S16 E49: Jay Berg on Bitcoin, SidePit & Maximalism
The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.
Read the transcript37,072 words, every line links to the minute it was said
Ask this episode
Jay Berg opened our four hours and fifteen minutes by telling me how the episode should be retitled. "I would say the idea of being called a shitcoiner should be the new Bitcoin maximalism," he said, and then, without being asked: "We should rename this podcast, the shitcoin takeover podcast." That was the first two minutes of S16 E49, and it set the temperature for the rest of the night.
Jay is a Bitcoin developer and the founder of Sidepit, a Bitcoin-based sidechain exchange for dollar futures. He worked at Bloomberg, then as a quant developer at a Fortress hedge fund, found Bitcoin in 2010, and in 2012 tweeted the first BTCUSD relative high, $12. I had him on the show because he holds a package of opinions I have not heard from anyone else. He thinks both sides of the OP_RETURN fight are wrong, that Ethereum is leveraged Bitcoin, that the 2017 civil war was partly his fault, and that a futures exchange belongs in a digital copy of the Chicago trading pit. Early on I asked how he would describe his position, and he answered, "I probably disagree with everybody."
I came in with my own habits. I covered Bitcoin Cash at Bitcoin.com News back when the outlet was still green (it has since gone orange and pivoted to BTC), and I own one of the six laptops used in the 2016 Zcash trusted setup ceremony, which I bought from Peter Todd. So I was not a neutral party for most of what follows, and I pushed back more than once.
Crypto Is Bitcoin
The foundation of Jay's thinking is a definition of Bitcoin that is much wider than the one I use. "Crypto is Bitcoin. Ethereum is Bitcoin. Zcash is Bitcoin. Lightning is Bitcoin. Liquid is Bitcoin." His reasoning is that each of them supplies a function Bitcoin itself never delivered: "We have not achieved peer-to-peer electronic cash in Bitcoin itself."
I objected, and my objection was simple. Bitcoin is a specific codebase, and the other things are other things. I have the same reflex when someone tells me Ethereum scales Bitcoin, which is a claim Jay makes outright, and I asked him what exactly is being scaled when the two chains share neither rules nor history. His answer is that the Bitcoin brand and the BTCUSD ticker matter more than any particular implementation. "BTCUSD is always going to be Bitcoin," he said, and, on the fork wars, "whoever lost the ticker symbol loses." He said he still can't get over the fact that Ethereum Classic survived at all: "I couldn't believe it when Ethereum Classic stayed alive."
He believes this view would earn him hate from every direction. Of the Ethereum-scales-Bitcoin idea he said, "I would get hate from both sides immediately," and he puts most of the reaction down to psychology: "It's mostly cognitive dissonance." Jay's prescription for dissonance is the standard one, "then you have to update your priors."
He also floated a joke about supply that I will repeat for the record. Faced with the 21 million cap, he said, "I'm just going to calculate the number of Ethereum that exists and add it to the 21 million." In his telling the cap is less sacred than the culture around it: "21 million is not core to Bitcoin." And on the Ethereum price: "every single currency that is not a scam is literally sideways forever," a line he applies to ETH against BTC since 2016. That is where his "Ethereum is leveraged Bitcoin" claim comes from, and he said it plainly: "Ethereum is leveraged Bitcoin."
Neither Side of the Filter Fight Is Right
On OP_RETURN and the filter debate, Jay says the argument is badly framed. "I think both sides are incorrect." He opposes raising the OP_RETURN limit ("definitely not a good idea") but does not think filtering is a coherent answer either. His own approach is blunter: "if you want to kick out or you want to do a filter, get people to use use Bitcoin as money and ordinals will be dead."
He has a gripe about how little Bitcoin gets used as money in the first place. His example is conference tickets. "You can't even buy a ticket to Bitcoin 2025, you know, in Bitcoin," and more broadly "all the tickets being sold at every single toxic Maxi conference are sold in USDs. Right. So it just it just got so out of whack." I have bought plenty of tickets in dollars myself, so I took that one on the chin. I had previously recorded S15 E50 with Murch on Ordinals, OP_CAT, zero-conf and the 2140 panic.
