 times, a hundred times, a thousand times more people would mine if they had an opportunity, minute as it might be, to win. And then you would have not just a node, as they like to call them, but a node that's working, one that's mining. They're not just securing the network by auditing and holding the node, you know, responsible by recording it. They would be mining at the same time, which is doing the work.
55:48And further, I would go ahead and venture to say that you could probably hold the Bitcoin block, the entire block that's out there. You know, how many, how many blocks does a given miner need to hold in order to know what's going on? It seems to me that, you know, you could hold a hundred on the mining computer and then just have thousands of places that are holding the oldest transactions.
56:22Vlad CosteaOh, you mean by hold, you mean store, store, store the data. Yeah. Well, most miners just use some other third party node. They don't need to store anything themselves.
56:34Mark EdgeYeah, they're not even doing it, not even doing the work.
56:38Vlad CosteaAnd it's not that much work. It's just downloading some transaction data and validating it.
56:44Mark EdgeWell, I had a, ran what they called a QT wallet back in the day and then ABC wallet and a variety of other wallets on a laptop, a laptop I had retired. So I bought a, the laptop from BitcoinStore.com with Bitcoin, and I retired my old ASIC or something like that. And I restored on that computer, a Bitcoin wallet that was doing the work, you know, just not, not mining, just, you know, recording. And that wallet was fine for years. And then one day that didn't work.
57:22So I'm like, oh, well, I'll put it on my workstation. And I did that for a couple of years. And then it's like, this is using a lot of my CPU power. What's going on here? And so I took it off that, and now I don't run a node any longer. And there, maybe it was the, maybe it was the hard disk space. I don't know. It was something that was taking up space in my computer and I'm like, I don't want this anymore. And that was it. I, you know, stopped securing the network.
57:52Vlad CosteaWell, you can prune your node so you can set it to only store like 10 gigabytes or whatever you're comfortable.
58:01Mark EdgeThe right. But the what the people that are making the decisions for Bitcoin presume that people who are the less and less ignorant, the easier you make it, the less ignorant, the more ignorant the person can be and still do it. I would call myself pretty ignorant of all of these, you know, cryptocurrency things. I know some, but I just decided it was easier rather than trying to figure out something new on how to prune my node or whatever it might be. I just decided to take this off, get rid of it.
58:38Vlad CosteaWell, you also need a purpose for running a node, right? The reason why you should be running one is that you're validating your own transactions. And especially if Bitcoin is going to go forward with this small block design, you're going to have to wait longer for your transactions to get broadcast. So let's say that you pay a fee, which is below the market rate. If you keep your node running, it will keep on being broadcast until I guess it gets added into a block. It's something that I've done before, like waiting six months to get a transaction because I paid the smallest fee that's currently possible.
59:16Mark EdgeNow, I haven't used a what I would call a QT wallet, one of these old computer run Bitcoin wallets for years in the use in the sense to make a transaction. Now, Keene, New Hampshire was at one point the epicenter of cryptocurrency transactions for the world. We had, you could get your hair cut, you get your car repaired, you could go to the nursery and buy plants, you could get a cup of coffee, you could buy sodas and newspapers and all kinds of things, hamburgers, whatever you wanted, you could do transactions in lots and lots of food, by the way, and you could do those transactions in Bitcoin and then later in Bitcoin Cash and Dash and probably some other, I know I did a transaction at least once in ETH.
1:00:10And these things were pretty easy with a wallet, a transaction system called AnyPay. And I mean, I've made a lot of Bitcoin transactions and many, many, many of them are sub $100. But I haven't done anything in many years and more than a decade on a QT wallet.
1:00:37Vlad CosteaWell, it's not the most efficient way if you're on the go, but at the same time, I got to ask you something, because I see in my Twitter bubble, a lot of times people making fun of the... Laszlo Hanyecz, the developer, the guy who sent 10,000 Bitcoin and received two pizzas. Yeah, back in 2010. And people make fun of him and they're like, oh, this guy had no conviction in his investment. He had no idea he's holding on to the most scarce asset. Humanity has ever known. He's an idiot, you know.
1:01:11Mark EdgeI would call that foolish to make that accusation. Those people did not know at that time whether Bitcoin was going to be worth anything. And it's every transaction that occurred after, you know, it's every transaction that occurred up to this point, but has made Bitcoin worth what it's worth. And pardon me, I've got to get a call coming in here that I just got to get rid of.
1:01:39Pardon me for that. So I say that that person's a hero and ought to be lauded every day, every year at Bitcoin Pizza Day, which I have on my calendar as an important holiday. And I have pizza. It's coming up on the 22nd of May. And I would encourage everyone to raise a slice. I don't care if you're some kind of, you know, pizza purist or some heretic that wants pineapple on your pizza, whatever it might be, you know, raise a slice and thank the good folks that have all made these transactions in order to make things worth what they are.
