S16 E58: Leona Hioki on INTMAX, ZK Rollups & Privacy
Search this conversation
0:47Vlad CosteaThe Bitcoin Takeover Podcast. This is Season 16, Episode 58. This episode is sponsored by SideShift.ai, Bitcoin.com News, LayerTwo Labs, and NoOnes.com, and we are live with Leona Hioki, one of the most prominent Bitcoiners and Ethereans and builders from Japan, who is working on a ZK rollup, which promises to offer privacy and low fees and scalability, and it's called INTMAX. And also, he is one of the main figures of the Japanese conference scene. So if you're into Japanese stuff, I think this is a very good opportunity for you to learn about a part of the world which is very active, but is not in the news a lot in the West.
1:34So it's really good to have you, Leona.
1:37Leona HiokiHi, yeah, nice to join this podcast here. I was quite a big fan of you, and I was always listening to your podcasts, so I'm really happy to be here.
1:50Vlad CosteaReally? Which podcasts did you listen to?
1:55Leona HiokiThe Zcash-related ones, almost everything.
2:02Vlad CosteaOh, that's cool.
2:03Leona HiokiAlso, I'm a big fan of kind of Layer 2 solutions, so the ones on there. So, related to that, I really am an audience of that.
2:16Vlad CosteaYeah, about Zcash, the price crossed $500, and I said I'm gonna do this again, so I have to do the stupid Zcash pump dance, which I did first at $100, then $200, $300, $400, $500. Seems like I have to dance until I die, so this is the dance, I have to do it for my viewers.
2:40Leona HiokiBut what's this? Oh, Z! Z, exactly. Cool, cool. Yeah. I was thinking about, you know, you are kind of doing like a chicken or a bird or something. Yeah, you are mocking that. No, this is a chicken. Yeah, no, I take a bit of time to realize it.
3:04Vlad CosteaAnyway, it's been amazing over the last month for privacy in general, like every coin with privacy seems to come back from the dead and catch more attention. Some people say it's just a fading trend or a fad, something that's gonna go away. I think it's something that's a response to the world in which we live, which is becoming increasingly Orwellian. And I think a good place to start our conversation is just what you're doing with INTMAX, because it offers privacy, it's a ZK rollup, it's also focused on scalability and low fees. How does this work and what are the trade-offs?
3:48Leona HiokiYeah, what is trade-off? Yeah, that's the best question. So basically, let's start from the trade-off.
3:55Vlad CosteaI like this, you don't present anything positive, you're like, let's start with the trade-off.
4:00Leona HiokiYeah, no, basically, we are building INTMAX. And INTMAX is a client-side validation plus recursive ZKP. So what is client-side validation? So not just kind of record data or a hash of recorded data, everything else is client-side. So the validation of balance and the validation of transaction, it happens on client-side. For example, in Bitcoin ecosystem, the X, the counterparty, and also RGB, they are client-side validation. So when we do the client-side validation, the history will go very long as you send a transaction.
4:52So each person needs to validate all the history of the UTXO. So this is the limitation of client-side ZKP, client-side validation. But if we apply ZKP to that, once you verify the previous ZKP, the previous ZKP has already proven the previous ZKP. And the previous ZKP has already proven the previous ZKP, which is the origin. So once you verify the previous ZKP in the chain of ZKP, you can verify the entire history of UTXO, right? So this is why client-side validation will significantly get better combining with recursive ZKP.
5:36So it's something different from Zcash, right? So let's start from trade-off. So trade-off is like client-side validation has more scalability and more privacy. But the functionality is quite limited. So this is only the trade-off we can have. So if we focus on more general stuff like kind of smart contract or privacy applications, more general programmable one, maybe INTMAX is not so cut off with that. But if we just want super scalable payments with extreme privacy, yeah, I truly believe that INTMAX is the best way. I think that it's a bit arrogant to say this, but no, Zcash should apply client-side validation in my opinion.
6:34Vlad CosteaThat's interesting. I know that client-side validation was sort of brought into the conversation first by Peter Todd. And it was also, you mentioned RGB, in the case of Bitcoin, that's where it was prominently promoted. And INTMAX, as far as I know, is a ZK rollup on Ethereum right now. And I want to ask you, what would it take for INTMAX to also work on Bitcoin? Like what kind of opcode or how do you think this could work?
7:10Leona HiokiOkay, so if you want to bridge Bitcoin, we need BitVM or witness encryption. And if you want to just use Bitcoin for the recording system or double-spend prevention system, like kind of maintain USDC on the mega payment system in layer 2 of Bitcoin or something like that, actually no opcode is needed, just OP_RETURN is fine. Because everything is on client-side with ZKP. So ZKP circuit works offline, it's totally safe. Online, sorry, offline, it's totally safe. So basically, it works on Bitcoin.
8:01Anyway, it works on Bitcoin. And Shielded CSV published by Alpen Labs on BitVM and Blockstream, that idea is very similar to INTMAX. They are quoting our paper. Basically, Shielded CSV is more private than INTMAX. INTMAX itself is like, you know, very private, but only the thing we left is like obfuscating. Not obfuscating, encrypting the sender side entirely. So senders are mixed in a block in INTMAX, and the recipient and the amount is totally encrypted or hidden. And this kind of mixing part of the senders, Shielded CSV is replacing this part with total encryption.
8:55So they are more private, but basically very, very similar idea. So actually, let's say in Bitcoin space, this kind of tendency and this direction is well discussed. I'm really happy to see this as well.
9:11Vlad CosteaI know that there's something else which sounds similar in description with INTMAX, and it's called StarkWare. And they also promise to have scalability and privacy and low fees. And they are also built on Ethereum, they want to bridge it to Bitcoin and they need OP_CAT for that. And I was going to ask, how is INTMAX different from StarkWare?
9:33Leona HiokiSo nobody can kind of escape from this kind of trade-off. So functionality or scalability and privacy, right? And basically, yeah, let's say functionality versus scalability. This is a common trade-off and there's no exception so far. So basically, StarkWare is, yeah, absolutely, it's scalable, but it's still stateful. It never will be the same level scalability as a stateless one like INTMAX or, you know, Zellocoin or RGB, Lightning Network. These are stateless ideas or Plasma is also a stateless idea. And they are less kind of functional, less functionality, but yeah, more scalability.
10:31And, you know, we are on the same trade-off. So, yeah, let's say, StarkWare is more functionality. And also, yeah, it's wrapping Bitcoin. Yeah, it's very good idea to apply StarkWare and a STARK proving system to make a lot of Bitcoin on Ethereum, for example. It's a really cool idea. And if I could choose a wrapped Bitcoin, maybe I will use it. But at the same time, functionality, it's a beautiful feature of StarkWare. And it's something making their stack unique with the Cairo language, right?
11:12And so we don't have such a VM or kind of Cairo language to make kind of various type of applications. But, yeah, we are more focused on payments and, yeah, with extreme scalability and privacy. So right now, we are just consuming 0.08 bytes per transfer. And so it's less than one bit. Maybe it's a Guinness record of on-chain minimization, especially regarding transfer. And so only a stateless system can do this. And the stateful system, it's a bit difficult to do this.
11:58And 99.9% of blockchains in this industry are stateful. No, Ethereum and Solana and, you know, the StarkWare, Arbitrum, all of them are stateful basically. And Bitcoin itself is stateful. It's more stateless friendly by UTXO design, but it's still stateful. And stateless idea is kind of on-chain minimization and everything happening on client side.
12:30Vlad CosteaYeah, we should aim to have more of these stateless constructions in the space. I was going to ask you, I know that you started out with Plasma, which was another Ethereum L2. And that one didn't really get traction. But it was pretty, how should I put it, popular in its time, like there was Raiden, there was Plasma, there was I think one other that I don't remember its name.
13:01Leona HiokiAnyway, maybe Raiden, you want to refer to Raiden.
13:06Vlad CosteaYeah, maybe. But what I really want to ask you is, how would you describe the differences between your work on Plasma and what you do today with INTMAX? Is there any overlap? Are there similarities or you change the design entirely?
13:22Leona HiokiSo basically, we started from Plasma on the, no, I started the researcher, not passing this industry, how from Plasma researcher in 2018. And the Plasma's idea is basically stateless idea, putting their, making a same security assumption as layer one. How to do that? Well, this is a quite a difficult challenge for many people. And in 2019, some people abandoned that, because people thought it's kind of impossible. And so putting all the data on calldata, basically it's on-chain, it's rollup. So rollup started from Plasma, actually.
14:12And so it's a, I don't say it's a compromised version of Plasma, but it's like, you know, Plasma wanted to try. Store all data off-chain, but rollup, basically store almost all data, all history data, on layer one, which is the least scalable place in L1s. And this is how Plasma works. And the INTMAX, sorry, it was how rollup works. So we are, we have one idea from Plasma, it's called, yeah, Plasma Cash, exit, non-exit game, hostile. And the non-exit game, how it's like, people can prove themselves having no transaction after this block or this transaction.
15:13They can prove that. And with zero-knowledge proof, it's a more efficient way to do that. And so in INTMAX, it's following this idea, and combining this to their communication-based ZKP circuit, and also applying the recursive ZKP, which I told you from the beginning. This kind of combination of their ideas makes a significant improvement of Plasma. Mainly fixing the problem of online requirements. So in Plasma, the biggest problem was like, people needed to be online to keep watch over, keep watching over the other malicious behaviors.
16:07This is the limitation of Plasma. So the other people needed to be online, watch over each other. And it's a bit of an exhausting point of Plasma at the moment. And so INTMAX is basically eliminating this point. Each person can prove that I did not send a transaction after this. So this last state given by block producer is totally available still. And the people can exit money to L1 by themselves without waiting one week, watched over by the other nodes. No, we don't need that. This is a significant improvement from Plasma.
16:51Vlad CosteaYeah, to me, Plasma sounds a lot like what we have in Bitcoin with Lightning, which is interactive, and also maybe not the ideal design for Layer 2.
17:06Leona HiokiActually, I'm a big fan of both Lightning Network and Plasma. And also, I think that Lightning Network is still undervalued, and it's quite useful for many use cases still. And also no other Layer 2s can achieve instant finality. So Lightning Network has their instant finality. And they also have the security assumption of Layer 1, and they also have some privacy. I think it's kind of one of the masterpieces, in my opinion. But they have a significant problem in another way. It's a channel capacity problem, and as you mentioned, similarly to Plasma, it's like the online requirement. So these two problems are quite difficult. So yeah, it needs improvement, yes.
18:00Vlad CosteaI also want to ask you, I think the market for Layer 2s on Ethereum is more dynamic. And I want to ask you if there is anything that makes you think that at the end of the day there's going to be like four or five or even fewer of them that will succeed. And I'm not going to ask you to pick which one will succeed, but which kind of qualities do you think it takes for Layer 2 to actually be successful on the market? Because I can think of a lot of them that existed a few years ago and were popular, but I don't hear about them anymore.
18:37And I was wondering, do you think that the ZK rollups will eventually become more popular than the regular ones?
18:44Leona HiokiRegular ones like optimistic rollup?
18:48Vlad CosteaYeah, like I think it's actually called Optimism, right?
18:51Leona HiokiYeah, Optimism. Optimism is like, it's one of the optimistic rollups, and Arbitrum, Optimism and Base are optimistic rollups instead of ZK rollups. And basically, Optimism people, they want to make kind of half the ZK rollups and the optimistic rollups in the future. And many people admit that ZK rollups are superior to optimistic rollups eventually. But, you know, they are doing quite a wise way, starting from optimistic rollups and changing themselves to ZK rollups. I think it's the best idea. Optimistic rollups, it's more kind of stable, especially regarding the compiler or from their Solidity to their bytecode.
19:45The ZK rollups, it's a bit unstable part. And the optimistic rollups, it's, yeah, you know, It seems that it's more stable than ZK rollups so far because ZKP is a really difficult space still. Maybe you saw that two days ago or three days ago. The new vulnerability is affecting many kinds of ZKP fundamentals. Such things can happen. But the optimistic rollup idea is much more simple than ZK rollups. And so, due to that, ultimately ZK rollups are the best, but the optimistic rollups have a stable kind of operation so far. And actually, they're doing better than ZK rollups.
20:39They're doing much better than ZK rollups so far in terms of adoption. So yeah, we need to admit that. We are ZKP people, but we need to admit that. So yeah, optimistic rollups have an advantage over ZK rollups till now. But right now, MegaETH people. Many kind of successful ZK rollups are coming. And I hope that it will bring more significant evolution to Ethereum space. And also, you know, BitVM is inspired by optimistic rollups, right? So it's already made many, many good influence on many innovative spaces.
