Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S16 · E22 · 2:07:36

S16 E22: J-Dog on Counterparty & Bitcoin Tokens

19 Apr 2025 · by Vlad Costea · 13 min read
Published at block 893,028
Cover art for S16 E22, J-Dog on Counterparty & Bitcoin Tokens
MP3 (175 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript20,782 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

We recorded this one live, a little over two hours, while Counterparty was in the middle of a split that had half the community picking wallets and the other half picking sides. My guest was Jeremy, who goes by J-Dog: the former lead developer of Counterparty, the creator of FreeWallet, and the creator of TokenScan (formerly XChain). I have used FreeWallet since 2021, and I made the Bitcoin Heads collection with it, so I had a pile of questions that were part journalism and part customer support.

J-Dog started by mining Dogecoin and joined Counterparty six to nine months after Dogeparty, and since then he has written the wallet, the explorer and a good part of the culture around both. He now runs Counterparty Classic, the fork that came out of the recent consensus changes, along with FreeWallet Classic, and he has a new project called BTNS. The sponsors of the night were SideShift.ai, LayerTwo Labs, Citrea, Bitcoin.com News, Noones.com and Hodling.ch.

A playground on top of Bitcoin

I asked him to explain Counterparty for anybody who landed here from a Bitcoin conference. "It's a token platform that rides on top of Bitcoin," he said, "like a playground to play around with what you can do on Bitcoin and other blockchains other than just store a value, create a token and send it back and forth." The mechanics are plain enough: "You have Bitcoin transactions, you send OP_RETURN data within these Bitcoin transactions, and you just build from there."

His own way in was less academic. "Bitcoin was kind of boring to me," he told me, "I started mining Dogecoin on day one." Dogeparty came first, the same idea on a dog-themed chain, and Counterparty followed. Early on he saw himself as a minor figure: "I was just kind of a supporting character that wrote FreeWallet and XChain." He says he built FreeWallet "originally for myself because I didn't like Counterwallet. I was like, well, this is how I want to use Counterparty."

The early pitch was heavier than what most people picture now. "In the early days, Counterparty was more heavily focused on like, this is the new stock market, like for financial things." I brought up Samourai Wallet, which symbolically issued company shares using a Counterparty token, and the Rare Pepe cards that came out of the culture around the platform. The first Rare Pepes were handed out by treasure hunt: "Somebody would be like, okay, I'm dropping this in the middle of India, go pick it up." He pointed out that the geo-hunt idea has a hole in it, because "I can just GPS spoof where I'm at and then go collect all these things without actually traveling to the location."

Dispensers: the original Bitcoin smart contract

I call dispensers the original Bitcoin smart contract, and J-Dog did not argue the point, though his own description is humbler. "For lack of a better term, they're vending machines." He built the feature with John Villar, and the brief was simple: "John and I got together and kind of talked about, like, how can we make this like a fire and forget type thing where I have a token, I want to sell it for Bitcoin."

The thing he likes about them is the on-ramp. They are "a great way to kind of introduce people to Counterparty without having to make them jump through hoops to download a custom wallet." You send bitcoin to an address and tokens come back. Nothing else is needed, and that is exactly the part that broke.

According to J-Dog, the new version of Counterparty restricted dispenser purchases to specific wallets, namely FreeWallet, Horizon and Rare Pepe Wallet. "They called it a bug for the ability for anybody to send Bitcoin to a dispenser from a non-Counterparty address." His summary of the current state was short: "you can't buy from dispensers anymore." Atomic swaps, the newer way to trade, get little use, in his telling, and the same goes for numeric sub-assets, of which "a total of like 20 that have been created since October." I tested his claims about atomic swap sales live on stream, which is the sort of thing you can do when the chain is public. His verdict on where the money is: "it's the old stuff. It's dispensers. It's not the new way of doing things."

How the fork happened

J-Dog says Adam Krellenstein returned to the project after ten years and shipped a version that, in J-Dog's words, "crashed like two blocks after the new features activated." I asked whether that was fair to say about a release, and he answered with a disclaimer: "again, my opinion, I'm stating as fact."

The split, as he tells it, ran through governance. "In my opinion, it's no longer a community-driven project that is driven by consensus," he said, and he added that "there's no set path of, Hey, this is how we gather consensus." He explained why he forked anyway: "I decided to give the users what they wanted." Before that he had tried to argue his case, and "still, I didn't feel that that was enough to push a change forward."

