Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S16 · E50 · 1:46:02

S16 E50: Ray Youssef on Why Paxful's Terminated

8 Oct 2025 · by Vlad Costea · 11 min read
Published at block 918,171
Cover art for S16 E50, Ray Youssef on Why Paxful's Terminated
MP3 (146 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript17,949 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Before we had said anything about Bitcoin, I wanted to get one thing straight, so I read the phrase from the press release out loud: "winding down operations." That is how Paxful described its own end on October 1, 2025. Ray Youssef, who co-founded the company and was its CEO, had been telling me for a while that this was coming, and now he was on my livestream, sponsoring the show through NoOnes, the platform he built after leaving, ready to say what he thinks happened.

We ran 1 hour and 46 minutes. I had brought a pun, "Taxful," which I will explain below, and I had also brought a promise that I would be the pun master for NoOnes if he ever needed one. He did not take me up on it. He did tell me about Age of Empires, a water bottle, two portraits on his wall, and why he now believes Bitcoin cannot be built on anymore.

"Taxful" and the 3,000 Bitcoin

Ray had predicted the shutdown to everyone around him. "I told everyone at the time, this company is not going to stay up," he said, and his reason was structural: "This company is not viable as an American company to serve the global south." He pointed out that Paxful's own announcement gave the same cause: "they said the same thing in their press release, American regulations."

The coins are what he cares about most. Paxful, he says, held about 3,000 BTC in cold storage, and "I'm willing to bet that 3000 Bitcoin is not there anymore at all." According to Ray, regulatory trouble was a convenient cover: "that was their excuse to actually pull the money out of cold storage." He also said plainly that he cannot see inside the company anymore: "I have no visibility."

Then there is the part that gave me the pun. Ray described a monthly "dormant tax" of 2% to 3% on inactive accounts, which is why I started calling the whole situation Taxful. He added that "Some people's accounts are just deleted," and that American customers were given one month to withdraw.

I asked about a class action, because that is the obvious Western reflex. Ray said "maybe we'll start a class-action lawsuit," while warning that "it would be, you know, a long painstaking, a very expensive process." His practical suggestion for users was to sue so that discovery forces Paxful to produce its database records. He kept to his own old line about custody too: "every Monday I sent an email telling people about cold storage." And the advice he gave again on air: "Don't keep your money on centralized exchanges, especially not American ones."

Eleven Days in the Code

I wanted to know what he did before leaving, because he left in 2023 and the collapse came afterwards. Ray said he spent 11 days trying to repair the wallet code. "I stayed up for 11 days, 11 straight days trying to find help going into code." He also told me he put real money behind it. "I'll give you $1.6 million of my own money to make sure that you do the compliance work to unfreeze funds," was his offer, as he related it to me.

He stressed that he had chosen his co-founder carefully, though the advice he drew from it was general: "you choose your business partner like your wife." He also said the point of exposing all this has a cost to him. "Every time I tell the truth about this, I put myself at legal risk," he said.

His own Paxful account was not spared. "My own account got drained," he told me. I mentioned that I do not trust press releases for this kind of story, since "reading press releases is very sterile," and that is why I wanted him on a livestream rather than a statement page. He told me he wants customers to have "three years to get their money back" rather than a month, which is the window he thinks would be fair.

Ray's Mexico arrest and life after NoOnes are the subject of a conversation I recorded later: S17 E12: Ray Youssef on the Mexico Arrest & Life After NoOnes.

Eight Million Gone, No One Out of Pocket

Not everything was a postmortem, and I pushed him on NoOnes's own security record, since a founder who criticizes Paxful should answer for his own platform. Ray did not dodge. In January, NoOnes lost "$8 million gone" through "an old Solana bug." And his account of the aftermath was: "No one lost any money," and "we reformed our entire security team."

He sees the role of a platform founder in a particular way: "kind of like the president of a country and your users are your citizens." His reasoning is that "Essentially what these fintech platforms really are is governance. They handle all your money. And 99.9% of governance, it's really about money." He pairs that with an insistence on transparency, "it's all public for the whole world to see," and says he would never flaunt the profits: "I wouldn't be caught dead in a Lambo."

