S2 E1: Wassim Alsindi on Bitcoin as a Time Machine
Search this conversation
0:48Vlad CosteaYou are actually the first guest that I have who demanded to have a spot in the show. You actually contacted me and said, "I have listened to the other episodes and I was actually thinking, can I join the show and talk to you?" And it's part of the policy that I want to use that I don't want to have just, you know, the regular people who do podcasts on a regular basis. And if you check right now iTunes or Spotify for Bitcoin-related podcasts, you're going to see how you have a dozen people who are part of every show available.
1:25And I will try to avoid that purposely, just to give floor to many more voices and opinions to share whatever insights that they might have.
1:38Wassim AlsindiSure, I think fresh perspectives are always nice, and that was one of the takeaways from listening to the first season. You had a few people that I'm friendly with on there, and you got into some interesting topics, some roads less traveled. And that's nice. I mean, I suppose when there's not so much of a heterogeneity of, you know, the guests, the clientele that, you know, then you might start to see the same topics coming up again and again. And I think that's one thing that's really important to avoid in this quite small and young community that we've got of, you know, Bitcoin, Bitcoiners, is not to turn into a kind of self-referential echo chamber.
2:20Vlad CosteaYeah, and when I had one of the interviews, and I'm not going to disclose all the information, but at the end of it, I was told that there wasn't really anything new that I got from it. As in, the topics had been discussed in previous interviews and I had no idea. I don't really have time to listen to every other interview that the guests have done, just to make sure that I don't ask the same questions or I don't get the same answers and ask for something new.
2:53I'm actually hoping that these interactions are spontaneous. And they pretty much provide a snapshot of our thought process. And that's one of the reasons why I don't like to edit interviews. I don't cut parts where maybe we err or we say something wrong. Because part of the conversation is to find a common ground and maybe identify something that we collectively agree as being true or being a good version of the truth.
3:27Wassim AlsindiSure, or maybe we don't agree about something, but then that's also fine. I mean, I don't think anyone's going to have enough time to listen to all of the podcasts. The number of podcasts is increasing and expanding faster than the universe at the moment.
3:42Vlad CosteaYeah, it's a big trend right now. Everybody is doing a podcast for various reasons. I think they have reached their peak in terms of popularity and some people have this theory that inventions such as the AirPods, like earphones which are wireless and are very expensive, have enabled people to be much more free and listen on the go while they are commuting, while they are traveling. And maybe it's useful to get new information while you just stare or glance outside the window and see some landscapes and get some new ideas. But now let's stop being so meta by breaking the fourth wall about podcasts and do an actual podcast where we discuss the topic.
4:30Wassim AlsindiSounds good.
4:32Vlad CosteaSo I know that this is generic, but I usually discuss this with people. So how did you first get into Bitcoin and what was the reason behind your decision to put so much time and energy into this invention?
4:51Wassim AlsindiSure, well, I guess most people usually have kind of a couple of moments. You know, there's usually the kind of first introduction, and then there's the kind of dawning realization of the significance of what's going on. So my first encounter was, well, previously, I spent a decade or so running an experimental arts organization. You could almost say I was trying to make a decentralized arts organization, but I didn't have the tools or the foresight to execute completely on that.
5:24So anyway, I was touring with some friends around the West Coast of the United States. We were in San Francisco. And one of the musicians I was touring with had a buddy in Santa Clara in Silicon Valley. So he said, "Let's go visit my friend." We went over there. And he was interning at Intel. And if you intern at Intel, then the stationery cupboard is full of computer components and whatever you want. So we got there, we start talking and hanging out, and he opens his closet in his small apartment and says, "Check this out. I'm doing this thing called mining Bitcoin."
6:02So he had like a GPU, a rack of GPUs crunching away. This was summer 2012. And that was the first I heard of it. And I was fascinated by this idea. I've always been interested in technologies and weird and wonderful inventions. And in the same trip, it was kind of a tour and a voyage and a travel. So I spent a lot of time just moving from place to place. Roads less traveled, you could say. I actually took the Amtrak, the very slow and unwieldy train network in the States, coast to coast from San Francisco to...
6:41Washington DC, going through Denver, Chicago, and Philadelphia. And that train is very slow. So this is a lot of time on the train. Would have been nice to have some podcasts back then. So lots of time to think after this encounter. And, you know, when I got home, when I got back to Europe a few months later, I started looking a little bit more seriously into what was going on with this Bitcoin thing. Now at that time, you know, mid 2012, there's not really that much.
7:14I wasn't a computer scientist or a cryptographer, so looking at the detailed technical discussions were really beyond me. And everything else was like Mt. Gox and Bitcoin account, BitInstant, things like that. Things which have later collapsed and turned out to be kind of quite unsavory or a bit shady or a bit scammy or however you want to frame that. And so I just started observing, just continued observing, thinking about this thing, you know, this idea of, you know, some kind of new digital money that some anonymous person or people created and put out there.
7:55And it just sounded like a cool technology experiment, cool science experiment. It wasn't really until the big run-up in 2013-14 and then the subsequent kind of goxing, the crash and all of that. You know, people kind of said Bitcoin was dead after the Mt. Gox collapse. But then when you started to look at the phenomenology of the network, of the, you know, spitting out blocks, transactions are getting confirmed, people are moving value around, I started to get more and more interested, seeing that this thing was actually a resilient network, a resilient piece of technology.
8:37And then I started to see some more of the potential of it. And since then I've just been going down the rabbit hole. I'm sure that's a very common theme with everybody that, you know, you peel away the layers of complexity, the, you could call it like the technology stack or the ontological stack, you know, from the social and the political to the monetary to the protocol and the data architectures and all the rest of it.
9:08Vlad CosteaYeah, it's always like that. I mean, the story is never the same about how people discover and come across this invention. But it's always like I had that one month when I became obsessed with it and I read everything that I could about Bitcoin. And then I started to make up and maybe create connections in my mind and try to relate something which I have just discovered with something that I want to accomplish. And it's fascinating how people coming from so many different backgrounds can actually find usefulness and purpose in a decentralized currency that is not by any means controlled by any nation state.
9:58And it's completely uncensorable and it cannot be taken away, which that's a very complicated word to pronounce, but it's unconfiscatable. It takes me actually a linguistic effort to say "unconfiscatable".
10:16Wassim AlsindiYeah, I also think that, you know, because Bitcoin is this kind of ensemble of technologies and emergent phenomena and properties from this network, from this protocol and then the monetary asset that's issued at the top of it, you can kind of think of Bitcoin as like a Rorschach test. You know, people see different things in it depending on the lens that they view it with. And that's, I think, why you see so many people struggling to communicate with each other, talking past each other online, in person, that we, you know, we're humans.
10:54We're kind of pattern-recognizing creatures. We need to reduce things down to squash them in our heads and make sense of them. And so the little kind of stories and narratives that we tell ourselves may be quite different from the ones that other people tell them. And, you know, of course, we all have different lives and different ways of being, different ideologies, different philosophies, and different life experiences. So everything is squashed into what you think or what one thinks Bitcoin is or Bitcoin does or Bitcoin can be.
11:32Vlad CosteaSure, but generally I like to assume, and I like it when it's not the case, but I like to assume that getting into Bitcoin is preceded by some kind of ideological mindset, which has to do much more with libertarianism or the idea of sovereignty and personal freedom.
11:55Wassim AlsindiAnd individuality.
11:56Vlad CosteaYes. I don't think people who like the idea of state intervention or welfare will like anything that is not controlled by the government.
12:11Wassim AlsindiI guess it depends at what stage of the Bitcoin life cycle you encounter it. I mean, if you found it in 2010, you could probably be a government official and think, "Well, this is a science experiment, I can watch this." But you may not want to contribute to the network or transact with it or help to improve the ecosystem around it necessarily. Just getting back to one of your last points, when you said that people find this thing and it's often the potential is seen in it as a function of the life experiences or the philosophy of the person.
12:55I've always been quite individualistic, I suppose. One other interesting thing in my background that may have kind of afforded me a special insight into it is that my family's from Iraq, this small country in the Middle East, which I'm sure everyone's heard of by now. Lots of bombs got dropped there in the last hundred years or so, and had a succession of quite unsavory characters in charge of that territory. It's kind of a mélange of tribes and peoples squashed together that don't necessarily get along, and lots of resources there, lots of inherent riches.
13:37And so we had the situation where the country was very wealthy, quite secular, very educated, one of the better places to be in the Middle East in the middle of the last century, 50s, 60s, 70s, you could say. And things went very, very sharply downhill. And, you know, myself was extremely lucky that my parents were able to exit at a time before the decline had really taken shape. They left in '79, which is just before the war with Iran started.
14:11That was a 10-year war with huge human costs, and that kind of laid the groundwork kind of foundations for the United Nations sanctions, and then the UN Food Programme, and then the US adventures, and so on. So one of the things that happens when a country gets taken over by a strong man or by a dictator, and you may know something about this from your own experiences in Romania, is that freedom is a train that leaves the station. So the freedom of speech, the freedom to transact as you wish, the freedom to hold assets.
14:51And so the fortunes of my family changed very quickly gravely from one moment to the next. You know, one moment, you know, it's... I've got two sides of the family and they're actually very different. One side was Shia and one side was Sunni, which is unthinkable now, but it was not a problem at all, not a big deal back in those days. And one side was just, you know, like you could say a middle-class family, civil servants sort of thing. And the other side was quite in the upper echelons of society.
15:31My grandfather was a brigadier general in the Iraqi army, and there were several generations of high-ranking military officers. And so when Saddam and the Ba'ath Party came into their ascendancy, you know, if you're a dictator, kind of put yourself in the shoes of a dictator, you're going to get rid of people that you perceive to be a threat. And so my grandfather was one of those people that was perceived to be a threat. And so he had pretty much everything taken away from him, except his life. But they did almost take that as well. And so when you have this kind of, you know, genesis story or this background story of an idyllic life, which is how my mother described her childhood...
16:23And it turns into, it just falls apart, kind of overnight. You know, land was confiscated, a house was raided by secret police, assets taken. As people tried to leave the country, you know, at airports, you would have your gold taken away from you'd have your dollars taken away from you. There'd be bandits patrolling the desert at the border between Iraq and Jordan. And so, I guess that is something that I've been carrying around for a lot of my life. This idea that the state can go bad and that individuals have very little recourse or access to tools to mitigate those kinds of overreaches of the state.
17:12Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess I have similar stories from Romania. And I'll be telling the story of my parents who got married maybe until the day I die, and how they raised enough money to buy a new car, but then the revolution came and it was followed by hyperinflation. And this led to the fact that they spent their wedding gift money on a new couch.
17:42Wassim AlsindiOh.
17:43Vlad CosteaAnd that's something that's going to follow me at least. It'll be in my mind forever in terms of realizing what kind of currency I want to hold. As people who are working for the secret services and had access to financial services outside the country actually exchanged their money for dollars before the inflation came.
18:05And overnight they became millionaires and started buying land and assets and all sorts of stuff. Also, my grandparents had their small businesses confiscated by the communists. As Romania was on the side of Germany for the first half of the Second World War, in 1944, we actually switched to the Allies overnight. During the peace conference and during that famous meeting at Yalta between Stalin and Roosevelt and Churchill, they decided that Romania would become a part of the USSR side of influence on the eastern side of the Iron Curtain.
19:00And there was nothing that the Allies would actually do to protest against it. So we had a very small amount of time, like a couple of decades, in which we had a flowering and a flourishing. That's the word, flourishing, not flowering. We had a flourishing bourgeoisie and a quick industrialization in terms of bringing technologies and trying to modernize the country. And for a couple of decades, actually between the two world wars, Bucharest, which is the capital of Romania, used to be called a small Paris, because they brought so many cultural influences from Paris.
19:46Everybody was speaking French. I mean, everybody who was going to school and was at least educated at the basic level was speaking French and reading French magazines and newspapers. And they brought some parts of the French architecture. We have the Arch of Triumph in miniature in Bucharest. And also, if you look at the main administrative buildings, you'll see many influences in the columns and the style of the buildings, to tell you that they actually took inspiration from Paris, just like the University of Bucharest, which I attended, and it's a copy of the Sorbonne from Paris.
20:29Wassim AlsindiOh, very nice.
20:30Vlad CosteaYeah, it's interesting how they took these ideas. But the main point is that after all these maybe Western ideas which started coming into these lands, it all went to the communists who came and they confiscated all private property. And everybody who was a business owner, not only that they had their goods and money confiscated, but they were not allowed to become a part of the new establishment. Their children could not attend university if they wanted. It was... What's the translation?
21:10Wassim AlsindiIt's like ostracization or something like that. Yeah. You're kind of ejected from society.
21:21Vlad CosteaIt was a figure of speech. It was in Romanian, it's "rădăcini sănătoase", meaning "healthy roots". So if you were from the kind of family which was poor and working class, you had greater chances to actually become a minister and go to university. Whereas if your parents were small entrepreneurs before the communists came, you're ostracized and have no chances to actually accomplish anything.
21:53Wassim AlsindiI suppose, you know, if you're looking in the kind of communist paradigm, then this is kind of a, you're trying to, I suppose, in some ways, invert class structure to make everyone equal, because I guess that's kind of one of the ways that communism functions, right? It doesn't really have this kind of tiered class system that you might find in a free market society or a traditionalistic society. Speaking of hyperinflation, I just looked up the long-term chart of the Iraqi dinar.
22:27It's quite entertaining. So when my family first came to the UK, it was two Iraqi dinars for one pound. And obviously the pound back then was much stronger than it is now. And I think, you know, my father was, he was a doctor, but he was by no means wealthy. But his and my mother's family who came over with them at the time of their honeymoon, which is actually when they left, they were just shopping in Harrods because it was cheap to them.
23:01Everything was just cheap. Their money was good and it was cheap. If you look at the long-term chart now, you are talking about a thousand dinars to the pound. But it's not quite Venezuela territory, but you know, you were not rewarded for hodling your Iraqi dinars.
23:22Vlad CosteaI would definitely not. And right now, one of the dilemmas that you might have as a Romanian is: are you supposed to hold your money in your bank account and get that 2%? Or is that actually less than the inflation rate? So you're actually losing money even though you actually think that you're making something.
23:46Wassim AlsindiSo you have the, is it the leu, the Romanian currency?
23:52Vlad CosteaLeu, yes.
23:53Wassim AlsindiLeu. Is it, because I know Romania is now inside the European Union, but you're not inside the eurozone. So some countries like Denmark that have a similar arrangement, they have a soft peg of the currency to the euro. Is that the case in Romania or not?
24:09Vlad CosteaNo, I don't think so. As far as I know, we don't, and there is actually a plan to switch to euro at some point. But as time passes and we had this wave of populism in 2016, and the more we got into it, the farther we moved from the criteria that we had to fulfill before adhering to the European Union. So right now, if we were to be a country like Serbia, for example, which is not part of the European Union, and try to become member states, we would not be accepted.
24:49Because in these 10 years since we... Actually, it's almost 12. In June, it will be 12 years since we became members of the European Union. But in this time, we actually became less democratic. And there was this further move towards becoming... How should I put it? The government tried to take over the judiciary.
25:18Wassim AlsindiOh, I see. So like a kind of concentration of power or kind of increase of authoritarianism or something.
25:24Vlad CosteaSeparation of powers is not as functional as it was 10 years ago or 12 years ago, but it's much more functional than it was in the 90s.
