Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S2 · E3 · 1:17:26

Igor Artamonov on Bitcoin's Competitive Advantage (S2 E3 Article)

6 Jul 2019 · by Vlad Costea · 6 min read
Published at block 584,069
Cover art for S2 E3, Igor Artamonov on Bitcoin's Competitive Advantage
MP3 (62 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript9,549 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Igor Artamonov used to be the lead developer of ETCDEV, the team that pushed Ethereum Classic to learn as many lessons from Bitcoin as possible. Under his watch, ETC got a different mining reward schedule, closer to Bitcoin's, and leaned into immutability and decentralization. So I wanted to hear from a builder of another chain why Bitcoin keeps winning.

His answer was surprising: the fighting. You can listen on the episode page.

A Separate Community

I expected him to say ETC people are Bitcoiners at heart. He didn't. "I think it's a separate community. It's not Bitcoin people. We have more Ethereum people than Bitcoin people. Because it's not about money, it's about smart contracts." But on the technology side, "we are more close to Bitcoin vision about immutability, decentralization."

Why Bitcoin Is the Most Decentralized

Igor has written and spoken about decentralization. "I think that all blockchains are far from being fully decentralized, but Bitcoin is the most close." Bitcoin had time, and "nobody thought basically about any centralization at that moment."

Others took shortcuts. "To make it faster you need some concentration of power, of decision-making process. So all other blockchains are centralized just because they want to compete with Bitcoin."

Fighting Is the Point

This was my favorite part. For Igor, Bitcoin's real decentralization comes from its community. "It's different opinions, different views in community, and all these fights is actually good for Bitcoin." People call it toxic, "which I disagree. It just, you know, nobody has enough power to make a decision."

Then he nailed it. "If everyone would agree on the same decision, you don't need blockchain at all. That's the whole point of blockchain, that it will work even if you hate each other. You can still transfer bitcoins between you and your worst enemy."

"So if you already agree on everything, why don't you send a bank transfer or PayPal or anything else?"

The community "fights any changes that can break something." He hoped ETC would be like that too: "a second blockchain, decentralized blockchain, with community that makes final decision."

Bitcoin's forks, in his view, lack this. "None of them is much decentralized and has some, you know, core principles, ideas, vision, independent from blockchain." Without people driven by "their ideas and beliefs," it's "much harder for them to develop something similar, this open infrastructure around blockchain."

Fair Launches

We agreed that "a cryptocurrency shouldn't have any pre-mine. It changed, just from the start, the distribution of power." Bitcoin's early miners had an advantage, "but it's acceptable because they believed in the future of technology."

He liked Grin's approach. "No pre-mine, no foundation, no these public figures, leaders, CEO, distributed team, everything is just right." Early investors weren't a problem for him, "because we live in a different time now."

Cars and Horses

Igor had an analogy for how projects are built, from a book he was writing. With a car "you can reach your final destination much faster and you can control everything." But you can crash. With a horse, "maybe it's slow," but it "moves you to the destination basically in any state."

Bitcoin is the horse. Its developers believe in what they're building, and "when you believe in something, I think you're just going to be more effective." The downside is that many people "can work just on their weekends or evenings, you know, steal time from family. It slows down development of a project."

Who Pays the Developers?

As someone who ran a development team, Igor knew the problem firsthand. Exchanges are "probably the only business currently on blockchain. And they make money, definitely make money." Some give back, but usually "just small amounts." His team "didn't have anything actually." ETCDEV wound down at the end of 2018 after running out of funding.

The incentives were upside down. ICOs with "tens of millions" paid exchanges for listings. "So many of exchanges actually think that a cryptocurrency will pay them for integration, not opposite." He kept getting asked why ETC wouldn't pay. "Nobody thought that we don't have any money for that stuff."

His point: "Only Bitcoin was widely accepted as something decentralized, so nobody expected that Satoshi would pay some exchange to list it."

He saw hope in the open source model from other industries, where "companies hire someone inside the company" to work on open source software they rely on. "I see that companies are getting interested in hiring people, exchanges, to work not only on their product, but on some products for industry itself."

Wallets were his new focus, and they have the same problem: "everything is expected to be open source, everything is expected to be free." His answer was to "make technology useful for some businesses and for yourself, and then build on top of this."

