Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S2 E4 / Transcript
Transcript · S2 E4 · 2:01:04 · 29 Jun 2019

S2 E4: Rajarshi Maitra on Bitcoin in India and the Cult status of BTC communities

With Rajarshi Maitra. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:29Vlad CosteaHello and welcome to the Bitcoin Takeover. I am Vlad and my guest today is Raj, who is also known as RajarshiMaitra on Twitter. And he is a prominent Indian Bitcoiner. And he likes to tell me that there aren't a lot of Bitcoiners in India. And he is part of that very small community, which he has formed and he has become a part of. So it's very fascinating to know more about the second most populous country in the world and how it actually goes with these innovations and the way we perceive money and the way we transact. So, hello, Raj.

1:29Rajarshi MaitraHey, Vlad. Thanks for having me.

1:31Vlad CosteaIt's good to have you, and I'm happy that you told me that you want to join this podcast after you have listened. I think it was the John Carvalho podcast that you listened to?

1:44Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah, right. I have listened to all of your podcasts. So that was the podcast that Ravi posted in Twitter. And I was just suggesting people to listen to you because there seems to be a lot of great content, but not enough viewership. So I thought like this is a very important work that you are doing. There are interesting conversations that are coming out of it. And I'm just trying to promote it as much as I can in small little communities I have.

2:12Vlad CosteaI'm very grateful for that, by the way. And I'm happy that you're here.

2:16Rajarshi MaitraAnd yeah, thanks for having me. This is my first podcast and thanks for giving me this opportunity to talk Bitcoin. It's always fascinating to talk Bitcoin with other people.

2:28Vlad CosteaYeah, sure. I guess that's why I'm doing this. And I like giving the chance to speak to people who otherwise wouldn't get this opportunity. Because, you know, this is a very large community in Bitcoin and there are lots of people with different backgrounds doing lots of interesting stuff. And usually if you look at Bitcoin podcasts, you're going to see that the shows tend to have the same guests and you're going to have this situation where you end up listening to a different podcast but the same person saying basically the same stuff, promoting their company, and...

3:07Rajarshi MaitraYeah, true. That happens. That happens a lot.

3:10Vlad CosteaJust being in PR mode in various places. So to me, it's very interesting to interact with people who have a different background, who maybe haven't spoken in other podcasts, and at the same time have something very interesting to say. And my curiosity in regards to you and what you do is: how did you get into Bitcoin and why? What was maybe... what drove you to it? Was there like an ideological predisposition or some kind of personal values that made you think that this is what you're looking for? Or was it just pure curiosity which took you down the rabbit hole and made you appropriate certain ideological components?

4:02Rajarshi MaitraOkay, yeah, I understand what the question is and yeah, it's a very interesting journey that I had. So there are lots of parts to it. So what happened is I stumbled upon Bitcoin on October 2017, kind of like in an accident way. So if you remember, that was the time when the market was going into this boom, the 2017 cycle, and Bitcoin was all over the news and I happened to have some extra money in my hand, so I thought like, okay, why not just put it and see what happens? And then I went up and I thought the first thing that I did was some kind of crypto index fund. So I have plowed my way through all the shit that there is. So the first thing that I noticed was this: the thing that popped out was this address.

4:51Okay, this weird random long address. And I was like, okay, that's weird. I haven't seen these things before. So what is this thing? And so that's when I started to go deeper. But the story goes a little back because, well, I was doing my master's in structural engineering. I was quite fed up with the way academics work. I was like fed up with the culture of academia, and I was totally frustrated that there is so much lack of curiosity happening in this academic field that I just wanted to leave it.

5:22But instead of leaving it, what I did is like, okay, if I'm not being able to study what I want to study, so why not study on my own? So at that point on 2016, I started studying the most difficult subject that I could find, that was theoretical physics. So I started studying theoretical physics and I did that for two years and that was a fascinating journey. And then I stumbled upon Bitcoin. So by that time I stumbled upon Bitcoin, I already had this curiosity drive to understand complex things.

5:54And when I saw this thing called crypto or Bitcoin, I didn't understood what's the difference between them back then, and it seemed that it's pretty complex thing, and I thought, okay, I am done with physics, let's just dive into another field and see what happens. And when I started diving deep into it, something very fascinating occurred to me, and which goes back into another period of my time when I was in my bachelor's.

6:18So here I think it's a very interesting story. When I was in my bachelor's, I was in a university which was very much politically active, in the sense that we organized rallies, we organized all these sorts of meetings, we organized all these sorts of political discussions, debates, and cultures that were very predominant in this sphere of academia.

6:44And the curious thing is I am placed in the western province of India called West Bengal, and this place, this particular geography, has been dominated by communist ideologies for like last 40 years. And we had a communist regime for 37 years before it broke down. So when I started joining into these discussions and debates, these ideas of communist thinking and communist romanticism was very much ingrained into me in a social and cultural way.

7:20And later I figured out, after coming out of my small zone and looking at the world, that the idea of communism is kind of like treated in international global space as almost as a form of terrorism, or almost as a form of like a very heinous thing that you don't want to talk about. But it was not the situation when I was in my area. It's still not the situation in most part of the Bengal, because the ideas and romanticism of communism was pretty much ingrained in their literatures, in their cultures, in their poetry, and in their songs, and all in the stories. So there are a lot of people who are communist and who think communism still can work, but I don't believe it anymore.

8:04But at some point I was also subscribing to myself as a communist, and by the end I passed out from my college. And when I was having done through all these discussions and all these debates of why communism failed... And the interesting part is that communists started with a movement. If you look it up, it's called the Naxalite movement of western province of India. Mostly happened in Bengal regions. And they went as a student movement. It was my university and many other universities surrounding my city where this movement actually started, its epicenter.

8:43They were like brilliant students who like dropped out of college and picked up guns to destroy the state or whatever it is. And that created a huge amount of force. And ultimately, they came into the democratic power around 1978. They ruled West Bengal, the Communist Party ruled West Bengal from 1978 to 2010, ultimately, before they completely collapsed through utter corruptions and bureaucracies and all.

9:10So it was a fascinating thing for me to see how a certain very ideologically motivated, brilliant people take up arms, where they could have been engineers, doctors, lawyers, or whatever, but they chose to take up arms, and most of them died for an ideology that didn't seem to work.

9:31And that kind of bugged me a lot, that why did this thing didn't work, and I wanted to understand it. And I didn't started understanding it until I stepped in Bitcoin, and the moment I stepped in Bitcoin, within the first two days, I was kind of swept away when I saw the problem statement that they are trying to solve. I didn't knew any clue how they are solving it. I didn't knew how Bitcoin works. I didn't knew how any of this shit works. But I saw the problem statement, and that problem statement hit me in my mind in a very blunt way. Like, this is the problem statement I have been asking for all these years. This is the problem that is related to why communism failed, why a central planning doesn't work, and how can you have anarchic systems without a central planning. So the width of the problem immediately blew my mind.

10:36And I was kind of like, "Whoa, this is big. I need to understand how this thing works." And that was the first step I took at the entrance of the rabbit hole. And since, it's been two years and I'm still not out of it. And I'm still going further and further and further. And I think that was the drive that put me into this quest of understanding Bitcoin, because I immediately made that link, because this is somehow related to my very old question: why central planning of communist structures cannot work?

11:08And if that cannot work, what else you can do without having a self-imposed structure of state or politburo or any kind of hierarchy into the society? Will the society fall into chaos? Before Bitcoin, I thought it would. The answer was yes to me. If you don't have a structure, if you don't have a hierarchy, you cannot have order. And once I saw Bitcoin, once I saw the Byzantine Generals' Problem and I understood the problem statement, I realized this is the exact same problem that you are trying to solve.

11:40I don't care if you solve it or not, but the fact that you are trying to solve it is immense. And the fact that you have a fucking computer protocol that you can use to solve it is out of this world. So that's what got me into Bitcoin.

11:53Vlad CosteaYeah, that's very fascinating because I'm also coming from a country which used to be communist until 1989. And I know all about this from my parents and the way they were grown and indoctrinated with the ideology, and how they still relate to power in a different way. And they have this kind of respectful fear for whoever is more powerful than they are, and they have a different view towards hierarchies and power structures. So I know that whatever we call communism in any part of the world is actually a form of state capitalism.

12:36Rajarshi MaitraExactly. What was interesting was also, while I was having these discussions in my student community, most of these people, even they are left-leaning, right-leaning, irrespective of their political ideologies or irrespective of their party or association, most of them seem to understand this point that it's not the person who is at the top who is at fault. It's the structure who is at fault. So this idea of anarchy was almost ingrained in a subconscious level in this part of the communist regime of the world, where people inherently understood.

13:14This came up a lot of time in our debates and discussions, that we should not be fighting against a person or a party, we should be fighting against the structure. And people understood this problem, that it's the problem of the structure, it's not the problem of the party or problem of the leadership. So you have to solve the structure somehow. But there is no way that you can have any kind of perceivable or conceivable meaningful solution of order without a structure. And that's why Bitcoin was fascinating me, because it's exactly that.

13:54Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess Bitcoin, if you take it from this perspective, also creates this kind of classes of citizens, and I remember Satoshi saying in a comment on Bitcoin Talk that people who do not validate their own transactions and rely on somebody else's node are second-class citizens, but I guess this is more of a joke.

14:21Rajarshi MaitraI don't think it's a joke. It has a sustainable, tangible...

14:29Vlad CosteaThe second-class citizen part is a joke, but it makes a lot of sense for you to want to validate your own transactions.

14:35Rajarshi MaitraYeah, it does. It does. Also, I kind of have a different view on this. It's like, this entire ecosystem made out of individuals, and each of individuals are citizens. So the classification of the citizens are dependent, are based on how much impact a citizen's decision is made on the structure of this entire system. So you have the first-class citizens as those whose decisions have the highest amount of impact, who runs their own node, who validates their own transaction, who maintains their own private keys. So they have the highest amount of influence.

15:19Vlad CosteaRaj? I lost you. Raj, I lost you for about 10 seconds.

15:32Rajarshi MaitraOkay, so can you hear me now?

15:34Vlad CosteaYes, you are saying that some people have the infrastructure to validate their own transactions and that's why...