He even carried this into selling. "If you never sell your Bitcoin, you literally don't have enough Bitcoin," he told me, and a bit later, "You should be selling Bitcoin every single day to eat and live. Like, whoa, how are you going to buy lunch if you're not selling your Bitcoin?" I teased him that this was more hodl-heresy than I get at most conferences.
OP_CTV and the "Original Sin"
When I asked him where Bitcoin went wrong, he named a specific opcode. "OP_CTV was the one thing that we found and that could have been the beginning of the solution." He claims it had consensus for years, "There has been zero objections to OP_CTV for the past five, six years", and that what stopped it was money and influence. "I think that's the original sin of Bitcoin," he said, and, as part of his wide definition of the word, "I believe Bitcoin includes OP_CTV."
The villain in his version is Adam Back, or more precisely, Adam Back's silence. "All Adam Back had to say was, you know what, I have no opinion and take a step back." He also argued that funding and mindshare were the missing ingredients. "The fact of the matter is that OP_CTV was ready to go, had consensus, and it is Bitcoin."
I disagreed about the rivalry. In my view OP_CAT currently has more of both: "OP_CAT has more backing and has more money behind it." Jay's reply was that it is all moot now. "It's too late for any of this stuff." Elsewhere in the conversation he said he thinks the next big proposal will "take too much mindshare" to get through. A later episode picks this thread up: Moonsettler on OP_CTV and failing to improve Bitcoin.
His take on soft forks in general is unusual too. "Every single soft fork is a hard fork for the miners." That was part of an argument about who holds power in these upgrades, and I did not have a ready answer.
An Apology for 2017
Partway through the evening, Jay apologized, and not for something small. "I really want to apologize for my part in it," he said of the 2017 civil war. The way he tells it, the movement made a mistake by recruiting the wrong audience. "We invited, you know, the plebs, the normies, and we gave them one liners." After that, "They never left and they took control." I asked how he squares this with having been a developer-first type, and the line he returned to was the idea that "the coders are now in charge," which is how he felt about Bitcoin in the early days.
He is also grumpy about the shape of the fight itself. "It's crazy that it became the big blockers and the small blockers when SegWit was a block size increase." Jay's view is that Shaolin Fry's BIP 148 was the mechanism that forced SegWit through, and that the story told afterward was cleaner than the facts. "Nobody was actually running UASF binaries," he said, and he added that the binaries lacked the proper signatures for Windows and macOS. I corrected him on the timeline of the New York Agreement along the way, and we spent a few minutes sorting out the sequence of events.
What he believes could follow is a reconciliation. "There's no reason why we can't bring everyone back and create one Bitcoin again." In the same stretch he said the real hardcore Bitcoiners in that era "were against even extracting our BCH to sell it. We considered going to cold storage to extract our BCH, an attack vector on our cold storage." I raised the question of whether anyone believes in a Bitcoin reunion now.
Full RBF and the Meaning of Confirmed
Jay does not like full RBF, and the sentence he uses to say so is as direct as he gets. "The worst thing that Core ever did was full RBF," he said, and then again, "Full RBF is the problem." His argument is that it undermines the protocol's purpose of preventing double spends. Peter Todd and Sergej Kotliar had this argument on the show in S14 E4, the full RBF debate, and Jay is firmly on Kotliar's side of it.
The larger principle he builds on it is that confirmation is not a binary state. His line was that there's "no such thing as binary confirmed," and "as soon as you sign it's on a path towards finality and it's never 100%." For daily payments, he wants wallets that handle unconfirmed transactions gracefully, and he thinks the ones we have are lacking. "The wallets were not built for the real world."
