Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
Episode · 1:55:25

Max Hillebrand on Wasabi, Hardware Wallets and Privacy (S8 Special Full Article)

16 Jun 2021 · by Vlad Costea · 6 min read
Published at block 687,744
Cover art for S8 Special: Max Hillebrand on Wasabi Wallet, Hardware Wallets, Privacy & Anarchy
MP3 (159 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript16,718 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Wasabi sponsored the whole hardware wallet season, so it made sense to close it with someone from the Wasabi team. Max Hillebrand was the obvious pick. He pushed for Wasabi's hardware wallet support, and he loves explaining CoinJoin as much as he loves arguing philosophy.

We covered how Wasabi talks to hardware wallets, what WabiSabi was going to change, why merchants shouldn't fear CoinJoin outputs, sidechains and Bitcoin as a philosophy. The original show notes have the short version.

DIY Wallets and the Supply Chain

Max liked where DIY hardware was heading, because it "removes a lot of supply chain risks." General purpose boards "are produced at mass for many, many other projects. So it will be more difficult to do a targeted attack."

He added a warning, though. "It's not impossible that there would still be an attack in the supply chain of these general-purpose devices." He pointed to software, where "library packages in software, like many dependencies down the tree, were taken over by malicious actors" and Bitcoin wallet users lost coins.

How HWI Got Wasabi to Hardware Wallets

Hardware support was a long debate inside Wasabi. nopara73 didn't "want to keep up with maintaining the firmware compatibility for each hardware producer." Then Max looked at Andrew Chow's Hardware Wallet Interface, which "puts that into a separate software repository that can be used by other wallets to then talk to any hardware wallet."

That solved it. Andrew keeps fixing things "whenever a firmware upgrade of one of the hardware vendors breaks something," and "every software project that uses HWI as a dependency can benefit from that." Wasabi "was one of the first Bitcoin wallets to utilize HWI and to ship it."

Max was honest about the limits. "We don't really have the capacity to test each of these devices constantly." Still, "thanks to HWI, our uptime is better than it otherwise would have been."

He also gave credit to the original. "The OG for that is, of course, Electrum, which worked since forever with Trezor." His view is that splitting the work makes sense: hardware makers build hardware, and software teams focus on one job. Wasabi's is "to make Bitcoin usage as private" as possible.

Tor, Done Properly

Wasabi doesn't just switch Tor on. "It uses multiple Tor identities in parallel to communicate to Bitcoin peers of the general Bitcoin network, and multiple identities to talk to the coordinator about each task separately." It all happens "magically in the background, with zero user interaction." The team was also doing "a massive refactoring of the Tor integration" at the time.

Back then, hardware wallets worked in Wasabi "only for sending and receiving transactions as a single user." CoinJoin was the missing piece.

CoinJoin From Cold Storage

The feature Max was most excited about was CoinJoin with a hardware wallet. "You can CoinJoin all the stash that you have basically in your hardware wallet, cold storage, so to say." People keep more on hardware wallets than on hot wallets, so this "removes a lot of attack vectors that might have made users uncomfortable to be part of a CoinJoin."

WabiSabi and the End of the Minimum

Its core trick: "one user can register multiple inputs to the CoinJoin, as many as you want, basically up to a certain limit. And the coordinator, even the coordinator does not find out that one user controls all of these coins."

It also removes the minimum. At the time, "we have a 0.1 Bitcoin minimum denomination." Without it, CoinJoin gets "all of a sudden much more inclusive." Payments inside a CoinJoin also become possible, because "even the coordinator cannot link your input to the payment output, or even to your change output."

Then there's the whale problem. With ZeroLink, big holders get split into tiny coins and "end up with thousands of UTXOs in their wallet." WabiSabi "flipped that decomposition upside down." Whales get large coins, "much fewer block space is used," and CoinJoin becomes "a lot, a lot, a lot cheaper." The trade-off is "a somewhat reduced anonymity set." Old coins that remix can even pay lower coordinator fees.

WabiSabi did ship later, with Wasabi 2.0 in 2022.

Why Merchants Shouldn't Fear CoinJoin

Some services had flagged or refused CoinJoin outputs. Max's argument was economic. Bitcoin "is cash with final settlement. It is not a debt certificate as fiat money is." With debt, you check your counterparty. "But in the Bitcoin system, once I give you my Bitcoin, they're yours, and I cannot take them back." Refusing CoinJoin users might look good to regulators, he said, "but ultimately it will lose you users."