15:42Rajarshi MaitraOkay, yeah, so I think these classifications of citizenship comes from this fact that these individuals who have all these required sovereign individuals and infrastructures at their home in order to validate their own transactions or have their own private keys, they have the highest amount of influence. Even if it is at an individual level, it's very minuscule. If you add up all these people who are doing the same, then it's become a very tangible, real thing. And I think a part of that happened in the No2X debate and that battle that happened in 2017. So there we saw there is a huge impact of individuals running their own node. So it kind of makes sense to segregate citizenships depending on the impact that they are imposing on their individual decision-making level over the whole ecosystem.

16:40Vlad CosteaSo, from your perspective, do you think that Bitcoin is much more than an economic system which competes with world finance and you see a political dimension to it?

16:54Rajarshi MaitraI do, I do. Yeah, I do. I do not have yet formulated a coherent view of how might that look like. But I do have a feeling that Bitcoin is much more like a lifestyle thing than it's just an economical system. It's an economical system at first, but it's also a lifestyle thing. And it changes your... You have to mold your lifestyle. You have to mold your way of thinking. You have to mold your time preference in certain ways in order to meaningfully participate in this ecosystem, in this economical system even. So yeah, it has this kind of effects. And yeah, that's what I think.

17:41Vlad CosteaYeah, that's a very interesting perspective, and you're basically implying that every participant must educate himself or herself in order to participate to this system. But my counterexample right now, and you said that you haven't formulated your ideas, maybe that's why we are having this conversation, so we get a better understanding of what we're thinking. But let's think of the average Coinbase user who doesn't even know what a public key and the private key is. They just know that they bought something which they hold in that wallet.

18:18And they will probably never switch to their own wallet. They just check price whenever they see mainstream media news. And that's pretty much it. They don't care much. It's like a hobby. They don't care enough to get involved. Are we going to say that these people are not authentic participants or that they don't matter? Because I guess they are a large part of the economy. If you look at how much of the community gets involved on forums or on Twitter, you're going to see that this world is quite small.

18:53Rajarshi MaitraIt's true, it's true. It's a few thousand people who are just like these crazy teen head cypherpunks who are like running nodes and buying hardware wallets. And I think what's happening here is basically all these people, the entire people who doesn't care about Bitcoin, who cares about Bitcoin, who runs their node, who doesn't run node, all this spectrum of the entire people does have all of their influence on the whole economy. Even the governments who bans Bitcoin does have an influence on Bitcoin. Even the banker who hates Bitcoin, who will never buy that piece of shit, also has an effect on Bitcoin.

19:32So everybody has their effect on this ecosystem, and these effects are not exactly similar for everybody else. So it doesn't mean to say that everybody needs to run their node or everybody has to go through all these cryptographic primitives and all these complex structures and all these complex concepts to understand and to meaningfully participate in Bitcoin. We just need enough people who are doing that, because if we have enough people who are doing that, the remaining of the ecosystem can gather around these people, can gather around this infrastructure and do whatever they want to do.

20:10So the ecosystem will evolve in this diverge way, and there is a very similar parallel that exists between this particular characteristics of Bitcoin and the way gold is used in Indian households. Basically, I was just looking through your post last night when you posted, and somebody suggested that you should ask this question of how gold culture in India can help Bitcoin or the reverse of it. I think there is a very interesting pair. I was thinking about it, and in India, most of the people, every household, lower class to upper class, from an entire spectrum, has a certain stash of gold in it.

20:57Okay. Now, they have this gold, but they don't see that gold as an investment vehicle. They don't see that gold as a store of value. 90% of the people in India doesn't care what the value of gold is, yet they have it. The reason they don't care about the value of gold, what is the price of gold is today, because they are not willing to sell. They don't sell their gold. So they hold this gold. Most of the time what happens is this gold changes hand through generations after generations after generations without ever being liquidated.

21:34And the only time an Indian household, middle class, lower middle class, upper class, anyway, any Indian household touches their gold stack and liquidate it in the time of crisis. And that is also at the very last resort, when they have nothing else in saving, when they have nowhere else to get the last lump of liquidity to extract, they will touch their gold and sell it.

21:58So what's happening here, the people in India, the common household people who have their gold, they don't understand why it's gold. If you go and ask them, "Why do you behave for this yellow rock, why do you think this yellow rock has value?", they will not be able to give you a proper answer, because they are not acting on a conscious level.

22:23It's ingrained in their subconscious in such a way, through cultural and social norms of thousands of years, that they immediately feel that it's a good idea to get a piece of gold without having to think about how gold is changing, how gold is the hardest money or hard money, or how they are going to go against the central bank or any kind of Austrian or libertarian philosophy. They have no clue. And they do not even understand why gold has the properties it has so that it can retain its value throughout time.

22:59But that doesn't matter. That doesn't matter to have them that stack of gold. So I think the cultures develop in this way. So you have certain people, you have a certain group of small chunks who see things differently, who invest in gold for whatever purpose. So there are gold bugs and all. There are gold bugs in India. So they invest in gold. They put money into their gold as a return of investment or as a self-sovereign store of value or whatever. But that doesn't stop other people to have gold.

23:36To have gold as a store of value without even knowing why they are using it as a store of value or why it is a good store of value than other metal crafts. This happens over generations and generations, and it takes a longer time to get engraved into the social psyche of the people to behave around certain asset classes in this way. And Bitcoin has exact same properties as gold. So I don't see any reason why this kind of behaviors cannot happen around Bitcoin, because it has the same properties that you need to simulate this phenomenon.

24:18So even though people don't run their full node, even though they're not libertarian, even though they don't care about central banking, monetary policies, inflation, the social psyche can be built around Bitcoin in such a way that people immediately know in their gut that it's a good idea to have some sats without being able to explain why that might be the case.

24:44Vlad CosteaI guess in 200 years, we're going to have something similar, especially maybe even closer than that, maybe before 2140, when we're going to have the last few bitcoins being mined. And I'm not sure what's going to happen to the network at that point. If the community will decide to hard fork and maybe create a greater inflation, or they will just have a moment and say, "This is it. We're going to use this supply rationally and make sense out of it." See how we can distribute the coins in a way that helps the prosperity of whatever they're going to have, like world state or nation states, or I have no idea what the future...

25:31Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah. Nobody has any idea. It's very difficult to try to predict futures even beyond three to four years, because, a big man, Nassim Nicholas Taleb described this very lucidly and very rightly, because our entire world is basically random. So there are lots of randomness that we cannot even comprehend. So if we know what would happen in future, we would already have that in present, because we know how to do that in future. That means we know how to solve that problem. So if we know how to solve that problem in future, that means we know how to solve that problem now.

26:09So the fact that we don't happen to have the future does say on its own that we don't, we cannot predict the future looking at our present. So that's a very deeper philosophical meaning about exploration on reality. I want to touch another point, that there is a difference between Bitcoin and gold, and that is our tangibility. This, what it seems around me is, in this Indian society, when a housewife gets a small stack of gold, or in form of jewelries, or in form of earrings, in form of a necklace, or in form of any other form, they always tend to have the form in such a way that they can show off it to the society.

27:05And this showing off is a very crucial part of having that asset, because you want to have a kind of thing that you can show to people, you can point to people, you can hold it in your hand, and you can wear it in your body and display it to the society that you have this asset. It kind of brings a human bias into forefront, that humans are prone to display their status, their social positions, their way of life, their way of thinking in society and in the surrounding society near them. And that is a very crucial part of being socialized.

27:50And so that is the problem that Bitcoin has that gold doesn't, that you cannot just point to a thing and you say, like, "Look, this is my Bitcoin," or "Look, I have made a necklace out of Bitcoin," even though that is not my entire Bitcoin stack, but I am showing off my Bitcoin stack to the society as a form of displaying my social position. You cannot do that with Bitcoins.

28:16Vlad CosteaWell, you can wear a QR code. And people can scan it and see how much Bitcoin you have.

28:24Rajarshi MaitraYeah, that's true.

28:26Vlad CosteaYeah, you can imagine that they're going to have some kind of wearable item which scans the codes, like the Google Glass. You know that thing?

28:35Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah.

28:36Vlad CosteaIt's something which enables augmented reality. So if people in the future are going to be wearing that, they can actually see how much Bitcoin each other actually has, if they want to show off.

28:50Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah, true, true.

28:52Vlad CosteaBut unfortunately, the culture of Bitcoiners is to not reveal how much they own, for tax reasons or for personal security reasons. As you don't want to get doxxed, you don't want to get swatted. If you own a lot of Bitcoin, it's a lot better for you to be pseudonymous on the internet and try not to reveal any personal detail about what you do, where you live, and stuff like that.

29:20Rajarshi MaitraYeah, true. This is the thing about Bitcoin. It incentivizes you to think about your privacy. It incentivizes you to take responsibility of your privacy. And that is the lifestyle teaching that Bitcoin teaches you when you try to hold your private key. It's a very difficult job to hold your private key. So I think Bitcoin in this front, I'm not very sure, but it seems to me that Bitcoin will not be properly, completely eradicate existence of gold, because gold doesn't have this kind of incentives.

29:57Vlad CosteaOf course it does. It's another form of property you have to-

30:00Rajarshi MaitraYeah, it does, another form of property, but the thing is, like, if you wear a gold necklace, it just looks good. And there is a social norm that established in the society that everybody agrees that it looks good on you. Like, that's the mental psychology that happens in every Indian woman. So they are fascinated about gold jewelry because it's shiny, it looks good, and they're fascinated about... It's not, it cannot be just any yellow metal. If you have a yellow metal that is painted yellow metal ring and you have a gold metal, there is very different, very...

30:42It's very difficult to just watch and see and tell from your eyes which one is the real one. But it almost like it doesn't matter to them. They want the real thing, because they want to tell people that this is the gold that I have, and that showing that also tells everybody else readily that they have a huge gold stash somewhere hidden. So that's the thing that is happening with gold.

31:13But you cannot happen to have that in Bitcoin, because if you try to show off your Bitcoin holding, the very next thing that you will have, that you will get doxxed, and you will get all sorts of attacks on personal things.

31:32So you have to be secretive about your Bitcoins. But it seems to me that it's not necessary for gold because people can comfortably display their gold to the society, yet they can be relatively secured about their entire gold stack hidden somewhere.

31:52Vlad CosteaYeah, that's just because everybody supposedly has their own stack of gold. So it's more unlikely for you to actually want to steal somebody else's.