I pushed back, because I care about confirmations. I said they matter and that dropping them is how people lose money. Jay kept returning to practical examples, including a picture of a drug-dealer-style cash trade: "Even he would be able to accept Bitcoin, just like hundred dollar bills, just like a pile of gold. Because he just had to wait six blocks." His point was about trust at the counter, since "almost every single time you use money, there's trust. First of all, what are you doing with the money? What are you getting back?"
He has another reason for being annoyed with how Bitcoin software works. "It was never going to scale Bitcoin itself," he said of on-chain use, and I admitted that I stopped running my own node after a mundane failure ("One day my node just died and I didn't feel like putting it together again."). That is exactly the sort of friction he wants wallets to hide.
I also asked about Lightning. He said the logical consequence of the Bitcoin-only framing is a trap. "So if everything that's not Bitcoin is a scam, then Lightning is a scam. If Lightning is not a scam, then everything else is okay."
MEV Is the Double Spend for Money
His favorite way to explain what is wrong with decentralized exchange is a game of rock paper scissors, which he performed for me live. "I say scissors," he began, and the punchline is that on a blockchain, the other player sees your move first. "The most basic gambling game in the world is completely broken. It just can't work in blockchain." He called that "the most simple understanding of what MEV is," and the principle he draws from it is that "If you could do anything on blockchain, you can't do anything."
His definition of MEV is the one I keep thinking about: "The MEV for exchanges is the double spend for money." He claims it costs users billions. The alternative he sees people using is far worse, and he cited "A billion dollars and more every day traded on Telegram chat rooms, person to person." I mentioned that P2P platforms like NoOnes exist for exactly that reason. SideShift came up as a comparison point for no-account swapping.
On what an exchange is for, he was consistent all night. "The purpose of exchange is price discovery." And later, "An exchange is a place to discover price and not get screwed by a counterparty. That's that's what the exchange was like an escrow."
A Trading Pit on Bitcoin
That brings us to Sidepit. The model, Jay explained, is the Chicago S&P 500 futures pit. In a physical pit, traders yelled and signaled in plain view, and so the Byzantine generals problem never arose, because everyone could see everyone else. "We take the physical trading pit, we make it digital," he said.
The contracts are dollar futures priced in Bitcoin. "Bitcoin is the currency. Dollar is the commodity and each contract is worth $500." He warned me that his numbers were approximate: "These are not exact because I wasn't prepared for this." Access works through Ordinals. "just like you needed a special jacket to get into the trading floors, you need a special jacket to get into Sidepit," he said, and the jacket is an inscription tied to "a native SegWit Bitcoin address." On the choice of Ordinals, he said, "Ordinals opened the door for solving this problem," which is a sentence that will annoy some of the people who are anti-Ordinals.
The decentralization trade-off is deliberate. "We're the only one that actually chose price discovery," he said, and the way they get there is by relaxing where the trust sits: "We just punt the decentralization to the settlement." Jay's critique of competitors is that they ask you to "trust the casino," and he is open that he is not building a casual product. It is "a professional game where 90, you know, 80 to 90 percent of people are going to lose."
He did not dress up the timeline or the money. "We want to launch this quarter, but we definitely need help getting there, to be honest." The funding situation is rough: "It turns out there's not a lot of funding in the space." He is not impressed by much of the crowd that talks about building. "They're just cosplaying on Twitter." Layer-two builders were part of that wider conversation, and I mentioned LayerTwo Labs and Citrea as projects that are at least shipping something, in different ways.
The Privacy Coin Basket and Who Goes to Jail
Jay holds a basket of privacy coins, and I corrected him on his use of "index." He clarified: "It's not an index. It's just each one is separate." What he is interested in is separation between price and project: "There's a complete separation between price and project." I wanted to hear how that squares with the Zcash side of his stack.
His opinions about other coins are not subtle. "I told the Litecoin guys a long time ago, I'm like, you should just rename, just basically rename Litecoin to Doge and kill Doge and no one will know the difference."
On the legal side, he made a point about developer liability that I thought was well put. "I could actually make a program to take the Declaration of Independence and turn it into something illegal. But if I did that, I should be the one going to jail for doing that." The tool is not the crime; the person who uses it for something illegal is the one who should answer for it.
