S7 E3: Joshua Scigala on Gold, Philosophy & Ethics
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript15,396 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Joshua Scigala has never understood why bitcoiners and goldbugs have to fight. The co-founder of Vaultoro sits somewhere between Peter Schiff and Barry Silbert, and he explains it with a cinema analogy: everyone still loves going to the movies, even though they have a nice 4K TV at home. Different tools, different reasons to like them.
Joshua was the first sponsor who truly saw long-term value in my work, and this was his second appearance on the show, a distinction only Peter Todd and John Carvalho had before him. We had already talked about Bitcoin and gold in Season 6, so the plan for Season 7 was to leave Bitcoin aside and talk about hobbies. That plan lasted about thirty seconds. The shiny rock came first, and from there we drifted into banking history, government, ethics, parenting and the online rage that now has a name: cancel culture. It's one of the most philosophical conversations I recorded that year, and I still remember it fondly because Joshua is one of those people who argues without getting angry.
The Pet Rock Argument
Joshua doesn't pretend gold is rational in every respect. "Even though it's so weird, because it is a pet rock, and I can understand when people say, 'Ha ha, have fun with your pet rock.'" But he also thinks something happens when you hold a bar: "there's something in our DNA where we really treasure it."
The practical case is older than any of us. Gold doesn't rot or rust, it is malleable and divisible, and it keeps its integrity. Its weaknesses are just as clear: it is heavy, easy to counterfeit and hard to verify without equipment. That's where he sees Bitcoin as the perfect complement: "It's rare, but it's easily verifiable, and it's easily divisible. So both of them come together really nicely."
I told him about a divorced woman my mother once met, who was making a very big case out of the fact that her former husband had sold all of her gold jewelry. For centuries, jewelry has been the guarantee that a woman left alone could pawn something and survive for a few months. Joshua had similar stories. His grandmother had a lot of rings stacked on one finger, one for every year of marriage, and he pointed to the refugees who fled Germany with gold in their pockets. A foreign currency can be seen as unpatriotic in a crisis, "whereas if you're busted with some gold, it's fine."
3,000 Years of Scams
Self-custody is hard with both assets. Most people Joshua knows who lost bitcoin did so because they forgot the password or the seed. Gold has its own trap: "People talk about scams in the crypto community, but with gold, you've got 3,000, 4,000 years of scams."
His argument for professional vaulting comes from insurance companies, which price risk better than anyone. Insuring gold at home is expensive "because they know that most gold gets stolen." Tungsten-filled bars also widen the spread between buying and selling, while a top-tier facility is almost impossible to break into, so the insurance there costs almost nothing.
Then he told the story of how vault operators became bankers. People deposited gold and received receipts, the operators noticed that nobody came back for all of it at once, and they started issuing more certificates than they had gold. They got rich enough that people started asking whose castle that was. Joshua's version of the punchline: the bankers offered a share of the interest, and that's "kind of where interest, you know, came from." Today, he said, fractional reserve banking is "like no reserve banking."
You Can't Reform the Hell's Angels
I asked whether there is a way back, given how many people now want the same regulations and guarantees for Bitcoin that they had in the fiat world. Joshua was confident: "No, the separation of money and state is here to stay. The on-ramps and off-ramps will get harder and tighter." He remembered the early events full of techies and anarchists, then the years when bankers and regulators showed up, and the "Bitcoin is not very interesting, but blockchain is" phase he called "all this sort of nonsense."
His view of revolutions was blunt: "You always meet the new boss, same as the old." What he wants instead is technology that makes parts of the state redundant, the way the internet made the public library less essential.
I disagreed a bit, and it got personal. I had run for parliament in my district and lost big time, and I told him about a local mayor who fixed a cracked roof with volunteers instead of an expensive contractor and was slammed for skipping the procedure. Joshua's reply: "never underestimate the power of the entrenched." He laughs at people who tell him to run for office and change things from the inside. "It's like, no, it's fundamentally a criminal gang, and you can't like go in there and change it from the inside."
I still think we Bitcoiners should try to take over politics at some point, if only because it's healthy for democracies to hear another view of markets and freedom. On air I said we are using the standards our grandfathers would have voted for. I haven't changed my mind on that one.
Batman, The Three Investigators and Sci-Fi Thinking
A conversation about the state of emergency took us to The Dark Knight Rises and Bane, and then to a funnier detail. Joshua was improving his German with The Three Investigators audio books from the 90s and found an episode about ransomware, with hackers demanding cash. "Banks get hacked quite a lot, like a lot. It's just never talked about."
He approaches anarchist philosophy the same way: as a thought experiment. When he suggests that police could work without government, people get so angry they can't discuss it. "And for me, it's so silly, because for me, it's more like a sci-fi novel in my head." He sees the cypherpunks as people who played exactly these games, asking what happens when governments listen in on every message and what software could stop them.
Ethics Without the Threat of Hell
This was the part I enjoyed most. As a PhD dropout with four years of research in political philosophy, I agreed with Joshua that the discipline has wandered off. "Everyone thinks philosophy has to be something like, 'Are you living in a dream within a dream?'" He wants to go back to simple questions, "like, can we put together a good framework for secular ethics?"