25:34Wassim AlsindiMm-hmm. Oh, the Ceaușescu, or the end of the Ceaușescu era.
25:38Vlad CosteaYeah, we had the first years of democracy, to call it so, but it's hard to move away from this kind of oppressive regime, as most people don't even understand what freedom is and what it means. And they will just ask you, OK, before this, we never had any real elections. So what is the impact of me going to vote? Why would I even care? Why should I vote for that one and not this one? And usually they just like to preserve the status quo as opposed to changing something.
26:11As in the minds of the regular people, it's much easier to observe what you already have and preserve it than actually take a plunge into the unknown and try something else. So that's why, totally, I think we had many more governments of the left, and our left is culturally and pretty much even in terms of human resources and ideas rooted in the Communist Party, which was totalitarian. So I suppose we got sidetracked by this whole political discussion, but it makes sense in the context of explaining why we got into Bitcoin. And why it makes so much sense for us to demand for autonomy and self-empowerment. I think that's the expression.
27:08Wassim AlsindiWell, I think the two things that are in common between, you know, let's say Iraq before the 80s and Romania up until, you know, whenever it was, 15 or 20 years ago, is that the state was this kind of monolithic entity that had its kind of influence or tentacles or edicts kind of infusing all aspects of life. And people had very little freedom or really even any notion of what freedom is, as you said. We had the same thing in Iraq as well. The thing with a long-lived regime is people don't really know what comes after it.
27:45People don't really know what to do with themselves. So when Saddam eventually was removed, there was a gigantic power vacuum. And, you know, that's kind of inevitable, I suppose. But it doesn't always end very well. And so that's, I guess, what we've seen more recently in Iraq with the Taliban, you know, things like ISIS and a very, you know, mixed bag of kind of tribal clan leaders and foreign stooges and things like that popping up. But anyway, yeah, let's jump on to something else.
28:25Vlad CosteaSure. So we determined why both of us have gotten into Bitcoin. And I think this process took us longer than we expected, but it's actually nice that we exchange cultural backgrounds and information.
28:38Wassim AlsindiSure.
28:39Vlad CosteaSo what is it that you do in this field? As you said that you're not a cryptographer, and you are not a computer scientist.
28:46Wassim AlsindiSure, who am I? But I don't really know what I am anymore.
28:50Vlad CosteaThe first picture I saw of you contained in the background a big mining rig with Gigabyte video cards being used to mine something. I'm not sure what. That image of you actually made me think of somebody who is technical and likes to get into these geeky activities.
29:14Wassim AlsindiWell, you can be technical without being a card-carrying computer scientist, I suppose. So let's, you know, rewind the tape a little bit more. Before my decade with experimental music, I was a research scientist. So my background was kind of between chemistry, physics and astronomy. And you know, I spent a decade or so in universities doing research, teaching, managing research programs, commercializing research, and working in spin-outs and start-ups and all that kind of stuff. So it's not really that I'm not technical in a way. You know, I was doing ultrafast photophysics and, you know, astrochemistry and photophysics of DNA damage and all kinds of stuff like that.
30:03But it's not really computer science. So as time goes on, you know, you pick up some skills if you're motivated and you're not afraid to get your hands dirty, so to speak. So I picked up some experience coding, some experience scripting, moved more towards open source software. I do a little bit of mining, mainly for R&D purposes, just I wanted to learn how this thing works. I thought there was some interesting research projects in there. I run a few nodes here and there, again, just to see how various aspects of technologies work.
30:40But yes, I'm not a computer scientist per se. So what I'm doing these days, you know, as the time goes on and you fall deeper and deeper down these rabbit holes, I guess there's a natural instinct to want to learn more, to know more about what this crazy thing called Bitcoin is. And so I've just spent, you know, the last few years trying to peel back the curtain, understand as much as I can of all the different facets of what's going on here.
31:12So from finance, I went back to university. I spent some time in a business school to try and pick up some finance to see if I could relate that, finance and economics, to what's going on.
31:30Last year or so, I've spent a lot of time trying to understand how consensus mechanisms and distributed systems work. Because when all is said and done, a network like Bitcoin is a bunch of computers talking to each other, passing messages to each other. It just happens that the messages are money or have some kind of pseudo-monetary value, or something like that. And so what I'm doing is I sort of started and I'm bootstrapping this independent research organization called Parallel Industries, which has been going for a few years now. And I'm just conducting various investigations and trying to move various initiatives forwards.
32:14So, a few different projects I'm juggling at the moment. I'll just say something very briefly about them and then we'll see where we go. So, one of the interesting things that has been happening recently, or let's say in the last couple of years, is these networks have started to fork. Chains have been splitting. Factions have been appearing. Networks have been fragmenting. And so I started trying to study these fragmentations of both the code bases and the networks from a, you know, maybe slightly different perspective to how you might approach it if you were coming from a pure computer science perspective.
32:58So I called that project Forkonomy by analogy with astronomy because, well, what's astronomy? Astronomy is the study of faraway objects that you can't necessarily observe directly and completely. So you have some information coming from them. You have the light traveling from the star.
33:37And you have experiments you can do on the ground, which kind of simulate, model, and you have your hypotheses or your theories or your, you know, mathematical approaches and, you know, how science and organized thought goes. You're basically trying to triangulate these three things. So that's the kind of analytical lens I've been using with that project, and trying to use those various approaches to make some reasoned judgments or some speculations as to the probable fates of some of these networks. So one of the interesting analogies you can make between something like Bitcoin and something like a star, like the Sun, is that both, you could think of them both as thermodynamic systems. So what's the star?
34:09A star is a big ball of energy. Nuclear fusion is going on. Hydrogen becomes helium and so on. And what's Bitcoin? Well, Bitcoin is... Well, in an energetic sense or a thermodynamic sense, the mining you can think of as the energy, the work being put into the system, the enthalpy. And the entropy is kind of the time that passes and forks. And so if you use that kind of very coarse-grained model, then, you know, just as a star, you know, we don't know. I mean, it's never certain; the fate of a star does depend on many variables.
34:50But there's this stellar taxonomy called the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram, which is very highly successful at predicting the future fates of stars, depending on their luminosity and their brightness and their mass, their size. And so if you know those two things, you can find roughly where this star is going to end up by comparing it with the kind of passage of other stars over the course of their lifetimes as the fuel kind of burns out and the star either collapses in on itself, becomes a white dwarf, neutron, sorry, neutron star or a black hole.
35:43Or it kind of, the fire goes out, and it lacks the economic, the gravity, the accretive force to keep its mass. It just kind of loses everything and becomes cold rock. And so I tried to draw this parallel with Bitcoin and Bitcoin-like networks. Now, Bitcoin is the oldest of all the proof of work, or even of all the cryptocurrencies, really. And so it's very hard to peer further into the future of the life cycle of a proof of work network than Bitcoin.
36:15Now, I suppose most of the people that will listen to this have at least some idea of how the, we call the halving, regime of the subsidy paid to the miners, the bribe that's paid to the participants who put energy in to secure the network, how that halves in Bitcoin terms every four or so years. And so as that's going down further and further, it's kind of a smaller piece of the pie that is there to kind of reward the miners for securing the network against adversaries. And so you can kind of think of this like stars as they kind of go through their life cycles and they lose their fuel.
36:49They lose the fire that's burning inside them. So the question really, you know, the reason the analogy came up is, you know, is related to the question of what happens to Bitcoin. Does it maintain its incentive, the necessary incentive to the miners to defend the network, as the fee, as the mining subsidy falls, or does it lose that kind of economic gravity and become a white dwarf or become a failed project? And the kind of inspiration to go down that road was finding a less well-known network, which has now become a bit better known because of lots of bad things that happened to it in the last nine months since I started looking, which is called Bitcoin Private. You've probably heard of this, Vlad, I guess.
37:39Vlad CosteaOh, yeah. I mean, wasn't it some kind of fork and a combination between, I think it was ZClassic and Bitcoin? Some miners forked off from Bitcoin to create this.
37:54Wassim AlsindiIt was actually a bit different. The genealogy of this thing, it's quite like a family tree, you could say. So, Bitcoin, a lot of the code base of Bitcoin was adopted into Zcash and they added the zero knowledge proofs and some additional cryptography to have shielded transactions and so on. Then a group of people disliked the founders' reward or the developer tax inside Zcash, so they forked that. Code base fork. Yeah, not a ledger fork. This is a fork of the code, not a fork of the balances of the ledger of the blockchain.
38:32And they created ZClassic. Then some other people decided they wanted a dev tax, so they forked that again, made a new network with a fresh chain called ZenCash, which is now Horizon. But from ZClassic, after the ZenCash fork, it kind of looked like it had died a death. The fork didn't go well, there was lots of attacks, there was lots of hostility. And so that network was kind of left for dead.
39:00And then about November, December 2017, the height of the mania, you could say, the original creator of ZClassic came back and said, "Hey, we're going to do this thing where we combine ZClassic and Bitcoin, the UTXO sets of both ledgers, and we're going to call it Bitcoin Private." So this is the first time to my knowledge that this operation, which you could call a merge fork, or fork merge, or whatever you want to call it, this kind of synthesis of these two UTXO sets was conducted.
39:29And the interesting thing here, what I saw in it that was interesting was ZClassic was a very young network, so it only had 3.5 or 4 million of the 21 million coins issued. Bitcoin was a relatively mature network. It had about 16 or so million coins issued at that time. So if you put those two together, what you end up with is a network that's already issued over 20 million of its 21 million coins. What that means is there's not much left to give to the miners.
40:03There's not much subsidy there. There's not much stellar fuel for this thermodynamic engine. And so because the subsidy was quite low, you had a fiat token price that was also very low. There's very little incentive for the miners to defend the network. And this thing was just a sitting duck, you know, in terms of majority attacks, 51% attacks and things like that. And when I wrote the paper, the nominal... Oh, the other thing to say is that it wasn't the major coin, it wasn't the most valuable network with the Equihash mining algorithm.
40:40Which means that there's already lots of hash rate out there, GPUs and ASICs and all the rest of it. And, you know, just one mining pool on Equihash, a Zcash mining pool, could have easily done a large-scale attack, reordering blocks, double spent on exchanges, and all the rest of it. So at the time I wrote the paper, the 51% attack, I mean, when you talk about the cost of it's a bit of a misnomer. A lot of people have seen this website called crypto51.app, which kind of lists some headline figures of how much it might cost to attack a network. But that doesn't really take into account the fact that there's a market for hash rate, like a market for coins. If you buy lots of hash rate, the price of that hash rate goes up. But you could use it to make some kind of relative judgment.
41:25So at that point, it was on the order of a few hundred dollars an hour to attack it, maybe a thousand per hour. Now it's way under $100 an hour. So this thing is not thermodynamically secure. There's no reason you would use that to store your wealth or as a transactional medium. So by analogy with this kind of stellar notion, I was calling Bitcoin Private a white dwarf chain. This thing is kind of, it's wrecked, it's dead. Nobody's going to use this thing. It's too easy to attack it.
42:00It's too, there's nothing there. There's no incentive. They filled the ledger with Bitcoin UTXOs to kind of use the Bitcoin name, maybe for a bit of marketing or kind of quick flip or something like that.
42:19Indeed, the token did, the coin did a 100x pump in about a month or six weeks from the announcement of the fork merge until the actual operation in USD terms. So, what is the most interesting thing for me really was that if you kind of, Bitcoin started off with 50 bitcoins per block as the mining reward and 10 minute blocks. ZClassic had 12.5 ZClassic per block on two and a half minute blocks. So they're just kind of constant scaled factors of each other.
42:54So you can plot them on the same scaling diagram. And indeed I did that. And when I did it, I realized that Bitcoin Private is basically halving ahead of Bitcoin. So that's a new data point. It's kind of like we Frankenstein-monstered an elderly blockchain, which we didn't have before. We didn't have that data point before. So it's kind of a look into a possible future of Bitcoin. I mean, admittedly, it's the very worst case scenario for Bitcoin.
43:22You know, people talk now about reducing the block size, and they're worried about fee market. People want, you know, transaction fees to develop and to be significant, to provide the incentives for miners when the block subsidy decreases a lot. And I suppose Bitcoin Private might be a little kind of signifier of what happens if that transaction fee market doesn't develop and if the per coin fiat price is very low.
43:54All of Bitcoin's potential problems with the mining subsidy going down, they disappear if Bitcoin's price keeps going up. Because then the miners pay their bills for electricity and for their silicon chips and so on in fiat currency, in old money. So if Bitcoin is a million dollars a coin, then even if the mining subsidy is very small, that will probably be sufficient, and transaction fees will probably plug the gap.
44:23But if Bitcoin's only $5 a coin, you're going to have to pay so much in transaction fees to sufficiently incentivize the miners to keep the network secure, then it's probably not going to be a worthwhile proposition for anyone. So really, that's what the Forkonomy thing was. I just kind of sort of glance into a possible future of Bitcoin and dive down that rabbit hole. Now, since I did that work, Nic Carter and Antoine Le Calvez and the team at Coin Metrics did some absolutely amazing work spinning up some Bitcoin Private nodes and looking at the UTXO distribution around the time of the fork merge operation.
45:08Now, indeed, I did the same thing. So as you said in my picture, there's a bunch of nodes and stuff running in the background. I think one of those is actually a Bitcoin Private node that's running. Something very odd goes on around the time of the fork merge as they insert all of these UTXOs into the new network's blockchain. The size of the chain is just absolutely enormous.
45:32So my very fast computer with 32 gigs of RAM and graphics cards and all this kind of stuff was continually crapping out, trying to parse all this data so I could put it into some analytics suites that I use. And so I was looking mainly to find a potential heuristic for network health from the inter-block time, from the time between blocks, to see if smooth inter-block time would be a marker for a healthy network. And if the inter-block time is all over the place, it's kind of a proxy for hash rate variations, for difficulty swings, to see if there was a possible heuristic there.
46:09Now, they went a step or two further, and they were looking at the UTXOs themselves, and that's where they saw this gigantic pre-mine or fork pre-mine or whatever you want to call it, this hidden inflation that was put into the shielded pool of approximately 2 million coins at the time of the fork merge.
46:28So even though Bitcoin Private was already extremely wrecked, thanks to Coin Metrics and their sleuthing, it got a whole lot worse.
46:42Vlad CosteaSo in a nutshell, your case is presenting a situation where the solution to provide greater incentives for miners was to merge two coins and have their protocols developed into one. And you are projecting this as a future solution that may or may not be used for Bitcoin as the incentives to carry on with the mining operations decrease.
47:10Wassim AlsindiMaybe not, not quite. So I would say that this kind of fork merge thing, other people are going to try this for sure, because, you know, we live in this infinite universe and people are always going to try crazy things. More the opposite, really. Like, I think this operation was a disaster because the outstanding supply of the coin, of the ledger, is the incentive to keep the network secure. So when you run out of that incentive, you're going to have to find some other way of doing it.
47:43Like Bitcoin Private couldn't sustain high token price, so the incentive wasn't there. And then they start to explore all sorts of other mitigations or potential solutions, inverted commas.
47:55One of them was, "Let's steal Satoshi's coins." And, you know, this thing was marketed as Satoshi's vision. You know, they did that thing. So I don't know if you can say we've got Satoshi's vision and we're going to steal Satoshi's coins. That doesn't quite sound very consistent to me. There's all these other solutions of minority networks, of networks that aren't the most powerful one on their hashing algorithm. You can do checkpointing. You can dump your latest block hash into the Bitcoin blockchain. You can do merge mining where one cycle on a major network counts for one cycle on yours.