He also had a line about the old Bitcoin crowd that made me laugh. Luke Dashjr, as Jay told it, was long seen by the community as poor, and then lost millions in Bitcoin to a hack.
Where We Still Disagree
We ended up in roughly the same place we started. Jay thinks Bitcoin is a family of functions that includes crypto, Ethereum, Zcash, Lightning, Liquid and OP_CTV, and that the ticker and the brand are what matter. I think Bitcoin is a codebase and a chain with specific rules, and that calling something else Bitcoin does not make it so. He thinks confirmations are a spectrum that wallets should present to users in everyday terms, and I think a confirmation is a confirmation and the cost of getting this wrong lands on ordinary users. He believes Ethereum scales Bitcoin, and my view stays that I have not heard a theory of it that I can follow.
We also kept going back and forth over how to read the history. Jay finds the original sin in OP_CTV being stalled by a handful of well-known figures, and he blames "the top-down approach of the non-technical people" for how these calls get made, while I see a longer list of reasons why Bitcoin changes slowly. Neither of us moved the other, and the episode ran past four hours before either of us was ready to stop.
Listen to Jay Berg on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More
Time stamps:
- 00:01:57– Hot take: Maxis wrong, shitcoining new Bitcoining
- 00:03:00– Bitcoin kernel: Litecoin, Ethereum, Zcash, Lightning, Liquid
- 00:03:23– Bitcoin failed as P2P cash
- 00:04:09– Filters vs. OP_RETURN debate
- 00:05:18– Luke Dash Jr. fork prediction
- 00:05:45– Original sin: No OP_CTV (BIP 119)
- 00:06:47– 2017 civil war: Gavin Andresen, Mike Hearn
- 00:07:45– Craig Wright conspiracy
- 00:08:42– Wright intro: Bitcoin Belle, Gavin signing (2015)
- 00:09:32– Debate with Nick Szabo
- 00:10:02– Szabo denies Satoshi; Hal Finney, John Nash possibles
- 00:11:05– Civil war apology
- 00:12:08– Shitcoiner as new maxi
- 00:12:42– Code over 21M meme
- 00:13:58– Jay's background: Bloomberg, EURUSD
- 00:14:49– 1998 digital cash, double spend
- 00:15:39– Fortress HFT
- 00:17:03– Bitcoin discovery (2009)
- 00:18:36– BTCUSD tweets: Newberg Consulting
- 00:20:00– 2010-2014 decentralized era
- 00:21:10– Roger Ver adoption (2011)
- 00:21:30– BitMEX on 2010 data debates
- 00:22:01– OP_RETURN war: Counterparty, Omni
- 00:22:34– Ethereum rise
- 00:23:13– CP FUD on chain
- 00:23:36– Cognitive dissonance
- 00:24:30– Ethereum wars: Jimmy Song, Samson Mow
- 00:25:01– Ethereum scales Bitcoin tweet
- 00:27:11– Plebs control post-2017
- 00:28:05– 21M changeable
- 00:29:06– BIP 42: Pieter Wuille
- 00:30:23– Security budget FUD
- 00:30:57– Ethereum VM anti-pattern
- 00:32:25– Rock-paper-scissors example
- 00:35:03– MEV in DeFi
- 00:38:12– Ethereum scales post-war
- 00:38:45– Roger Ver buy Core attempt
- 00:38:52– Luke Jr. block increase
- 00:39:38– OP_CTV from no two-way peg
- 00:40:05– Blocked by Adam Back
- 00:41:36– Full RBF issue
- 00:42:10– Sponsor: Layer2 Labs, Paul Sztorc, Drivechain (BIP 300)
- 00:42:35– Sidechains: Thunder, Zside, BitAsset, EthSide
- 00:43:45– Litecoin BIP 300 test
- 00:44:26– Lightning not Bitcoin
- 00:45:44– Sponsor: Citrea ZK rollup
- 00:46:02– DeFi, Tornado Cash on Bitcoin
- 00:47:29– OP_RETURN bytes need
- 00:50:02– Lightning custodians
- 00:50:58– Lightning as Bitcoin how?
