Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S6 · E11 · 1:58:19

Joshua Scigala on Bitcoin and Gold (S6 E11 Full Article)

24 Oct 2020 · by Vlad Costea · 6 min read
Published at block 654,149
Cover art for S6 E11, Joshua Scigala on Bitcoin and Gold
MP3 (162 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript18,247 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

In a space where people pick a tribe, Bitcoin or gold, Joshua Scigala refuses to pick. He calls himself a "competition maximalist," and he built Vaultoro so people could trade Bitcoin for physical gold and back without going through fiat.

He's also been around a long time. Before our talk, I showed him an old comment from his early YouTube videos, someone mocking him for buying Bitcoin as it fell toward $2. "It's just funny reading that stuff nowadays." This was the Season 6 finale. The original show notes cover the basics, and here's the full conversation.

Searching for Money Without a Central Bank

Joshua's first business was SwapStyle, a clothes-swapping site. Barter didn't work well, so he needed a currency. He looked at e-gold, Liberty Dollar and Liberty Reserve, and considered issuing his own credits, but "then I just become the central bank again. And I could print as much as I want by putting more digits into the database."

So he started looking for "some sort of system that's not centralized." Gold made sense. "Gold you find into existence. You don't print it into existence."

The trigger for all of this was 9/11. Following the money led him to a book on the history of the Federal Reserve, and from there he concluded the system was "an inherently mathematically wrong way of doing money." He tried to use gold and silver as currency, and found that "it's impossible. It's super hard and it's an annoying thing to do."

"She's Cracked It"

Then, around "late 2010," he read the white paper. "I looked at it and went, 'She's cracked it.'" The key was digital scarcity. "You can have an MP3 and make a copy of it and give you one. This is the first digital thing that I can't make a copy of. I can just send it on." He added Bitcoin to SwapStyle, which "was probably one of the first services to incorporate Bitcoin."

He also liked that Bitcoin "works with incentive structures rather than punishment structures." The miners and the game theory "is based around incentives."

Boom, Bust and Proof of Value

What convinced skeptical bankers? The cycles. After Mt. Gox, the price went from about $1,200 back down to the low hundreds, "and then it went back up." That's when people realized "this isn't something that's going to zero." It's also why he understood Core developers' caution: Bitcoin "really has stood the test of time so far."

He also explained why paper markets can't suppress real assets forever. If prices are pushed down on paper, you get "this separation that happens" between paper and physical prices, and people "just see it as some nonsense market," like the official bolívar rate versus the street rate in Venezuela.

Pricing Bitcoin in Grams of Gold

Vaultoro came from a simple wish. "I wanted to price Bitcoin in something else, something real, in grams of gold rather than fiat." Ideally, "even in pork bellies or bushels of wheat."

The gold-to-Bitcoin pair turned out to be a good signal. In 2015, his gold supplier asked, "what if you guys get too big for us to handle?" He laughed. Then in 2017, "we were selling more gold than the largest gold retailer that we were buying the gold from could supply us." Vaultoro traders, he said, tend to be "a little bit more switched on than the average day traders." In 2017, "the smart money" moved into gold near the top, then back into Bitcoin later. "It kind of gives a pointer to the tops."

Two Counterparty Risks

Why gold instead of fiat? When you sell Bitcoin for fiat on an exchange, "you have two counterparty risks": the exchange, and "the bank that the exchange uses going broke." Mt. Gox showed it. When it collapsed, "even the people that had fiat on that exchange lost it."

Bank deposit insurance covers only so much, "100k, some countries up to 250k." With allocated gold, it's different. "Once that gold is sold, it's in the client's name sitting in a vault." If Vaultoro failed, "it doesn't matter because our clients assets aren't on our books." "It's not some weird financial instrument."

Glass Books

Joshua wanted a proof of reserves "anyone could read and go, okay, I get it." The result was the Glass Books protocol. Every user gets an anonymous ID, and Vaultoro publishes "every single anonymous ID with the amount of gold and the amount of Bitcoin." "Because we don't know you're checking, we have to have the right amount" at all times.

He had even tried to build a decentralized exchange with a model similar to what Bisq later used. But vaulted gold "needs to be centralized because of insurance and auditing. So let's focus on transparency instead." His message to users: if you keep coins on exchanges, "they should demand total transparency, absolute transparency." Otherwise the state will impose its own rules.

