Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Home / Podcast / S6 E7 / Transcript
Transcript · S6 E7 · 1:38:39 · 7 Sept 2020

S6 E7: Jarret Dyrbye (JD2983) on Lightning Network Development, Sparkshot & Socket Money

With Jarret Dyrbye. Hosted by Vlad Costea.

← Episode page Plain text
Machine transcript, corrected by hand. It can still contain mistakes, so the recording is what counts. Tap any timestamp to play from that moment. Use Cite to copy a timestamped link and a short attribution. Dotted words were hard to make out in the audio.

Search this conversation

0:31Vlad CosteaHello there and welcome to Season 6, Episode 7 of the Bitcoin Takeover podcast. I am Vlad and my guest today is JD, which is the abbreviation for Jarret Dyrbye, who is a Canadian software developer best known in the Bitcoin space for Sparkshot and another project which is called Money Socket. Essentially, these are Lightning Network projects. And I got JD here to explain more about his work, why he does it, what it is, and much more about, you know, anything that he's up to. So hi, JD.

1:24Jarret DyrbyeHi, thanks for having me.

1:26Vlad CosteaIt's good to have a software developer who does Lightning stuff. I feel like lately there's a shortage of Lightning projects, or possibly I'm ignorant to them. What do you think about it? Is Lightning still burgeoning?

1:41Jarret DyrbyeI think Lightning's doing really well. I think maybe the popular narrative of Bitcoin's kind of lost kind of the software development, kind of the work-in-progress aspect of Bitcoin. There's a lot of talk about stock-to-flow ratios or whatever that's got people excited. So I don't necessarily see, you know, a lot of podcasts really covering what's going on in the trenches. But yeah, I think in the trenches, Lightning's very healthy. Lots of cool stuff. Maybe it isn't quite living up to the initial hype, which is kind of natural. I think people got a little overexcited at the beginning. And yeah, we're just in the hard work grind right now, I'd say.

2:20Vlad CosteaYeah, it's good to hear, because I have mentioned this in a couple of past episodes, that there are people questioning the nature of Lightning and its success these days. They just say, "What if we build it and they don't come? What's going to happen? Are we going to have some sort of replacement for the same principles with a different technology? Or are we still going to debate doing stuff to the base layer?" Or, I don't know, are we going to use sidechains like Liquid?

2:50Jarret DyrbyeYeah, there's definitely some questions about like the overall success at this point. But I think the problem is a little more deeper than that. I think the general problem is users aren't really used to using Bitcoin. People speculate on it and they get very excited about it, but they're not necessarily using it to pay their bills or, you know, earn income.

3:24There's certainly a subset of people that are, but I don't think there's a ton of users that have a wallet set up that they're ready to spend on stuff that they'd be buying anyway with Bitcoin. So because I think Lightning reduces it to just that spending element of Bitcoin, there's not a lot to spend on. There's not a lot of users that provide like an ecosystem to service with an application. So we have kind of data on this with Sparkshot, which is a Lightning Network app to, you know, allow users to do micropayments. And yeah, people come and they're experimenting with Lightning.

3:59So they do a couple transactions and then they go away. There's no sort of repeat market of people that are using Lightning apps every day. It's still very much in the experimental phase. So it's kind of disappointing the people that, you know, expected Bitcoin to moon as a result of Lightning. And yeah, we're still experimenting in the cauldron, mixing together different ingredients to find, you know, the recipe of like what Lightning is really useful.

4:30Vlad CosteaYou did mention Sparkshot before, I mean earlier, and I did notice that it bears some similarities with Satoshi's Place, which was an online canvas on which people could draw in exchange for a few satoshis that they had to pay via Lightning Network. I think LightningK0ala was the developer who built that, and it was one of the earliest applications. But I think you really took it to the next level by allowing artists to publish their works. And I can see that artists are identified according to their Bitcoin addresses, which means that they can also receive donations from whoever enjoys their work.

5:20Jarret DyrbyeYeah, absolutely. So I think it's absolutely fair to say that Sparkshot, anybody that's listening can check it out right now, sparkshot.io. It's fair to say that, yeah, we're directly inspired by what we saw at Satoshi's Place. That kind of kicked us off on the thought train that led to Sparkshot. But yeah, we have kind of iterated on the concept. You know, like, don't get me wrong, Satoshi's Place was fantastic. It still is a great app that really showcases what can be done with the technology.

5:52But we, from using Satoshi's Place, particularly like in the first couple weeks after it launched, we kind of had a lot of conversations. So myself and my co-founder, I'm talking Dean, we kind of riffed on what we thought a proper, fully realized app would look like. And kind of extending the Satoshi's Place concept, we ended up with Sparkshot. So yeah, as you mentioned, it allows artists to earn money, in that the basic design of the site is the users pay to reveal pixels. And in the act of revealing pixels, they can also add their creative contributions.

6:34So we've had users write messages and draw stickmen and riff off of other messages that have been written. But it's all serving to reveal and, you know, crowdfund this piece of art from the artist.

6:49So we have, in a very minimal sense, the concept of users. However, they're only identified by a Bitcoin address, so it's still kind of anonymous, but there's no real logins on our site. The users that pay, it's strictly a Lightning payment function. And then the artists that upload, that earn, they're identified by a signed message from a Bitcoin address. So I guess one of the things that you discover in all this, it sort of opens up a world of anonymous art, which is kind of an interesting concept, where you get artists that contribute anonymously and then users that respond to the art in anonymous ways.

7:30We've had a lot of fascinating things that have come out of that, of just the basic design of what we put out there.

7:38Vlad CosteaYeah, it's definitely interesting. Right now I'm looking at a piece of art which is called "The Face of Hal Finney." And it's not 100% revealed, so I would have to pay some satoshis to reveal some pixels on this canvas to be able to see the face of Hal Finney.

8:00Jarret DyrbyeYeah, so that's an interesting thing you can see on that piece of art, is people are starting to riff with Bitcoin-specific kind of humor. And we've seen, based on the art, kind of maybe how people have started out drawing on other pieces of art, they sort of riff in different directions. There's one up there, the dog and wolf, that it was kind of muted colors, so people started drawing stickmen, and based on that, an entire jazz band formed. There's a guy playing a saxophone and the drums, and then people dancing started showing up.

8:40And then on a completely different piece of art, like the face of Hal Finney, people are kind of doing their Bitcoin commentary based on the messages that they post. And we've seen all kinds of different examples go in different directions on this art. So it's very cool to see.

8:58Vlad CosteaIt's just impressive to see how creative people can get. Like you mentioned, dog and wolf. I can see that it has some sprites from Super Mario Bros. 3 and a cowboy, and I think this is Wario from the Nintendo games, and a lot of stick figures, and, as you mentioned, the jazz band, and Bulbasaur from Pokemon. It's just such an eclectic collection of...

9:32Jarret DyrbyeYeah, one, I'd almost call... I don't want to throw shade on Satoshi's Place, but kind of one problem that we saw in the early days, once the bots arrived, is people would spend time drawing very elaborate drawings to kind of show off. Like, you know, very cool art was emerging on Satoshi's Place, but then somebody would paste over it with an ad that was like zero effort. It would kind of ruin the fun.

9:58So part of the idea of making it the base image is something that an artist contributes, and then the act of revealing pixels means that your art isn't going to be stomped by somebody else. It's sort of there for all time because you paid for it. That hopefully encourages, and we've seen a lot of this, you know, the users to invest time and, you know, put time into their message that they put up there.

10:26Vlad CosteaYeah, I'm definitely happy to see that there's some art and there's some artistic expression, and it's enabled by the Lightning Network.

10:37Jarret DyrbyeYeah, it's particularly like we don't care who you are. This is one of the kind of problems with modern social media, is because like spam bots are always a problem, they have to make you log in with an account. They have to track your phone number, because really that exists so that they can ban you if you're misbehaving or you're spamming. And then, you know, so they then develop all these algorithms to basically judge your quality of a user, and sometimes that goes into sort of dark political directions.

11:08So I think one of the innovations that we're just starting to scratch with Sparkshot, Satoshi's Place, certainly other apps in the ecosystem, is we don't care who you are, we just care whether you paid the invoice. If you pay the invoice, that's good enough for us and your message goes up. But then that leads to potentially other problems, where, you know, like Satoshi's Place, there was like porn that went up, and different off-color messages and whatever else, which is maybe fine, but I think that just pushes back on the app designers.

11:40Like, you know, when we're building Sparkshot, how do we set the app up in a way such that things remain tasteful, relatively tasteful anyway? And I think, you know, designs, like, we're inspired also by Reddit, where Reddit has different subreddits. So perhaps if we reach critical mass with something like Sparkshot, we could kind of split it into sections where if you do want perhaps off-color stuff, you know, that's its own subreddit, and then somebody that wants just like clean, you know, blockchain humor or whatever, there would be a section for that as well. So I think this is just sort of a first experiment in social media. I think we're going to see lots of wild stuff happen with this notion of anonymous users, anonymous posting.