48:32And if somebody finds a block on the major network, they get a block on yours. You can change the chain selection rule, so you can change how the network determines which is the canonical chain, which is the true history of the ledger. And a lot of these things have been tried already on minority networks. So I kind of took a little bit of a trip down a shitcoin safari, looking at lots of minority networks to see that had been attacked or that had been vulnerable from these attacks to kind of see what they did.
49:05And because, you know, Bitcoin has not been 51% attacked that we know of. And, you know, there may be a reorg here and there, but that's more just a case of the way that mining works. You know, miners are always looking for blocks. There is no kind of single solution that's valid to finding a block. You just have to find a hash which is sufficiently low that it fits under the difficulty requirements. So it's totally within the normal operation of the network that two sets of mining pools or mining participants can find a valid block.
49:41And then it's just a race to propagate those across the network and see which one holds. But no, I wouldn't say that there's any good design lessons in Bitcoin Private. Quite the opposite. It's kind of like a menu of what not to do if you want to not have your network collapse and fall apart.
50:03Vlad CosteaWell, I guess there are lots of people who look at altcoins and forks of Bitcoin and they say that they should not exist and they are irrelevant and they are just a waste of time and money. But actually, they are very interesting in terms of providing data for worst case scenarios, and we can see what's going to happen with big blocks, what's going to happen if you merge two protocols into one. If you mess with the incentives and create pre-mines, you get to see on a practical level what attracts people, what causes the market dynamics to shift.
50:46And where it all goes wrong, one way or another. So from this point of view, I guess the forks are very educational, even though they are a bad investment for anyone.
51:00Wassim AlsindiOh yes, I absolutely agree with you and that's one really important thing to separate out here is that, you know, as a researcher or as a kind of investigator or a sleuth or a nerd, you might be interested in something as an experiment, something as a, you know, it's a mutated strain or something like that. But that doesn't mean you want to put your money in it. That's all your life savings or something to pass down to your descendants. I mean, those two things are very different in my opinion.
51:28And so you really... It's one of the kind of memes or one of the kind of themes in Bitcoin that people are saying that Bitcoin trains you to have this long-term mindset, low time preference or however you want to call it. And I don't see that in most of the other projects. I see very short-termism, kind of growth hacks, you could say, like, you know, quick, quick, short pumps and dumps and flips to try and get some cheap attention and, you know, burn out whatever fuel you've got as quickly as you can to get noticed and then disappear in a wisp of smoke.
52:04There's a really interesting saying from, I can't remember if it was Jesse Livermore or another one of these old storied investors, that in the short term, the market is a voting machine. In the long term, it's a weighing machine. And I suppose from that, you can take the lesson that short-term sentiment, market prices and so on, aren't necessarily an indicator of the long-term viability of a particular technological choice. But I totally agree that all these different forks, they're kind of like different timelines. I mean, you might be a bit too young to have seen Back to the Future. I'm not sure.
52:44Vlad CosteaNo, I've seen it. It's a cult classic.
52:46Wassim AlsindiGood, good, good. So that's how I think of these things. So in Back to the Future 2, or the end of Back to the Future 1, I think it is, Biff gets the almanac from his future self with all of the results of all the sports events that are going to happen. And then he uses that to become the, inverted commas, luckiest man in history, and amasses a huge amount of wealth. And then, you know, part of the second film in that trilogy is in the alternate timeline, the kind of dark side timeline where Biff is... He resembles a lot, you know, Biff resembles a lot a very well-known, very important person in the United States at the moment.
53:25I'm not going to say who it is, but I think it's pretty apparent to a lot of people. So he's amassed a lot of wealth. They're living in this kind of dystopian reality or alternate reality. And the film kind of flips between these two timelines. I kind of see these forks as a similar kind of set of parallel dimensions or set of parallel timelines. And so it's valuable to have all of these different alternate realities that we can explore. Obviously, these things have blockchains. They have open ledgers and networks.
53:57We can study them. We can examine them. We can see how these things go and the various design choices. It's a bit like it can be an explosion in Earth's history as well, where the complexity of life on Earth increased and proliferated very rapidly as we moved from sea to the land. So whereas I may not be particularly wild about terabyte blocks or hidden pre-mines or even very short block times or unaudited smart contracting virtual machines, I'm all for people doing these experiments. I just wish that people would be a bit more responsible and honest in reminding everybody that these are experiments.
54:44I think because markets are one of the first things that can develop around these coins and these tokens before any kind of real uses and any kind of real utility or kind of real value, you could say long-term value, worth. I suppose you're always going to get that speculation. You're always going to get people trying to flip, you know, an altcoin or another token or something like that to either get more Bitcoin or maybe because they fell in love with their bags and they thought that their thing was going to be the new Bitcoin or whatever.
55:19Maybe that's a learning process. I mean, it's one of those things that gets very, very often discussed in Bitcoin circles. I go to a lot of these Bitcoin conferences and so on, that, you know, people start with Bitcoin very often, or they did a few years ago, and then they might get seduced by the promises from another network. And they'll go over there and see how that's going and it's all very utopian and idealistic and the potential is really there. And then reality gradually kicks in. And then, you know, the kind of perspective of what has been, not promised per se, it's not always a promise, what has been suggested or intimated, and the reality of the situation can be very different.
56:06Now, you and I, we're familiar with the space. We look at these things where we're kind of knee deep in this stuff. Most of the people that are familiar with, have heard of Bitcoin, have heard of cryptocurrencies, they don't know that much about these things. So if some guy in a suit is sitting on a panel at Davos and says that his thing is better than Bitcoin, and his, you know, thing is for banks, but it's more decentralized than Bitcoin.
56:28Then people don't necessarily have the knowledge base to be able to easily refute that. And so, I suppose, you know, we have a leaderless network, it's permissionless. You are going to have these kind of Svengali-esque characters or, you know, might call them charlatans or whatever, that come in and promise, make these magical claims and promise the earth.
57:01Vlad CosteaYeah, and to some people, that was the first kind of exposure to any kind of cryptocurrency. If you were looking for "make money off of Bitcoin" on YouTube back in 2017, there are very high chances that you ended up discovering BitConnect, as that community, which was obviously part of a Ponzi scheme, was the most active and the most enthusiastic. And the idea that people make a lot of money overnight attracts much more people than actually presenting some kind of brilliant idea that's going to maybe explode in 10 years and produce something of great value.
57:48Wassim AlsindiWell, I mean, the other thing to bear in mind is that, you know, Bitcoin doesn't have a marketing department, doesn't have a marketing budget. A lot of other projects they do, from ICO treasuries, from masternode DAOs, and so on. So, in a way, Bitcoiners have this additional kind of responsibility to educate and inform people as to the reality of the situation. It wasn't just YouTube. If you cast your mind back, there were banner ads at the top of CoinMarketCap, which is, you know, maybe not the most ethical website, place to get your price data or market data, but it's one of the most popular websites in the whole space.
58:24And there were banner adverts taking people straight to BitConnect's website there. So there's also that and... It's easy to see how people can be taken in. I mean, before BitConnect, there was OneCoin. As you may remember, OneCoin didn't get quite as big as BitConnect. It was just a very, to anybody familiar with the space, it was just obviously nonsense. It was obviously a pyramid scheme or worse. But you know what? Today, this morning, I got a message from a friend. Nice guy. Met him traveling in Myanmar a few years ago.
59:04English guy. And I gave him some Bitcoin a year and a half ago. Before the run-up, actually it was... He came to stay with me. The price was about $5,000. And then I went to stay with him and the price was over 10, but I gave it to him at the old price. I didn't want to, you know, it's horrible if your first experience with Bitcoin is somebody gives you Bitcoin and then it loses all of its value immediately.
59:38So, I gave him some Bitcoin, and he's been sitting on it, and then he sent me a message the other day saying, "I had to change the wallet and this and that. By the way, have you heard of OneCoin? My friend's father is telling us to invest in it." I didn't even know this thing was still going. I thought they put some people in jail and shut it down, but maybe it's still going and we just don't see it because it's not marketed to us. It's not marketed to people that are familiar with Bitcoin, cryptocurrencies and so on, because they know that we're not going to fall for it.
1:00:06Because this thing is a small world and it's growing. As you know, there's quite a few well-known people that used to be Bitcoiners that aren't Bitcoiners anymore, they seem to have the same approach, which is trying to catch people at the turnstiles, catch people as they're coming in. When they don't know anything, they don't know any better. They don't know the difference between a BTC and a BCH and a BSV and a BTCP and so on. Because it is confusing. And, you know, when you know less, you never know less than you do in that moment.
1:00:40You know, when you first arrive, you know almost nothing. And a lot of people don't have a friend to look over their shoulder to kind of warn them or to give them advice.
1:00:57Vlad CosteaYeah, I agree with that, but at the same time, I think OneCoin is something different right now. As I looked that up at some point and it was an ICO. And the OneCoin of which you know that used to be a Ponzi scheme was, I think, made in Bulgaria or something.
1:01:16Wassim AlsindiDr. Ruja Ignatova, she was Bulgarian. Well, she was the face of it anyway. So this is a different project then. That's interesting.
1:01:24Vlad CosteaIt is, and I think it's Korean or something. But it might be one of these instances where either they are not aware of what the name stands for or what it's remembered as by people who have been a part of the community for a longer time, or one of these situations where the proverb of "fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me" applies, as they're basically tongue-in-cheek and they're shameless in their attempts to scam people. But OneCoin sounds so great, like one coin.
1:02:00You buy one coin. You have bought one coin. We are going to be using one coin to transact between ourselves in the future. Why Bitcoin? We can have one coin. It's the number
1:02:12Wassim AlsindiOne coin, the one coin to rule them all. I mean, the marketing writes itself. But I mean, I've been to Korea. I spoke at the Ethereum Classic Summit in Seoul last year. And Korea has this, you know, they're very pro technology. They're very interested in cryptocurrencies and things like that as a, you know, culture overall. But it still seems far-fetched that they wouldn't have done an English language web search and saw that there was this tainted project that had this negative history and still use the title. Unless, as you say, it's kind of a joke. I mean, I don't know if you remember, there was a project called PonziCoin. Over a year ago, I found that.
1:02:59And they were just saying, "Hey, we're a Ponzi scheme, but it's honest." A bit like that FOMO3D game. Kind of said, "Hey, this is kind of a self-perpetuating thing until it collapses. And that's why it's fun."
1:03:13Vlad CosteaYeah, that was in the middle of the ICO bubble when everybody was speculatively putting like $100 in each ICO. And they were used to the idea that maybe 9 out of 10 would fail. But that one of them which was legit and was generating value, that was the one which was feeding expectations and actually paying for the other nine to collapse and maybe enrich a few who are creating the ICO.
1:03:48Wassim AlsindiMm-hmm. Yeah, it's almost like the venture capital model, right? Early stage entrepreneurial funding kind of works on the same model where people will fund things in a very early stage. There'll be very little chance that this thing will get to a successful exit, but if it does get to a successful exit, you might be looking at, you know, 50 times, 100 times, 200 times, 20 times return on investment. But of course, the difference between kind of early stage VC model and the ICO model is the incentives. The ICO model, at least of the 2017 vintage, was just completely upside down.
1:04:26You know, this was... People were issuing these tokens for nothing, cost nothing to issue them, or pretty much nothing. And there's very little in terms of claims or in terms of rights or in terms of things that are really promised beyond, you know, some nice graphics in a PDF.
1:04:45That was about it, I guess. Maybe a website, maybe some wallet or a little bit of a smart contract or something like that. And so, I guess, yeah, that's one of my main problems with the whole thing. And maybe it takes us on to one of the other projects that I'm working on, because I was just editing a manuscript I'm preparing. And I was just going through the bit where I was taking the ICO incentive model, at least of 2017, to task.
1:05:18Vlad CosteaYeah, you know, I remember that enthusiastic period of time when somebody would come up with one wild idea. And even if it sounded stupid, if they were able to write a white paper and create a website, they would find people who are enthusiastic about it and say, "You know, this actually has potential, or this can be the future," or whatever. They would have big communities on Telegram. But at the end of the day, I think it was just pure speculation and nobody actually cared about developing the project or advancing with the roadmap.
1:05:55They just wanted to buy the tokens before the ICO and on the same day when that project ICO'd and the public had access to buy the tokens on exchanges, they would dump it and maybe maximize their early investment.
1:06:14Wassim AlsindiSure, and even the way the insiders were given tokens at discounts and they could dump them on retail as exchanges listed this thing. It reminds me of this really interesting book and paper and a talk online by a chap called Nick Gogerty. He's from SolarCoin. And I can't remember what the paper is called right now, but the concept is called network capital theory. So he's trying to look at all kinds of monies as protocol networks, trying to figure out a way that you can connect the dots between the different drivers of a price.
1:06:53So if you think about, like, if, Vlad, we want to make a transaction, say you've got some nice Romanian bread, and I would like to purchase it at some point in the future. It's very hard for us to agree a price until the moment of the transaction. There's lots of different factors that might go into that. The exchange rate, the price of flour, the transport costs, whether the UK will still be in the European Union or not, all that kind of stuff. So he tried to come up with this way that you could model the value of assets and the networks that facilitate the transaction of those assets.
1:07:27He calls it transactome theory. I don't know if you've heard of the human biome, the genome, the connectome, and so on. Kind of the sum of all possible connections that can be made between the willing economic agents in a monetary network, you could say. So he had this interesting idea that the price kind of is constituted of these three elements, these three factors. One is kind of the, if I've got this right, the network, the value from the network, the size of the network, the breadth of the protocol, or the amount of people that will accept your bread as money or as a pseudo-monetary asset or whatever. The redemption utility, the, you know, the ease of the value of kind of cashing in your asset, you could say.
1:08:21I mean, for bread, it would be eating the bread. Or for Ether, it could be using it in a smart contract. Or for Bitcoin, it could be transacting and spending with it. And then the speculative utility, whether you try to foretell the market and its perception of the value in the short term. So what's interesting is you then can have this kind of intertemporal view between past, present and future. So in the past, we know the price of stuff in the past. We have those records. That's kind of objective.
1:08:56We can look that up. We have records. We know what the prices of stuff were. We just spoke about exchange rates of currencies. We can just look it up. We have that data. In the present, it's more difficult. It's more kind of intersubjective. It's a transient matter. It depends on the moment and the conditions in the moment. And in the future, it's subjective. Like, you know, if you ask me what the price of Bitcoin is in six months' time, I have no idea. All I can do is have a guess.
1:09:27And so this theory that Gogerty and Johnson came up with this kind of, there's a book as well that Gogerty's written. I can't remember the name of it right now. But the concept is called network capital theory, and the transactome kind of concept is really interesting because when you apply that back to things like ICOs, they didn't really have much of a network beyond the exchanges. I guess that's about it. There was no real use of them because nobody built the product, nobody built the, you know, the thing that they were meant to be building.
1:10:03They were raising the money at the start to go off and build the thing. People are still building these things. The ones that have stuck around are still building them. So all you really had was the speculative value, as you said. But it was interesting to see this kind of economic model of these networks and how the different aspects of the utility or the value or the components of price might be arrived at, depending on, you know, the intertemporal nature of where you are, whether you're looking in the past or the present or future.
1:10:39Quite interesting.
