Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S16 · E18 · 3:40:31

S16 E18: Rockstar Dev & Max Hillebrand on Privacy

10 Apr 2025 · by Vlad Costea · 12 min read
Published at block 891,793
Cover art for S16 E18, Rockstar Dev & Max Hillebrand on Privacy
MP3 (303 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript28,370 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

"Either you remove info or you add information," Max Hillebrand said, about two and a half minutes into the show, and then he gave me the line I have been repeating ever since: "That's, I guess, the two main strategies of privacy. Shut up or get cover traffic." Max, the former CEO of zkSNACKs and one of the loudest privacy advocates in Bitcoin, sat in a Google Meet call with Rockstar Dev, the BTCPay Server and Strike contributor who is also an advisor to BTC Inc. We were live for 3 hours and 40 minutes.

Rockstar had a slogan ready before we got past introductions: "no privacy, no freedom." He has been building on BTCPay Server and Strike for eight years, with Lightning and Ark in his current toolbox, and he described what he wants from CoinJoin as "making a protocol out of CoinJoin, essentially." Max, for his part, has spent a good part of his career on Wasabi Wallet. Between them they cover most of what interests me about this corner of Bitcoin, and I did not manage to keep them on a single topic for more than twenty minutes, which is how it should be.

Shut Up or Get Cover Traffic

Max's framing deserves a second pass, because everything else in the episode hangs off it. Privacy, as he sees it, comes in two flavors. You stop leaking (encrypt, don't register, don't post) or you drown the real signal in fake signal. CoinJoin is the second kind, and so are mixnets, which he later called "a quite substantial improvement over onion routing."

He was also the one who reminded us that cryptography only gets you part of the way. "Even if you have crazy sophisticated cryptography, you can still be totally fucked on the network layer," he said. His wish list for Nostr clients is a good example of what he means: "I would love to see Nostr clients that, for example, create a new Tor identity for each pub key that they query via WebSockets from Nostr relays, etc."

Max went on to say that "Privacy gets so much easier when the people who build the tools and protocols have considered privacy in the design of the tools." Rockstar, who spends his days on payment software, agreed and added that tooling for ordinary merchants lags far behind what privacy people use themselves.

I will admit I was a little annoyed at how easily the two of them agreed on the basics. I had come in expecting at least one fight about whether we need KYC-free coins at all, and I did push on it. I was told, more or less, that I was asking the question from inside a bank account that had not been frozen yet. Fair enough, though the Kraken story comes later.

The Billboard and the Bathroom

Early on Max teased Rockstar that "your billable hours for shilling BTCPay are quite substantial." Rockstar took it well: "there is also a running joke that I'm like a walking billboard of BTCPay Server." He wore the logo for most of the stream, and I will not pretend it did not work on me.

That led to a question I had been saving since BTC Prague 2023. Rockstar asked about the Wasabi branding in the restrooms there, and Max confirmed it was a low-cost advertising choice. His reasoning: "Nobody wants to advertise in the bathrooms, right?" so the space was cheap. And "in the toilets, people want their privacy," which he considers a perfect fit for the product.

I pointed out that stickers in a stall are the only ad format where the audience cannot scroll past. Max did not dispute that, and neither of them could name a better cost per impression in Prague that year.

Does a Dead Company Kill a CoinJoin?

The zkSNACKs question was one I had planned to ask since before I even booked Max. The coordinator that powered Wasabi's CoinJoins shut down, and plenty of people announced the death of the project right along with it. Max gave a short answer: "zkSNACKs can die. That was a special purpose vehicle." CoinJoin volumes, he said, remain high, and the project survives despite the closure of the company that built it.

His reasoning for why: "if even a suicide cannot kill the project, then probably nothing can." I laughed, because that is exactly how Bitcoin people talk about their own projects, and then I asked the awkward follow-up about what happens to a wallet after its founders move on. His answer was that open source is the whole safeguard, which led us into the Samourai story. Max notes the project failed in part because it hosted its own source code, and his lesson from it is that "This just shows that self-hosting your stuff is not in every case beneficial."

