Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S13 · E16 · 38:32

S13 E16: MetaMick on Geyser and Bitcoin Fundraising

14 May 2023 · by Vlad Costea · 9 min read
Published at block 789,679
Cover art for S13 E16, MetaMick on Geyser and Bitcoin Fundraising
MP3 (71 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript6,174 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

I came into this interview with a prejudice. Crowdfunding means somebody collects money and then vanishes, and I said as much to Mick Morucci within a minute of sitting down: "I guess there were rug pulls in Bitcoin before there were anywhere else." The question I wanted answered was how a platform where strangers send each other sats could possibly be built without becoming a rug-pull dispenser. Mick, the MetaMick of Twitter, is co-founder and CEO of Geyser, and the answer he gave me involved far less promised magic than I expected, plus one story about a fake campaign that he told against his own platform.

We recorded at the Libertarian conference at a film festival in Warsaw, and the conversation ran about 34 minutes. Much of it turned out to be about what happens around the money rather than the money itself: who gets to be believed, who pays whom, and how a creator keeps people interested after the first donation.

Fireworks With No Follow-Through

Mick dates the idea to the Bitcoin community around 2020 and 2021. "there was so much effervescence, so many ideas sparkling, so many people with these ideas, and then oftentimes nothing was being done about it." The people with ideas had no real place to ask for funding. "They were just sort of adding lightning QR codes on their Twitter feed and hoping that people will fund."

Geyser is a crowdfunding platform for Bitcoin projects that runs on the Lightning Network. A creator posts a project, funders send sats, and the page keeps a running record of who gave what. Mick pointed to a very mixed bag of campaigns when I asked what kinds of things get funded: Bitcoin for Fairness, the project of Anita Posch at bffbtc.org, Bitcoin trading cards, a Bitcoin racing car, educational platforms like Mi Primer Bitcoin, the clothing brand CryptoCloaks, Bitcoin Block Munich, and a show called Between Two ASICs. On that last one, he described someone taking an existing event and turning it into a Bitcoin show: "transform it into a Bitcoin show, calling it Between Two ASICs."

I asked how he picks winners. He doesn't. "And the only way to make it happen is to not govern centrally and decide what's a good idea." Instead, he said, "put out a tweet about your idea and see what the community says." Lightning also makes payments small and fast enough that, in his words, "even just in a matter of a day or two, your project can receive hundreds of contributions, millions of sats, and that idea can happen."

Twitter as the Trust Layer

My main worry was impersonation, and Mick's answer began with Twitter. "So Twitter represents currently that social trust layer," he said, referring to the "power of platforms," in his phrase. Users log in with Twitter, which lets a project page show who is actually behind it. Geyser also partners with Hive.one for social ranking.

I pushed on whether follower counts mean anything. Mick agreed they don't, by themselves: "It's easy on Twitter to convince 10,000 people from a like farm or whatever to follow you and you're going to look like you're influential and big." Hence the Hive.one angle, because for him the relevant question is "are you actually in the network?" A newcomer is still welcome: "Again, you can still create a project with zero friends, right?" What the ranking surfaces is the track record.

Along these lines I offered a thesis of my own, which Mick took on board: "Also, even though Bitcoin is trustless, a Bitcoin world requires not necessarily a trust system, but a reputation system, where you can see the track record of every actor." I added that "you need a reputation before you can ask others to pay you in Bitcoin." His advice to creators was close to a dress code: "Show your face. You may be an anon, and that's totally fine as well. But it does usually help to see someone who you can trust a little more."

The Praia Bitcoin Brazil Fake

Then came the incident that shows what these safeguards are up against. Someone created a campaign impersonating Praia Bitcoin Brazil, the real organization. Two people donated a total of 10,000 sats before it was caught. Mick put the blame on his own team's shoulders: "And that was more a problem on our end for not actually noticing it," because "what was missing was the social net."