- 03:26:01– Zcash soft fork (2013)
- 03:26:42– Trump Ethereum: World Liberty
- 03:27:50– BIP 300, OP_CTV excitement
- 03:28:38– Stubborn fork potential
- 03:28:49– Stamp JPEG issue
- 03:29:11– Luke Jr. denial
- 03:30:28– No real JPEGs
- 03:32:24– Gloria Zhao attack
- 03:32:54– Matthew Kratter channel
- 03:33:21– Mechanic handler theory
- 03:34:38– Luke lost Bitcoin
- 03:35:48– Richard Heart Hex debate
- 03:37:20– Maxi used ETH
- 03:37:51– Gresham's law
- 03:38:56– Jason Lowery defense
- 03:40:31– Naka, David Bailey
- 03:41:34– Maxi cycle
- 03:42:23– Cult elements
- 03:42:52– Hypocrisy: Dogecoin, Litecoin
- 03:43:30– Freedom Index: Monero, Zcash, Pirate, Zano, Nym
- 03:45:43– Nym mixnet
- 03:46:44– Zano tokens, FUSD
- 03:48:23– Roger Ver Zano
- 03:49:40– Saberhagen Cryptonote
- 03:51:55– Alpha vs beta
- 03:55:10– Ethereum leveraged BTC
- 03:56:21– Opportunity
- 03:58:21– Dorsey funding
- 03:58:51– Renaissance or burn
- 03:59:30– Number up vs fundamentals
- 04:00:28– Success/failure
- 04:02:17– Laszlo Pizza fear
- 04:03:00– Swaps
- 04:03:24– Lightning failure
- 04:04:30– Platforms differences
- 04:05:56– Shitcoiners new
- 04:07:20– No blockchain solve?
- 04:08:49– 2010-14 decentralized
- 04:09:40– Mt. Gox exchanges
- 04:10:59– SidePit swaps
- 04:11:18– Follow: sidpit.com, JAYBNY
- 04:11:51– Launch Q404:15:01 - Next: Sean Bowe Tachyon
Verify this episode
This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.
- SHA-256
18c17b611b5afd55168c9487f66e5920b0fd79d3eef47f3dd74f81a542fb6a5e- Proof
- 2025-10-10_s16_e49_jay_berg_on_bitcoin_sidepit_maximalism.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
- Status
- Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
- Timestamped
- After release. The episode came out on 10 Oct 2025, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
- Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
- Run
sha256sum 2025-10-10_s16_e49_jay_berg_on_bitcoin_sidepit_maximalism.mp3(on a Mac:shasum -a 256 2025-10-10_s16_e49_jay_berg_on_bitcoin_sidepit_maximalism.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above. - Install the OpenTimestamps client (
pip install opentimestamps-client) and runots verify 2025-10-10_s16_e49_jay_berg_on_bitcoin_sidepit_maximalism.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node,ots info 2025-10-10_s16_e49_jay_berg_on_bitcoin_sidepit_maximalism.mp3.otsshows the block height to look up in any block explorer.
Related
S17 E13: Charlie Spears on Blockspace Media, the Purity Spiral & the Case for Classical Maximalism
Editor’s note: this conversation was streamed live in mid-March 2026, a week after the US switched to daylight saving time (which…
S14 E18: Lisa Neigut & Calle on Scaling Bitcoin & Free Open Source Software
During the 10th edition of Hackers Congress at Paralelni Polis (HCPP), I’ve had the pleasure to meet Lisa Neigut and Calle. The…
S17 E23: Hunter Beast & Mark Karpeles on Quantum-Proofing Bitcoin, Satoshi’s Coins & the Ghost of Mt. Gox
This interview took place on April 29th 2026, at the LayerTwo Labs booth at the Bitcoin Conference in Las Vegas with Hunter…
Comments
Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.