12:32Vlad CosteaOh yes, you mentioned social media, and it just struck me that Sparkshot reminds me of Pinterest, and I think also Tumblr. In design, it's very much similar.

12:46Jarret DyrbyeYeah, like the main page, it's sort of there to help you find some interesting stuff. So it's hard. We've had a little bit of volume that kind of helps us, you know, see what art's popular. So we have it ranked by percentage revealed. But we also have some stats to say, okay, what art is hot this week. We're not necessarily putting it on the front page. But yeah, the idea of like finding you content that you might like is one thing. So right now you can sort by artist.

13:20So if an artist has done good work in the past and they put a new piece up, you can just assume that it's good because their last art was good. Stuff like that. But yeah, it's really challenging us to find new ways to reveal, you know, rather than like track everything about you, like knowing what your spending habits are and your political leanings or whatever else, we need to find other ways that help you get matched with the content you might find interesting. So there's sort of a limited amount we can do because there's not a lot of people using Sparkshot right now. But if we got, you know, hundreds of daily users or whatever, some very interesting stuff could start happening.

14:02Vlad CosteaRight, so there are lots of Bitcoin artists out there. And as far as I can tell, Sparkshot enables some sort of 8-bit pixelated art that they can publish. So what's your pitch? How would you convince people who are artists to get on Sparkshot and publish their works?

14:23Jarret DyrbyeSo that's, yeah, that's interesting. So we've reached out to a few artists, like they're aware and, you know, they've liked our tweets and all that. I think one of the problems is artists are already doing their own thing. They already have their style of art and sort of the thing that they've found that their audience responds to.

14:43One of the things we noticed with Sparkshot is the art that embraces the medium the best. I'll point to the top listing right now at the time of this recording, "Territory Conquest Western Continent." It's an art that's sort of been done natively to sort of embrace the pixel format. So it's a picture of a map, and there's ships in the ocean and there's different stuff like castles and all that on the land, but it's done in very nice pixel style. So I think it works on Sparkshot because the artist had a style that fit kind of the pixel nature of Sparkshot, or they just kind of understood what was happening there and they made art that was adapted to the medium. So we've had actually some artists that are recognizable in the space post images, but they post a very large image.

15:29Maybe they don't fully understand, they haven't used Sparkshot, so they find an image off their hard drive and they upload it to Sparkshot, and it's maybe like 500 pixels by 500 pixels, or 800 by 700. So that's almost a million pixels that get thrown up on Sparkshot for users to individually buy, and they'd have to buy quite a bit to even see what the art is. So it just looks exhausting when presented on Sparkshot. So people tend to gravitate towards the smaller pixel-based stuff that, you know, once you buy a few pixels, you can see something.

16:10So people are probably familiar with like Where's Waldo, you know, just sort of that style of art where there's like a big, large drawing where there's lots of little small details. You know, almost like a puzzle where each piece has a little piece of art on it. So I think that type of art is going to work well with Sparkshot. So I'm not necessarily sure that the current batch of, you know, quote-unquote "Bitcoin artists" that are doing Bitcoin art to show at conferences or whatever else, I'm not sure that that's an instant fit.

16:46However, if you go on Instagram or Twitter and you just start searching for pixel art, there's a lot of very cool artists that are doing art that get a lot done in a small amount of pixels. And so on Sparkshot, they could, you know, even price those pixels higher. When we accept an upload, we allow them to set prices. They set a second file, so you can price art up to 16 satoshis per pixel. So if you had a very small kind of, you know, postage stamp-sized art, you can still price it fairly high, assuming that the content is good enough to provide a good experience for the people that are buying it.

17:26Vlad CosteaRight. And I was about to tell the joke that concerns the names of your two services. Okay. And I didn't want to tell you this joke when we were discussing prior to the interview, because I want your reaction to be genuine. So you have two websites, two Lightning projects, and they are called Sparkshot and Money Socket. And if you combine the names together, you get the money shot.

17:58Jarret DyrbyeYeah, so my good friend Pavel from graph.one, he was trying to, jokingly, he also did the money shot joke, because we were talking about, you know, how do you sort of maximize your revenue in that sort of porn and do something a little bit salacious? So that was kind of our joke to rebrand Sparkshot as Money Shot. And well, you can imagine what images might come.

18:33Vlad CosteaOh yeah, that's the right verb, I guess. Might come.

18:39Jarret DyrbyeBut yeah, at this point, we're not open source. It's potentially in the future. But yeah, certainly our idea is more of a tech stack thing, that it would be easy to kind of rebrand it. And then also, like, what we have is sort of a real-time environment. You know, if you wanted to design a similar app that was like a board game, I think, you know, the technology basis we have is quite adaptable to something like that. But yeah, definitely if there is demand for less tasteful images within some bounds or whatever, yeah, somebody could clone this. Maybe we could do like a subreddit type thing. Yeah, I'm not sure what the demand is, though.

19:27Vlad CosteaThis is why you have started Sparkshot, I guess, to test the waters to see how much people appreciate pixelated art and if they're willing to pay to reveal some artistic pieces. I guess this is the greatest experiment of them all. If people are interested in paying for art in an innovative way where it doesn't get revealed in its entirety, but they can get to pick the pixels that they want to reveal, which is more like, I don't know, like a mystery kind of painting reveal or something.

20:09Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I would say so. It took us, you know, more or less two years to develop Sparkshot, and I think our reasons for doing it changed along the way. I think we chose the pixel reveal because that was an easy problem and it was sort of an excuse to build the tech stack. I think once we saw Satoshi's Place, and that kind of made a splash for the couple weeks once it launched, we kind of had the notion, okay, well, like the gold rush is on, like Lightning works, you can build a cool app with Lightning.

20:45So we started, okay, well, we got to get a tech stack, we want to start like a games company or something like that. So we picked revealed pixels, and that would force us to build the tech stack and kind of get it launched. However, I guess you'd say like a year into it, we kind of realized that there wasn't a ton of people doing the exact same thing that we knew of. So I think maybe the focus of the app wasn't necessarily a commercial interest, but I think just, you know, we had to launch it just to kind of blaze the trail, to kind of get some ideas on the table.

21:23Because we were, of course, checking out other Lightning apps and kind of taking inspiration, you know, Satoshi's Place primarily. But yeah, just to like kind of show what it means to build a Lightning app without logins, something that's interactive, something that can do micropayments. And that at least started a discussion. And we can talk about how that went into something like Money Socket and some of the problems that we personally spotted as a result of just launching the app and seeing how users use it.

21:56Vlad CosteaSo what is Money Socket and how would you describe it?

22:00Jarret DyrbyeOkay, well, Money Socket is, in a simple description, it's sort of a way to embed access to your wallet into an application. So for the listeners that are looking at the Sparkshot website right now, if you select pixels and you go to checkout, it shows you a QR code, which then you have to go through sort of the ritual of payment, which probably looks something like you've got to reach into your pocket, you've got to unlock your phone, you've got to find your wallet app, launch it, you got to type in your PIN, you got to wait for it to sync with the network, which some wallets require, you got to find the scan button, you got to press the scan button, you got to scan that QR code, and then you have to do a final confirmation: "Yes, I'm sure I would like to pay."

22:50And then maybe two or three seconds later, the payment will go through and your pixels will be revealed. So right there's about, and we see in our logs, we see that from the time the invoice is created till the time it gets paid is typically about 20 seconds, 25 seconds, when it looks like some random user just showed up at our site to buy some pixels. So people get kind of surprised with the notion of, okay, I gotta pay. Oh, my money's over there and I gotta go dig up my money so I can pay this thing. So Money Socket is sort of our take on the piece that's missing to enable apps like Sparkshot to exist and to do micropayments seamlessly.

23:36So what that would look like is you'd be able to connect your browser to your wallet, whether that's your node, like if you have a myNode in the closet, or whether you have a phone in your pocket, or you're running a full node on your desktop, or if you have like a custodial account somewhere else. You could connect your browser instance to your wallet and it would tell a few things like how much, what's your balance, what's your preferred currency, a couple other things we're discussing.

24:10But on the Sparkshot interface, we could then be able to show you what your balance is. And then when it comes to buying that pixel, be able to trigger that payment automatically. That, of course, opens a can of worms, like, why are you giving permission to an app to spend? So we have a couple answers for that, you know, certainly low amounts. Money Socket is meant for micropayments. We're not talking about coffee-sized purchases. We're talking about sub-cent payments. And then also being able to give the user control on how much they're authorizing to spend. So if you sit down with something like Money Socket or Sparkshot, and you have it set up to point to your wallet, and then you could authorize, say, 1,000 sats for your session, you just click on the pixels you want to buy and they just get bought.

