Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S12 · E4 · 2:41:10

Rahim Taghizadegan on Austrian Economics and Bitcoin as a Cult (S12 E4 Full Article)

19 Oct 2022 · by Vlad Costea · 7 min read
Published at block 759,384
Cover art for S12 E4, Rahim Taghizadegan on Austrian Economics & Bitcoin as a Cult
MP3 (297 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript22,364 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Lots of Bitcoiners call themselves Austrian economists. Rahim Taghizadegan actually teaches it, from Vienna, through his Scholarium. I met him at Mallorca Blockchain Days in July 2022, where his talk was about Bitcoin's cult-like community. That's not a topic most economists touch, so I had to have him on.

This is one of the longest episodes I've published, and it's calm and careful from start to finish. The original show notes have the short version.

What the Austrian School Is

Rahim described it as "a tradition of economics that emerged out of a late Austrian Enlightenment, out of a phase of cultural flourishing within a society in crisis." What makes it special is "its interdisciplinary approach to understanding human action." And for Bitcoiners, "it's a tradition that best helps explain the emergent phenomenon."

Don't call him part of a group, though. "Oh, I really dislike labels. I think they're part of our tribalism. I don't think there's anything like Austrian economists as a group or a community."

Describe First, Judge Later

That set the tone for the whole conversation. Rahim separates the descriptive from the normative. You "try to withhold judgment and first seek to understand." With Bitcoin, he tries "to figure out what people want and what utility they are seeing."

He admitted where his early views were off. "I'd rather be part of the big blockers, I think, early on." Looking back, the slow pace made sense. "It made sense to focus on the resilience of the first layer and not on scalability at first." That's why he thinks it's "unfair to use the term ossification with that value judgment."

Fungibility surprised him too. He once thought it was "the major issue." Instead, "practical privacy still seems to be good enough." His explanation is neat: "one way to enhance your privacy, paradoxically, is not only technology, it's liquidity. It's how many different users you have."

Privacy, though, is never settled. "We've always been in a privacy war and it was never sure who is going to win in the end. It's always the bottom-up process of innovation versus the top-down process of the state."

Predictions That Didn't Happen

Rahim expected the US to be the first major government to push against Bitcoin. "But it was the Chinese in the end who got rid more or less of the mining and their exchanges." He thinks that "was the wrong decision, because the adoption in Asia was much stronger before."

The 2021 mining ban taught him something else. "The mining infrastructure is surprisingly resilient." He "wouldn't have expected that the Chinese mining ban would have so little impact on the general hash rate."

Bitcoin, Gold and the Dollar

On analogies, he's careful. "I try to avoid analogies unless they really help you understand something." Gold helps, because Satoshi's "peer-to-peer cash" doesn't only mean payments. "Of course, cash is a lot of things."

Ten years ago, he thought the chance Bitcoin would challenge the dollar was "absolutely minimal." He still isn't sure it does. But "it's a contender for assets, in particular treasuries." The dollar isn't really banknotes. "It's a settlement layer and it's a trust layer." And "Bitcoin is already quite a contender for an international settlement layer."

His view on portfolios: "both gold and Bitcoin will be increased in portfolios because an age of artificially low volatility is ending." He gives Bitcoin the edge: "It allows for self-custody, it doesn't need the centralized marketplaces and storage solutions that gold needs."

The case is strongest against what he calls regime uncertainty. If your risk is "capital controls, regulation, and so on, then I think the case for Bitcoin increases."

CBDCs Help Bitcoin

Rahim pushed back on the idea that CBDCs compete with Bitcoin. "CBDCs are presented as an alternative to Bitcoin, and that's completely wrong, of course." People misunderstand cash. "It's a permissionless bearer instrument and it wouldn't be able to emerge nowadays."

So as cash fades, "the case for Bitcoin increases and gets stronger because there's a vacuum to be filled." He agreed with me that "CBDC is a dystopian scheme," but he isn't passive about it. "It will increase the pressure as well."

Trust Is Underrated

This was my favorite part. "It would be a big misunderstanding to think that Bitcoin is a trustless solution because trust is bad." His version: "We have to replace trust because trust has been abused and trust can't be trusted anymore."

Money, he said, "emerges if foreigners are cooperating, and foreigners have trust issues." And it isn't a movement in his eyes. "Money and technology usually are discoveries and not conventions." That's why Bitcoiners tend to be optimistic: they see "a success story against all odds."

Three Kinds of Maximalism

Rahim split maximalism into three things. The first is style: "shitposting, trolling," memes on Twitter. Some people are triggered by it, but lumping everyone together is a mistake. "You are perceived as a 'we' which doesn't exist."

The second is moral, people who feel obliged to call out others. Not his approach, but he'd "be reluctant in perceiving it as a big problem."

