S16 E53: Xenu on Bitcoin Culture & Moreno vs Zcash
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript38,901 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Xenu took his name from the Scientology volcano alien, the one adherents only learn about after ten years of dedication, and he now hosts the AntiMoonBoy News podcast. He also wrote the "Attack of the Poison Outputs" video series and a manifesto called "Darknet Market Maximalism." I had been wanting to put him across from me for a while, because last month I sold my Monero for Zcash and Zano, and I figured a man who named his show after his enemies would have opinions about that.
We recorded for more than four hours. My OBS glitched along the way and cut my audio out a few times, so if I sound like I vanished mid-sentence, I did. I also mispronounce Monero a lot (Montevero, Murcielago, Italiano Vero, Sandero), which Xenu took in stride.
I came for the privacy-coin argument, and we had it. But it kept running through the same question: what happened to Bitcoin culture, and what is left of it for the rest of us to defend.
Moonboyism and the Sterile Corporate Coin
I asked Xenu what AntiMoonBoy is for. "The purpose of anti Moonboy is to push back against Moonboyism," he said, and the target he described is a crowd who would reduce every coin to a price chart and a slogan. I admitted that I sat on the other side of that for years, since "store of value" was the phrase I used myself for a long time.
His complaint about Bitcoin's current mood is about tone more than price. "It's very sterile. It's very corporate," he said, and then, of the people running the show now, "they don't have idealism." I tried the line that Bitcoin was born countercultural and asked where that went. "Somewhere along the way, the counterculture became subverted," he answered.
He put the blame on a very specific person. "The litmus test for a Bitcoin supporter is how they feel about Michael Saylor," he told me, and then he went further: "The moon boys have gravitated to this guy and they've taken over Bitcoin. It's a 51% attack on the soul of Bitcoin is really what it is." I ran my own version of this argument with Jameson Lopp on Saylor, ossification and paranoid crypto anarchism, and Xenu's version is angrier than anything I got there.
The politics came up too. "We have this Bitcoin president. He doesn't give a shit about Bitcoin," Xenu said, and he thinks the man probably does not understand how mining works, imagining it as literal digging into the ground. We both found the whole spectacle depressing, though I think we found different parts of it depressing.
The Filter War as a Simpsons Meme
Then I asked about the Bitcoin Knots filter fights and the OP_RETURN debates, because that is where the culture war has become code. Xenu's summary was that "the best way to summarize the filters war going on is a Simpsons meme," and he called the whole thing "just pure virtue signaling." I did not argue with him much, because I have my own theory. If Bitcoin had real on-chain privacy, nobody would be asking nodes to police what other people put in transactions. "Basically, the fee would be the filter," I said. If you cannot see what a transaction is doing, the only thing left to price is the space it takes.
I know the Knots side does not accept that, and I did not pretend otherwise. What I wanted from Xenu was his read on whether anyone in that fight is thinking about the user's privacy at all. His answer was that the loudest participants are performing for each other.
This is also where regulation crept in. I told him that European MiCA rules and the travel-rule requirements discourage merchants from touching any of this, which is one reason adoption stories in Europe are thinner than the conference circuit pretends. Xenu's own take on adoption is less polite than mine: "I think global adoption is a meme. Okay, I don't like it. Never have liked it. I think that we should focus on adoption for people who care about digital cash."
Samourai, Tornado Cash and Who Fought Back
We spent a good while on the prosecutions. I said the worst response to Samourai Wallet came from the Bitcoin community itself ("The worst response came from the community"), and compared it with how the Ethereum side rallied around Roman Storm. They "actually turned out to be better cypherpunks and they actually fought for their own," I said.
Xenu pushed back on the framing a little, though only to widen it. "I think they're underrated as being cypherpunks," he said of the Ethereum people, which is a sentence I did not expect to hear on this show.
His forward-looking view of the whole situation was bleak and practical. "In the future, we're not going to have respect from governments," he said. "Our open source projects will have to exist like cockroaches."