1:10:41Vlad CosteaSo you told me before this interview that you have this idea about Bitcoin being a time machine. And you got me intrigued at that point, and I was just waiting for you to start the conversation about it. But I guess it takes me to actually inquire about it.
1:11:02Wassim AlsindiWell, we kind of had. We started the conversation already. So the Forkonomy project, looking into the possible futures of Bitcoin as the mining subsidy attenuates, that's kind of a related concept, and this idea of the forks being parallel dimensions. So Bitcoin is kind of like, especially with kind of economics of Bitcoin, if we strip out the exogenous factors, the external factors like Bitcoin price in dollars or lei or Moroccan dirhams or pounds or whatever, one Bitcoin equals one Bitcoin.
1:11:33Every block, every nine and a half minutes or ten minutes, 12.5 bitcoins are created in a coinbase transaction that goes to a miner or a mining pool in return for their services in defending the network. And the issuance, the kind of mathematical relationship of the issuance of Bitcoin, the effective inflation rate or however you want to look at it, versus time, that is known. That is deterministic.
1:12:00And so when you have things like, you know, when I said I put on the halving diagram, the stepping down diagram that you often see with relation to Bitcoin, and when you put, say, ZClassic and Bitcoin and Bitcoin Private on this network, you kind of see that you're kind of looking through the ages of the network there. It's kind of like that, you know, what was that Shakespeare play, The Three Ages of Man, The Seven Ages of Man? I can't actually remember what it is. I'm not so literarily educated as I am with technical stuff. So, because the supply issuance is deterministic, because the way the network works, it's kind of like quite a cold mechanical machine in a way.
1:12:48You know, the energy goes in, blocks come out, blocks get appended to the chain, and the blocks contain transactions, the history of the ledger is updated. By looking at these different coins that are in different regimes of the halving, or indeed looking at Bitcoin as it progresses through its life, that's kind of this idea of Bitcoin being a time machine, that we can rewind. We can rewind back and look at Bitcoin's past when it was a young upstart, when it was in its inflationary phase, when the effective inflation was very high.
1:13:26And we can kind of, you know, if you find more anomalies like Bitcoin Private, you can kind of fast forward a little bit into the future and see what the futures of Bitcoin might be or the futures of other networks might be. So really that's where that concept kind of came from. It's also an interesting philosophical kind of quandary or something to ponder that, you know, we don't have necessarily just one timeline. It depends, I don't know if you believe in free will or not, or, you know, these kinds of philosophical considerations.
1:14:05But it's not necessarily the case that we only have one timeline and we're kind of mechanically rolling through our lives on rails, you know, as a kind of mannequin being shepherded from one station of our life experience to another. So having these kinds of insights into possible futures, I guess it's like that Gogerty equation. You have the subjective future, the intersubjective present and the objective past. So the more data we have with the objective past, the better informed our kind of speculative trajectories of the possible futures are and might be.
1:14:47Vlad CosteaSo let me ask you a more practical question, which is much more rooted in practical and everyday affairs. As I know that you travel a lot and you have been to a lot of countries in the last few years, and I'm not sure for how long you have been a Bitcoiner, but I know that an ideal of Bitcoiners is to have their digital cryptographic currency accepted in as many places as possible and ideally to be able to live off your bitcoins everywhere you go. So of all the places that you visited, which ones do you think were the friendliest in terms of accepting Bitcoin as a mean of payment?
1:15:33Wassim AlsindiYeah, really good question. So let me just preface answering the question. Maybe we have a little detour on the traveling before we get there. So, I wasn't really interested at all in traveling when I was younger. I was just a nerd. I was chained to a laboratory desk, operating large lasers, and that was my thing. And then I got to my late 20s. I left the university after a decade or so and realized that I kind of misspent my 20s. I could have spent those, you know, adventuring around the world.
1:16:07And so I kind of went off and did that. Started traveling around Europe a lot with music, bouncing around from many of the same places where we were doing our very niche kind of experimental music: Berlin, different parts of Holland, or the lowlands in general, Spain and Portugal, Malta, west coast of the States, Scandinavian countries, all around Europe really. Not so much to the east, but let's say Western, Northern, Southern Europe. And then as I started living more and more on the road, it started to become a bit more advantageous to understand really how travel works. It's the same as Bitcoin. If you spend all your time thinking about Bitcoin, you want to know how it works. So I started kind of peeling away the layers of how transport works, the economics of transport, how to hack your way around for less and less money.
1:17:03And so there's a thing called travel hacking. May not be as much of a thing as it used to be. So before Bitcoin, I was kind of interested in, you know, like frequent flyer points, hotel points and all that kind of stuff, hacking my way through those because it helped me travel. And as time went on with music, my budget became more and more constrained. And I also wanted to travel further and further. So I had to get more and more creative about how to do that.
1:17:33So England, because England's a very kind of free market capitalistic place, a bit like the States, we have this huge credit culture. Credit cards, loans, all this kind of stuff. And there's all kinds of incentives attached to these credit cards. Like air miles, you know, you might have a British Airways credit card or American Express credit card that gives you points and you can spend those on flights. And if you do it just right, you can get something crazy that you would never be able to afford or you'd be able to go to a place that you could never normally go.
1:18:06So I really, you know, made the most of that. I think I'll hit 80 countries this year. And obviously, I've visited many places multiple times as well. So I was just in Malta last month. My friends there, we used to do a lot of experimental music events there, even though it's this tiny place. There was a little scene for what we did. And my friends asked me, "How many times have you been here?" And I couldn't answer them because once it gets to 10 or 12, what's the point in counting?
1:18:36I lost count completely. And so, traveling that widely, and then, as I said, I started working less and less on music. I started traveling more and more just for the hell of it. So I started traveling more widely, went around places like South America a number of times, Pacific Islands.
1:19:02North Africa, parts of Asia, East Asia, Australasia and so on. You start to go to South Asia as well. You start to go to places that might be considered less developed, more closed, or places with simple lives, less material. And the thing that really fascinated me with going to places like, I don't know, Myanmar or Bolivia or India, is that you get off that kind of international trail, what they call the banana pancake trail in Southeast Asia.
1:19:37You get off that kind of Lonely Planet itinerary, you start to see quite real, quite gritty things. People that have very little, very little in the way of exogenous resources, very little access to capital or material goods or income or whatever. Cambodia is a very good example of that as well, where I spent Christmas and New Year last year.
1:20:00But what's amazing is you see that the less resources people have, the more resourceful they are and they can be, the more imaginative they are. That was really something quite inspiring. But just to get back to your point, which was about acceptance of Bitcoin. I'd say most of the places that have been most accepting or that I've been able to transact with it, or that I've seen the signs of transaction going on, have been in Europe. Prague, I think it's well known as one of the hotspots, epicenters of, you know, acceptance, merchant acceptance and commerce, or peer-to-peer transactions.
1:20:43In Prague, there's that amazing place, the Institute of Crypto-Anarchy, where the Hackers Congress conference is held every October. And they don't accept fiat in that place. It's just cryptocurrency. You know, first it was Bitcoin, now it's Bitcoin and a couple of others. So you don't have a choice. If you want to eat, if you want a beer, that's what you've got to do. You've got to pay with Bitcoin. That's great. And I suppose the downside of something like that is the volatility risk.
1:21:20So, you know, if you're accepting Bitcoin as a merchant and Bitcoin is $20,000, and then you put that in your wallet, and then you need to pay your bills in a couple of months' time, and Bitcoin is $6,000, that is a problem, you know, because your bills are probably not in Bitcoin. We don't have these complete circular economies in Bitcoin quite just yet. But, you know, hopefully, as these ecosystems build out, it will be easier to have these kind of complete circular economies. I also noticed a lot of acceptance in Baltic countries. I've been to Estonia and Latvia, and I've noticed it there.
1:22:06Even in Malta, where I was last month, I saw some signs of it. I mean, not everywhere. We're talking about a handful of places in Malta. But what was interesting was I walked past a real estate vendor and estate agent in Valletta, in the capital. There was a Bitcoin sign in the window with all these luxury apartments and the yacht marina and all this kind of stuff to rent and to buy. So I went in, asked them, you know, "Hey, take Bitcoin?" They said, "Yes, we do." I was like, "So I can rent, buy a place with Bitcoin?" And they're like, "Yep."
1:22:39So I don't know how they're doing it. I didn't want to press them too much, but I don't know if they're taking it as a, you know, kind of payment processor intermediary like BitPay that they're using, or if it's Globee or something like that, or if they're actually, the owners are requesting Bitcoin as an alternative to euros, and they're conducting the sales in Bitcoin, as something like Hodl Hodl, the Latvian website run by the people that also make the Baltic Honeybadger conference, how they have a kind of marketplace where you can buy your houses with Bitcoin or your apartments and so on.
1:23:13So, I haven't seen huge amounts of merchant adoption. Indeed, when I was in Scotland, until a few months ago I was living in Glasgow, in Scotland, and was running a series of meetups and just trying to spread the good word. Make sure that people don't get kind of misled or taken down wayward paths. So we thought we could do, you know, this was just before Christmas, you know, 15 months ago.
1:23:41Might be nice to do kind of a pub crawl. We'll go get some drinks, get some food, we'll pay with cryptocurrency. It'll be fun. We found basically nothing. This is a city of a million people. It's quite a big city. Well, maybe not quite a million. It's the biggest city in Scotland, one of the larger cities in the UK. Almost nothing. There was one small cafe where the owner's son was into Bitcoin, so you could pay with Bitcoin for your fry-up, if you so desired.
1:24:15And there was a kind of a rough-and-ready pub where you could pay with ScotCoin, which is a local project of dubious repute, shall we say, because the guy that owns the pub was also a ScotCoin guy, something like that. So you have very heterogeneous kind of levels of adoption from place to place. If you go to London, it's a different matter entirely. I'm not saying that you can necessarily pay for your, you know, your Caesar salad in a Carnaby Street cafe with Bitcoin more often than not, but you can find places and ways to transact.
1:24:53There's a black cab, a taxi, traditional London taxi that drives around. It's called the BTC Black Cab. You can find it on Twitter. You send it a DM if you want a ride. You can pay in Bitcoin or Lightning. So there are little kind of pockets of adoption coming now. Now what I foresee, or what I hope for, is that as the kind of ecosystems build out and the on and off ramps between fiat and Bitcoin kind of proliferate in type and diversity and number, then a lot of this friction will be removed.
1:25:31There are some really interesting projects in the UK, like Azte.co, which is Bution's project, and FastBitcoins, which is Danny Brewster's project, which are kind of like point-of-sale vouchers. So if you think of a phone that's kind of in a case, attached to a little printer, then if you're in person in a shop, you can hand them cash or whatever. They can print you a little voucher. You go off to the website. And then bitcoins go to wherever you tell it to go. So things like that will start to remove some of the friction, because we still need some more infrastructure to be built out and mature to have these circular economies.
1:26:19Vlad CosteaYeah, sorry, I accidentally turned off my microphone. Anyway, I was just thinking that in Romania we used to have these small places where, for example, one of the venues where you could have your mobile phone repaired or fixed or had parts changed used to accept Bitcoin, and that was maybe a year ago. And they had this big logo of Bitcoin right on the window of the shop, so it was very visible and close to the city center. And there was also a pawn shop, which accepted Bitcoin and Ethereum and XRP and Monero, and I think also Litecoin. And they were basically giving you about 5% less than the CoinMarketCap price. So you could do crypto to fiat trades with the owner. But in recent months, I saw them closing down. And last month...
1:27:25Wassim AlsindiYou mean the shops closed down or they just closed that payment option?
1:27:28Vlad CosteaThey closed down the payment option. They just gave up completely on Bitcoin. And I don't think it was because of the bear market. I think it was because of regulations and tax reasons and maybe that they received a couple of visits from the financial authorities, and they were asked about how much of these digital assets they were holding.
1:27:59And there was no framework up to last month. There was no way to actually tax cryptocurrencies. And now they created a law with... I'm not sure if it was enacted as in signed into law yet, but it was about taxing crypto gains. But gains are defined as the kind of profit that you're making when you transact from crypto to fiat. If you make crypto to crypto gains, as in increasing the amount of Bitcoin that you're holding, then you're not liable to pay any taxes, because you're not holding any kind of currency that is recognized by the government.
1:28:52Wassim AlsindiObviously, that's quite sensible. Like, you know, it's a kind of a pragmatic way of approaching these things, that you kind of think of cryptocurrency as a basket you hold. And as you exit that kind of sphere of that basket, then you might trigger a taxable event. That's much more sensible than the way things have been in the States, where every trade that you might make from one cryptocurrency to another counts as a taxable event. And really, I think one of the drivers of the negative sentiment and, you know, possibly by extension the bear market is this unclear legal regulatory status, lots of ominous words from government types, regulators and so on. That's something I've been looking at as well. Maybe there's ways that we can develop tools that can educate lawmakers and regulators a little bit.
1:29:34Vlad CosteaOh yeah, but as far as I know, most people involved in Bitcoin are not very interested in collaborating with their government. And they just leave them in the dark, or they leave them with partial or very bad knowledge of the phenomena. So they end up hiring all sorts of people whom they think are specialists and actually understand how it works. But they end up being ill-advised and making the worst decisions possible. And I see sometimes people making fun of governments and how poorly they actually grasp the whole concept of... It's actually data.
1:30:20It's code that you have stored on a public ledger into which you have access with your keys. So in that sense, if you describe it like this, you don't own anything but a line of code and like a password. You have a password and you can say it's like your email address. And how are they supposed to tax your email address? Maybe your emails are valuable to others and you can just cede ownership of them to somebody else. But at the same time, you can also describe it as something like... Let me think of a virtual currency like M-Pesa, if you heard of it.
1:31:04Wassim AlsindiOf course.
1:31:05Vlad CosteaAnd also I think in China they have something with that all-encompassing application. I don't remember.
1:31:13Wassim AlsindiThose are more like payment processors. I was in Shenzhen a few weeks ago, and I was sitting with some buddies eating some crab. And the meal finished, and on the table there's a QR code, and they scanned it with their Alipay or WeChat Pay, one of these kind of payment processor things. And I said to them, like, you know, I only had cash because none of my cards work in China. I walked over the border from Hong Kong. And they said, "Oh, no, we've already paid. It's done."
1:31:38You know, so they've got these very low-friction fintech apps. You could say they're not anything peer-to-peer or, inverted commas, decentralized. But I think it's a big problem, this kind of lack of education of regulators, because, you know, people that you could say Bitcoiners or cryptocurrency aficionados might see governments as a threat and therefore not want to help them understand what's going on. And other people take a different perspective, which might be more that if regulators and lawmakers and the like were a little bit better educated about what's going on here, what these assets are really like and about, then that might help them make less or better informed judgments.
1:32:35And then they might be able to see the similarities and differences between things. I mean, one of the biggest problems we have right now is that when people think of, you know, inverted commas cryptos, they lump into this gigantic bucket Bitcoin, XRP and, you know, two dozen ICOs and they just call them the same thing. When in reality, these things are very different. I mean, they have some similarities in terms of the way that they're constructed, kind of a technological paradigm from which they originate. But many of their characteristics are very different.
1:33:07So, yeah, I've taken it upon myself to develop some, you could call it like a taxonomy project. I'm working on classification and characterization concepts, things that somebody non-technical could use as a tool to try and tease apart similarities and differences in a subjective sense between these things. So maybe that would help them see, for example, that Bitcoin is more like a lump of gold than it is like Apple stock, but then XRP might be more like Apple stock than it is a lump of gold. So just those very kinds of basic, easy to understand things.