He then described what happened to his reputation. After the fork, he says, the Counterparty site flipped its description of FreeWallet and TokenScan: "FreeWallet went from like, hey, everybody uses this wallet. It's the best wallet and whatnot to, this is a scary wallet. You can lose your funds if you use it because they support a fork." The same thing happened to TokenScan, which went from the preferred explorer to a bad actor.

He did not want the interview to become a duel. "I try not to play it too much into the, you know, Adam versus Jeremy," he said. On what Counterparty Classic is for: "my intention is not to have two versions of Counterparty and try to be warring against each other." His advice to the other side: "just unify your vision and build something for users." I asked about the hope that the two camps reunite, and he said, "I hope the best for Counterparty and that Adam figures it out."

He also laid out the cost of his approach plainly: "Consensus is tough. And if people want to add things or don't like things, getting everybody on board to agree this is a good idea is tough." A few lines later he told me he does not consider himself on the Counterparty team or a member of Counterparty anymore. The community, to him, is "the users that use it every day, not the small group of developers who rah rah and say, yeah, that will be a great feature."

There is a long tail of drama in the history, and he knows it: "there's always drama in Counterparty, but most people try to keep it respectful and keep it behind the scenes so it doesn't spill outwards." He told me about a falling-out with Joe Looney and Sean Leary that ended with him leaving the Rare Pepe Scientists group. The funniest thread in that story was that Joe was deep into Ordinals at the time: "Joe was really into Ordinals. He was like, Hey, check it out. I encoded all of the Counterparty code base into an ordinal."

When Counterparty almost had the EVM

The story I most wanted him to tell was the one about Ethereum. "Vitalik was a Counterparty community member at the time," he said, and Adam Krellenstein "basically had the Ethereum virtual machine set up and running on Counterparty." The Foundation rejected it. J-Dog's account of why Adam hesitated is technical and a bit gloomy: "as soon as we pushed this out the door, we're forever bound to the Ethereum virtual machine."

I asked him how he feels about that design now, and he gave me the version of the argument I like. "The smart contract author has to be a security expert in everything," he said. His preference for Counterparty is a smaller menu: "everything boils down to, is it a send? Is it a broadcast? Is it a setting up a dispenser?" Adam's episode was S16 E14: Adam Krellenstein on Counterparty & Bitcoin Tokens, and I later recorded S16 E24: Vitalik Buterin on the Future of Bitcoin & Ethereum. J-Dog's take on the competition between all these token platforms: "we'll see who makes it to market first."

Counterparty also has a dormant betting mechanism that uses JSON broadcasts to set up oracle-escrowed bets, "which has since been thrown in the garbage can by Adam, but it's still implemented." I pushed on whether Counterparty could grow into a layer 2. "To be honest, I don't know enough about the Layer 2," he said, and then added that he is "doubtful that Counterparty can evolve to become a Layer 2 scaling solution."

Spam, STAMPs and the UTXO set

J-Dog's relationship with STAMPs ended over a technical principle. Mike's visit was S14 E6: Mike in Space on STAMPs and Attacking Bitcoin, and J-Dog was careful: "to Mike's credit, I don't agree with him on everything." What bothered him was key burning. "Creating a bank account in the UTXO set and throwing the key away," he called it, and he had a concrete reason to care: "the UTXO set has to live in memory of every single Bitcoin node." On the debate over whether data should be prunable, his view was that "the whole unprunable versus prunable is kind of a silly argument."

When the STAMPs project started, he says, he asked users not to send him any, and "Everybody who sent me a STAMP, I sent them back."

On the broader culture war around inscriptions, he said, "I'm all for anybody creating their own token platform and experimenting with stuff," and then sketched the opposing camp's attitude: "this is not how you're supposed to use Bitcoin. This is spam." His answer to them is the one most people on this show would recognize: "at the end of the day, we don't need your permission." On the question of what belongs in a block, he quoted something he'd read: "When historians of the future will study Bitcoin, I don't think they will look at transactions between people as much as they will look at data that users have put into the blocks."

I asked about the argument that Counterparty's protocol-level features differ from what Ordinals do, and he stopped me on one point: "that's not actually a protocol level thing."