What Zcash Delivered and What It Left Shielded
I got my Zcash defense in early. Zcash was always a research lab for Bitcoin, I said, and Ethereum ended up using more of what Zcash built. I also credited the team on delivery: "they actually delivered what they said they would," which is not something I can say about every project in this space. Earlier I recorded S15 E62: Josh Swihart & Kris Nuttycombe on Zcash, Zero-Knowledge Proofs & Cash for the Internet and S16 E51: Sean Bowe on Bitcoin, Zcash & Scaling Privacy with Tachyon.
Xenu's objection is the one you expect from a Monero person, and he made it precisely. "It is inexcusable that it is not a milestone for them to go 100% shielded Zcash," he said. He also claimed Monero does around 24,000 transactions a day against roughly 2,400 for Zcash. I came back with growth: the Orchard pool went from 900,000 coins to 4.1 million in 2024, which I put to him as "We have gone from 900,000 in the Orchard pool to 4.1 million." His answer was short: "but it should be 100%."
That matters most in the discussion of Zashi, the Zcash wallet, and NEAR Intents integrations. Xenu argued that these link transactions to transparent addresses and that this is exactly how a shielded coin leaks. My reply was that "Zashi, the wallet, is not Zcash, the network," and that a wallet design problem should not be filed as a protocol flaw. Xenu did not think the distinction would comfort anyone whose transactions had been linked. "Privacy is not an on or an off switch," he said, and then: "It's something that we have to constantly be fighting."
"I think Zcash is the technology that was created for Bitcoin to improve Bitcoin," I said more than once, and I meant it, even if the Zcash community and Bitcoin have not always behaved like relatives.
Where Monero Is Bought and Who Can Delist It
I raised exchange concentration, because I had looked it up. About 49% of Monero's volume sits on KuCoin, while Zcash volume is spread across Binance, Coinbase and others. That sounds like a Monero weakness, and Xenu said it misses how people buy. "Monero is punching way above its weight on all these websites," he said, and most users, in his telling, acquire Monero through instant swap services like Trocador and Cake Wallet rather than through exchanges or decentralized markets.
He kept returning to darknet markets, which is what his manifesto is about. On adoption he was blunt: "they literally go online and they're like, I need to buy drugs. Buy Monero. Okay. That's it. It's adoption." That kind of use rarely appears on a conference slide, but it is real payment volume with real merchants, and it is the kind of thing a coin can lean on when exchanges get nervous.
I asked about the decapitation risk, and this is where we disagreed on something concrete. Xenu argues Zcash is vulnerable because it has named researchers and corporate backing, so a regulator knows whose door to knock on. I answered that Monero's anonymous developers are hard to replace in a different way: you cannot swap out people nobody can identify, but you also cannot easily swap in people who write the code at that level. Earlier I recorded S16 E32: Bitcoin vs Monero vs Zcash Privacy with Diego Salazar & Luke Szramowski of Cypher Stack.
RandomX, Qubic and a Tweet I Got Wrong
Xenu loves CPU mining and was happy to say why. "I like the fact that the mining is dedicated to the common man," he said, and then: "you can mine Monero with your CPU, so if you have a computer you can mine Monero." Zcash, by contrast, runs on specialized hardware. I do not think that difference is nothing, even if I weigh it differently than he does.
The Qubic episode was where I had to correct myself. I had tweeted that Monero got 51% attacked, and Xenu set the record straight: it was a temporary successful attack, not a majority takeover. I took it back on the spot. He described what the Monero community did in response as practical rather than ideological: "We were able to turn on our computers and mine against it," and he stood by the algorithm afterward, saying "RandomX actually survived the attack."
He also made a point I had not weighed enough, that the problem is general. "This could happen to any proof of work cryptocurrency," he said. I agree.
Why So Toxic With Zano?
Zano is the project I most wanted to hear him on, because I recently moved some of my Monero into it and the hostility I get from Monero people for that is out of proportion. So I asked directly: "Why so toxic with Zano?"
His complaints were specific. He called it "a worse version of Ethereum," which is a sentence that stings if you like Zano, and he also criticized the pre-mine. He added, about the people behind it, "some Chinese company." I did not hear a technical argument in that phrase, and said so. What I do find legitimate is the pre-mine objection, because in a space that prizes fair launches it matters.
