Christian CK on Why Shitcoins Might Be Good for Bitcoin (S3 E10 Full Article)
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript13,377 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Are shitcoins a smokescreen that keeps regulators busy while Bitcoin grows? That was the most memorable, and most controversial, idea in our Season 3 finale with Christian CK, co-host of the POV Crypto Podcast and my colleague at Bitcoin Magazine at the time.
The original show notes asked the question three ways. Are altcoins risky investments that newcomers should avoid? Definitely. Do they deserve liquidity? Clearly not. Do they keep the media and governments busy while Bitcoin blossoms? They might. Here's how CK made his case.
A PhD and the Expert Problem
We started with my own dilemma. I was deep in my doctorate, and my supervisor had pushed back on my use of Phil Zimmermann's own description of PGP. "Are you an expert in the field?" he asked. I wasn't, not in cryptography. Everyone, including Christie at Bitcoin Magazine, told me to finish, and I joked that I'd be "the first PhD to write for Bitcoin Magazine, which in itself is a stupid way of getting credentials from an authority."
CK, who is "younger than 30," remembered teachers warning him against Wikipedia, and summed up my position fairly. "I think you're stuck between a rock and a hard place. There's definitely the sunk cost fallacy." He was "glad I went straight into the workforce personally."
Bitcoin as a Psychedelic
CK has tweeted that "Bitcoin's a psychedelic, Bitcoin is the orange pill. It's something that wakes you up from this illusion." He agreed with me that the nanny state lets people avoid responsibility, and that "a Bitcoin world would definitely change that."
Altcoins Are Terrible Investments
He started with a disclaimer. "Let's not by any means mince words. Altcoins are terrible investments. Most of them have absolutely no future. They're just a course in rektonomics, the economics of getting rekt." His advice to friends and family is simple: "Buy Bitcoin, research Bitcoin, and then, you know, generally speaking, avoid everything else."
And then: "But with that being said, I definitely do think that altcoins are very good for Bitcoin."
The Trojan Horse
His first argument is confusion. "Bitcoin is an anti-fragile technology and network," and it has a lot of enemies. "All of the noise created by ICOs and altcoins and Libra and all this stuff, all of that stuff takes up a lot of regulatory bandwidth." It "takes their eye off what's really happening, which is Bitcoin. I really see altcoins as kind of like this Trojan horse. And on the inside is sound money."
His second is gravity. "I would argue that the number one use case for Bitcoin right now is acting as the reserve currency for the network of shitcoin casinos." People come for the gambling, buy bitcoin to get in, and generate fees and volume that fund Bitcoin businesses. "People are getting rekt. Yes, I agree. But Bitcoin is getting better."
He put it dramatically. "There are no weapons that are beyond Bitcoin's disposal. And Bitcoin will dispose of everything and everyone to achieve its mission."
The School of Rekt
CK's third argument is about learning. Projects like Ether and Decred, he said, are "based off of misconceptions on how Bitcoin really works," built to fix things that "are really features." As they play out, "their incorrect assumptions are going to start becoming very evident." For example, they assume miners are in charge, but "it's pretty clear that miners are not in charge of Bitcoin. They're service providers."
That has value. "Learning what not to do and having a case study for what not to do can be and is just as important as what to do." Developers might cut their teeth on altcoins, "gain valuable skills and valuable lessons in the school of rekt," and come to Bitcoin with more conviction, "because, you know, they've been getting rekt and they keep seeing orange coin go up."
This is where his favorite point comes in. "I say all the time that we are living in hyperbitcoinization today. Like, this is the process of hyperbitcoinization. It started the day Satoshi released the code." Bitcoin went from nothing to "a household name," with "thousands and thousands of copycats." His question to the purists: "How do you think we can go from a world that's operating on fiat to a world that has returned to a new hard money standard without this, like, rekt education, this school of rekt?"
Bitcoin's own process is the opposite. Miners, users, node operators and exchanges have "slightly misaligned incentives," and together they "form this beautiful rough consensus." I'm still not fully convinced shitcoins are a net good, but I've never heard the case made better.
Toxicity and the Majority of Value
CK thanked the maximalists who taught him. "I'm personally thankful that there were toxic maximalists there to educate me. I entered Bitcoin in 2017." He argues that "toxicity is absolutely necessary for a monetary standard to bootstrap," and he sees Ethereum fans on his own show getting more toxic over time.