1:33:50And I also totally agree with your point about the people that end up advising the governments. Largely, it's a net negative. I guess you could call them the blockchain experts of LinkedIn, the people in suits that come from banking or fintech backgrounds, that there's a bandwagon passing by and they jump aboard it. And it's easy to call yourself an expert when you're not. Nobody else knows what they're talking about. You can wave your hands around and use some buzzwords, and then you're an expert, and then you're on the panel, and then you're advising the central bank, and then you're advising the regulator.
1:34:28So those kinds of things are dangerous, but there are some people with their heads screwed on that understand Bitcoin very well. They're also talking to lawmakers and regulators and central banks. I know some of them. So that's promising in itself.
1:34:45Vlad CosteaI agree, but as you said, there is a large difference or huge difference between what we have in Bitcoin and what we see in XRP. And usually people confuse the idea of fintech with Bitcoin. And they are very different in their origins and in their purpose and their methods.
1:35:05Wassim AlsindiOh, absolutely.
1:35:07Vlad CosteaI have to say that something which comes from the cypherpunk culture and which actually tries to be the kind of wealth that you can possess without having it confiscated, and that's maybe the greatest value that Bitcoin has. And something like that cannot be compared with something that's supposed to be liquid. And by design, it's supposed to be a mean of exchange, like you said, WeChat and Alipay and all these applications, which, by the way, are so much more efficient than anything blockchain.
1:35:49Wassim AlsindiDefinitely, of course, because they're designed for efficiency. They're optimized for efficiency, for performance. Blockchains absolutely suck for efficiency and performance. I mean, if that hasn't become apparent to everybody by now, I guess it will kind of gradually dawn on them over time. And these things are not designed, you know, these cryptocurrencies, peer-to-peer, trust-minimized networks are not designed to be efficient. They're designed to be, they're more like tanks than Ferraris. I mean, you know, they're meant to be resilient. They're meant to withstand external pressure and, you know, adversarial conditions.
1:36:24Vlad CosteaBut I meet a lot of people who tell me that I'm short-sighted in my belief in Bitcoin, and there are so many use cases for the blockchain that are being experimented right now. And IBM and Carrefour and some other business venture, large corporation, has found some kind of application that is very much efficient. And it's going to revolutionize the way that we use maybe transactions and we track down, because that's the whole purpose of a blockchain. You have it written down and it's immutable, theoretically.
1:37:00And I don't know, sometimes I'm torn and I like to listen to them and I try to understand what they're up to, but it's not very often that I get to...
1:37:14Wassim AlsindiMaybe I can play devil's advocate. So I think that both sides of the argument can have an element of truth in them. But it's only because things are relative. These aren't absolute truths necessarily. So there are a few applications where I can imagine, I mean obviously we've been through a few years of people strapping blockchains to everything and then realizing that it's not particularly well-suited technology match. But there are some that I think, even if blockchain is not the ultimate, you know, solution to a technology challenge or problem, it may provide incremental improvement because the existing solution sucks so much.
1:38:01And some of those examples are, I've heard insurance company CEOs foaming at the mouth about blockchains. I've heard, you know, does IBM have a project with Maersk, the Danish shipping company, putting shipping containers on the blockchain? They love that. A land registry is going on the blockchain. And what those three things... These are usually kind of not public blockchains, these are, you know, Hyperledger type enterprise, walled garden, intranet blockchains. But the commonality, the common strand between those three things is that the current processes are absolutely...
1:38:39Terrible. People are pretty much still doing shipping by pen and paper. So if you can imagine, you know, land registry, buying a house, there's all these different links in the chain, so to speak. And so, you know, shipping is, you know, manifest still done by pen and paper. Insurance, there's all these loss adjusters and claimants and then the valuers, and there's all these different links in the business process. And so if you use a blockchain, it's actually kind of... A shipping container is not that bad an analogy. So what a shipping container does is it kind of standardizes. It forces everybody to use the same structure and therefore you can optimize a process around it. So you can almost think of blockchains as shipping containers for data between these mutual parties.
1:39:27Whether they trust each other or not depends on the situation. But if you're doing something on pen and paper, you can't get less efficient than that. So blockchain will provide some kind of incremental advantage. But of course, they could all just say it's a consortium of shipping companies or whatever, insurance industry service providers. They could just use the same goddamn database structure, API setup, and, you know, web portals, and they could not need a blockchain at all and have much better efficiency. But what the blockchain is kind of doing is what shipping containers did to logistics, which is kind of forcing everybody to use the same...
1:40:16Template, I guess. So that's really as much as I can see there. I think people might find some incremental steps forwards there. There are some very smart people doing interesting things, looking a bit broader than money as well. But they're all experiments. So I'm very interested in them as experiments. But I don't see if there's value there yet.
1:40:40Vlad CosteaAnother argument that I like to present, and I guess this came from a conversation, it was a brief exchange that I had with Peter Todd on Twitter. And that resulted in an article which I wrote yesterday and got published today. And probably by the time this podcast gets released as a second season altogether, it's going to be old news already. But I pretty much argued that Bitcoin is not the culmination of that cashless society that some people talk about. And if anything, we need cash in order to have a fungible Bitcoin at this point.
1:41:24When you go to various places where they don't even accept the credit card, or there is nothing that you can do without the local currency, it's good to have fiat, and that's not going to change for at least a few decades, even though they're going to try to promote the idea that they can have POS terminals and stuff like that to accept people's credit cards.
1:41:53You'll still have the farmer's market or lots of places where it's best to use cash. And at the end of the day, it's much more private to hold a few pieces of paper in your wallet, and nobody knows how many of them you actually own and what you do with them, where you spend them.
1:42:15Whereas when you use your credit card, you leave traces about your whereabouts and your spending behaviors and all that kind of Orwellian stuff. And when you look at Bitcoin and you think about how we can use it in commerce and transactions, it's not the most private choice that we have, and there are easy ways to actually make connections between your public key and realize how much Bitcoin you might be holding. And sometimes, depending on the kind of wallet that you're using, you actually leave traces. And people see how much Bitcoin you own when you spend it.
1:42:50Say you make a purchase of the equivalent of 0.05, you're going to be able to see that you actually own a whole Bitcoin. And that's not something that you reveal when you go to the supermarket and you buy something with a $20 bill. And you just take it out of your wallet and nobody else sees how much money you have left. So until we solve these issues with privacy and also fungibility, it's difficult... to make exchanges between Bitcoin and cash, but not in terms of going to Coinbase and registering to some kind of KYC process and basically telling them how much money you have, how much you're taking away.
1:43:36But in terms of having small meetings or knowing somebody who wants to buy Bitcoin at a price that is lower than on exchanges, and it's pretty much like LocalBitcoins, but without the credit card component. And it requires trust. That's the only problem right there, because you're meeting with a stranger. And unless you know something about them, like their full name, they can go and report them to the police or something, or to be certain that they're not going to try to come with some kind of gang and rob you, torture you, take away your private keys or something.
1:44:21But this kind of interaction is much more productive and is actually the spirit of Bitcoin itself. It's much more cypherpunk than being stubborn and saying, "I'm going to use Bitcoin in everything," as the technology is still immature, and it doesn't have all the qualities of sound money and all the advantages that we might look for when we want completely private and safe transactions. I mean, safe, they are safe, but not in the sense that you preserve some kind of private information about you that you're giving away whenever you make a transaction on the open ledger of Bitcoin.
1:45:02Wassim AlsindiYeah, lots to unpack there. So let's start with the privacy and the fungibility. So it's interesting that we bring this up because Matt B, who you had on the first season, we're writing a series of articles together in a magazine called In the Mesh, which is goTenna's outlet to do with the political aspects of decentralized technology. goTenna make mesh networking devices so that you can transact, say, in areas, or you can broadcast messages peer-to-peer in areas which might be, you know, internet might be restricted or censored, or you're offline or something like that.
1:45:39So, yeah, privacy and fungibility are definitely linked concepts. So the lack of fungibility in the money impacts the privacy of the individual, as you were saying. And so cash is still king in many ways because you can transact without digital breadcrumbs and this kind of Orwellian superstate machine learning monolith learning everything about you and trying to second guess your movements and what have you. And it is, you know, for all of us, if we start to think about how much information we have to give up to move around or to transact online or to do this and that, it's quite horrifying.
1:46:08So, and you really don't know where your data is going. So I told you about how I used to do this travel hacking thing. So I used to harvest air miles on credit cards, which involves getting a card, spending a bit of money on it, getting the reward, cancelling the card, getting another card and doing that.
1:46:38And I got a letter about 18 months ago from Equifax, the company that does credit reference scoring, and they're very famous for having a huge hack and losing a lot of very sensitive information. I got a letter from them saying, "Yeah, your data was on our server in America, and sorry." I thought to myself, "Well, why is my data on your American server? I'm not American. I'm British. Why is it there?" And so we don't even really know what happens with the data as it gets...
1:47:10Warehoused and moved around. So cash is king, but, you know, there's also an issuer of the cash. So if you cast your mind back a year or two to what happened in India, where they demonetized the 100 rupee notes, and 100 rupees was the highest value note, it's only about 15 euros or something like that. They demonetized the 50 and 100 rupee notes with, I can't remember, 10 days' notice, two weeks' notice, something like that. So that's when you saw those pictures that went around the world of huge queues of people trying to cash in their money for the new money.
1:47:58And the whole point, I think, was to try and sort of smoke people out, kind of run a turnstile to get the black market, to kind of suppress the black market, which is really rampant in India. It actually reminds me a little bit of what's going on with Zcash at the moment. So I don't know if you've been following this. Zcash had this inflation bug due to an error in one of its cryptographic proofs. And what's been going on now is as they've upgraded from one phase of the project to another, the previous one was called Sprout, and the next one's called Sapling.
1:48:29So they're doing this kind of turnstile where they're auditing the coin supply as it comes out of the shielded pool, out of the hidden pool of Z addresses, into the transparent pool, which is kind of like Bitcoin-like UTXOs that everyone can see on a public ledger, then goes into the Sapling pool, the new kind of privacy shielded pool. So if there's any inflation, they should be able to detect it as people leave the Sprout shielded pool. But of course, if somebody's leaving the turnstile, that doesn't necessarily mean that they were the...
1:49:01They were the culprit. So the last people to leave the pool will be the ones that lose out because there'll be... It's a bit like you buy a ticket for a concert, and you get there and they say, "Oh, it's already full. We, you know, 500 people showed up, that's the capacity." And just because you've got a ticket doesn't mean you get in. So you have to... You're a bit at the mercy of the issuer with cash. And, you know, demonetization of large denomination banknotes is, you know, it's happening all over the place.
1:49:32They're talking about the UK, the Treasury or the Bank of England is talking about getting rid of the 50 pound note. Now, 50 pounds is only, you know, it's barely more than 50 euros these days. That's the largest note we've got. We're talking about getting rid of that. So the denomination of cash is getting lower and lower as governments try to kind of gently push people towards using digital payments. I was having a conversation on Twitter with a friend yesterday about Sweden. So I used to run a music festival in rural Sweden.
1:50:04And this is in a forest in the grounds of a disused mining facility, you know, a few hours outside Stockholm, kind of in the place where everyone has their cabins in the wood, near all the beautiful lakes that you see. It's kind of like Lord of the Rings country.
1:50:17Now, a few years ago, the treasury was stolen from the, you know, the cash box was stolen from the festival. They lost, you know, several thousand euros equivalent, let's say. And so the festival went cashless. Now this is a small festival, less than a thousand people in a disused mine. There's no running water or electricity. You have to get all of that from the town. And yet the festival was cashless. And the reason they were so easy to push on to do that is because Sweden is the closest thing that the planet's got to a cashless society.
1:50:51At its peak, 97% plus of all transactions were cashless. But the... And they did try to make a cashless society, but they failed because there are people in society that either can't, won't, or are unable to, don't have access to technology to use electronic payments. So in Sweden they have a system a bit like that WeChat and Alipay chat, WePay and Alipay with QR codes. I think it's called Swish in Sweden, I can't remember. All of the Nordic countries have this kind of thing. So people are very used to paying on their phones.
1:51:28It's just linked to their bank accounts and it's all very fintech and centralized and efficient, and you trust the bank because it's the bank. But the problem is there's an intermediary in every transaction. So cash is kind of peer-to-peer, right? Or as close to peer-to-peer as you're going to get with old money. And so what the banks, the Riksbank, the central bank of Sweden, started to worry that, you know, you've got all this systemic risk, all of this kind of... The stakes of failure of these payment processes are extremely high.
1:52:04If there's a service outage, nobody can do anything. You can't buy your train ticket, you can't buy your meal, you can't pay to use the conveniences. It introduces all of these fragilities in our society, relying on these single points of failure. And back to your point about the cash-led economies, you reminded me of India and Cambodia in particular. So Cambodia is interesting because they don't have, well, they do have their own money, the riel, but because the country has had like very...
1:52:41Choppy history, very, very rocky road. At one point, the United Nations basically took over the administration of the country. I think Australia had a lot to do with it. And a lot of American GIs were based there after the fall of the Pol Pot Khmer Rouge regime. And they brought dollars with them. And I don't know if you've heard of Gresham's Law, this kind of economic, in inverted commas, law, that bad money... No, wait a second. There's Gresham's law and there's Thiers' law, which is the opposite.
1:53:12And they're both apparently laws, but they contradict each other. So Gresham's law is bad money drives out good money, and Thiers' law is good money drives out bad money. So I suppose in Cambodia, the country dollarized because Thiers' law was in effect, whatever that means. So they still have their old money, but it's pegged to the dollar. So the currency is de facto the dollar. People like dollars. They prefer dollars to riel.
1:53:58And so a lot of the transactions are still in cash. What was very interesting, I went back, you know, I was there six weeks ago. It'd been a couple of years since I'd last been there. You start to notice electronic commerce, digital commerce, digital payments. So they've got an app in Southeast Asia called Grab, which is a bit like Uber or Taxify, and it's got electronic payments inside it. So you can now hail a... You can even hail a tuk-tuk. You can hail a, like, you know, rickety motorbike.
1:54:21You can hail a taxi or a 4x4, and it can be paid for kind of in that fintech online app payment paradigm. So it is actually happening quite quickly. I remember I went to India a couple of years ago, and Uber was trying to enter the market in India. Now, in India, you've got these kind of auto rickshaws or tuk-tuks, just like in Cambodia, these either LPG or petrol mini-cars, you could say. They're just like a, you know, they look like they're made out of paper or papier-mâché or something. They're very fragile things, but they're great for little kind of intra-city journeys.
1:54:42And Uber was trying to undercut the rickshaws with their cars, with their taxis. So part of the bargaining process in India, everything is bargaining, just as in Cambodia, these transaction economies. So you would literally get the price, get the expected fare from Uber, and then the rickshaw driver would ask you for two or five times that because you're a foreigner. And then you just show them the app, and then they would acquiesce. So I suppose there are some kind of price discovery signal advantages to these kinds of electronic payment or electronic platform apps and companies entering these kind of frontier economies.
1:55:23But you're right that there's always going to be a place for cash. And I don't know if you saw the recent guidance from the, I think it was the IMF, this week or the week before. People have been getting in a rage about it on Twitter. You've probably seen it, about this idea that, you know, should a recession or a global downturn arrive, central banks usually have to cut interest rates four to six percent. And, you know, interest rates are already at basically zero in most of the developed world.