IMGR slashes, 40,000 asset names and my inflated portfolio

The best story of the night was about an early explorer hack. J-Dog explained that "IMGR/" prefixes in asset names pulled images from Imgur and IPFS, and that was one of the tricks people used to make cards show up with art before there was any proper standard.

He collects for the art: "I collect stuff for the artwork, not for the value." He dislikes how generative drops work now, calling them "10,000 almost identical PFPs," and thinks one-off art is "in my mind, more pure." The other side of that is his hoarding of names. He says he "registered like 40,000 asset names," a number that made me laugh because I have never managed to name a single thing well.

I then did what I always do on a live stream and looked at his portfolio. He owns 18 VLADHEAD cards, which inflates his portfolio to roughly $122,000. He laughed it off: "I think I'm worth like 16 quadrillion dollars or something." He also got turned into an NPC in Sarutobi Island by Christian Moss, which I consider the greater honor.

For the record, I corrected the article after the stream to reflect that J-Dog only provided advice on the Bitcoin Heads collection, so any credit for the cards is mine, and the blame for the cards is also mine.

Fixing FreeWallet live

The last part of the stream was a bug list, and J-Dog took it in stride. I asked about exchange pairs. "I can add a create exchange market button at the top," he said. Then stuck fees and multi-send, then token descriptions, and then supply locking: "Sure, yeah, I could do that." The way tokens get divided came up too, because the UI sells a whole card by default: "one satoshi of the item rather than one whole card." On the cause of the issue I raised, he said, "currently it is a UI issue."

Mobile was my next question. "FreeWallet Mobile is coming, but probably not for six, nine months." On the name, which I think confuses people, he said, "Maybe when I do the update, I'll rebrand it to something else." For the habit of not reading the screen, he had a theory: "nobody really reads anything."

Security came up through scams. "As soon as somebody enters their 12 word passphrase in, boom, the scammer has access to their wallet," he said, describing the fake sites that copy wallet interfaces. He wants to keep the infrastructure honest: "We're hosting five servers to the tune of, you know, tens of thousands of dollars a year on my own dime because I love this stuff and I want to support people." On an old design choice that bothers him, he said, "you're relying on a third party." He also still hears the same complaint about the command line, which is "still like two or three commands."

I asked why people stay with him, and he pointed to Telegram: "I've always been heavily involved in Telegram and interacting with the users on a daily basis, which is why I generally have so much community support." He calls FreeWallet "the Swiss Army knife of Bitcoin."

BTNS and what comes next

J-Dog's new project is BTNS, the broadcast token naming system. He described it as "dumb databases to write data to," with the logic left for the indexer to interpret later. He expects to build against a "long runway of time" and described how it will compare with other schemes "within a day or so" of an event being confirmed. On the funding, he said, "if it goes around and gets funded, I'll build it."

For Counterparty itself he sees a long future whatever happens at the top: "Even if all the current developers walked away and whatnot, there's always going to be a hardcore group of Counterparty users who will just keep it alive because they love it."

His plan for the near term is concrete. FreeWallet Classic gets the update that adds the exchange market button, locked supply and the other fixes from the list. FreeWallet Mobile follows in about six to nine months. The five servers keep running, Counterparty Classic and TokenScan stay up for users who chose the fork, and BTNS gets built if the funding arrives.