I have talked about this ecosystem on the show for years. I recorded Max Hillebrand on Wasabi Wallet's Development Roadmap in S12 E17, before this episode.

Surveillance as a Service

We were recording on Google Meet, which is not a choice either of my guests would have made. Max had a name for it ready: "Surveillance as a service." Rockstar's version was gentler: "Convenience as a service." Both of those landed within three seconds of each other, and I did not need to ask a follow-up.

I did ask whether using it at all made the whole conversation a bit hypocritical. Max's reply was that every privacy decision is a tradeoff, and a call with a live audience is a case where reach beats secrecy. I added my own take, which I will repeat here: "You're not avoiding, you're just delegating." Someone always holds the data, and the only question is whom you trust to hold it.

The same logic came up with Microsoft Recall. Max teased Rockstar as a "Microsoft fanboy," Rockstar noted how invasive Recall is, and Max pointed out that Recall could snapshot a user's Bitcoin seed backup.

Nostr: Private Zaps and Poop Emoji

Both of them like Nostr, for different reasons. Max praises it for anonymous group chats, and his favorite feature is specific: "I'm a big fan of the private zaps." He is less excited about public ones. "Do you really want to tell your grandson that you zapped 10,000 sats to a stranger for a poop emoji? You know, like 10,000 sats is going to buy him a damn spaceship."

Rockstar's critique is aimed at the community, which in his view spends too much effort building X-like features. I asked whether that was a fair complaint about a young protocol. He thought a protocol that can do encrypted group messaging should not be mostly known for reposting.

I also asked Max about SideShift, since I used it for years. He noted it dropped Lightning support, and Rockstar pointed me to FixedFloat as an alternative. I had not realized the Lightning support was gone until that moment, which says something about how often I use the service now.

Vibe Coding and the Security Pivot

This is the part of the show that got the most chat attention. Max looked at one project that had come up in the conversation and said "it looks pretty vibe-coded to me." Rockstar, a few minutes later, swung it around: "Now we're vibe coding instead of talking about privacy."

The more interesting argument was about what AI does to programming as a trade. Max's historical comparison: "If we would all have to still write assembler code or use punch cards or something like this to program our machines, we would just need a gazillion people to write any meaningful software." So he treats AI assistance as the next layer of abstraction, nothing scary.

Rockstar's angle was practical. His advice to developers worried about their jobs is to pivot to security work, because somebody has to read the code the models write. He also has a theory about what too much generated content does to people: "As we produce more information, as we now have AI to produce information, you have people going what I like to call information mad. You're going mad from all the information available."

Rockstar also confirmed, when I asked, that he sits in the top 2% of Stack Overflow contributors with nearly 21,000 reputation, a number I mention only because it means he has been explaining code to strangers for longer than most of us have had Bitcoin.

Max's reason for caring about open tools at all is one of my favorite lines of the night: "There's nothing more rewarding than stumbling upon a problem in the tool that you have, and then fixing it, and knowing that now the tool is better, not just for yourself, but for potentially everyone."

Drivechains, ChatGPT and a Pálinka-Sipping Romanian

I had Paul Sztorc on the show for S9 E4 on the philosophy of Drivechains and prediction markets. So I expected, and received, a debate. Max prefers zero-knowledge proofs: "cryptographic proofs are better than the game theoretic approach of drivechains." Rockstar's critique of the man rather than the proposal was that Paul lacks consensus-building skills, and he said "this is just one person standing against the rest of the world."

My side of it was the one I always bring: miners on a drivechain are not going to steal the sidechain funds, because stealing would destroy the thing they are mining. I described the miner's situation as "it's like farmers burning their crops and asking for insurance money." Rockstar's counter was a stunt. He typed my argument into ChatGPT and prompted it to argue against my view that miners would not steal sidechain funds. I read the resulting debate script out loud on the stream, and it addressed me as a young Romanian sipping pálinka. I do not drink pálinka while recording, but I did not correct the model, because the rest of the script was better than my own opening statement.