He prefers voluntary regulation. The British gold industry, where Vaultoro was registered, "is voluntarily regulated," with industry rules you can check before you buy.

Signing SegWit2x

Joshua was honest about the block size war. He supported smaller blocks, but during the stalemate, "I did sign the 2X because it was like, look, we lift it by double and we get SegWit, then everyone's happy." Once the big blockers had their own chain, he wrote to the other signers that "we don't need this anymore." "We can try big blocks, let's try it out." That's how he sees forking.

He was "really bullish on the Lightning Network," too.

As a non-coder, he described trust in open source in a way anyone can follow. In the early days, people asked whether they could trust the open source paper wallet generator. "You could read the code, but I couldn't read the code. I'm not a coder." What mattered was that "50 people, 40 people verified the code." It's like reviews on Amazon or eBay: "you want to have as many reviews as possible, because someone's going to raise a red flag if there's something sketchy." "Anyone that hasn't downloaded a Lightning wallet yet, it's free, go do it."

Drop Fiat

The Grayscale "Drop Gold" campaign and the constant Bitcoin versus gold arguments frustrated him. "It's a silly conflict. Rare assets are an important thing." His slogan: "Drop fiat. There are so many people holding their life savings in fiat."

He sees the two as complements. "Bitcoin is a mathematical model of gold in a way." Bitcoin is "native to the internet" and "very easy to verify," while gold is "quite stable, compared to Bitcoin," with "3,000, 4,000 years of being treasured as a store of value." "When you put them together, I think it's a really great solution to the entire fiat corrupt structure."

His preferred move during a bull run is to "trade it into something solid, and then trade it back to Bitcoin when you need to spend it again." He found algorithmic stablecoins like Maker interesting, but "Maker is so young," and depegging was already happening a little. "So I'm a big fan of metal."

Storing Gold

Where should you keep it? Taking it home has risks. "People get robbed," and gold loses "a lot of premium" because dealers must verify it when you sell. His favorite jurisdiction is Switzerland, which "has been through two major world war conflicts and stayed pretty neutral." And beware of paper gold. If the custodian goes broke, "they could bail themselves out with that gold. So make sure to have allocated gold."

What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To

Joshua has been in this since Bitcoin was under $2, and he still doesn't do tribalism. If you hold both gold and Bitcoin, or you've wondered whether you should, this is the episode for you.

You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Joshua Scigala's guest page. He also came back in Season 7 to talk about gold, philosophy and ethics.

Listen to Joshua Scigala on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:01:39– Falling to $2
  2. 00:02:51– SwapStyle
  3. 00:04:36– Not becoming a central bank
  4. 00:05:53– Gold is found into existence
  5. 00:07:13– After 9/11
  6. 00:08:58– Gold is hard to spend
  7. 00:09:48– The first digital scarce thing
  8. 00:13:02– Incentives, not punishment
  9. 00:17:48– Boom, bust and back up
  10. 00:23:21– Paper vs physical
  11. 00:25:26– Pricing Bitcoin in gold
  12. 00:26:29– Selling more gold than the supplier
  13. 00:27:51– The ratio points to the tops
  14. 00:29:19– Two counterparty risks
  15. 00:31:03– Gold in the client's name
  16. 00:33:12– Glass Books
  17. 00:38:02– Transparency over decentralization
  18. 00:41:11– Voluntary regulation
  19. 00:54:14– Signing SegWit2x
  20. 00:56:15– Bullish on Lightning
  21. 01:00:55– A silly conflict
  22. 01:02:24– Same but opposite
  23. 01:05:25– Trade it into something solid
  24. 01:17:11– Taking gold home
  25. 01:18:33– Switzerland and allocated gold
  26. 01:30:13– 50 people verified the code

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
9c4ba23363f182a34038f69f59621f19895132ea068a9e649b859542ae569c55
Proof
2020-10-17_s6_e11_joshua_scigala_on_bitcoin__gold__vaultoro__more.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 17 Oct 2020, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2020-10-17_s6_e11_joshua_scigala_on_bitcoin__gold__vaultoro__more.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2020-10-17_s6_e11_joshua_scigala_on_bitcoin__gold__vaultoro__more.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2020-10-17_s6_e11_joshua_scigala_on_bitcoin__gold__vaultoro__more.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2020-10-17_s6_e11_joshua_scigala_on_bitcoin__gold__vaultoro__more.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00