21:35So it's doing their job. And in Ethereum systems, the problem is like the fragmentation among layer 2s. It's a bit harsher than people expected in 2020. In 2020, people expect that, you know, sound people do the sound competition of the layer 2s. And some winner make kind of division, but they have a more sovereignty of their development. And it should be recognized as a part of Ethereum. But what is happening on Ethereum layer 2 space? The liquidity and community and users are significantly separated, let's say, fragmented.
22:25And also, people are not recognizing layer 2s as a part of Ethereum. And this is a very big problem. And actually, it's a part of Ethereum, especially stage 2 or stage 1 rollups. It's definitely part of Ethereum. But people do not recognize it right away. And yeah, it's problematic in terms of adoption.
22:54This problem also happened from our nature as libertarians, right? So libertarians and kind of freedom advocates, they easily branch, right? And they start to fight each other. And the people with good business-minded kind of policy, for example, Base, they can kind of have a significant influence to unite people. And they're much better than kind of libertarian mindset people, yes? And that's what happened on Ethereum ecosystem, in my opinion. So I love most of the layer 2s, and I'm a big fan of them. At the same time, kind of some kind of unification, unifying each other, the libertarians, is needed right now.
23:54And I'm not pretty sure if in Bitcoin space or in ZK space, this would happen as well. Maybe it might be possible, right? So many, many layer 2s. But the one big guy with a good business mindset take everything, and the libertarians are still fighting each other. It might be possible. And yeah, so as a libertarian mindset, how we need to unify people somehow in the same direction, even if sometimes we don't like each other.
24:31Vlad CosteaWell, yeah, that's kind of the point of money, right? To get people who don't know each other or don't like each other to make trade with something that they both agree that has value. But at the same time, it's very difficult to promote something like Base when there was an AWS outage a few days ago, or a couple of weeks ago, I don't remember, I'm very lost in time with these kind of events. But there was something that happened with AWS, which is the server system from Amazon that you can rent.
25:08And Base was down and had some reliability issues because of this. So if anything, we should search for something which scales and enables people to validate or run individual nodes so that we don't have to deal with decentralization issues. Like, it's nice that we are creating layer twos. But at the same time, we should also be cautious with these layer twos to be sure that, of course, they should not be as decentralized as layer ones, but they should have a degree of decentralization to enable users to participate and make this more censorship resistant. Because if you rely on just a bunch of corporate servers, you can't expect that to have the values that we expect, first of all.
25:57And secondly, the people who can't afford the fees on layer one and they onboard layer twos, they're gonna have like a second class citizen experience.
26:07Leona HiokiYeah, it's totally true. But actually, it's, you know, everything, it's kind of market principle. And this is a trade off people choose by themselves as well. It's a bit difficult point, because everybody complains about decentralization, kind of lack of decentralization and the liveness when the server cloud system problem happens. But, you know, they should have noticed before that. So basically, they have been choosing this trade off for themselves. So it's a bit hard to make it happen, you know, and having the same choice at the same time, like having a decentralization and the extremely short finality for smart contract and the extremely stable cheap gas fee at the same time.
27:06Actually, it's not, it's not on the same trade-off. So it's out of the trade off. And it's unnatural sometimes. So, yeah, I think people have a right to kind of complain about this kind of lack of liveness or decentralization. At the same time, people need to be kind of aware of the trade off they're choosing.
27:39Vlad CosteaYeah, I want to also talk about other topics, because you said we only have one hour. But at the same time, one question when I talk with someone working on rollups, is to explain the difference between a rollup and a sidechain. Because sidechains for a long time, like a decade now, have been kind of the goal to create the two-way pegged sidechain. One of my sponsors is also LayerTwo Labs, which is trying to build drivechains. And that one basically is a two-way pegged sidechain that enables miners to secure sidechains with different features, like an Ethereum sidechain for Bitcoin, a Zcash sidechain for Bitcoin and everything else that can be interesting and useful for people.
28:22But it seems like these ZK rollups, especially with BitVM, they're getting traction, mainly, I think, because they do not require any kind of soft fork. So you can just run them with not maybe a trustless setup, but trust minimized. But I want you as a developer to tell me what you think are the differences between sidechains and rollups.
28:49Leona HiokiSo basically, it's all about having a same security assumption of Layer 1. So this is a definition of Layer 2. So in a strict definition, maybe stage 2 rollups are only the Layer 2s, and the others are sidechain, we can say that. And so drivechain, it's not a sidechain, actually, it's a Layer 2, and it has almost full security assumption of Layer 1. And especially about Bitcoin, kind of, you know, two-way peg of Bitcoin, it's totally the same security assumption of Layer 1. And so rollups and drivechain, Lightning Network, they are Layer 2, and sidechain are not Layer 2, simply because they're, you know, their ultimate security is on their validators.
29:51So the majority of their validators say yes, it's yes, and the majority of their validators say no, it's no, and no, it's a totally different kind of system regarding security. Rollups, it's kind of, Rollups, we can see that Rollups are sidechains managed by smart contract on Layer 1. So smart contract security is guaranteed by Layer 1 security, right? So yeah, Rollups are sidechains, which is managed on the, and also, let's say, regulated by smart contract. And sidechains are not regulated by smart contract, just they're kind of recording some data to do that two-way peg.
30:54Vlad CosteaI think it's also useful pointing out that in Bitcoin right now, the rollups that we're gonna have, like Citrea or Alpen, they're optimistically verified rollups. They're not full rollups like in the case of Ethereum.
31:09Leona HiokiMany limitations on Bitcoin kind of script, and yeah, I think some kind of trick is needed, like that, I think so. At the same time, sometimes I feel kind of, it's not strange, but, you know, I feel wonder. I just wonder why Bitcoin Layer 1 does not verify ZKP by opcodes. I think it's maybe, in the future, it should be time for that, in my opinion, because, you know, people of core dev robots rejected many kind of functionality from Bitcoin script, simply because nodes are kind of, nodes' computation have limitations, of course, but the spec of the nodes and the spec of the computers in this world is increasing all the time.
32:17So in the future, you know, there will be a time to accept that Bitcoin script is able to verify ZK-SNARK or ZK-STARK kind of natively without compromising their decentralization. So it's just a matter of time, it's just a matter of, you know, timing to kind of introduce that new opcode. So the problem is when. And so what do you think about this point? You know, ZK-SNARK, many people are inventing many ways to verify ZK-SNARK on Bitcoin, and BitVM is the most kind of significant way to do that. But so right now, why don't we kind of introduce new opcodes for that?
33:27Vlad CosteaWell, the reason is that there is this cultural issue in Bitcoin. I like to point this out a lot that Bitcoin doesn't have any technical issue per se. There are a lot of solutions to every issue. It's a cultural issue that people don't agree with anything. And it's very difficult for them to understand because I think along the way, while we accepted mass adoption, we also onboarded a bunch of people who don't really understand how Bitcoin works. And they think that as long as the price goes up, there is no need for any technical improvements to be made.
34:02If anything, they think that these technical improvements can actually be detrimental and make the price not go up anymore. Because maybe that Wall Street investors or, I don't know, central bankers or whatever, they will get cold feet about Bitcoin and be afraid to purchase any more of it and potentially sell it. And that's why I guess a lot of users are very cautious about any proposal that can bring more privacy or more scalability on-chain. Because basically the scaling layer that we have nowadays is the ETF or the paper Bitcoin.
34:41I think those are the most used ones today. They're more popular than the actual base layer. But it's also an existential threat to Bitcoin because the price can't double every four years to keep all the miners profitable. And we do need to get to a point in a few years where a lot of the mining revenue comes from transaction fees, which we still don't have.
35:07Leona HiokiYeah. So do you think bringing kind of more revenue out of Bitcoin transaction fee and block reward, like kind of reward in the transaction fee and drivechain transaction fee in the other sidechains or rollups? Do they have bad effect on Bitcoin or good effect on Bitcoin? So miners can have more rewards by kind of running or verifying layer 2s or EVM chains whatsoever on Bitcoin.
36:00Vlad CosteaI don't see the bad effect. It's just that it's a lot of politics and you look at it from the point of view of an engineer. But if you try to invest a lot of time into promoting upgrades on Bitcoin, you're going to see that anything that requires any kind of soft fork gets frowned upon. And even the stuff that doesn't require a soft fork gets frowned upon. And they're like, oh, but do we really need this? Because we were supposed to use Bitcoin in this way.
36:29But the problem is that it's not used in that way. It did not get this critical adoption at the base layer. A lot of the ways in which Lightning is used is custodial and still the liquidity on Lightning is very small. It's like 4,000 Bitcoin. So by a few metrics, the Lightning Network is not successful. Liquid Federation is also not successful. It's a bit depressing. Once again, one of the sponsors of the show is LayerTwo Labs. Let me promote the sponsors and then we can move on to the next topic.
37:04LayerTwo Labs and they have the software that's ready. So if you want to see what the future of Bitcoin can look like, you go to layertwolabs.com/download. And you try the software on the Bitcoin signet, which I think is very polished and functional. And if you need someone to send you some coins so that you can experiment on the signet. There's also a Telegram chat that's called Drivechain Talk. Check it out. I think you will have a lot of stuff to discover and it can be a very fun weekend project.
37:35Another sponsor is NoOnes, which is a peer-to-peer marketplace which aims to empower the global south. The CEO of NoOnes is Ray Youssef, who was previously active in Paxful as the CEO. But he discovered that you can't really reach this goal by being based in the US as you have to deal with a lot of regulations that stop you from it. So he created NoOnes today and it's very popular in Africa. It's super popular in South America and the Middle East. And basically, if you decide to trade your Bitcoin on NoOnes, you're giving liquidity to these people who are going to be buying it from you and reselling it within their communities at a premium.
38:16But the principle is called everyone gets a seat at the table and everyone eats. If you want to check out NoOnes, it's N-O-O-N-E-S dot com. And they have a marketplace for goods and services. They have a spot exchange. They have a peer-to-peer exchange and also a debit card for spending your coins. There is also Bitcoin.com News, which I think does a very good job nowadays at being balanced. What I like about them is that they're not as political as Bitcoin Magazine and also not as corporate as CoinDesk.
38:50They find sort of a middle spot where they also present some community efforts and also push out some press releases, which I guess is the industry standard. And they also cover gold and other markets which maybe are not present on other websites. So I check out Bitcoin.com News a few times a week just because it has very special coverage that I don't find anywhere else. And I recommend people to go to news.bitcoin.com because they're no longer the website that says BTC is slow and expensive and you should use BCH.
39:29Now they're even orange. So check it out. And last but not least, there is SideShift, which is the place where you can swap coins. If you have USDT or USDC and you believe we're in a bull market, then you can basically swap immediately with very good volumes and low fees. And if you believe we're in a bear market and it's time for you to swap into stablecoins, you can also do that. So check it out. It's S-I-D-E-S-H-I-F-T dot AI SideShift dot AI.
40:03Not available in the US, unfortunately, but pretty cool otherwise. I also want to ask you Leona about basically your Bitcoin journey and what Bitcoin is like in Japan, because of course Bitcoin has this story with the creator who has a Japanese name. I'm curious if that matters a lot in Japan, if it motivates people to get more involved, if there are more projects. I think the only other person I've interviewed from Japan was the CEO of Nayuta, a Lightning implementation.
40:45And I'm curious because that was a few years ago and I don't know much about Japan. I would love to come if you ever have a conference and you need someone to do stuff. I can join, that's gonna be a perfect excuse to visit Japan. And yeah, what's it like?
41:03Leona HiokiSo first of all, Satoshi's name, I'm not pretty sure people kind of care about that so much. Because maybe people thought that maybe some foreigners named after Pokemon, Satoshi.
41:23Vlad CosteaOh yeah, for context, Satoshi is the name of Ash Ketchum in the Pokemon series. So in the West, his name is Ash Ketchum, but in Japan he's Satoshi.
41:33Leona HiokiOh, I see, I didn't know that. So maybe that's a wrong statement. Yeah, maybe possible. Nakamoto, actually this name is not so popular and it's a family name. This is quite unfamiliar family name in Japan. Only one person I know, Nakamoto, is a famous philosopher quite a long time ago, maybe 300 years ago. That's the only famous Nakamoto for me. And so Satoshi is super kind of common name in Japan. But Nakamoto, it's a bit, yeah, it's strange to hear that name, by the way. So anyway, people, of course, many people got obsessed with Satoshi, actually.