1:02:19If the accusation is aimed at me, why didn't you keep all the many thousands of bitcoins that, you know, went through your hands? If you believed, as you said, that if the Bitcoin's worth a dollar, it's worth a million, then why didn't you keep every Bitcoin you ever had and scrape and figure out how to, you know, pay your bills otherwise? And the answer is, to some extent, I did. The last thing I spent, because it's hard to spend at the time, especially, is Bitcoin. We always spent all the cash, all the US dollars that we made first.
1:02:59But, you know, when you run a business and your largest advertiser decides that they're going to switch in a relatively short period of time from paying you dollars to paying you pixie dust, you're going to try to figure out, you know, how to run your business. And today, sure, things make some sense, but we had to pay to keep the lights on and that sort of thing. In other ways, you know, I kind of wonder, what was it, Andrew Tate? Not that I'm, this guy's no prophet, mind you, but he did mention that having 20 million dollars and having 200 million dollars, there's no difference in lifestyle.
1:03:45You know, a bigger yacht, a grander mansion, a 747 instead of a private G5. Like, I don't think these things really make a difference as far as lifestyle goes. So I'm not claiming to have 20 million dollars, but what I would claim is that it's just, you know, I mean, money isn't everything. I would rather see adoption of Bitcoin as a currency, which meant that you had to use it. Stop using their money. Stop using the money of killers and liars and use the money that is backed by real value, mathematics and privacy.
1:04:34That's to me what the message of cryptocurrency has always been. It's not about my bags, you know, it's about trying to get other people to use it. And in the process, the currency will increase in value and you will be rewarded for your steadfast walk along the path of justice, brother. Just use cryptocurrency, use it whenever you can live your life on it. If you can, there's lots of ways to use crypto and I encourage them all. I'm not here to call one coin or another, you know, bad.
1:05:19I just find interesting what I find interesting. Personally, I'm a, you know, Zano and Monero guy these days, I like the idea of private transactions and they can cost a little more than currencies like Bitcoin Cash or something like that to make the transaction. But to me, helping people keep their transactions private is the best way. If every transaction on the Monero network is something going through the dark web, then all they have to do is hunt down one transaction and they catch a little fish. If, however, that transaction might be, I paid for a meal by buying, somebody, you know, ran my meal in Amsterdam on their credit card and I sent them Zano.
1:06:13So, you know, it's a private transaction, but I don't think any law enforcement agency would find it terribly interesting.
1:06:22Vlad CosteaNo, they would not. But I got to ask you, how come you didn't get into Zcash because that one actually has zero knowledge proof privacy and on the Z side, which is the shielded side of the blockchain, it's actually more powerful than Monero. It's just that Monero is private by default and Zcash, you have to opt in for the privacy and you have to send to another private address. The difference is that in Monero, you're going to have a transaction recorded on the blockchain, but you don't know who sent it because you have like 16 decoys and that's your deniability, basically.
1:06:59You don't know how much of it was sent and to whom it was sent. Or maybe, you know, to whom it was sent because you get some information. But it's difficult to backtrack from that. But in the case of Zcash, it's hard to prove that a transaction took place at all. And I think that's much more powerful and it's the kind of technology that was built for Bitcoin, except that Bitcoiners forgot about it.
1:07:24Mark EdgeI can't say anything about it. Zcash, Dash and Monero came out at all about the same time and I purchased some of each of them in order to support those projects. I can't tell you what is on, you know, my hardware wallets that sit many, many, many miles from me.
1:07:56And, but I can say that I like anybody who's trying to make private transactions. I remember, you know, post 2017 that Zcash kind of got beat up as far as pricing went. And I don't think Monero got quite as beat up. I don't know. I can't tell you precisely what it was that made me more of a Monero guy. Maybe it's just Fluffypony talking to us on the Internet. You know, I like that, but I can't I can't say I'm not here again, not here to shoot down any particular project. There's no project that I think is worth shooting down. Do your research, ladies and gentlemen, find what works for you.
1:08:42Vlad CosteaAt the same time, we can spend the entire day fighting and saying, well, this one is better. No, the other one has this feature. But we're all getting our asses kicked by the U.S. dollar, which now is tokenized on Ethereum, on Tron, on Polygon, on Solana and whatever. People are transacting with USDT in South America, in Africa, in the Middle East, even around Korea and Japan. It's the most popular way to transact. And it sort of sucks that we spend so much time talking about free market money and becoming a hedge against inflation and stuff like this.
1:09:21And then people chose out of free will to use the U.S. dollar as a medium of exchange on the technology that we invented for something else.
1:09:31Mark EdgeYeah, I think that this is a very touchy point when it comes to the big blockers. These are people that advocated for larger blocks on Bitcoin. It looked like for a little while there 2015, 2016, that Bitcoin was on a trajectory, an adoption curve that would cause it to potentially become a currency that was important on the world stage. And the Bitcoin devs decided that there were better ways to make Bitcoin usable by stepping down for some years and making transactions very expensive for that period of time.