31:58Rajarshi MaitraRight, that's also true.

32:00Vlad CosteaThere is also this social structure which allows people to know how much gold the other person owns. So if you steal from them, it's going to be very obvious. You're going to get caught. So your incentives to actually try to rob somebody of their gold in India, I guess, are much lower just because your chances of being caught are high and everybody has it.

32:29So your neighbor knows how much gold you have. And if you happen to show off with the gold that you stole from somebody else, then I guess it's going to be well known, as people can recognize. But at the same time, gold is one of these metals which aren't wasted. So you can melt gold and put it in different shapes and create various objects or

32:57Rajarshi MaitraJewelry with it. Yes, yeah, most of the time it happens. What happens is like this gold stack of every Indian household, they never get liquidated. What happens is they get transferred through generations and generations and generations without ever getting liquidated. In the process, they get molded from one jewelry to another jewelry or from multiple jewelries to one big jewelry or all sorts of different kinds of forms. But they almost never get liquidated. There are households which have this gold stack or some particular items of gold that has been in their family for generations of generations, and they never think about liquidating it.

33:40And this particular effect is also true in case of Bitcoins. There are people in Bitcoin space, I believe, who have this mentality of never liquidating their Bitcoin because they can simulate that exact same thing that Indians are doing with their gold, of passing wealth to generation without ever needing to convert it into other form of money or without ever needing to calculate its ROI, per se. And that works. And there is no reason why it cannot work for Bitcoin.

34:14It can similarly work for Bitcoin, and I think we will, over our generation and over the next generation, we will see these kind of things happening when the Bitcoin doesn't even touch the blockchain anymore.

34:29You just transmit the private keys from generation to generation to generation. And that's how it can retain its wealth very effectively through time. So you can very easily do that, and I think people will do that at a certain point of time.

34:46Vlad CosteaIn the culture from which I come, in Romania, there used to be this tradition for women to get gold after the marriage. And it was gifted by the man whom they were marrying as a guarantee that if they get left alone, they're going to be able to break even and become independent financially. This was before we had divorces, which allow you to take 50% of what you commonly own, and before we had this sort of legal and civil agreements. It was just a social norm to ensure that the woman, if she happens to be left alone and abandoned, she would be able to handle herself financially. And the gold was a guarantee that was offered to her for a good life, no matter what.

35:39Rajarshi MaitraTrue, same thing happens here. Yeah, it makes sense in a social and political structure where you actually don't want to waste your life and you don't want to... I don't know how I should call the term. You don't want to be left alone. You don't want to start from somewhere.

36:02You need some kind of securities, and gold seems to be a very socially accepted normative form of securities that you just transfer it to somebody, just handing it over. That's all you need to do. And that's all. And it's socially accepted and it's easy to do, and as it has retained its values through time very effectively, it has ingrained in the social psyche that this is a very good thing. This is a good idea to have some gold. So that's how these kind of norms emerges out of our society.

36:35Vlad CosteaThe point where I was trying to get from this is that what we were having is a very primitive form of what we have right now, and is called multisig. So it was a mutual agreement between multiple parties in which everybody owned like a part of the private key. And if they wanted to get out, they had their way of actually being financially well off if they wanted to. Right now, if you wanted to replicate it, you'd have a three-part private key, and each spouse would have one, and the other one would be maybe stored in a bank. So if one of them wanted to divorce and they agreed that it's okay for them to separate, then they would get access to that third part, and the spouse who is maybe in the worst financial situation would be able to get access to that Bitcoin.

37:42Rajarshi MaitraTrue, yeah, that kind of thing can emerge. It's much easier to do this kind of constructs with Bitcoin than on gold. You cannot do this kind of crazy multisig things on gold, but you can very easily do that on Bitcoin. And I think we will see a lot of this kind of primitive social contracts that can leverage the power of Bitcoin smart contracting tools to have these kind of ways for people to negotiate different kind of social norms and different kind of mitigation of social situations. And yeah, we are just at the tip of the iceberg.

38:32We just don't know how far this thing can go. We just know that this is big. This is huge. This has huge implications on our society. We just have to wait and see, and this is the fun part of studying Bitcoin. You don't have to bang your head a lot to figure out the problem, figure out the solution of the problem. The problem has been solved. All you need to do now is sit back and observe. And the thing will unfold in our eyes in real time. And that will be a sight to behold. We just don't know what's going to happen.

39:09Vlad CosteaWell, we know what's going to happen with the currency itself, as it has a fixed monetary policy, and that's predictable, and that's part of the reason why we agree that Bitcoin has value. The reason why I got into Bitcoin has more to do with the inflation and the monetary debasement happening in my country, where you have a monthly inflation rate of about 4%. So let's say that if I make about $1,000 a month, then from one month to the other, I'm going to lose $40 of purchasing power.

39:48Rajarshi MaitraYeah, that's terrible.

39:50Vlad CosteaNot only that is terrible, but the prices that you have for the phone bill, for your rent and for a lot of services that you pay are actually calculated in the euro, which is the European currency of reference. And it's a lot more stable than the Romanian leu. So it makes a lot of sense to look for something which helps you retain the value of your money, if you want to save. Otherwise, you're going to end up in this rat race where you're incentivized to spend your cash as fast as you can and dump it to the other person. And you're not going to save anything. It's all about consuming and buying and buying and buying, and that's how you're going to live.

40:40Rajarshi MaitraYeah, that's the vicious consumer death cycle that happens in hyperinflating countries. And also, 4% inflation monthly is very, very high, and that disrupts a lot of life. So our world needed these kind of ways to retain their values. And gold was doing a very bad job at it because of its nature, because it's heavy, because it's a physical metal, so it needs to be inherently centralized in a vault. So that was the big fault of gold. So gold failed us to provide the store of value we needed, and Bitcoin came in a very crucial time of our human history. We were just going to get doomed into this ever inflationary cycle of central banks printing money, and it's not that they are bad people, they can't do anything about it. They can't just stop it. The moment they try to stop it, the entire economy will collapse. So they are kind of in a path of self-destruct.

41:49They will self-destruct themselves within the next hundred years, maybe even sooner, nobody knows. But yeah, for the first time we have this relief valve system where the society can finally say, like, "Screw you, screw your monetary policies. I am not gonna... I'm not gonna play your game. I'm not gonna play this stupid game of endless consumerism. I'm going to save my money. I'm going to build my future, and I'll just pass it on even if I can't liquidate it. Even if you don't let me to convert it into fiat currencies, I don't care."

42:23"I'll just pass it on to my next generation, and maybe they don't even need to." So this is a very big statement, and this is a very impactful statement that a human individual can say to himself. So this changes a lot.

42:41Vlad CosteaIt's not just about oneself, it's also about the society at large and the government. As when you refuse to use the currency that your government issues, you're creating a problem which has no precedent and has no actual solution. They can ban Bitcoin. They can tell you will not be able to convert legally your Bitcoin into our national currency. But they will not be able to confiscate your Bitcoin. They will not be able to censor your transactions, unless they shut down the internet. But even for that, they figured out solutions with the satellite and mesh antennas, with radio signals, which is brilliant. Thank you, Nick Szabo and Elaine Ou.

43:32Rajarshi MaitraThat's fascinating. I was just reading through this paper that recently launched on Lightning Network over mesh connections. So they are incentivizing these mesh nodes to forward messages for a very small amount of sats, for very small amount of Lightning payments. So that was fascinating. And yeah, we are going into zones where people are gathering more and more forces so that they can say these things to the government, like, "Screw you. I'm not playing your game anymore. I quit. I exit." So Bitcoin was the first exit door that was placed inside a burning theater, as Andreas likes to put it. And once we got out of this exit door, there is this new entire world.

44:19And we are slowly, slowly starting to navigate through that world. And we are slowly building the houses, the electric poles, the other infrastructure, so that people can successfully live outside that burning theater. So far we have just gone outside the door through that exit door, and as we are going out through that exit door, people are building more stuff so that we can go further out and out and out, and it's going to keep on building.

44:49Vlad CosteaI agree. But what is the situation of Bitcoin in India? It's the second most populous country in the world. Some people estimate that within 20 or 30 years, you're going to have the most citizens, even more than China. And I suspect that there's a lot going on with Bitcoin, right?

45:10Rajarshi MaitraNot necessarily, not really. Part of the reason is the Indian currency is not failing that much catastrophically right now. So it's kind of stable. It still has, I think, a yearly 2% inflation rate, which is pretty high for common people. They are feeling the heat, but they don't seem to grasp what exactly is the culprit. They are blaming all sorts of different parties, and all the political parties are blaming each other and blaming the central parties for doing this. But nobody is actually grasping why this is happening.

45:40But as the problem is not very dire right now, they are also not looking for a desperate exit door. Even the exit door is there, they are not looking for it right now. So most of the situation in India with Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are merely speculations. So they are just speculating. They are just looking at it and seeing this price rise, this weird parabolic price rise, and they are just getting fascinated with it, and they just want to make a good buck. That's all. There are people who are realizing to the fact, but it's not happening in large enough scale so that you can have a rolling, moving economy, a complete closed-loop economy where you can do most of the things with Bitcoin. It's not happening that way because there is not enough need right now. The currency is kind of stable. So mostly there are a lot of hype regarding the blockchain, DLT, and all these other crypto projects per se.

46:52Today I saw an article that RBI is doing some R&D research on some blockchain, DLT kind of thing. So they are looking into this thing from a very different perspective. So they are kind of like looking at the entire structure and extracting some certain parts out of it, like the blockchain data structure or maybe whatever. I have no clue why they decided to extract the blockchain data structure. It's kind of irrelevant. So they're extracting different parts of these structures, and they are trying to build systems which are the old systems, but basically trying to make it more efficient.

47:36And I don't think that they will be able to succeed on this quest in a very meaningful or socially transformative way, because they are looking at a solution for which a problem doesn't exist. And this has been happening a lot. So most of the spaces are like that. RBI has imposed a banking ban on cryptocurrency. So this is what they're saying. So they are saying: you as an individual can do whatever with your money, we don't care. But they are saying the banks that it's your duty to make sure that you do not get involved in any kind of cryptocurrency transaction.