I also pushed the old objection about who the miners are in practice: "mercenaries with ASICs." Max said that was exactly why he would rather not depend on them. The trade I see is that a cryptographic proof system is more work to build than a miner vote, and I would rather someone with Max's background finish it than the rest of us keep arguing.

Compartmentalize, Then Read These Books

The longest stretch of the night went to practical advice. Rockstar's rule is separate work profiles and compartmentalization, and Max agreed with the underlying idea: "Compartmentalization, so to say, is a very great privacy strategy and need-to-know basis." He recommends Debian, GrapheneOS, Proton Mail, Nextcloud, Syncthing, and Signal, in that order of importance for most people. For the first step, he told listeners to "take the first step and cancel it yourself," meaning cancel the account or the subscription before something forces the decision.

Rockstar, meanwhile, said "The main thing is to find an anchor," and then gave his version of the same rule: "You're one death away from complete privacy," which is the sort of thing that does not sound funny until you think about it for a minute.

Then Max went through the books he recommends. The list: Declaration of Separation, A Cypherpunk's Manifesto, A Declaration of the Independence of Cyberspace, A Lodging of Wayfaring Men, The Second Realm: Book on Strategy, Sedition, Subversion, Sabotage, and Extreme Privacy: What It Takes to Disappear. For one of them he had a caveat: "It's not a literary masterpiece." Another, he said, is for a particular audience: "This is not a beginner's book. This is for the seasoned psychopath." Rockstar's reaction was "It escalated quickly,"

The strategic point in those books, as Max sees it, is that "violence is a bad choice because the state can outprint you and therefore outgun you." What he recommends instead is to "protect your perimeter and get notified when the adversary is approaching your lair and then build layers of defense and of obstruction." And on waiting for a political solution he was blunt: "if you're waiting for your liberation until the state is gone, then you're probably going to wait for a very long time."

Rockstar's version of the same idea was a technology argument: "Over past few decades, we have developed better systems, a better technology that are literally plug and play replacements. And now we still have state as this obsolete technology" He called money "a nice tool" and said "It's not the goal."

Max also mentioned the Cypherpunk Bitstream podcast, which he called "a cypherpunk-as-fuck podcast when the episodes are numbered in hexadecimal and not just decimal." I mention it so you can go count in base sixteen.

Kraken, Roger Ver and One Announcement

Somewhere past the three-hour mark I told the Kraken story. My account was closed because of Lightning transactions, and I said I still believe in privacy, which Max answered with a shrug: "It's your mistake of trying to use a centralized exchange." I took the point, though I also reminded him that most people's first on-ramp is a centralized exchange and that telling them not to use one is not a plan. I went on to say "I feel more free than I was last year," which I attribute entirely to having fewer accounts to lose.

On Roger Ver the conversation turned technical and a little gentler than I had predicted. Max's assessment: "Roger understands a lot of the economics, but he had technical mistakes." Rockstar's contribution was a rule he applies everywhere: "be hard on a problem, be easy on a person." I had Paul Sztorc on Roger Ver earlier in this season.

I also had to defend my guest list. Rockstar suggested at one point that I invite guests to be provocative. I corrected him: "my job is to ask people questions," and I do not invite anyone to start a fight.

The one piece of news came late and Rockstar gave it to my audience first: "Exclusive for your show, Vlad: multisig support in BTCPay Server will be announced tomorrow." He added, about how the multisig interface looks today, "Right now, the UI/UX, to be frank, it's pretty basic." Max had already asked for a lecture, and Rockstar announced that Max will deliver one on privacy resources.

Before we signed off I got to the lighter things. Rockstar and I joked about Donald Trump and Melania Trump launching meme tokens, and I told the chat that my girlfriend and I are producing an illustrated book called Bitcoin Year One. I also mentioned that BCH supporters once mocked Bitcoiners at an Einundzwanzig meetup in Frankfurt, a story I tell whenever someone claims the block size war is over. And then Derek Ross dropped into the live chat with the only question that mattered after nearly four hours of cryptography: would we rather fight 100 honey badger-sized ostriches or 10 ostrich-sized honey badgers? Max went for the ostriches. Rockstar and I could not agree, and the stream ended with neither of us having a plan.