25:11And you can see your balance decrease. And so there's a lot of questions about permissions and all that. So we're kind of going through this ideation phase and I'm building a prototype of Money Socket to fit into stuff like Sparkshot, but also enable an entire ecosystem of similar stuff.

25:33Vlad CosteaOkay, so, Jarret, you are essentially a software developer. I'm not sure what you have done prior to getting into the Lightning Network, but you have found a way to use your skills into a brand new technology for payments, which is very interesting and very scalable and enables a lot of privacy. And why would any software developer like yourself get into Lightning? What is ultimately the incentive to ditch their old job in, I don't know, some sort of corporation like IBM or Cisco or something and get into Lightning and develop something fresh and new and possibly innovative in terms of how it's monetized?

26:25Jarret DyrbyeWell, I could speak for myself personally. I could tell you maybe a little bit about my story. But I had a nine-year career in distributed systems, deep backend stuff. I worked on an enterprise storage product. So something where you configure storage to use like an Oracle database or like a VM cluster or something like that. So actually, I worked for a startup at the beginning of my career that got acquired and then acquired again. And then I was working for one of the corporations you mentioned, but slightly different.

26:59It's a three-letter corporation that is not IBM, but similar. So that's where I found myself when I sort of went down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, as they say, when I started really digging deep into figuring out what Bitcoin was, what it was useful for, whether it had potential or not, or just a bubble. So yeah, I was sitting at my corporate job programming. It wasn't too hard of a job. I was perfectly capable of doing it, but it was a 35-hour-a-week kind of job, right?

27:37So I had plenty of time to go get into trouble on the evenings and weekends. So I was monkeying around with Bitcoin just to kind of learn it. Certainly, I had heard about Bitcoin when it was much earlier and much cheaper. So this is later in the game. But yeah, I had a pretty strong notion that, like, I was obsessed with Bitcoin. And then I had the good fortune of getting laid off from my job. So I kind of was stunned, not, like, it was unexpected.

28:14And I got a decent severance package, so I'm like, "Oh, I should just sit down and work on this Bitcoin thing for however many months." And so that led me to where I am today. So yeah, I guess I've been full-time, somewhat Bitcoin, since the beginning of 2017, was when that story occurred. But yeah, what motivates me? Well, it is a passion thing, I would say. You know, certainly I worked with other programmers that certainly have the skill set. I wouldn't say I'm a particularly outrageously talented developer.

28:52I think there's certainly those people in the space of Bitcoin. I wouldn't consider myself one of them, but there's lots of really good developers that wouldn't touch Bitcoin with a 10-foot pole. So there had to be something that got me and is failing to get other people over the hump to kind of see Bitcoin for what it was. So yeah, I'm not sure. I think a lot of the noise of the space kind of scares people away. I think because developers of that sort of high-end skill set, because they already have six-figure jobs with some big tech firm, why would they leave that to go work for some job where it could go out of business within six months because the space is so volatile?

29:45And then, yeah, everybody on Twitter looks like a nut and probably is a nut. And yeah, I would say that there's quite a lot keeping people away. And I'm not sure how to tackle that other than you just got to show what can be done with Bitcoin and get it out of the context of speculation, to show what systems can be built, and hopefully make the case of why new startups should go do something crazy like Sparkshot or whatever cool idea they have, something to motivate them to quit their job.

30:20Vlad CosteaI think you have mentioned that part about people on Twitter looking like nuts and probably being as such. I think my biggest problem is that we look too much like a cult to outsiders. It just looks like you have different, I don't know what I should call them, like branches of the same church or something. You have the maximalists, you have the multi-coiners, you have those who identify as whatever they want. And you have different schools of thought in regards to how Bitcoin should be used and if Bitcoin privacy should be pursued or if it's just this transparent store of value that you hold.

31:07Pro-taxation, anti-taxation, left-wing anarchists, right-wing anarchists. It's just all over the place. And I think that new technologies in themselves get adopted by the freaks first. So if you think of video games, before we got to this point where playing video games is safe and is part of the norm, we have had all of these outcasts and people who could not get into sports teams, could not do something else, and they found a refuge into this virtual world where they could just play and immerse themselves into games.

31:49And possibly these people are also the ones that developed some very interesting video games that are legendary by today's standards and have earned millions of dollars. And I think it's the same with early Bitcoiners. They are kind of strange and weird. But I'm very much concerned about the fact that we look like a cult and people behave like they're part of a cult and they don't mind it, and they act like, "Oh, let's build a citadel. Let's surround ourselves with huge walls so we keep the outsiders out and we live among ourselves, and only our own kind is worthy of living next to us."

32:31And they are also delusional in thinking that just because people are Bitcoiners and they have some of the same ideas as they do, they're going to end up living peacefully and agreeing with each other. I mean, come on, that's childish. Anyone who's ever been in a relationship and knows how hard it is to get along with somebody, even when you have the best intentions, knows that it's kind of a miracle that any human society still exists and we can still peacefully talk to each other and walk outside without jumping at each other's throat. And then you want to build something from scratch, which has no culture and no norms and only theoretical ideas.

33:17That's my main issue and my main concern, that we don't talk too much about the reasons why we should use Bitcoin, and instead turn this into a cult where Bitcoiners are some sort of demigods and everyone should kiss their feet because they got in early on and they preached the word of Satoshi Nakamoto. And I've even heard in the previous podcast Max Hillebrand saying "Oh my Satoshi," which, okay, I don't mind it, but that's kind of...

33:52Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I would definitely agree. I think part of... You're right that there's sort of like kind of a wacky edge and that's sort of normal for new technologies, new particularly disruptive technologies. But like I think a lot of the choices people make, particularly like when they're launching a product, you know, how they name it, like, you know, Satoshi's Place, I'll pick on it because I think Satoshi's Place is very good. But, you know, to pick a name that sort of signals to the insiders rather than present something to the outsiders.

34:27You can get lots of Twitter traction amongst the insiders by signaling to them. And it doesn't, and that pays off right now. What I hope we turn the corner on is where sort of the attention gets thrown to how do we make products to appeal to the non-converted? Where perhaps, you know, the non-converted don't even know that they're using Bitcoin. Bitcoin's just sort of a minor detail in the background of stuff that's happening. So yeah, that to me is kind of a problem with the space that I'm hoping we flip over at some point.

35:05And I've done my share of doing tech talks to non-Bitcoin audiences, to, you know, I've shown off Sparkshot and a few other projects to just like random local meetups that have a tech focus and just like, yeah, hey, this is a thing I built. It's got Bitcoin in it. Happy to talk about Bitcoin, but I'll talk about the thing I built instead. I think I'd encourage more people to take those opportunities to challenge themselves to, yeah, not necessarily, like, evangelize Bitcoin to somebody else, but to build a product that is targeted at somebody else's problem.

35:41Vlad CosteaOh, I agree with you. Even myself, I'm not a coder, I'm not a programmer, I don't do any that... Actually, I do something that people find subjectively useful. I write articles and that's my main way of making a living. And I wrote a couple of articles, one about Bitcoin and Pokemon, and the other one about Bitcoin and Jim Morrison and the way he would have loved it. And I got a lot of negative feedback from the community, and they said, "Oh, this is stupid. We would never read this." And it's very hard for them to understand that it's not for them.

36:22And it's out there for search engine optimization purposes, so that you associate something that's popular outside of the Bitcoin space with Bitcoin. And some people are going to find it and find some common ground and connections in there. It's like a bridge between two fantasy worlds. And you gotta build it. Someone has to merge these audiences somehow and make it easy to transition from one to the other. But they just don't get it. They expect content to be preaching to the choir and to be pretty much the same stuff that's already been heard.

37:03And if you don't echo the opinions of Saifedean, you're kind of doomed in this space. You end up having disagreements with everyone.

37:13Jarret DyrbyeYeah, that's an important point, is the search engine optimization. That's a heck of an art in itself. I can tell you one story. So prior to Sparkshot, my co-founder and I were working on a site called ForkDrop, forkdrop.io, where we listed Bitcoin forks. And we SEO'd the site. We wrote a bunch of articles that, you know, gave tech guides on how to dump forks and, you know, how to do that safely, how to protect your privacy while doing so.

37:47And the truth is, is like the Bitcoin, the pure Bitcoin articles hardly got any search traffic. Is, you know, the audience of Bitcoin isn't all that big and the people that, you know, presumably these articles would have helped, they kind of already know what they're doing and they can hack it. The articles that got all our search volume were ones that were like had Ubuntu, like how do you run Tor Browser on Ubuntu, Ubuntu live boot, how do I use Tails, stuff like that.