42:28Some people believe that it's one of the dead computer scientists in Japan. And some people expect that it's kind of made by the CIA. Or no, maybe, might be possible some, many, many expectations or speculations. But yeah, Roger Ver, maybe you remember Roger Ver, right?
42:57Vlad CosteaYeah, he was in Japan also.
43:00Leona HiokiYeah, he was in Japan from the beginning of Bitcoin. And he made a lot of kind of promotion in Japan. And they also, yeah, for example, my wife was, yeah, knew Bitcoin because of him. Yeah, he did many things in Japan. So there are many Bitcoin OGs, OBs, and there are many Bitcoin Maxis in Japan as well. I think, you know, that was really good for Japan. After 2018, the financial regulator kind of strengthened the regulation regarding exchanges and also ICOs and these kind of stuffs.
43:56And Japan lost significant amount of kind of traction and attractiveness in crypto market. So before 2018, Japan was more kind of out funding, having a good regulation and having a good community full of OBOGs. And also, you know, innovators. Maybe after 2018, especially foreigners left Japan because it's not so, it became not so kind of above crypto.
44:44Or, you know, kind of, it lost the position of the special place for crypto. And maybe because of that, you know, people still a bit kind of struggling to make it happen in Japan again. It's still in the way, and I cannot imagine that regulation will be better than U.S. In Japan. And regulation-wise, it's a bit difficult. The Japan way is pressured by itself, its own people, and also from kind of Western alignment as well.
45:36So both are quite kind of providing strict requirements. And the U.S. Can change their policy very quickly, like Trump got elected. And so kind of 180-degree change happens. But in Japan, once it's decided, it's very hard to change. So it's influenced by kind of Western alignment to regulate more, maybe this last decade or these 10 years. And it's still struggling to change their kind of direction. It's a situation of Japan. So not starting from very bullish part, it's a bit, you know, I feel sorry about this, but yeah, it's kind of recovering right now. And I hope it will go well in the near future, like five years.
46:39Vlad CosteaOh, so you're kind of pessimistic. I guess this is why you moved to Switzerland to build INTMAX, right?
46:48Leona HiokiYeah, so especially a privacy project, yes. And the privacy project in Japan, as I said before, one of the computer scientists died in Japan. And he fought maybe 10 years with the government because he made a peer-to-peer, what we call illegal kind of software. And he had many kind of trials for a long time. And yeah, he is one of the candidates of Satoshi in Japan. I don't think so, but no, many people believe so. And it's implying that making peer-to-peer or kind of crypto rated technology, it's irrationally pressured or not only regulated, no, irrationally pressured in Japan at the time.
48:03And yeah, it was a very difficult time. And I didn't have any kind of candidate besides Switzerland because many places were not so friendly to privacy, the US both, at the time. After Trump, no, it's changed a lot. But before that, it's almost impossible to go there as a foreigner to start a privacy project. And so, yeah, that's the reason why I moved to Switzerland. It's not like Japan was, but it's kind of especially bad, particularly bad. Many places were totally awful to privacy at that moment. So Switzerland had a quite rational way to regulate it or kind of not so hostile policy regarding that point. So yeah, that's good.
49:04Vlad CosteaI remember last year, and I'm not sure if it's nice to disclose, but Amir Taaki has had a lot of these situations. He's building DarkFi in Switzerland, as far as I know. And I think last week he was actually raided by the Swiss police. And they tried to arrest him and made him sign documents. But last year I met him in Mexico City for a privacy conference. And when he made his way and he was a bit late, he said that he was actually detained in Japan for a few hours at the airport.
49:37And they were trying to ask him questions like, are you trying to undermine the power of nation states? Are you trying to destroy our currency? Stuff like this.
49:44Leona HiokiIn Japan? Yeah. Well, why?
49:47Vlad CosteaI think he was in the HBO documentary about Bitcoin. And he presented this very anarchistic perspective of Bitcoin. And maybe he was like sort of a celebrity for a while when he was traveling. And they saw him and they recognized him. And I guess he's also... on lists because of some political statements that he's made.
50:14Leona HiokiAh, yeah. When was that?
50:17Vlad CosteaYou mean which Japanese city or airport?
50:20Leona HiokiOh, when was that? When?
50:22Vlad CosteaYeah, a year ago.
50:24Leona HiokiAh, I see. It's strange that he got detained, you know, there.
50:32Vlad CosteaI mean, he was held for questioning for a few hours.
50:35Leona HiokiI see. But you know, there's no way to attack the currency of Japan. Just kind of stay in the airport, right?
50:44Vlad CosteaOf course not.
50:45Leona HiokiYeah, it's strange. That's basically in Japanese society, how they're not so familiar with libertarians. So it's a long history in Japan, you know, kind of such a rebellion against the Emperor. So the Emperor remained for 2,000 years, it's the same dynasty, the same one dynasty. And some thousand years ago, the dynasty fell or got detached from the power. Like in Japan, of course, it's the same as England as well. And you know, the power and the power were detached from the power, political power. It's been a while, you know, thousand years.
51:46Vlad CosteaJust a second, Leona, because there is an issue with the audio, let me fix it. Okay, you're saying about issues with the Emperor, I apologize to everyone. I've been dealing with this weird, since I updated OBS to the latest version on macOS, I've been dealing with this glitch, which I guess after an hour or something, the audio cuts off. But now it's fine. I fixed it.
52:12Leona HiokiOkay, got it. So, okay, so to summarize this, so yeah, Japan has a long history detached from the power, you know, maybe it's over a thousand years. And so nobody had enough excuse to have a rebellion against the Emperor. The Emperor has been at the top of society for a long time, it's more than 2000 years. With this kind of condition or with kind of historical condition, libertarian is quite weird, you know, kind of existence in Japanese society, right? So why people should be libertarians in Japanese society?
53:03It's really hard to kind of answer to that question. And so, for example, in US, it's from the beginning, kind of libertarian, right? So basically, you know, the US itself was founded by the tea traders, you know, and they threw away their, you know, tea stuff to the Boston Gulf, right? And this kind of libertarian movement is always the beginning of the current nation or society. In France as well, and in many places like that, some rebellion happens, and it started kind of new kind of society. And Japan did not experience that, and libertarian is a bit kind of weird existence.
53:59And so let's say Bitcoin mindset or kind of Bitcoin, you know, the concept itself is really, really kind of interesting for Japanese people in another perspective from, you know, which maybe Westerners don't have, and yeah, I think so. So maybe if you experience, you know, kind of crypto ecosystem in Japan, it must be different from your country. I think so, because the history is totally different.
54:42Vlad CosteaI also heard stories from Tokyo that there's this Lamborghini that was first bought by Roger Ver with Bitcoin, and it's been sold multiple times to different Bitcoin people. But it's still in Tokyo, and it's still like an icon for people who know what this is. And I'm pretty sure that there are a lot of landmarks. One open source developer, actually, I know a few of them. You're not actually the second. I've also had Koji Higashi on the show, Coin and Peace. And I've also had Nicolas Dorier from BTCPay.
55:17Leona HiokiYeah, in Japan. You know Jonathan Underwood? He's also in Japan.
55:24Vlad CosteaNo, I'm not sure I know him. Maybe I should.
55:28Leona HiokiYeah, no, he's always in the Bitcoin Core people's hub in Japan. And yeah, basically, yeah, there are many kind of OB, OGs of Bitcoin in Tokyo, in Japan as well. And cryptography-wise, there are many cryptographers in Japan. And yeah, that's something that we followed. But the separation of the cryptography space and the crypto space, I don't think it's deep, but it's quite separated. So I don't know anybody from the cryptography kind of academic space attending, for example, Bitcoin conference or Ethereum conference in Japan. It's very, I think it's very rare.
56:30Vlad CosteaI also think it would be very interesting to invite them to a conference on a panel just to get their views to see what's the roadblock there, like what prevents them from getting involved. Maybe it's a sense of loyalty, because for a long time, cryptography was attached to the nation state and to national security. And cryptographers are sort of people working for the government for defense purposes to secure important documents or whatever, communications.
57:03Leona HiokiYeah, the last crypto war was actually not the blockchain war. The first one was like the encryption war back to the beginning of the internet, on how to encrypt the internet. And the US government wanted to regulate that, kind of limit that to 32 bits or something like that, which is totally kind of breakable. And yeah, so cryptographers did a lot of jobs to make this kind of internet space separated from the power of the nation states. And maybe the Financial Cryptography conference started from Anguilla, island of Anguilla, near the US.
57:50And a lot of tech libertarians went there together and started this movement. Yeah, Bitcoin's, on this long history, started from that movement. And yeah, right now, the Financial Cryptography conference itself, very, very blockchain oriented, basically occupied by blockchain people. But actually, they were kind of older than the history of blockchain. And yeah, I think it's quite interesting history. They already had a lot of fights before Bitcoin.
58:33Vlad CosteaYeah, just for the record, to the listeners, I also have an interview with Phil Zimmermann about PGP. And I think it's one of my highlights from two years ago. You can check it out. It's, I think, season 14, episode 20 something. Search for it. I think it's really good. It's about 30 minutes long, so it shouldn't take too long for you to go through it. But it's really amazing how far we have come because Satoshi himself used PGP. And this was part of his setup to be able to stay anonymous.
59:08And without the fights that cryptographers before him have fought, we would not be here. So we got to pay respects to David Chaum, to Phil Zimmermann, to all the others who, in times when there was no money to be made from this, there was no coin on which they could speculate and make a lot of money, they defended this technology and they made sure that it becomes available to the masses. Without them, we could never have Bitcoin.
59:43Leona HiokiYeah, maybe I need to watch that as well. But how many stories did you already kind of podcast?
59:53Vlad CosteaBy stories, you mean episodes?
59:55Leona HiokiOh yeah, episodes, yeah.
59:57Vlad Costea300 something in almost seven years. I used to do it like once per week, but now, for example, this week has been the craziest. This is, I think, my fourth or fifth this week. It seems like...
1:00:11Leona HiokiBecause of Zcash.
1:00:13Vlad CosteaI don't think it's because of Zcash, it's just scheduling. For example, the previous episode was the CEO and the CTO of Trezor. We actually did a live unboxing and demo of their new device, and that's where I also met you, in Prague, at the Trezor event. I have this on my desk still, and I did the initial setup with it. It's an interesting device. It actually pairs well with the iPhone, which was part of the reason why I wanted to do that, because before this, there was no way to use a Trezor hardware wallet with your iPhone, and now it's possible, and I think it's a game changer.
1:00:49Leona HiokiYeah, recent one is kind of more Bluetooth-oriented, and I like it.
1:00:57Vlad CosteaYeah, and it's also encrypted. That's also something I like.
1:01:01Leona HiokiYeah, no, before this, I was a bit afraid of using Bluetooth for hardware wallets, but yeah, this one, I really got ready to use it.
1:01:15Vlad CosteaYeah, but you also have the screen to verify, so when you're signing, you should always double-check. Don't blindly trust the hardware. Yeah. Because there's the other one, I think it's called Bitkey, by Jack Dorsey, and it's basically a rock that you hold in your hand, and it has a couple of buttons to confirm transactions. Like, you should always have a screen on the device to verify. If you don't have a screen, it's kind of pointless.
1:01:41Leona HiokiYeah. It is possible.
1:01:46Vlad CosteaAnd it's a lesson that people should learn, I don't know why we have this mentality that people try something for the first time, when in fact it's been tried before. The first Ledger Nano had no screen, so that's why they made the Ledger Nano S, that's what the S stands for, screen, and the first BitBox also had no screen.
1:02:07Leona HiokiOh, I know that S was named after screen.
1:02:11Vlad CosteaIt's also kind of an iPhone type of naming, because at the time there was, for example, in between iPhone 5 and 6, there was the 5S, which was like the slightly improved one. But, yeah, S stands for screen in the case of the Ledger Nano.
1:02:28Leona HiokiOn the announcement of this one, quantum resistance was also under the discussion. It's said to be quantum resistant.
1:02:40Vlad CosteaWell, it's quantum ready.
1:02:43Leona HiokiReady, so ready, okay, it's a bit different. But, you know, what do you think about that? So, does your community of Bitcoin or your community of Zcash, do they care about quantum resistance right now?
1:02:58Vlad CosteaNot so much. I think it's kind of a paper tiger. It's something that is made to scare people, but at the same time it's not real. And not too many people are concerned about it, but it's, I think, useful to move to cryptography, which is designed to resist potential quantum attacks. Of course, this is only about the firmware, so you cannot compromise the firmware potentially or allegedly with a quantum computer if we had one. But the coins in your wallet, they can be compromised because they still use ECDSA and signature schemes that if we actually got there to that point of computation, they could be broken.
