S16 E19: Daniel Krawisz on Bitcoin & Narcissism
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript30,184 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Daniel Krawisz co-founded the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute, the site where the early emails and the white paper are archived for anyone who wants to read the source, and he wrote "Hyperbitcoinization." He also left the Institute years ago, thinks the Bitcoin most people hold is a counterfeit of the thing the Institute documents, and prefers BSV, which forked from Bitcoin Cash in the fall of 2018. On the night we recorded, Craig Wright was the name he kept circling back to, even though, by his own account, he does not like arguing about whether Wright is Satoshi.
We went live for four hours and nine minutes. I opened with a mistake: I told the audience Daniel had left the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute in 2019. He corrected me on the spot: "I left in 2016 or 2015, I don't remember exactly, but around then." His account of why is that his partners treated Saifedean Ammous with undue deference and stopped publishing his own work. That detail set the tone for the evening, because the Austrian economics he cares about, the Bitcoin he thinks was lost, and the personalities he thinks derailed it all run through the same story.
Most of the show was me testing his positions one at a time, and he did not give ground on many of them. A few times he did, and I will point those out where they come up.
"A social, an ideological hack"
I asked how he describes what happened to Bitcoin Core. He thinks the project was taken over, and he does not mean a hostile code merge. He called it "a social, an ideological hack," meaning a set of false ideas about the block size limit that spread through the community until they became common sense. He added that "all of that stuff applies to Bitcoin before it was taken over," which is how he squares his love of the early material with his contempt for the present chain.
His critique of the scaling plans that followed is blunt. Sidechains and drivechains are, for him, "all just replays of the SWIFT network, which is what we were trying to get away from when we got into Bitcoin." Layer two is another version of the same idea: "that's like imagining that everybody's going to be a ham radio operator or something like that." He wants scaling on the base layer with no cap.
I brought up Paul Sztorc's drivechain hard fork as the obvious test case, since it is a scaling proposal people actually argue about. Daniel's reply was a challenge to the premise that such designs could work in practice: "But if it did that, that would prove that I'm right." I came away without a clear sense of what evidence would change his mind, so I asked about it a few times from different angles.
Soft forks, nodes and a UTXO backup
The fork question got more heated. Daniel regards soft forks as the sneakier of the two kinds: "Really, the soft fork is a lot worse than a hard fork because that's like introducing new rules covertly that people didn't agree to." I argued that users upgrade regardless of which kind of fork it is, so the covertness is mostly theoretical.
Then the node debate. Running a full node is, in his telling, a Core ideology and not part of the design. "That's another thing about the Bitcoin Core ideology is the idea that everybody is supposed to be running a node, but that's not the original design," he said. His answer is simplified payment verification, and he told me, "I've been working on SPV for a while now." For your own safety he recommends one habit: "you should back up your transactions that are in the UTXO set."
Mining came next, and here Daniel made the case that centralization is the intended outcome. "They are going to get super centralized. That's the point. That's the design," he said, and his shorthand for it was "That's just capitalism." Elsewhere he put it more tamely: "it's okay to have a few large firms." On collusion between those firms he argued that "A collusion between miners is unstable because it just takes one to prove that the collusion is happening. That's how the free market is supposed to work."
Ross Ulbricht, Agorists and the Saudi Argument
This section is where I pushed hardest, and it produced the most surprising claim of the night. Daniel says Bitcoin was designed to be traceable, and that the protocol changes since 2017 were aimed at a specific outcome: "The interventions since SegWit have been about making Ross Ulbricht's defense easier." His reading of Schnorr is in the same family, an attempt to let users like Ross build a legal defense. He also said of Satoshi that "he believed that it was going to be good for the black market," which I took to mean Satoshi expected illicit use to follow, not that privacy was a goal.
I asked what that means for agorists, the people who use Bitcoin to run counter-economic businesses. His advice: "if you want to be an agorist, it's better to do it in a way where you're not going to get caught," and "just make sure your business doesn't get very big." On whether anonymity is achievable, his view was flat: "You cannot conceal your identity with the blockchain plus other information that's available."
