Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S6 · E4 · 1:39:15

Justin Wales on Bitcoin as Free Speech, Regulation and Taxes (S6 E4 Full Article)

8 Sept 2020 · by Vlad Costea · 6 min read
Published at block 647,240
Cover art for S6 E4, Justin Wales on Law, Taxes & Bitcoin as Free Speech
MP3 (136 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript14,397 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

I first interviewed Justin Wales in December 2019, when I was writing for Bitcoin Magazine and wanted a quick explanation of his paper. I got much more than that, and a young lawyer who didn't need to remind anyone of his status. So I brought him back for a long-form conversation.

His paper with Carlton Fields partner Richard J. Ovelmen is called Bitcoin Is Speech: Notes Towards Developing Conceptual Contours of Its Protection Under the First Amendment. The original show notes cover the basics. Here's the full 99 minutes, distilled.

He opened with a Beatles line from "Revolution": "Don't you know that you can count me out, in?" "He was a revolutionary unless he wasn't, and I think a lot of us maybe fit in that category." It's a fair description of a lawyer who loves Bitcoin.

Bitcoin Native Lawyers

"I might be part of like the very first generation of lawyers who can claim to be, you know, Bitcoin native." He wrote the paper because he was tired of what he was reading. The articles were "hyper, hyper-focused on securities sales, token sales" and on how blockchain could "marginally make centralized entities more efficient."

Finding a publisher took time. "Even just the notion that the First Amendment is implicated was a little too far for some of these papers." They chose the University of Miami law review, partly because "the people who were on the law review board were Bitcoiners."

An Expressive and Associational Network

The core argument is simple. We focus so much on Bitcoin as money that we forget what else it is. The network "allows people from all over the globe to associate, to maintain a common truth. And that common truth is the validity of the Bitcoin ledger."

That brings in First Amendment associational rights, which could "potentially prevent regulations from being applied specifically to Bitcoin that aren't applied also to other types of" networks. And there are non-financial uses, like "publishing messages, political, religious, philosophical, otherwise, onto the blockchain."

He compared it to the internet. "It's an expressive network, and it should not be viewed very differently than we view something like the internet." Illegal things happen online, and those are prosecuted. But "the fact that I want to have financial privacy, is not automatic, should not be automatically suspect."

His example came from China. Activists exposing tainted whooping cough vaccines kept getting censored, so "for 47 cents worth of ether, they were able to actually put that information into the Ethereum blockchain in a way that the Chinese government or anyone else can't delete it."

The Coffee Tax Problem

The IRS treats Bitcoin as property, which turns every small purchase into a taxable event. "If you go and purchase a cup of coffee with Bitcoin, you know, the elusive cup of coffee that everyone talks about," you owe a capital gains calculation. That, he said, "makes it very difficult for Bitcoin to become adopted by the masses in the United States."

He pointed out the inconsistency. "The CFTC views it as a commodity. Most states view it as money," while the IRS "views it as property and doesn't really treat it as money, and that just causes a lot of friction." He mentioned a bipartisan bill, backed by Coin Center, for a de minimis exemption.

Banks, Custody and Your Parents

Justin knew this view would be controversial with my audience. "As much as we all say, 'Hold your own keys,'" a lot of longtime Bitcoiners have made it part of their identity. But "there needs to be an easy way for like my mother to go and purchase Bitcoin."

The OCC had just said nationally chartered banks could custody crypto for clients. For many people, he said, a small allocation "held with Wells Fargo and insured through Wells Fargo's insurance" is fine. "I think for a lot of people, it makes sense to be your own custodian," but not for everyone.

On wrapped Bitcoin and other products, his view was that "it's Bitcoin, but it's sort of Bitcoin once removed." If someone builds a derivative product on top, that product will be regulated so there's "a place that you can point to" when something goes wrong.

Would an ETF Hurt Bitcoin?

This was my favorite answer. "Imagine how fragile Bitcoin would be if it could be fundamentally destroyed by an ETF. I don't buy that it's that weak." To him, the fact that Bitcoin went from "message board money" to serious ETF talk "shows how strong it is." Then the twist: "At the same time, I wouldn't use most of those products." US spot Bitcoin ETFs were approved in January 2024, so this one aged well.