1:56:01So the article or the position paper was exploring very negative interest rates, you know, minus 5%, minus whatever percent. And the way that they're proposing to do that was to kind of make a cashless society so that your money is in the bank, and then your kind of E-Leu or your E-pound or your E-crown or whatever then has an exchange rate against the paper money. So you're kind of bifurcating the money into paper and electronic money, and then there's kind of a non-unity exchange rate between them to allow them to haircut your money, to take your money while it's in the bank.
1:56:44It'll pay you negative rates of return on it in order to keep the kind of crazy quantitative easing fake money train going a little bit longer. So I think all of these things are going to compel people to become more interested in real alternatives to the legacy financial system. You know, Bitcoin is an excellent example of something that does not subscribe to this kind of profligate, debt-based, unsustainable financial paradigm. So I do wonder about that. But also, you know, going back to places like India and Cambodia, there's also places where people aren't really free, right? You know, the governments can be quite authoritarian. You know, people just don't really have a concept of personal agency and sovereignty and freedom in a lot of these places.
1:57:38There's a lot of corruption. There's a lot of lack of transparency with the way the government works or where your tax dollars go and all this kind of thing. And so I think one of the greatest narratives that we may well see in the coming age of Bitcoin is the potential of Bitcoin as a liberation technology, as a way for the individual, for the downtrodden and dispossessed, to reclaim their agency, their financial independence, their sovereignty, in a way, from these kind of failing and collapsing institutions.
1:58:18Vlad CosteaI actually agree. And while you're telling your story about Sweden and how they had their experiment with the cashless society, I actually have an experience from 2012 when I was there as an exchange student. And I remember that I had the money to pay my rent in cash because I would receive my scholarship on my credit card. Actually, it was a debit card, but anyway, I received my scholarship there and I would go to the ATM and withdraw the corresponding amount to pay my rent. And then I would go to the office and they would say, "Oh, we don't accept cash."
1:59:00And I would tell them, "So what do I do?" "Oh, you can go to Western Union or MoneyGram and tell them that you're trying to send to this account." And I went to, I have actually waited in line for 30 minutes at Western Union. And they told me when I got to the desk that not only I have to pay about 16 euro fee for the transaction, but also I am not eligible to make any kind of transaction just because I'm not a member of the Schengen area and the European Union. So my passport was not eligible to make use of any financial services that were provided by Western Union in Sweden.
1:59:46Wassim AlsindiSo you basically couldn't, you could barely transact in Sweden in the cashless paradigm.
1:59:50Vlad CosteaSo I had the money in my pocket. I showed it to them and I said, "You know, I'm trying to send this into that account. How difficult can this be?" No bank wanted my money unless I open an account. I was not eligible for that either because I was not a citizen. I did not have a proper residence because I was living in the student campus for only six months. So there was no way for me to pay my rent. And that's a harsh realization that you have when you get there and you realize that you have the money to pay for something and nobody wants your money, even though it's the local currency.
2:00:31It's not like you have some, you know, bolivar or petro or whatever bad currency that nobody really wants. And the solution that I used at the time was to ask a French friend, because France is part of the European Union. I just gave her the money and told her, "You know, you wait in line here. You explain to them that you want to send money to this account." So actually I've done it through Western Union. So that was the only way that I could do it.
2:01:06And then I had to repeat it every month and ask somebody who came from a country which is in the Schengen area of the European Union. And then tell them, "You know, if you have 30 minutes, you can really do me a big favor right now." I would ask them after class, "Can anyone actually help me pay my rent?" They were intrigued by the idea and it was ridiculous to them also, as there was no way for me to pay for my rent and I did not have that kind of online access to my bank account.
2:01:41That's the problem. That service at the time was, I guess, an extra five euro a month to be able to check your balance online and make payments from their online platform. I did not opt for that and there was no way for me to get that feature unless I traveled back to Romania. And that was expensive and I did not have time for that because I was attending classes on a daily basis.
2:02:12Wassim AlsindiYeah, so you start to see the kind of electronic payment systems as kind of a walled garden, like it's invitation access. And going back to the conversation I was having with a friend yesterday on Twitter, we were talking about Sweden and we were talking about people on the street. You know, the downtrodden, the dispossessed, vagrants, homeless people or sleeping rough, or however you want to look at it. Now, one of the kind of quite curious things in Sweden is the cashless society got so far that people that were asking for money on the streets of the big cities like Stockholm...
2:02:48I don't know where you were in Sweden, by the way, but let's say Stockholm, for example. People would have point-of-sale terminals as they were asking for money and begging for money on the street. They might be selling a magazine or they might be asking for donations. And my friend said, "That's just crazy," because, you know, they can be censored, they can be denied access. And that is true, but nobody carries coins and notes with them anymore. So you wouldn't get any donations if you were just asking for change.
2:03:16I mean, in the UK, we still have a cash society on some level. You can still pay with cash in most places. Some people like to, some people prefer the convenience of cards and what have you. And so if you see somebody on the street, they're asking for change, asking for coins, asking for cash. Whereas in Sweden, they want to swipe your credit card or they want to get a contactless payment from you. So I thought that was quite curious. But then also, you know, when you're on the street, you might fall into, you know, inverted commas, the wrong crowd, might get into, inverted commas, unsavory activities.
2:04:01And if that then comes back to... People on the street are much more likely to get arrested or have problems with the law. And then if you get denied your access to your electronic point of sale facility, then you're kind of in that situation that you're in, where you're on the outside looking in. But at least you had access to friends that, you know, at the university, presumably they had, you know... They weren't on the streets, you know, they were, you know, people with access to modern conveniences and the things that we take to be, you know, the trappings of civilized modern life, like a house and, you know, heating and food and all of that stuff.
2:04:44But if you don't have people that can help you get your money out of Romania and into Sweden, then you would be as stranded as some of these people on the street might be if they lost their access to their payment processors.
2:05:01Vlad CosteaI've had a similar experience in France two years later, when I went there for a scholarship, and I could not open a bank account because I did not have a proper residence, as I was living without a contract. And that's common with exchange students. You have to look for a place and the landlord just tells you that they don't want to sign a contract because they want to avoid taxes. And you have spent about two months looking for a decent place to live in, and that's the only one that you were able to find.
2:05:35And you're not going to argue against it. You're going to say, "OK, I don't care. I just give you the money. I'm going to stay here. Just don't evict me or anything."
2:05:44Wassim AlsindiSure.
2:05:45Vlad CosteaAnd when I went to a bank office, they told me that there is nothing that they can do to me. And I guess also the fact that I gave them my ID and they saw that I'm Romanian and I spoke to them in English. And they picked up the phone and they said in French, and I can actually understand French. I don't speak it very well, but... I understand what people say. And they said, "We have this Romanian citizen and he wants to open an account." And within 10 seconds, they just told me to go out because there is nothing that they can do for me.
2:06:23And 30 seconds before that, they almost appointed me for the next week to come and get my card. But if you don't have a credit card or a bank account in France, you don't benefit from many services. Like if you're a student, you cannot have a transportation card with discounts. You cannot buy certain items above a certain amount of money. So anything more expensive than, let's say, €3,000 cannot be bought unless you have a bank account. But it's not like I had that much money. I was actually paying 500 for my monthly rent and, you know, living off what I could buy on discount from supermarkets.
2:07:01But anyway, these experiences have made me appreciate something like Bitcoin, which is not only universal, but has the qualities that make it less Orwellian than fiat money, which can be controlled and centralized and censored and confiscated. It's terrible when you think about it. We are part of this system that, theoretically, we are financing it with our tax money and it works for us. But the more we look into it and we see its developments over time, we realize that actually it works against us. And it doesn't really do much for us in the long term.
2:07:45Yeah, I think, you know, at this point, at one moment in your life, you have to choose between becoming a high-ranking politician and trying to change the system according to your views, or doing some kind of grassroots politics in your community and trying to convince people that it's a good idea to move away from this financial system and maybe have some kind of reforms that you come up with. Or you can take care of yourself, and you take it upon yourself to handle everything, and it becomes a matter of agency and self-discovery and individuality and independence.
2:08:29You try to educate others into using the same kind of attitude, hoping that the government someday will turn towards you and try to negotiate their position and maybe bring a change. So it's either you join them trying to change something, or you express your individuality in ways that they cannot censor, and hope that at some point in the future they are going to maybe just listen to you and try to adapt their way of conducting affairs according to your expectations.
2:09:06Wassim AlsindiYeah, there's another lens you can look at this from, you know, your experiences and, you know, the hypothetical experiences we were talking about with people who are kind of on the outside. You can kind of think of, you know, cash facilitates an informal economy as well as a formal one. You know, you were paying your rent in cash because the landlord wanted cash for... You know, he was looking to do some informal business, you could say. And digital payments, credit cards, bank payments and so on, they don't really exist in an informal economy.
2:09:40You know, everything is very tightly observed, recorded and regulated. Whereas something like Bitcoin, being peer-to-peer, even though the ledger is open and it's public and everyone can see every transaction and so on, it does allow for an informal economy to be built around it, as well as a formal economy. I mean, we've all seen those guys in suits from institutions that talk about Bitcoin as the herald of a new asset class and how they're building financial products based on it and so on.
2:10:24So I also think there's another side of it as well, which you're also getting at, which is kind of the potential of Bitcoin as a kind of a guerrilla technology. Something that can tilt the balance of power back towards the individual or the small group, collective community, and perhaps leave a little bit less power for the larger institutions, the national governments or the state apparatuses and so on.
2:10:54And that's actually kind of the theme of the work that I've been doing with Matt B, is kind of looking at Bitcoin as a way to kind of opt out of let's say a political situation that you don't philosophically agree with, or how to have an alternative when the money of the territory that you inhabit is being debased by mismanagement or Cantillon effects, where people are printing money to line their own pockets and debasing everybody else's money. We spoke about hyperinflation in Romania and Iraq. That's kind of how those things go. The voracious appetite of the state printing press when too few hands are operating it with too little oversight.
2:11:45And so having this kind of, as you said... I really like Nic Carter's description of the assurances of Bitcoin, where he talks about, I can't remember the exact terms for all of them, but kind of like open entry, this kind of permissionless entry, anyone can participate in the network, the censorship resistance...
2:12:09The seizure resistance, the counterfeit resistance, and the free exit. And those are kind of the most important characteristics for people that live in places that aren't that free, where the government or some other powerful entity is making their lives worse, it's got too much power, and it's making decisions that don't have the best intentions for the people in mind. And I think that, you know, going back to that point of Bitcoin being a liberation technology, I think that it's gradually dawning on people. Maybe the bear market has some upsides, you know. Nobody likes to feel poor.
2:12:55But maybe the narrative of a couple of years ago of like, you know, Bitcoin is a get-rich-quick scheme or, you know, it's the hottest investment in history, that seems to have faded a little bit. Now, instead, people are talking about Bitcoin being a kind of a financial instantiation of free speech, or a code-based instantiation of free speech. And I think that's really important. And what we see now is more and more in the last, let's say, 12 or 18 months since I started thinking about this stuff with Matt, which is a kind of an open initiative called Reaching Everyone.
2:13:36More and more we're seeing now all kinds of different ways of communicating, of nodes communicating, of transactions being broadcast, of private keys being passed between each other. You know, think about the ones that we know about, like hardware wallets, and then Opendimes are kind of like a little cyberpunk version of a disposable hardware wallet, like a bearer asset. So you could make a transaction on a little USB key that has some additional security, and that transaction can say, "I'm going to buy your car, and the price is 0.1 Bitcoin." I put 0.1 Bitcoin on my Opendime.
2:14:12I hand the Opendime to you. Now you own it. You can verify what's on there. Now I own your car and you own that. To the blockchain, to all these chain analytics companies that are providing services to governments and what have you, nothing's changed on the network, but the possession of that digital bearer asset has changed. So there's all kinds of interesting things going on now. I don't know if you've been following the latest experiments with ham radio. So Rodolfo Novak, who runs Coinkite, who make Opendime, Coldcard...
2:14:44He started off a little bit of a trend with ham radio. So he broadcast a private key, salted private key, over ham radio, over public long-range radio. Nick Szabo and Elaine Ou were working on something with weak radio that could broadcast tens or hundreds of kilometers to go deep into censored areas. LoRa and LoRaWAN mesh networking devices, and can provide alternatives to people where the internet is being censored. So there's really like a huge proliferation of ingenious solutions going on right now.
2:15:25In my opinion, it's the most exciting thing in the Bitcoin space, this kind of, you know, mass expansion of the ways that people can transmit the information once they're on the network. Now, it doesn't quite take care of the on and the off ramps, you know, to get from your local currency or whatever you hold in your hands into Bitcoin.
2:15:49And that part, we still need to figure that one out. But I do pick up some lessons from these travels that I've had. So I remember, especially in rural India, you'll be on a bus, and you'll arrive in a place, little town or whatever it is, in the middle of nowhere. And the bus will pull up, or, you know, whatever, the van or the car or the rickshaw, and you'll be in a dusty square. There may be nothing there, maybe just some jungle and some mud, some dirt.
2:16:22But there's almost always somebody, usually a man, but somebody standing by a table selling GSM top-ups, mobile phone top-ups, like, you know, Vodafone scratch card kind of things. And so maybe that's the way that everybody gets on, like little kind of Bitcoin scratch cards, very low denomination ones. And then people can verify that the, you know, they could scan, there could be a QR code to scan the public key.
2:16:44You can verify that the voucher still contains the value that it says it does. And then you can redeem that to your wallet or you can leave it on the voucher. And then that's your way on to the network if you need to get onto the network, or it can be something that you hold as a piece of paper with your value on it, like kind of a paper wallet, I guess. But the big upside of that is that you don't need to know a huge amount about how the network works, how to manage your keys, how to run a node, how to update software, seed phrase, and all those other technical complexities that are non-trivial barriers to entry for people.
2:17:27And, you know, some people may not have the infrastructure. They may not have internet in their village. They may not have GSM. The government may have switched it off. They may not even have electricity. And so I think one of the ways that Bitcoin is going to survive the challenges that are placed in front of it by whoever the adversaries of the present and the future might be, is by having this diversity of mechanisms to conduct the transactions, to move data around, private keys or signed transaction data or pieces of paper which act as kind of proxy bearer assets or simple devices.
2:18:11Radio transmitting gear. I think that's extremely important. And for me, that's the most mind-blowing thing that I can see that's going on in Bitcoin space right now.
2:18:27Vlad CosteaI think I have one last question, and this deals with... Yeah, we have been talking for over two hours, and I'm not sure if anyone will be listening to all this. But I would be glad to know this, and if you have been listening to this, just send us a message on Twitter or something and say, "Hey, I'm one of the ones who have so much time on their hands that I listened during my trip from one country to the other or something, I've listened to three hours of podcast."
2:18:59But I want to ask you if you believe that we are underestimating the power of governments and if you think that up to this point, it has been the honeymoon of Bitcoin, as we never really had this kind of big attack from governments other than the propaganda of it being a scam and being a Ponzi scheme and being something that collapses and trying to deter people from actually putting any money in it. We never had any kind of hash wars in the sense that they try to overtake the network, create double spending or... As far as I know, maybe there are some people who tried to create, or maybe...