I raised the Saudi argument, the idea that Bitcoin must be private so people can break unjust laws. Daniel rejected it, and said that is not the design: "The point of it isn't the black market, the point of it is privacy." That sounds like a reversal of what he had just said, so I leaned on it. What he means, as far as I could follow, is that the black market is a side effect and not the pitch. Even so, he does not accept anonymity as a moral good, and said "you are morally responsible for bad things that other people do who receive that anonymity from you." His version of the argument against it is social as well: "Without history, without identity, you cannot have friendship. Okay. So if you try to join a network where everybody's concealing their identity, you're just in a really dangerous place."
I summarized his position back to him as the claim that Bitcoin would have to be worthless to be usable for illegal purposes. He answered by flipping it: "So you're basically trying to say that Bitcoin has to be worthless so that we can use it for illegal purposes," which is a fair statement of the argument I was making, just aimed at me.
He also gave me his own privacy design, which uses large transactions with many outputs to scramble the graph. Unlike coins built around hiding, this keeps the chain legible. For payment finality he said, "With Bitcoin, nobody controls the payment. You shoot the payment out into the network. It gets processed. And that's that. And then if there is a legal problem, then things can change later."
Craig Wright, Satoshi and the Question of Evidence
I asked directly whether he believes Craig Wright is Satoshi. He does, because Wright understands Bitcoin better than anyone else he has met. He denies that Wright signed the genesis block or proved he mined Satoshi's coins, which are the two claims people usually point to. "I don't like arguing about whether Craig Wright is Satoshi," he told me, and then argued for a more modest version of the same belief: "You don't need to believe that Craig Wright is Satoshi in order to learn from him."
I asked what kind of community he imagined around BSV, and his answer was a picture of researchers: "I was imagining something like a community of scientists." He described the BTC side of the story as a refusal to engage: "They were only interested in people who were pro-BTC," and "people are not interested in Austrian economics and not interested in understanding it."
I had a fair amount of material on this from previous episodes. Arthur van Pelt talked about Craig Wright earlier in the show's run. Months afterwards I recorded Kurt Wuckert Jr on the big block wars, BSV, Craig Wright and the road not taken.
Why BTC Is Not Money, and What BSV Cannot Explain
The core of his economic argument is about how money gets its value. "So the value of money has to do with the way the economy changes," he said, and he applies it like this: "So what they did in BTC is they destroyed the whole economy in Bitcoin." On that view BTC is not money, because there is no economy running on it for the unit to measure. The rise in its price he reads as something else entirely, and he does not argue that anyone should invest in it. On Tether he was equally negative: it is "a money printing operation that works just like the old proliferation of banknotes that used to happen with private banks."
I asked about price. His answer was careful. "Markets are efficient in the long term. And what the long term means really depends on how intelligent are the people in the market." He also said "competition between monies is negative sum," which I took to mean he does not see a healthy market in the many coins competing today. For the idea that price proves success, he cited "our beliefs about success, at least in capital markets" as something to be suspicious of.
Then I asked the obvious question about BSV: why is there no merchant adoption? His answer: "That's a good question. And I don't really have a good explanation." I appreciated getting a plain reply there. He expects the Teranode software to remove the mempool, so that "the transaction is processed as soon as the miners accept it."
On mining he said "The optimal hash rate is based on the income that you can receive from the chain," and on the idea of inflation-free handouts for miners, "That would be like giving away free money." Of the unlikely scenario where he was wrong about Bitcoin's price, he said "I'm happy to admit that I was wrong about that," but then added "I am not going to say that I'm wrong about Austrian economics."
I asked about the community's expectations for central bank digital currencies, since I had seen the claim. He said "part of what people are expecting in BSV is for BSV to be the network on which the central bank digital currencies are issued." When I asked him to make the pitch, he declined: "You should ask Craig Wright to make that pitch. I'm not going to do it." For the network's shape he used an image I did not expect: "like a slime mold."
Love at Scale, Narcissism and Ayn Rand
The Austrian economics detour came with a definition I will not forget, partly because it was meant to be provocative. Daniel defines the theory as large-scale love, and compared it to a giant homosexual orgy. He wanted the comparison to land as a point about voluntary cooperation among strangers, and I took it that way, though it got a laugh from me before it got an argument.