Listen to J-Dog on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:00:53– Introducing J-Dog
  2. 00:02:13– Counterparty's Founders
  3. 00:03:19– What is Counterparty?
  4. 00:04:24– History of Token Platforms
  5. 00:07:57– Creation of Dispensers
  6. 00:09:50– The Fork Controversy
  7. 00:12:42– User Reactions to Changes
  8. 00:13:16– Counterparty Classic
  9. 00:13:52– Current State of Dispensers
  10. 00:14:41– Ongoing FUD in the Community
  11. 00:15:02– Recent Developments
  12. 00:16:05– Control and Development
  13. 00:17:25– Token Scan and Exchange
  14. 00:20:55– Counterparty's Early Challenges
  15. 00:23:16– The use case for Bitcoin
  16. 00:23:39– Counterparty's missed opportunity
  17. 00:24:11– Community decision-making challenges
  18. 00:25:27– Smart contracts and security
  19. 00:26:42– Counterparty's innovative features
  20. 00:27:40– Evolution of Counterparty's focus
  21. 00:28:19– Concerns about asset transactions
  22. 00:29:26– The evolution of meme culture
  23. 00:31:03– Collecting Rare Pepes
  24. 00:32:04– Geolocation-based token distribution
  25. 00:33:14– Comparison to Pokémon Go
  26. 00:35:50– Current projects and developments
  27. 00:36:50– Citrea's zero-knowledge rollup
  28. 00:37:53– Counterparty's future on Layer Two
  29. 00:38:25– Current work and future vision
  30. 00:43:07– Community-driven development concerns
  31. 00:45:59– Consensus measurement in development
  32. 00:46:39– Consensus Gathering in Counterparty
  33. 00:49:42– Atomic Swaps Explained
  34. 00:51:33– Adoption of New Features
  35. 00:55:05– Counterparty vs Horizon Market
  36. 00:58:16– Impact of Ordinals on Counterparty
  37. 01:00:09– Integration of Ordinals with Counterparty
  38. 01:03:21– Fallout Among Developers
  39. 01:04:34– STAMPs vs Ordinals
  40. 01:07:45– Concerns About UTXO Set Bloat
  41. 01:09:58– Introduction to the UTXO Set Concerns
  42. 01:10:48– Turning Point on Stamps
  43. 01:11:07– Pixel Art and Compression Challenges
  44. 01:11:47– Nihilistic Moments in Bitcoin History
  45. 01:12:08– Innovations in Small Data Graphics
  46. 01:13:38– Future of Interoperability Among Protocols
  47. 01:14:02– Challenges in Ecosystem Integration
  48. 01:15:35– Islands of Unconnected Communities
  49. 01:16:03– Historical Significance of Bitcoin Artifacts
  50. 01:17:38– Hope for NFT Market Revival
  51. 01:18:37– Mixed Feelings on NFT Participation
  52. 01:20:22– Sponsor Plug for SideShift.ai
  53. 01:22:55– Counterparty Classic and Current Focus
  54. 01:23:58– Counterparty's Resilience
  55. 01:24:59– Future of Counterparty Protocol
  56. 01:27:42– Cultural Acceptance of On-Chain Data
  57. 01:28:18– Difference Between Counterparty Assets and Runes
  58. 01:29:04– Valuation of Vlad Head Cards
  59. 01:30:39– Scams in Low Liquidity Tokens
  60. 01:31:52– Concerns Over Domain Squatting
  61. 01:32:43– Counterparty Improvement Proposals
  62. 01:33:44– Creating an Asset Escrow Service
  63. 01:34:42– Resetting Asset Supply
  64. 01:35:21– Counterparty Wallet Quirks
  65. 01:36:44– Protocol Functionality Improvements
  66. 01:37:31– Funding Development through Donations
  67. 01:41:03– Betting System Revival
  68. 01:44:24– User Feedback on FreeWallet
  69. 01:47:05– Creating Exchange Markets
  70. 01:48:19– Transaction Fee Issues
  71. 01:50:11– Token Description Formatting
  72. 01:51:14– Multi-Send Transaction Challenges
  73. 01:52:58– User Interface Updates Needed
  74. 01:53:34– Mobile Wallet Development
  75. 01:54:51– Mobile Free Wallet Update
  76. 01:55:01– Free Wallet Confusion
  77. 01:56:02– Counterparty's Future
  78. 01:57:18– Investment Needs for Counterparty
  79. 01:58:56– Competing Visions for Counterparty
  80. 01:59:46– Message to Counterparty Team
  81. 02:01:14– Community Engagement
  82. 02:03:37– Running a Counterparty Node
  83. 02:05:06– Hardware Requirements
  84. 02:06:18– Importance of Running a Node
  85. 02:07:39– Closing Remarks

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
8633f67470d30f06d96dd75fd0a6e4fa6ad8b51ffe6e89b0a70b42bf1bdbcf73
Proof
2025-04-29_s16_22_j-dog_on_counterparty_bitcoin_tokens_-_29.04.2025_15.52.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 29 Apr 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2025-04-29_s16_22_j-dog_on_counterparty_bitcoin_tokens_-_29.04.2025_15.52.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2025-04-29_s16_22_j-dog_on_counterparty_bitcoin_tokens_-_29.04.2025_15.52.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2025-04-29_s16_22_j-dog_on_counterparty_bitcoin_tokens_-_29.04.2025_15.52.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2025-04-29_s16_22_j-dog_on_counterparty_bitcoin_tokens_-_29.04.2025_15.52.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00