38:21There's all kinds of people that are looking to learn these tools that aren't interested in Bitcoin. However, they can find an article that, you know, somewhat touches on Bitcoin, but it's giving them a useful piece of information otherwise. So yeah, the Jim Morrison, I remember that. I didn't realize it was you that wrote the Jim Morrison article. But yeah, I saw it go by, and it was kind of weird to see. But yeah, it's good to hear you say that, that's for SEO purposes.

38:47There's going to be hopefully hundreds of people that click on that article that maybe they hate Bitcoin and they're just, you know, they like Jim Morrison, they hate Bitcoin, but they're going to read that article, and then you have whatever your 10 seconds to make a point before they click away, right?

39:07Vlad CosteaYeah, that's possible, but it's good to throw all sorts of baits out there. So people may find just a couple of ideas that challenge the preconceptions that they have and make them ask questions about what they think that they know. So if you have these hooks which allow them to possibly read more and get more informed and better understand what this technology is about, then I think that's a net positive. If I anger some people, Samourai Wallet developer, I mean, that's not my purpose, to appeal to somebody who doesn't do anything for me in the end and develops a product that I don't use and for which I have very little esteem.

40:02Jarret DyrbyeYeah, certainly. Yeah, that's a feeling. So when we were trying to market Sparkshot getting launched, we actually did a bunch of outreach to pixel artists, people that had nothing to do with Bitcoin. And they seem to understand the idea, even the payment part of it. But yeah, just like the Bitcoin part of it is just like they tune out at that point because it's complex. It's got all these things. And Bitcoin Reddit has all this drama on it and whatever else. It's hard to get your hooks actually into it if you're just a pixel artist.

40:38So, yeah, I feel that we could do a much, much better job. And I think kind of understanding this set of things as a failure has really informed how I'm thinking about Money Socket as we're brainstorming through those ideas and how to make something that'll actually work to get past the Bitcoin problem, which I can go into if you're interested.

41:01Vlad CosteaYeah, send it over. I can look at it and possibly find a creative use case for it.

41:09Jarret DyrbyeOkay.

41:10Vlad CosteaBecause in the end, I'd rather have, you know, innovation and good ideas and stuff that breaks the bubble and takes us into new territory than the paved road which is safe and has been made safe by people who have been here before. But we still need to innovate. We still need to find new use cases, find out where this leads us eventually.

41:36Jarret DyrbyeOkay. Well, let me just put one idea for the audience with Money Socket. So the way the protocol works is it's advertising how many satoshis you have available. However, it can update, you know, in a split second. It's instantaneous. So if, like, the exchange rate of Bitcoin changes, you can get a notion of, like, a stable value. So if you have 10 US dollars, it'll be constantly changing the satoshi amount to reflect a stable value of 10 US dollars. So that could enable you to build user interfaces.

42:05So if some user is just playing poker and they have an account with some, you know, poker services, and they can connect with Money Socket, they're only going to see 10 US dollars. They're not going to see Bitcoin. So I think that's a user interface problem to, like, you know, fool people into not knowing that they're using Bitcoin. I think that's going to solve a lot of problems.

42:39And then once they've been using it, they can then say, "Oh, wait, this is Bitcoin. How does Bitcoin enable this?" I think stuff like that is like we've barely attempted solutions like that in the space. So I think I'd like to see sort of the next five, 10 years of Bitcoin be, you know, about ideas like that, of how to get Bitcoin out into the world.

42:59Vlad CosteaI mean, I can think of like 10 to 15 people who will say, "Sats the standard. Ditch the US dollars, forget about it, just use sats."

43:09Jarret DyrbyeYeah, that's, and I can kind of see it. I can understand them, particularly like from the political philosophy angle and all that. But like realistically, your grandparents and your parents and your brother-in-law and whatever doesn't know what a sat is. They know what a dollar is. So why are we adding that additional complexity to the conversation when they know what a $10 is? And yeah, it inflates and the value changes over time. But if they spend a dollar and they had $10, they want to see that they have $9.

43:46And then when they open up their phone a week later, they want to see that that $9 is still there. So I think from a practical standpoint, and then I could pivot that to why this is in the interest of Bitcoin maximalists.

44:01If somebody's paying their rent payments and their bills every month in Bitcoin, it settles in Bitcoin, but their balances are in fiat. What that means is that when the price is $20,000 for a Bitcoin, and then it goes down to $3,000, but the expenses during that entire period have been stable at a fiat value, you've increased the demand at the bottom of the market by, you know, several multiples, you know, 20,000 down to 3,000. So you're demanding more Bitcoin at the bottom of the market and potentially less at the top.

44:37And that's going to smooth out the market cycle, which, you know, people also tend to not like it when they lose 85% of their money in the course of a couple months. That's kind of a bad usability experience, in my opinion, anyway.

44:53Vlad CosteaYeah, I think we put too much emphasis on the price, when we should focus more on qualities such as censorship resistance and unconfiscatability, and all of these qualities that are unique to Bitcoin. Otherwise, it's just a financial asset like many others. But for example, I think a lot about censorship resistance, not because I have something that can be censored or should be censored or I'm that politically incorrect or something, but because I have like bad experiences from my family side with confiscation, with money inflation, and all sorts of abuses that have happened across three generations of my family.

45:43I had my grandfathers who lost everything to confiscation from the communists who came to power in 1946, 1947. And then I had my parents who lost their wedding money to inflation in the 90s, and the same money that was supposed to buy them a new car ended up buying them a new couch. And yeah, I mean, it's hard not to think about these examples and then look at places like Argentina. And I know it's cliche by now, but Venezuela, which also has a lot of economic problems and has a lot of inflation.

46:26It's hard not to see that this state-agnostic money, which cannot be confiscated or censored, has some really great use cases and has a great value. But people in the first world, and no offense, you're from Canada, I guess you don't think about this too much. You tend to financialize and compare Bitcoin to the stability of your fiat currency. And I don't know, think about it as some sort of long-term investment.

46:59Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I think in the West, like, so I live in a part of Canada that has lots of Ukrainian and Eastern European immigration that happened around sort of the timeframes you're mentioning. And yeah, certainly my own family history is linked back to some horrors around that time. And it is disappointing in North America because we've had it so good for so long that so much of that memory is lost because, you know, frankly, we have a functioning society that's got robust, somewhat robust democracy. Certainly it's not perfect, but yeah, the confiscatability is starting to, you know, certainly the threats are rising for the people that are paying attention to, you know, what their government balance sheets are looking like in the last six months, for example.

47:53So yeah, I think a good goal for Bitcoin is to, you know, sort of enable your normal salt of the earth, whatever, like a plumber or, you know, some blue-collar type thing. Like how does that, as an independent business owner, how do they take advantage of Bitcoin in some way, such that, you know, if they post the wrong thing on social media or whatever, all of a sudden their company listing or whatever is bombarded by people and all that. And that's, I've had a friend who had that happen to him. He had a, in Canada here, he was exercising some freedom of speech, and he had to take down his company's Facebook page because of people that didn't like it. So I get concerned when that starts encroaching into our banking system. So I think, and correct me if I'm wrong, but in other parts of the world that aren't North America, they think about this stuff a lot more.

48:55If I could ask you, like, what's stopping those people that have a crisper memory from using Bitcoin?

49:05Vlad CosteaSo, what's the question more exactly?

49:08Jarret DyrbyeSo, my experience, as you mentioned, is in Canada, and I would agree with your assessment. But yeah, we hear about Venezuela and, you know, certainly other countries that have their problems that are somewhat more extreme. However, is the adoption really that real? And why can't you make the case to everybody on the street why they need to buy Bitcoin?

49:35Vlad CosteaI mean, I go back to what I've been discussing with John Carvalho, who basically said that you should not try to push people into accepting Bitcoin and explain to them why it's important, because they will use it when they need it. It's the kind of tool that is nice to have, but generally you use it most when you need it the most. And unless you end up in the situation where your credit card company decides to seize operations in your case, because you have published something on social media, and they are so woke that they care too much about it and want to ban you, and you end up in a situation where you cannot possibly access any sort of financial means, that's when you start considering Bitcoin.

50:27Or when you are in cases of severe inflation and you look for alternatives that are weightless and some cartel cannot kidnap you and steal your dollars, that's another case where it's possibly a good idea to consider Bitcoin. Or when you're some sort of woman in Middle Eastern countries where you have no rights and you cannot own property, you should also consider Bitcoin as some sort of hedge against the situation in which you got stuck.

51:03I think essentially the first adopters, after the early wave of speculators, the first real adopters are going to be those who really need to use it. And after we get these, possibly we can move on to a more general adoption. I spoke with Justin Wales this season. It was like two or three episodes ago, and he was a lot, or very much, in favor of ETFs and the idea of institutionalization and being able to invest in Bitcoin funds with your bank and stuff like that.