1:03:42So the fact that you're using this Trezor, yes, is more secure than the average hardware wallet, but at the same time you should not expect it to protect your assets from quantum computing because that's not how it works. They added this quantum cryptography, I guess, because it's fashionable and because it's part of the trend to move from the old style to something that is more resilient.
1:04:09Leona HiokiYeah, one thing we need to care about is quantum computing and privacy stuff. Basically, a privacy project cannot realize that they are hacked immediately because if cryptography is broken by quantum computers, we don't have a way to realize that. What do you think about this point? Some people might say that it's a bit scary in comparison with non privacy kind of preserving projects.
1:04:49Vlad CosteaYeah, so what you're referring to is that we can have situations where people get robbed and nobody else can see. And we can also have situations where there's hidden inflation.
1:05:02Leona HiokiYeah, yeah, maybe something like that. Maybe hackers do not do the significant inflation for the beginning. And when Mt. Gox was hacked, the hacker did not throw all the money at the same time, at one time. Basically, they kind of steadily withdraw from Mt. Gox and they maximize their profit to scare people.
1:05:28Vlad CosteaYeah, but that's actually smart. That's how withdrawals should be done. You fly under the radar, that's how it works. But I understand what you're saying. I think the design of Zcash, which was from the beginning to have a transparent side and a shielded side, is what eventually Bitcoin will become. And I also believe them when they say that this is why they made it like this, so they can prove that there is no inflation in the system. And also to make it
1:06:29Leona HiokiCompatible with Bitcoin, because if they went shielded from the beginning, I don't think that's ever going to happen. In Bitcoin, we are culturally tied to this model. And I think privacy will always be an option, for better and for worse. Yeah, I think it's quite wise.
1:06:29It's interesting that UTXO itself is a very unique idea from the beginning. So if I, the founder of the cryptocurrency, for example, maybe I have no talent to start from UTXO. Maybe I would use a more account-based model, like everybody's balance is recorded to one slot. It's an easier way to understand, right? Maybe it's an easier way to implement design. But UTXO is adopted by Bitcoin. It's really interesting. I think that they prepared for the soft fork in the future for adding more functionality like privacy or scaling afterwards without doing the hard fork.
1:07:23And it's a good match, UTXO, on the soft fork-based functionality expansions. And yeah, so maybe it might be possible, you know, the founders of Bitcoin prepared for this at the moment to add more functionality without security and security problem more and peer of the security regarding having new functionalities.
1:08:00Vlad CosteaYeah, first of all, I like how you refer to the founders of Bitcoin, like there are more of them. And I also think that we should look back into what Satoshi gave us, because he disabled some opcodes at one point when he was concerned about potentially having some vulnerabilities. But the intention of Satoshi was to have a much more powerful tech stack that enables builders to do a lot more with Bitcoin. And he was also not this toxic kind of guy who said you should not do this with the technology.
1:08:33He supported Namecoin when it was called BitDNS, I think. And he said, yeah, it should be a merged mined blockchain with its own asset. And the miners can collect transaction fees from that one too. And also mining rewards, like, he was very open about this kind of stuff. And he left us with a lot of interesting technology, which we're not currently using. And there's this renaissance of people looking back to see, well, what did Satoshi also build? Well, in the initial version of the software, you were also able to do this and this and this, and today we don't have that in Bitcoin anymore.
1:09:13And it's interesting. It's interesting also as a thought experiment, like what it could have been if we had all of these opcodes and developers could build without asking for permission. But it's also interesting as a challenge, how to bring them back.
1:09:33I think, once again, the issue that Bitcoin has is not technical at all. It's cultural. It's people who have been indoctrinated to a degree that Bitcoin is digital gold. And they have been sold ideas about what this means. And then someone puts inscriptions on the blockchain and everyone is shocked, like, how is this even possible? And they have no context of colored coins or counterparty or something else that came before. And then they act like they should purge the blockchain to make sure that there are no such transactions ever recorded.
1:10:07And they also become overly concerned about the kind of content that gets inside. Because we spent so many years saying Bitcoin is permissionless and there's nothing you can do to stop a transaction. And then you have a part of the users who come along and they say, well, let's filter and let's make it so easy for everyone else to filter by running this version of the code. And I don't see how this is gonna lead to a positive outcome where governments can just come to us and say, hey, since you're filtering these transactions, why don't you also add this list of addresses that you're blocking?
1:10:45Why don't you also add this list of nodes that you're gonna be blocking? And once you open up the floodgates and you accept that you'll be filtering, I don't see how you can say no after that point.
1:11:02Leona HiokiIf you don't think Bitcoin is a digital gold, what do you express Bitcoin? How do you express Bitcoin?
1:11:12Vlad CosteaI think it's a money network.
1:11:14Leona HiokiMoney network?
1:11:16Vlad CosteaIt's a computer network, first of all, which issues this currency that people use in different ways. And also think it's sort of like Linux. It's a design that was left to us that we can modify and we can fork and we can experiment with it. It should not be monolithic. I remember there was this guy, Rodolfo Novak, who is the CEO of Coinkite, the company that builds the Coldcard wallet. For a while he was playing with licenses that restrict use for altcoins. So basically you can only use the software for BTC and nothing else.
1:11:58So he was trying to do this and that's not really open source software. And that's not really something that gives incentives to other people to pick up and try to break and try to build something useful and maybe find other bugs or improve upon it. That's why I say that Bitcoin is like Linux because it's supposed to be tested and you're supposed to use the code for other purposes and find either limitations or opportunities to it.
1:12:31Leona HiokiSo is Bitcoin monolithic right now? So basically we have many many kind of layer twos on Bitcoin. And you know, there's many ways to scale that and so it's kind of defined as a monolithic chain or kind of cryptography system. Do you think so, regarding Bitcoin?
1:12:59Vlad CosteaI think right now it's like 60% of the market. Maybe 50-something, I don't know. I haven't looked at charts lately. But by saying that Bitcoin is monolithic, you're choosing to ignore 40% of what's happening out there.
1:13:18Leona HiokiSo you are comparing Bitcoin and the other altcoins.
1:13:23Vlad CosteaI mean, what did you mean by monolithic?
1:13:26Leona HiokiBasically monolithic you know, this word is used for using blockchain space, like architecture of blockchain. It's like monolithic blockchains like Solana and then modular blockchain instead, like Ethereum, or like that. No, it's kind of typical comparison. And you didn't refer to that, but basically you were talking about dominance.
1:13:55Vlad CosteaOh, now I understand what you meant, but we decided to not scale on-chain. That was part of the outcome of the block size wars. So since we have limited capacity, it cannot be monolithic. It's going to be modular. We're going to build on layer twos. The problem is that there are layer twos that sound very good. They have competent teams, but they cannot be built in the current framework. And it's kind of terrible that we cannot have like an actual free market to choose between them.
1:14:32And it becomes monolithic in the sense that we decide culturally that for example Lightning is the way to go and that's the only way. And then we run into all the problems that it causes. And we realize, okay, this cannot be the only way, but we have spent so many years already working on this. And we have fallen behind. I think Ethereum has more interesting layer twos. There are ideas that Bitcoin can take from them and part of them are coming back like ZK rollups. But still I think we should have proper sidechains, which we have been promised for 10 years now.
1:15:12And maybe that some of these new ideas also have a place. It's just that most of them require some sort of covenant soft fork or OP_CAT or whatever. And I don't see that coming. And I wish we could let these builders actually build and we could just choose the best stuff that's out there.
1:15:38Leona HiokiAs far as I remember, drivechain, basically it's based on BIP 300 and 301, but basically 301 is kind of optional and you know, we can have another kind of alternative way to do the same thing instead of BIP 301. And this BIP 300 itself can be replaced by BitVM, right? So actually, drivechain is kind of available right now, isn't it?
1:16:17Vlad CosteaI think they could be built with OP_CAT. But there are two dimensions to the drivechain proposal. There's the actual drivechains and there's also BIP 301, which does merged mining, blind merged mining. And that one would actually provide some protections that you don't get only with OP_CAT. Like technically you could make these miner enforced sidechains.
1:16:47Leona HiokiI think that BIP 301 can be replaced by adapter signature or something like that. And so yeah, only the problem is like BIP 300.
1:17:00Vlad CosteaMaybe I should get you in a call with Paul if you have any interesting idea.
1:17:06Leona HiokiYeah, it's a, well, yeah, what an unexpected pleasure.
1:17:10Vlad CosteaAre you friends with Paul Sztorc?
1:17:12Leona HiokiNo, I'm just following him.
1:17:14Vlad CosteaOkay, maybe I should connect you if you think that you can replace BIP 301 with something else. That's interesting, even though I see that there is interest in activating this on Litecoin and let's see how that goes. Because there's a lot of concern in Bitcoin that this can lead, for example, one of the situations described is that what if one of the sidechains becomes dominant and has more transactions and more activity than the base layer?
1:17:46Like isn't there an incentive there to basically pervert what's happening with mining? And also there are people concerned that if you're going to have different sidechains with different features, like let's say you have a Zcash sidechain and an Ethereum sidechain, they're not going to be equally valued on the market. Because maybe there's more demand for the privacy sidechain than there is for the smart contract sidechain. And therefore you're going to have different kinds of BTC which trade at different prices. But I think that's not much of a concern to be honest.
1:18:25The market will solve this. You already have a bunch of wrapped assets and all sorts of liquid coins, which represent ownership on another blockchain. Like if I look at CoinGecko right now, in the top 10 you have Lido or Lido Staked Ether. And you also have Wrapped stETH, S-T-E-T-H, you have Wrapped Bitcoin. Wrapped Beacon ETH.
1:18:59Leona HiokiYeah, or Coinbase Bitcoin. Exactly. But yeah, let's get back to the discussion regarding the drivechain. Drivechain, so basically the idea of drivechain requires a stateless client for the sidechain. Otherwise, the miners need to have the full database of the sidechain and it's not entirely good. Because if you have more requirement about having database outside of the Bitcoin blockchain, we cannot call that scalable. But if it's kind of stateless client, miners do not have to store and make a big database in addition to the Bitcoin blockchain.
1:19:55They can make kind of drivechain without adding kind of cost to the miners or let's say hash motors. So I think drivechain should be revisited by people because it can be more functional with more functionality like EVMs. And actually if we apply stateless client of Ethereum to drivechain idea, Ethereum main chain set or Ethereum layer can be one of the drivechain for Bitcoin. It's not kind of defining which is greater. It's yeah, literally, technically, we can say that stateless client can be a drivechain.
1:20:46Ethereum layer one can be a drivechain of Bitcoin. And so if the era of the stateless client happens by ZKP, I think drivechain idea should be heavily more revisited by people. It was too early in 2015. But no, right now, the stateless client technology, it's well-developed by ZKPs. Yeah, I think so.
1:21:21Vlad CosteaYeah, I should definitely get you in a conversation with Paul, because you have some good ideas about how this can work. I'm pretty sure that you already thought about most of it. He's a smart guy. And he did a lot of the math. It's just that what I'm trying to do with my podcast is to open people's minds and get them to realize that there is so much more out there. And the mission is not to be friends with BlackRock and just accept that we're going to be this treasury asset that people use as collateral or something for loans in stablecoins or US dollars.
1:22:00There's so much more to it. And we should be building a parallel economy. We should be having actual cypherpunk marketplaces or whatever. Just something that gives us more freedom and allows us to have more privacy. I think that's the goal here. I also want to ask you about Zcash. You mentioned it a few times. What do you think about it? It's been around for nine years now. It seems like it's finally reaching its full potential and getting more recognition. The price is like $545 right now, which is incredible.
1:22:38Leona HiokiYeah. So basically, of course, Zcash is the absolute pioneer of their ZKP technology in crypto space. And privacy, full privacy of coin has been super undervalued for 10 years, since the beginning of Zcash. And yeah, it's amazing that it's still super hot. It's making another movement in this crypto or blockchain industry or blockchain space. And financial privacy, it's very, very complicated. So for example, Monero had a big community. They made a lot of private money. I thought it was really good. People might say that, what's the difference? Monero and Zcash, for example. It's not only about the encryption, right? Some kind of attitudes toward society are a bit different.
1:24:00And so I believe that Monero is more anarchy kind of stuff. It's more hostile to the government. And Zcash is kind of neutral. And that's the main difference in my opinion. But in that sense, Zcash kind of attitudes to the society is a bit similar to Ethereum, more than Bitcoin community, in my opinion. So that's a first impression on the...