1:10:20And then bringing on board, you know, Segregated Witness and Lightning and a variety of other things. I don't know whether history will show that this was the right move, but what it felt like at the time was, at the very least to me, is that there's an opportunity for cryptocurrency to replace these fiat currencies that are out there that are controlled by governments and allow them to prosecute unlimited wars. But if we don't take that opportunity now and today and just have a minimum viable product out there, then we're going to lose that opportunity.
1:11:06And in that timeframe, major companies like Dell went from taking Bitcoin to not taking Bitcoin. And that felt like a huge blow to me.
1:11:18Vlad CosteaI think it was Microsoft, not Dell. I'm not sure if Dell accepted it.
1:11:25Mark EdgeI'd be willing to bet that they did, because I bought a Dell machine in Bitcoin. Now, maybe I got confused. Go ahead. Do the work while I figure out something else that I want to talk about here. So essentially, when these major retailers stopped selling their products.
1:11:47Vlad CosteaNo, you're right. 2014. There's a news article from July 18th of 2014 and says Dell now accepting Bitcoin. I was not aware of this.
1:11:59Mark EdgeAnd, you know, now they don't. And I think that there are some companies that are coming back and trying to accept Bitcoin again, but it might be might be too little too late. Maybe it's not. Maybe I'm wrong. And maybe we wouldn't have had the opportunity to overtake the dollar. Maybe I'm wrong that now is too late. I don't know the answer, but that's kind of what it feels like in a lot of ways. And I can understand why somebody would move to a stable coin to avoid a downturn in crypto markets and protect their wealth and these sorts of things.
1:12:39I can see it. And I have in the past, you know, knew a transaction was coming up. So I took the opportunity to sell in, you know, whatever coin BTC that I had and hold at a higher rate rather than, you know, a rate that I found acceptable. So let's say, you know, the major transactions coming up, Bitcoin is getting volatile. It's at 106, like it was, I don't know, earlier today or something. And you decide I'm going to sell at 106 and then it say drops down to 96.
1:13:20Well, then you've done a great thing and you've saved 10% on whatever it was you were going to purchase. Now, mind you could sell and then it goes to 116 and you lose 10%. Pardon my math here. I realize I'm off a little bit.
1:13:37Vlad CosteaNo, that makes a lot of sense, except that the copium or the way in which people try to rationalize what's been happening, they will say, well, nobody wanted to spend an asset that's going up. They want to hold it. So if they want to hold it, of course, we're going to be using stable coins.
1:13:56Mark EdgeYeah, that's the Gresham's law that people will use crappier currencies and hold better currencies. Maybe that's true. And I think there's a great argument for the small blockers when they say Bitcoin is a better store of value than it is a currency. I think there is. I think there's an argument there. I'm not, you know, I'm not a one-sided guy here. I can be convinced of different points, but what I like to hear after I acknowledge, yes, Bitcoin has proven itself to be a great store of value. I'd like to hear acknowledge. Yeah, but we lost BitPay. We lost Dell. We lost Microsoft. We lost these things because of these actions.
1:14:49Vlad CosteaYeah, and Steam and Expedia and a bunch of others that were accepting Bitcoin until 2017 or something.
1:14:57Mark EdgeI bought a lot of plane tickets on CheapTickets.com.
1:15:03Vlad CosteaThere was also CheapAir.com. I think it was CheapAir.com. Now it's CheapOair. They rebranded, but they don't accept Bitcoin anymore.
1:15:12Mark EdgeBummer.
1:15:13Vlad CosteaYeah, it was so magical, right?
1:15:16Mark EdgeWhy would you maintain the code to, you know, use these things if nobody and not enough people are using it to buy? I stopped. I remember a Bitcoin transaction. Oh, I can hear the Maxis now. He's a liar. Get ready. You know, put the banana in so your voices are ready. Okay, guys. I had a Bitcoin transaction that was over $100 in transaction fees. Let me tell you how that happened. That happened because we had, we received tips for in Bitcoin. It was bitcoin.freetalklive.com and you could go there and you could tip.
1:16:05Many people wanted to say thank you for introducing them to Bitcoin. And they sent us, you know, little transactions, one, five Bitcoins, at the time little transactions. And then later, you know, 0.5 Bitcoins, 0.1 Bitcoins, 0.01 Bitcoins, and a variety of things just to say thanks for introducing them to Bitcoin. And because of that, we had a wallet. We had wallets that would have very, would have a lot of transactions, a lot of small transactions. Well, if you want to move that to some place in order to, you know, sell or consolidate, not have it on all in the same wallet, whatever the situation might be, you're gonna, you're gonna pay a lot, especially when rates were three and five and, seven dollars, $11, back in 2017, this is when this occurred.
1:17:03It was either late 2016 or late 2017. you know, the result was we paid a great deal and could have paid more.
1:17:15Vlad CosteaYeah, believe it or not, I'm responsible for two of the largest fees in the history of the Lightning Network. I think I paid more than 50 euro, which is like $70 for a transaction fee on Lightning.
1:17:29Mark EdgeI didn't know Lightning had transaction fees.
1:17:31Vlad CosteaIt does have transaction fees. It's not supposed to be cheap. It's just supposed to be fast and give you some privacy as a sender.