48:22Okay, so if you happen to have a fiat to Bitcoin transfer through your bank account and the RBI knows that and the bank knows that, the bank will close your account because they will say like, "RBI told us not to do this, so we can't allow you to do this." So this is the banking ban situation right now that is going on. So all this blockchain and DLT people, they are like really putting up enough force. And that's why I don't necessarily think all these things are bad ideas.

48:53All these things are irrelevant. They are relevant. And they are here to put that required force on the government to lift up these restrictions. And they are doing a really good job. The community is doing a really good job in taking the entire force of the mass, the entire incentives of each and every individual mass, even if it's for speculation, even if it's just for gambling, but the incentives are real, and they are gathering these incentives and kind of building up this force on the government through policy making, through discussions and through media outlets to withdraw this restriction.

49:38And government is finding really hard time to try to negotiate this domain right now. Because one hand they don't want to be left behind on a technical revolution. On the other hand they don't want to lose control over their monetary policies. So they are in a very tricky situation right now.

49:57Vlad CosteaJust for the record, what is the RBI which you mentioned?

50:03Rajarshi MaitraRBI is the Reserve Bank of India. It's the central bank. It's the Fed of India.

50:08Vlad CosteaOkay. You mentioned it about three times and I didn't want to interrupt, but so it makes a lot of sense now.

50:15Rajarshi MaitraSorry, I didn't get that.

50:17Vlad CosteaI said that I'm happy about the clarification.

50:20Rajarshi MaitraOh, okay.

50:21Vlad CosteaAlso, I wanted to ask you about politician views or statements about Bitcoin, if you had any. If you had any kind of mainstream FUD being spread across the media.

50:37Rajarshi MaitraYeah, there hasn't been much voice from the politicians, even from the central bankers, RBI governors and all those people. And they kind of have this, rightly so, and they kind of have this policy of not to talk about this thing much in public, and most of the time when there has been instances of reporters asking questions about these things, they seem to wave off the issue as much as they can. But what happened, I think this month or last month, I think this month, there was an interview where two government officials came into a local news channel, and there was another blockchain business PR person also there, and they were having this nice conversation of how the regulatory situations can go along or can be formed, and how can we learn from other countries what they are doing.

51:35So what was the interesting thing I noticed in their words is they are much more lenient now. They are not completely dismissive of it, because they know that being completely dismissive doesn't work anymore. But also what they are trying to do is they are trying to raise some ethical questions about this kind of currencies, suppose a Bitcoin or privacy coins like Monero, Zcash or something. So what they're saying is like, these are the coins that are being used by criminals. These are the coins that are being used by money launderers.

52:11"Yeah, they are good for monetary policies. They can retain value. They are a good store of value. But as a responsible citizen, do you really want to put your value onto something which is not completely ethical?" So they are kind of pinching the sentiment in a different way now. So instead of completely saying that this is illegal, you should not do it, they're more appealing for the moral nature of individuals listening to the show, that it's not actually very ethical thing to do. So that's an observation that I just made. I don't think it's much significant because people are gonna do what they're gonna do.

52:58So it doesn't make much difference, but this is a very clear change of their position that they have shown. I think they just shifted from anger to bargaining in that five stages of grief. And so that was interesting.

53:16Vlad CosteaYeah, it is fascinating because usually they make appeal to their power and they say, "We tell you to not do it and you're going to get punished by law."

53:26Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah, yeah. They changed their stand from appeal to individual ethics now because they know that their power cannot stop this thing.

53:36Vlad CosteaDid they try to appeal to religion in any way?

53:39Rajarshi MaitraNo, not necessarily right now. Not necessarily right now. I don't think the government official will go that far to have religion, religious ethics imposed on using such kind of monetary systems, because that will be ridiculed away immediately by the community or by the normal people. The religious rigorous works in the subconscious of human culture, but doesn't work in the forefront of government power structures and businesses and economic policies and all. So they haven't made any kind of statements like that and I don't think they will be making any kind of statement anytime soon.

54:26Vlad CosteaThat's very good actually, as being able to separate between religious beliefs and the state is a major step forward in terms of having a modern state and being able to do politics at scale, as opposed to just addressing a small or maybe a majority of religious people. I saw something similar happening in Arabic states where they were reluctant to use Bitcoin, maybe.

54:57Rajarshi MaitraYeah, they have a term for Bitcoin. They call it haram money or something like that. It means that this kind of effect actually shows you how much religion and state is interlinked in particular states. The nations where this religion and states are interlinked too much, like the state and the business, the state and the banking sector is interlinked too much in every nation around the world. When these kind of things happen, the state tends to appeal for the religious ethics that people inherently have in their subconscious, in their guts.

55:41So that's a very prominent pain point for them to attack at. And you won't be able to see these kind of things happening in other progressive countries where they have a complete separation between the religion and the state. So that's a good thing for a progressive society, as you have correctly pointed out. It makes the politics able to scale up for the society that it needs.

56:07Vlad CosteaWell, in this part of the world, it just happens that we saw in Poland how they managed to put the Catholic belief and religion into their constitution. And we also had a very extremist religious group, which was trying to impose their agenda to the extent that we were supposed to write into the Constitution that we are Christians and return to a set of norms that are very traditional and very 19th century.

56:37Rajarshi MaitraYeah, that's the recipe for fascism. Just one step further from there and you end up with a fascist state.

56:45Vlad CosteaWell, it depends on how you define fascism, as there have been links between the church and the state before fascism was even coined as a term. But I guess in our modern consciousness, we perceive a strong link between being a Christian fundamentally and taking your beliefs way too far and becoming a fascist and rejecting maybe the values or the realities that surround you and do not comply with what you believe.

57:23Rajarshi MaitraYeah, that's true. And that's what I exactly mean by fascism. It's true that there are a lot of different terms that how you describe fascism. But that's what I had in mind, because I am seeing a very similar kind of situation happening in India also, because the present party which is at power is kind of backed by this religious Hindu extremism. It's not extremism per se at this moment, but the situation can get very bad, very fast from here, because that's a recipe that you have built in your system, in your political structures, that can very easily morph itself into a Nazi-like structure.

58:09So when you have these kind of ideologies, belief systems engraved in your constitution... It's not happened in India yet that far, but it's true that the political party which is right now in power do comes from a Hindu majority support systems. But the problem is like when this happens, the very next step is basically seclusions and mass riot and all kind of chaos that happens to the society. Because one part of the group that believes that they have the power and they rightly have the power, they believe that they have a higher definition of morality than other groups, that these groups are not moral. And that's a very dangerous situation to have.

59:03Vlad CosteaLet's get to something more practical, and which is closer to the topic that we have surrounding Bitcoin. And let's imagine that right now I travel to India, and I lose everything. I lose my passport. I lose my money. And all I have is maybe a cell phone with some Bitcoin in it. Will I be able to survive?

59:26Rajarshi MaitraNot necessarily. Not necessarily. You have to convert it some way to fiat because there is nobody who accepts Bitcoin as a payment for goods and services in India yet. So at this moment, what you need to do is you have to have some form of way to get that converted into fiat. So now if you don't have a banking account in the country, if you come out from somewhere else, you will have no banking account. So you cannot have a bank transfer. So most of the peer-to-peer exchanges that are working in India happens through bank transfers.

1:00:01And I am not aware of any OTC desk that is at place right now where you can buy Bitcoin from cash. Because the moment you try to do something like that, the government will come and shut you down and put you into jail. So it will be very difficult to survive on Bitcoin if you have no means to convert it into fiat. So what you can do is you can call up your friend. You can tell that friend, "I want to use your bank account." So you send that money to an exchange.

1:00:34You go to a peer-to-peer exchange like LocalBitcoins or Hodl Hodl or WazirX, or there are many of these such things. You can go there and make a transaction with somebody else. You sell those bitcoins, get the fiat in your friend's account and then friend can cash it out and hand it over to you. You can do that way, but not directly with Bitcoin.

1:00:54Vlad CosteaBut let's forget about this appeal to a third party, which is either institutional or commercial when you use the service, and let's say that I go to the merchants directly and I tell them, "How about you take Bitcoin as a form of payment?" Do you think there are any chances of persuading them because they know Bitcoin and they understand that it has value?

1:01:18Rajarshi MaitraThey do. They do. Heard of Bitcoin. They understand it has a value, but they don't know how to use it. They do not have an exchange account necessarily, because if you go to the next door grocery store, they will not have an exchange account because they have bigger problem to solve in their life than to speculate on cryptocurrencies. So even if they heard about Bitcoin, they will not be able to accept it because they don't have the required infrastructure at place.

1:01:48So the only thing that they need to have and access is just a computer running a BTCPay Server. So that's all they need to know. That's all they need to have. But they don't know that they need to do this in order to accept Bitcoin. Or they don't even know that why they should accept Bitcoin, because the propaganda that is being transferred through the mainstream media, even though the government is not directly saying it, the mainstream media is morphing the government statement and producing in front of public in such a way that the public feels that Bitcoin is right now something illegal.

1:02:27So that's another thing that the community is trying to fight off very hard. The government never said it's illegal. They just said their banks not to be a part of that kind of exchange. But the translation of that statement in front of the common people is that Bitcoin is something illegal. So if you try to persuade someone, a grocery store owner, to accept Bitcoin as an exchange of goods and service, he might have heard about Bitcoin, he might have known that it is gaining value, but in his subconscious, he also, in his consciousness, he also knows that it's something illegal.

1:03:06So probability is that he will answer you with a resounding no.

1:03:12Vlad CosteaYeah, it makes sense. As you have fiscal authorities and you have people who check your supply of goods regularly, and if they discover that they have given something away and there is no way for them to prove that they have taken any form of money, then they can get accused of stealing.

1:03:34Rajarshi MaitraYeah, they can get into a lot of trouble by doing that. So even if they want to do that, they might not want to take that extra added risk that comes with that payment.

1:03:44Vlad CosteaIt makes sense. Is there any piece of legislation in India which specifically mentions Bitcoin?

1:03:51Rajarshi MaitraNot right now. Not right now. They are in the process of forming such regulations, but they have been in the process of forming such regulation maybe for last three, four years. They haven't been able to come up with anything concrete or anything documented. A few weeks back, there was this leaked document, a draft from the committee that has been formed to make a legislation or proper regulation on cryptocurrencies and Bitcoin by the Supreme Court. There was some leaked document that seems to suggest that this committee is suggesting the Congress to pass a bill that will make Bitcoin illegal.