Listen to Rockstar Dev & Max Hillebrand on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:00:47– Intro, sponsors and Max's haircut
  2. 00:03:15– CoinJoin or Lightning: remove information or add cover traffic
  3. 00:03:39– No privacy, no freedom, and what Ark is doing
  4. 00:05:11– BTCPay Server and the billable hours of shilling
  5. 00:07:15– Wasabi's bathroom billboards
  6. 00:10:30– Nopara, Nicolas Dorier and the first Wasabi wallet
  7. 00:12:11– Hidden Wallet and Samourai's rejection
  8. 00:14:13– Why Wasabi survived zkSNACKs
  9. 00:14:57– Ginger Wallet, Kruw and coordinators after Samourai
  10. 00:17:19– Samourai's confiscated source code
  11. 00:20:43– Several people behind one account
  12. 00:22:36– Network layer privacy and Tor identities
  13. 00:24:00– NymVPN and mixnets
  14. 00:26:52– Derek Ross asks about honey badgers and ostriches
  15. 00:28:51– Privacy in a world of public immorality
  16. 00:35:21– From Stack Overflow to AI coding
  17. 00:39:28– Roo Code and Windsurf
  18. 00:43:35– One-person companies and why privacy matters
  19. 00:47:08– Live ChatGPT analysis of BTCPay plugins
  20. 00:54:19– SideShift and stablecoin payments
  21. 00:58:08– Google Meet knows your IP address
  22. 00:58:53– Drivechains versus zero knowledge proofs
  23. 01:03:33– ChatGPT argues against drivechains
  24. 01:09:58– Max's privacy reading list
  25. 01:17:17– A Lodging of Wayfaring Men
  26. 01:18:49– The Second Realm and sovereignty strategies
  27. 01:21:09– Sedition, Subversion, Sabotage
  28. 01:23:43– Extreme Privacy: defense or offense?
  29. 01:28:37– Compartmentalizing your identities
  30. 01:42:54– Nick Szabo and social scalability
  31. 01:47:12– Nostr as identity technology
  32. 01:50:58– Zapstore and publishing without gatekeepers
  33. 01:52:48– Private zaps
  34. 01:55:50– Privacy advice for beginners
  35. 02:00:23– Review your technology stack
  36. 02:15:07– The Roger Ver interview disagreement
  37. 02:31:01– Status games and choosing your arena
  38. 02:36:40– Ordinals, markets and Giacomo Zucco
  39. 02:51:37– Monero, Zcash and altcoin sandboxes
  40. 03:02:00– Max on building despite difficulty
  41. 03:04:05– Ethereum and blockchain computation
  42. 03:18:24– Why Vlad keeps exploring privacy
  43. 03:23:53– Sponsors: Bitcoin.com News, NoOnes, Hodling.ch
  44. 03:30:15– Exclusive: multisig in BTCPay Server
  45. 03:37:44– Wrap-up and Bitcoin Year One

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
3659e51b533f4d900a82c185de84d80c805e91d05a3271476797aa9857f792e9
Proof
2025-04-15_s16_e18_rockstar_dev_max_hillebrand_on_privacy_bitcoin_-_11.04.2025_23.37.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 15 Apr 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2025-04-15_s16_e18_rockstar_dev_max_hillebrand_on_privacy_bitcoin_-_11.04.2025_23.37.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2025-04-15_s16_e18_rockstar_dev_max_hillebrand_on_privacy_bitcoin_-_11.04.2025_23.37.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2025-04-15_s16_e18_rockstar_dev_max_hillebrand_on_privacy_bitcoin_-_11.04.2025_23.37.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2025-04-15_s16_e18_rockstar_dev_max_hillebrand_on_privacy_bitcoin_-_11.04.2025_23.37.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00