51:40And he said it's a good way for people to understand how Bitcoin works. And I think I disagree. You know, it should be kept in its purest form and should not be regarded at all times as an investment. It's more like a tool that you acquire for needs that are blocked or at least restricted by your government, or by some sort of local cartel, or by your social status in a society which doesn't allow you to have any rights.

52:19Jarret DyrbyeYeah, so I like to tie it back to, I guess, wallet design, more particular software issues. I guess, like, what I'm feeling, and I guess what I hear you saying is, like, yeah, there's other reasons beyond, you know, network fees that are keeping people away from using Bitcoin. However, once we get there, and maybe, you know, global financial events might lead us there naturally. But I think in a way, Bitcoin isn't ready. And particularly, like, we don't have enough on-chain capacity, so we need layer two stuff to be ready.

52:58That software isn't ready. I think if you show, you know, these regular people a Bitcoin wallet where it's got some, like, you know, base58-encoded text as part of its interface, and they got to manage their network fees, and then, if it's a Lightning wallet, also they got to know what channels are and, you know, how to set them up and how to get connected with incoming and outgoing capacity and all that. It's just like the wallets are super, super complex. And I think if you pull somebody off the street and try to teach them how to use a Bitcoin wallet, like, it's just a non-starter for them.

53:35So that personally has me at least pursuing other avenues of like, okay, what's really wrong with wallets? What's wrong with the sort of the intellectual framework that we're presenting to new users, potential new users? So I'm not sure I have all the answers, but I can at least do my project and hopefully inspire other thoughts to take off. But yeah, I don't see our current ecosystem of wallets really getting ready, or even hardware wallets are still pretty serious intellectual undertakings to learn what they are and how to use them, in my opinion.

54:12Vlad CosteaYeah, and even the most friendly, user-friendly ones can be burdensome and can be dishonest, and that's one of the biggest problems that I have. Because most of them, if you connect to their servers, they're going to store all of the addresses that you generate. They're going to know how much money you have. And if you need to trust them with a secure element or something that they don't control directly, or nobody can check or verify to be sure that the device does what it's supposed to do.

54:47They can even release like a software update to steal some particular user's funds and create some sort of glitch, and then they can say that it's the fault of the user for some reason, because they did not know how to use it properly. So there's a lot of improvement that, or there are lots of improvements that need to be made, even in this field, which tries to be user-friendly. And I agree with you, it's hard to onboard people who don't know how to use applications.

55:25I suppose mobile wallets are the simplest to use, and they come in most naturally to people who have been using services like, I think it's N26, or Revolut, or all of these banking services which rely on mobile applications. So to somebody who is exposed to these services, it's easiest to understand how a Bitcoin wallet works. But then you get into the territory of full nodes and UTXOs and xpubs and everything that Peter McCormack pretends not to understand. And I'm not saying that it's very hard, but it does take some time. It's like, I go back to the comparisons made by John Carvalho. It's like a toothbrush. You get taught at an early stage that it's a good idea to brush your teeth.

56:20And after that it becomes a habit. It's the same with full nodes and with managing UTXOs. I mean, it doesn't come in naturally, but after you figure out why you need to do it, you're going to do it.

56:35Jarret DyrbyeYeah, one direction I think is good is a lot of these, you know, projects like myNode or RaspiBlitz and even like BTCPay Server. So they enable you to do all the non-custodial stuff, but typically they're kind of aware that, like, average users probably just want a custodial solution. Now the difference between that and the banking system is you can be a bank today if you set up BTCPay Server or whatever.

57:05So I think, you know, being able to get the open source ecosystem of stuff that does, you know, your full banking stack and have that, you know, a one-click install potentially, and then, you know, enable, you know, what your existing bank or financial services people to run it. At the same time, if you just have your plumbing business, or if you're a landlord and you want to collect rent or whatever, you can run your own server and be a first party on that banking system. I think that somewhat offends kind of the Bitcoin purists who want everybody to be running a node on their phone.

57:52But from all the usability stuff I've had, seen, tried to, like, teach people to use wallets, like, we're just so far off. And I think we're going to be looking at sort of the Hotmail equivalent of Bitcoin. But rather than making that a Microsoft product or a Google product, that's just got to be an open source project that is easy and simple to set up and run, in my opinion.

58:15Vlad CosteaI mean, that would be ideal. But we have wallets like Coinbase and Blockchain.com, which I think these two are the most popular. They are the ones which have most downloads in app stores. And they're not open source, even though they rely on open source technology for some of the wallet files. And it's kind of worrying to know that users pick these for their first onboarding experience.

58:45It makes you think and ask yourself, why is it that we don't have something that's actually open source and that's actually time-tested, that is very popular and that's non-custodial and has all of the qualities for privacy and at least uses Tor and allows you to manage UTXOs? I mean, that would be ideal. And something that I think is very newbie-friendly on desktop is Wasabi Wallet, and I can't stop singing praises for that project. It's just so good. It got everything right. Maybe people will say that their CoinJoins are not the most effective. They're actually improving in this direction. But for general wallet features, I cannot think of a desktop wallet that's easier to use.

59:39And it's also foolproof in the sense that if you try to use the same address twice, it's not going to let you. Once you generate one and you copy it on the clipboard, it's going to disappear. So only if you specifically want to take that address which you generated and reuse it, that's the only situation in which you can reuse an address. But when you generate it, you always get a new one, and that's precious. Plus, it connects to a full node. Plus, it has UTXO management in a very simple way.

1:00:18Plus, you can set fees, because that seems to be a problem in the beginning with setting fees and understanding why your Bitcoin transaction doesn't get confirmed constantly during the same amount of time, or predictably with the same fee in the next block. And it uses its own observation of the mempool and allows you to just use a bar which you drag. And you don't set the satoshis specifically. You set how long you want it to take until the payment gets confirmed. So you can set anything from two weeks to the next block, or at least the next hour.

1:01:04I think that's the approximation. So if you're a newbie and you're listening to this and you're kind of scared of that Bitcoin cult with people who want to live in citadels and stuff, just try Wasabi Wallet. It's a great gateway drug later on to try Bitcoin Core, which I'm not sure if it's more advanced. It's more advanced if you decide to use that command line feature that it has. But other than that, I think Wasabi is excellent, and you should give it a try.

1:01:38Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I have not used Wasabi. I've seen screen tutorials of it just so I could understand what's going on there. I haven't used it myself. But I think, like, I have had the experience of an exchange freezing my funds, like a non-trivial amount, and them telling me I need to prove where I got the coins. And yeah, so that's happened to me. I don't think that's happened to every Bitcoin user yet. I think also people that are paying attention, they're seeing that, yeah, Coinbase, if Brian Armstrong doesn't like you or what you're doing, he'll shut down your account.

1:02:08I think one of the heartening things about the state of Bitcoin is we do have that open source stack coming together. So maybe that plumber that starts with a Coinbase account, he gets shut down and then, you know, he realizes, oh, well, I can just, like, run my own bank and interface with all the payment software that my customers already have. So why do I need Coinbase, particularly if they're going to put my business at risk or stuff like that? So, yeah, Wasabi has been a cool project to see evolve.

1:02:46I haven't used it myself, but yeah, I think it's good. I also haven't used Samourai Wallet. But again, like, these are probably, in the long run, these are back-end technologies that some service provider is going to be running, but the end user is probably not.

1:03:07Vlad CosteaActually, it's funny because you're from Canada, and one of the Canadian Bitcoin exchanges, Bull Bitcoin, has integrated the Wasabi open source standards to basically CoinJoin all of their transactions, so that they break the link between the payer and their bank accounts. Actually, Bitcoin accounts, not bank accounts. So it's very difficult for any kind of state authority to determine which bitcoins have come from whom, who has made the payment. It's a smart way of eliminating this tracking that can be done on the Bitcoin blockchain because it's an open ledger.

1:03:54And they are using that, which is derived from Wasabi Wallet. And I forgot to mention that another feature that this wallet has is Tor integration, which means that each time you connect, it's going to hide your IP address and generate a new route, which allows you to get a new identity.

1:04:15Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I would say every Bitcoiner out there that's not up to speed on what Tor is and how it works, download Tor Browser and go figure it out, because it's very, very important technology. I think most Bitcoining should be done through Tor, if you have the option, which, if you know how to use it, you do.

1:04:38Vlad CosteaI mean, it's not perfect by any means, but it's just good enough, and it depends on your threat model. And I spoke about this with Peter Todd, who also happens to be Canadian. There's a lot of Canadian references in this episode. But he said that if your threat is your government, you probably should not use Tor, or especially if you're American, because the Tor Foundation is founded by the Department of State in the United States. There might be some CIA involvement, and they might de-anonymize the exit nodes to figure out who does some sort of illegal activity.