1:04:35That means dealing, selling, buying and even holding Bitcoin can put you in jail for 10 years. That's a very scary situation and a lot of talk has been happened over that, and it turned out that it was just a draft bill. So even if the bill does include a clause like that, it seems unlikely to me that it will actually get implemented. And right now that so many things are happening on this blockchain and DLTs and other cryptocurrency stuffs around the space.

1:05:12Vlad CosteaYeah, that's very interesting, because most European countries already have some kind of regulations in terms of making sure that you pay taxes for the Bitcoin that you convert into fiat.

1:05:27Rajarshi MaitraYeah, we don't have anything right now in India like that. It will be very necessary for the community to even properly function. There are a lot of businesses in this market, lots of exchanges who are shutting down their shop just because this kind of regulatory issues. The regulatory situation in India is very obscure right now. It's not at all clear. Nobody has any clue how they are going to behave, what they are going to consider. And it's very difficult for the entrepreneurs to make business in this kind of situations. And that's what we are seeing here. A lot of people are closing shop. They just cannot sustain this uncertainty.

1:06:08Vlad CosteaI was thinking right now at a comparison with China, which is also a populous country, and they had many instances in which they announced that they were banning Bitcoin. But at the same time, they had these mining rigs that were running. Are you aware of any mining going on in India?

1:06:31Rajarshi MaitraI'm not particularly. I haven't came across anybody saying any kind of mining activity going anywhere in India. I am not very sure about the mining profit loss calculations regarding the current electricity price in most of the cities and around the villages of India. I'm not sure how it turns out, but it seems to me there is not much mining activities happening in India. And if it has been happening, I think the government would have already stopped it by now, because they seem to be keen on stopping all these kind of activities that are happening until they manage to come up with a proper regulations and proper decision how they are going to handle this.

1:07:17Vlad CosteaLet's say that India bans Bitcoin tomorrow. Is there any way for you to appeal to that political process and maybe contact your representatives and help to draft a better bill which favors the Bitcoiners in your country?

1:07:37Rajarshi MaitraThere is no structured process for that. I think a lot of people will do that and a lot of people will come out and put their voice together to impart sense in this kind of ridiculous banning, if that happens. A part of the very obvious sense that they can try to impart into the government is that this kind of banning doesn't work. If you try to ban it, the entire system will still exist, but it will only exist in the dark market. And the government knows that. This is the thing about India.

1:08:11India has a very huge dark market. It has all sorts of illegal market in every cities, in every village, and you can get anything in anywhere if you pay the price for it. So the black market problem is very big in India, and it's kind of a bigger part of the economy in many places, where the white market is the smaller one and the black market is the actual market where you go to buy stuff.

1:08:37So as this kind of markets exist very freely and very fluently in India, it will become very difficult for government to implement this kind of ban, because the moment this kind of ban will happen, what people will start doing is just simply make OTC cash transaction, cash on-ramps for Bitcoin in corners of markets, like in black alleys or something like that. And these kinds of things will keep on popping up. So the government needs to know that if they try to go to that path, what will happen is they will not be able to stop it, but the entire economy will go into the black market.

1:09:21And they already cannot stop the black market, so they can't stop Bitcoin in black markets. That's even a more difficult problem. I think if the government does go around this path, there are people who will come forward, even I would come forward and try to impart sense into this legislation that this is not the way you should handle it, because it will only make the situation worse.

1:09:55Vlad CosteaSo right now, considering your views, you're basically red-pilled. It's too late for you to get back to that old beliefs that you used to have. And if the situation in India was to get very bad and you basically had no way to use your bitcoins, would you consider leaving your home country?

1:10:18Rajarshi MaitraProbably, it depends on a lot of situations. Leaving your home country is a very difficult part, because in India we live in this kind of social structures where you live close nearby to your parents, you live close nearby to your relatives, you have this kind of social cultures around your localities, you almost know people around you. So it's very difficult to sever this kind of ties and leave to another country just because they don't let you use Bitcoin. It's not a good enough bargain for me, it seems, because there are other important stuffs in my life that I will tend to attend to than putting my priorities on Bitcoin.

1:11:14Bitcoin is important for me, and I would love to have my savings in Bitcoins, and I would love to use it as a store of value. But if they have imposed some kind of bans and I cannot use Bitcoin right now, that doesn't affect me much, because I am not using Bitcoin anyway, because there is no closed-loop economy going on right now with Bitcoin. And that is one of my goals to do in this ecosystem, where I can have this kind of closed-loop economies where people accepting Bitcoin as a exchange of goods and services. We don't have that right now. So even though government is not banning it, I still can't use my Bitcoins because there is no one accepting it.

1:12:04So it's going to take some time to have that kind of closed-loop economy. But just because government banning it, I don't think I'll be leaving my country.

1:12:12Vlad CosteaBut that's a huge power which the government has over you as a citizen, as they just know that you're bound to your family and to your house. So yes, in very specific terms relating to this industry, that's a central point of failure.

1:12:30Rajarshi MaitraTrue, true, very true. That's the central point of failure. And that's a very big shackle that you have around you. And the government can game that shackle to force you to do things that you might not want to do, or force you not to do things that they don't subscribe to. And that's a very true problem, and I don't know how I can solve that right now. I can only hope the situation will not go much worse, because it's really very difficult for me to go settle in different country and sever all these ties that I have. So yeah, that's all. It's the central point of failure, and I'm kind of like hoping that that central point doesn't do something very bad.

1:13:24Vlad CosteaYeah, in some cases like Venezuela, there were entire families which moved out of the country because of Bitcoin. It's not because of Bitcoin, but thanks to Bitcoin, as...

1:13:36Rajarshi MaitraYes, they used Bitcoins to go out of it. I think the situation in Venezuela made people do that because the situation is so much dire there. It's not that bad here. I told you before, the currency is kind of stable. It's not completely collapsing. People still can use it as their unit of account. And the situation, the theater is not burning enough right now. That doesn't say that it will not burn in some point of future with that much force. It can burn, but it's not just burning at that heat right now, so that the people are not screaming out of the theater and moving out through that exit door. They are just... It's just warm. They are just feeling the heat, but it's not warm enough to make them leave the theater. If that makes sense.

1:14:28Vlad CosteaIt does. I mean, even when I think in my case, I'm part of the European Union, and that has both advantages and disadvantages. On one hand, I am able to leave to any country, any of the 27 other countries which are part of this organization. But at the same time, we have a legal framework which comes from Brussels. So if they decide at the European Union level to ban Bitcoin, then it's going to be felt in all the states. So I'm thinking sometimes that the worst that we can have in terms of political reception hasn't happened yet.

1:15:15And part of the reason why I'm happy about the developments in Bitcoin is that I see a lot of institutional friendliness towards it. I don't care much about their adoption and how much they're buying it and how much they invest in it, but the fact that they show interest means that it's not going to get banned, at least not in the Western world.

1:15:40Rajarshi MaitraYeah, I have the same kind of feeling here, because I told you about that interview, that TV show that happened, a news show that happened with two government officials. And the optimistic view that I ended up at that show is that they just shifted from anger to bargaining. So that means they are moving up through the ladders of stages of grief. So that means that there is now less probability that they will make an outright ban than it was two, three years ago.

1:16:13Two, three years ago, they might have higher chance of considering outright ban, but they just showed that they have a lower chance of it, just because showing that they stepped up the ladder from anger to bargaining. So that's a good sign.

1:16:27Vlad CosteaAlso, as a politician, it makes a lot more sense to try not to divide the people and collect taxes, as opposed to instilling fear and making use of the force that you have.

1:16:43Rajarshi MaitraYes, yes, yes. The biggest incentive for politicians to not ban Bitcoin is because if they don't ban Bitcoin, they have these exchanges running, and through these exchanges, they can at least collect the taxes that they want. If they ban Bitcoin, the market immediately goes to the black market, the black zone, and they do not tax black zone anyway. So they lose a huge amount of tax from the economic activity that will be happening, and they might not want that. Any simple intelligent politicians will decide not to ban Bitcoin if they understand remotely anything about Bitcoin, and I think they do. They have been studying a lot, and that has been shown. I have seen that in that past news show that happened.

1:17:36So they know and they understand these problems. They know that they can't stop it. They understand the privacy issues. They understand the laundering issues, and they are trying really hard to come up with a sensible way of dealing with this thing that doesn't necessarily make the situation immediately worse. And banning Bitcoin outright will immediately make the situation much, much worse. And I'll be surprised if they do that.

1:18:06Vlad CosteaBut if they shifted their position, as you said, from being angry to being willing to cooperate, then there must have been some kind of pressure coming their way. There must have been some people who told them, "You know, it's a lot better to allow this to flourish and we can collect taxes." So there must be a large community, right?

1:18:32Rajarshi MaitraYeah, I think there is something interesting happening here. It's not even about the community. I think many of the politicians are waking up to this fact that Bitcoin is a fucking good store of value. So they want to have that store of value for themselves. So they have their inherent interest, self-interest, not to ban this thing, because they would want to use this thing because it's good for them also. We did not have this kind of awesome store of value before Bitcoin. So it makes sense.

1:19:06And if you know anything about Indian politics and its scams, you will see all these politicians have huge amount of wealth stored in foreign banks or in underground or even as gold, as a stack under their mattress. This thing happens. And this is such a menace in India. I think a lot of people will wake up to this fact that the reason they were doing this thing is because they want to store this huge massive wealth that they have gathered through corruptions or through whatever ways or through whatever other different ways.

1:19:45They want to retain that wealth and they don't want to... Not only they don't want to tax on it, they don't want it to inflate away. They don't want it to inflate away. So the thing that they do, they immediately convert it into hard assets like real estates, like gold, like foreign dollars, and put it into foreign bank accounts. The reason they are doing that is because they want to escape out of the inflation. Whatever the small little inflation, it's not even small, it's quite big. Whatever the inflation that is happening to Indian currencies, they don't keep that wealth in Indian currency. They immediately convert it. The reason they convert it is because they want to store it through time.

1:20:20And once they realize that Bitcoin is the best of all the store of values that we have right now, they will have a huge amount of self-interest to want to use Bitcoin. So I think not only there is a pressure from the community, which is also there, as lots of businesses are trying to make, and they are also arguing the government that if you try to ban it, what will happen is we will lose all these economic activities and we lose out in the forefront of this emerging technology. While that is also happening, I think also the politicians are waking up to this fact that this is a very good store of value for them also.

