Research
Timechain
Search Donate
Sponsors
Cake Wallet, private Bitcoin and Monero walletSideShift.ai, no-signup crypto exchangeOrangeRock, non-custodial bitcoin spot and perps tradingBraiins Hashpower, buy and sell Bitcoin hashrateLayer Two Labs, drivechains for Bitcoin
S2 · E4 · 2:01:04

Rajarshi Maitra on Bitcoin in India and the Cult Status of BTC Communities (S2 E4 Full Article)

6 Jul 2019 · by Vlad Costea · 7 min read
Published at block 584,212
Cover art for S2 E4, Rajarshi Maitra on Bitcoin in India and the Cult status of BTC communities
MP3 (69 MB)

The audio keeps playing while you browse the site.

Read the transcript18,584 words, every line links to the minute it was said

Ask this episode

Embed this episode

Paste this on your site or blog. It is a small player that streams from here: no trackers, no cookies, no ads.

Preview the player

Rajarshi Maitra listened to the first season and reached out. I'm glad he did. He's a self-taught coder from West Bengal, and he gave me one of the most original takes I've heard on Bitcoin, gold and culture. He also ended with a claim that some Bitcoiners won't like: Bitcoin is a cult.

The short show notes are on the old post. This is the full story.

From Physics to Bitcoin

Raj "stumbled upon Bitcoin on October 2017, kind of like in an accident way." He had some extra money and bought into a crypto index fund. "So I have plowed my way through all the shit that there is." Then he saw "this weird random long address" and got curious.

He was already primed for it. He was "doing my master's in structural engineering" and was "fed up with the culture of academia." So in 2016 "I started studying the most difficult subject that I could find, that was theoretical physics." By the time Bitcoin showed up, "I already had this curiosity drive to understand complex things."

Why Did Central Planning Fail?

Raj grew up in a place "dominated by communist ideologies" for decades, and "communist romanticism was very much ingrained into me in a social and cultural way." At university he even called himself a communist. But one question bugged him: "why did this thing didn't work."

Bitcoin answered it. "Within the first two days, I was kind of swept away when I saw the problem statement." It was the same question: "why central planning of communist structures cannot work?" Before Bitcoin, he believed that without hierarchy, society falls into chaos. "Once I saw the Byzantine Generals' Problem and I understood the problem statement, I realized this is the exact same problem."

His reaction is one of my favorite quotes on the show: "I don't care if you solve it or not, but the fact that you are trying to solve it is immense. And the fact that you have a fucking computer protocol that you can use to solve it is out of this world."

The secret, he said, is greed. "The order emerges out of human greed. Because humans are greedy, that's why Bitcoin works." That's "the crucial brilliance of Satoshi Nakamoto's design, that he used greed to make order out of chaos." And "Satoshi didn't invent any of this." He combined existing pieces into "an incentive structure which completes a loop on itself."

How India Holds Gold

This part was new to me. "90% of the people in India doesn't care what the value of gold is, yet they have it." Gold "changes hand through generations after generations after generations without ever being liquidated." A family only sells "in the time of crisis," and only "at the very last resort."

They don't know Austrian economics. "They have no clue." It's "ingrained in their subconscious" through "cultural and social norms of thousands of years."

Raj thinks Bitcoin can get the same status. "Even though people don't run their full node, even though they're not libertarian," society can learn "that it's a good idea to have some sats without being able to explain why." Some Bitcoiners already treat it this way. "You just transmit the private keys from generation to generation to generation."

You Can't Wear Bitcoin

There's one big difference. With gold, you can show off a necklace while hiding the rest. With Bitcoin, "you cannot just point to a thing" and say that's your stack, or make "a necklace out of Bitcoin." If you try, "you will get doxxed, and you will get all sorts of attacks on personal things." So "you have to be secretive about your Bitcoins."

Bitcoin in India in 2019

Raj was honest. The rupee wasn't collapsing, so people weren't "looking for a desperate exit door." Most activity was speculation. "They just want to make a good buck. That's all."

The bigger obstacle was the Reserve Bank of India. "RBI has imposed a banking ban on cryptocurrency." Individuals could do what they wanted, but banks had to stay away. The government "never said it's illegal," but the media made people believe "that Bitcoin is right now something illegal." So even a grocery store owner who knows Bitcoin is gaining value "also knows that it's something illegal."

There was also a scary draft bill. Raj said under it, "dealing, selling, buying and even holding Bitcoin can put you in jail for 10 years." He thought it unlikely to pass. For the record, the Supreme Court of India struck down the RBI banking restriction in March 2020.

People used peer-to-peer platforms. "You go to a peer-to-peer exchange like LocalBitcoins or Hodl Hodl or WazirX." Merchants could accept Bitcoin with "just a computer running a BTCPay Server," but few knew that.

Raj wanted Bitcoin savings, but the problem was more basic. "Even though government is not banning it, I still can't use my Bitcoins because there is no one accepting it." Building that closed-loop economy was his goal.

Bitcoin as an Idea Virus

Raj sees Bitcoin as "a biological organism." In nature, "the only mutation that stays is the one which makes the species better as a whole." Bitcoin spreads "through waves of adoptions" like "an idea virus."

He went further, to Resident Evil. "In Resident Evil, you have this concept of T-virus." Once infected, "the next thing you want to do after becoming a zombie is bite other people." Sound familiar? "If you are into Bitcoin, the next thing you want to do is tell people about Bitcoin."