The third is his own. After years of watching, "it looks like there were many issues and people tried to improve upon it. Nothing is really convincing. There are trade-offs. And it's not obvious that any altcoin made a better choice."

He's relaxed about experiments. "I myself lost a lot of my Bitcoin early on, of course, in experiments." His view: "It shouldn't be illegal to lose your own money." Still, he's skeptical about retail speculation after "the ICO hype, the DeFi hype, the NFT hype," because it "will lead to regulatory pressure."

Bitcoin as a Cult

Then the topic from Mallorca. Rahim doesn't use "cult" as an insult. "A cult can be the seed of a culture. It's our capacity to have a very abstract layer which is not blood." He traced the word religion to "religio. It's a bond."

The Austrian school cares most about "the catallaxy, the extended order," where "we are capable to cooperate with foreigners." Bonds help that, but they can also limit it, "because the tribe needs the other, and potentially the enemy."

Compared to other reactions to lost trust, he thinks Bitcoin is "one of the least toxic reactions, because it's one of the most positive phenomena of looking for alternatives."

His advice on community drama is healthy. It "feels only bad if you've linked so much of your identity to it." Better to "seek other and more physical ways for that kind of need for belonging." Drama isn't a sign of failure either, "because there'll always be drama where human beings are involved."

Why He Left the University Model

"About 12 years ago, I think I realized that the institution of the university is not working, and in particular in the social sciences." A university was meant to be a community of teachers and learners. "It has become just a community of the teachers, and this has become a community of the certifiers."

When he started, "there was no one teaching the Austrian School of Economics. It completely died out in Austria." The Scholarium is his answer. It "has always sustained itself, always cash flow positive, never accepted any subsidies." The program is mostly in German, and he doesn't market it. "People need to really want it."

For a first book, he'd pick "'Human Action' by Ludwig von Mises." But "I would not overrate books too much."

What Makes This Episode Worth Listening To

If you want a calm, academic look at Bitcoin that isn't cheerleading, this is it. Rahim explains why things turned out the way they did, admits where he was wrong and gives you a better way to think about maximalism and community. Take your time with it.

You can read the full transcript, the original show notes, or visit Rahim Taghizadegan's guest page.

Listen to Rahim Taghizadegan on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:02:23– What the Austrian school is
  2. 00:05:17– No labels
  3. 00:06:28– Describe first
  4. 00:07:18– Good trade-offs
  5. 00:09:11– Big blocks and ossification
  6. 00:11:55– Fungibility
  7. 00:13:03– Liquidity as privacy
  8. 00:18:49– The privacy war
  9. 00:21:47– China, not the US
  10. 00:23:34– The wrong decision
  11. 00:29:27– Analogies and gold
  12. 00:33:50– Regime uncertainty
  13. 00:41:33– A contender for assets
  14. 00:44:41– Settlement and trust layers
  15. 00:46:56– Gold and Bitcoin in portfolios
  16. 00:54:48– CBDCs and cash
  17. 00:56:32– A vacuum to be filled
  18. 00:59:29– A dystopian scheme
  19. 01:08:40– Human Action
  20. 01:14:08– Trust is underrated
  21. 01:15:48– Money between foreigners
  22. 01:16:30– A success story against all odds
  23. 01:19:32– The least toxic reaction
  24. 01:22:33– Maximalism as style
  25. 01:23:57– A "we" that doesn't exist
  26. 01:26:01– His kind of maximalism
  27. 01:26:51– Resilient mining
  28. 01:34:57– Losing your own money
  29. 01:37:27– ICO, DeFi and NFT hype
  30. 02:07:50– The extended order
  31. 02:09:06– A cult can seed a culture
  32. 02:10:36– The tribe needs the other
  33. 02:15:45– Drama and identity
  34. 02:17:14– Physical belonging
  35. 02:22:17– Drama isn't failure
  36. 02:24:55– Leaving the university model
  37. 02:28:54– A dead tradition revived
  38. 02:31:10– Scholarium
  39. 02:32:34– Not marketing it

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
7f84ced6d37f56f83dafadd6e24c166c2c864b5d62f105af029b2b0ca71585a5
Proof
2022-10-12_s12_e4_rahim_taghizadegan_on_austrian_economics__bitcoin_as_a_cult.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 12 Oct 2022, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2022-10-12_s12_e4_rahim_taghizadegan_on_austrian_economics__bitcoin_as_a_cult.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2022-10-12_s12_e4_rahim_taghizadegan_on_austrian_economics__bitcoin_as_a_cult.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2022-10-12_s12_e4_rahim_taghizadegan_on_austrian_economics__bitcoin_as_a_cult.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2022-10-12_s12_e4_rahim_taghizadegan_on_austrian_economics__bitcoin_as_a_cult.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00