1:21:02And that's also a reason that they will not ban it.

1:21:06Vlad CosteaSo, we have yet another instance where the situation is solved by human greed. And maybe it's part of the solution, an extension of the Byzantine Generals' Problem.

1:21:22Rajarshi MaitraYes, exactly, exactly. This is what blew my mind when I first saw Bitcoin in the first two days. The way you solve that age-old problem of order without structure is use an incentive mechanism to model a design that works on human greed. The order emerges out of human greed. Because humans are greedy, that's why Bitcoin works. That's why mining works. That's why you have the longest chain. That's why the system is not disintegrating itself into chaos. Because humans are greedy. And that is the crucial brilliance of Satoshi Nakamoto's design, that he used greed to make order out of chaos.

1:22:05And basically he used human greed to create a deterministic anarchic system. And that is just fascinating.

1:22:12Vlad CosteaYeah, I guess he understood money a lot better than most of our economists.

1:22:17Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah, it sometimes blows my mind, like how can someone have this many ingenious ideas in one single design from all these different fields? Like, you have to be very good at writing code, you have to be very good at understanding cryptography, you have to be very good at understanding game theory, you have to be very good at understanding economics, you have to be very good at designing the entire human psychology that should make that system work. It's just not a simple cryptographic structure. It's not just a simple computer code. It's a huge, massive incentive, human, social engineered thing.

1:23:00I don't even know how to describe it, and it just works, and it works because of human greed, and it's just so fascinating. I sometimes think that it cannot be just one people. I have hard time believing that all of this came out of just one single mind. I think it was a group of people who brainstormed for years to finally come out with a design that can work.

1:23:30Vlad CosteaWell, if you look at the history of inventions dealing with digital cash, you start with David Chaum, who had eCash, and then you get to Wei Dai and you get to Adam Back, who tried to find a way to prevent spam by creating hashing cycles from your processor. And then you get to Hal Finney and also Nick Szabo, who had Bit Gold.

1:23:55Rajarshi MaitraE-gold was the last workable iteration that happened before Bitcoin. It was in 2005, I think. I think Bitcoin happened after e-gold stopped.

1:24:08Vlad CosteaRight, but e-gold had the central point of failure.

1:24:11Rajarshi MaitraYes, yes, yes, most of them had the central point of failure. I'm not an expert on this thing because there are lots of people who studied this thing a lot. But what I seem to understand is that the crucial difference between Bitcoin and all other previous iterations that happened is this closed loop of incentive structures that is self-sufficient, that grows on its own. Because if you look at the design, Satoshi did not invent any of the primitives. All the primitives are already there. Many of the crucial primitives like the proof of work, like the blockchain, Merkle trees, cryptographic hashes, digital signatures, all these things exist for 20 years.

1:25:00So Satoshi didn't invent any of this. What he did is combining all these primitives in such a way that you have an incentive structure which completes a loop on itself. And because it completes this loop on itself, it has this self-sustaining, this periodic growth, almost like a biological form, and it grows on its own. So that was the crucial key point of Bitcoin and none of the previous iterations had this thing. So yeah, that's it.

1:25:34Vlad CosteaThat was a very nice description, Raj. I feel like I couldn't have said it any better than you did, and that comparison with a biological being actually blew my mind.

1:25:47Rajarshi MaitraYeah, this is another thing that blew my mind in, I think, the third or fourth month of my Bitcoin study, when I finally understood that this is a biological thing. The reason it blew my mind is because two years before that, I read Richard Dawkins' "Selfish Gene". And in that book, at the last chapter, Richard Dawkins talks about ideas. How ideas are very similar to genes, and ideas spread among the society through minds to minds, just like genes spread among the species. And the ideas which are sustainable, which survive, are the ideas that morph the society. So, it's like a biological evolution. The only idea that gets morphed into the society is the idea which is sustainable on its own. But we have all these different kinds of iterations, random iterations of ideas, just like we have all these different kinds of random iterations in genes.

1:26:52So mutations happen in genes, but all mutations don't stay. The only mutation that stays is the one which makes the species better as a whole. So he extended the same kind of thing, and that was fascinating to me. And this clicked two years later when I first understood Bitcoin as a biological organism. And this blew my mind and I thought like this is exactly working like a virus. It's like an idea virus spreading in the world, and it has all the characteristics of virus growth.

1:27:25It's growing exponentially, it's growing through waves of adoptions, and it just keeps on going and going and going because it has this self-fulfilling incentive structural loop inbuilt in its design. And so, yeah, it is very much like a biological organism. It's very much like an idea virus that grows through the society. And I even go a little bit farther and I extend it, like it's almost like the T-virus. Have you seen Resident Evil? So in Resident Evil, you have this concept of T-virus. A T-virus is like a virus that when you get affected, you become a zombie.

1:28:04So the next thing you want to do after becoming a zombie is bite other people, because the T-virus wants to spread to other people. So this is the same thing that exactly happens here. If you are into Bitcoin, the next thing you want to do is tell people about Bitcoin, and you want to spread this idea from one mind to another. You almost have your inherent need of doing that, and that is so weird, and that is exactly like an idea virus works.

1:28:32Vlad CosteaWere you able to be an advocate of Bitcoin to your peers, to your family, to your friends?

1:28:39Rajarshi MaitraThat's what I've been trying to do for the last seven or eight months, almost. I think of it almost like an exercise. It's a very difficult thing to do. It's amazingly difficult to explain Bitcoin to people. So what I have been trying to do is I have been catching students in universities and trying to have conversations with them on Bitcoin. And to my surprise, I have successfully indoctrinated some people into this Bitcoin zombie, and I have this group of people right now working in my local universities who are amazingly fascinated by this idea.

1:29:25They just needed the click to happen. And the click is very difficult because the click happens after a long period of exploration. It just doesn't happen immediately. Just because you see Bitcoin, it doesn't immediately click in your head. It happens when you start exploring and exploring and exploring. So in the part of indoctrinating other Bitcoiners, the key is to find the potent mind. The potent mind is a mind which has all the relevant ideas in place, and all you need to do is connect them together.

1:30:03Once you connect them together, it just clicks in them, and then they will just explore on their own. They will learn on their own. They will scour on their own. They will go to the extent that you have just done in order to understand this thing, so that they can understand it better. You cannot explain Bitcoin to people. They have to understand it on their own. What you can do is put the dots in their head and then just connect them so it clicks.

1:30:29Vlad CosteaOkay, so that sounds a little successful on your side. You managed to convince some university students.

1:30:36Rajarshi MaitraNot in a large enough scale, it's just two, three people. I am planning to build it up in scale so that I can have a local group of Bitcoiners in local universities. So we can have all these kinds of meetups, discussions and hackathons, and maybe build cool stuff on it. So I am in the process of it. When I started, I was like the lone wolf and there was no one.

1:31:07And when I started thinking about making Bitcoin businesses, Bitcoin-only businesses in India, the first biggest difficulty I faced is like there are no Bitcoiners. So I kind of had to make Bitcoiners out of thin air. So that's what I've been doing for the last seven, eight months. And I got like two, three people who I have successfully been able to convert, and they are right now in the process of this transition, this process of studying and this process of exploration. And I'm planning to build it up in scale and see how it goes from there.

1:31:38Vlad CosteaOkay, but have you also educated yourself to code and be able to develop applications for Bitcoin, like wallets?

1:31:46Rajarshi MaitraYeah, I have done that. I have been doing that, but for the first one year of my study, what seemed important is I should learn how to code. I should learn the cryptographic primitives. That was the basic understanding I should have in order to work on this system. So I taught myself how to code, but I am not at that level where I can cook up full functioning wallet softwares. So I have tried my hand in many hobby projects, but it's nothing in a deployable way.

1:32:26But the more I am going towards it, I am thinking like I don't want to be a full-time developer developing things on Bitcoin. I just happen to know people who can do that. I should be able to motivate them to do this thing, because they can do this job better than me. So I should not be directly writing code on Bitcoin. I should find out people who can do that thing better than me, and I should make them realize why that's the best thing that they can do with their free time. So that's what I've been trying to do. That's what I've been doing right now.

1:33:05Vlad CosteaSo what is your plan? Maybe in the next few years, are you trying to build a large community and then what? Develop businesses surrounding Bitcoin? Educate the minds of the youth?

1:33:18Rajarshi MaitraEducation is obviously a big part of it. Francis Pouliot very recently made a post on Twitter which I completely agree with. He said, like, the way to make a cypherpunk business is don't go for a product at first, go for a network of motivated and resourceful people. What you need first is a network of motivated and resourceful people who are investing their mental capabilities, their mental time, and their free energy into understanding a seemingly complex stuff. Once you have that, what you can do, you can make all sorts of different structures with this group of people.

1:33:59You can make an academic forum, you can make a club, you can make a society, you can make a meetup or you can make a business where you are building Bitcoin infrastructure products like nodes, like full nodes or hardwares or hardware wallets or all these kind of stuff. And there is a very big lacking of this kind of infrastructures in India, we just don't have it here. And the problem is, like, if you want to import this already super cool model hardwares, it's just so costly that most of the people can't just afford it.

1:34:32So the reason the people cannot afford it is because, once there is this currency conversion thing, $300 is pretty much a big amount for a regular Indian. Then over that, there is this import cost.

1:34:51So the cost boosts up so high that people can't just use it. So mostly what people are trying to do in the small community that we have is people are trying to build their Bitcoin nodes on their own. So that's much cheaper to do, but it's much harder to do. But it's a very good exercise of learning. So that's what I have been doing and that's what many other people have been doing. So I think there is a very good scope of having Bitcoin-only businesses and infrastructure businesses to deploy in India.

1:35:21That's one of my goals, but I do not have a properly chalked-out path how I can reach there. Right now, I have this immediate goal of making as many Bitcoiners I can out of these university students because they seem to be the most potent mind that I have at my disposal, that I can use them. Or I can help them to understand these things. And they almost always receive these ideas in a very enthusiastic tone. So that's a good thing. And that's what I'm looking to build next.

1:35:57Vlad CosteaJust out of curiosity, what are these students studying right now? The ones who got interested in Bitcoin?