1:24:37Vlad CosteaHello? Leona?
1:24:43Leona HiokiYeah, sorry.
1:24:43Vlad CosteaOh, I was thinking you froze or something. Maybe there's a technical issue.
1:24:48Leona HiokiYeah, I was literally froze. My brain reader is froze right now. It's thinking about how to describe the kind of mysterious features of Zcash. I cannot expect how it will be like 10 years. And this is a really interesting point, right? So most of the systems in crypto industry are more expectable, how it will be in 10 years or five years. And Bitcoin will be like this, Ethereum will be like this, layer twos will be like this. No, I feel it's more expectable, predictable. Zcash, it's really unpredictable for me.
1:25:40And this is why I'm super excited. And also I'm fully into this kind of financial privacy space, which is a small space in crypto space, which is getting bigger. So what do you think about this? So what do you think
1:26:10Vlad CosteaZcash will be like in 10 years? Oh, that's a good question. So there are two scenarios. There's one where Bitcoin adopts the technology of Zcash, and there's one where Zcash remains the only one of its kind. And I think both of them are kind of bullish for Zcash, because if Bitcoin acknowledges that this technology is useful, then they can use Zcash to be like the layer that pushes research to the next level. Like they're trying whatever is avant-garde in academia and advanced cryptography that maybe is too experimental for Bitcoin to actually try.
1:26:44And in the event that Bitcoin does not adopt this, I can also see a scenario where Zcash, even though they're more advanced than Bitcoin, they become also sort of ossifiers. And they say this technology is good enough and we should not mess too much with it. And the community will just want something that gives them the right kind of privacy, but also makes the number go up, makes them rich. So I think if Bitcoin adopts Zerocash, which is the protocol that Zcash uses, then there's going to be more innovation and there's going to be more of an incentive to push privacy to the next level.
1:27:30If Bitcoin does not adopt that, I think there is a chance that if the community gets bigger, there's going to be more of a movement to become conservative. But also, I think there's going to be a push to find the next big thing that Bitcoin might adopt, because Zcash was started by some of the most bullish and positive OGs that were in Bitcoin. You can actually find their accounts on BitcoinTalk and you can find a lot of their tweets until 2015.
1:28:05Leona HiokiVitalik himself was quite a Bitcoiner. He was the editor of the Bitcoin Magazine, right?
1:28:11Vlad CosteaYeah, and Zcash has 21 million coins and was designed exactly after Bitcoin, started with 12.5 rewards, just like it was at the time in Bitcoin. So obviously, if you look at some of the design choices, it's clear that this was meant to be something that is going to be used by Bitcoin, but somehow the culture changed. And I do respect what's happening in Zcash and I like it a lot and I wish this was Bitcoin instead. We wouldn't have to talk about Bitcoin and Zcash right now, we would just talk about shielding your Bitcoin.
1:28:50Leona HiokiYeah, maybe possible.
1:28:53Vlad CosteaBut I'm enthusiastic that privacy is popular and also want to add something to your classification where you described Zcash and Monero and how they're different. I think that they try to appeal to different markets. Monero is very focused on darknet and this idea that they should facilitate the purchase of goods. While Zcash right now is focused on DeFi, it's integrated with Hyperliquid and NEAR Intents. So basically, it's this intermediary asset where people try to break the link between their trades on DeFi. Basically, if traders don't want to reveal how much money they have or they want to get some privacy at some point, they swap their stablecoins into Zcash, they shield it, they wait for a while.
1:29:48And then they continue their trading by pegging out small amounts like you described that the Mt. Gox hacker was doing. So this is a strategy that they can use to minimize the amount of information that they give to the market about the money that they have. And I think that this market is more liquid and more dynamic than darknet markets, which are sort of more predictable and not really expanding. But I also see some brick and mortar adoption for Monero, like there are some stores like in actual real life where you can go and pay with it.
1:30:29Maybe Zcash will also get that. But right now they chose a more interesting path, which is to become a DeFi asset. And by design, the fact that they have this transparent and this shielded side of it makes it easier to integrate.
1:30:46Leona HiokiBut still, nobody is kind of making Zcash, wrapped on Ethereum right now, right? On Solana it's available, right?
1:30:54Vlad CosteaI guess there's an opportunity there. But Zcash has been big for Ethereum, because that's how ZK rollups were built, because of the research that Zcash did. And also there's Tornado Cash and Railgun, which are using some of the ZK-SNARK libraries.
1:31:19So I feel happy for these guys, they deserve it. I don't hold a lot of Zcash, I wish I did. But when I see that the price is going up, all I think about is, well, these people are going to have more research money. And what they have done so far is really amazing. And I really look forward, they have something called Tachyon, which is going to use oblivious synchronization to scale the privacy of Zcash to potentially billions of users. Interesting.
1:31:53Leona HiokiI think Zcash should adopt client-side validation from my perspective. Because if it's on-chain, it's kind of a limitation, right? So the same thing happened on Bitcoin, also happens on Zcash, isn't it?
1:32:11Vlad CosteaYou mean with the block size and stuff, like scaling issues?
1:32:17Leona HiokiYeah, scaling issues maybe are the same thing. What happened on Bitcoin will happen on Zcash as well, right? Isn't that?
1:32:26Vlad CosteaIt's very possible, if there's a lot of demand for block space, people can just fill the blocks and increase the transaction sizes. But Zcash also has faster blocks, I think it's 1.5 minutes right now.
1:32:40Leona HiokiYeah, but you know, if we have more kind of faster block production, the faster state growth happens to kind of make decentralization difficult. So that's why I'm thinking about why don't people apply client-side validation on Zcash. So if we apply client-side validation, almost only the root of the Merkle tree, let's say one hash, is recorded on blockchain. And everything happens off-chain, and it's encrypted just like the coins of Zcash.
1:33:24Vlad CosteaYou might be onto something here, maybe I should connect you to one of their cryptographers, or you can go to their forums and post about this. I know that Abdel from StarkWare proposed some STARK verification for Zcash, and he was actually quite successful in convincing the community. He ran an experiment and posted, first of all on the Bitcoin-dev mailing list, and then on the Zcash forums to see where he's gonna get more support. And it was actually the Zcash forums that said, well, this is a good idea, let's try it.
1:33:58Leona HiokiYeah, sounds great. And one year ago Zooko was following me, but after I retweeted some kind of, no, stupid tweet, he unfollowed me.
1:34:12Vlad CosteaI don't know, he's very unpredictable, he used to have me blocked for a while. I don't know exactly why, but I had to ask someone else, hey, can you tell Zooko to unblock me, and I think last year we got on a call, because I interviewed Roger Ver last year, and a lot of the Bitcoin community hated me for it. And it was a bit dramatic for reasons which I don't understand in retrospect. But basically Zooko was also in a bad situation at the time, he was trying to bring back Zcash, and it was in tough times, and he also felt the same way, like the Bitcoin community for which he put a lot of work, forgot about him, and kicked him out, and doesn't recognize his merits.
1:35:01And we had sort of a wholesome conversation last year. And I remember telling him, you know, I like your work with Zcash, but I would never invest in it because it seems to perform very poorly on the markets. You don't have much of a community. And maybe it motivated him or something. Maybe it made a change because I messaged him last week and I told him, you know, I was wrong. I'm really sorry I was wrong. I mean, I'm happy you're successful, but at the same time, I wish I bought more of this. I had more faith in it last year when it was like 30, 40. Dollars.
1:35:39Leona HiokiYeah, I think you're pretending to be a no-pointer.
1:35:43Vlad CosteaNo, it's called zidelined. When you don't have any Zcash, and you're just watching the price charts, you're called zidelined. Yeah, zidelined.
1:35:58Leona HiokiZeffed, zidelined. Yeah, that is quite an interesting moment. I didn't expect that Zcash, I actually, I was tweeting about, you know, Zcash will kind of get close to Monero, but no, kind of, this kind of flip happened, so I didn't expect that so early.
1:36:22Vlad CosteaI see lots of predictions, and I think the dominant narrative is that it's coming for Cardano and Solana, and Ripple potentially, like Ripple is the one that everyone hates, right?
1:36:38Leona HiokiYeah, how about you?
1:36:41Vlad CosteaI don't think too much about it. I don't think I hate it. I just don't get it, you know, for so many years they have been saying the same things like we're gonna replace Swift and we're gonna be the settlement network and our coin is gonna be used for settling banking transactions. And Then everyone gets excited and it's been like 10 years or more and they haven't done anything, but they keep saying the same old story. And it's like a game of poker where the only two cards they have is we are made in the US. And they also complain about Bitcoin being mined in China or being too energy intensive or something. They started a campaign against Bitcoin three or four years ago.
1:37:29Leona HiokiYeah, they did that. I remember that, I remember that. With Greenpeace. What's the name of the movement? Change the code?
1:37:37Vlad CosteaNo, change the code.
1:37:38Leona HiokiChange the code. Yeah, yeah, I remember that.
1:37:41Vlad CosteaThey were saying change the code, not the environment, or whatever.
1:37:45Leona HiokiNo, when Zcash gets bought by BlackRock, maybe the same thing happens, right? No, change the code for Zcash, it might be possible.
1:38:00Vlad CosteaI think they're already talking about having a hybrid of proof of work and proof of stake.
1:38:07Leona HiokiOh really?
1:38:08Vlad CosteaIt's a proposal that was presented. But I think some of the people rejected it and said, well, maybe that the mining looks centralized right now, but if the price goes up, there's going to be more of an incentive for other mining pools to get created, and the free market will solve this issue. And I've also heard a proposal to basically make Zcash mineable, just like Monero, just like Ethereum was a few years ago before it switched to proof of stake, to have like 15 second settlement and be able to mine it with your GPU.
1:38:45Leona HiokiYeah, it's a bit difficult topic because I believe that Zcash should remain a PoW network, and so yeah, a lot of people think about, you know, CO2 emission or kind of carbon emission or PoW or something like that, and in my opinion, the coins should come from competition, and PoW is the most pure competition, right?
1:39:25Vlad CosteaYeah, and it's very dynamic. Like in proof of stake there's no incentive unless you have the whales selling, but they are earning rewards that actually can help them support themselves forever, so they don't have to sell, which means that on one hand maybe that the price goes up easier because there is less selling, but on the other hand it's less dynamic.
1:39:51Leona HiokiYeah, less dynamic, yeah, because of PoW, yeah, I understand what you said, you know, dynamic. No, the people who lose the competition will get out from the competition on stages.
1:40:07Vlad CosteaAnd someone else comes to replace them.
1:40:09Leona HiokiYeah, yeah, it's quite important. Yeah, well, actually, I'm doing the privacy mining. No, this is kind of how we do the coin generation in INTMAX. And it's basically, you know, coming from the competition. And yeah, I have a maybe, many people kind of call this belief weird. The coin should be coming from the competition. And, yeah, it's a bit difficult point to discuss. There's so many kinds of agreement with, among many people. And certainly it's really good, interesting kind of way to have this kind of ecosystem so far, because it started from kind of ICO.
1:41:05They had a spreadsheet, what we call spreadsheet, you know, and they had a mining after that, and they, and after the enough period of the decentralization and competition, many people still want to buy Ethereum, even though they had their kind of, you know, the first kind of balance list of ICO. And they moved to their, you know, PoS. Yeah, and it reaches the current status. And I think it's really unique path of Ethereum regarding this kind of distribution of coin, and the dynamism of the position of the coin. And yeah, PoW is only the way to have a totally fair competition on the dynamism, to have a distribution.
1:42:02So most of the PoS chain, I don't know how it's possible to have a, you know, kind of long-term stability if they did not kind of PoW before they started PoS. Because most of the holders from the beginning can control the network if they have enough vote, right? So the most significant problem is called long-range attack. And the initial minter can kind of hold the chain entirely and replace it with their kind of, you know, yeah, by definition. So regarding this, even if we do PoS on some chains like Ethereum, then we need a PoW period before starting PoS.
1:43:12And yeah, so if Zcash goes to PoS after PoW, maybe it's totally fine. But, you know, regarding the dynamism of the position of the assets, yeah, PoW is still perfect. And yeah, I think that only one problem of PoW, it's not, it doesn't have a good match with smart contract. Smart contracts make MEV revenue, and it makes fork incentives. And it's well-discussed in kind of Bitcoin Core community: MEV will kill PoW. And that's the reason why, it's another reason why they cannot kind of adopt drivechain or sidechain, because it's make a revenue for additional revenue for miners to incentivize the fork with a quite complicated problem.