1:05:21But this is all being done because they hate some other overseas regimes. So Tor can actually be a very good instrument to escape the censorship from, I don't know, anywhere from Russia to China, to Gulf countries that might be in the middle of warfare. And as far as I know, it's also a popular tool in embassies, and diplomats use Tor to anonymize and encrypt their communications. So if you're down with that, and you just want to hide your information from companies that process your data, like, we have Google and Amazon and Microsoft, and I think Yahoo is obsolete by now, but there are these internet companies that take your data and monetize it and sell it and try to profile you wherever you go and track you across multiple websites.

1:06:23And you can trick them with Tor. And you also have Bitcoin companies that have figured out how to use your data and how to sell it and how to market it, and Coinbase is one of these bad actors, and we have seen news reports about them selling this data to the CIA. And we also know that they have basically acquired a company that's called Neutrino. This happened last year. And Neutrino is associated with Hacking Team, a team of Italian hackers who are best known for working with authoritarian regimes that were trying to track down freedom fighters.

1:07:04And imprison them and punish them. And they were basically very much against universal human rights. And some of the same people who were working on that project are now trying to track down Bitcoin transactions, which is insane. It's something that we should not encourage. And if we get to vote with our dollars or our satoshis or whatever kind of money that we have, it's possibly the best idea, once we become aware of how Bitcoin works, to get out from Coinbase, to move our coins into any other form of sovereign storage.

1:07:42It doesn't matter if it's a paper wallet, if it's a hardware wallet, if it's some sort of hot wallet that's on your phone but allows you to hold your keys. Really, just consider moving away from Coinbase. And just for the record, I don't really recommend hot wallets because they are most exposed to attacks. But I don't recommend holding your coins on Coinbase either, even if it seems the safest, and you can argue that it was never hacked. That's what they said about Binance. Last year, I think, you had CZ Binance proposing to roll back the Bitcoin blockchain because he lost money. So I wouldn't trust in anything to be 100% secure.

1:08:30Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I'd agree with all that. I'll echo Peter Todd's concerns about Tor. I think, you know, he's, I recall him saying this in some podcasts, but, you know, make no mistake, Tor, the project, is centralized in the way that we understand decentralization. So all the concerns and conflicts that you have with centralized blockchain projects, Tor has all those, because there are literal people in a building working on Tor that are funded through centralized means and even government means. So yeah, Tor is not a panacea.

1:09:06I think there's, in the Lightning Network, there's, you know, people playing around sending messages through the Lightning Network. There's at least a suspicion that the technology of Lightning Network can lead towards, you know, a decentralized message passing system that uses, you know, the economic incentives to protect against spam and all that. So I believe there is hope, particularly, like, the more interest and more economic concern there is in, you know, protecting your privacy. So I think, yeah, Tor is an incremental step to get to where we need to go.

1:09:44But yeah, it's not perfect, but it is much, much better than just using the clear internet, I would expect from everything I know. But yeah, there certainly is. It started with the US Navy, and yeah, it's been heavily funded. And yeah, just the funding sources. Another thing to keep in mind is, yeah, not everybody in the technology industry is a free market capitalist, particularly when it comes to open source projects like, you know, Debian and Linux.

1:10:23And all these other things, that there's a lot of people from all ends of the spectrum, and they don't necessarily like Bitcoin. And they don't like Bitcoin running on their systems and these kind of things. So yeah, don't assume that everybody in privacy or all that likes Bitcoin, that they could have, you know, other motives, in other ideologies that exclude Bitcoin. Yeah.

1:10:51Vlad CosteaRight, so I feel like we should get back to Money Socket and Sparkshot. What's the future for them? How do you envision these projects maybe six months to one year from now? Do you think that a bull market that some people say is emerging or is inevitable or whatever, would that change the number of users that you have on a daily basis?

1:11:18Jarret DyrbyeThat's the hope. I've certainly tempered my expectations. I'm not sure every new Bitcoin convert is going to be ready to be flinging Lightning microtransactions immediately. There's quite a lot to learn once you get into it, and then you get distracted with other, more volatile investments. So yeah, I kind of feel that there's kind of a silly season upon us where maybe not a lot of super productive work will get done in the next two years, let's say. But yeah, for Money Socket, I'm planning to spend, you know, sort of the winter working on it.

1:11:55I've kind of cleared the deck to, you know, fully expand kind of the ideas under display. I've got a prototype running, but, you know, I'm kind of refactoring it and there's new ideas that are factoring in. So I think, yeah, it deserves a good six months of my attention. Certainly, like, if anybody else is interested in these ideas, certainly, like, it's an open source project. But yeah, right now it's kind of just me bootstrapping everything. But yeah, I would like to see other projects too. There's the LNURL project that's doing interesting stuff too.

1:12:30I'm not necessarily fully on board with, like, all their aesthetic choices and all that, but it's something people are excited with, and they're really doing the cool experiments to really figure out the tech. So yeah, check that out too. And I'd hope there's something when it comes to usability, and particularly usability and open source, there's always infinite amount of projects that always emerge. Like, if anybody's a Linux user, like, there's all these desktop environments and even, like, distributions of Linux, but, like, more specifically, the desktop environments: there's KDE, there's GNOME, there's MATE, there's Cinnamon, there's XFCE, there's, like, tiling window managers.

1:13:13There's almost a necessary amount of chaos that needs to happen to really figure out usability. And when it comes to Bitcoin, I kind of expect it to take a similar arc of, it's going to take 15 years of, like, just crazy scrambled eggs type stuff to kind of figure out how to use Bitcoin in an effective way. And then it'll kind of get to the point where, like, the Linux desktop is now, where there's all these choices, but it all interoperates. It's all very composable, and you can kind of build your usability experience you want. So I think, yeah, I'm aware of all that working on Money Socket.

1:13:52I wouldn't sell it as the be-all end-all, but I'm in the experimental phase and I'm trying to tune out the noise of the space. So whatever happens in Bitcoin, I'll just kind of duck my head and work on some software. And yeah, hopefully the maximalists won't get too angry at me and the altcoiners won't be knocking on my door looking for something. I just want to get the code written and get those ideas. Because with this excitement, I think we've learned in the space, like, when people get irrationally excited, we get an 85% correction in the next six months.

1:14:30So I think my mind's already turned to, okay, well, what am I going to do after the 85% correction happens? How do we keep the, you know, the pedal to the metal, let's say, during the next bear market? How do we take what we've got now and level it up, such that we can hopefully create the next price movement that's more based on fundamentals, more based on people using it? So yeah, I know for the listeners, getting up to speed on Bitcoin is a lot. But yeah, don't get too excited that we're going to, like, end the government or build our citadels or whatever else. I think there's a lot of work that needs to be done.

1:15:13And we're going to see, I think, a couple more 85% corrections between here and then.

1:15:19Vlad CosteaI mean, you're kidding, right? We are obviously always in a bull market and we're going to a million dollars per coin, a hundred trillion market cap in like 10 to 12 years. And we even have a graph which displays how the price has increased in the past. And obviously it's going to follow the same pattern, because that's how, you know, anything works, and that's what we have seen in history with predictions, that they always turn out to happen just the way that we expect them.

1:15:45And there's no negative events that can stand between us and having a million dollar Bitcoin, because, you know, it happens by itself. It's meant to be. It's hard-coded. It doesn't matter if we actually spend time trying to promote the technology or develop it or build interesting stuff. These people will add the red dots to their descriptions on Twitter and think it's happening.

1:16:17Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I listened to your Eric Voskuil, one of your recent podcasts, and he went into depth on that. So I'd recommend your listeners check that out. But yeah, like, I kind of, because I've kind of become cynical in Bitcoin because I've been around it long enough. Yeah, it seems like we invented this entire ideology or ethos where, like, demand doesn't matter, it's just magic internet money that goes up. And I think on some level that offends some of the developers that are putting in, like, a lot of work to add, you know, increase the demand of Bitcoin, you know, to actually add that utility.

1:16:55So yeah, to me, the stock-to-flow measure and all that, like, it's nonsense economics, because it's not measuring demand. And what I see actually happening is people are just marketing Bitcoin to their friends. So yeah, we can create speculation demand if we, like, you know, give people misleading thoughts about what the future might look like. And then, yeah, if you get all your friends to buy Bitcoin, the price will probably go up, and it might start a snowball effect, and we might get a 20X price bump, but then we're going to get an 85% correction. So yeah, that's one of the... And I'd also recommend people check out the SayBitcoiners Twitter account.