He wasn't worried about competition. "UTXOs secured on the Bitcoin blockchain are what actually matters." Whether bitcoin's share is "30% or whether that's 70%," the majority of value sits with it. The next shift, he said, would be "from us giving a shit about altcoin inflation and for us to start giving a shit about real world inflation against Bitcoin."
Beyond Digital Gold
CK thinks the digital gold meme did its job. "It's been very effective at getting Bitcoin from the cheap payments narrative to the store of value narrative," and at converting gold bugs and hedge fund managers. But it's limiting. "Bitcoin is a complete monetary shift." He'd been pushing "the metric system of value," admitting that "in terms of its meme quality, it definitely could use some work."
He imagines Bitcoin built into everyday life, even "miners and nodes and stuff like that in appliances," anything that needs heat. Most people won't need to understand it, because "its values get transferred to you anyways." Those values: "saving over spending," "improving yourself," and "you have to pay for everything and nothing is free."
With hard money, "you'll see things getting cheaper and you'll see only things that are truly good investments will be invested in." From San Francisco, where he did sales at startups before Bitcoin, he had a personal reason to want that world. He'd worked at several startups and "literally every single one was such a garbage company," yet each raised millions. "I just do not think that's going to be happening the same way in a Bitcoin world."
The Sovereign Individual
I hadn't read The Sovereign Individual yet, so CK summarized it. The book describes past shifts like gunpowder changing the medieval world, and "it's really freaking crazy how accurate a lot of the things that they talk about are." Written "well before Bitcoin," it predicted that the internet would create its own nation and make it "very difficult for nation states to control their people," so states would have to compete to serve citizens. The book, by James Dale Davidson and William Rees-Mogg, came out in 1997.
He also argued that "one of Bitcoin's greatest weapons is regulatory arbitrage," and didn't expect all governments to coordinate a mining ban. China banned bitcoin mining in 2021, and the network kept going as miners moved elsewhere, which is exactly the arbitrage he described.
What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To
It's the best defense of an idea most Bitcoiners hate to hear, made by someone who still tells his family to avoid altcoins. It's also a reminder, as CK kept saying, that we're already living through hyperbitcoinization. It's a marathon that started in 2009, not an event that will happen someday.
You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Christian CK's guest page.
Listen to Christian CK on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:03:46– Wikipedia and the expert problem
- 00:07:03– Stuck between a rock and a hard place
- 00:10:33– Bitcoin as a psychedelic
- 00:22:26– Altcoins are terrible investments
- 00:24:37– The Trojan horse
- 00:30:23– Reserve currency for shitcoin casinos
- 00:38:10– Built on misconceptions
- 00:44:04– The school of rekt
- 00:48:48– Toxicity and bootstrapping a standard
- 00:52:27– UTXOs are what matters
- 00:54:36– Beyond digital gold
- 01:01:24– Bitcoin's values
- 01:05:23– Garbage startups and hard money
- 01:12:52– The Sovereign Individual
- 01:27:43– Regulatory arbitrage and mining
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
20f049bf5e401537aed8d451f45acf39386480c13c6f420cd579a49243a97157- Proof
- 2019-09-27_bitcoin_takeover_s3e10_ck_on_shitcoins.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 27 Sept 2019, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2019-09-27_bitcoin_takeover_s3e10_ck_on_shitcoins.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2019-09-27_bitcoin_takeover_s3e10_ck_on_shitcoins.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2019-09-27_bitcoin_takeover_s3e10_ck_on_shitcoins.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2019-09-27_bitcoin_takeover_s3e10_ck_on_shitcoins.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S3 E10: Christian “CK” on Shitcoins and Sovereignty
Are shitcoins just a convenient smokescreen which keeps governments and regulated distracted from Bitcoin? This has to be the…
Bitcoin Is Not Slow – It’s Highly Secure
When critics say that Bitcoin is “slow”, it’s good to remind them that security is much more important in decentralized networks…
S2 E7: Sasquatch Muscle on going from Shitcoiner to Bitcoin Maximalist
American bitcoiner Sasquatch Muscle has really come a long way. He started out as a poorly informed shitcoin speculator who was…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.