1:17:40Mark EdgeOkay.
1:17:41Vlad CosteaSo I was exactly in your situation. I received some donations and I wanted to send the coins to an exchange and the service that I used as a Lightning service provider, because running a Lightning node has become so difficult that I had to go to a Lightning service provider and they take a 1% fee of your transaction.
1:18:00And when I made these transfers, I paid a lot of fees because they take 1% plus the routing fees and whatever. So I'm responsible for doing this because Lightning is better when you're dealing with exchanges for the simple reason that it doesn't matter where your coins come from. It's not like blockchain analysis does not work on Lightning. And I didn't want, I appreciate that people have been sending me coins, but when I do use them, I don't want to get their identity. I don't want to spend the coins as the person who sent them to me.
1:18:35I don't know who that is. I'm grateful, but at the same time, it's better to not get into that. Nowadays, blockchain analysis is very complex.
1:18:45Mark EdgeRight. Maybe one of the members of the Sinaloa cartel think that your show is just the best and they decide to give you a little Bitcoin. And then suddenly you're somehow wrapped up in, I don't know, the murder of 50 high school kids in Mexico.
1:19:04Vlad CosteaI don't want to comment on that, but I do have a section that's bitcoin-takeover.com slash donate, and that's where you can send me a bunch of coins if you want. But you don't have to. Let me tell you about the sponsors so you don't have to donate. So there's also Layer 2 Labs, which is trying to build the drivechains that are sidechains for pretty much every use case out there. I guess you've heard of Ethereum, you've heard of Monero and Zcash, you've heard of prediction markets, you've heard of Namecoin and other chains that do assets.
1:19:38What drivechains are trying to do is to bring all of these use cases as individual sidechains for Bitcoin that use BTC as the currency and provide all of the functionality with a currency which is superior. What they do need is to get their BIP 300 across, to get Bitcoin Core developers to agree with merging that piece of code into everyone's software, which hasn't happened so far. Paul Sztorc, who is the CEO of the company, has been pushing this for almost 10 years. Not actively, but it's been 10 years since he came up with the solution and it seems to be pretty good.
1:20:18But at the same time, it's controversial. Some developers do not seem to agree with it. The good news is that you can test the software today. It's on layer2labs.com slash download. You can download the software for Windows, for Mac OS and for Linux. And that's a way for you to see how the future of Bitcoin can look like. It currently runs on the signet, which is just a network with no value on it. You can trade tokens with people.
1:20:47And there's also a Telegram chat that's called Drivechain Talk, where you can talk with people and get free coins that you can send across so you can see how the system works. I think it's worth a try. I think it has its merit. And I don't think there should be any gatekeepers that tell you what should exist on Bitcoin and what shouldn't. We've been pushing that permissionless narrative for some time. But once you get to a certain level, you hit some roadblocks. You hit your head against the ceiling and you realize it takes some human politics to get stuff included in the code.
1:21:25But yeah, there's also Citrea, which unlike LayerTwo Labs, does not require any permission to get into Bitcoin blocks. But at the same time, if you do want to do this more efficiently, they would need a covenant soft fork. They're trying to bring some sort of financial services on Bitcoin. So lending and borrowing and all of this DeFi stuff on a Bitcoin layer by removing what is currently popular, which is WBTC on Ethereum. Not removing, but trying to compete with that because it's custodial. It's based on trust.
1:22:05It's not the ideal design, what we have today. But with Citrea, you can actually have that with the security of the Bitcoin network and protocols as opposed to companies being involved. And you can try the software also at citrea.xyz. I think what they have been building is really cool. And once again, it deserves. Just give it a try for you to understand that this can also be part of the future of Bitcoin and part of the way in which we're going to interact with this network in a few years.
1:22:37And last but not least, and this is the last ad for this episode, there is noones.com, which is a peer to peer exchange, not very different from LocalBitcoins, except that the focus of noones.com is the global south. And the CEO, Ray Youssef, is very adamant about this vision that he wants to empower his Lions from Africa and from the Middle East and get them to lift themselves out of poverty and hustle for making some more money. If you want to participate in this economy, you can also sell gift cards or coins on this peer to peer market.
1:23:14And there's this system which is called that everyone gets a seat at the table and everyone eats, which means that there's a cut for every party that's involved. And ultimately, I think there is a higher premium for people buying in Africa. I'm not sure exactly why that is, but there is no I don't think it's morally wrong to give them liquidity so that they can empower themselves and get engaged in trade. And they also have a debit card. If you're into spending your coins, you can get the noones debit card.
1:23:45And I think that's pretty cool. There's also a spot exchange to keep on adding services, but the main use case is the peer to peer network. And you can find that at noones.com. Now, sorry for...
1:23:58Mark EdgeHow do you spell noones?
1:24:00Vlad CosteaN-O-O-N-E-S.
1:24:02Mark EdgeN-O-O-N-E-S.