1:17:37It's run by Rusty Russell, who's a highly decorated open source developer prior to working on c-lightning. He's sort of one of the lead devs of c-lightning. But yeah, that's sort of his venting account where he makes fun of all the citadel memes and all that. And yeah, if you go listen to, you know, actually deep dive and listen to Rusty on podcasts, particularly when he's talking about the history of open source, is, yeah, we've seen stuff like this happen, where people get sort of irrationally exuberant with new economics, like, you know, the notion in the '90s that Microsoft was going to be destroyed by Linux.

1:18:17That all we got to do is do this open source thing and, yeah, Microsoft will go away, and we'll sort of live in this, like, kind of open source utopia, where developers will get paid and they'll have no bosses and they'll be valuable anyway, and the software will be amazing, and Microsoft and whatever boogeyman of the day is going to go away. So Rusty, somebody like Rusty, has lived through that. Certainly, I'm a bit younger, I think, but I've sort of been a student of that history as well, and that kind of inoculates you a little bit from getting too ahead of yourself and how fast the world is going to go.

1:18:58The world's going to change as a result of something like Bitcoin.

1:19:03Vlad CosteaYeah, I feel like we should level our expectations. I did onboard some people, so a few months ago, I was on Kaiser Report, and I spoke about my research into hardware wallets. And I did get some emails from people who are curious about getting into Bitcoin for the first time. And I told them, just level your expectations, know why you're buying this, and don't have any kind of expectations other than having uncensored, uncensorable and unconfiscatable money. These are the use cases, these are the advantages that this has over any kind of other investment, which might go up a lot more, like stocks and stuff like that.

1:19:51And the data this year so far is in favor of stocks, and has been since the Trump presidency, I guess. So I don't recommend anyone to speculate on Bitcoin. If it happens that the price goes up, I don't want that to be the determining factor to stick around. This has to do with something that's actually useful and goes beyond ideology, goes beyond anything that people conceive and think in terms of economics. This has to do with usability. And I'm not going to go Roger Ver and pretend that it's all about making transactions on the base layer for very small fees.

1:20:41Because that's stupid. And you're supposed to make the network become sustainable in collecting fees at some point, and build a market for it as the block reward diminishes. So that's very short-sighted. But I do think that this is a very secure network which serves a very good purpose for maintaining the qualities of private property. And I actually wrote an article in which I argued that Bitcoin as a network is better at securing your private property than most governments that will gladly confiscate what you have and take away everything from you. When you become an enemy or something, or you live in a tyranny where it's forbidden to own some sort of, some sorts of property.

1:21:34Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I think the point to take away is all these cynical kind of, you know, anti-citadel kind of notions, and there's a bunch of people that are sort of an undercurrent of Bitcoin. We're all still working on Bitcoin. Bitcoin's amazing. But yeah, we just gotta temper the expectations, and certainly the people that have done it long enough have lived through at least one major bubble where we've just seen just utterly absurd things happening and people expecting the government to fall within the year and stuff like that. And people earnestly saying these things to you and not taking any sort of contrary point.

1:22:13They're not listening to any sort of sanity, and these are like Uber drivers and whatever else. Not to pick on Uber drivers, but they're sort of the stereotype of people that just learned about this and they're into altcoins. I've talked to all those people, and they've all gone away as the price has gone down. So I'm expecting that to come again. And I guess part of the mindset I'm in is I'm just gonna duck and cover and avoid those discussions. I engaged in them last bubble and, yeah, don't necessarily have the same energy.

1:22:49So hopefully a new generation of people can pick that up and find, to inject some sanity and hopefully help people not get hurt too badly by bad investments. But yeah, I think there's a lot of work to be done for developers, people like Rusty and, you know, Lightning developers and myself, who I'd consider a developer doing interesting stuff. So yeah, we just gotta avoid the noise. And Bitcoin, the core of Bitcoin, all the Core developers, all the Lightning Labs people and the people around these various Lightning projects, I think they're all pretty much in the same heads-down focus mode right now. So I think that's really bright. But the fruit of those labors are still probably 5, 10, 20 years off, in my opinion.

1:23:44Vlad CosteaOh, that's possible. And I'm also taking into account the fact that it might take our entire lifetimes until we get to the so-called Bitcoin standard, or at least we get some sort of fiat currencies that get issued on the basis of Bitcoin reserves, which would be very nice if it happened. But we have yet to see something like this, and it's very hard to believe since governments kind of enjoy being able to print their own money and regulate the financial policy according to whatever they think is fit in the moment.

1:24:25I think one of the reasons why I'm still here is that governments have this arbitrary nature in which they only think in the short term, and it has become very hard for them to say no to a lot of ideas. So there's no rolling back, really, once you open the doors for something like universal basic income, even though I think we're not ready for it. And it's not, we have not reached the point where we don't have human labor and we have replaced it with automatic machines.

1:25:03But it's still going to be interesting to see how these two very contrasting worlds develop, because we have Bitcoiners who are very hardcore Austrian economists for the most part, and they study economics and they believe that every labor should be useful and we should try to be productive members of society and actually add value to what we do. And then we have the readers of John Maynard Keynes who will say, you know, we should pay those who dig the holes and just put all of that mud back to cover the holes.

1:25:47There is value in that and we acknowledge it as a society. Even if we are not evolving, we should encourage that sort of employment, and when it's all gone, we should just give money to people for meaningless tasks that they perform and allow governments to acquire even more power. I mean, I can rant about it all day, but you can see where this is heading. I think this world of Bitcoin is parallel to the fiat system. A lot of people try to build bridges and create financial institutions and stuff like that.

1:26:25I don't think it's beneficial to Bitcoin. I don't like the idea of companies like BlockFi or Celsius, which deal with fractional reserves and lead to this financialization.

1:26:41Financialization. I hope I pronounced that right. It's a very difficult word for me as a non-native English speaker. But I just don't like them. I think that we can even have inflation on the market, but not on the Bitcoin blockchain. Inflation in terms of the number of bitcoins being traded on the market and these financial institutions. And I read a blog post by BlockFi and they said, you know, 100x leverage has been around before we even started. But the more institutions you get doing fractional reserves, the worse it's going to get.

1:27:20Jarret DyrbyeYeah, I think that's a key point about non-blockchain inflation. In Canada here, we had QuadrigaCX, which I'm sure most people have heard of, which was an exchange that went down in dramatic fashion with the CEO apparently perishing in India. But yeah, in the postmortem of what happened there is basically, yeah, he didn't have the Bitcoin. So there's a bunch of people that thought they had Bitcoin, but they didn't have the Bitcoin. And then when the company failed, which wasn't a super well-run company, that Bitcoin went away.

1:27:55And yeah, I've talked to victims of this episode because we're in Canada, people have come by our Bitcoin meetup who lost significant amount of money in Quadriga. And yeah, they talk like that was real Bitcoin, but it wasn't real Bitcoin. It was just some database that this kid had set up to make them think that they had Bitcoin. So yeah, people need to be aware that there's more than 21 million Bitcoin out there right now in people's heads.

1:28:27So, yeah, do manage your own security. The other point I'll make is, yeah, the inflation, the fiat world has kind of almost become as insane as Bitcoin. It's like it all, particularly in the last six months, like I'm in Canada. I live, I'm not a rich man. I live fairly lean to enable myself to work on Bitcoin. So the government thinks I'm a poor person, so I'm just getting checks from the government. And they're talking about these universal basic income things up to 2,000 Canadian a month, which is basically like 1,500 US dollars a month.

1:29:12And it's basically just like a vote-buying scheme. We got sort of a left-of-center government here in Canada. They don't have a strong majority. Yeah, they're just going to buy our votes now, I guess. And that, I guess, kind of helps me, you know, pay my bills as I work on Bitcoin. But yeah, I'm not sure that that means particularly good health of our financial system. And, you know, am I going to be able to go to a restaurant ever again is actually a question in my mind at this point. Either the restaurant's not going to exist or it'll just be too restrictive that it's just not worth the trouble.

1:29:52So these are questions that have occurred in the last six months. And yeah, Bitcoin is almost tame by comparison. I don't know what your experience in your country is, but yeah, in North America, things are very crazy. Australia also looks quite insane right now.

1:30:12Vlad CosteaI mean, in here it's like the authorities are very much concerned and they tell us to distance ourselves and wear masks and stay at home. But when you get out, you see people not respecting any kind of rules. And I think the only kind of rule that we do respect is that when we walk into public institutions or private shops, for example, where they ask you to wear a mask, we do it out of courtesy. But outside we're not supposed to wear masks, so you barely see anyone wearing one.

1:30:50Plus, I'm not sure how these paper masks actually stop the spread of something which is a lot tinier and can penetrate the tissue. So yeah, I don't know, I guess it's kind of absurd here in Romania. We have some recommendations, but 90% of people that I see don't really respect any of them. And the number of cases used to increase to up to 2,000 new discoveries a day. But now the testing has also slowed down. Comparatively, in statistics, I think we have had less deaths this year than we had last year.