How Many Coins Do We Need?

Not many. "I don't think we're going to have many cryptocurrencies. There's just no reason for that." Maybe some corporate or game coins, or stablecoins. "But as a currency, as a global cryptocurrency, we're going to have one or two, maybe three of them. So probably Bitcoin as digital gold."

He wanted privacy for everyday payments, maybe even more than Bitcoin itself. "Bitcoin is really good for holding, for savings." Lightning "still lacks some things that we usually expect and lacks privacy." Maybe a sidechain. Or, as he put it, "Maybe Bitcoin will adopt some privacy. And it will change everything."

Upgrades Are Slow, Downgrades Are Fast

Igor shared what coordinating upgrades was like at ETC. "It was really hard to convince people, miners, exchanges, to upgrade their software." Often "99% of emails are just ignored." He noticed that rolling back in an emergency is fast, because everyone wants to avoid losses, but "upgrade is usually a slow process. People are upgrading their machine slowly and it takes months and months, especially for Bitcoin."

Bitcoin as Technology First

Igor found Bitcoin around 2013 to 2015 as a developer interested in distributed systems. Coming from databases and the CAP theorem, he saw that "with Bitcoin, the technology made it just so much different."

What clicked was the idea "to avoid any central party, any bank or any company, and communicate directly with other people and send money and change everything technically." He didn't even read the white paper for months.

He bought some coins, "but not as an investment, but to play with technology." He even had mining gear but "didn't even took this money from mining pool." He told his friends about Bitcoin, and "nobody believed me at that point." In 2017 they came back: "Why you didn't tell me more about that many years before?" His regret: "I wish I would think about the economic aspect, investment aspect of Bitcoin many years ago."

He still saw the bigger picture. "Money is a power, it's another side of power." But what fascinated him most "was this brilliant way how it works, how it was designed, that it can't be broken by anyone."

Protocols Become Invisible

Igor compared Bitcoin to the internet. People use apps "and nobody cares how it was implemented." Yet the switch from IPv4 to IPv6 "took already many years, and it's unclear when it's going to be finished because it's really hard to change the protocol behind the internet." Bitcoin will be the same. "At some point people will start talking about applications, not about protocol."

Looking Back

It's rare to hear someone who led another chain's development explain Bitcoin's edge so clearly. His line about sending bitcoin to your worst enemy is still the best explanation of why consensus without trust matters.

Read the full transcript, visit the episode page, or find more on Igor Artamonov's guest page.

Listen to Igor Artamonov on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:02:37– ETC and Bitcoin communities
  2. 00:04:29– The most decentralized blockchain
  3. 00:05:22– Fights are good for Bitcoin
  4. 00:06:16– Your worst enemy
  5. 00:07:01– The community decides
  6. 00:10:40– Forks without principles
  7. 00:12:48– No pre-mine
  8. 00:15:39– Grin's approach
  9. 00:18:27– Believing versus a job
  10. 00:19:36– Cars and horses
  11. 00:20:25– Reaching the goal anyway
  12. 00:23:39– Exchanges and developers
  13. 00:25:02– ICOs paying for listings
  14. 00:25:48– Pay us for integration
  15. 00:26:34– Satoshi didn't pay
  16. 00:29:51– Companies funding open source
  17. 00:30:48– A good trend
  18. 00:35:52– Wallets expected free
  19. 00:36:34– Build useful technology
  20. 00:39:56– Few cryptocurrencies
  21. 00:40:23– Bitcoin as digital gold
  22. 00:41:14– Privacy for daily use
  23. 00:54:18– Slow upgrades
  24. 00:55:07– Ignored emails
  25. 01:01:21– Bitcoin to play with
  26. 01:02:12– Nobody believed me
  27. 01:02:51– Unclaimed mining rewards
  28. 01:05:58– No central party
  29. 01:06:41– Money is power
  30. 01:09:44– CAP theorem
  31. 01:14:50– Nobody cares how it's implemented
  32. 01:15:16– IPv4 to IPv6

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
1d59d21282c746d6acbed576a2532f4af083fe196df4a8077d9da70bf33361b7
Proof
2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 29 Jun 2019, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2019-06-29_igor_artomonov.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00