1:24:04Vlad CosteaGreat. Not like Nintendo. Like no and yes. No, it's noones.com. Very good. There's a lot of stuff happening in Bitcoin. And it's really frustrating, at least for me, that I interview developers who can't deploy their stuff. They've been working on it for years. They've been proving that it works. And then they get, ah, we don't need that. The price went up. I think it feels defeating in a way that you try to build something and you put a lot of years from your life to build that. And then people say, well, we don't really need that. But what this really means is that we're fine using exchanges, we're fine using banks, we're fine using custodians.
1:24:54Mark EdgeRight. I mean, it seems like there is a very powerful force within the cryptocurrency sphere that simply says, wasn't this a great digital asset? And wasn't it wonderful that we all got very wealthy? And many of the ideas that Bitcoin was founded upon have been left bodies on the wayside, on the way to libertarians getting rich. And, you know, I'm grateful for all those libertarians who have gotten rich in the process and the many projects that they've started. But I can totally see what it's like to be some developer who's got some idea out there.
1:25:38And, you know, maybe you trot it out on a Bitcoin fork so that you can show what it looks like and what it does. And, you know, some people have shown some interest in it. And then. No, thanks. You know, it's but those those doors that close often something will be opened, you know, later on. I, you know, in my business, plenty of doors closed in the process. And we always found a way. Thank God for Bitcoin.
1:26:11Vlad CosteaOh, yeah, of course. But at the same time, you have to remember that Ethereum was proposed as a layer for Bitcoin and it was not built on Bitcoin due to some limitations and hostility towards non-monetary uses for the network. And Zcash was also supposed to be a soft fork to add privacy to Bitcoin. And that did not come to Bitcoin for reasons which I think I understand today because Zcash had some issues along the way. But now they're like the fourth iteration of it. And it's much more powerful.
1:26:47They don't require the trusted setup. They have better cryptography that requires less computation. I think it's finally ready for Bitcoin. But the problem is that Bitcoin has moved on and they don't care anymore. They just look at bankers. They celebrate that BlackRock is an investor. They're happy that governments are buying Bitcoin. I'm not sure what I got into anymore. It feels confusing sometimes. It feels conflicting, like I'm supposed to cheer for this. I'm happy. Look, I'm getting rich. But at the same time, what price?
1:27:20Mark EdgeAnd that's one of the things that I think we all need to acknowledge. Pardon me, I got a cough in Amsterdam, probably French kissing those Dutch sailors. But that when a project gets bigger, more ideas are proffered, right? Everybody's got their idea. Everybody thinks their idea is the best idea. And at some point or another, you know, we all have to work together. And that means that not all of the best ideas are always going to be adopted.
1:28:00Vlad CosteaYeah, of course. But at the same time, it's weird when you have to deal with gatekeepers who say, well, Bitcoin should only be this and it's fine the way that it is. And it's like the way that I see it right now is like the goose that lays golden eggs. And some people think that Bitcoin is that and they don't want to kill it. They see that the price keeps going up every cycle and they're happy with it. They say, why should we bother to follow some sort of stupid white paper or vision about what this should be when we can just larp that Bitcoin is fine?
1:28:35It's very ironic in a way, because the Tron network right now processes USDT transactions for which users are paying three, four dollars for one transaction just to get USD around the Internet to move some money. But on the Bitcoin network right now, I think it's sort of a ghost town. You go to mempool.space. Oh, the fees are actually high right now, but they're like one dollar. People pay much more to move US dollars on another blockchain. And then you're going to have the commentators, the observers who say, well, Bitcoin fees are just one dollar right now.
1:29:14Maybe we never needed to scale. But what they don't see is that the whole industry has routed around the limitations of the Bitcoin network. And exchanges make more money than Bitcoin miners from Bitcoin trades. And you have all of these other blockchains that are tokenizing Bitcoin, like Zano, for example. It can do Bitcoin as a token on the Zano network with the Zano privacy, which I think is beautiful. But I wish this was the Bitcoin network with the security of the Bitcoin network with the anonymity set of the Bitcoin network because you have more users.
1:29:52But it's not happening. And then you have to ask yourself, is it really that important to build on Bitcoin or can we just have a parallel economy that routes around it?
1:30:05Mark EdgeHow would one use Bitcoin on the Zano network? Would you just sort of custodialize it with an auditor or even just hold it? And, you know, an auditor says that this Bitcoin is reserved for the Zano network. And then you say you roll out, you know, you roll out 10 Zano Bitcoin coins and or satoshis, however you want to do it. Right. There's any infinite variety of ways to sort of segment it and then just hold those bitcoins in place.
1:30:40Vlad CosteaThat's the traditional way in which you're locking your Bitcoin into a contract and then you're issuing the tokenized Bitcoin on the other network, according to the amount of Bitcoin that you can prove is still in that contract that's locked. But now I think there's also something that's called Confidential Layer, which is trying to provide a trust minimized bridge between blockchains so that you can lock an asset like Bitcoin or ETH or whatever you're into on a blockchain that has privacy. And that can be pretty big. I think Firo, which formerly used to be called Zcoin, is part of this agreement and also Zano.