His starting point is that almost nobody wants to be aggressed against or stolen from, whether they believe in God or not. When I said I was fine with some state services, maybe because of my European upbringing with public education and healthcare, but not with surveillance, he answered with an analogy I didn't expect: "You say, 'You know, I think I'm all right with a tiny little cancer, but not a big one,' you know." He was careful, though. Certain things can't be switched off overnight, and what he wants is "a post-enlightened, slow movement towards making components of the state just inert."
We also spent some time on Plato's Republic, which I read at 19 or 20 and still recommend to anyone ready for "the true red pill" (my words, not his), and on the idea Michael Goldstein and Pierre Rochard came up with, that anything and everything is good for Bitcoin. Joshua compared it to Trump's knack for media coverage and added the eternal market truth: "It's too expensive right now. It's been always too expensive. It's never been cheap."
Raising a Child Without a TV
Joshua thinks the way out is how we raise the next generation, while admitting that "it sounds exactly like what the hippies would say." If every answer a child gets is "because I said so," the teacher becomes the authority next, then the state. His daughter was 13 months old at the time, and the television in their house stayed off. "I just want that little tiny super creative brain, that's when it's the most creative, that's when it's most questioning."
He also worried about what the pandemic would do to kids growing up behind screens: "a whole generation who social distance themselves into a total hell." And he connected it, in one long arc, back to Socrates and the hemlock. "And that it's even got a name, cancel culture, is a warning sign, I think."
Road Rage on the Internet
Joshua's first startup, built with his girlfriend at the time (now his wife), was a clothes-swapping site with a store called Swapstyle. It taught him early how people behave when there is no face in front of them. "There's no way anybody would walk into a store and start just shouting the filth that you get over email." He compared it to road rage: you don't see a person, "You just see a car."
Bitcoin had its own version during the block size war. Joshua remembered people getting death threats over block sizes and others leaving the space for good, and the cruise ship debate between Jimmy Song, Tone Vays and Roger Ver. It could have been a philosophical discussion. Instead, "the unfortunate side of that entire debate was so ugly."
His antidote is old-fashioned. Growing up in Adelaide, he could go to Speakers' Corner every weekend and hear someone on a soapbox talking about whatever they felt passionate about, sometimes a religious nut, sometimes a conspiracy theorist. You had to say it to their faces.
What makes this episode worth listening to is the way Joshua questions his own positions while defending them. "I think challenging your own beliefs is so important," he said near the end, and that's what he did for nearly two hours. He came back in Season 9 to talk about anarcho-capitalism and voluntaryism, which feels like the natural sequel. You can also read the full transcript of this episode or find more of his appearances on his guest page.
Listen to Joshua Scigala on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:02:18– Intro: no Bitcoin this time (sort of)
- 00:03:07– Between Peter Schiff and Barry Silbert
- 00:06:00– Why humans treasure gold
- 00:08:19– Gold jewelry as insurance
- 00:13:56– Self-custody, scams and insured vaults
- 00:17:35– How vault operators invented fractional reserve banking
- 00:21:25– Is there a way back to separating money and state?
- 00:29:19– Revolutions and making the state redundant
- 00:34:28– The mayor who fixed the roof
- 00:39:51– Why you can't change government from the inside
- 00:44:58– Batman, Bane and ransomware in 90s audio books
- 00:50:20– Anarchist philosophy as a sci-fi thought experiment
- 00:56:52– Secular ethics and first principles
- 01:01:27– A tiny little cancer
- 01:11:44– Foucault, spin and all news being good news
- 01:16:26– Plato's Republic
- 01:23:13– Raising the next generation
- 01:34:39– Swapstyle and online rage
- 01:42:17– The block size war
- 01:47:24– Where to follow Joshua
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
317ff4c080df82f33eeb2ab7f6fd1d8ed30c2e9c476db55e096ceea6c3d1637d- Proof
- 2020-12-25_s7_e3_joshua_scigala_on_gold__philosophy__ethics__cancel_culture.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 25 Dec 2020, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2020-12-25_s7_e3_joshua_scigala_on_gold__philosophy__ethics__cancel_culture.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2020-12-25_s7_e3_joshua_scigala_on_gold__philosophy__ethics__cancel_culture.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2020-12-25_s7_e3_joshua_scigala_on_gold__philosophy__ethics__cancel_culture.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2020-12-25_s7_e3_joshua_scigala_on_gold__philosophy__ethics__cancel_culture.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
Mallorca Blockchain Days 2021: Permissionless Fun
“Nothing is true, everything is permitted” – this is the Friedrich Nietzsche quote which lured me into attending a memorable…
S9 E3: Joshua Scigala on the Philosophy of Anarcho-Capitalism & Voluntaryism
Imagine there’s no government, it’s easy if you try. Roads still built by privates, above us only sky. Imagine all the people…
Joshua Scigala on Bitcoin and Gold (S6 E11 Full Article)
In the Season 6 finale, Vaultoro co-founder Joshua Scigala tells how he went from gold and silver to Bitcoin in late 2010, why he…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.