1:36:03Rajarshi MaitraThey're from all sorts of different backgrounds. There is no one background. We have students from economics, mathematics, engineering, all different forms of engineering, political science, history, law, and all sorts of things. And that's one of the crucial part of understanding Bitcoin. Bitcoin is not a domain-specific knowledge. It's a multidisciplinary thing. So you need people from all different sorts of discipline to come together to explore this one idea from all these different viewpoints. And the fascinating thing about Bitcoin is everybody has a perspective on this object from their own different discipline.

1:36:46This hasn't ever happened with any kind of other technical innovations or softwares or any kind of other sciences. So even people from history, even people from political science, can relate it very easily. We have all sorts of people from all different backgrounds. Right now, what I have is two or three people from different engineering backgrounds and different other majors like history. I think that's all I have. We are still looking for a political science student. We don't have a political science student as of yet. But yeah, mostly engineers and mostly we have another. Ravi is a mathematician. Ravi is doing a PhD in maths. So yeah, that's it.

1:37:36Vlad CosteaSometimes I think that in order to get into Bitcoin, you need the proper background or life experience which motivates you, as you don't just get into it. You somehow need it in your life.

1:37:49Rajarshi MaitraYeah, true. In order to properly jump inside that rabbit hole, you need to have some kind of questions that you have been looking answer for. So it happened to me because I was asking that question that Bitcoin suddenly gave the answer for. And that's why I just jumped into it. And this happens to all people, and it's not necessarily to say that there is one single background that you should come from in order to have this kind of jumping moment. It can happen for any kind of background. It can happen from any different background.

1:38:28Whatever your background is, there is some part of life, there is some questions of life, there is some questions of quest that you can ultimately attach to this thing and then ultimately can fall down into this rabbit hole. So that's the reason why we see people from all sorts of political domains, from left, right, center, from all sorts of religious domain, from all sorts of technical domain, from all sorts of artistic domain, are able to make themselves interested in Bitcoin because Bitcoin can be seen from all these different perspective viewpoints and everybody can have their own story engraved in it.

1:39:11Vlad CosteaThis is more of a joke, but it can become a serious question in a certain context. How would you explain to somebody who maybe listens to this and has no idea what we're talking about that Bitcoin is not some kind of religious cult and we are undergoing this missionary quest in order to spread the word about it and make people use our made-up money that no government backs? So the essential question is: why are we not a cult and what sets us apart from one?

1:39:50Rajarshi MaitraI think we are a cult. What's wrong with being a cult?

1:39:55Vlad CosteaOkay. I was about to argue that, unlike many cults which are mostly concerned with spiritual savior and redemption and whatever concept they're trying to promote, this is more about economic rationality than about anything else. So if it's about your self-interest and greed and money, it makes a lot more sense than... It's much more practical than anything else that deals with something immaterial that we cannot perceive and is not tangible. Even though Bitcoin is not tangible in itself, it holds a certain value that we agree on, and that's something very different from trying to establish norms regarding what a perceived God is like or trying to find ways to worship.

1:40:49Rajarshi MaitraOkay, I understood your point. I can argue from a completely opposite way because the cult emerges because there is a belief system. The belief system happens because people believe in certain ethical norms, certain ethical statements that they seem to be following to be the truth. And that's completely subjective. That depends on their entire religion, that depends on their geography, that depends on their culture. But cults always happen because they have a belief system. And a belief system emerges whenever there is a question of ethics.

1:41:24And I think Bitcoin is exactly that. I think Ethics of Money Production, who wrote that? Mises? No, sorry, Rothbard? I forgot. If you read the Ethics of Money Production, I forgot who wrote it, and there, the question of economics is basically answered through the question of ethics. And ethics and economics is very much related to each other. You cannot have a sound economics without a sound ethical ground. So in order to have a sound economics, if you need to have a sound ethical ground, inherently that means that the thing with which you are trying to build the economics has to have ethics engraved, question of ethics engraved into some form of it.

1:42:16And Bitcoin does engrave some form of ethics into it. You cannot inflate the supply of Bitcoin. That's our ethical stand. So whenever you have an ethical stand, immediately there is no difference between a cult. You can describe cults in lots of different ways, in positive ways, in negative ways, but the core concept of a cult is that it has to have its one basic ethical statement. And because Bitcoin does have its one basic ethical statement, I don't think that you can argue that it's not a cult. It is a cult.

1:42:55Vlad CosteaBut what is that ethical statement that you're speaking of?

1:42:59Rajarshi MaitraNobody should have the power to manipulate money supply.

1:43:07Vlad CosteaThat's fair. That's the ethical statement. Do you think that's the only one involving it?

1:43:12Rajarshi MaitraI think no, there are many, many others. There are ethical statements with privacy. There are ethical statements with sovereignty. There are ethical statements with free trades. There are ethical statements with free markets. All this comes... All this builds up on this basic ground, I think. The basic ground is nobody should be in the position of power to control monetary policy, because if somebody does, that's unethical. The reason that they control, the fact that they control is itself the unethical part of that statement.

1:43:50So the basic building block of this free market ethics that you can build up on top of Bitcoin starts from this fact that nobody should be in the power of control monetary policy. And if you believe that is an ethically correct statement to have, then you have a cult.

1:44:12Vlad CosteaThat makes sense if you look at it from this point of view, even though I guess the Western understanding of a cult is slightly different and has to deal with all sorts of crazy people getting together.

1:44:26Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah, that's just how you define cult. You can define the word "cult" in many images. You can have a bad image, like all these crazy people with black hairs and black nails and all. You call that a cult. Or you can call a cult in a very different image. It depends on how you are defining the word. But the essence of, I guess, the essence of a cult is this: you need to have a belief system. You need to have a belief system engraved in the design of the cult. Every cult believes some statement. Without there cannot be any cult. And if you have a belief system, then you inherently end up being in a phenomena which is kind of like religion. And you hear saying this thing from other people who are not exactly Bitcoin maximalists. They think of Bitcoin maximalism as kind of a religion because maybe it is.

1:45:24Maybe it is because it has a belief system engraved into it. It has an ethical point. It has an ethical stand over which you stand and make the further progression of your societal viewpoint that you build on top of it, like the free market, the privacy, the user sovereignty and all these other things. So it does kind of make sense to agree with their argument that this is a belief system, and if this is a belief system, there is not much difference between it and any other kind of religion.

1:45:59Vlad CosteaThese can be actually the foundations of an institutional cult that we can establish, so we don't pay taxes anymore?

1:46:08Rajarshi MaitraProbably, probably. This can be the cult of the next human evolution. And I don't know how it's going to play out, but it seems to be that I don't necessarily see it as a bad thing. So whenever I hear the word "cult" in context of Bitcoin, I happen to agree with it, but it doesn't necessarily immediately strike a bad image in front of me. What strikes me is that it's a necessary feature that Bitcoin needed to have in order to do what it is aiming to do. It needed to have this ingrained belief system in it because that's when you hit individual mind at the core heart of it.

1:46:54If you cannot hit at its belief system, you cannot make it a zombie virus. So the only way Bitcoin can succeed is by making itself like a zombie virus, and the only way it can make itself as a zombie virus is by hitting at the heart of the human psyche, that is their core belief system. And I think Bitcoin is in the process of doing that.

1:47:18Vlad CosteaThat's interesting. It's going to also be fascinating to see how this plays out in the coming years and with more adoption, how we are going to change the narratives, because objectively speaking, we can say that Bitcoin has gone through many phases of adoption and different narratives that preceded and facilitated this. So it's going to be a matter of how do you present this protocol, because essentially it's just code, to somebody who is willing to embrace it, but is not at the edge of the society, is just a normal person.

1:48:00Rajarshi MaitraYep, yep, yeah. We will see narrative changes. Narrative changes happens all the time. But what I think we need to be careful about these changes of narrative is that the core narrative of Bitcoin should not be distorted. The core narrative was this one single ethical statement: nobody should have the power to manipulate economic policy, the monetary policies. So if this narrative gets distorted in some way... We can have all these higher kinds of narratives depending on the suitability of our environment, depending on how the network is behaving, depending on how the adoption is coming, but we should not be willing to forfeit this very basic core fundamental narrative, because that's what makes Bitcoin tick.

1:48:57Vlad CosteaI guess the biggest kind of attack vector that you have on Bitcoin is the fixed supply. If you no longer have that and people agree that you can have an inflationary Bitcoin, then that's the end of it. You don't have to take down the mining rigs.

1:49:15Rajarshi MaitraI don't remember where I read, but I was reading it somewhere that the biggest right decision that Satoshi took was having a fixed supply cap, because he knew that the moment you make the supply cap fluctuating, the moment you have this question of inflation, that opens up a lot of political attack vector, because there is no right answer for the right inflation. There is no right inflation. So you can never objectively determine that this should be the right inflation. You can see this happening in the Ethereum right now.

1:49:53They do not have a consensus on what should be the right inflation because you cannot have a consensus on what should be the right inflation, because every inflation is right inflation. So the moment you start making this question, you open yourself to this political attack vector where you can never reach a consensus. And that's why Satoshi fixed the cap at 21 million, because he knew that this question was an attack vector. Once you start having this question of whether to increase the cap or not, that opens up the attack of controlling the monetary policy, because there is no one true answer for it.

1:50:27Vlad CosteaI agree. And that's the most important feature of Bitcoin. We like to say that it's going to lead to deflation and a situation where the demand is higher than the supply, which means an appreciation in terms of fiat money.

1:50:40Rajarshi MaitraYes.

1:50:41Vlad CosteaAnd the way it's going to play out during the various halvings that we have throughout the years, that's also something interesting to witness.

1:50:54Rajarshi MaitraYeah, true. It's interesting because we never had a deflationary money supply. It's not deflationary, it's negative inflation. So the inflation is there, the inflation just decreases with time and at some point it just stops. So it's not exactly deflationary, it's fixed supply money system. So we never actually had this fixed supply money system and we don't exactly know how it's going to play out. And we can theorize lots of crazy theories. We can theorize how it will work, how it will not work. But this is the biggest problem of Bitcoin.