2:19:49You know, argue for an increased block size or argue for greater miner incentives, which translates in increasing the supply, so actually devaluing the existing supply. Maybe these people are government agents and they are trying to destabilize from the inside and send their people to become influential and then talk about all this nonsense, which has nothing to do with the vision of Bitcoin and only deals with this small aspect like fees and the size of blocks and validation times and all the inefficiencies that the original design has. But has for a very good reason that avoids issues. So let's get back to the original point: do you think that we are underestimating governments?
2:20:45Wassim AlsindiOkay, so let me signpost this, because I was in a conference in London a couple of weeks ago called Advancing Bitcoin. And before it, there was a developer meetup a couple of days before. And Eric Voskuil, who's the lead maintainer of libbitcoin, which is one of the client implementations of Bitcoin, alternative to Bitcoin Core, he gave a talk which he calls Principles of Cryptodynamics. You can find it on YouTube. He also gave a similar talk at Scaling Bitcoin in Tokyo recently, and he goes into a lot of these things where he talks about Bitcoin being in a honeymoon phase now, where it's too small.
2:21:22The government won't, like a big government won't really care. It's not going to wreck a national financial system, it's not that big. And he makes this point that, you know, if it doesn't get much more well resourced than our adversary, than a government with a printing press that has a money that has a significant liquidity...
2:21:47I saw actually a graph today on Twitter, which was a comparison of the security spend of Bitcoin, the amount of money it costs to deploy the hash rate that secures the network, versus the budget of the US military. It was log scale, and there's a very big difference between these two things. So, you know, if the US military turned around tomorrow and said, "Oh, actually Russia's our friend now, Iran's our friend now, Venezuela's our friend now. Our biggest enemy is Bitcoin," then they could snap this thing in two very easily, assuming that they could marshal the kind of supply chain logistics together to gather the materials to make or buy the ASICs, to run them, to censor transactions. They could break the fungibility of Bitcoin by only mining transactions that they wanted to mine.
2:22:49So you can imagine kind of black UTXOs and white UTXOs. KYC coins that came off Coinbase, they might let them get transacted because they know the chain of custody of those. But then some 2010 UTXOs from some dark web market or something like that, they might not like those to transact.
2:23:10So there are potential attacks there. I think those are probably in Bitcoin's future, which is why I think the resilience and the breadth of transaction media and the improvement of the fungibility and various aspects of transactional and address level privacy are really important for the long term prospect of the network. There are, you know, you made the point about forks. You know, maybe the forks are social attacks, maybe the, you know, kind of government-sponsored attacks.
2:23:43Maybe the kind of conflicting narratives and the design choices that people put forward: bigger blocks, smaller blocks, change the block time, change the supply. Maybe they're social attacks as well. I mean, maybe they're social attacks by commercial entities, maybe they're social attacks by government entities, maybe they're not social, maybe they're social attacks by individuals, well-resourced individuals, and maybe they're not. I guess in the fullness of time, we'll start to see those things. It's funny that you bring this topic up because I'll be speaking at a few conferences over the course of this year.
2:24:20And this is kind of the topic. You know, the topic is sort of "Why Bitcoin's Resilience Matters" or "Could a Government Break Bitcoin?" So I'll be unpacking a lot of those things. I don't want to say too much now because I don't want to give out all of my thoughts and secrets before I've put the talks together. But yes, it's very interesting. I suppose it's a hypothetical at the moment. It's a very interesting, you know, intellectual pathway to explore. And as Eric Voskuil says in those talks, I really recommend everybody to watch them.
2:24:57I don't see 100% eye to eye with Eric, but I think most of what he's saying is very hard to disagree with, that Bitcoin is just too small for a nation state to really care about. But if it got to the point where Bitcoin was, say that, you know, we have a global financial downturn, interest rates go to minus five, minus ten, they do this e-money thing, ban cash, and then, you know, your only opportunity to engage in an informal economy or peer-to-peer economy, or an only way to escape the kind of demurrage or the, you know, the savings tax, I guess you could call it, on holding your money at the bank would be to use Bitcoin. Then bet your bottom dollar that people are going to start seeing it as a threat.
2:25:48Because if Bitcoin is the best money around, and the other money is getting worse and worse, then more and more people are going to get interested in it. If governments start to ban Bitcoin, like really ban it, not like what we've had before where pressure gets exerted on exchanges, onerous regulatory and compliance regimes, I mean really ban this stuff. Like a few places have really banned it, but not that many. But if governments start to go down that road, I mean, there's a saying in China, I won't remember it literally, but...
2:26:19It's basically that if the government bans something, it's because it's really good. So as soon as the government bans something in China, everybody starts paying attention to it. So I imagine that may have already happened in China when there was all the pressure on... I believe the ICOs were basically kind of extinguished. I don't know the exact mechanism. And a lot of exchanges had pressure placed on them, presumably to beef up KYC, so there wasn't any funny business, people underreporting gains and things like that.
2:26:49But if, you know, imagine that a government tries to actually ban Bitcoin. I believe, if I'm remembering, I believe the Central Bank of Algeria banned Bitcoin last year, or 2017. Now, you know, I'm not a citizen of Algeria. I've never visited Algeria. I guess the government and the Central Bank of Algeria have some legitimacy within that territory. But say, for example, that you're Algerian and I'm Algerian, and you're in Algiers and I'm in Paris, and we have a one of two multi-signature wallet with...
2:27:32X number of bitcoins in it. Who owns that? And, you know, when it gets transacted with, who's doing the transaction? So there's also this kind of mismatch between the way that kind of traditional legal structures and legislative constructions are built up, and the way that Bitcoin acts as this kind of radically decentralized, borderless technology. So it's going to be interesting to see. The other thing to say is that fiat currencies have a limited lifetime. No fiat currency has lasted forever. The British pound, I believe, is one of the record holders, if not the record holder.
2:28:21And it has definitely seen better days. So here's a little diversion for you before we finish. Pound sterling, the name comes from, like literally it used to mean, it was exchangeable for one pound, which was 454 grams in imperial measurements, of sterling silver, which was 92.5% purity silver. Now, if you go and look up the price of 454 grams of 92.5% purity silver now, it's a lot more than one pound. So the pound has lost over 99% of its purchasing power against silver.
2:28:56And silver is one of the most hated, poorest performing commodity assets on the planet right now. So sooner or later, the fiat currencies will struggle. Governments will have hard times. They'll put pressure on the monetary issuing authorities, the treasuries, central banks, to print more. Or there'll be this kind of, you know, electronic money, negative interest rate, rehypothecation, quantitative easing, chicanery. And Bitcoin as the, you know... What's that saying? You know, you can be the prettiest mare in the slaughterhouse or something like that.
2:29:42Bitcoin may not be perfect. There's lots of problems with Bitcoin, lots of limitations, lots of inefficiencies, lots of frustrating things and design choices which are pretty much locked in now by the intersubjective consensus between the network stakeholders. But I don't know if we're going to get a better shot at something that provides a genuine alternative to the perpetual mismanagement of state money. I really don't know if we're going to get that.
2:30:16Vlad CosteaI also think I want to ask you something more, and maybe this will be the closing thought that we are going to be having. In regards to foreign policy and how Bitcoin, despite being the place where, ideologically at least, Bitcoin... I'm sorry. So despite being ideologically the place where Bitcoin started, the United States doesn't really, in terms of foreign policy, doesn't really believe in the values of Bitcoin. And you can see how it's being used in Venezuela, which is under financial embargo by the United States.
2:30:56And it's being used in Palestine, for example, which I guess the United States does not want to support or acknowledge due to their partnership with Israel. And there are all sorts of places around the planet that use this stateless and immutable currency that nobody can do anything about. And if you look at it in geopolitical terms, you can actually deduct that it works much more in the interest of Russia than it does in the interest of China or the United States. And this is just the mindset of being stuck in the world of superpowers.
2:31:31Wassim AlsindiSo, actually, I wanted to pick your brains on Russia, because you're in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet bloc, so you have probably a bit more insight than I do. I've always been pretty fascinated by Russia. I watch Russian TV quite a lot. I don't know if you know about this.
2:31:53English, Spanish, Arabic language channel, French language channel, RT, Russia Today. I watch an awful lot of stuff on there. They've got like Max Keiser, who was one of the earliest public advocates of Bitcoin. He was shouting about Bitcoin on there since 2011, I think, something like that. And there was this story recently, I don't know if it was really verified, that people were saying that Russia, the state or the central bank or whoever, you know, the part of the government was going to start buying Bitcoin, was going to start accumulating Bitcoin as a strategic asset.
2:32:27And that's one of the kind of alternate pathways, alternate kind of, you know, timelines of Bitcoin, I suppose. Maybe it doesn't ever develop into a good money. Maybe it doesn't solve those privacy and fungibility issues. Maybe it doesn't make it as a money.
2:32:49But it may end up being the premier digital commodity, the, you know, the uncensorable, unseizable digital gold of the 21st century. And the other thing to say is we talked about the government before as if it's some kind of monolithic entity. If I was to have one criticism of the Bitcoin space as a whole, it's that everything is very America-centric. I mean, really America-centric, to the point where you listen to a conversation, it could be in a conference or a podcast or YouTube or whatever, and people just talk about the government.
2:33:17They may not even be Americans, but they're usually talking about the American government. And there's a funny, just a slight segue, which I've noticed as a Brit, I've noticed on American TV: when they talk about royal families, the monarchs of different countries, they'll say the King of Spain, Queen of the Netherlands, Prince of Denmark. But when it comes to the Queen of Britain, they just call her the Queen. So maybe it's all kind of tied up. The point I wanted to make was that nation states aren't some kind of contiguous mass that all have the same opinions and ideologies.
2:33:54We know this. We can see this in the geopolitics that plays out every day in the world. I wonder now if we're going to start to see nation states, some will come around to the merits of Bitcoin, whether they see it as a money or a commodity or whatever else they see it as. I begin to wonder now if we start to see some countries kind of break rank. A bit like Malta's done with the rest of the EU, which I thought was quite interesting. I mean, you know, you'd think that they would be a little bit constrained because of this political and economic union.
2:34:32I wonder if we're going to start to see some interesting geopolitical plays around Bitcoin, maybe around the, you know, there'll be another bull market in X number of years. And as part of that, we'll start to see some nation states start to pound the table or talk up their bags, however you want to think about it. And, you know, as you said, if America is going to have this, the government of America is going to have this hostile perspective towards Bitcoin, then that kind of opens up a counterpoint, a little bit of an opportunity for, you know, for the bloc of nations, which is not favored by the Western consensus or the Anglo-Atlantic consensus.
2:35:20Whatever you want to call it, the Atlantic consensus, I guess you could say. You know, the Russias, the Chinas, the Irans, Venezuelas, then maybe there's something there for them. You know, if everyone is going to get excluded from SWIFT, from the international banking and payment clearing system, as a kind of, that's being used as a weapon to financially censor nations. So Russia's built their own alternative system to SWIFT. And, you know, somebody like a country like Iran, which may well have been, you know, kicked out of SWIFT already, I'm actually sure, or a country like Venezuela, once they go under embargo or sanctions or what have you.
2:36:03Then maybe these parallel systems, you know, Russia's payment scheme or even a Bitcoin-denominated scheme, that might be something that you start to see. And this is just speculation about possible futures here. Remember what we said earlier about Bitcoin being a Rorschach test: different people and different entities that come from different perspectives will see different things in the potential and the possible futures of Bitcoin. And I think that may surprise some people when we see some very powerful, could be governments, could be corporations, could be wealthy individuals, start to use Bitcoin or leverage Bitcoin or take advantage of the features and the characteristics of Bitcoin in unexpected ways. So I'm really looking forward to seeing that.
2:36:59Vlad CosteaYeah, me too. That's part of the thrill in this ride. Maybe that sometimes we get distracted by price action or we look at, you know, conflicts that go on every day on crypto Twitter, how people change their opinions and how they come up with new ideas and how we see a change of narrative in terms of what we see in different projects and how they are presented to the average consumer. But at the end of the day, if we think about the grander scheme, and we think about what it's going to be like in 10 years from now. Like, for example, you look at CoinMarketCap, which we both agree that is a bad metric and maybe a toxic actor in this environment, but it's useful.
2:37:50Wassim AlsindiNot only that, but I think the metric of market cap is also, you know, not very useful.
2:38:00Vlad CosteaBut nevertheless, you look at CoinMarketCap and you have this historic view to see which assets existed five years ago or when the website was launched. And you're going to see Peercoin, you're going to see Namecoin, you're going to see Mastercoin and all these projects which no longer have support or have been abandoned for a long time. And I believe that five years from now, we're going to see many projects like, I don't want to speculate on names, but maybe something like NEM, maybe something like NEO, and EOS and all these projects which have a lot of money, have raised a lot of money from ICOs and sustain themselves at the top.
2:38:47According to how much they own right now. And they try to attract many more investors to their marketing campaigns. But their approach is not really sustainable and they don't provide anything of value at the end of the day. So I guess they're going to disappear and we're going to see maybe a new wave of entrants in this space, or maybe we are going to see a greater agreement that we have like three or five legitimate projects which actually have a viable long-term plan.
2:39:25Wassim AlsindiThere will always be more. There will always be more, just because of entropy. The incentives exist. People will create new projects. It's so easy to issue tokens. It's easy to fork a network and fork the UTXO set, airdrop those tokens. I just don't see it. There may be consolidation, like the most important networks become more important, but there will always be. I think it's just going to be more and more. It's just entropy. There's a small number of more ordered states, orderly states, and there's a larger number of disorderly states. And by the way, you mentioned them. They're not that well capitalized anymore. There was a news story not so long ago that their foundation has run out of money.
2:40:09So I guess that's the problem when you rely on these kind of centralized command and control structures that, you know, you require money for marketing, to pay for conferences, to go and pump the price, to get people excited about your thing. And maybe that's the feature, and one of the greatest features of Bitcoin is there is no marketing team. There is no, I mean, there is a foundation or two, but they're not real. It's not intrinsic to the network. There's no leader. There's no, you know, there's none of those kind of endogenous central points, single points of failure, you could say.
2:40:51Vlad CosteaAnyway, in regards to my statement before this, I was about to conclude that no matter which projects go away and which ones get created along the way, we are always going to have Bitcoin. And that's why this podcast is called The Bitcoin Takeover. I'm certain that in spite of all the market dynamics, we will always have Bitcoin. And the survival of this whole, what they call nowadays, blockchain industry relies on the success and sustainability of Bitcoin. And as long as it's still there, it's still functional.
2:41:27Other projects and other people who speculate on this success are going to create much more and establish this framework through which they make money. But it's essential. Even in the case, I had this argument with a coworker from Crypto Insider, who is much more on the side of permissioned blockchains and how blockchains can be used in fintech and in various industries around the world. And he told me, "You know, it's not all about Bitcoin."
2:41:56And I asked him, "How are you going to market a blockchain to a business unless you point out to the original use of the blockchain and say, 'This is what they use in Bitcoin'?" And when you stop doing this, and if Bitcoin fails tomorrow, you're not going to have the same kind of enthusiasm from businesses which embrace blockchain. You're going to say, "Oh, it's flawed. Why should I use this? It was proved to not be viable. It had these issues or these loopholes that people did not see for a long time and they were discovered yesterday or last week. And look, it doesn't function.
2:42:37I don't want to deal with this." But as long as Bitcoin exists and is successful, then there is a lot of room for lots of side projects to be created and be experimented with.
2:42:51Wassim AlsindiYeah, I guess, but then, you know, the counterpoint to that, I totally agree with you, but the counterpoint is that people always try to make analogies with what's come before. So there was the concept of the information superhighway in the '90s versus the internet, the closed information superhighway, the corporate intranets, versus the open internet.