Lightning vs Sidechains

Max loves Lightning because "we can make non-custodial Bitcoin transactions in a way that not everyone has to verify that the transaction happened." His test for any layer: "always compare if you can actually control money proper or if you cannot."

Sidechains fail that test in his view. "This is in fact a money substitute. It is no longer base money, but a claim on base money." He used Liquid's federation as the example, which he sees as "always custodial, if you look at it from a base layer perspective." That's a design point, not a dismissal. He finds the research interesting.

He also doesn't expect layers to make the base chain quiet. Even with Lightning, he still makes on-chain transactions, maybe "5 Bitcoin transactions per month" for a decent node. "I don't envision a world where we will actually have empty blocks for a sustained time, if there's actually usage of Bitcoin even on higher layers."

Not in It for the Money

"It's kind of weird that we're here building a money, but so to say, we're not really in it for the money." Once you see what Bitcoin could mean, "it gets kind of hard, if not impossible, to actually, like, you know, not spend your time on Bitcoin."

He even prices his time in sats. "My Socratic seminars go at 250,000 sats per month. That price has not changed for many, many months."

He also warned about sudden wealth. "For many people, probably for most people, getting a lot of money really fast is very bad for you." The hope is that Bitcoin flips your priorities, so "reading books about monetary history, is all of a sudden the most important thing that you could possibly do."

Hierarchies of Competence

We ended on philosophy, as we always do with Max. He explained anarchy from the Greek, "'An' meaning 'without' and 'archon,' 'rulers.'" For him, "there are still hierarchies in anarchy. But they are not hierarchies of power." They're "hierarchies of competency."

His example was his own team. "I cannot code. So he's much superior in coding per se than I am," he said of nopara73, "and there is nothing wrong with having this hierarchy."

Bitcoin, to him, is "a manifestation of an individualistic philosophy," and more than theory: "a weapon for sovereign individuals." The reason is simple. "Nobody can break the mathematics of your private/public key encryption."

He was also excited about Taproot. "As we're speaking, the 144-day moving average signaling rate is at roughly 93%." Taproot locked in shortly after and activated in November 2021. He was already thinking about the next soft fork, especially "to enable the eltoo Lightning Network channel update mechanism."

What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To

If you've wondered how a privacy wallet can work with your hardware wallet, Max explains it clearly. The WabiSabi part is a great primer on how CoinJoin design choices affect fees and privacy. And the philosophy at the end is classic Max.

You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Max Hillebrand's guest page.

Listen to Max Hillebrand on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:04:36– DIY wallets and supply chain risk
  2. 00:05:21– Dependency attacks
  3. 00:08:10– Should Wasabi support hardware wallets?
  4. 00:08:53– Andrew Chow's HWI
  5. 00:11:17– Testing every device
  6. 00:14:54– Electrum, the OG
  7. 00:19:59– Multiple Tor identities
  8. 00:20:38– Tor in the background
  9. 00:21:00– Single-user hardware wallet support
  10. 00:22:27– CoinJoin from cold storage
  11. 00:26:31– CoinJoin outputs flagged
  12. 00:27:31– Losing users
  13. 00:29:00– Cash with final settlement
  14. 00:31:33– Beyond ZeroLink
  15. 00:33:56– Multiple inputs, one user
  16. 00:34:46– No minimum denomination
  17. 00:38:48– Payments inside a CoinJoin
  18. 00:43:48– The whale problem
  19. 00:45:35– Flipping the decomposition
  20. 00:54:32– Fee incentives for old coins
  21. 00:57:33– Why Lightning is genius
  22. 00:58:52– Sidechains and custody
  23. 01:07:18– Control money proper
  24. 01:11:27– Blocks will stay full
  25. 01:19:42– Not in it for the money
  26. 01:26:05– Hierarchies of competence
  27. 01:35:24– Sudden wealth
  28. 01:46:27– Priced in sats
  29. 01:47:58– Taproot and eltoo
  30. 01:50:18– A weapon for sovereign individuals

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
c32ca109637734a5e964a2306117cce44cc94aa9fae3d0ae45805032e8f0596b
Proof
2021-06-09_s8_special_max_hillebrand_wasabi__hardware_wallets__freedom.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 9 Jun 2021, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2021-06-09_s8_special_max_hillebrand_wasabi__hardware_wallets__freedom.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2021-06-09_s8_special_max_hillebrand_wasabi__hardware_wallets__freedom.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2021-06-09_s8_special_max_hillebrand_wasabi__hardware_wallets__freedom.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2021-06-09_s8_special_max_hillebrand_wasabi__hardware_wallets__freedom.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00