1:51:33We do not have a mathematical theory that proves, a mathematical derivation that proves that this is why Bitcoin will work or this is why Bitcoin will not work. So this is the curious part of Bitcoin. I read somewhere, I don't remember, that Bitcoin is this weird thing that doesn't work in theory, but it only works in practice. And because of this nature of Bitcoin, we cannot predict what it will do, because we don't simply have a derivation of why it's working. We just know it's working. We're kind of trying to guess how it's working, why it's working, and we have all these different kind of theories, but we do not, we haven't been able to describe it in a mathematical formal language.

1:52:20Why this will work or why this will never work. So that's a thing that is remaining for us. And I don't think we will ever be able to describe it in a formal mathematical language. What we will be able to do is we will be able to observe and formulate our rationale about why this system is working, how this system is working and what kind of effect this system is having in our society. That's all we can do.

1:52:49Vlad CosteaYou're right, and I guess this is where that part about possibly becoming a cult comes into play.

1:52:56Rajarshi MaitraYes, yes, it does, it does.

1:52:59Vlad CosteaWe are going to really, really be confident into the qualities of Bitcoin and trust that it works and project this kind of trust into others. And even though it's a trustless protocol that anybody can audit, even I can go into GitHub and check the code, we have to actually trust that the people who are improving it are not going to create some kind of inflation bug, or they're not going to destroy the protocol. And there have been precedents of contentious attacks towards Bitcoin and what it essentially is, as a decentralized network of computers. They try to impose a larger block size, which would effectively increase, decrease the amount of computers that are able to synchronize.

1:53:54Rajarshi MaitraTrue, true. So the system is rigged with all sorts of trade-offs. There are trade-offs here and there. And I don't think there is one single parameter that you can change in Bitcoin that doesn't come with a trade-off. So the trade-offs are everywhere. And this is where the narrative comes in. The narrative that you subscribe to, the narrative that makes it a cult, that narrative says what kind of trade-offs are acceptable and what kind of trade-offs are not acceptable.

1:54:24So that's how the community as a whole should be making decisions, and that's the reason why we should never dilute the core narrative of this protocol, because if we dilute the core narrative of this protocol, we don't have the direction of deciding on these trade-offs. So that is a very crucial point. And also, this trust has to happen. This trust has to happen like it happened for gold. See, in societies where people buy gold jewelry, they don't trust the gold money supply.

1:54:59They don't know where the money supply is coming from. They don't know who is holding how much amount of gold. They don't even know what's the price of gold. But they inherently trust the asset in their gut because they have been doing that for last thousands of years. And every time, it has been proved to work in a timeless manner. The same way you cannot find out a mathematical derivation of why Bitcoin will always work, the same thing happens in gold. You cannot have a mathematical formal derivation of why gold should always store their value.

1:55:40Because you can have all sorts of situations where gold doesn't store its value. For example, you get hit by an asteroid made out of gold, so then it doesn't store its value anymore. Or you make some weird, crazy technical innovations where you change any atoms into gold or something like that. Then it doesn't store its value anymore. So you also don't have these normative derivations in gold, but still people instinctively believe in the properties of gold, in its value transferring mechanism through time, and they don't have to think about it. It's engraved in their psyche, in their subconscious. They just know in their gut that it's a good idea.

1:56:21And that kind of thing will develop in Bitcoin as the propagation and adoption goes, and it is just a matter of time. It's the Cantillon effect. So I think it's the Cantillon effect, or no, or something else.

1:56:32Vlad CosteaThe Cantillon effect is about money being sent first to the bankers.

1:56:39Rajarshi MaitraOh yeah, it's that one. It's that one. So there is another effect. I forgot its name. It says like the more a thing exists, the higher the chance in future it will exist. What's that effect? I don't remember. Butterfly effect? I don't know. Yeah, it's not coming in my head right now. There is an effect like that. I have to look. So it's the same thing. So the more Bitcoin exists, the higher confidence people have that Bitcoin will exist 10 years more. So in 20 years, higher confident people will have that Bitcoin will exist 30 years more.

1:57:13In 50 years, higher confident they will have that Bitcoin will exist 50 years more. So this is how confidence and counter-confidence builds up the capability of society to have trust on a particular kind of asset as a store of value. And that's how monetary mediums emerges out of it. So this kind of thing will happen in Bitcoin, and it is very difficult to precisely figure out or precisely try to predict what exactly we will see, what exactly how it will happen. But yeah, we kind of get a sense, we kind of judge a sense of where this direction can go, and yeah, we just have to wait and watch.

1:57:52Vlad CosteaI'm not sure if I have any more questions for you. This was a very lengthy and well-structured discussion, which somehow came full circle. We started from the idea of gold in India, and we returned to it as a belief system. At first it was a traditional way of storing value, and then we discussed about how gold in itself is a cult in which you believe that it has value. You no longer question its viability on the market. And it's right there. You know that it has value and you're supposed to either hold it or transact it or melt it, because people have been doing it for so many centuries that you can no longer track where it all started.

1:58:38You have no idea why it's gold.

1:58:40Rajarshi MaitraYes. The question of why is not existent in this kind of system. So that's the property of cults. The question of why doesn't exist.

1:58:50Vlad CosteaExactly. So thank you very much for this interview. It was very good, very insightful. I didn't know what to expect when we first started. And even though I guess the beginning was a bit rough, as I was a bit sleepy, it's very early in the morning here and we had to adapt schedules, we ended up having a very good conversation, which...

1:59:15Rajarshi MaitraYeah, me too. It was fascinating talking to you. I look forward to listening to it after the show.

1:59:21Vlad CosteaYeah, me too.

1:59:23Rajarshi MaitraSo I remind myself some ideas which you passed to me, of which I didn't think before. Yeah, it has been fascinating. Every time I have conversations on Bitcoin, I seem to have gathered new ideas that I haven't thought of before. So there are many ideas that I have said that just came to me right now that haven't occurred to me before. And that's why I enjoy talking about Bitcoin, because it opens up in all sorts of different ways that you can't just expect what will happen, where the conversation will go. And that's just fascinating and so much enjoying.

1:59:58Vlad CosteaYeah, exactly. That's why I do this podcast. Not only that I get to brag about it on Twitter, but most importantly, I get to learn.

2:00:08Rajarshi MaitraYeah, true.

2:00:09Vlad CosteaOtherwise, there wouldn't have been an efficient way for me to learn these ideas and understand how it works in India and get an insider's view, basically.

2:00:21Rajarshi MaitraYeah, yeah.

2:00:22Vlad CosteaSo I'm very grateful for this, and I guess I'll publish this very fast. Maybe by the end of the day it will be online, so we can share it.

2:00:30Rajarshi MaitraOkay, yeah. Thanks for having me.

2:00:32Vlad CosteaIf you have any closing statements or maybe you want to say hello to anyone who might be listening to this is your last chance.

2:00:41Rajarshi MaitraYeah, not that way. Just a general statement: stack sats. That's it. That's all you need to do. Stack sats.

2:00:50Vlad CosteaOkay. Have a nice rest of your day and I'll talk to you later.

2:00:55Rajarshi MaitraYeah, have a nice day too. It has been a fascinating conversation. Thanks for having me.

2:01:00Vlad CosteaBye, Raj.

2:01:01Rajarshi MaitraBye.

2:01:01================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one audio/video call in English (early morning for Vlad), opening with a short music intro, no sponsor reads, with a brief connection drop around 00:15:19. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 8 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (160 chunks) and 51 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans; [unclear] resolve pass: 2 of 2 flagged paragraphs re-checked. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed ♪ intro and stray "Thank you"; fixed handle RajarshiMaitra, Byzantine Generals' Problem, rabbit hole, politburo, Bitcoin Talk, Ravi; split interjections (Raj greeting, "Yeah, true. That happens", "Exactly") and restored dropped text (ideologies for 40 years, poetry/songs, Exactly, stepped in) from second ASR; guest relabelled Rajarshi Maitra; Removed hallucination at 00:15:42 and restored dropped speech (influence/2017 No2X) from Qwen+Scribe; removed stray "Thank you." (00:16:40, 00:17:39) and restored dropped lines; restored dropped "this very... randomness" gap and "And this showing off is a very crucial part" and "Look, I have made a necklace"; fixed Nassim Nicholas Taleb, full node, doxxed, sats, stack, "own" (stoned), "looks good", "metal crafts"; split interjections (Raj "Yeah, yeah. Nobody...", "Yeah, that's true", "Yeah, yeah", "Yeah, true, true"; Vlad QR code turn); relabeled Guest A as Rajarshi Maitra; Removed hallucinations ("Gold Stock Exchange" x2, "first part of the video...", stray "Thank you."); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (households passage, three-part private key, gold failed us, "so that they can say these things to the government, like, 'Screw you. I'm not playing'", "not enough need right now", "looking at it and seeing this price rise"); split out Raj interjections ("Right, that's also true", "True, same thing happens here", "Yeah, that's terrible", "True, yeah"); fixed multisig, Romanian leu, Nick Szabo, Elaine Ou, sats, Lightning Network, printing money, gold (not code), live outside, per se; Guest A relabelled Rajarshi Maitra; split Vlad/Raj exchange at 00:50:08 and "Yeah, yeah, yeah. They changed" at 00:53:16; restored dropped text from second ASR/re-check (local news channel, "onto something which is not completely ethical", "religion and the state. So that's a good thing", "incentives", "So you cannot", "even if they heard about Bitcoin"); fixed mosque→mass, fear→fiat, monetary assistance→systems, pinpoint→pain point, bargain→bargaining, HODLHODL→Hodl Hodl, Wazirix→WazirX, local bitcoins→LocalBitcoins, BTC server→BTCPay Server, hard→heard, going→gaining; Removed hallucinations ("The video is a video of the committee", stray "Thank you"/"you"); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (black market passage at 01:08:11, savings line, shackle ending, "It can burn" split, privacy issues, "payment"); split Raj's "I'm not particularly" from Vlad turn; moved "Thank you" fragment; fixed "Angler to Berkey"→anger to bargaining, "red pillar"→red-pilled, import→impart, "regulatory situation", guest label Rajarshi Maitra; "ban" → "not ban" inferred from context; Removed hallucinations ("The video is a video of the BTC community", "The video is available on iTunes...", "The world is changing and growing", "end-to-end"); restored dropped text from second ASR (bank accounts, "the entire human psychology... social engineered", "And in that book", "this is the same thing...", "And when I started thinking"); fi

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00