1:31:39So it's quite possible that we have become much more cautious and we have eliminated some other risks due to this new virus. And I do hope that it's going to go back to normal. Possibly, I think the plan, even if they don't want to talk about it and it's an unpopular opinion, the plan is to just get some sort of herd immunization, so that we all get sick at some point, but not all of us at the same time.

1:32:14Jarret DyrbyeYeah, they have mandatory mask indoors here, which I just do it to so I can get my damn groceries and get out of there. But yeah, it really, it's quite the thing. In particular, all the politics that also get intermixed, to tie back to Bitcoin, the crypto Twitter, the fact that everybody now has to have a political stance on what they think about masks or this and that or the government. It was almost like this COVID thing was a jump-the-shark moment for a lot of crypto Twitter for me.

1:32:53And I've talked about this with my friends, that I think, you know, our political situation that we see today, I don't think there's anything we can do about it as Bitcoiners. I really don't. I think, and this goes back to the low time preference, is the political system and the authority that sort of our fiat overlords have, that's the result of stuff that happened in our parents' generation and before, is system got set up in a certain way that, you know, the municipal bylaws and whatever else that can ban you and, you know, shut down restaurants and all that, that was all set up, you know, before your time.

1:33:36I think, you know, kind of the cypherpunk ethos is, yeah, you just write code and you change how the future is gonna go. And I think that to me at least empowers me to feel like I have some control in this frankly quite wild situation, is if I sit down and write code, I cash those government checks to buy groceries, okay, whatever, that hopefully for the next generation, things will be a little bit better. At the very least, if fiat's still around, there will hopefully be the Laffer curve when it comes to taxation. If the taxes are too high, people will figure out how to avoid them. I think that's ultimately how we get to a point of better liberty and a better experience for all. I think yelling about politics of the day and talking about your citadels on crypto Twitter, that just seems non-productive and non-fruitful.

1:34:40So I've personally unfollowed a lot of people, almost directly after this COVID stuff started saturating my Twitter feed.

1:34:52Vlad CosteaI think I know what you mean. And I don't think I have a clear opinion on what's going on. I believe that there are pieces of misinformation on both sides of the debate. Clearly everyone tries to push an agenda and have some sort of story to tell about why the others are trying to do something. I don't think anyone has bad intentions, but being stuck between two extremes is kind of an interesting situation. Anyway, I wanted to ask you, how can people follow you on Twitter and talk to you and ask you questions about your projects and possibly interact with the applications that you develop on the Lightning Network?

1:35:41Jarret DyrbyeOkay, well, first, the easiest thing for people to do is go to the sparkshot.io or sparkshot_io Twitter account. And there's links to Telegram and Discord if you're on those platforms. Get in those rooms, because what it does is it echoes all the purchases. It renders a nice image of the pixels that have been purchased and posts it to those chats. So you can kind of follow what's going on. So if you're passively interested in something like Sparkshot, just do that and, you know, check in once in a while to see what people are doing. I think it's very interesting. But personally, my personal Twitter account is JD2983. That's 2983. And then also, yeah, in my bio, I have links to the Money Socket project, which also has a Telegram chat. So yeah, follow any of those, whatever you're interested in. I'd be happy to talk about these concepts or more specifically about Money Socket in some of the Telegram chats.

1:36:40Vlad CosteaThat sounds good. I mean, I would want to see these projects evolve in time and see how far art can make it into this space, and more specifically pixel art, which is like a subcategory of Bitcoin art. And I don't think many developers are into it right now, and by developers I mean artists. But at some point in the future, you can never be so sure. I grew up with 8-bit graphics. I used to play on my NES clone. I feel kind of nostalgic when I see this.

1:37:18I still enjoy to see how creative people can get with such limited artistic means of expression. And if you're listening to this, you should definitely give it a shot. As an artist or as an observer or admirer of art, you should check it out. And also, JD, thank you very much for joining this episode. It was very good to talk to you about your projects and then complain and whine about some popular Bitcoin activities, which can be relieving. It's like releasing some valves, I guess, venting about stuff that is beyond your control. And I hope that I get to hear good news about your projects in the future.

1:38:12Jarret DyrbyeYeah, well, thanks for having me on your show. It was a fun conversation. And yeah, we'll be continuing on. And hopefully in the future, when I have something more tangible to show with Money Socket, hopefully I can get some exposure in the media channels for Bitcoin. And I think it'll be interesting to show once it's ready.

1:38:33Vlad CosteaSo thank you very much. I'll talk to you later.

1:38:37Jarret DyrbyeYep. Thank you.

1:38:37================================================================================ Production notes: Remote one-on-one English-language conversation between Vlad Costea in Romania and Jarret Dyrbye in Canada, opening with a short music intro and containing no sponsor reads. Correction: anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 via NanoGPT in 6 windows with a whole-episode speaker/glossary plan, the show notes, the Qwen3-ASR full pass (133 chunks) and 56 Scribe v3 re-checks of doubtful spans. Automatic checks: word count vs raw, timestamps, seam duplication. Fixes: Removed ♪, "Episode:" tokens, "I'm going to go ahead and start the show.", "And we're going to be doing a lot of", "Bye.", stray "Thank you." and doubled-word stutter; split "Hi, thanks for having me" as Jarret's turn and moved "use sidechains like Liquid" to Vlad; removed injected "Jarret Dyrbye:" label; restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (00:03:24, 00:06:49, 00:09:58, 00:11:08 onward, 00:13:20, 00:14:43, 00:15:29–00:17:16); fixed Jarret Dyrbye, Sparkshot, LightningK0ala, Hal Finney, Liquid, sats/satoshis; relabelled Guest A as Jarret Dyrbye; split long monologues with interpolated timestamps; Speaker labels Guest A → Jarret Dyrbye; split "Okay, well" to Jarret at 00:22:00; restored dropped text from second ASR/Scribe (made a splash/launched, invoice created/paid, trigger payment automatically/can of worms, "So there had to be something that got me", "hopefully make the case"); fixed Sparkshot/Money Socket/SocketMoney, myNode, Satoshi's Place, sats; removed stray "." and "-" segments (00:26:24, 00:30:18) and trailing "Yeah"; "the money shot joke" garble fixed; Speakers fixed (Guest A → Jarret Dyrbye; "Episode:" label at 00:37:47 is Jarret); restored dropped speech from Qwen/Scribe (00:35:05 end, 00:37:13 ForkDrop SEO, 00:38:21 Jim Morrison passage, 00:40:38 Money Socket sentence, 00:47:x "functioning society", 00:47:53 ending); removed "Thank you"/"How fast?" hallucinations; Max Hillebrand, Saifedean, Samourai Wallet, Money Socket, Sparkshot, Tor Browser, Tails, sats; 1946, 1947; moved "sats" to Vlad's line; split Jarret's "Okay" at 00:41:09; Speaker repairs: 00:48:55 split Jarret/Vlad/Jarret; "Yeah, I would" moved into Jarret's 01:04:18 turn (timestamp shifted slightly); "do it" kept with Vlad. Restored dropped speech from second ASR/Scribe at 00:49:08, 00:50:20, 00:51:40, 00:53:35, 00:56:58, 00:57:52, 01:01:29. Removed "Thank you." fragments, "Thank you for watching... Bye.", injected "Jarret Dyrbye:" and repeated "Jarek Dyrbye:" labels. Fixed N26, Tor (Doors), citadels, myNode, RaspiBlitz, BTCPay Server, Samourai Wallet, CoinJoin, Blockchain.com, xpubs, Hotmail, burdensome; Speakers fixed (Guest A → Jarret Dyrbye, continuations labelled); restored dropped speech from second ASR (CIA/selling data, Lightning messaging, usability/Linux desktop, citadels, stock-to-flow passage); removed hallucination "We are very happy to be here today...", "Episode:" token, "*sniff*", duplicated "going to go"; fixed Tor, Neutrino, Coinbase, Money Socket, Sparkshot, Eric Voskuil, c-lightning, SayBitcoiners, XFCE/MATE, "literal people"; split long turns; Speaker repairs (Guest A → Jarret Dyrbye; Jarret's reply split from Vlad at 01:21:34; final "Yeah,"/"Yep. Thank you." to Jarret); restored dropped speech from second ASR/Scribe (anti-citadel passage, Quadriga postmortem, political/cypherpunk passage 01:32:47–01:34:00, Sparkshot follow-up); removed "Bitcoin.com" loop, doubled "Thank you" hallucinations and stray "The first thing I want to say"; fixed Qua

← Back to the episode · All transcripts · Ask the Archive

0:000:00