1:31:25And this can be a feature of Bitcoin. I'm not going to lie about it. This can actually happen. But I wish we got Drivechains instead so that you could use the security of the Bitcoin miners to provide finality for these transactions. And also, I wish the transaction fees that are happening within the system were going to the Bitcoin miners as opposed to the Zano network, which, if I'm not mistaken, actually burns the transaction fees.
1:31:54Mark EdgeYeah, again, I don't know that much about Zano. I do hold some and I'm excited about it. But just because somebody slapped the word privacy on it, I am not the one to go to audit code and know whether something is properly private, those sorts of things. I would think that it would be relatively simple to get some people to dedicate some Bitcoin that is otherwise not going to move to a network like Zano to see what happens.
1:32:32Vlad CosteaIt's already happening on Ethereum with wrapped Bitcoin, WBTC, and that's like a hundred thousand coins, which is a lot.
1:32:41Mark EdgeThat is a lot of coins. What about Zano? Can it handle the transactions? I mean, I don't know. I know nothing about the network. You know, what if Zano blew up overnight and people were making transactions with Bitcoin intending to use it as a currency?
1:33:00Vlad CosteaI'm not sure what you mean by blew up overnight. But what that means is that the network becomes insecure. In Zano, it's more complicated because in Zano you need to have a large percentage of the stake and also a large percentage of the hash rate to attack it. It has this hybrid proof of work, proof of stake system. So if you do get 51 percent of the hash rate and a large majority of coins, then you're going to be able to reorganize blocks. But it still doesn't cancel out the tokens that were created on it.
1:33:35Mark EdgeNo, I'm actually talking about transaction fees here. So what appeared to, if it didn't drive a stake through the heart of Bitcoin, what hobbled it was transaction fees in 2016 and 2017 and the concomitant issues with splitting and a variety of things. So what would happen if people began to use, you know, say BTC, private BTC on Zano and going to, you know, just presume every business that's ever accepted cryptocurrency to do business, accepted it right now and people could do business with these businesses and they're actually doing transactions.
1:34:21They're buying cups of the proverbial cup of coffee, which I have bought with Bitcoin and a variety of things. And so they just they're getting a lot of transactions that are going through. And then I presume that some people are going to use Zano to, or Zano, I'm not sure how to pronounce it properly. I presume that they're going to use it to buy some things that they want to keep private, you know, whether that's, you know, some medical treatment for their diabetes or their, you know, marijuana for their glaucoma or whatever it is they might do.
1:34:57Vlad CosteaIt's an interesting question. So you're curious about fees. I'm a nerd about this stuff, so I happen to know it. On the Zano network, you have 0.01 Zano per transaction. That's the fee. That's what I paid recently. If the price is like $10, then that's 10 cents?
1:35:21Mark Edge10 cents, yeah.
1:35:23Vlad CosteaOK, so 10 cents per transaction right now, if the price goes up because of increased demand and you're going to have many more transactions. Well, the rationality behind this transaction fee is that if you have a certain number of transactions per day or per block, you're going to have a system that's deflationary because there is going to be more of the currency that's burned as opposed to getting issued by inflation. So that's sort of the point. Right now, I think the system issues a new block every minute, so you get 60 blocks per hour multiplied by 24. That's 1,440 new Zano issued every day.
1:36:09So multiply that by 100, and if you're going to have that number of transactions, then the system becomes deflationary and you're going to have fewer coins entering circulation as opposed to getting burned, and that's going to drive up the price. But if it gets to a point where it's super expensive, I think the developers can decide to have a vote or whatever within the community so that you decrease that 0.01 and make it 0.005 or whatever, cut the fee in half or maybe make it 10 times less. I don't know, but the goal overall of the system is to have this point where it becomes deflationary.
1:36:56Mark EdgeGot it.
1:36:57Vlad CosteaIt's an interesting gamble, I think. In the case of Bitcoin, the gamble is that it's going to be profitable for miners to maintain the network after multiple halving cycles. That's the interesting part about Bitcoin, that you have the rewards being cut in half every four years.
1:37:15Mark EdgeYeah, it is fascinating. And the game theory that goes behind all of that, it seems like the transaction fees would just go up, but presumably things like the... Excuse me. Presumably things like the... I lost my train of thought. Sorry. The FBI stole my memory.
1:37:38Vlad CosteaNo, so far it's been the price that decided that transaction fees are not necessary. Because if the price doubles every four years, then I guess we're fine. But once we get to the point where we run out of people to sell Bitcoin to, and that's going to be interesting because it's the end of price discovery and we settle that one Bitcoin is worth this much. I don't know. That's when we actually need transaction fees for the miners. That's when we have to worry. And it's going to be interesting to see what happens when we get to that point.
1:38:16If people concede that it's good to have cheap transactions for everyone and have lots of them. Or we're going to say, well, transactions are only for banks and large institutions for high value transfers, which I'm not sure they happen every day. I'm not sure how often you're going to get these settlements between institutions.