Where we ended up was less a disagreement than a difference in what each of us wants from a coin. Xenu wants a digital commodity that exists whether or not anyone approves: "Monero is a digital commodity. It's going to exist regardless of what someone thinks about it. It is digital cash. We've discovered it and we're harvesting it." I want something with a team that ships and a roadmap I can read, and I accept that this makes me look like a corporate guy to the cockroach crowd. My closing remark on that front was that I meant my Zano comparison "as a compliment, not as an insult."
A Rematch in a Year
We drifted late into other territory. I mentioned that Peter Schiff's father, Irwin Schiff, wrote a book on tax resistance and died in federal prison, which fit the mood by that point. I also tried, one more time, to get Xenu to say something nice about Monero and Zcash in the same sentence.
What we agreed on is a rematch in one year, to compare how our projects have done. I have a sense that Zcash's Orchard share will be the number we fight about, and he will have something ready on transaction counts. If I'm right about the shielded pool and he's right about the leaks, we will both be partly vindicated and neither will concede it. I still reach for "store of value" when an argument gets hard, and the rematch is as good a deadline as any to quit.
I came in expecting the man from AntiMoonBoy to be the angriest voice I would talk to this year, and for about the first hour he was. Somewhere in the third hour, between the filter war and the Qubic attack, I stopped hearing a man pushing back against Moonboyism and started hearing someone who just wants digital cash to stay out of other people's hands. Xenu, the guy who named himself after a volcano alien, turned out to be one of the more idealistic people I have had on, and the sterile, corporate coin he describes is the one I am still trying to get away from.
Listen to Xenu on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:01:46– Welcome to Bitcoin Takeover podcast
- 00:01:52– Vlad introduces himself and Xenu
- 00:02:06– Debating Zcash vs Monero
- 00:02:44– Xenu thanks Vlad
- 00:03:36– AI and aesthetics discussion
- 00:03:41– Vlad sold XMR for ZEC and Zano
- 00:04:31– Zano as CryptoNote fork
- 00:05:18– Bitcoin as speculative asset
- 00:06:55– Satoshi white paper vs Michael Saylor
- 00:09:24– Ordinals and blockchain data
- 00:10:11– Filters war and Simpsons meme
- 00:11:36– Bitcoin Knots vs Samurai Wallet
- 00:12:18– Privacy as key to censorship resistance
- 00:13:01– Op_Return and Samourai conflicts
- 00:14:04– Luke Dash Jr critiques
- 00:15:50– Paul Sztorc and drivechains
- 00:18:03– Bitcoin Core devs like Ava Chow, Gloria Zhao
- 00:20:13– Potential Bitcoin fork
- 00:21:45– Government attacks on privacy
- 00:23:12– Adam Back's profile
- 00:24:15– Lightning Network failures
- 00:25:53– Citrea ceremony and L2 scaling
- 00:26:36– Mining sustainability concerns
- 00:28:44– Bitcoin Strategic Reserve meme
- 00:30:30– Gold vs Bitcoin flipping
- 00:32:00– Regulations like MiCA in Europe
- 00:35:37– Visa network irony for Bitcoin
- 00:36:59– Subverted counterculture
- 00:39:05– Rise and Rise of Bitcoin doc
- 00:41:19– Coinbase and custodians
- 00:42:31– Samourai Wallet plea
- 00:43:10– Bitcoin cultural issues
- 00:45:23– Tornado Cash devs as heroes
- 00:46:05– Ethereum as better cypherpunks
- 00:48:03– Ethereum underrated
- 00:49:19– Privacy laws outdated
- 00:50:19– Roman Storm t-shirt in trial
- 00:53:44– Zashi wallet and Near integration
- 00:55:01– Zcash culture elitism
- 00:58:05– Inflation bug concerns
- 01:00:25– Zcash as company token
- 01:02:01– Dev fund and delivery
- 01:03:02– Dandelion++ from Bitcoin
- 01:04:15– Bitcoin rejects privacy tech
- 01:05:02– Demand Z-to-Z transactions
- 01:06:55– Timing analysis attacks
- 01:08:14– Zcash avoiding "smoke"