1:44:14Yeah, but if Zcash doesn't have kind of, you know, plenty of functionality, we don't need to have a kind of PoS in terms of that.
1:44:32Vlad CosteaYeah, I like proof of work. It's more fair. It's also unfair if you can't afford cheap electricity, but...
1:44:42Leona HiokiYeah, it's actually unfair.
1:44:45Vlad CosteaThat's the cost of doing business. Like there are parts of the world where you're gonna have access to a lot of excess energy that you can use for mining. And then there's Europe, right? You can't really do mining in Europe unless you own solar panels or your own wind turbines or you're working for the government or something and you can mine in your office with free, you know, Taxpayer-subsidized electricity.
1:45:15Leona HiokiYeah, I see.
1:45:19Vlad CosteaBut I've heard a lot of good stories from Norway, for example, where they have a lot of energy production and a lot of it goes to waste and they use it for mining. And yeah, I also have a tiny miner here. It's called the BMM. It's called a Bitcoin Mini Miner by Braiins. And I haven't taken it out of the box because I'm waiting for a special occasion to actually present it, maybe interview one of their guys so that they can explain what's inside.
1:45:55Leona HiokiOh, yeah, you don't have to expose it here.
1:45:59Vlad CosteaBut basically, it's this household item that you keep and also shows you the price and shows you the time and shows you the hash rate. And that can do some interesting things like, for example, mining at the same time, you can use the hash rate that you have to distribute it between BTC and BCH, for example. You can do it like 90% BTC, 10% BCH. And you also have a lottery ticket in BCH just in case you're going to be getting that reward.
1:46:31Leona HiokiI see. It's kind of, you know, unexpected much mining, right?
1:46:38Vlad CosteaYeah, it doesn't have too much power, but it's also not noisy. So it's nice to hold on your bookshelf and I think it's like $300 or something. So there's much worse stuff you can buy with this money. You can buy stupid stuff like an Apple Watch or whatever, which you're going to throw away anyway in a couple of years. Or you can actually get a lottery ticket and maybe get that Bitcoin mining reward on a tiny device. You can also connect it to a mining pool if you want that, but you're going to be like a very small drop in the ocean.
1:47:15So maybe it's better to just go for the full reward on a lottery ticket.
1:47:22Leona HiokiIt sounds so strange.
1:47:25Vlad CosteaYeah, but I think this is the future. I think everyone mining from their home is actually how we are going to decentralize this. And I see there's something called the Bitaxe, which is an open source ASIC miner for Bitcoin, which is gaining a lot of traction. And there are lots of forks and there are people selling it and there seems to be a community behind it. Before that, there was the NerdMiner, which was actually a tiny Raspberry Pi with a screen that was mining.
1:48:02Of course, they're not as powerful as the S19 XP or whatever is the latest model, but that's not the point. The point is to get people to mine and to have the power in the numbers, not just a few farms around the world. Maybe they're going to make one for Zcash too. I'll be the first person to buy it.
1:48:31Leona HiokiSo mining from home. Right now, the Zcash hash rate is kind of high enough not to be mined from home. Is that correct?
1:48:46Vlad CosteaYeah, but once again, this is about lottery tickets. It's not about industrial scale. It's not about trying to rationalize the electricity costs. It's just a hobby. There are people who keep their computers online. I used to do this too when I was a teenager playing MMORPGs. And I was using some sort of macros like mouse clickers that was making my character do something overnight or something like this to train a skill or whatever. And I was leaving it open just to train my video game character.
1:49:25So I suppose there are far worse ways. Or I remember when I had my Nintendo that had no saving option. I would leave that on overnight because I had no saving feature and I wanted to continue the next day. How is that different to have a home miner? Something that you keep online and it's not very energy intensive. It's not very heat generating. And it's also not noisy, but it's something. It's like your personal contribution to the network.
1:50:04Leona HiokiMaybe it's like 0.000001% to get the lottery, right?
1:50:13Vlad CosteaI think it's much lower than that.
1:50:16Leona HiokiYeah, but it's actually, it might be possible that it's more kind of better bet than actual lotteries.
1:50:28Vlad CosteaYeah, it might be.
1:50:31Leona HiokiYeah, maybe. Yeah, it's better than.
1:50:33Vlad CosteaBut then again, a lottery ticket is cheaper and more easily accessible. You just go to the shop in the corner, you buy a ticket.
1:50:42Leona HiokiYeah, it's a trade-off, right?
1:50:44Vlad CosteaYeah, it's harder to get this kind of miner, but you also have better chances than the lottery ticket. And the reward is also potentially bigger.
1:50:57Leona HiokiYeah, if you want to, yeah, if you like mining, join our privacy mining.
1:51:04Vlad CosteaYeah, this is also non-KYC coins that you're getting, supposedly.
1:51:12Leona HiokiYeah, non-KYC. Actually, it's just, shamefully, we have AML, but non-KYC.
1:51:23Vlad CosteaInteresting, so how does that work?
1:51:25Leona HiokiBasically, there's a system called Predicate. They're having kind of distributed node system. And they're tracing the addresses, basically defining the kind of risk score in the addresses, which is kind of, you know, maybe criminal score. And if less criminal score, you can deposit to the network. And if not, you cannot. Yeah, so it's all about how to kind of, you know, having this node with many nodes, having this functionality with many nodes. But I think that's kind of the other, how to make this kind of neutralized way to prevent some criminal cash. Because, okay, Zcash is Zcash as well.
1:53:17Some rivaled people have got the other problems in US as well. And the thing that, yeah, there's a difference. Yeah, how to make Ether private, how to make Ether a privacy coin. It's, you know, we need to provide the actual solution to that.
1:53:45And we are, yeah, struggling, and we managed to make this. This is the first answer we made, the distributed chain tracers to decide which deposit. And shamefully, I asked Vitalik to deposit, and Vitalik deposited, but not from his main wallet. His main wallet got rejected by this kind of AML system. And so this happened actually. So yeah, it means that your point, kind of your perspective, it's not the perfect way to kind of make this solution. But yeah, to make Ether private coin for this kind of maybe two or three years, we need a system on the, yeah, we need to upgrade our system to eliminate this point. But yeah, for now we need that.
1:54:42Vlad CosteaI think that Roger Ver might be ahead of his time once again. Because right now he's working on something. I mean, I don't think he's working on it, but he is promoting it. I've heard him talk about this confidential layer in Zano. Basically, you can take your BTC and ETH and bridge it onto a privacy blockchain called Zano, which is basically a CryptoNote fork, code-based fork. So it has the same privacy as Monero, but you can issue tokens on it. And the tokens inherit the same privacy properties as the base asset.
1:55:25And what you can do and what he said you can do is that you can bridge your BTC or ETH onto the confidential layer and then get your asset tokenized on Zano. And that's where you can trade it. Now I can see how this can be like a sidechain in terms of approach. But at the same time, it has no security benefits for the Bitcoin or the Ethereum blockchains. Like you're actually moving the activity to an entirely new blockchain, which is a useful tool if you know what you're doing. But on the other hand, I don't think it's like the end goal. It's like a workaround.
1:56:04Leona HiokiYeah, I don't think so too.
1:56:05Vlad CosteaYou don't think what?
1:56:06Leona HiokiNo, I don't think so too. Yeah. Yeah. You know, the end goal is like, you know, no KYC, no AML basically. And yeah, what is happening in Ethereum privacy space. So it's, yeah, it's more advanced. And we are using this system as well. It's a proof of innocence. And some people can prove that their money is not mixed with kind of specified addresses by themselves. It doesn't affect on the entire architecture of the systems. And it's kind of, it can be done by client side. So they can, themselves can prove that their money is not mixed with kind of criminal activities.
1:56:50And yeah, I think it's more neutralized idea. And it's, I think it's a bad idea. But the problem is like, I'm not pretty sure how much time it takes to onboard exchanges. So if exchanges do not accept this system, it doesn't work, right? And they just, people do not accept privacy kind of, privacy ETH or privacy USDC, which is coming from privacy protocol. And they just reject the deposit. And that's the kind of consequence we can see. So we need to promote that kind of proof of innocence.
1:57:39It's kind of good system and basically satisfying the other kind of condition of this kind of current AML regulation for exchanges. But I think it will happen in five years and some exchange will accept proof of innocence. And it's a ZKP proving that your money is not mixed with criminals. And maybe the privacy space on Ethereum is moving forward like that direction.
1:58:16Vlad CosteaI think we should also move towards replacing centralized exchanges as the default way of onboarding new people. Of course, they're convenient and they have nice network effects and they also hold a lot of coins. But we have the technology to build much better infrastructure that is more neutral and cannot censor people. And also enables swaps or trades with lower fees and more instant as opposed to waiting for an exchange to allow you to withdraw your coins.
1:58:54Leona HiokiYeah, I think so.
1:58:56Vlad CosteaI think what Ethereum did with Uniswap is really amazing.
1:59:01Leona HiokiYeah, DEX is, yeah, of course, this is the best way. And people are storing a lot of money still in fiat. And how to onboard that fiat into crypto space in a neutral way is quite important. Some people did the ZKP2P. It's another quite fascinating idea. It's kind of a decentralized swap. It's like a decentralized OTC swap between fiat and crypto. And yeah, maybe we need to indulge that kind of system instead of a big exchange, which is totally regulated. And yeah, it might be possible.
1:59:55Vlad CosteaI think centralized exchanges are just convenient right now. But they became very powerful, for example, when they became large stakers in Ethereum. I think this gives them a lot of political power over systems. And they also hold a lot of Bitcoins, so.
2:00:16Leona HiokiWhat do you think about the narrative of Zcash? Zcash has more listings on exchanges and Monero doesn't, so Zcash is more convenient, so this is the current situation on privacy coins, right?
2:00:30Vlad CosteaWell, I'm not sure if it's that much different, because I'm going to actually speak from data right now. So Zcash is listed on Binance, which Monero is not anymore. And Coinbase, which Monero never was. And what else is here? Gemini. But it's very small. Like 30% of the volume for Zcash today comes from Binance. And 10% comes from Coinbase. So there are all of these small exchanges that take up the rest. And what I'm getting right now, look, Kraken has Zcash, but it also has Monero. 4% of the trades happen on it. So let me get to Monero. And I'm also going to point out that they do have a bunch of exchanges that listed.
2:01:24So XMR is listed on KuCoin. This one has surprisingly 53.44% of all trades. It is listed on Kraken, which has 1.84% of trades. Actually has more because it has two pairs, one for USDT and one for USD. It's listed on, I think I've already said MEXC. Bitfinex. So Bitfinex has three trading pairs for Monero. BTSE, Poloniex. So all of these support Monero. Poloniex. Yeah, it's still around? Believe it or not. Still here.
2:02:17Leona HiokiYeah, cool.
2:02:18Vlad CosteaSo there are some centralized exchanges which are big, like Kraken and Bitfinex and MEXC. Is that MEXC or MEXE?
2:02:32Leona HiokiI don't know. MEXC, I like the way.
2:02:38Vlad CosteaSo I understand that this narrative is very convenient, that big exchanges don't support Monero, but it's still on two of the biggest at least, like Bitfinex and Kraken. That sounds enough. I'm actually curious if you look at exchanges, which ones are the biggest right now. So Kraken is number seven in terms of 24 hour volume. MEXC is number nine. And which one was the other one? Poloniex. And Bitfinex. Let's see Bitfinex where this one is. Well, it's quite low. I was thinking it's much bigger. NonKYC.io is actually higher in terms of volume than... How is this possible? Okay, Bitfinex is number 65 in terms of ranking. Oh, really?
2:03:42Leona HiokiTime has changed.
2:03:45Vlad CosteaBut once again Zcash is on Gemini, which I think is even lower. No, it's number 16. And Coinbase, which is top 10, I think. Yeah, it's the fourth. And Binance, which is the biggest. Oh, and the difference is huge. Binance had $22 billion in volume over the last 24 hours, and the second one is Gate. It had $3 billion. The difference is immense. I had no idea they're so big. Mostly because I never used it.
2:04:29But yeah, you have both of them on exchanges, so it's not like there's a roadblock involved. And if it's not supported in your country, I think some people get Monero by buying Litecoin and withdrawing it to Cake Wallet, and then they do a swap from LTC to XMR in Cake Wallet. I think that's how a lot of US citizens are buying Monero.
2:04:55Leona HiokiI see. Well, why not find a Flashift?
2:05:00Vlad CosteaWhich one?
2:05:01Leona HiokiA Flashift.