His hiring philosophy came up here too. Ray pays employees by a global scale instead of whatever the local market rate happens to be: "You should pay people not at the market rate." He compared underpaying workers abroad to something "worse than criminal." He told me about a young hire in Africa who attacked the work immediately: "this young guy hit the ground like a demon." I said something like "Like they just do their job," meaning I was glad to hear the staff were treated normally rather than as a charity project, and Ray described the company as "more like a country."

A story about a Ghanaian trader made it into this stretch as well: a user who joined Paxful at age 14 and became a multimillionaire by building a Litecoin app.

The WeChat of the Global South

NoOnes, Ray says, is "doing 10 times more volume than Paxful ever did." He puts the number in context by comparing the old company's scale: "320 or 360 million dollars." The new platform, he told me, is Bitcoin-first and not a USDT shop, and it has a Partner Program that he launched with Kate Grazic.

His pitch for the future is bigger than trading. "I really see it as the WeChat of the Global South." The Shops marketplace he described holds "domain names, cows, jobs, classified ads" and he summed it up as "basically like Silk Road, but no bad stuff is allowed, not even pornography or alcohol." Later he told me this is "the best commerce platform we have in all of crypto right now."

I listened, and then pushed on tokenization, because my concern is that these experiments tend to be launched before anyone has proved they work. Ray's answer was a theory about incentives: "Tokenization is the ultimate tool to align incentives in communities. That's what stocks were supposed to do, really." On the question of who owns what, he said "everyone should have a coin." I made a joke about a coin name and a different word, "how you spell doom," and moved on.

He asked me, in a tangent, whether I play games. I had to admit "the last RPG I played was Final Fantasy 6." That was nothing next to his answers. He mentioned "looking to build an army of 10,000 warrior mages" and, entirely seriously, "Garrosh did nothing wrong." And he claimed credit for a strategy: "The Priest-Prophet Rush in Age of Empires was pioneered by me, the Warchief," which, as he described it, means loading two transport boats with prophets named Moses, Jesus and Muhammad and beating a champion player. He also said, about the world itself, "Allah really is like the ultimate game designer. I mean, he does a lot of things. He designed the whole universe, but he designed this world that we're in right now as like a game."

Leaving Bitcoin for DarkFi

This is the pivot I had been waiting for, and it comes with a confession. NoOnes "was built on Bitcoin, which was a mistake because Bitcoin is completely ossified and nothing can really be built on Lightning." Ray is moving it. "I'm building on DarkFi because this whole thing should be private," he said, and he named a collaborator, "one of the original Bitcoin developers," whom we know from the show as Amir Taaki. Amir Taaki's episode is S15 E71: Amir Taaki on Bitcoin, DarkFi, and the Privacy Year.

His philosophy is that users decide through their wallets: "You vote by how you spend your money and who you spend your money with." So he asked me to help drive liquidity. "If you really want to help the world, go and trade on NoOnes. Put up some liquidity. That's the single best thing you can do to help the world."

Ray's view of Bitcoin's history is blunt, and he has apologized for it in public. "I apologize to Roger Ver," he said, and "Bitcoin was hijacked. It really was." He remembered paying "like $26 at the height of the bubble in 2017" in fees, when the plan was "onboarding the entire global south" and the debate was "big block, small block nonsense."

He is also dismissive of what gets built on top now. "Anything you're going to build on top of Bitcoin now is just going to be a waste," he said, and when I mentioned Layer 2 attempts like Citrea or LayerTwo Labs, his reaction was, "I'm not even sure what that is, but I can only guess."

I felt the need to say that I do not recognize the social picture Ray painted. I told him "what's happening on Twitter does not happen in real life," and I said that I have shared rooms with people who spend all day attacking me online, and we simply ignored each other. As for how I feel about being on the outside, I told him I am "kind of desolated, but at the same time not defeated." And we joked that he and I are both expelled from the church of Bitcoin.