1:38:39They're enough to maintain the security of the network. I'm not even sure if these institutions care about the health of the Bitcoin network. There's this blog post from Gavin Andresen from 2021. I definitely recommend that you read it. It's sort of this Black Mirror style story about Bitcoin, where the miners realize that they don't need the Bitcoin network anymore. And they're like, why should we pay for this mechanism? We can just move BTC, the token, to another network. Make sure that everyone gets to claim their coins.
1:39:13And that's it. We just go forward with another mechanism which doesn't require this expensive mining. And if we don't make it sustainable for miners to operate, we're going to get to that point where I guess people will fork off. They will say, well, it's been nice. It's been an interesting ride. This is how far mining can go. It's not profitable from now on. So let's just move to a different kind of consensus mechanism to another chain. Of course, not everyone's going to agree to that, but there might be some split within the community in the coming years, precisely because there's so much uncertainty about how the network is going to be sustainable over the long term.
1:39:56Mark EdgeRight. Well, this is the problem that groups and nations have confronted through as long as there have been these groups and nations is, is that when the group gets large enough, then there's the disputes get loud enough that people need to separate in order to pursue their ideas on how a given thing should work. And it's frustrating when, you know, we all read Eric Voorhees' post way back in the day that said, hey, don't do all these altcoins, just stick with Bitcoin.
1:40:36And it made sense to me at the time. But when you feel so poorly represented, the thing that ends up happening is that you want to go and you want to rule yourself. And especially libertarians can be very difficult in this realm. So I'm sure that people who own Bitcoin right now, many of them are like, we don't have to compromise. Everything's working great. But there will come another instance where it, you know, it's not going to work.
1:41:15Vlad CosteaSo far, I think the number go up aspect of it has sort of kept some voices quiet and some concerns were proven to be, I guess, too early. But once once it happens, it's going to be nasty. I don't expect this to turn out. I mean, even last week, I'm not sure if you followed the Bitcoin conversation, but there was this situation where the developers wanted to increase the capacity of OP_RETURN, which is where you can put data on the blockchain to basically remove any restriction.
1:41:52The only restriction is the block size itself. And this was because there is Citrea, which is a sponsor of the show, that's trying to build layer twos in which they put zero knowledge proofs in the Bitcoin blockchain, which are essentially data that they use for verification under layer two. And they realized that they need more data and they could put more data, but in a very inefficient way that actually is costly for the nodes. It requires more access memory, the RAM. And they realized, OK, we could do this much in a much more efficient way if we were allowed to have more storage in the blocks, except that the community, for some reason, became very toxic and the usual suspects who never learned anything in the last eight years or something.
1:42:42And they're still stuck in this mindset of the block size wars, that they got to fight the big blockers, they got to fight, you know, the barbarians at the gate, that they have to be there and watch for attacks. They're super and they call themselves this they're super toxic about every attempt to change Bitcoin. They think that this is an attack and this is something they should fight against. And it's so nasty and it's such a trivial issue. And once you realize how small this is and how great the changes need to be for Bitcoin to actually work for its intended purpose, it's so easy to get disillusioned and realize we're not going to get that.
1:43:24We're not going to have privacy in Bitcoin to make the currency fungible. We're not going to have proper scaling because these people are against anything. And it's so much politics. I have a background in political science. I spent five years of my life studying that I never worked for a single day in the field, thankfully, but I got into Bitcoin thinking that it's this meritocracy and it's this place where you don't have to deal with human politics. But what I discovered is an even nastier version of human politics, which is just nerds, just nerds fighting each other, large egos and stuff like this. I guess you have to go. You sent me a message.
1:44:09Mark EdgeI do, soon.
1:44:10Vlad CosteaSo it's messed up. I do wish that Bitcoin is going to become what it aims to be and it's going to fulfill this beautiful vision of peer to peer electronic cash, one way or the other. But there's so much fighting going on and it's tiresome sometimes.
1:44:28Mark EdgeWell, I would love to see compromise on all ends of this, because I think that's what it's going to take. It's just that everybody's got to give up a little something. Compromise means that nobody got their way. And that means, you know, people have to come together and listen to other sides and, you know, they look into nonviolent communication, because this is, to me, the best way to solve entrenched problems.
1:45:06Vlad CosteaYeah, before I let you go, and I hope this doesn't take too long, I got to at least address the questions that you got from the audience. There's Zooko who says, ask him about the principles of what can serve as freedom money, like not specific coins, but what qualities money needs to have.
1:45:25Mark EdgeWell, I think that we've kind of gone over it. It needs to be rapid. You need to be able to exchange it with people rapidly. And I think that I would love to see privacy. I don't think money needs to be private, but I think that it is better if it is, because there will always be a place in the marketplace for private money. So, you know, why not fill that place? Cash currently does. I can, you know, take some euros and hand them to you to, you know, solve whatever problem I have and you can accept them and, you know, do what you do.