- 01:09:29– Academics funding challenges
- 01:10:31– Monero devs like Luke Parker
- 01:12:04– Zcash tech in Bitcoin/Ethereum
- 01:14:11– Stablecoins using ZK proofs
- 01:15:04– Monero quality over quantity
- 01:17:03– Memecoins as political statement
- 01:18:51– Declining Lightning adoption
- 01:20:24– Shielded pool growth
- 01:21:50– Zcash self-defeating history
- 01:22:54– Zcash vs Monero transactions
- 01:24:06– NGPT and merchant usage
- 01:25:02– Passion for spending Monero
- 01:26:27– Free market dynamics
- 01:27:06– Zcash pump as bubble sign
- 02:27:20– Zcash progress and integrations
- 02:27:59– Project persistence
- 02:28:24– Zcash traceable statements
- 02:28:53– Forking debate
- 02:29:53– Blockstream in Monero
- 02:30:17– Liquid network ghost town
- 02:31:03– Zcash usage comparison
- 02:31:50– Zcash explorer check
- 02:32:30– Shielded stats
- 02:34:05– Shielded pool growth
- 02:35:39– 100% shielded demand
- 02:36:04– Pirate Chain issues
- 02:37:04– Forks treatment: Zcash vs Monero
- 02:38:52– Encouraging tech experiments
- 02:40:06– Xenu name origin
- 02:41:47– Scientology lore
- 02:42:05– Community forks response
- 02:43:16– Zcash-Monero tensions
- 02:43:34– Monerotopia invite decline
- 02:44:13– Discouraging forks
- 02:44:47– XMR toxicity towards Zano
- 02:45:30– Monero stablecoins?
- 02:46:29– Chat: X accounts recommendations
- 02:47:44– Hit on Joel Valenzuela
- 02:48:04– Community toxicity
- 02:49:24– Calling out behavior
- 02:50:00– Luke Parker quit incident
- 02:51:02– Proof of work work
- 02:53:16– Nation state attacks
- 02:54:48– Dev attitudes
- 02:55:47– Broader adversaries
- 02:56:53– Privacy incentives
- 02:57:34– Personal privacy motivations
- 02:59:00– Darknet experiences
- 03:00:07– Zashi wallet node connect
- 03:01:20– Post-cap mining
- 03:02:08– Monero dev count
- 03:02:43– Talent replacement
- 03:03:52– Multi-coin world
- 03:04:13– DAG tech
- 03:04:20– Tornado Cash, Samourai
- 03:04:39– Wasabi differences
- 03:06:56– Closing thoughts
- 03:07:18– Dark Market Maximalism
- 03:08:39– Xenu's reaction when ZEC flips XMR
- 03:10:08– Anti-Moonboy content
- 03:11:02– Cheap shots
- 03:11:56– Closing remarks
- 03:12:19– Rematch idea
- 03:13:07– Chat comments
- 03:14:23– Zano conference
- 03:15:00– Wownero follow
- 03:15:32– Feedback request
- 03:16:06– Proxy names
- 03:17:32– Is Vlad the Peter Schiff of Monero?
- 03:18:13– Schiff family
- 03:19:16– Final thanks
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
12665bcd62150d15e7e722998323e1a8ae53e9a62c2c49d13b9ae94c8d42c82d- Proof
- 2025-10-27_s16_e53_xenu_on_moreno_vs_zcash_final.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 27 Oct 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-10-27_s16_e53_xenu_on_moreno_vs_zcash_final.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-10-27_s16_e53_xenu_on_moreno_vs_zcash_final.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-10-27_s16_e53_xenu_on_moreno_vs_zcash_final.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-10-27_s16_e53_xenu_on_moreno_vs_zcash_final.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S15 E60: Andrey Sabelnikov & Pavel Nikienkov on Zano, the CryptoNote Wars & Private Proof of Stake
Zano co-founders Andrey Sabelnikov & Pavel Nikienkov on private tokens, hybrid proof of stake, the Bytecoin vs Monero feud and…
S17 E27: Kieran Mesquka on Railgun & Building Privacy Where the Users Are
Sometimes you have to wait a year for an interview to happen. I first met Kieran Mesquka at DevConnect in Argentina, back…
S17 E20: Amir Taaki, Harry Halpin & Christopher Cialone on Palantir’s Technofascism, the Roman Storm Trial & the Privacy Arms Race
Some episodes are planned for months. This one happened because Zach Herbert postponed, I panicked, and the universe compensated…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.