Blood, Power and a Water Bottle

For Ray, the argument underneath all of it is about who controls circulation. "The prize is the power," he said, and he compared it to "controlling the blood in a human's body." To make the point he tapped his microphone to illustrate how a central bank can drain or double the blood volume of an economy. His conclusion: "That is the power. And that is the power that they have that we must take away." Another version of his politics came out near the end: "There should be no taxes. Of any kind."

He has no illusions about his reputation: "people have accused me of being CIA, mostly." And I asked about the portraits of Malcolm X and Muammar Gaddafi on his wall, which he explained as part of who he is. He told me he met Michael Saylor and turned down efforts by institutional maximalists to make him a poster boy, and that CZ tried to buy Paxful but "I refuse because I wasn't just in it for the money. I was really in it for the mission."

I asked what he would do if it all ended tomorrow. "I can go back to my old life, just waking up every morning, training, boxing at MMA and lifting weights for five hours a day." He drives a Mini Cooper and is 3D printing a Shelby Cobra. And then the water bottle. Ray is developing a bottle that structures water, and he gave me the pitch: "The energy signature of spring water only lasts 48 hours once it leaves the spring and then it just dies." I was skeptical and said so, because "water structuring" belongs to a category I do not think holds up.

At Monerotopia, I had said the date as 2025 and had to be fixed. "it's actually next year in 2026," I read out when I looked it up. Ray was by then busy: "Oh, sorry. I was doing my hair," he said, as the stream wound down.

For Ray, what comes next is a rebuild of NoOnes on a Web 3 stack, most likely DarkFi, a larger Shops marketplace, and the Partner Program with Kate Grazic. He wants more traders putting up liquidity there, and he intends to keep telling the Paxful story, legal risk included. His earlier talk with Nicholas Gregory about a peer-to-peer marketplace is in S14 E2: Nicholas Gregory & Ray Youssef on Civ Kit & P2P Marketplaces.