Geyser's rule on deletion is blunt: "You can't delete a project on Geyser unless it's received no funding at all." Once someone has paid, the project page stays, which protects funders from a creator who tries to erase evidence. The flip side is that a fake that has collected anything stays on the site as well, which is where social verification has to do the work.

The planned fix is Nostr. Geyser is adding Nostr login alongside Twitter, and Mick explained the direction: "So you're going to be able to log in with Nostr on Geyser and create a project through your Nostr account." Geyser would then be a window onto what already lives on Nostr, "We're just more of like of an interface." Native Nostr update broadcasting for campaign milestones is also on the list, because "keeping the community up to date socially is absolutely critical. And we have, we are aware of the problem." Mick gave me his NIP-05, metamick@nostrplebs.com, and mentioned that Nostr badges are minted from user keypairs and can be gifted. They are not meant as speculative NFTs. When I asked, he said "No, not quite. Because mainly they're not tradable."

HODL Invoices and a Non-Custodial Pipe

Technically, the thing that lets Geyser avoid holding anyone's funds is the HODL invoice. Mick described it step by step: "So every payment goes through the Geyser node in a non-custodial way." The sequencing is the point: "we only receive the funds from the sender after we have sent the money to the receivers." Geyser never sits on a pile of user money.

On the fee, Mick laid out two tiers. A project that uses a Lightning address pays 2%, and "the creator gets 98%." A project that connects directly to its own node pays no fee. He thinks this design has a side effect: "because we believe that we actually incentivize people to run their own nodes." I wondered aloud whether charging fees at all amounts to "monetizing your project off of everyone else's monetization." His answer was about friction. "there needs to be some costliness so that funding is real."

He also told me that "We noticed that 30% of funders actually come from within the platform," meaning people who found one project and then browsed to another. Funders who start on Geyser tend to stay on Geyser, and Mick is happy to take that as a reason to keep it a place where people browse.

Not Yet at Break-Even

I asked the awkward question, whether the 2% pays the bills. "It's not. Right now we're not in break-even, but we're relying on the long-term projection of Bitcoin." What he did offer was a growth claim: "50% growth month over month for the last four or five months."

His bet on why it will keep growing is that the next gains for Bitcoin are not in the protocol. "we think it's these next layers, namely the social layer of Bitcoin, that will help Bitcoin go to the next level, that will help hyper-Bitcoinize the world." Most people, he reminded me, will not write code. "98% of the world doesn't know how to code, and probably don't know what money is." The aim is to let them "play a part in world-changing ideas."

He also said he is "bullish on Bitcoiners that are supporting these creators, that are giving back value for the value that creators are providing to the network." Some of the funding, he said, is grassroots in the most literal sense: "And I think there are people in Africa just simply orange-pilling, asking for donations and just giving sats away." The money pays for in-person orange-pilling, where an advocate meets someone and explains Bitcoin face to face.

I later recorded S16 E17: Ben Arc on LNBits V1 & The State of Lightning Network and S14 E14: Michael Bumann on Building Alby, Nostr & Lightning Network Development.

What Lightning Still Cannot Do

I asked about the features he wished Lightning had. Recurring support was first. "I wish that it was easier to subscribe," he said. A second problem is that crowdfunding often depends on all-or-nothing pledges, where money is only released if the goal is hit. Mick described the underlying need as funds "locked up in a contract." Then he drew the line between layers: "On-chain it's totally doable with HTLCs. But on Lightning it's kind of doable but not great."

So a project on Geyser today runs on plain donations rather than escrowed pledges that vanish if the goal is missed. Because of that, as I told him, "you have to remind people constantly that it's out there and push it." Mick agreed: "It's not enough to just sit back and let people fund you or expect people to fund you."

I mentioned my own plan on the show: "I'm gonna try to create the first project to raise 1 Bitcoin and write history there for Geyser." The project is meant to debunk Bitcoin myths. When I asked how funders see the campaigns they are choosing among, Mick said that "So you can pick and decide where the funds go to," and added that even a heavy user is looking at a sea of options: "I have to pick among 360 projects."