2:05:02Vlad CosteaFlashift?
2:05:03Leona HiokiYeah, a Flashift.
2:05:05Vlad CosteaNever heard of it.
2:05:07Leona HiokiYeah, you know, actually many ways to get Monero, but maybe investment-wise it's a bit difficult because the volumes are a bit limited.
2:05:19Vlad CosteaFlash Shift. I see that it's an ability in Metroid Dread, which is a Nintendo video game.
2:05:26Leona HiokiWhat's that?
2:05:29Vlad CosteaFlash Shift. But the one that you mentioned is Flashift.
2:05:34Leona HiokiNo, Flash Shift. No. Yeah. Yeah, Flashift is combining shift.
2:05:43Vlad CosteaF-L-A-S-H-I-F-T dot app. Seems to be the one. Okay, let's see. Oh, so it looks like a swap. You pick your pair. Do they have XMR? Yeah, they have it. Do they have Zcash? I thought so. Yeah, but do they support shielded Zcash? That's the other question.
2:06:06Leona HiokiI don't know. Most people, I remember that instead of that, I used NEAR Intents to get Zcash.
2:06:16Vlad CosteaYeah, that one I think is the most liquid and part of the reason why Zcash price went up. It's listed there. And they have this very nice wallet which is called Zashi, which basically has a feature swap ZEC with NEAR Intents right here in the menu.
2:06:39Leona HiokiOh, yeah, I have that.
2:06:44Vlad CosteaSo a lot of people use it for this. Zashi. I think Zashi is like a masterclass in how you should build a user experience for a wallet. Yeah, because it doesn't have a lot of buttons, but whatever is there is very useful. You have receive, send, pay. Pay is very powerful because you can pay in any other coin from Zcash and there's going to be a swap in the background. It's called CrossPay actually, and then they have pay with Flexa, swap with NEAR Intents, connect to hardware wallet, and they also have one for Buy ZEC with Coinbase, which seems to not be available in my country.
2:07:29Leona HiokiWhere's your country?
2:07:30Vlad CosteaMy country is in Eastern Europe, Romania. Have you ever been here?
2:07:36Leona HiokiOh, I've never been there. I went to Ukraine last year, this year and last year, so maybe I could have a time to go there.
2:07:44Vlad CosteaI'm actually planning to do a conference next year around Halloween in Romania. And I think the concept, like the final one to which we agreed, is privacy vampires. Oh. And it's going to be like an event where you put on a vampire cloak and we're all going to be dressed the same. And then it's going to be like a council of vampires discussing matters of privacy.
2:08:15Leona HiokiSo we wear mantles.
2:08:18Vlad CosteaYou mean which mantles?
2:08:21Leona HiokiMantles, like a wizard.
2:08:24Vlad CosteaOh, mantle, you call it. Yeah, cape, mantle, yeah. Like, not like a wizard, like a vampire. Like Count Dracula from the movies.
2:08:35Leona HiokiYeah, a vampire. I don't... What's the difference to like a vampire?
2:08:41Vlad CosteaDifference between what?
2:08:44Leona HiokiA vampire and Dracula.
2:08:45Vlad CosteaDracula? Yeah. I think Dracula is the most famous vampire story. Oh, I see. It's because of the history of Romania, which had this character named Vlad Dracul and also the story that was written by Bram Stoker in the 19th century, which is called Dracula. I think it's actually called the castle from the Carpathian... Le Château des Carpathes. Bram Stoker.
2:09:21Leona HiokiSo vampires are kind of conceptually related to privacy.
2:09:27Vlad CosteaI mean, they sleep in coffins, right? They hide away from sunlight. They only come out and they hide behind people when they want to bite their necks. You don't see them when you walk outside. They turn into bats when they need privacy.
2:09:45Leona HiokiSo yeah, we can name some product after that. Maybe no privacy product named after vampire or Dracula, right?
2:10:01Vlad CosteaYeah, why not? But what I'm saying right now is that I'm considering organizing a conference next year. And I'll put you on the guest list because I like what you're building.
2:10:11Leona HiokiOh, cool. Thanks so much.
2:10:14Vlad CosteaAnd I think privacy people should get together to have like a gathering, which is not going to be so private if I start selling tickets or something, but yeah.
2:10:28Leona HiokiYeah, it's a difficult kind of perspective. It's like making a privacy kind of conference or making a privacy meetup. How much privacy do we need for that? It's always kind of maybe repeatedly, frequently asked question in that opinion. And basically, if people gather with sunglasses and hats, it's too outstanding. And if we show up with our faces, it seems like no, we don't have privacy, even if it's a privacy conference. So some people might say that, you know, it's contradicting. It's a difficult perspective to make a privacy conference.
2:11:14Vlad CosteaYeah, but if you show up for the conference on Halloween, there's nothing weird about wearing a mask or a cape or being dressed up or having makeup on your face.
2:11:27Leona HiokiYeah, it's true.
2:11:28Vlad CosteaLike you're expected to go to some kind of party and it is like all conferences are parties, essentially.
2:11:38Leona HiokiYeah, I'm super looking forward to going there, not with any excuse. I want to go to your favorite place in your country.
2:11:51Vlad CosteaYeah, and maybe one day I'll also come to Japan. I'm such a weeb sometimes. I have a Seiko watch, I drive a Japanese car, I play Nintendo games, I watch anime sometimes.
2:12:08Leona HiokiSometimes.
2:12:09Vlad CosteaAnd I listen to city pop, which is this genre from the 1980s.
2:12:13Leona HiokiIt's surprising that, you know, the city pop in 1980s was quite popular in Western countries. I didn't expect that. And I said many kind of pessimistic thoughts about Japan regarding crypto maybe, but no, it's totally fine. I can really highly recommend Japan to live in, even if it's for private crypto stuff. And actually a lot of people are moving to Japan recently, and I think it's good. And it's not a good timing to talk about Metaplanet, but no Metaplanet is also kind of a Japanese company.
2:12:56Vlad CosteaOh, Metaplanet is like the hotel that...
2:12:59Leona HiokiIt used to be.
2:13:01Vlad CosteaIt used to be a hotel business and now they are into buying Bitcoin. Yeah, just like MicroStrategy. Good luck with that. I don't know how it's gonna play out. Yeah, good luck. And in theory, it's nice you're buying a lot of Bitcoin, but then you're gonna have to pay the people from whom you loan the money. And you don't want to sell the Bitcoin to do that. So, good luck. Yeah. It's a difficult business.
2:13:34Leona HiokiLeveraged trading is always difficult.
2:13:38Vlad CosteaYeah. So how would you compare Japan and Switzerland in terms of Bitcoin culture?
2:13:47Leona HiokiBitcoin culture. So, when you see how people in Crypto Valley in Switzerland, basically everything happened from Ethereum. So, yeah, of course, before Ethereum, many kind of cryptographers and crypto people were talking about Bitcoin, and it was quite active even before that. But after Ethereum, basically most of the people who came to Crypto Valley, Ethereum was their model and the most successful model for them, Crypto Valley people, was Ethereum. So, it's heavily influenced by Ethereum, of course. And the most significant difference people-wise is the majority of people in Switzerland, I feel like they're more kind of quiet people, like researchers or lawyers, and yeah, that kind of people.
2:15:05And in Japan, basically, there are a bunch of various types of people living there, of course, developers, of course, speculators, and so on and so on. Switzerland is the most kind of...
2:15:20Vlad CosteaIs more what?
2:15:21Leona HiokiAnd it's, let's say, Switzerland is a small country, like 8 million people in a smaller kind of space, and it has more, less diverse type of people, mainly lawyers, and more solid businessmen, and there are cryptographers, researchers, and such people. And when you see the people in the conference in Switzerland, a bit surprised that many people wear suits, and it's a bit different from what's happened in Japan. And yeah, basically, in financial industry in Switzerland, they are super strong, and the bankers are super strong. So basically, the trustworthy people are doing business in crypto as well, and you cannot see so many scammers in Switzerland, maybe.
2:16:33And yeah, that's the biggest difference. So maybe Japan is more diverse in terms of that perspective, maybe.
2:16:44Vlad CosteaI also want to ask you, and maybe I should have presented this in the beginning of our interview, what's your personal story with Bitcoin? When did you first find out about it, and what was your first reaction?
2:16:56Leona HiokiI read Bitcoin in 2013. Yeah, no, 2012. Actually, I could not understand it a lot, because I was a college student at the time. And the Bitcoin, you know, eliminating the need of central bank, and kind of inflation resistant, printing money, it's possible. It was the opposite idea, what I was doing at the time. I was a programmer at the time as well. But I was doing the stock, you know, I was trading stock at that moment. And many people were expecting the stock market will go up because the central bank will print more money at the moment.
2:18:00And that was the excitement in the kind of Japanese stock market ecosystem at that moment. Bitcoin was totally opposite, right? Basically, the printing money, the relaxing the financial situation, that kind of stuff should be hedged by Bitcoin. I could not see the need of kind of eliminating central bank at the moment. I was too child and kid at the moment. And after that, the first code I was writing was RSA related, you know, cryptography related stuff. And I became a security engineer. And then I got interested by Ethereum, and I started learning Ethereum.
2:18:56And I understood Ethereum very well. Then I could earn some Bitcoin after that. So the first cryptocurrency I understood was Ethereum, not Bitcoin. And so, yeah, what's kind of foolish of me, I could not understand Bitcoin for the first moment.
2:19:18Vlad CosteaYeah, that's actually very funny, because I say a lot during my podcast that there are people who came to Ethereum before they came to Bitcoin. And they understood Ethereum first and they say, well, that's not true. It's impossible because Bitcoin is for people who care about sound money and libertarians and gold bugs who want to search for something more interesting. And the Ethereum people only care about tokens and trying to create all of these protocols to trade tokens and shitcoins and whatever. But I can relate to that.
2:19:55I was also a university student when I read about Bitcoin the first time. And I think I also did not understand it to the point that I thought it was a stupid idea. And I think this was 2013, I was 21 years old at the time. And I was like, well, this is about banking the unbanked. I have a bank account, so why do I need this? It's kind of silly that you should have internet money. But I didn't get all the aspects of it, like the fact that it's impossible to censor and that it gives you actual freedom.
2:20:34And that there is actually a limited supply and there can be an upside to it. I didn't care too much at the time. But I kept following it over the years and eventually I got there. And I also had my Ethereum moment when I was thinking that it makes a lot of sense. I was watching the TV show Silicon Valley, where I think in 2016 or 2017 they had an episode with the main character. It was talking about inventing a new decentralized internet that you can run from your phone or from your computer and you don't need servers anymore.
2:21:09And when I discovered Ethereum, it was talking about building decentralized applications. And I was thinking, Okay, this is it. This is what I've been searching for. This is interesting stuff. And of course, CryptoKitties happened a few months later and I had to reconsider my assumptions. But, yeah, I think there's a lot of merit. In some ways, I think sometimes that Ethereum is the anti-Bitcoin because it has a different structure and also different motivations. Bitcoin is supposed to be resilient and accessible to everyone, while Ethereum is supposed to push research and get new technology.
2:21:56Leona HiokiI see. I don't think Bitcoin and Ethereum have different purposes. I think it's quite same. I believe so.
2:22:13Vlad CosteaIt would be funny if The Future of Money was something that was launched with 60% premine and had all of these insiders and was supported by JP Morgan and whatever. Like, Okay, I can accept it, but at the same time, it's not the kind of revolution that I was hoping we're going to have.
2:22:36Leona HiokiYeah, I think that's the distribution. It matters a lot. At the same time, it took enough time to kind of distribute that kind of allocation or kind of possession of Ether to many people. And so many people saw that in the early days because Ethereum thought to be a fake in the early days. So people did a lot of mistakes and it's totally mixed up, I think. And they did a kind of correct path in terms of introducing PoW before making PoS.
2:23:22And at the same time, it's widely discussed in the Bitcoin ecosystem right now: MEV kills Bitcoin, or PoW, meaning that PoW is not cut out for making smart contracts, meaning that DeFi is kind of the apps. And so in terms of that, Ethereum needed to have PoS definitely and they had a correct path before launching the PoS, in my opinion. So, yeah, I think too much people are kind of over-influenced by kind of criticism regarding their kind of starting point with Ethereum. And some people, it's quite funny that some people are in some kind of radical place, radical kind of group of Bitcoiners, maybe.