Listen to Ray Youssef on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:01:08– Introducing Ray Youssef
  2. 00:01:15– Discussion on Paxful Termination and NoOnes as a Better Alternative
  3. 00:01:29– Ray Youssef Accused of Undermining Paxful
  4. 00:02:54– Paxful Press Release on Winding Down Operations
  5. 00:03:31– Ray Youssef's Response and Exit from Paxful
  6. 00:03:46– Warnings About Paxful's 3,000 Bitcoin in Cold Storage
  7. 00:04:29– American Regulations Impacting Paxful
  8. 00:05:15– New Indian Team at Paxful
  9. 00:05:27– BitGo as Former Custodian for Paxful
  10. 00:05:53– Dormant Tax Introduced by Paxful (Taxful Pun)
  11. 00:08:36– Ray Youssef's Beard and Hair Discussion
  12. 00:09:23– Expulsion from Bitcoin Church and Fatwa by High Priests
  13. 00:10:07– Bitcoin as Financial and Monetary System
  14. 00:10:44– NoOnes Replacing Financial Pillar for Global South
  15. 00:10:49– Economic Apartheid Concept
  16. 00:11:15– Ray Youssef Homeless When Starting Paxful
  17. 00:11:20– Ex-Co-Founder (Artur Schaback Implied) as Business Partner Warning
  18. 00:11:50– Executive Team Letters Against Ex-Co-Founder
  19. 00:12:03– Attempt to Shut Down Paxful and Handle 3,000 Bitcoin
  20. 00:12:47– Lawsuit by Ex-Co-Founder on Martin Luther King Day
  21. 00:13:03– Accusations and Projections by Ex-Co-Founder
  22. 00:13:27– Fintech Company Without Engineers During Lawsuit
  23. 00:14:23– Ex-Co-Founder Incompetent as CPO
  24. 00:15:05– $1.6 Million from Ray Youssef to Unfreeze Funds
  25. 00:15:29– Delaware Law Firm Handling Paxful
  26. 00:15:35– New Indian CEO Removing Paxful from LinkedIn Bio
  27. 00:16:00– Ray Narrative on BitcoinMagazine.com
  28. 00:16:17– Ex-Co-Founder Raiding Estonian Office
  29. 00:18:32– Kate Grazic Back for NoOnes Partner Program
  30. 00:18:57– LocalBitcoins Traders at NoOnes
  31. 00:19:03– Paxful Family Reunited at NoOnes
  32. 00:19:27– NoOnes Structure Outside the West
  33. 00:21:07– 3,000 Bitcoin Worth $360 Million
  34. 00:24:56– Own Account Bitcoin Disappeared from Paxful
  35. 00:24:59– Solana Contract Issue in January
  36. 00:25:04– Nick Carter Calling Ray Youssef a Clown
  37. 00:25:11– Ari David Paul Accusing Scamming with NoOnes
  38. 00:25:24– Support for Gaza and Palestine
  39. 00:25:30– Nick Carter and Ari David Paul as Zionists
  40. 00:26:19– Hack During Hajj in Medina
  41. 00:27:34– Solana Bug Leading to Hack
  42. 00:28:09– Ray Youssef Driving a Mini Cooper
  43. 00:30:42– Muy from Ghana as Top Advocate at NoOnes
  44. 00:33:07– Victor Schauberger's Work on Water
  45. 00:35:43– WeChat of the Global South (NoOnes Vision)
  46. 00:36:27– Silk Road Comparison (Clean Version)
  47. 00:37:28– CivKit Project
  48. 00:37:34– Nicholas Gregory (CivKit Collaborator)
  49. 00:37:41– Commerce Block
  50. 00:38:29– DarkFi Project
  51. 00:38:34– Amir Taaki (Narodism) as Original Bitcoin Developer
  52. 00:42:38– Roger Ver Attacked by Trolls
  53. 00:44:21– Michael Saylor Meeting
  54. 00:45:58– Adam Back as Skinny Twerp
  55. 00:59:18– Tokenization Experiments by Ray Youssef
  56. 01:04:09– Shelby Cobra 3D-Printed Car Project
  57. 01:04:34– Water Bottle Structuring Water (Victor Schauberger Inspired)
  58. 01:06:17– Malcolm X, Muammar Gaddafi, African Heroes on Wall
  59. 01:18:06– Bitcoin.com News
  60. 01:18:43– Roger Ver Quoted
  61. 01:20:06– Roger Ver as Hero
  62. 01:21:03– Bitcoin Cash
  63. 01:23:00– Lunar the Silver Star (Sega CD Game)
  64. 01:23:14– Garsh Hellcream (Warcraft Reference)
  65. 01:24:37– XMR Bazaar (Monero Marketplace)
  66. 01:25:32– Layer 2 Labs (Drivechains)
  67. 01:26:05– Zcash Sidechain
  68. 01:26:12– Thunder (Big Block Bitcoin Sidechain)
  69. 01:27:25– Citrea (ZK Rollup for Bitcoin)
  70. 01:32:57– Litecoin and MWEB (Mimblewimble Extension Block)
  71. 01:33:10– Bitcoin Cash
  72. 01:33:17– Monero
  73. 01:34:12– Age of Empires (Priest Rush Invented by Ray Youssef)
  74. 01:35:52– Sandy Peterson (Age of Empires Designer)
  75. 01:36:06– USA Stablecoin Act
  76. 01:37:02– Monerotopia Event
  77. 01:37:39– Vitalik Buterin (In Photo)
  78. 01:40:17– Val Venis (WWE Wrestler)
  79. 01:41:10– Taxes Abolished in New World
  80. 01:45:15– Sideshift (Swap Platform)

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
efe7605389eb92a9ed6bc75d1d648ea0ea826b477307ed34f1d0249398c0c586
Proof
2025-10-13_s16_e50_ray_youssef_on_why_paxful_s_terminated.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 13 Oct 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2025-10-13_s16_e50_ray_youssef_on_why_paxful_s_terminated.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2025-10-13_s16_e50_ray_youssef_on_why_paxful_s_terminated.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2025-10-13_s16_e50_ray_youssef_on_why_paxful_s_terminated.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2025-10-13_s16_e50_ray_youssef_on_why_paxful_s_terminated.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00