1:46:05And that's relatively private. Then you sell, then you use them wherever you use them. Now, when I was in Amsterdam and England and France, I often found that they would prefer me to use a credit card over cash. But I find that to be threatening.
1:46:28Vlad CosteaAaron Day says hello and wants to know what can we do to help Free Ian?
1:46:34Mark EdgeSure. Please go to FreeIanNow.org. That's FreeIanNow.org. Sign my petition there. It's pathetic at this point, but we've just really started it in earnest. Trying to promote it last week at the convention, and I'm hoping to get to a thousand very quickly, so it's FreeIanNow.org. It's the number one thing you can do to help Ian get some justice.
1:47:04Vlad CosteaLudovic Lars wants to know, what is the Shire Free Church?
1:47:07Mark EdgeShire Free Church is the organization that owns Free Talk Live, my radio program. We decided somewhere around 2012 that we were more of a moral teaching platform than we were a political program. And in the United States, many churches had radio programs, still have radio programs, many churches broadcast in a variety of different ways. Nothing unusual about a church being formed and then purchasing a radio program.
1:47:44Vlad CosteaMark Edge, thank you very much for doing this interview. You said you have one hour. We ended up talking for two.
1:47:50Mark EdgeIt's because I didn't look at my calendar right. I thought you had allotted me for one hour and you had a lot of me for two. And that's exactly right. We used it.
1:47:58Vlad CosteaYeah. So I'm sorry for that. But the conversation was great and very productive. To everyone listening, I hope you have already checked out the Free Ian website. And once again, thanks to the sponsors, noones.com, hodling.ch, SideShift.ai, citrea.xyz, news.bitcoin.com and layer2labs.com. Thank you very much.
1:47:58================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: the pipeline's local Whisper medium.en transcript (int16) with automatic speaker diarization (Mark Edge / Vlad Costea). Unlabeled continuation paragraphs inherited the previous speaker. Turn-boundary fragments split across segment edges were moved to the right speaker (e.g. 'So hi, Mark. / Thank you very much', 'Sure. So the story goes', 'Yeah, thanks for that', 'So he also had some ATMs', 'It ought to be', 'Is that Jamie Redman there', 'I would call that foolish', 'take this off, get rid of it', 'I bought a lot of plane tickets', 'That is a lot of coins', 'I find that to be threatening', 'Shire Free Church is the organization...', 'It's because I didn't look at my calendar'), and short interjections buried in the other speaker's paragraph were split out after checking them with local TitaNet speaker embeddings (the Pepe/magazine exchange, 'Multi-sig wallets, yeah', 'Indeed', 'I keep a private mailbox', 'No, no, it's a hard fork', 'Bummer', 'I didn't know Lightning had transaction fees', the noones spelling exchange, 'Got it', 'I do, soon'). Second opinion: YouTube auto-captions of the published video (read-only copy from the Zcash documentary project, S16E26.en.vtt; YT time = mp3 time + 50.1 s), word-aligned to the ASR; about 390 non-filler word differences reviewed by hand. Doubtful stretches were re-transcribed from the published mp3 with local faster-whisper (medium.en, int16, no prompt) on about 60 short clips. Restored dropped/looped stretches: the opening 'Hello there and', 'He kept it in his... he was...' (Casascius bar), 'I think there's an argument there. I'm not, you know, I'm not a one-sided guy here', 'I bought a lot of plane tickets', 'put the banana (unclear) in so your voices are ready. Okay, guys' (the ASR had looped the following sentence instead), Mark's aside 'The FBI stole my memory'; removed a looped duplicate sentence in the Drivechain ad ('some developers have been pushing this for almost 10 years') and an ASR insertion ('And one of the interesting things'). Notable name/jargon fixes: Free Talk Live / FreeTalkLive.com (the show's actual name; Vlad calls it Free Talk Radio), Keene, New Hampshire; Gavin Andresen; MemoryDealers; Crypto X Change; Girls Gone Bitcoin; Bitcoin Magazine; Bretton Woods Accords; The Creature from Jekyll Island; SWAT team; Sam Bankman-Fried; Aria DiMezzo; the Crypto Six; FreeIanNow.com / FreeIanNow.org; Ross Ulbricht, Free Ross; Casascius bar; Tornado Cash; Phil Zimmermann; Samourai Wallet; Hodling.ch; Braiins Miner; Blockclock; CheapTickets.com, CheapAir.com, CheapOair; Laszlo Hanyecz; Fluffypony; Zeno/Xano -> Zano; Paul Sztorc, BIP 300, drivechains/sidechains, signet, Drivechain Talk; Citreya/Citria -> Citrea (citrea.xyz); NoOnes.com, Ray Youssef; LayerTwo Labs; Confidential Layer; Firo (formerly Zcoin); hop return -> OP_RETURN; Zuko -> Zooko; Aaron Day; Ludovic Lars. Kept as spoken: '1996 Microsoft ruling' (code-is-speech case), 'Hong Kong Accords', '105' (BTC price in thousands). Leftover uncertainty is marked in square brackets with 'unclear:' and a best guess.