That fed into a long stretch on narcissism. His clinical-sounding definition: "narcissism occurs when a child of approximately age two is punished for individuation, which means exploring their own personality." In his model, "The cult leader is the primary narcissist." He thinks narcissists do not know how to love: "Attraction is like something that should bring people together, but then real love is about investing in the relationship every day. What a narcissist will do is just try to act attractive every day." And he says of blank-slate theories: "Theories of the blank slate are appealing to narcissists because that means that propaganda works. So if everybody's a blank slate, then you can create the society you want through propaganda."
Ayn Rand fit in the same frame. He claims she was a narcissist who used her philosophy to justify infidelity. I told him about being blocked on Twitter by Saifedean Ammous after I asked a skeptical question, and he nodded along, describing the dynamic as "something like an addictive substance," meaning the attention and the following.
I asked whether he worries about being a narcissist himself, because the question seemed fair after that much diagnosing. "I don't think that I'm a narcissist. Of course, that's what every narcissist would say," he said. When I asked about the people who invite him on shows, he said, "I think that they're using me," and "free to invite me on their podcast anytime."
Autism, Furries and the Libertarian Future
A lighter stretch ran through the show's third hour. I showed off a custom wooden avatar my girlfriend painted for me, and Daniel recalled that the early furry fandom was a space for autistic people before woke ideology took it over. That led into his view on the future of libertarianism: "If libertarianism has a future, it has to be with people who transcend their own autism and start to get a better understanding of the thinking style of ordinary people."
He misses the older mood of the crypto community: "things were a lot nicer back in 2012 and 2013," and "a less scammy place." I asked about the shift, and he suggested it is partly what happens when some people get rich, and the space turns more hostile.
Mises, Menger and the Reading List
I asked him what to read, and then regretted the phrasing, because he answered with a long list. I later pointed out that "you went on a 15-minute, very descriptive enumeration of everything that you read." The core of it: Mises, Menger, Bastiat and Böhm-Bawerk. "I would pretty much recommend everything by Mises," he said, and told me a story about the Mises Institute: "I remember somebody at the Mises Institute telling me that he was the most boring author ever, but I thought it was really good." He is not recommending "The Bitcoin Standard": "I don't think that book is any good."
For the Austrian argument I touched on Mises's planning idea. "The conclusion that Mises got from this idea is that money would have no value. Because people would be able to plan every purchase in advance." I have covered Austrian economics with [R.L. R.L. Bryer's earlier appearance was S2 E10 on Austrian Economics and Bitcoin.
That book project is a history of Platonism and libertarian class theory. He thinks Plato's work is mostly evasion: "I would say everything in Plato is double talk." On the libertarian side he traces the line differently: "I link libertarianism to Diogenes."
On security he said "The only security that you can have in real life is probabilistic," and on the cypherpunks, "Bitcoin was influenced by the cypherpunks, but it is not a cypherpunk idea." That last line matters for his whole case, since it is how he separates what Satoshi built from what the privacy crowd wanted it to be.
For the closing question, I had a joke prepared and he gave a deadpan answer. I asked him to define a truncated icosahedron, the shape of a soccer ball and the thing our audience had been shouting about in chat for most of the night. Daniel's answer: "a 20-sided three-dimensional shape with the edges cut off."