2:24:25Some people misunderstood that Vitalik is having 60% of the entire Ether. And so many kind of miscommunication is kind of brought in this space, so I don't like that so much. But anyway, no, distribution is quite important and people should think it's quite important. But at the same time, you know, if we stuck to that too much, there's no perfect system and there's no system right to exist, actually. So, for example, Bitcoiners, criticism for Bitcoiners, most of the mining was concentrated on the early age and the people could not join that.
2:25:17But what if later the people who will be born in later 21st century, people will think that it's quite unfair because they do not have any chance to join the mining of Bitcoin before they get born. And there's no perfect system to distribute kind of coins. I think there should be fair competition and the kind of enough legitimization to make system go on with a compromised agreement among people. And for you, what is the perfect system regarding the coin distribution and the fairness of opportunities?
2:26:21Vlad CosteaWell, that's difficult because no matter how you frame it, you're going to say, well, there was information asymmetry. So even if a million people knew about it and they could mine it fairly from the beginning, you're still going to say, well, but there are 8 billion people who were sidelined. That's the new word for it, who are not part of this. And I don't think there is any fair or perfect system. I think it becomes perfect once there is good distribution and the money changes hands many times and there is actual demand for it.
2:27:00And it gets used by a lot of people. That's when it becomes better. But of course, I do believe that distribution should be proof of work because there is some actual cost to the creation of coins as opposed to a process where you create the... You basically print your money and then you distribute it and you say, let's build a system. That's pretty much what the fiat world has created.
2:27:24Leona HiokiYeah, I think so too. We need the cost to print money or issue money. It should be done by fair competition.
2:27:34Vlad CosteaI agree with this. So I think proof of work is the best way to create money. The fairest, even if some people will complain that it's unfair to them, it's the fairest to the entire world. And afterwards, there should be markets that decide what has value, what doesn't have value and establish a price for everything and also enable everyone to get their hands on the coins. I think availability is the second most important aspect after distribution, like how fast people can actually access it.
2:28:16This is why Bitcoin is so important, because it has this conception which was unlike anything else and it's very hard to replicate, where for a couple of years there was no market for it. It was just a bunch of nerds trying stuff, experimenting with the technology. And some of them are still around. And that's beautiful. Nowadays, if you launch something like, I can argue that Grin had a much fairer launch than Bitcoin, because it's the Mimblewimble implementation, which is purest and focused on privacy and is closest to the description of the whitepaper. And Grin basically had no and still has no advantage to early adopters.
2:29:05It has like a fixed supply issuance. I think it's like one coin per minute or something. That's the way in which it works around the clock. That's how they describe it. And yeah, the more inflation there is, there is no scarcity and there is no reason for newcomers. No, there is no reason for people who are there from the beginning to get rich.
2:29:37So there is no advantage. If you discovered Grin from day one and you started mining, you're not going to become wealthier than someone who discovers it today. And this is the fairest kind of launch. But at the same time, it's the one that doesn't attract people too much because it doesn't make them rich.
2:29:54Leona HiokiYeah, it's a bit difficult. Yeah, it's so difficult. And maybe there's some kind of triangle or trilemma, you know, something is impossible if we satisfy the other elements. And yeah, fairness is like that. So I think that people should not kind of, you know, stuck to that point too much. Some should be revisited many times, but yeah, people should not stuck to that.
2:30:26Vlad CosteaI agree with you. And I got to come back on my previous statement. Like, I don't think there's anything wrong with premines and dev taxes and basically different kinds of social contracts to which people sign up. They know very well, like they're aware of what's happening. And they still choose to invest in this because they have hopes that it's going to reach a certain goal. And as long as the money that is raised in an ICO or in a premine or in whatever is used to build what it promised it was going to build, I think that's fine.
2:31:05I think the problem and this cultural, how should I describe it, like an allergy to premines and to ICOs is that a lot of them turned out to be scams. And it provides kind of the wrong kind of incentives where the creators have a lot of money from the beginning. They burn that money in one way or the other in very inconsiderate ways because they think they're always going to be rich. And then they run out of money and they realize they cannot complete the mission anymore.
2:31:38Leona HiokiYeah, you know, I think so. So this is how we need kind of proof of work or kind of competition. Spreadsheet, it's like, you know, basically, yeah, coins should come from competition, not kind of friendship, right? And yeah, fair competition can make kind of cutting this point. The spreadsheet coin is like, yeah, I admit that sometimes it needs that because most of the projects are based on the contract, legal contract to launch the project. So I don't kind of attack them too much. But yeah, I don't like spreadsheet.
2:32:25Vlad CosteaYeah, there should be a fine line. For example, I got to give credit to Ethereum. They did their ICO, they sold the coins before the network was launched. Some people were not happy about this and still are not happy. But to their credit of the Ethereum creators, they actually delivered what they promised. And they keep going with this project. I think it's way beyond the initial expectations.
2:32:52Leona HiokiYeah, it's quite a rare case, right?
2:32:55Vlad CosteaA lot of people... So if you look back, and I said this to Vitalik too when he was on the show, and I interviewed him back in May. If you look back at the various competitors to Ethereum, there was Mastercoin, there was NXT, which seemed much more professional. There was Counterparty on Bitcoin, which already had users. The odds for Ethereum to succeed with just a bunch of young people wanting to build stuff were very small. They did not have the best kind of launch, they did not have most of the community on their side.
2:33:32But somehow they managed to get very smart people working for Ethereum. And that's how they took off and got to this point where they established Ethereum as the number two after Bitcoin. Because it wasn't always the case. The origins, maybe it seems corporate, maybe if you look at it in retrospect, you're going to be like, yeah, but with this kind of financing, of course they succeeded. But there were other projects that also had the financing and they did not get to this point. And then there was the entire class of Ethereum killers that emerged in 2017 and kept going from, what was the Chinese one?
2:34:15EOS. No, no, EOS was the American one, was like the big ICO, I think the biggest ICO of all times. There was NEO, that was the Chinese one. NEO and NEM.
2:34:27Leona HiokiYeah, yeah, yeah. The Ethereum killers from the beginning.
2:34:32Vlad CosteaExactly. And what else was there for Ethereum? Polkadot, which was actually started by one of the co-founders, and Cardano.
2:34:42Leona HiokiYeah, Cardano, yeah.
2:34:44Vlad CosteaAnd they're still around, but at the same time, they never got to the same level and they will probably never get the same number of users. But it's amazing that there was so much competition for it. And unlike Bitcoin, there were fewer reasons to actually say, well, let's stick to Ethereum because there was something interesting about all of these chains, but somehow it retained its supremacy. And that became the most popular platform for smart contracts. Even after it had, four years ago, $100 fees and situations that basically were contradicting the initial purpose.
2:35:23Leona HiokiYeah, I think that these competitors like Polkadot and EOS and Cardano made Ethereum very decentralized in terms of the possession of assets. And many people sold their Ether because the other competitors might be kind of superior or something like that. And yeah, actually it was a good path, and it's really good to have many competitors for Ethereum. And otherwise, the first people, ICO-related people, remaining Ether, whoever, are kind of holding all the Ether from the beginning to the end, right? So I think it was good.
2:36:12Vlad CosteaI think Zcash also has a similar story in the sense that it had this 20% what they call dev tax. The miners were giving 20% of their rewards to the development fund of the project. And to their credit, they actually built much more than they promised. Like the kind of stuff that they're doing right now goes way beyond the initial design of the Zerocash protocol. And they keep going and they sold most of it. So it's on the market, other people bought it. It becomes very dynamic after a while. In the first few years you can argue yes, but the developers have most of it. I don't think that's the case anymore.
2:36:58Leona HiokiYeah, dev tax. A bit controversial, right? When I proposed that in our mining system as well, people could not accept that. So yeah, we do that. But mining, if we call that kind of donation whatsoever, it's literally tax. So yeah, people wanted to use crypto for freedom. So tax is the worst word to have in the system. So yeah, it might be possible. People hate that more than devs think or the designers think.
2:37:49Vlad CosteaYeah, so once again, I don't have an issue with them as long as they do what they promised. But if they're just some sort of way for the founders to exit scam and raise a lot of money, then disappear. I think we've had too many of these cases and it's these cases that make it look shady when legit actors maybe try to build something useful for the rest of the space. And once again, I want to go back to my Linux metaphor because everything that gets built can be used by another project.
2:38:26I don't think there's anything that's useless, like any kind of experimentation is good. And even if you can argue that it's so bad and it's so useless and it's such a scam, it's something that keeps the regulators and the governments busy. So that one has a use case also. Like imagine a world where we only had Bitcoin and Ethereum or something.
2:38:56Leona HiokiThey raised the tax rate to deal with that, right? Yeah. Okay, cool. So funny. So thanks for inviting me.
2:39:10Vlad CosteaThank you for joining, Leona. How can people follow you? I know you have a large following in Japan. I don't think my audience is from Japan.
2:39:17Leona HiokiOh, yeah. So please follow my Twitter account. It's HiokiLeona, that one. It's an English version. So basically, Japanese account is for Japanese. So yeah, if you're an English speaker, I really recommend following my one. And also, please follow intmax.io account. And we will have many, many announcements from here because we will publish the zERC20, which is totally kind of cross-rollup, privacy-preserving transfer. It will be great. So please follow that as well. So thanks for listening to me and I really appreciate this opportunity to talk with you. And also talk in front of many privacy advocates, which is totally sharing the same mindset together.
2:40:24Vlad CosteaYeah, we've had more than 1000 viewers on the live stream and I want to thank them all. And also thanks to you, Leona, for joining and thanks to the sponsors for making this possible. Once again, Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes.com, SideShift.ai and LayerTwo Labs. Thank you very much. I'll see you in the next one. And I hope I'll get you, Leona, to the privacy conference.
2:40:48Leona HiokiPerfect. I will be the Dracula. Bye. Bye. Sayonara. Sayonara. Bye.
2:40:48================================================================================ Production notes: CORRECTED. Base: local Whisper medium.en transcript with automatic speaker diarization, given a full manual read-through (about 260 corrections, including a pass against the YouTube auto-captions of the livestream), then reconciled against a full local small.en (int16, VAD) re-transcription with word timestamps; three-way comparison (draft vs small.en vs YouTube captions) over the whole episode (418 disagreement spots reviewed). 109 doubtful or dropped stretches were checked against short audio clips re-transcribed locally with medium.en (int16, VAD) and against the small.en words, including the dropped Amir Taaki / Japanese airport exchange at 00:50:14 (restored), the Greenpeace "change the code" exchange at 01:37:29, the exchange-listings data passage at 02:00:30 (Binance, Coinbase, Gemini, Kraken, Bitfinex, BTSE, Poloniex, MEXC), the Flashift exchange at 02:04:55, the Halloween privacy-conference "council of vampires" / mantles / Dracula exchange at 02:08:15, and Leona's closing zERC20 announcement at 02:39:17. Speaker turns were checked with a full-episode local speaker-embedding scan (two reference voices, 1.5 s windows at 0.75 s hop); paragraphs were re-segmented on the small.en word timings and short turns re-attributed where the scan was unambiguous. Sponsor reads (SideShift.ai, Bitcoin.com News, LayerTwo Labs, NoOnes.com) are read live by Vlad. Names and jargon were checked against the title, the feed and the web: INTMAX / INTMAX privacy mining, zERC20 (EIP-7503 zkWormhole, cross-rollup), client-side validation, recursive ZKP, stateless vs stateful rollups, Plasma / Plasma Cash, Shielded CSV (Alpen Labs, Blockstream), BitVM, witness encryption, OP_RETURN, OP_CAT, StarkWare / Cairo, RGB, Lightning, Optimism / Arbitrum / Base, Citrea, drivechain (BIP 300 / BIP 301, Paul Sztorc), Lido stETH, Wrapped Beacon ETH, Coinbase Bitcoin, MEV, long-range attack, Predicate (AML), proof of innocence, Railgun, Tornado Cash, ZKP2P, NEAR Intents, Zashi / CrossPay / Flexa, Flashift, Cake Wallet, Zooko, Tachyon, Zerocash, Mimblewimble / Grin, Zano, DarkFi, Phil Zimmermann / PGP, @HiokiLeona (English X account), David Chaum, Amir Taaki, Roger Ver, Koji Higashi, Nicolas Dorier (BTCPay), Jonathan Underwood, Nayuta, Metaplanet, Mt. Gox, Namecoin / BitDNS, NEO / NEM / EOS / Polkadot / Cardano, Rodolfo Novak (Coinkite), Bram Stoker. Light clean verbatim: ums, false starts and stutters removed; spoken phrasing (including Leona's non-native grammar) kept. Intro music omitted. Remaining doubtful words are marked best guess.