Merch Pins, Tatum Turn Up and a Ring

The best sales story of the day came from the trading-card side. Mick said one seller "I think he's sold more than 100 different pins in just three, four hours." He gave Tatum Turn Up as the example for his main advice to would-be creators: "Sometimes you have this skill and you love Bitcoin. Well, put those two things together and you'll find some unexpected things that will happen." Or, as he put it elsewhere, "Just bring your passions, your skills together."

His standing recommendation for bad market days is also simple. "And if you're ever feeling like a bit of FUD, just go on geyser.fund and just see how much is happening." As he said, "Every day there is something new."

Mick's wife had joined us for the last stretch, and she weighed in on the stranger corners of the platform, saying she "was quite surprised that there was a race that wanted a Geyser... That wanted Bitcoin to support a race car." On the early days of the project, she said, "Yeah, those were very early ones."

I stumbled over how to describe her and called her his girlfriend. Mick corrected me on the spot: "My wife. Wife." Then he grinned and told me that he had "put a ring on it."

If you want to find Mick, he is @metamick14 on Twitter, and the platform is @geyserfund.

Listen to MetaMick on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:00:51– Welcome and meet MetaMick
  2. 00:01:43– Skepticism after Dark Wallet and old rug pulls
  3. 00:02:29– How Geyser began: ideas on Twitter with no way to fund them
  4. 00:03:40– Twitter as a social trust layer
  5. 00:04:52– Hive.one social ranking and Nostr login
  6. 00:06:44– Hundreds of contributions in a day or two
  7. 00:07:19– Geyser versus GoFundMe and Kickstarter
  8. 00:08:07– Who trusts you: the social graph
  9. 00:08:38– The Praia Bitcoin Brazil impersonation
  10. 00:10:12– Reputation systems in a trustless world
  11. 00:10:49– Connecting a node or a Lightning address
  12. 00:11:58– The 2% fee and HODL invoices
  13. 00:12:40– Geyser's business model
  14. 00:13:05– Why 2% and how it compares
  15. 00:14:29– Is 2% enough to sustain Geyser?
  16. 00:16:02– Hyperbitcoinization and the social layer
  17. 00:16:47– Films, books and educators on Geyser
  18. 00:18:32– The most successful projects
  19. 00:20:24– My one Bitcoin challenge
  20. 00:21:15– Per-language funding and Nostr badges
  21. 00:22:33– The Greenpeace green skull pins
  22. 00:24:05– Race cars and football coaches
  23. 00:24:34– Between Two ASICs and Bitcoin Block Munich
  24. 00:26:47– What Lightning still can't do
  25. 00:28:08– Advice for new creators
  26. 00:30:32– How to reach Mick
  27. 00:31:24– Why campaigns die in silence
  28. 00:33:35– Wrap-up and Nostr handle

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
584d64e0f655cc6e3dc8a1c1fdd9b57490473860500908e03889ddddaaddf3b6
Proof
2023-05-11_s13_e16_michele_morucci_metamick_on_geyser_and_bitcoin_fundraising.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 11 May 2023, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2023-05-11_s13_e16_michele_morucci_metamick_on_geyser_and_bitcoin_fundraising.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2023-05-11_s13_e16_michele_morucci_metamick_on_geyser_and_bitcoin_fundraising.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2023-05-11_s13_e16_michele_morucci_metamick_on_geyser_and_bitcoin_fundraising.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2023-05-11_s13_e16_michele_morucci_metamick_on_geyser_and_bitcoin_fundraising.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Season Episode Ben Arc LNbits Nostr DIY V2

S14 E5: Ben Arc on LNBits and Nostr

10 Sept 2023 · 5 min read

Ben Arc is the creator of LNBits: a modular Lightning wallet which empowers users to pick their desired features (presented as…

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00