The deeper point was about money printing. Bitcoin, "written, you know, basically into the Genesis block," takes "away the government's ability to create more money. And if you fix that problem, you end up, I think, fixing a lot of the inequities in society."

From Punk to Crypto Lawyer

"I was a punk growing up." In law school he wanted to practice First Amendment law and do something "where I felt like I was wearing a white hat." WikiLeaks brought him to Bitcoin around 2010 and 2011. "At first, my first instinct was it felt like a scam."

Then he became the lawyer friends called. "When you're the only lawyer someone knows, you're the lawyer they call." His firm had 400 lawyers, so he could ask the tax, securities and money transmission experts. "In about 2014, the practice got enough traction that we made it its own practice group."

He was a third-year lawyer when he and Matt Cohen started it, and older colleagues told him, "You shouldn't be doing this." "I took it seriously," and "I actually have a much better career now than I would have, because I did take a risk."

He was modest about it. "I got stupid lucky." For a lot of people in the space, "you caught the bug at the right time and you got obsessed in something that probably shouldn't have worked out as well as it did." If you got in before 2017, "you saw the ups and downs." I think that's the honest version of most of our Bitcoin stories, mine included.

The Financial Advisor Story

A financial advisor visited his firm before the 2017 boom and again during it. Both times, the advice was not to touch Bitcoin. Why? "Well, that's sort of the company." Finally: "I don't know enough about it to recommend it to my clients." Justin's answer: "you should learn as much as you can to determine whether you should recommend it or not."

Tell Three People

He asked Bitcoiners to stop mocking newcomers. "We can't keep this as our own secret." His math: "If every Bitcoiner tells three people how great Bitcoin is," then "15 or 16 rounds in, everyone in the world has had a pitch."

States and Printing Presses

He liked what Wyoming was doing. "Wyoming's been incredibly innovative and that's causing other states to notice." But he didn't think any government would decide Bitcoin's fate. Its success depends on "the world governments continuing to print money out of thin air."

Lawyers Can Shape the Industry

His closing message was for law students and young lawyers. "You actually do have an impact on how the industry develops, in the same way that First Amendment lawyers had a huge impact on how the newspaper industry developed in the 60s and 70s." In the Pentagon Papers case, newspaper lawyers coordinated, and "every year to this day, there's a media law bar" that still meets in New York. Crypto needs something like that.

What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To

Justin sticks to facts and doesn't avoid nuance, even when nuance means disagreeing with Bitcoin Twitter. If you're a lawyer, this is a good place to start.

You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Justin Wales's guest page.

Listen to Justin Wales on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:03:04– Count me out, in
  2. 00:04:36– Bitcoin native lawyers
  3. 00:06:18– Why he wrote the paper
  4. 00:15:13– Publishing with the University of Miami
  5. 00:17:46– An associational network
  6. 00:18:34– Non-financial uses
  7. 00:22:13– Like the internet
  8. 00:25:21– The Chinese vaccine scandal
  9. 00:30:51– Micropayments as taxable events
  10. 00:32:45– Commodity, money or property
  11. 00:33:56– The OCC custody letter
  12. 00:37:57– Bitcoin once removed
  13. 00:43:16– Being your own custodian
  14. 00:52:31– From punk to First Amendment law
  15. 00:55:04– The only lawyer someone knows
  16. 00:59:47– Taking the risk
  17. 01:05:29– Caught the bug at the right time
  18. 01:08:44– The financial advisor
  19. 01:16:55– Don't keep it a secret
  20. 01:22:51– Bitcoin isn't that fragile
  21. 01:29:18– Wyoming and money printing
  22. 01:34:19– The Pentagon Papers

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
aed354357cbee0863948b8d10be48a0f3393b0319706f6db696b18628f32f67d
Proof
2020-09-01_s6_e4_justin_wales_on_bitcoin_law__free_speech__and_government_intervention.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 1 Sept 2020, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2020-09-01_s6_e4_justin_wales_on_bitcoin_law__free_speech__and_government_intervention.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2020-09-01_s6_e4_justin_wales_on_bitcoin_law__free_speech__and_government_intervention.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2020-09-01_s6_e4_justin_wales_on_bitcoin_law__free_speech__and_government_intervention.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2020-09-01_s6_e4_justin_wales_on_bitcoin_law__free_speech__and_government_intervention.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00