His approach to orange-pilling: "the key is to find the potent mind," someone "which has all the relevant ideas in place, and all you need to do is connect them together." The click "happens after a long period of exploration."

He taught himself to code, but decided "I don't want to be a full-time developer." Instead, he wanted to motivate people who can build, through meetups, clubs and businesses. India lacked infrastructure like nodes and hardware wallets, and imported devices were "so costly that most of the people can't just afford it."

Yes, It's a Cult

Then came the claim from the title. Raj pointed to The Ethics of Money Production, the book by Jörg Guido Hülsmann, though on air he couldn't remember the author. "You cannot have a sound economics without a sound ethical ground."

"And Bitcoin does engrave some form of ethics into it. You cannot inflate the supply of Bitcoin. That's our ethical stand." So "because Bitcoin does have its one basic ethical statement, I don't think that you can argue that it's not a cult. It is a cult."

He didn't mean it as an insult. A cult can have "a bad image" or "a very different image." The essence is "a belief system engraved in the design." And that's the point: "the only way Bitcoin can succeed is by making itself like a zombie virus," by "hitting at the heart of the human psyche, that is their core belief system."

Why 21 Million Matters

Raj tied it together with the supply cap. "The biggest right decision that Satoshi took was having a fixed supply cap." Once inflation is up for debate, "that opens up a lot of political attack vector, because there is no right answer for the right inflation."

And trust grows over time. The longer Bitcoin exists, the more confident people are that it will keep existing. That's "how confidence and counter-confidence builds up the capability of society to have trust on a particular kind of asset as a store of value."

Looking Back

Raj's idea that Bitcoin could become a family heirloom, like gold in Indian households, stayed with me. And his "cult" argument isn't as crazy as it sounds. If 21 million is a belief worth defending, then Bitcoiners are a community built on an ethical stand.

Read the full transcript, see the original show notes, or find more on Rajarshi Maitra's guest page.

Listen to Rajarshi Maitra on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and More

Time stamps:

  1. 00:04:02– Stumbling upon Bitcoin
  2. 00:04:51– Fed up with academia
  3. 00:05:22– Studying theoretical physics
  4. 00:06:44– Growing up with communist ideas
  5. 00:09:31– Why didn't it work?
  6. 00:10:36– Into the rabbit hole
  7. 00:11:08– The Byzantine Generals' Problem
  8. 00:11:40– A protocol to solve it
  9. 00:20:57– Gold that never gets sold
  10. 00:21:34– Only in a crisis
  11. 00:22:23– Thousands of years of culture
  12. 00:24:18– Sats without knowing why
  13. 00:27:50– You can't wear Bitcoin
  14. 00:31:13– Showing off gets you doxxed
  15. 00:33:40– Never liquidating
  16. 00:34:29– Keys across generations
  17. 00:45:40– Mostly speculation
  18. 00:47:36– The RBI banking ban
  19. 01:00:34– P2P exchanges
  20. 01:01:48– BTCPay Server and media fear
  21. 01:02:27– "Something illegal"
  22. 01:04:35– The draft bill
  23. 01:11:14– No one accepts it
  24. 01:21:22– Order from greed
  25. 01:25:00– Satoshi combined primitives
  26. 01:26:52– A biological organism
  27. 01:27:25– The T-virus
  28. 01:28:04– Biting other people
  29. 01:29:25– Finding the potent mind
  30. 01:32:26– Not a full-time developer
  31. 01:33:59– Missing infrastructure in India
  32. 01:41:24– The Ethics of Money Production
  33. 01:42:16– It is a cult
  34. 01:44:26– Defining a cult
  35. 01:46:54– A zombie virus
  36. 01:49:15– The fixed supply cap
  37. 01:57:13– Confidence over time

Verify this episode

This is the SHA-256 fingerprint of the MP3 as published here, timestamped in the Bitcoin blockchain with OpenTimestamps. If one byte of the file changes, the fingerprint changes.

SHA-256
6e42096e3f68d580ec3cf86cb2de396c727b79d60e24383591dbb4d2b4f75ba1
Proof
2019-06-29_bitcoin_takeover_s2.mp3.ots · all episode hashes (proof)
Status
Anchored in Bitcoin block 974,312
Timestamped
After release. The episode came out on 29 Jun 2019, but this proof was made on 3 Nov 2026 and anchored in block 974,312, so it proves this exact file existed by 3 Nov 2026, not on the release date.
How to check it yourself
  1. Download the MP3 and the proof into the same folder.
  2. Run sha256sum 2019-06-29_bitcoin_takeover_s2.mp3 (on a Mac: shasum -a 256 2019-06-29_bitcoin_takeover_s2.mp3). The result must match the SHA-256 above.
  3. Install the OpenTimestamps client (pip install opentimestamps-client) and run ots verify 2019-06-29_bitcoin_takeover_s2.mp3.ots. It hashes the MP3 again and checks the proof against your own Bitcoin node, then prints the block and the date the file existed by. Without a node, ots info 2019-06-29_bitcoin_takeover_s2.mp3.ots shows the block height to look up in any block explorer.

Share: X · Email · Link

Related

Comments

Comments run on my own server. No trackers, no tracking cookies.

0:000:00