2:43:18Then, before that, there was the VHS and Betamax, which was the videotape protocol war, you could say. And then there were the protocol wars around the standards of the internet from the '70s onwards. So maybe you'll see this thing where people will say, "Oh, but Bitcoin was blockchain 1.0, it was Betamax, and our blockchain is blockchain 6.7, it's DVD-R or Blu-ray or whatever you want to call it." So I just think that we're always going to see people try to develop mutated strains along the lines of the Bitcoin blueprint. You know, borrowing sometimes more, sometimes less of the characteristics of the, you know, kind of elements of the Bitcoin protocol on the network.
2:44:04And even if, like, you know, I don't even like to talk about it, but even if Bitcoin fails, even if there's catastrophic technical error, and if the cryptography breaks on the elliptic signature scheme, or there's an inflation bug, or, you know, something terrible happens, then there's the prospect that a mutated strain, like, you know, a fork from an earlier block, which changes, you know, the path to a different timeline from a common history, that may be a way for the Bitcoin network to continue on. I know that sounds almost like heresy in the present day, but we've got to...
2:44:51We've got to bear in mind that Bitcoin is still a grand experiment. We're 10 years into a grand experiment and nothing is certain. Success is not guaranteed. I mean, we're all willing and hoping and working for Bitcoin to succeed. That's extremely important, I think, not just for us in the Bitcoin world, you know, that are interested in cryptocurrencies or what have you, or the kind of techno-libertarian utopian fantasy or whatever you want to say. I think it's genuinely important for humanity that we can return to this sort of sense of an asset that you own that's not another counterparty's liability, that it's not some kind of financial Rube Goldberg machine that's built upon promises to others and obligations that come due.
2:45:48I think that's really important for the whole planet.
2:45:54Vlad CosteaI agree. And tell me, how can you be contacted on Twitter, as you shared all these interesting insights? And maybe that people will want to call you and invite you to conferences. And how can they do that?
2:46:09Wassim AlsindiSure. So, yeah, I spend all day every day on Twitter. And so my thing is called Parallel Industries. So the first 11 letters, I think, are ParallelInd. That's the handle on Twitter, and I've got a website which is pllel.com, nice and short. And I pretty much put everything through Twitter. You know, if it goes on my website or it goes on Hacker Noon or some other outlet in the mesh, things usually go to Twitter first. So I mean, if you're interested in Bitcoin and you're not on Twitter, what are you doing with your life?
2:46:43Vlad CosteaSo if they don't have Twitter, how can they contact you? Do you use email?
2:46:48Wassim AlsindiSure. Yeah, I mean, I have the same handle on Telegram as well. They can contact me there. I've got an email address. So if you go to the website, pllel.com, then you can find an email address to contact me there.
2:47:21And yeah, I'm pretty easy to find. My name is Wassim Alsindi. There's only one person with that name. I think I'm the only Wassim that's really doing anything in Bitcoin as well. And maybe you want to look up some of my projects. The names of those are Forkonomy, like astronomy but with fork. I have a project that's called Reaching Everyone. I have a project that's called Token Space. I have another project called DAOs and Dots, which we didn't talk about today. But yeah, those are all things that I'm outputting material and giving talks about and stuff like that. And the last thing, if you don't mind me plugging it, we're a kind of non-profit organization that's subsisting on donations.
2:47:47So if anybody's interested in helping us expand what we do and push things forward, that would be really helpful, so feel free to get in touch.
2:47:57Vlad CosteaOkay, thank you very much. And this was very lengthy and consistent. And people are going to find a lot of information to dig into. And maybe they're going to have a big revelation with the time machine theory about forks being parallel universes that we explore at this moment in time.
2:48:19Wassim AlsindiAnd yeah, I mean, I congratulate people for getting to the end, I'd say.
2:48:25Vlad CosteaAnd there's a lot, and I hope this second season is going to be much more successful than the first one, but that's a lot of wishful thinking. Anyway, I thank you very much for your time. And I know that you work on a lot of projects, and it means a lot when you get to talk to somebody as busy as you are for three hours. That's something impressive.
2:48:49Wassim AlsindiOh, it's a pleasure. It's nice to unpack these concepts and ideas in detail. And also, you're a very thoughtful person. So that's what I got from the first series. So it's just very nice to be able to get into the weeds, into the nitty-gritty, and not be so worried about, you know, hitting all the major talking points of the day or whatever.
2:49:11Vlad CosteaOh, sure. I hate watching the news and commenting on it because I know that tomorrow it's not going to be as relevant. It just passes. It's so consumable and easy to digest that it doesn't really leave you with the kind of intellectual input that makes you richer. I don't think people who read the news every day get too much out of it. It's much more useful to understand how the history of our societies and species actually went, and then you're going to see patterns and you're going to understand common events and news in a different way. And you're not going to be as interested, maybe not on a daily basis, as interested in following who said what and what they announced and stuff like that.
2:50:05You're going to have a larger perspective on society and on your life as a whole. There's a point where we appreciate our time in this world to a greater extent and quantify it in terms of how much can I do and how great can that activity of mine be in this limited amount of time that I have.
2:50:31Wassim AlsindiOne thing I'll say about the news is, like, occasionally I'll pick up the newspaper, sometimes I'll watch the news on TV, and the news is an interesting tool for understanding what other people are hearing and listening and reading about. But I don't see much more in it than that, really.
2:50:50Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess we're both the kind of isolated people. Like to work with their own projects and play with their toys and maybe it's hard for the outside world to understand sometimes, but it's good that we have this kind of platform to get our ideas out. And part of the reason why I do the podcast is because on a daily basis, I have nobody to talk to about these topics. So it's useful for me to get out some ideas, to test them with people who may or may not agree or may criticize me.
2:51:23I put myself out there. And I'm open to criticism, but that's part of growing. And there is no way to actually evolve unless you take these risks, which are not even vital. It's not like I'm threatening my own life by saying something which might prove to be either stupid or unpopular.
2:51:45Wassim AlsindiIf you spend your life in the shadow, you know, being scared of your own shadow, being worried that other people are going to think you're an idiot because you think this and you said that and you act this way, I mean, it doesn't seem like much of a way to live. I'd rather be the stupidest person in the room than the person that everybody thinks is the smartest.
2:52:08I've been the stupidest person in quite a few Bitcoin conferences, especially early on in my adventures when I was going to my first few technical conferences. It was great. I really enjoyed it just because all you can do is learn. Every interaction you have with somebody, you'll be learning something. Every talk you'll learn something from. So, you know, if we're going to sign off with a kind of positive message, I'd just say to people, be curious, open your minds to different ideas and don't be afraid of what other people are going to think if you say this or you have this line of thought. Just explore them all. Life is an experiment as well.
2:52:47Vlad CosteaSure, and that's a very positive thought to end this. So thank you very much once again, Wassim. Did I pronounce that well? Wassim?
2:52:56Wassim AlsindiYeah, close enough. Close enough. Thanks for your time as well, Vlad. I really appreciate it. And I think that you're going to have a good second season. I'm sure that once the first season has been disseminated, people will find it. You know how the internet works. It's this gigantic repository. People will find it. People will share it. People will talk about it. And so from there, you plant the seed and from there, the flower blooms.
2:53:22Vlad CosteaYeah, sure, and the topics are not, you know, news to be consumed within a week and then they become irrelevant. I guess this kind of stuff can be discussed five years from now. And we might stumble upon the same problems and the same issues. And I hope that people who will be adopting Bitcoin in the future will find this and say, you know, these people back in 2019 were not much different and did not have different issues from what we're having right now.
2:53:52And that's something that I like to think about when I do this podcast, that we discuss matters which will not get solved tomorrow or within a week. Maybe there are small bits that are unimportant in the larger scheme. The main ideas will still be there and people will still be asking what Bitcoin does to world politics and which big power of the few that we have right now actually benefits most from these interactions and the usefulness of forks and how altcoins can actually be viewed as research projects and experiments for different models of governance.
2:54:39Wassim AlsindiYeah, at the very least, time will give us more information, more data, more experiments. And then, you know, events will unfold and play out. So many of the things we've spoken about, we've been speculating quite openly about, you know, possible futures of various things. So, you know, if somebody finds this in five years' time, maybe they'll treat it like a time capsule. I don't know if you used to do this when you were young; when I was at school, we used to bury things in the field for people from the future to find. So maybe these podcasts will be a bit like that, a kind of a simulacrum, a digital abstraction of a time capsule.
2:55:23Vlad CosteaI like to think that too. But that's a bit optimistic, but let's hope that.
2:55:30Wassim AlsindiIf you can't be optimistic, then what can you be?
2:55:35Vlad CosteaAnalytical? Realistic? So maybe we're Bitcoin realists. I don't know. I don't want to define myself because I hate these labels. And you can say, "Oh, you're a contrarian," but I can be a contrarian to a contrarian. So I don't know. I try to avoid labels on it.
2:55:56Wassim AlsindiI think Bitcoiner is my favorite term because what does it mean? It's just a person of Bitcoin. There's no kind of identity attached to that.
2:56:08Vlad CosteaYeah, a lot of people try to call themselves maximalists or whatever. They try to invent these terms to distance themselves from other people and give themselves or try to adhere to certain values. But I find that stupid because at the end of the day, there is just 1% of arguments on which they do not agree. And they should not try to create small tribes according to that 1%. And there are different interpretations on it. But whatever. We're just human.
2:56:46Wassim AlsindiThat's what humans do. I mean, you know, Bitcoin doesn't care. Doesn't care about your political ideology. Doesn't care about which currency you've got in your pocket. Doesn't care about which country or city or which car you drive. Bitcoin is Bitcoin.
2:57:04Vlad CosteaYeah, and it will be here for a long time for us to observe. That's the thing which gets me excited.
2:57:11Wassim AlsindiYeah, so I can't wait to watch, just to keep watching and to keep participating and keep discussing.
2:57:20Vlad CosteaThank you very much. And I look forward to seeing you in a conference in Romania, maybe.
2:57:26Wassim AlsindiYes, and there is apparently one coming up later in the year, and there should be some news to share about that quite soon.
2:57:33Vlad CosteaI hope I get to attend it.
2:57:36Wassim AlsindiYeah, I look forward to seeing you there then, Vlad.
2:57:38Vlad CosteaOkay, so we'll talk until then. It's not like until whenever that conference takes place, we're not going to interact. But whenever this season gets out, I'm going to send out to you a link. And as you know, I have this model if anybody wants to donate any BTC. And by the way, that's the only type of currency that I will be accepting for this podcast. I don't want to start a Patreon. I thought about it, but really that defeats the purpose. The Bitcoin Takeover is Bitcoin only, and if anyone donates anything, 50% of the donation is going to get to the guest or a charity of their choice. That's the model here.
2:58:22Wassim AlsindiGreat. Well, I would probably put it towards Reaching Everyone, this project where we're trying to develop strategies, mitigations and tools for the dispossessed.
2:58:33Vlad CosteaSounds interesting, but that's your affair. It's like I give you 50% and I don't care what you do with it after that. That's the point.
2:58:43Wassim AlsindiYeah, sure. Well, that's where it's going. I mean, the most interesting thing we've been looking at recently, probably we'll do some hackathons in this over the summer, is sending data over sound waves. That's my newest fascination. So I'd probably put it into doing a little bit more work on that.
2:59:01Vlad CosteaOkay, Mr. Polymath.
2:59:04Wassim AlsindiOr Renaissance man. Yeah, Dr. Polymath actually.
2:59:13Vlad CosteaOkay. Very irreverential.
2:59:16Wassim AlsindiI'm joking. All right. Thank you very much for your time, Vlad. I really appreciate the conversation. It was super interesting.
2:59:23Vlad CosteaLikewise. Talk to you later. Bye.
2:59:23================================================================================ Production notes: Remote audio/video call in English between Vlad in Romania and Wassim (UK-based), conducted as a long unedited conversation of nearly three hours with no sponsor reads; Vlad briefly turned off his microphone mid-episode. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 12 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (239 chunks) and 66 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 5 of 5 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed "Thanks for watching" and "As a Time Machine" hallucinations; restored dropped speech (end of Wassim's 00:01:38 turn, decentralized arts sentence, "Check this out", "of course, we all have different lives"); fixed unfriendly→friendly, station we covered→stationery cupboard, conventions→inventions, Algen/using your phones→like earphones, Sumi→Sunni, hype ranking→high-ranking, the round→with Iran; split speaker turns ("Sounds good", "And individuality"); Removed "As a Time Machine" hallucinations (00:18:05, 00:18:52, 00:22:53, 00:30:52, 00:32:04) and "Thanks for watching!"; restored dropped speech from second ASR/Scribe ("land was confiscated...", "exchanged their money for dollars", "land and assets", Parallel Industries sentence); fixed Yalta/USSR, Arch of Triumph in miniature, rădăcini sănătoase, leu, Ceaușescu, "further move towards", "Before my decade", Gigabyte, card-carrying, photophysics; split interjections (Oh, Sure, "who am I", Leu) and Separation-of-powers boundary; removed stutters; Removed "As a Time Machine" and other hallucinations (00:33:37, 00:35:43, 00:36:15, 00:41:01, 00:42:19, "Amen") and restored the dropped speech from the second ASR and audio re-check. Fixed Forkonomy, Hertzsprung-Russell, stellar taxonomy, ZenCash, Coin Metrics, Nic Carter/Antoine Le Calvez, halves, parse, sleuthing and Bitcoin Private. Relabelled same-speaker turns as Wassim Alsindi, and split 00:38:32 at an interpolated 00:39:00; Removed "As a Time Machine" hallucinations (00:55:15, 00:55:31, 00:58:17), "Bye.", "As always"; restored dropped speech (00:54:51-00:55:36, Davos sentence, CoinMarketCap sentence) from Scribe/Qwen; split Vlad's "No, I've seen it. It's a cult classic." out of Wassim's turn; fixed Bitcoin Private, pre-mines, Svengali-esque, BSV/BTCP, OneCoin, Ruja Ignatova, masternode DAOs, Bitcoiners, "fool me once", wisp, valid, miners, amasses; Removed "As a Time Machine" hallucinations (01:02:34, 01:04:45, 01:16:35) and restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (50/100/200 times, PDF graphics, halving diagram, west coast/Scandinavia, "built the, you know"); fixed speaker split at 01:03:13 ("Yeah," moved to Vlad) and 01:05:55/01:06:14 ("Sure" to Wassim); PonziCoin/Ponzi scheme, FOMO3D, Nick Gogerty, Forkonomy, lei, coinbase, Bitcoin Private, "writes itself", "literarily", "transactome"; Removed many "As a Time Machine" hallucinations, fake ad/podcast lines ("platform to invest", "Best Bitcoin in the World", "See you soon. Bye.") and restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (North Africa list, Prague/Institute of Crypto-Anarchy, Malta, BitPay, BTC Black Cab, taxes/basket passage, financial authorities). Fixed Hodl Hodl, Baltic Honeybadger, ScotCoin, Azte.co, Globee, M-Pesa, Lonely Planet, "tax/cede". Speaker repairs: Wassim interjections at 01:27:25 and 01:31:04 split out; Wassim's 01:28:52 turn starts at "Obviously" moved from Vlad's paragraph; Speaker fixes: 01:32:35–01:34:28 attributed to Wassim; split Wassim's "Oh, absolutely" in