Listen to Daniel Krawisz on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:00:50– Introducing Daniel Krawisz
- 00:02:40– Bitcoin Takeover
- 00:05:30– Scaling Bitcoin
- 00:09:30– Soft Forks vs. Hard Forks
- 00:14:10– Running a Bitcoin Node and Privacy
- 00:18:10– Verifying Transactions
- 00:20:00– Miner Centralization
- 00:24:40– Bitcoin Core Ideology
- 00:29:00– Fungibility
- 00:30:30– Ross Ulbricht
- 00:38:55– Bitcoin's Competitive Advantage
- 00:44:00– Bitcoin and Legality
- 00:48:50– Sound Money and Friendship
- 00:50:40– Satoshi Nakamoto's Identity
- 00:57:20– Craig Wright's Teachings
- 01:00:40– Leaving the Nakamoto Institute
- 01:03:40– Investors vs. Entrepreneurs
- 01:06:00– The Nature of Bitcoin
- 01:12:15– Bitcoin's Value
- 01:14:40– Market Efficiency
- 01:16:20– Bitcoin vs. Gold
- 01:21:15– BSV Adoption
- 01:24:00– BSV's Success Metrics
- 01:28:20– Hash Rate and Miner Incentives
- 01:30:30– Market Efficiency and Truth
- 01:33:55– BSV's Future
- 01:37:00– BSV vs. BCH
- 01:40:10– Mempool
- 01:42:40– BSV Mining and Jurisdictions
- 01:46:45– BSV vs. CBDC
- 01:52:35– Privacy and Mixing in BSV
- 02:00:03– Security and Probabilistic Thinking
- 02:01:21– Capitalism, Monopoly, and BSV
- 02:05:01– Central Bank Digital Currencies (CBDCs) and BSV
- 02:07:28– BSV's Role and Traceability
- 02:08:14– Traceable vs. Non-Traceable Money
- 02:08:54– Anarcho-Capitalism and Private Services
- 02:15:07– Cypherpunk Literature and Privacy vs. Compliance
- 02:18:12– Anonymity, Privacy, and Traceability in BSV
- 02:24:49– Layer 2 Solutions and Scalability
- 02:32:35– Narcissism
- 02:42:46– Narcissism and Financial Scammers
- 02:48:14– Avoiding Cults and Narcissistic Relationships
- 02:52:23– Benefiting from Narcissistic Relationships
- 02:53:13– Narcissists in Bitcoin/Crypto
- 02:54:37– Relationship with Nakamoto Institute
- 03:00:14– Appreciation and Book Recommendations
- 03:00:48– Hayao Miyazaki and Narcissism
- 03:04:40– Current Reading List
- 03:39:20– Stance on 2017 Block Size Wars
- 03:40:45– Book Project Idea
- 03:47:04– Plato, Socrates, and Propaganda
- 03:53:07– Diogenes and Libertarianism
- 03:55:15– Final Book Recommendations
- 04:00:01– Narcissism and Self-Awareness
- 04:00:40– Denouncement of Litecoin, Dogecoin, and Ethereum
- 04:01:17– Competition Between Monies
- 04:02:55– Changes in the Bitcoin Space
- 04:04:40– New Altcoins and Tokens
- 04:04:54– Bitcoin Year One Manga
- 04:05:29– Podcast Invitation and Appreciation
- 04:09:08– Sponsors
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
ebf46d55e6927a89f89fcaff2624cfc24c2c58fefbda3cff309cc121f284f542- Proof
- 2025-04-17_s16_e19_daniel_krawisz_on_bitcoin_satoshi_s_vision_sv_nakamoto_institute_narcissism_-_15.04.2025_19.20.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 17 Apr 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-04-17_s16_e19_daniel_krawisz_on_bitcoin_satoshi_s_vision_sv_nakamoto_institute_narcissism_-_15.04.2025_19.20.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-04-17_s16_e19_daniel_krawisz_on_bitcoin_satoshi_s_vision_sv_nakamoto_institute_narcissism_-_15.04.2025_19.20.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-04-17_s16_e19_daniel_krawisz_on_bitcoin_satoshi_s_vision_sv_nakamoto_institute_narcissism_-_15.04.2025_19.20.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-04-17_s16_e19_daniel_krawisz_on_bitcoin_satoshi_s_vision_sv_nakamoto_institute_narcissism_-_15.04.2025_19.20.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S17 E44: Marc De Mesel on the Bitcoin Cash Bet, the Privacy Coin Basket & the Price of Conviction
There is a particular kind of person the Bitcoin Cash community produced in its glory years, and Marc De Mesel is the…
S17 E26: Calin Culianu, Steve Thurmond & The Phenomenal Big Blockers on Nine Years of Bitcoin Cash
Almost nine years after the big split of the Bitcoin community, it was time. Time to sit down with the people who…
S17 E19: Amaury Séchet on Forking Bitcoin Twice, Quantum FUD & Scars from the Block Size Wars
Two years after our first interview, I decided to invite Amaury Séchet(@deadalnix) to find out what the Greg Maxwell of big…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.